I like this album a lot, I'll start there. It's great, but flawed in my opinion. Concept albums can work, but in general, I don't love long, drawn out concept albums - because it gives an excuse for an album to be over bloated and self indulgent under the guise of the "narrative" Again, I like this album and still giving it a 4 because there's some great stuff here, but IMO the bloated-ness holds it back from being great like DSOTM and WYWH.