Album Summary
A Wizard, a True Star is the fourth album by American musician Todd Rundgren, released March 2, 1973, on Bearsville Records. It marked a departure from his previous, Something/Anything? (1972), with its lesser reliance on straightforward pop songs, a development he attributed to his experimentation with psychedelic drugs and his realization of "what music and sound were like in my internal environment, and how different that was from the music I had been making."The album was produced, engineered, and, with the exception of some tracks, entirely performed by Rundgren. He envisioned the record as a hallucinogenic-inspired "flight plan" with all the tracks seguing seamlessly into each other, starting with a "chaotic" mood and ending with a medley of his favorite soul songs. At the time of release, he stated that Wizard intended to advance utopian ideals; later, he said that the album had no definite meaning. No singles were issued from the album, as he wanted the tracks to be heard in the context of the LP. With 19 tracks, its nearly 56-minute runtime made it one of the longest single-disc LPs to date. Upon release, A Wizard, a True Star received widespread critical acclaim, but sold poorly, reaching number 86 on U.S. charts. According to Rundgren, "the result was a complete loss of about half of my audience at that point." To support the album, Rundgren formed a new group, Utopia, his first official band since the Nazz. Their technologically ambitious stage show was cancelled after about two weeks on the road. A Wizard, a True Star has since been recognized for its influence on later generations of bedroom musicians.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
The art work should give you a clue Todd is a true musical genius and artist, but sometimes that gets in the way of some enjoyable music. Starts out really odd and experimental, then there are a few songs in middle that seem to be more structured. As if in the days of albums one side is experimental, the other... MOR. First part shows he still has stuff to sort out.
I bought this in high school in the late 70s and never really got into it beyond the novelty of the 2nd track. Listening now, I like it a lot more--it's a little all over the place in a good way--but I'm still not buying what he's selling.
Lock a guy who can play every instrument and likes ELO, R&B, opera, the White Album, soft rock. Give the dude all the LSD. Let him record in a restless frenzy of addled self-regard. It sounds like a great idea, right? It's not.
There were parts of this album that I really disliked listening to and found it very creepy or irritating. But the rest of it was either fun or quite delightful. The transitions between songs were sick too. It’s a mixed bag, and most of it landed on the better side of weird.
C+
One of those throw everything and see what sticks type of albums. A pretty fun experience overall but he probably needed to learn to say no to some stuff
The middle of that one befuddled me. It was like he misplaced his LSD then found it again for the last three songs. It is amazing how many albums on this list he is associated in one way or another. 5/10 Top song... Sometimes I don't know what
Truly terrible.
I met Todd once, real prick. I've heard many times how brilliant he was. I have never listened to this album, nor has it ever been mentioned to me as one I needed to listen to. I've been told he was ahead of his time. There's just TOO MUCH going on during "International Feel", it's so busy and mashed together, it's like two songs are playing at the same time. The percussion doesn't match up. Super annoying, even at under 3 minutes. The next six songs were 1 minute long and incomplete in so many ways. "Dogfight Giggle" was monkeys and birds fighting, WTF? Research: It sold poorly. A Wizard, a True Star peaked at #86 on the Billboard 200 and spent about 15 weeks on the chart. It didn’t chart in the UK at all, even though critics were largely enthusiastic. Its reputation has grown a lot since then. It’s now widely cited as an influence on later experimental and electronic artists, including Trent Reznor, Daft Punk, and Frank Ocean. If I were on acid this might've been a ball, but sitting in my office fully sober this was a real drag. I hated the experience, really, it was so disjointed and all over the place. 'Pop savant' my ass. People bought this record? 2 stars, closer to 1.
Not what I expected, pretty good.
sounds kinda bad
It’s out there I dig it
This is a really interesting and infectious album, I have to admit I had kind of written poor old Todd off until hearing this album, back end a bit more cohesive then the first half,⭐⭐⭐⭐
Very unusual record, very strange, but I kinda liked it. 7/10
I like some of the artist’s songs but this album was too weird for me.
One of my favorite albums of the early 1970s. You won't hear anything else like this!
