User Submitted Album
View Submitter's ProfileReviews (page 2 of 2)
No, not this. 2/5.
Not bad 3
What a pleasant surprise to find one of my favorite cult bands here. It's not the album I would have chosen from their discography, but The Decemberists have always seemed to me like one of those bands incapable of making a mediocre or bad album. They've been getting closer and closer to pop, but I always saw it more as a natural evolution than as a pretense to reach more people. And their latest albums are just as enjoyable. Even more so, in fact. Great thanks to whoever posted it for giving me this joyful time on the streets of Basel
It's like a rock opera fairytale. Usually I listen these albums during my car commute. And so I did with this. But it gave me the urge to listen it again, with the lyrics in front of me to really get the full story.
Yeah. Really strong narrative sound, although maybe a song or 2 too many.
My general issue with the Decemberists has been finding them too faux old-timey and leaning too heavy on affectation and quirk. The lyrical and musical leitmotifs and harder rock edges in this album did a lot to temper those tendencies, though my eyes still rolled a bit at some of the more bombastic murder-ballady stuff.
This is why I still like to listen to the user albums. Sometimes there's an entrance which you just like. At first it sounded just folky but later there was also a rawness with heavy guitars and a kind of progressive feel also, especially the song 'The Wanting Comes in Waves/ Repaid' which I found quite appealing with that epic chorus. But they kept the quality going til the end. Chapeau!
Love this one
The ultra rare album where the closing track may be the best one?
8/10. I do really like it when Rock Operas actually have different singers for different characters, makes it a lot easier to follow. And there really isn't enough modern music about people getting fucked over by forest spirits, so this was an enjoyable listen for me.
Interesting Indie concept album and if I had time to listen to the lyrics/story I may have gotten more out of it, but as someone else said, they are too one dimensional in their sound
Hazards lacks some of the titular hazards as it rounds the generational line and covers the wide American musical landscape. The twangle achieves full body as country music at the end, something that may have been a more complete feel for the album.
Didn't like it
I wish they'd go hard more than they go pretty, and I wish they'd altogether avoid going twangy.
Used to like them in college. But it always feels a bit one-dimensional.