The Great Outdoors Jam by Pigeons Playing Ping Pong

The Great Outdoors Jam

Pigeons Playing Ping Pong

2.59
Rating
290
Votes
1
15%
2
31%
3
36%
4
15%
5
3%
Distribution

User Submitted Album

View Submitter's Profile

Reviews (page 2 of 2)

Eh, it's ok. They're definitely talented but I'm not a big fan of jam bands. 3 stars.

As a guitar player, I really despise this kind of jam music. Technically uninteresting, gratuitous noodling on the fretboard is a bit like masturbation –fun for you but nobody else really wants to hear or see it. I imagine that if I was on a suitable amount of drugs this would be interesting, but as it stands sober this commits the cardinal sin of media by being boring as hell. 10+ minute jams with little to no dynamic contrast, key changes, melodic progression – it’s just flat and sterile, a block of music ready-made and packaged for you with no lumps or bumps to cut your teeth on. Really telling that A) there’s no crowd noise, probably because they were asleep or sitting politely in their walkers, and B) the best moments are when the band lifts melodies from people who know how to actually write catchy, enjoyable songs.

You tube asked me if I was still listening. I wasn't.

The great thing about the user generated list is that nothing bad will happen if I don't listen to the whole album before I die. I was therefore able to listen to a bit, skip forward some, and repeat until it became clear that, although these may be talented musicians, a 75 minute live record of improvised psychedelic funk just isn't my jam (fnar, fnar). Rating: 2 Playlist track: Ghostbusters Date listened: 04/04/25

Maybe they should have kept it with playing ping pong. This is just annoying.

3/10. It's not that it's really bad or anything, but I don't really need to hear hour-plus jam band albums before I die. And the Wikipedia article called these guys a funk jam band, but they just didn't feel that funky to me, a bit sterile even. I'm sure it'd be fun live. Having a Ghostbusters cover is fun for the first 5 minutes or so.

Rating: 7/10 Best songs: Ocean flows, Lightning, Poseidon

OK, jam bands aren't normally my thing, but I dug this. Really talented and I bet these guys are a blast to see live. Cool stuff.

Jam bands seem very masturbatory. The people involved seem to be very talented, but I don't think anyone needed an extended vamp on the Ghostbusters theme song, among other things.