I'm not huge on live albums, but I think there's something special with Cooke's voice and energy here that warrants its place on this list. So undeniably electric--"Feel It (Don't Fight It") got a creeping smile out of me by the chorus. The gravelly grit of Cooke's voice (most prevalent on songs like "Somebody Have Mercy" or "Bring It On Home To Me") was amplified in its power by the joyous crowd; had I been present, I'm sure I'd feel the same catharsis everyone in the room must've felt. Cooke is clearly a talented vocalist, and I appreciate how he lets loose to make for an unforgettable display of human soul. I do hesitate on ranking it any higher than a 4, though. I don't see myself coming back to this particular record very often, and many of the songs on an individual level weren't suited to my particular tastes. Still, I can't deny its incandescence: this is a light 4 for me.
STAND-OUT SONG: "It's All Right / (I Love You)"
HONORABLE MENTIONS: "Feel It (Don't Fight It)", "Cupid”, "Chain Gang", "Nothing Can Change This Love"
Really good folk & blues rock. It’s not an immediate standout record, but there are moments of brilliance & I can see myself coming back to these tracks when the mood is right. I need some time to develop a final opinion, but songs like “See the Sky About To Rain” and “On the Beach” easily tip the scales in favor of a solid three. Excited to explore some more Neil Young!
STAND-OUT SONG: “See the Sky About To Rain”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Walk On”, “On the Beach”, “Revolution Blues”
Coltrane is clearly a massive talent, but I guess I just don't gravitate towards instrumental jazz like I do with most genres. Wouldn't mind it as background music though. A personal 2, but I can recognize why it'd be much higher for others.
STAND-OUT SONG: “A Love Supreme, Pt. 2: Resolution”
HONORABLE MENTION: “A Love Supreme, Pt. 4: Psalm”
So chill but hypnotic—I can really see how a lot of contemporary music was informed by this record’s sound. Some tracks dragged a bit but it never made for a poor listening experience, and when there were highs (“Sour Times”, “It Could Be Sweet”, “Glory Box”), they soared.
EDIT (7/8/26): after sitting with this album a bit longer, it’s really stuck with me in a way many of my other four stars haven’t. upgrading to my first 5:)
STAND-OUT SONG: “Glory Box”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Sour Times”, “It Could Be Sweet”, “It’s A Fire”, “Mysterons”
Ugh Dolly my queen. The songs are structurally pretty simple, but her voice infuses them with a quality that’s so soothing and moving. A three almost feels too low, but I don’t see myself coming back to most of these songs. Nonetheless a really enjoyable listen throughout: probably a veeeery strong three overall.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Early Morning Breeze”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Coat of Many Colors”, “The Way I See You”
It was pretty fine, but I don’t feel compelled to listen again. Stewart’s voice is unique enough but its gravelly quality can get repetitive at times; I can recognize the appeal though. These songs have the potential to come to life in a live setting, but on their recorded versions, I’m generally lukewarm. Overall a strong two.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Country Comfort”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Gasoline Alley”, “My Way of Giving”
His voice is so finely controlled but loose and expressive it’s insane. Vocal performance aside though, I wasn’t feeling this one. It’s probably a symptom of it being another live album but some tracks were quick & abrupt, while others ambled slowly to the finish. It never felt like the album found its footing to me, but I can totally see the appeal. A personal very strong two.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Try Me”
HONORABLE MENTION: “I’ll Go Crazy”
Vast majority of the songs are a pleasant listen and enjoyable background music. I don’t know if I’d come back to these songs as anything but a musical backdrop, but I felt the groove and life in each track. Some songs didn’t click for me (“Blues for Huey”, “Ingoo Pow-Pow”), but the ones that did (“Part of a Whole”, “Minawa”, “Maseru”, “Inner Crisis”) made the record worth it. A solid three.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Part of a Whole”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Minawa”, “Maseru”, “Inner Crisis”
After listening to the first track of this album, I was prepared to extrapolate & judge this album for its off-putting atmosphere and disparate elements. But as I listened, I realized that these weren’t necessarily bad things; the last thing I want from a record is for it to be uninspired, and you can’t argue that this record isn’t full of funky sounds and imaginative storytelling. It sets a mood for sure, and it’s one I haven’t heard from any artist prior to Waits. He won me over by the end, but there’s still something lost between my personal tastes and where the album goes sonically. A personal strong three.
