The Black Saint And The Sinner Lady by Charles Mingus

The Black Saint And The Sinner Lady

Charles Mingus

3.33
Rating
29180
Votes
1
7%
2
17%
3
30%
4
27%
5
19%
Distribution

Album Summary

The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady is a studio album by American jazz double bassist, composer, and bandleader Charles Mingus. It was recorded on January 20, 1963, and released in July of that year by Impulse! Records. The album consists of a single continuous composition—partially written as a ballet—divided into four tracks and six movements.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

#317 THE THREE TYPES OF JAZZ REVIEWS ON THIS SITE 1. I don't know anything about jazz but I hate this. 2. I don't know anything about jazz but I kinda like this. 3. I know everything about jazz and I'm going to preach to the rest of you losers.

Jazz isn’t a genre I listen to very often, which might be why I couldn’t quite get into it. That said, I can definitely say it’s different from other jazz music. The transitions between the notes are so stirring that they almost make it impossible to just sit still while listening. It certainly stands head and shoulders above many of the clichéd albums found in the jazz genre. 2,75

This sounded kinda evil man idk

It’s just a bunch of random instruments thrown together on one song… is what I would say if I was lying. There’s too much at one time… is what someone who can’t handle the heat would say. Not me, though, I’m tough. Yeah, I listened 3 times. With each additional listen, I heard different instruments and energy. This jazz album is dynamic, shifting with the listening environment. For some listens, the complex solos stood out, but other times, the lavish amalgamation of instruments was intriguing. Either way, I was impressed with the experimental artistry demonstrated on this record. Its ability to be so incredibly diverse is what makes it exceptionally interesting for me, but I can see how it can be off-putting to those who did not listen multiple times in the right conditions.

Wildly creative. This is a masterpiece. A reminder of how expansive music can be. Unrestrained, it lights up my brain in the best way. 5 stars.

#3 I like to think of music as a language. And jazz is an ultimate form of conversation. It is not always intended for the outsiders. Just a group of friends (and versatile speakers, too) enjoying each other's company. Sometimes you can't understand what they're talking about anymore. But if you've been listening from the beginning, you understand how they got there. One can't deny - it's a beautiful act.

i'm such a fool for underestimating his hype

It's been a strange weekend, so I've only had the opportunity to enjoy this at the back of my mind. So it is no surprise that I've got no closer to distinguishing good jazz from bad. I'm still not sure I know why I like one jazz record over another. In our recent Duke Ellington review, I mentioned that it was hard to hear big band jazz as anything other than a Time Machine. Whereas the self-expression of later jazz puts it in parallel to post-Dylan-and-Beatles pop - it is in the same artistic world in a very broad sense. Thus, while Mingus and his players sound a lot like big band, they also sound wild and free. There is some goal other than making you dance, if one could even dance to this. But, like the big band sound, the music here can be a sort of Time Machine. Certainly, many parts of the record take you back to 40s noir and may as well be in a spy movie. Or further back to some 20s speakeasy. It is only the shonkiness, the occasional falter or tuneless parp, the sections of pure noise that take you away from the cliched cinematic image to an image of people playing in a room. But exactly they're playing and why, I'm not really sure. I suppose the ragged edges make this seem more alive than Duke and his band, but I don't see that it is doing much more. 2.5 I used to quite like this and among that pile of Jazz CDs in the attic that catalogues my failure to spark with the genre this is, alongside Bitches Brew, the one I returned to the most. For radically different reasons to Bitches Brew obviously. Black Saint… is much easier listening but still has enough musical eccentricity in it to flatter the listener that they are digesting something avant garde. And that was the very sort of flattery I had a taste for when I was young. Listening now, and it has been a long time since I have listened, it is clear to me that Charles Mingus’ ‘masterpiece’ is, in truth, entirely quaint. Perhaps this had some teeth in 1963, when you could still find swing records beneath your da’s gramophone. But sixty years on it is harder to credit Mingus’ spin on Big Band as much spin at all. The scribbles and slashes on the surface sound as dated as the maudlin themes underneath. Even the ‘free’ bits sound, somehow, sentimental. The muted trumpets sound silly. There’s just no effective darkness here at all and there ought to be because presenting this music - rhythmically insistent and rich with ostinatos, dissonant, squawking - as a ‘ballet’, Mingus must have been thinking on some level about Rite of Spring. Rite of Spring is half a century older again than Black Saint… and it’s still plenty dark, still challenging, still potent. And none of it sounds like The Stripper. 2

Artistry.

Full on. That space of 50's+60's jazz meets Bob Fosse. Intense at the end. Not for the faint hearted.

