An album that requires endurance. These are huge, great songs, and there are a lot of them
It isn't hard to pay attention and listen to this one, but don't underestimate it: this listen requires stamina.
Read a few reviews by Christgau calling Elton a machine. His piano playing and ability to fill the album with energy are certainly machianic. But I also thought of how Joni Mitchell and Carole King talk about the pop music "machine". Reading about how Elton is not actually writing these songs made that description even more apt.
And of course there is something not earnest here, before he came out in 76' and 92'.
nice sounds. i see why he is special. but something deeply boring about his voice. i suppose the work is important given the chicano influence.
unfortunately for him, this stuff sounds like music made for Apple commercials. I guess the Cali upbringing is no accident there.
i think this is a you had to be there one. like teaching kids about the cold war. just seems like there's no war at all
im sure theres a there there, but it's beyond me. i like my satire at least a little bit remarkable
Excellent tunes. Too long. Too many versions. Cult and idolatry adulterating the main body of work. Derek & the Dominoes probably contribute to this. Wish we knew a bit more about who was doing what on this album.
Sweet Lord and Wah-wah have great sounds and Harrison's voice is so earnest you could weep.
I don’t have a conception of this album due to the many changes of order and track additions and removals. If only they had let it pass.
Never too much, almost too little, but that would be a misreading of this work. It's easy listening, and for that reason credit must be given where it's due: Green is in control, and there's nothing to worry about.
Green breaks out more decidedly in "How Can You Mend A Broken Heart?"
With the story behind the making of the album, you'd expect a real sense of identity. Boston by Boston recorded in Massachusetts, definitively and against label wishes.
However, you listen the album and hear a white frail body embodying Aretha Franklin. Now, I don't have a real issue with white people doing black music, but I have an issue when there's no personalization to it. When Bowie did it, it was still a Bowie record. Here, it is quite empty to me.
Going through the album, I got over this and just thought of the album as a love letter to the Blues tradition. The idioms fill the album.
Just when I thought I was fine, the gospel outro commences. Sealed the deal. Hate the album.
Is the "Boston sound" just postmodern hell? Sounds a bit like The Eagles too. Or bad Zeppelin pastiche. Sterile melodies and timbres all around to corporatize rock. You can hear the through-line to the cheesy 80s ballad. But the band plays tight.
Wish i had more time to sit with this one.
Just good musicians jamming out. A little repetitive, and hard to get past Fela's charlatanism. But he's also cool af.
Feels like it couldve come out in the 80s (derogatory). It makes absolute sense that this came out in the same year as Boston. Same lack of identity. Same corporatization.
Made me come to realize that it isn’t rock music’s style that i like, it’s what creative rock stars are able to do with it. This is pure rock. And it’s boring and shallow..
Frampton can shred, but he doesn't have much to say
More like a 2.5, but giving it a 3 for the chops. And at least it isn't a caricature of Black music like Boston.
God that voice is awful. 4 for the sheer effort and size of the thing. pretty inventive stuff. would've loved to hear Cobain sing it. Corgan got the other chops though