I'm not very familiar with Todd Rundgren's apparently prodigious output, but it *feels* like the "1001 Albums" editors must have a love/hate relationship with Mr. Rundgren, or maybe they're just haters, because there's no way Rundgren could have had an entire musical career that sounds like this and his previous album, neither of which are all that interesting and/or must-hear selections. But at least this one is shorter (and yet still too long) and the first side is a *lot* more quirky than "Something/Anything?"; sadly side two feels a lot less unhinged and a lot more derivative. And what an album cover--it feels like he somehow channeled in 1970 what AI would do to images 55 years later. I didn't really need the Wikipedia entry to guess that drugs fueled much of the music and concepts in this album (at least the first side), but perhaps he could have showed a little more restraint in layering *so* much into every track? Given the kind of lackluster music he seems to have made solo, and how much he was (and is) sought out to help produce albums, even when he pisses off the band members, I'm beginning to think that Todd Rundgren is a kindred spirit to Brian Eno.
Every album I've had in this list so far has had at least two or three tracks I like (this is album 11, so there's still a long way to go). I'm struggling to think of any besides "International Feel" for this, but perhaps that's because a lot of them are barely songs at all. The whole record either feels very fragmented or like one continuous and slightly trippy journey. It is whimsical and charming to an extent - but I can't see myself giving it any more than just the one star.
This is basically one long song.
love how batshit insane this album gets. one of my favorite LPs in my collection if only because of the fun shape of the sleeve. deserves to be one of the 1001? one of his should be and i'm leaning this one
Chaotic, uneven. I don’t know whether there’s a story behind this or a connecting thread between the songs that explains the sudden changes in energy. Sure, there were several interesting sounds and intrepid left field tracks, but there isn’t a lot that I’d necessarily go back to listen to.
Rock and Roll Pussy, huh? I’m a little confused with this one. It’s all over the place musically. It doesn’t feel like an album at all. Just a random collection of unconnected songs. Some of which are ok, but many of which are just weird. Too me, it feels like the artist being contrarian and antiestablishment for the sake of being different. Despite a couple of decent tracks, as an album this one is a loser for me.
maybe it would sound better after a hero dose of LSD?
7/10 Eclectic and weird. I like it. Could have done without the medley tbh. Highlights: La Feel Internacionale International Feel Zen Archer Just another Onionhead
просто хороший альбом
"I Don't Want To Tie You Down" has a nice melody, and so does "Just One Victory". But that's about it.
Todd is one of those dudes who got a TON of press back in the day, was highly respected, worked with everybody, etc. etc. But then I'd go back and try to listen to his stuff and I found it to be pretty bland. This album, however, is the complete oppossite of that. If there is an album that better represents ADHD, I'd love to hear. The songs are for the most part barely a minute long. Lovely, fun, energetic snippets. Then - on to the next! There is a liveliness to this whole record that I loved. And you're bopping along to this proggy psychedelic record then suddenly you're listening to soul music? WHAT. Fantastic. I really enjoyed this. A very easy - FOUR STARS
Always appreciate being all over the place more than being boring. This was all over the place, but I didn't hate it. Shout out to the farm animals.
Ups and downs, hits and misses, but always pretty interesting as Rundgren veers from musical theater to prog rock to soft rock. I would listen to this again.
This was a pleasant listen!
(4/7) kind of all over the place but fun overall
Classic Cure sound and songs. Brilliant.
Ok
I liked his previous album much more, didn't like the musical experiments, thought it was too uneven.
I once again don’t know what to say after listening to an album… I just know I didn’t enjoy it and I cannot see why this was a must listen to album.
this psychodelia destroyed western civilization..
I have to say, the beautiful gaudy cover perfectly captures this album's commitment to weird musical fuckery. And what an album it is! Some parts are a little too try-hard and I didn't gel with them, but overall I warmed up to this pretty fast. It's a cool experimental experience for sure, even if not all of the tracks are winners. Definitely quite out-there for 1973 and I wasn't expecting those zany electronic elements either! However, I don't think it meshes together too well. While each individual song has its quirky charms, there isn't really a method to the madness.