STAND-OUT SONG: “16 Shells From A 30.6”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Shore Leave”, “Johnsburg, Illinois”
Enjoyed this record more than “On the Beach”, but not enough to elevate it above a three (closer to a 3.5). It definitely has the Neil Young sound I’ve learned to take some enjoyment from, and expands upon it with punchier arrangement and catchier melodies. I think I connected more with some of Neil’s earlier work thematically, but enjoy these songs more as individual pieces, which is obviously very important. A strong 3 overall.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Welfare Mothers”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)”, “Pocahontas”, “Sail Away”
Such a broad range of songs with the through-line that is Fleetwood Mac’s musical synergy. I wouldn’t say any singular song blew me away, but together it’s such a solid—often soothing, sometimes electrifying—collection of songs. Strong four!
STAND-OUT SONG: “Brown Eyes”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Sara”, “Never Make Me Cry”
Accomplishes what it sets out to do, and does it well. I almost lean four stars, but I’m sticking with a strong three here because most of the lyrical content/song composition doesn’t do much for me. Nelson’s delivery makes these songs special, however, and warrants replay value on a special kind of nostalgic day.
STAND-OUT SONG: “September Song”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Moonlight in Vermont”, “Don’t Get Around Much Anymore”, “Georgia On My Mind”
I thought it was pleasant enough and enjoyed where it went sonically. It never surprised me, which I don’t love, but it feels derivative in a way I can appreciate. Not much else to say: probably a weak three overall.
STAND OUT SONG: “Jupiter and Teardrop”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Fuzzy”, “America Snoring”
I honestly didn’t connect much with this record. I can appreciate it for what it is, but the songwriting/lyrical content didn’t really resonate with me (esp the first few songs). There were some cool instrumental moments in the title track, but it’s not something I see myself coming back to regularly. Strong two.
STAND-OUT SONG: “In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida”
HONORABLE MENTION: “My Mirage”
Pretty interesting! This was my first (formal) introduction to Afrobeat as a genre, and I think Fela Kuti is a good ambassador for it. It was pleasant overall, but nothing really stuck out; at times the instruments’ meandering or the vocals chanting caught my attention, but it’s nothing I’m dying to come back to. With only four songs, I was hoping each would pack a punch—and in a way they did—but my feelings about this album were never really challenged after listening to the first few minutes of the title track. Strong two.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Mr. Follow Follow”
HONORABLE MENTION: “Zombie”
Childhood classics ❤︎ I’m a bit biased but I really did like this record. You can hear the imperfections, sure, but I think the hodgepodge nature of the Beatles’ earlier work is what makes it so charming. Can feel a little musically repetitive at times, but the melodies are catchy enough that I don’t find myself bored really ever. I didn’t care for some of the covers, and it’s not my favorite album of theirs, but a solid, career-defining entry of their catalogue. Four stars!