Nope, don’t get it. And, I tried. Man, I really tried. Maybe you need the ballet dancers for it to make sense. Some reviewers comment on the flamenco guitar. But, they just appear and go away, the composition doesn’t pick up on anything the guitar was doing. Maybe a snare grabs it for awhile in mode D or maybe E. I really couldn’t tell when a theme was finished. In fact, the first time my ear went “now, that’s interesting”. Spotify had finished the album and started playing Peace by Ornette Coleman

HOLY PEAK Track A – Solo Dancer→10/10 Track B – Duet Solo Dancers→10/10 Track C – Group Dancers→10/10 Mode D – Trio and Group Dancers Mode E – Single Solos and Group Dance Mode F – Group and Solo Dance→10/10 best→Mode D – Trio and Group Dancers Mode E – Single Solos and Group Dance Mode F – Group and Solo Dance worst→Track B – Duet Solo Dancers overrated→Track C – Group Dancers underrated→Track A – Solo Dancer overall→100/100 MUST HEAR OMFG…this is the best jazz album in the whole planet. There’s just so much going on at once that I can’t even understand all of it, but it’s just mindblowing. All I know for sure is that this is pure ear bliss. I’m at a loss for words. I DON'T FUCKING KNOW HOW TO EXPLAIN THIS‼︎

This is hard to categorize. It's jazz, for sure, but it's carefully orchestrated jazz that still manages to feel free form. It feels like elements of big band jazz, orchestral music, and film scoring all combined into a talented, happy mess. Parts are beautiful; parts are dissonant and ugly (intentionally). It's an incredible work of composition and performance, but it really needs a committed listen.

His name has Minge in it, so he wins.

In parts it's avant garde and in others, not just traditional, but twee and childish. I'd say I like jazz, I didn't much care for this.

Puikus albumas budėjimui

Incredible sonic textures. Was perfect for my rainy Friday morning commute.

This really is jumping in at the deep end of jazz. I bailed after three minutes, the asthmatic saxophones were just too much. I tried further snippets by dropping the play button elsewhere in the remaining tracks but Charlie and co had found new ways to annoy. Given the titles I was genuinely intrigued has anyone tried dancing to this, apparently they have. Someone clearly likes a challenge. I think the difference between this and the other jazz album I reviewed is that I could understand the influence of the Jimmy Smith album in mainstream rock and pop. I know little but names about jazz as to this album's influence on the genre. But no, it's just not for me.

Wanted to give this five stars. Clearly an amazing work. A little too rambling and lengthy for my taste.

As much as I want to be super hip and say that I was super into this, I really wasn't. Didn't bother me but I didn't engage with it. Probably would have felt differently if I wasn't listening while hating my passionless life of sitting in front of a computer all day.

My second time through The Black Saint... for this project is even better than my first, since I've revisited these songs several times since. I can't pretend to understand everything happening here, but this is great from start to finish, particularly "Group Dancers."

Can appreciate the free form but this leans a bit too noisy for me. Makes me want to check out his earlier stuff from the 50s, though.

good swingin album just nothing that wowed me

336. nice

It's too hard for me

Really dislike this album cover, its so boring, so generic, it looks like he didn't know what to pick. Charles is just sitting and smoking. I know this album has its moments, but I really REALLY dislike the presence of a tuba in jazz. The tuba sucks as an instrument and it kills the entire upbeat jazz vibe. Only 4 songs is not too much of a criticism because the medley is 18 minutes long and the overall album is 39 minutes. My only issue with that is that if I only enjoy 15:00 min - 16:30 min part of the song, then I would need to listen to 15 minutes before that. Skipping through the song is not really an option as I have Spotify free (which yeah, is my problem. If you could count a Medley as one song (which he does here) its not my favorite. Best Song: Group Dancer. Worst Song: Medley.

As jazz goes, this was pretty solid. Certainly one of the better albums from an instrumental perspective. Mode D- was my favorite of the pieces.

man idk I once tried to listen to Bitches' Brew too I guess jumping into the "experimental" end of the jazz pool is probably not a great idea ok I like the bass, I guess he's a bassist, that's cool but man this has a lot of noisy horns and I do not particularly love it

Date: 8/11/26 Album: 4/1102 Rating: 4.5/5 Fav Track: Medley: Mode D-Trio and Group Dancers It's been a while since I've heard any jazz, and I was not disappointed.

it was pretty good, especially the first song

My brain is incompatible with most jazz. It’s not them, it’s me.

Amazing.