2.5
Just because an album is written and recorded while a musician is on drugs does not mean that album is more worthy of being heard nor does it make the album important. I feel like this book contains a lot of "This isn't what the artist normally sounds like, but he was on drugs," explanations. That's how A Wizard, A True Star is explained. Todd Rundgren is an excellent musician and producer, so I find it a bit weird this album supposedly inspired a generation of bedroom musicians. There's not a lot of DIY music reflected on A Wizard, A True Star and each song is well produced. At times, it does sound chaotic but that's for an effect and is not the reality. International Feel starts the album off with a different sound from Rundgren's prior album and then there are 6 straight songs that don't crack the 2-minute mark. I took this to mean there are more ideas than execution of those ideas. This gets credit for being interesting but being drug-fueled doesn't mean it's inspiration-fueled. My favorite tracks: International Feel You Don't Have to Camp Around Zen Archer When the Shit Hits the Fan/Sunset Blvd. Sometimes I Don't Know What to Feel Just One Victory
This is definitely a weird one that I kinda like. A lot of really quick little nothing tracks that kinda drag it down for me, but when it settles down into a song and allows it to breathe, it's fun. It's definitely reminding me of another band, but I can't for the life of me place it. Still though, think it's gonna get the "Good, but I don't think I really want to listen to it again after this" 3.
Chaotic! Some good parts but others were a bit weird. Video game music?
It was pretty interesting, but also chaotic. I liked most of it, but some of the songs were a little too weird for me. I wish it was a bit shorter but I liked the transitions between songs.
I respect how much he clearly wants to alienate the audience he picked up with Something/Anything, but honestly, I'm a bit alienated too? Though I never liked Something/Anything in the first place, so...
Really cool album, will be revisiting this.
I’m sure in its time it was groundbreaking, and I like Todd Rundgren a good deal, but this did not hold up well imho - sprawling, messy, incoherent in parts. Some flashes of brilliance too often surrounded by overly precious dreck.
Sort of disappointed, as there were only three /real/ bangers. Still, I can't dislike Rundgren.
Kinda hated this
fun
The sound of a man terrified at being compared to a woman.
Rating: 4.7/5 Short Review: What the hell did Todd Rundgren put in this album? Psychedelic rock, soul, pop, electronic experiments, and complete madness, sometimes within the same song. It’s chaotic, unpredictable, and ridiculously inventive. Not everything lands, but the sheer imagination is incredible. Forty minutes of a man refusing to have a normal thought. Favorite Track: International Feel. What an opening. Absolutely electrifying.
Listening to this album made me angry.
Ei tainnut kaikki biisit olla alkuperäisiä. Mutta mukavan kokeellisia ja menoa riitti välillä.
1/1
Very fun and silly, I enjoyed it. The very camp end of this kind of 70s psych rock, go off king about your onions, why not? Very funny and enjoyable!
Mad classic! I love this album, fucking weird as hell, makes no sense, most garish album cover of all time
Kinda noisy
I only know Todd Rundgren by name (and the weird story about Liv Tyler,) and didn't think I had ever listened to any of his music other than "Hello It's Me" (which was on a 70s compilation I was given for Christmas one year,) but reading his Wikipedia page I see he also did that annoying "Bang the Drum All Day" song. I'm encouraged by the description on Apple Music saying that this album would come to influence bands like the Flaming Lips and MGMT, but that could mean a lot of different things (not all of them good,) so let's see... Some of this is pretty good but a lot of it just sounds like demos of ideas and not actual songs.
Oh fuck off already
Todd Rundgren is one of those artists whose name I've heard but don't think I've ever heard a single note of their music. I was surprised just how weird it was, felt a bit like turning the dial on a radio and picking up stations playing a variety of genres. The review distribution suggests a lot of people give this a 3, which surprise me as I would have thought it's a divisive which most people either love or hate. I was closer to the latter point of view and really wanted to stop listening at various points. One song did have a feel of the eclecticism of Super Furry Animals though -who I love- so for that reason and the fact some of the lyrics were funny, I'm awarding a 2.
Волшебник на голубом вертолете все таки прилетел и записал этот альбом. Не понимаю откуда столько нелестных отзывов, среди всех альбомов которые я успела прослушать этот очевидно заслуживает свое место здесь, то как Тодд работает со звуком просто сносит крышу и я это говорю как человек, который до этого проекта ничего не слышал об этом гении
Ok, look.. I'm fine if you want to do psychedelic drugs. I get it, I really do. But sometimes what seems like a great idea when you're tripping is just nonsense. This album is a good example of that. A street sweeper went by outside while this was playing and drowned out my stereo, and honestly it sounded better. Another album I would have been totally fine with never having listened to, but at this point I'm in this for the long haul. And the smugness.
Very strange and just a mish-mash of sounds at times. Odd as I quite enjoyed the last album of his that I heard. This felt more experimental though.
This is weird, I fux with it. It will require further listening but it might be brilliant.