STAND-OUT SONG: “It Won’t Be Long”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Hold Me Tight”, “I Wanna Be Your Man”, “Money (That’s What I Want)”
I actually love the electronic ambient-jazz fusion sound this record brings, but I found myself disappointed by its lack of consistent forward momentum. As much as I was trying not to be, I was just kinda bored. There are certainly idiosyncratic and noteworthy sounds produced (especially on some of the earlier tracks—“Tantos Desejos” & Na Neblina” come to mind), but the second half lost me and never reeled me back in. Solid three for the vibes, but not much else.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Na Neblina”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Tantos Desejos”, “Felicidade”
Expands on the David Bowie sound I was familiar with in all the best ways. I really love how he isn’t afraid to just let a song unfurl, and tracks like “TVC15” and “Wild Is The Wind” are better for it. He’s a master of crafting a good rock / pop song (whatever you wanna call it, but “Golden Years” is a straight bopppp), and his aura is radiant even on tracks that feel more drab than technicolor. All in all, however, I’m not actually sure it lives up to a five star score; I think it’s great, but I’d say it’s generally more of a superb installment in Bowie’s catalogue than its own five-star-worthy record. Strong four:)
STAND-OUT SONG: “TVC15”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Golden Years”, “Wild Is The Wind”
Half of these songs sound like they could be used in a Breaking Bad montage & one of them sounded like they sampled the fitness gram pacer test. Strange but in a weird electronic, club-y way that I can enjoy when I’m in the right mood. I liked the songs that settled into the electronic production more than the lyrical ones, though. Three stars.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Climbatize”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Smack My Bitch Up”, “Funky Shit”, “Narayan”, “Fuel My Fire”
This is the shortest record on the list and I was still actively waiting for it to be over… yikes. I’m too lame for punk I think, but “Beverly Hills” into “Operation” were the standout tracks for me. If more of the album sounded like these two tracks, I’d probably have it a bit higher. But it doesn’t. And I’m like never coming back to this album probably. Maybe time will pass & I’ll have a punk epiphany that prompts me to retcon this review. Until then, though, it’s a personal one star with some redeeming qualities :(
STAND-OUT SONG: “Beverly Hills”
HONORABLE MENTION: “Operation”
I was gonna give this a three… but I think I’m landing at a strong two here. I dunno. It’s fine. I liked “1969” and “I Wanna Be Your Dog” enough, and then “We Will Fall” hit and all momentum was lost IMO. It picked up again towards the end, but by then my opinion was tempered by the other less captivating tracks. I want to explore Iggy Pop & his work with The Stooges more for sure, but this album wasn’t my favorite.
STAND-OUT SONG: “1969”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “I Wanna Be Your Dog”, “Ann”
Reminiscent of the Beatles for me! You can hear the 50s influences undergird most of these tracks, and the forward momentum of the album generally makes for a pleasant listening experience. However, the songs themselves were nothing to write home about for me, which makes it hard for me to rate this anything higher than a three.
STAND-OUT SONG: “The Kids Are Alright”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “My Generation”, “Please, Please, Please”
I really like Tina Turner’s sound, and this is quintessential Tina. It’s pop music with an idiosyncratic 80s essence that only she could bring. It’s refreshing in a sea of British-fronted rock albums. Not a five for me, but solidly in the four camp.
STAND-OUT SONG: “What’s Love Got To Do With It”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Private Dancer”, “Steel Claw”
Pretty revolutionary for its time, and its sound definitely rippled into the funk/soul/pop atmosphere of future decades. Each track felt open ended, and I enjoyed where most of the songs went by the end of their runtime. Decent four.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Stand!”
HONORABLE MENTION: “Everyday People”
I know a lot of people find it grating & flat, but I think Bob Dylan’s voice works on a lot of these songs. Brimming with feeling, great great storytelling, and solid songwriting. It’s a classic for a reason. Strong four.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Like A Rolling Stone”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Tombstone Blues”, “Ballad of a Thin Man”
Lots of generally formless, but undoubtedly inspired songs here. Some stuck the landing for me, while others sauntered to the finish. These songs are best accompanied by a list of lyrics and an attentive ear, but can otherwise feel a bit drab. As a native New Jerseyan, though, hearing Mahwah & Linden & the turnpike in the span of a few tracks made me smile. Three stars.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Atlantic City”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Nebraska”, “Open All Night”
Loved a lot of the instrumentals & overall soundscape of this album. The vocals were hit or miss with me; sometimes they complemented the electronic/indie backdrop, other times they felt same-y. I could see this record growing on me since its overall sound is suited to my tastes, but for now, I land at a strong three.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Atlantis to Interzone”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Golden Skans”, “Forgotten Works”, “Gravity’s Rainbow”
Started at rock bottom, and almost clawed its way up to a weak two, but the last few tracks killed its chances. Overall questionable songs dotted with a few decent melodies here and there. I’m into experimental stuff, but not this type of experimental. “F**k Shit Up” really did fuck shit up…. and the album suffered for it. I’d love to return to this in a few years with a more trained ear and see if some of the sounds are more appealing then, but I don’t think it’ll ever be a standout favorite. Strong one.
