It’s good. I don’t think it’s anything absurdly original or out of the box as it mostly carries on from where Roxy Music started (particularly Psycho Killer). I find David Byrnes lyrics to be kind of bland and uninteresting on certain songs as well. It strays a bit too arty for my personal liking through the middle section of the album, but there’s first 2 songs and the last 2 are stellar. There’s some genuine belters on this album, so I can’t knock it too harshly. 3 stars, they’ve done much better.
Very enjoyable experience.
Not quite touching the sides of trip hop yet like Bjork does in future but that doesn’t diminish at all from the album. The choice of samples is fantastic, coupled with the Icelandic influence and unusual rhythmic lyrical patterns. Its absorbing. And the bass sounds phenomenal.
Bit of a fall off in the last 4-5 songs from the heights of the A-side but it’s just a very comprehensive project that makes you wanna dance, sing, nod your head. Crying and One Day are classics.
Very good album. Hard to ignore that she released multiple better albums tho.
To be perfectly honest, I don't really know what makes a jazz album good. I haven't spent enough time with them on my music journey.
I can seriously appreciate the talent of the performers, however. The way they seem to flow through each other in waves, coming together at points, adventuring off into different rhythmic structures in others. It's mesmerising. There's never a point in the record that I am bored.
I'm impressed by the subtleness of the bass, never overpowering the focal piano. Endeavouring on runs in the gentlest way. Evans himself never puts so much as a finger out of line, it's phenomenal.
Alas. I wish I could say I understand what makes great jazz great. No skips. Lovely music.
I think my rating for this is significantly increased by Papa Was a Rolling Stone, and the final two tracks which are funky as anything.
Motown is not really my area of expertise, but I've listened to enough of it and the soul scenes that came before and after to say that I think there are probably 25-50 better projects than this one, including one or two of their own. That does not detract from the incredible musicianship on this album, however. Particularly the brass and bass, which are subtle but provide that secondary point of interest to the singing ensemble. Do Your Thing is a prime example of this.
Will I be listening again? Yeah, I don't see why not. Will I be listening often? No, not by any means. It's no What's Going On. It's not even comparable to The Temptations Sing Smokey. But it's a lot of fun.
It's a very gorgeous experience. The guitar melodies are so intricate, yet full bodied and absorbing. His voice is intoxicating. You can barely take your ears away from the album.
Genuinely sounds like it could have been produced today. I can definitely see how it has influenced so many different artists, though perhaps not as clearly I might if I had listened to the entirety of his discography.
Further, it's always a nice breath of fresh air to hear something so creative without the reliance on a rhythm section.
All that knocks it down is my misunderstanding of the folk genre I'm afraid. I can appreciate the craft, the loveliness of the songwriting and singing, the self-examining lyrics. Maybe if I was more cultured. Or if I'd grown up with Simon & Garfunkel instead of The Smiths.
"It's very American for a British album" was pretty much the only thought going through my head as I listened to this the first time. Like a couple albums I've listened to recently, I think it gets carried by one or two songs whilst the others just make up the numbers and don't really contribute much.
I can see the appeal, I can see why it's got a plethora of positive ratings. I don't get it myself really. I think it's less well-formed than later albums they released; this is more experimental in the sense that it is testing of the waters of appeal of Americana blended rock on their audience. I don't think it's particularly earth-shattering or unique in it's content.
Jagger's voice gets annoying at times. Keith Richard's guitar work isn't what it is in the next couple albums yet; the album as a whole is produced well but good production can only do so much. It's nearly there.
What a great song Sympathy for the Devil is though. Wow. I could listen a million times and not be bored.
I will say on my second listen through I enjoyed it more. Sitting somewhere between a 3 & 4, but closer to 3 for now.
I distinctly remember listening to this a few years and thinking to myself something along the lines of: "take away Kids & Electric Feel and this is complete rubbish."