With the exception of a few Beatles songs, I'm not a big fan of music that sounds like it's meant for the circus.
Well, it's out there... 70s psychedelic rock and all its finery is on show here. You have to applaud the sheer levels of imagination that Todd engaged to put this together. I liked it, but not all of it was to my taste. Fun, though.
Extra crappy art rock
Difficult to rate.
Een magere 3. Een 2 zou weer te weinig zijn
I got the other Todd Rundgren album last week - liked that one much more. This one tries to do more without the sonic benefit. 3 stars
Quite the experience. I didn't hate it but I didn't love it either. I wasn't really sure what to make of it.
That was a fun bit of nonsense!
Interesting, experimental, irritating. Sounds ahead of its time. Mostly experimental and exploratory, and not all of those experiments or explorations lead somewhere, but I appreciate their boldness. I also appreciate the whistlestop tour of a huge breadth of styles, and almost all of them done very well. The only track I think I have maybe heard before is Zen Archer, but the album should clearly be listened to complete, it's a real journey, although as I said, it's quite annoying at times.
What in the hell possibly could've happened between Something / Anything? and this album for it to come out the way it did? In a one-year gap, he went from making fairly run-of-the-mill but still incredibly fun pop rock to an early Space Rock record with an average track length of a minute and a half. I feel like I definitely know the answer to the opening question, and the answer's probably copious amounts of LSD, but I just was not expecting this kind of an album to come out of a pop artist. That's what makes it an amazing album, though. I love bands and artists spontaneously deciding that their careers are just a little bit too stable and fixing that issue by releasing the weirdest thing they can make come out of their head. I mean, if I had millions of dollars in disposable income and hundreds of thousands of fans that would at least think "new album from this artist I like, neat." I'd also probably put out some crazy stuff. Look at The Flaming Lips, it worked out well for them.
It should’ve been called “man in need of a producer.”
Und was daran ist hörenswert?? Ansammlung von Geräuschen!
Drugs the album. Very hard and very heavy drugs, and I want whatever Todd is having. Ok, so Todd Rundgren is a name I’m positive I’ve heard of before, I just don’t know how, or for the life of me where I’d have heard it. I didn’t recognize a single song on the album, and it’s got a very low rating. I’m going to be an outlier and give it a 5. This had good Rock, Electronica, Prog, and more all in what may have amounted to the best hard trip Todd Rundgren ever produced in his life. As of writing this, he’s still alive and kicking at 78 somehow. By God, he still performs today even. So yeah, if the constant references in this review to drugs weren’t a tip off, they were cited as a big source of inspiration for why this album even exists in the first place. It also sold horribly and apparently “Cut his audience in half”. It’s one of those albums that wasn’t even popular at the time with the intended audience, but becomes something of a cult classic as each year passes. And I gotta tell you this, I never expected to be giving it a 5, but that’s exactly what I’m doing to do. This is the first of 2 Todd Rundgren albums I’ll get to listen to for this project. The other album, which came out a year prior, apparently is monumentally different from this one, so I can’t wait to roll it, but likely won’t enjoy the more Pop sounding beats half as much as I do this unorganized, drug fueled mondo extravaganza. Speaking of, I just keep adding songs from this album to my personal account. It’s just so catchy and good. But what really makes it stand out to me the most is that the songs when played out of order just sound completely crazy. They work so well in order, that listening to them out of order is still a fun experience, but it makes me want to listen to the entire album again to hear it as Godd Rundgren intended it, and yes that typo was intentional. I’m a fan now. It’s weird, it’s Proggy, it’s perfectly long, and it’s just really something I could find myself listening to from top to bottom over and over again. Didn’t see this album coming today, but man am I glad to hear it. That’s 2 5 star albums in a row, after hitting a massive dry spell of bangers for the past couple of weeks. Ultimately, if you put a gun to my head and made me chose, my gut instinct for favorite song on the album is going to have to be “Zen Archer”. I’d name the other 5 I added, but chances are good I’m not done adding songs, so I’ll save the unneeded review space. Damn, this album just further proves to me that anything even remotely resembling Prog may just be my favorite genre. I’ve still got a ton of Prog albums to get through that I know will be 5’s, and I wasn’t expecting this one to come out of the woodwork swinging, but here we are. Yeah, I’m going to give this one a 5. The weird matches my personal favorite kind of weird, and I dig it a lot.