STAND-OUT TRACK: “Firefly Child”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Wail”, “Dynamite Lover”
Groovy, if a bit boring. No moments from any of these songs felt like a big arrival or moment of catharsis—a characteristic that defines most of my favorite albums—but nothing was unsavory or offensive to listen to. That was part of my problem, though: the smooth consistency. I think it’d be unfair to call this album a drag, since I think many of these songs are beautifully composed and sang, but I’m not sure I can go any higher than a decent three.
STAND-OUT TRACK: “Chest Fever”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Tears of Rage”, “The Weight”
Dated and a little obnoxious, but ultimately fun. Helped define some of the new wave/post-punk sounds, but I don’t see myself returning to a lot of these tracks, if any at all. They all kinda blended together for me into one congealed, ant-y mass. Strong two.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Antmusic”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Killer in the Home”, “Feed Me to the Lions”
Lots and lots and lots of organ. Didn’t hate it, but didn’t love it either. Some really cool moments of build & lyricism I want to dissect a bit more, but it didn’t have the personal “it” factor that draws me to an album instantaneously. I know it does for plenty of people, given its spot on the list, but from my 21st-century ear I’m a little more lukewarm. Strong two bordering on weak three.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Soul Kitchen”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Light My Fire”, “Take It As It Comes”
Wait I really did love this album. Each song had this alternative-electronic-rock fuzziness to it with a through line of melodic electricity. Contrary to the album title, all the songs felt distinct and individual. I don’t think it’s necessarily a five star record, but surely a strong four!
STAND-OUT SONG: “Beetlebum”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Song 2”, “On Your Own”
I love some in-your-face experimentalism (& I’m a sucker for albums flowing from one track to the next), but half of these songs just felt like they were off-kilter for the sake of being off-kilter. When these tracks were given a chance to grow (“Zen Archer”, “International Feel”, “When Shit Hits the Fan; Sunset Blvd.”), they metamorphosed into dynamic and rightfully idiosyncratic tunes. When left at the one-minute mark (“Rock and Roll Pussy”, “Dogfight Giggle”), however, they just felt like disparate, half-baked fragments of noise. Overall moments of brilliance marred by moments of “what the hell okay sure.” The parts I loved and the parts I hated ended up reaching a middling equilibrium by the end; a weak three feels good here, all said and done.
Okay so historically hard rock/heavy metal doesn’t do much for me, and this record didn’t push the needle too far from my established opinion. However, I can recognize the merit in it. I liked when the songs deviated from the traditional gritty, gravelly vocals of hard rock and went somewhere a littles softer—something it dabbled in, but ultimately never pursued beyond a song like “Child In Time” (which is arguably its best track). It’s a solid, undeniable rock album, but its pockets of experimentation and slow-burn growth held my favorite moments, and unfortunately these were fewer and further in between than I would’ve liked.