I don't entirely disagree with the sentiment, but I definitely feel that the album has grown on me enough to amount for better than a two. The production is fine, songs have a good variety to what was coming out around this time period. It provided a good contrast to the MySpace scene and Club Pop culture.
Comparing how good the first 5 songs are with the last 5 is a bit unfair. But if you're gonna make an album, you got to try to be consistent across the board. I don't think they managed that. In fact, I know they didn't manage it. Relisten to The Handshake and tell me again they deserve anything above a 4.
Inspired a new wave of creativity in the indie scene by redirecting it away from it's rock roots toward the electronic.
Sitting between a 2 and a 3, so I'll be generous and mark it up. If only because Electric Feel is one of the most addicting songs released since the turn of the century.
I remember a friend at school used to listen to Green Day religiously. On the bus, during breaks, in the back of the classroom. One day I decided to find out what the big deal was for myself and downloaded this album from YouTube onto my iPod Touch. From that point forth I think Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams was on just about every playlist I made for the next decade.
That's not to say that I loved the album, or Green Day, as I quickly left them behind in the dust (after being introduced to Linkin Park). I just really enjoyed some individual songs, and felt connected to a few of their lyrics.
Exploring this for the first time in well over 10 years, what I can say is it's actually a way better album than I remember; there's a really good narrative theme surrounding the "Jesus of Suburbia", most if not all of the songs are better than listenable with choruses that get stuck in your head. The lyrics and style of music might be a fraction dated, but the production isn't. It's contemporaneous, explores relatable human issues, and balances being aggressive and punky with being introspective and gentle. It strays away from their original pop-punk style more often toward a more polished alternative rock, which was a smart creative decision as that ship was sailing in a completely different direction after Blink-182 & New Found Glory established themselves on the scene.
Just as an aside, my goodness I never noticed how much MCR ripped off this album for The Black Parade. Amusingly similar style. No wonder the Naughties sounded the way they did. Another reason this album is so good; it shaped the way mainstream rock sounded in the following years, thankfully shaking off the influence of butt rock.
Nostalgia might be pushing this higher than it should be. I dunno. It's a pretty complete project, and when we talk of albums, that's all you can ask for. Deservedly took them to the top of the charts. Change a couple tracks and we could be talking a 5. Alas, we aren't quite there.
To be perfectly honest, I knew from the first song that this was going to be a 5 star review. Also, continuing with the theme of honesty, I have never actively sought out listening to Bob Marley, which in retrospect I find scandalous, because this as a project is just so good.
It really is an album of two parts: the more technically advanced, spiritual, rebellious, reggae driven side A; and the more accessible side B, which taps into universal ideals like love, humanity and faith, whilst exploring the poppier side of ska. I personally enjoyed the front side more; there's more to unpack and engage with in a political and musical sense.
The reggae melodies are simplistic in their own right, but when combined with Marley's glorious optimism and gorgeous harmonic interplay, the album becomes quite the masterpiece. It's complete in that there is not a single bad song. Further, it's not discussed enough how this album is probably tantamount to the success of the Ska revival wave in the UK a couple years on.
The greatest part is you don't even need to be stoned to feel the calm, positive, relaxing engagement of this album. It's just that good.
Okay. First listen was a rough experience. It took me way too long to get used to the garage/DIY sound. And the last track made me want to throw my Airpods into the closest large body of water.
But on reflection... yeah it's pretty good. I wouldn't suggest it's anything more than that. However, if it was made at a different time, it'd barely be sniffed at. The revival of the punk scenes by other bands like The Strokes & The Hives did a lot for allowing this album to barge it's way to recognition and success.
The album isn't particularly different from anything that has come before it by the '60s garage/proto-punk movements. It has that unique DIY sound to it, but again that was already established by other bands. They just popularised it for a modern audience, which I will grant is a feat in of itself. The lyrics aren't great, but Jack White's vocals make up for it, being the perfect blend of raw, emotional & eccentric. The riffs are forceful or gentle on the flip of a dime, but they never seem to get the balance wrong. The drums are fantastic, and the album sounds very powerful for a band without a bass. That is to be credited.
