I was actually listening to this the day before I wrote this review and thought to myself does this album truly deserve a 5/5 if you were to go through the album track by track? The simple answer is no. The long answer is it’s probably more of a 4/5, arguably (excluding the white album) this is the Beatles album with the most filler and sgt peppers, to me anyway, is rather front loaded and only amazing song on side 2 is a day in the life. Actually let’s test this out and go track by track sgt peppers review/analysis: Side 1 Sgt peppers lonely hearts club band: The album opens with it’s title track a song that is really a track that sets the scene for the album. They wanted to escape being the Beatles (and that makes sense in the 60’s). It’s not one of my top Beatles songs but I like it for what it is. With a little help from my friends: This track is an all time greatest song I can’t deny it, (even though the album didn’t have singles) this is the equivalent of the song 2 hit single it’s absolutely amazing i’am actually a big fan of Ringo’s singing (well when he gets the chance) so this is a true treat. Lucy in the sky with diamonds: I know John Lennon said this was about some drawing but I just don’t believe him to be completely honest; the song is trippy as fuck and LSD it just can’t be denied. The song is absolutely amazing though absolutely no flaws. Getting better: Getting better is a banger, if it were a modern album with 4 singles this would be guaranteed to be one it’s so singley! I especially love the chord that runs through the intro and chorus and the Indian style bridge is class, probably my favourite track on side one. Fixing a hole: I like fixing a hole, is it one of my favourite Paul McCartney songs, no, do I always forget about it being on side one, yes, do I enjoy it and sometimes sing along to it, yes! It’s great just not the absolute best. She’s leaving home: I love the chorus of she’s leaving home the vocals are amazing, the verse are good though I especially like how it’s telling a story throughout. The track feels so powerful and has real gravitas to it, I’ve actually herd people say it’s filler, but how it’s perfect! Being for the benefit of mr kite: This song is fucking bonkers, it has John Lennon written all over it! Admittedly, while not my favourite, it’s probably the Sgt peppers track I’ve listened to the most, I love it too much! Side 2 Within you without you: Like how mr kite has Lennon written all over it within you without you has George Harrison written all over it, it’s this amazing classical Indian style track and it’s truly incredible, but I prefer love you too on revolver by a tiny bit as this song does drag just a little and putting a really slow track like this as side 2 track one is a really odd track-listing choice in my opinion. When i’am 64: This is the song that’s closest to early Beatles it’s sweet I really enjoy it the melodies are amazing. I don’t know why but I always think of a Scottish Granny when Paul says “grandchildren on your knee, Vera, Chuck and Dave”. The song isn’t as good as anything on side one though. Lovely Rita: Now we’re at the point of Sgt peppers that makes me skeptical of the “best album of all time” title, this song has a nice melody but other than that I find it filler. Good morning good morning: Lovely Rita isn’t the best thing ever but at least it’s not actively shit, I don’t like this song it’s so dumb and the repeated “good morning good morning’s” are so annoying. But I guess every album (even the classic’s)has that one runt of the litter (e.g. oh daddy on fleetwood mac’s rumours, Lounge act on Nirvanas nevermind and star on David Bowie’s Ziggy stardust). Sgt peppers lonely hearts club band (reprise): The fast version of the first song similar to the first song it’s great for the album but not one I would listen to in my own time. A day in the life: The best album closer of all time, my favourite tracks off Sgt peppers , my favourite Beatles song, possibly the only Beatles song on my top 10 songs of all time it’s just amazing!!! The album does have filler I can’t deny that I would be very suprised if even the most devout Beatles loyalist doesn’t deep down in their heart believe there’s filler even if they don’t admit it. But my original statement of it not being a 5/5 is somewhat ludicrous nowadays it stands as one of the most well received albums of all time it’s an album that hit number 1 everywhere and it’s also one of 2 Beatles albums (the other being abbey road) that I would call genuinely culturally significant to everyone. It’s absolutely amazing 5/5 (even with the flaws)!