Was ok as a morning background, but not my style

You enter a coffee shop in the Silver Lake neighborhood of LA. Order an Americano, like the locals, and sit down next to a guy in the corner. He's in his early 40s, dressed head to toe in linen, soft hands, eyes closed, swaying his head back and forth almost as if in pain. You tap him on the shoulder and he lifts one headphone off his ear. "What are you listening to?" "Mingus," he replies. "Migos?" you ask. He shakes his head and barely tries to stifle his sarcastic grin. "It's jazz, brotha. Start with the basics and work your way up. Eventually you'll hit Mingus." I don't know who is in the market for this ass slapping jazz, but I picture it being someone like that. Anyways I enjoyed this about as much as I can enjoy ass slapping jazz. I'm not a fan of the genre, but this was considerably more tolerable than some of the other jazz albums I've endured. The tempo never ripped too much for too long, the music seemed to have some actual direction, and it didn't meander endlessly like some of the Miles Davis stuff I've been assigned. I could even occasionally tell when one song ended and another began, which is always a nice bonus. The classical guitar intro on the last track genuinely slaps. I wish there had been more of that. Five stars for ass slapping jazz, three stars for an overall listening experience. I think that's about as high as I'm capable of going without developing a taste for Silver Lake scones and sporting the nicest thin white pants.

I liked this. I didn't love it.

I like the album art and title better than I like the music. Enjoyed the listen but took very little from it.

2/5 - Struggled to get through this. Not my thing.

Jazz ain't my jam, but could get behind it with a live atmosphere

it was nice. i dont think ive ever listened to jazz like that before, so throughout the whole thing it felt a bit like watching an old disney movie, probably because thats where most of my exposure to jazz comes from. really liked it though. feels like every track is telling a different story. the b one is definitely the worst of all four but i still enjoyed it. top3; c, d, a

Creative and interesting and do love a bit of jazz but not really my style, didn’t really enjoy how it would get chaotic at the end - 2.75

Really liked it. Listen to it again Up the Jazz

jazz del bueno, muy guay para tener de fondo, animado, pero no acelerado, de buen humor pero sin pasarse, 4/5

This album is exactly the reason for why i started using this website

One of the best jazz records. Get the vinyl in your collection NOW. 5/5 no notes.

LOVED IT

красота

Mingus deserves more than just one album for a list like this, but they did pick his one of his finest, exploratory works. Charles was so important for post WW2 jazz alongside Miles Davis that you could easily pick a random out of his and be amazed. He didn't live as long as Miles so he put fewer albums out there, but it's really a damn shame he somehow only has one album on here. mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus [incoherent yelling] mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus mingus bingus p.s: he also wrote a leaflet on how to train your cat to shit in a toilet. go google that, or voice command search that, or however the fuck human beings are able to operate search engines in [current year]

Not a jazz fan, but I liked this - except that the final song seemed to go on forever

As I understand it, this is a jazz ballet. I listened to it while driving and heard the variation in rhythm and sound from one track to the next, but it tended to fade into the background for me. Spotify rolled into a suggested song from Charles Mingus once the album ended, and I barely noticed.

Niet voor youri

It’s good. Yeah. Good.

I thought I liked jazz but I struggled sorry mr Mingus

gute lieder gutes album

Grabbed me from the start. I love the odd concept and the discordant sounds. 5/5

Amazing album,"Track B" (Duet Solo Dancers) and "Mode D" (Trio and Group Dancers) were my favorite. It's a good combination of high jazz with dancing tunes.

I like jazz, but typically something a little more palatable. That being said, there are some really brilliant passages on this album. Frequently the wind section would create sounds that you could swear was actual speaking. True talent. As a musician, I can't even wrap my head around deciphering, counting, and playing much of this music. As a listen, it does not appeal to me. But it still impresses me, and I am better for having heard it. The piano playing on it is super smooth and effortless. Would love to have heard more of it. But the chaos makes me pine for a little more space and groove between the noise.

такой неплохой блюзик

Holy shit this is so god damn cool

So many different instruments and influences show up in just these four tracks, telling stories of these different combinations of dancers. The harmonies are familiar but exaggerated and exciting--gritty sometimes. I hear both Spanish and African music throughout. Mingus' bass playing is the most outstanding I've ever heard. He is able to make his instrument sing in a way that often is uncharacteristic of bass lines. I can actually hum along with his lines—they don't get squashed in the mix... they cut right through. I suspect this is partly Charlie's facility, his instrument, and the incredible engineering of Bob Simpson.

I am a bit of a jazz guy, not so much a ballet guy. I think I'd need to see the ballet that is supposed to go along with this. I found a couple of interpretations online but failed to find a whole suite. I want to be in in the room while both are being performed. Sans dance I think Track C was the most enjoyable listen to the ballet of catching up on work emails.

It's at various times a rampage, a very loose party, funny and whimsical, grand and slinky. It's never boring. It's the kind of jazz that Gets You A Reputation in the office when it's your turn with the iPod, and your missus looks into your soul and wonders if everything is OK. But as a solo experience, this is a huge, and rewarding journey.