The second half of the album is much stronger than the first, but even then a couple of weaker songs crept their way through. Some great individual songs, but man there's some rubbish in there.
If it didn't have Seven Nation Army on it, it'd be one of the weaker albums I've heard this week. Good for them that it did, cause without it this album never would have touched the sides of the mainstream. What a belter of a song. Makes up for an otherwise middle of the road indie piece.
I think I have attributed much of Cyndi Lauper to other artists across the years. Half the tracks on this record found me exclaiming "DID SHE WRITE THAT?! I DIDN'T KNOW THAT WAS HER."
The first 6 songs are pop masterpieces. Stuff you've heard on the radio a million times over, and probably know half the words to without knowing why that is the case. The back 4 tracks are a similarly pleasant experience, but definitely demonstrated a bit more creative liberty, delving into ska, synthpop & Americana. Cyndi's taken inspiration from all her contemporaries and shoved them into a jumble of tracks in a way that actually works quite well all things considered.
I'm being harsh, but I just don't think the album flows particularly well. And the lyrical messaging is... very poppy. That is to say, there is basically nothing of import said at all. It's incredibly eccentric, which is not a critique. It was necessary and very influential for the reinvigoration of the pop-new wave scene through the middle portion of the '80s.
There's not a bad track on the album, there's just such a big disparity between the tracks that it is kinda jarring. There's really only one way to listen to it; sing at the top of your lungs, give it non-stop energy, dance with all your might, then sit down for 5 tracks and reflect on what you've done with a smile.
Pretty cool album.
Not for me at all.
There is some utter rubbish on this album. Poughkeepsie is a terrible song. There's a difference between being experimental and progressive, and just being bland and boring and hiding it behind intentionally abstract lyricism and discordant singing. Nothing in this album wasn't done a million times over by a thousand other artists. The lyricism barely makes up for it...
There are songs in the middle and latter half of the album that are more tolerable, in so far as the songs are composed as soundscapes. Banhart is weaker as a musical force when he is alone with the guitar. That feels almost blasphemous to say considering his clear skill with the acoustic, but it's the truth. Adding other layers really does bring about a better vibe to the music, makes it seem more whole, more Western, more American. Which is ultimately the goal of this music. I wish he would have done that more. Fall is a great example of it done right.
Bland, boring Americana tbh. He is not Swans, no matter how much he tries to be. All the ideas are stale, and despite the great production there is little else to shout and scream about with this album. Won't be getting much time on my playlists. A Sight To Behold is a gem though. One of only a couple songs that makes this album a 2 and not a 1.
Very good. Beautifully crafted choruses, lovely harmonies.
This album isn't about the band really; it's about the vocalists. And they're perfectly in sync. I really enjoyed the psychedelic elements; as someone with little background in psych pop this is a lovely introduction.
I enjoyed thoroughly. I wouldn't say there were weaker tracks in the middle portion, but certainly none that hit the heights of the cream of the crop, and that's all that drops it down from a five. Bit harsh maybe.
I'm always surprised by early punk albums like this one in how little is actually different from the alternative rock of the early to mid-70s.
Fighting lyrics, aggressive guitar riffs, drums that feel in places like they're trying to bash your eardrums to pieces; it has all the hallmarks for 70's punk. What it does well that is that these centrepieces aren't the only decorations on the mantle; there are elements of reggae scattered throughout, most notably in the cover of Police and Thieves. I will also give it it's flowers in that they don't just try to play loud and fast. There is thought in the project, a sense of humanity to the music in the ska elements and liberal lyrics. Much like the gothic sensibilities of The Damned, or the Ramones obsession with surf rock, they imposed their own style on punk. That is more than creditable.