Almost halfway through and I'm blown away. What is this jurney I embarked upon. So creative, interactive, crazy. Truly beautiful. The music is so intense sometimes I don't know what to feel- just as the name of the very intense opening song of side two. All of a sudden there's a medley of rhymes and blues 60's songs. I really don't know where it came from but the renditions are fantastic. It's one of the most surprising albums I've heard in a while. It would take at list a few more listens to process. But for now, I will calmly give this one a 5.
Un peu perché par moment, un peu vibe Elton John à d'autres, mais très cool bonne découverte !
Non
J'ai trouvé ça très sympa et original (sauf la chanson qui finit en cris de cochons d'Inde, Dogfight Giggle)
Really weird and interesting 70s psych rock. There's a bit of a prog rock feel with the way the songs progress and blend into each other. I really enjoyed the musical journey that the track list took me on, at least the International Feel -> La Feel Internacionale section. It's full of whimsy and had the right mix of silliness and serious moments that meant I immediately wanted to listen to it again once I was done. I'm not sure how the songs will hold up outside of the album but this has definitely been one of the highlights of the list so far.
New to me, liked it.
he went too far with it
Experimental agreed. Something I would listen to? Disagree. I must not be on drugs
Real curve ball - The kind of album I'll need to come back to a few times
Interesting, not really something I’d buy, but not bad either. 3 out of 5!
Referencing the Hat man on a drug field psychadelic rock album from the 70s is crazy. I felt like I was on a 4D carousel and it went crazy.
I only knew one of his songs (I saw the light) before this album, but dang this was an interesting listening experience! Cool stuff
Is this art rock? It’s ok in parts
Been on my wish list for a while now, mainly because of Zen Archer. I like the scope and oddness of the early tracks. Its a great album. The medley feels unnecessary considering its already a long side 2. 4 Heard before? Some Owned: No, 108/427 (25%) Will I get: Yes
Enjoyably experimental!
"Zen Archer" was a fun surprise to suddenly stumble upon in the journey through this album. Words can't really explain why I both like and dislike this album. First album I'm going to rate high but I can't explain why I am. 8/10
What a ride! If you can make it past the first track, you're in for a treat. Felt like 5 albums by the time I finished. Another album that was ahead of its time and that has to be factored into the rating.
I don’t think I’ve ever heard an album like this. I also have not listened to an album a second time because of how confused I was. I listened to this album twice because I felt like I couldn’t really wrap my head around it the first time. In my first listen, someone nearby asked me if I was listening to “‘It’s A Small World’ on acid” (it was “Never Never Land” ironically). And I actually was quite moved by “Sometimes I Don’t Know How to Feel” and instantly added it to my library. On the second listen, I still was torn between plugging my ears / skipping tracks and laughter in the first half(ish) of the album. Then hear the familiar “Ooh Baby Baby” and was again moved by “I Don’t Want to Tie You Down.” Those details aside, this album mostly didn’t resonate with me, but I could feel the joy, thoughtfulness, and creativity that seemed to have driven this album lyrically and musically. It got me thinking, challenged my ears and brain, and I loved the album cover art. For those reasons, I rated it pretty highly even though I didn’t love it.
6.9/10. The only way I could describe this album is a "psychadelic rock opera". It's so full and busy, and sometimes doesn't make much sense at times, but as a whole creates a nice round product that is pleasing to listen to. I don't think I could listen to any song individually, but I might relisten to the album as a whole a long time from now, to reexperience it's journey.
Yeah…. This guy might be a genius. The first half of this album is a psychedelic journey where each small idea flows into the next so seamlessly. The second half features some great soul with great variety of instrumentation. I loved Something/Anything but this is something else entirely. The moment he goes “tic tic tic” I sat up in my chair and was locked in until the end. Fantastic record.
Suuuuuuper creative. Can't really put this one in a box. It's got Prog Rock, Psychedelia, R&B, Glam, a little bit of everything. He doesn't really stick the landing on every song - sometimes he loses focus and the songs get hard to follow. But it's a very enjoyable listen nonetheless Highlights: Zen Archer, Does Anybody Love You
Lo he tenido un poco de fondo y no estaba mal pero tampoco me ha dicho gran cosa. Está bien.
There were moments that almost sounded R&B but then quickly back to psychedelia and I would lose interest again.
Kinda interesting and not what I was expecting from banging on a drum all day.