STAND-OUT TRACK: “Child In Time”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Into The Fire”, “Living Wreck”
This record was lucky to escape 1 territory. Not my cup of tea. “On Sir Francis Drake” might be one of my least favorite songs from this album journey so far; “Trillium” sucked too. The more mellifluous, albeit inoffensive tracks that surrounded these tracks protected this album’s score from reaching rock bottom, but not by much. I just didn’t really care about these songs. Very 60s, psychedelic, organ-heavy, Doors-adjacent groovy rock. I think I’m just tired of the abundance of albums in this list that share this album’s style, which could be biasing me against it. Weak two.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Sunshine”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Quicksand”, “Darkness, Darkness”
Or do you not think so far aheadddd, because I’ve been thinking about foreverrrrrr, oooohhhh…….. So many great alt-r&b-pop hits imbued with Frank’s ingenious sensibilities. I also liked the interludes—I don’t know if that’s a hot take. It gave the album a sense of cohesion where there otherwise might’ve not been. Some vocal and instrumental patterns dragged a little by the end, but it didn’t distract me from the crux of this record: a melange of skillful, melodic, summer-glistened tracks. Call me Colleen Ballinger if you must, but haters need to back off!!!
STAND-OUT SONG: “Sweet Life”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Thinkin Bout You”, “Super Rich Kids”, “Bad Religion”, “Pyramids”
Honestly just came off as boring folk rock. To my modern ear, I don’t extract a lot of enjoyment nor interest from these songs; some had a falsetto-d, melodic vulnerability that could be appealing, but most of the tracks dragged like the good mediocre, occasionally-psychedelic, folk-rooted rock album it was. “Cowboy Movie” did not need to last that long either. A two, probably, but ways to go from a three.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Laughing”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Traction In The Rain”, “Music Is Love”
The worst part about this album is that I wanted to like it so badly. It’s a prog-rock experimental concept album with enough breeziness and whimsy that it’s not infiltrated by a pompous state of mind, but evidently takes itself seriously enough to commit to a fully fleshed-out story. I was so excited… and then I was on the fence. The vocals had such a punk-adjacent screechiness that felt very of its time, which got grating by the end; the composition of the songs themselves, however, were ingenious. Sometimes an album can have all the right concepts but fails to entirely hit the mark on the execution, and that’s where this album lands for my personal tastes. I think this is the type of album that needs to be metabolized and analyzed with a fine tooth comb, and I fear this generator just forces you to keep on moving. Clearly boundary pushing stuff—and I’m happy The Mars Volta has continued to make music to this day—but I’ll go against the grain & honor my feelings. Weak three bordering on strong two, but open to changing my mind.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Televators”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Cicatriz Esp”, “Inertiatic Esp”
Lukewarm, albeit pleasant music. Not a lot to say but Coldplay is probably at their most original here, less informed by commercial success and more by their own songwriting impulses. Some really nice, yet safe vocal melodies and guitar moments throughout. “Sparks” and “Yellow” are the type of songs you might hear as background noise at a TJ Maxx, but at least you’d be tapping your foot to it. I dunno. Might be crazy to give it a three, but that’s what I’m feeling. A three!
STAND-OUT SONG: “Shiver”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Don’t Panic”, “Sparks”
The album that just keeps hittinggggg, so good. Just flow after bar after flow. A really good synergy throughout, and it’s clear that this record was only possible as the byproduct of each member’s ingenuity. Wasn’t necessarily a fan of every song, but think I’m gonna have to take some more time with it. Strong four—open to a five.
STAND-OUT SONG: “Tearz”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “C.R.E.A.M.”, “Method Man”, “Protect Ya Neck”
I think I just really love Janis Joplin’s voice. Without even recognizing the context of this album’s release (dropping three months after her untimely passing), there’s a persistent electricity marked by Joplin’s star-defining idiosyncrasy. She makes full use of her voice as the instrument it is, and the album is better for it. The songs could caterwaul for a minute too long on some tracks, but they were never devoid of the emotion needed to make the delivery land. My brain says a strong four, but my heart says a five, so it’s getting a five!
STAND-OUT SONG: “Cry Baby”
HONORABLE MENTIONS: “Me And Bobby McGee”, “Get It While You Can”, “A Woman Left Lonely”