I enjoyed the album, it just felt... slightly underwhelming. Maybe that's because I have had the fortune to listen to London Calling. Some of the songs seemed to blend together or I'd just forget entirely even after a second listen. It probably accommodates for four songs too many in the end. Trim down some of that fat, as they would in their following compilations, and it would've pushed a 4.
If you like The Clash, you'll inevitably like this project. Just 2 months late from being the seminal punk album, it spurred on a scene that sparked life into many genres and bands It is difficult to ignore that they have far better efforts down the line though.
Inconsistent, as have been all Stones records since the 70's. The front half sounds about as modern as the Stones have ever sounded, taking the best pieces of Blues Rock and combining them with elements of both 80's & 2010's production. I really liked the first 3 tracks, they sounded contemporary and variable to the traditional sound of the Stones. It's the most fresh and interesting they've been in 50 years. It doesn't last long though.
Bite My Head Off is not a great track when you consider the esteem of the writers (McCartney included), and some of the closing tracks are just bland and boring. I can't even remember anything of them from back-to-back listens. Rolling Stone Blues is the only track from the B side that stood the test of time with me; something that sounded exactly like their earlier records; blues infused with Americana.
This is all not to say that a band can't experiment with their sound 60 years on. I just don't think they really have at all. They've played it safe. And it does make you question who the intended audience truly is at this stage of their career. Is it the youth? Fat chance they're listening to this if it doesn't touch the sides of TikTok. Is it their fans from the 60's, 70's & 80's? If so, they're gonna tell you that the original was the best anyway, and I don't think auto-tuning Mick Jagger's voice is going to work wonders in convincing anyone otherwise. Blues Rock fell out of fashion in the late 60's in favour of psych & surf rock, and modern Pop Rock takes more from Pop than it does rock... it baffles me why they've set out to create a record in this mould.
Not for me. Give me 60's & 70's Stones instead. There's only so much a band can do to revive a dying genre in this day and age, particularly when they're not trying to push the boundaries of experimentation. 2 & a half would be more fair as a rating.
Run of the mill New Romantic album really, with a really great opening track and a few fun back up dancers through the second half of the album.
It's got all the hallmarks; synths, jingly melodies, funk inspired bass. A singer that likes to be eccentric and embrace unconventionality. Saxophone? Apparently that was necessary.
About halfway through, I was starting to feel like they're almost trying a fraction too hard; throwing a million darts at a board and seeing where they stick. Then came Miss Me Blind. What a fun track. Great shift away from the sound they'd holed themselves in, and the bass is just so damn good.
The album as a whole is nothing to write home about, but there's enough moments in there to turn the head. And maybe start some feet tapping too. Okay, fine, I danced to Mister Man. It's a bop. Forgive me.
On a side-note I despise that album cover. Shocking decision. Sack everyone involved if they're still employed.
All of that is to say that bands like Duran Duran and Spandau Ballet still stand head and shoulders above Culture Club both contemporaneously and presently. But though I've heard far better, I'll undoubtedly hear far worse. This is no bad album. It's just not a great one either.
Too many highs to detract from the slightly weaker tracks in the centre. Any album with Stairway to Heaven & Black Dog on it is going to be hard to beat. Add to that my personal favourite, When The Levee Breaks, and you've got yourself a masterpiece.
Going to California is beautiful as well. The epitome of Led Zeppelin. This album and LZII inspired about a hundred different rock derivative genres. And probably caused the downfall of blues rock as well.
Barely stepped a foot wrong. Fantastic.
So damn close to a 5 star album. There's not a bad track on the list, every song feels unique and creative. It's released at the height of the "hard rock" era that brought so much great music to the world from the British Isles.
Deep Purple are probably the more forgotten child of the greats of their era, but listening to this album I can't imagine why. It's fast, it's powerful. It, along with every Black Sabbath song, probably paved the way for modern metal to come to the fore.
I can't pinpoint exactly why this isn't perfect... maybe it just feels slightly "done before", or "done better". Either way, it's a phenomenal project that I thoroughly enjoyed.