User Submitted Album
View Submitter's ProfileAlbum Summary
Planet of Ice is the third full-length album from Minus the Bear, released in the UK on August 20, 2007 and in the US on August 21 by Suicide Squeeze Records. It was produced and recorded by the band's former keyboard player, Matt Bayles, in February and March 2007. It is the first Minus the Bear album to feature keyboardist Alex Rose, who replaced Matt Bayles after he left the band to concentrate on his career as a producer. It is also their last album on Suicide Squeeze Records until 2017's Voids.
Reviews
Planet Of Ice is the third album of prog rock band Minus the Bear. When I see the genre prog rock I'm always in doubt if I would like it. The seventies prog rock scene is a hit and miss for me. There are some bands I adore (King Crimson, Pink Floyd, Rush), some I detest (Yes, Emerson, Lake & Palmer, Van der Graaf Generator) and bands that have produced things I like and things I avoid (Jethro Tull, Genesis). The same feeling goes for the more recent ones. Porcupine Tree and Steven Wilson are not my cup of tea, but The Mars Volta is almost perfect. This album of Minus the Bear sounds like a softer version of The Mars Volta. Not as good, but still enjoyable with vocals that remind me of Peter Gabriel (and that is a plus). I like the songs the best that are a bit messy ("Double Vision Quest" and "Lotus"). I will check out their other albums. Interesting choice.
It's a bit generic but it's the style of rock I quite like, so I had an enjoyable time throughout. Wouldn't skip if it came up on shuffle but can't see myself seeking it out again.
I liked the first Minus the Bear album suggested on the list, and started off less enthusiastic about this one. But as I listened more it grew on my and I ended up liking it pretty well. The music feels somewhat “technical” to me, like machine-adjacent or something. Didn’t realize these guys are local to me. Guess I should have known that. I’m also quite taken by the story of their name from Wikipedia.
Indie rock, experimental rock, progressive rock, math rock. Ni fu ni fa.
Expected worse tbf
Honestly the top comment nails it. It's up my alley but I wouldn't seek this out. We have enough of this era of indie rock already. My personal rating: 3/5 My rating relative to the list: 3/5 Should this have been included on the original list? No
I've listened to this, but nothing really stuck with me. Ok music though
Sounds like alt rock radio!!! Ohhh yeaaah!!!
Without noticing I’ve already gone back to the user submissions. The fact that this was from 2007 clued me in: Dimery would never go back to fix that far… The album itself is a kind of proggy alt rock. Nice tunes!
My old housemate adored Minus the Bear. For me, a bit of a triumph of technical brilliance over songs, but not unenjoyable
I liked the previous entry by this band a lot. I liked this too, not sure if quite as much. Bit more of a uniform tone to it. But good, shades of prog rock, new wave and particularly the Police. Very confident in their sound.
It's fine. Best Track: Ice Monster 2.5