Absolutely blown away by tracks 3 & 4

RATING: 9/10 HIGHLIGHT: Duet Solo Dancers LOWLIGHT: Group Dancers

Not a big jazz guy, but damn this is good.

me at the concept of jazz: 🤩🔥🥰 me when it comes to actually listening to it: 🫩😩🙉

This album was a bit difficult for me. The cacophonous and often discordant sound wasn’t entirely pleasing, but by the end of the album, I really started to enjoy some of it and started listening to another track by Charles Mingus that I really enjoyed a lot. So, who knows, maybe I could learn to love it. What I do love is the album cover, the typography, the photo of Mingus, and the white space is just really, really incredible.

A bit rambly but great

1.9 - the main theme of the whole album was very groovy and I wanna like it.. but just too free form. And a majority of duration seems like just noise to me personally.

Ikke noget for mig

#263 I can't comprehend jazz, much in the same way I cannot with classical music. Two different beasts, neither for the casual listener. I like to think I am more than a casual listener but I definitely do not have the capacity to enjoy the nuances or speak jazz. I have no idea what I am listening to, I just know I like parts of it, and thats enough for me.

absolute vibe, especially on a gloomy morning

I don’t get jazz

This is the sort of music that I like and admire, but it doesn't really speak to me enough to get full marks.

not my cup of tea

Avant Garde jazz shows up to the party. Uninvited. JUST KIDDING I love jazz, and even I find this progressive opus difficult. It's confrontational and intellectual. It doesn't seem like there is a big audience for Mingus' oddball vision, even in the post-bop era, a time when Jazz was pretty popular, with a lot of mainstream acceptance. Mingus puishes the limits. I always thought his stuff was pretty academic.

I need to listen to this when I am high. Charles Mingus is one of the giants of Jazz with Miles Davis, John Coltrane and Herbie Hancock. This was composed as a ballet I would like to see this produced. Love the random Flamenco guitar. Very cool!

The best jazz album of all time?

I am not much of a jazz fan, but boy is this album good!!!!!! It is not that I dislike jazz, I usually just find it good/fine, but this album is exceptionally good. I love all the unique instruments like the flamenco guitar, and this album has such a great climax!!! Amazing album, I really need to listen to it more!!! High 5!!!!!!!!

Very nice album will need a proper revisit when i’m more in the mood!

I'll always love jazz, but this isn't anyhting special

I tend to like jazz but I never really have any intention of listening on my own. These are wonderful compositions that I may or not revisit. Probably not, though. The one I do enjoy about jazz albums, is that they tend to make these supergroups of amazing musicians. I like to check who is playing on the record on Wikipedia. I'm no jazz nerd but I know some names or three.

Enjoyment: 6/10 Replayability: 8/10 Cohesion: 7/10 Flow/Pacing: 7/10 Artistic Merit: 5/10 Weighted Average: 6.6/10 Review: A solid jazz album that musically conveys a tragic love story. I respect the choice of including the spanish guitar for flair between the horn section. Overall, a good listen. Liked Song(s): (None) Disliked Song(s): (None) Recommend? Maybe Heard Before? No

I love jazz... but this to me sounds like a 1-man band with parkinsons, sorry.

Was apprehensive going into this one but was better than i was expecting. last song was a highlight. Much better than some of the jazz on this list. A bit more relaxed than i was expecting.

Якраз вчора слухав. Класний альбом, мені сподобався.

This is funky as hell. Idk if I like it. Ok jazzy as hell. This is weird. He's minging it up. He's getting funky as hell. Idk. Kinda just here. Unremarkable. Favourite: Track B Least favourite: Track A

#279/1001 🇺🇸 Mixed feelings here. It obviously features some amazing playing but i found the final track quite annoying. Best Track: Track B.

I took one trimester of jazz band in high school, so I think I know my stuff here. This is exceptional. Don't ask me why, but it is. Very glad I was exposed to this. It's not something I'll keep in my rotation, but the big band musicianship is elite.

i never know if i like jazz or not because every jazz album i listen to is so different! but i really really liked this - moody and layered and strange.

Relaxed jazz

seems very high concept for its time

A very good Jazz album, but not my style. I prefer rock things and I’ll go make my reviews in that position so. I believe if I get into jazz and listen some times more, the album will be very good. For now 5 out of 10

Jazz was always a genre I was interested in, but never explored. This album was a taste of what I've been missing out on - at times, angry, visceral; other moments were soft, tender. I know next to nothing about Charles Mingus, and I still felt what he was saying through his music. You don't need to know the history of jazz to feel it in your heart and soul. You just need to be open to it.

The first jazz album on here that I've enjoyed. It's up tempo enough to not be laborious.

Lowkey volcanic.

pretty nice jazz album. one of two i had listened to before this list, and i liked it then; still like it now