I was not impressed. Was hoping for so much more since it's an album that was listed as a must listen before I die. There is nothing magical for me on this one. His singing is not great. The song writing is mediocre at best. It lacks deep connective emotion. There were a few decent grooves on it, but it felt like the songs were just beaten into the ground. Redundant and boring.
I agree that this is an album that everyone should hear. It is full of magical melodies and arrangements. I don't love it all, and it wouldn't be in my favorite albums, but it is clearly well made, mixed, and performed. I don't connect with all of the creative corners he was trying to explore, but it doesn't mean I don't appreciate them. Great piano work throughout, very lively and out front. The piano carries a lot of this music, as it should for him. So I really like it. My rating is based on the quality of this as a musical offering, not my own taste. I feel like this is one everyone should hear.
I was pleasantly surprised by this album. It has some nice haunting melodies, with some major arrangements mixed in to keep it interesting. Bono does some really nice, emotive singing on this one. His voice is not my favorite, seems overly dramatic sometimes, but it works on this one. The guitar and music is a little bit redundant. The guitar phrasing is repetitive throughout the album. All in all, a solid album, and better than I expected.
This album is not for me. You know, I listened to it on Youtube. I understand that when I listen to it on there that I am going to be among people who have searched it out, likely because they like it. I read the comments. I am absolutely fascinated at how musical tastes are formed and experienced. For me, this is absolute juvenile slop. I can appreciate the singer's commitment. His vocal delivery is fully convicted and that is a rare quality. I don't care for his vocals. I prefer more melodic phrasing. There are also several moments on this album that makes me feel like I heard it before in someone else's song. There is some Creep by Radiohead. Some Fastball stuff. I really can't fathom how this album won any awards at all. Which is one of the things that is fascinating to me. I have a friend who is very much into punk, and I will never connect with it. I don't get it. I get the angst, and the anarchy, but I don't know why you would want to listen to it for pleasure. Maybe that's not it, though. I guess it is more impactful that hearing someone read it to you.
Anyway, I don't like it, and it definitely doesn't feel like a record I should have heard before I died. I have a bad feeling about this exercise, that we will see entire genres missing because it doesn't fit into whatever direction was created by whomever created this list.
I like jazz, but typically something a little more palatable. That being said, there are some really brilliant passages on this album. Frequently the wind section would create sounds that you could swear was actual speaking. True talent. As a musician, I can't even wrap my head around deciphering, counting, and playing much of this music. As a listen, it does not appeal to me. But it still impresses me, and I am better for having heard it. The piano playing on it is super smooth and effortless. Would love to have heard more of it. But the chaos makes me pine for a little more space and groove between the noise.
This one I know very well. Some of my favorite ELO songs are on here. And there are some truly magical music on here. There is also a fair amount of indulgent stuff on here that seems tedious. This should have been a single album. Then it would have a been a five star album for me. Instead I have to give it four. Turn to Stone and Mr. Blue Sky are amazing. I always liked Standing in the Rain and The Whale has aged really well. The Jungle is really cool.
Meh. I don't love it or hate it. It's ok. Has some mildly catchy stuff on it. I do like the message on Working Class Hero. I read some of the critics on it, talking about how he really can't talk about a Working Class Hero, being a star and all. This thought process is so narrow minded. It's like people think that once someone becomes successful, they somehow stop being a normal person. Do you think he forgot what it was like to have nothing? Or to feel marginalized? And do you think he doesn't still have something to say on the matter? Or that maybe he wants to let his fans know he understands some things? I also am sometimes miffed about the whole self indulgent thing. Listen, a musician/artist is supposed to write and perform stuff from their heart. Art at its core is self indulgent. It's not like Da Vinci looked at the completed Mona Lisa and said, 'Hmmm, people might think she's pissed, so I should add a little smile.' Artists do what their hearts tell them they need to express, and if people dig it, then they get rich. If they don't, oh well.
So it was better than I expected. Not a huge prince fan. I have to take into account the era that this was released in. In my opinion, there is far too much Thomas Dolby Keyboard sounds in here. Maybe not so much that there’s too many as they are in my opinion not tastefully applied. There are some real moments on this album That would be really cool if they weren’t ambushed by these silly keyboards. But based on what I’ve heard it seems like it could’ve been groundbreaking at the time. That is somewhat of an assumption since I don’t really know that much about funk. In my experience, people who get credit for groundbreaking stuff are rarely the people who actually did it. I’m sure there were artists that came before prince he just happened to get most success from it. He’s clearly an incredible musician and vocally He does things on this album that are pretty cool. Has a really good falsetto with lots of control. He throws some very cool guitar solos in here and there. Also, there are some songs that go on way too long doing the same thing over and over again which I know is a big thing for dance music but I’m not dancing. I’m just sitting here listening to it so, too much. So all in all I think it’s a pretty good album.
First off, kudos to the singer for having a successful career while still being so completely terrible. Musically I thought there was some pretty cool stuff on here and I really wish the singer would’ve shut up long enough for me to listen to it. He absolutely ruins this album. And the further I go into this journey, it just confirms my lifelong belief that critics have absolutely no brains and no taste. 1001 albums to listen to before you die are you kidding me? Some of them make me feel like dying. And I think of all of the kick ass, outstanding, awesome groundbreaking albums that should be on this list. It’s just like the rock ‘n’ roll Hall of Fame. Bunch of clueless motherfuckers acting like they know music.
So before even listening to this I am dreading it based on the reviews. It's not because of the ratings, which mean nothing because many albums I love get shit ratings because people have vastly different musical tastes. It's because they indicate that this is another album where the singer doesn't actually sing, and to me, that sucks. I mean, what is the fascination with these so called music nerds with this shit? The other thing is, why is it that so many of these guys push this kind of music so hard? It truly makes me wonder if they are truly aliens, sent here to make us feel stupid. So far, the list is extremely disappointing. What I expected to be a cool musical journey has been a giant fart. I wish I had enough useless time and energy to make my own list. Entire swaths of genres are missing on this list. Why can't anyone make an actually good musical list?
Ok, just listened to as much as I could stomach. It's not terrible. I do like the musical delivery initially, but it just goes on and on and on. No dynamics at all. And the 'vocals'.......ugh. This is the kind of thing that works for one or two songs, but not as your only offering. The good news is, I wasn't disappointed. It was a little less shitty than I expected. Still, a solid 2 stars. And it should be on absolutely no ones list of albums you need to listen to.