Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness by The Smashing Pumpkins

Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness

The Smashing Pumpkins

3.68
Rating
30822
Votes
1
3%
2
10%
3
27%
4
35%
5
25%
Distribution

Album Summary

Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness is the third studio album by American alternative rock band the Smashing Pumpkins, released on October 24, 1995, in the United Kingdom and a day later in the United States on Virgin Records. Produced by frontman Billy Corgan with Flood and Alan Moulder, the 28-track album was released as a two-disc CD and triple LP. The album features a wide array of styles. Propelled by the album's lead single, "Bullet with Butterfly Wings", it debuted at number one on the US Billboard 200 with first week sales of 246,500 units. To date it remains the band's only album to top the Billboard 200. It spawned five more singles—"1979", "Zero", "Tonight, Tonight", the promotional "Muzzle", and "Thirty-Three"—over the course of 1996, and was certified diamond by the RIAA, equivalent to more than 10 million units sold. Praised by critics for its ambition and scope, Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness earned the band seven Grammy Award nominations in 1997, including Album of the Year and Record of the Year ("1979"), as well as nine MTV Music Video Awards nominations, eight of which were for "Tonight, Tonight", including "Video of the Year". Not only did they all become hits on both mainstream rock and modern rock stations, but "Bullet with Butterfly Wings", "1979", "Tonight, Tonight", and "Thirty-Three" also became the band's first Top 40 hits, crossing over to pop radio stations. The recording sessions saw a wealth of productivity: dozens of fully completed songs were cut from the album, and would turn up on later releases. A box set released in November 1996, titled The Aeroplane Flies High, compiled the promotional singles from the album, and featured approximately 30 fully completed songs from the Mellon Collie sessions which had not made the final cut for the album (including one track, "Pastichio Medley", which contained more than 70 short snippets of songs in various states of completion). Both Mellon Collie and The Aeroplane Flies High later saw reissues which included even more tracks from the sessions.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Is it necessary for this album to be over 2 hours long? Is it necessary for me to drink my own urine? No, but I do it anyway because its sterile and I like the taste

Somewhere in that 2 hour sprawl is the 45 minute album it should have been.

Insert photo of Billy Corgan sadly riding a ride at Disneyland here.

I finally get to listen to this one. I’ve been meaning to, and the fall weather is perfect for it. I mean, a two-hour-long album about the sadness and melancholy (hah) of adolescence? Quite appropriate. Anyway, as a mythologized double album, this does it about as well as you can. It’s not that every song is some insane masterpiece, but they all contribute to the album. Obviously certain sequencing choices make this album much, much better (“Tonight, Tonight” as the album’s de facto opener, “Love” into “Cupid De Locke”), and certain songs stand out against others as clear moments of importance, high points if you will. The album’s two anchors, aka the two best songs on the album according to everyone ever, are “Tonight, Tonight” and “1979.” Now lemme tell you about these two songs. The former? Yeah it’s symphonic, but that’s not what’s special about it. The lyrics are incredible, resonant, moving. The singing is, though an acquired taste, passionate and emotional. Where the song really shines though is the band playing. The drum work on this song is out of this world, that guitar riff is instantly iconic, and the chord progression on the chorus is about the same. The latter, is mesmerizing, subtly heartbreaking in its wistfulness and its longing, and it’s a cross between an anthem and a deeply personal song, and it’s understandably become both. As for the rest of the album, it’s really just incredible; every single song feels like the cold, autumnal depression of adolescence, and the sequencing is absolutely excellent. It is by far one of the best double albums I’ve ever heard, and one of the best albums I’ve ever heard, period. 10/10 DOES IT BELONG ON THE LIST: ABSOLUTELY REASON: quality, meaningfulness, influence, relevance

hell yeah billy corgan, you sweet, tortured bastard, you did it again

Mellon Collie manages to explore just about every aspect of the 90s alternative sound within its lofty 2 hour runtime

Meanders like a pompous, never-ending dream.

Would be 4 1/2 stars. Great mix of musical styles. I liked every song. Really hard to name stand out tracks after one listen, because of the orverwhelming amount of music. But i defently want to revisit the album. Corgans more raw vocal style on a lot of the songs doesen't allways work for me, but he is not unlistenable like other people think.

Billy Corgan might be an insane narcissist but this album has like 4 of the best songs ever made so I guess he has the right to be. Siamese dream and Gish are pretty flawless too but this is just the perfect encapsulation of a musical moment, a weird distilling of nostalgia that usually only dream pop and shoegaze can touch. Phenomenal album even if it is an hour too long.

I ain't listening to all that. I'm happy for u tho. Or sorry that happened. There’s some good stuff in there but needs some serious editing.

I wish I liked the Smashing Pumpkins more than I do, because they're closely adjacent to lots of other music I love, but Billy Corgan's voice has always been an obstacle for me. His sort of feline, nasal whine has perhaps dated better in some ways than other vocal stylings of the time, and sometimes it works, but I don't find myself rushing to hear it often. Yet when their songs are good, they're so good that the vocals hardly matter. Tracks like Bullet with Butterfly Wings are robust and timeless enough to weather years of memes. It's a really good album but a big undertaking to get through. It's never boring or bad, but it's overlong and the cream of the crop could easily fit onto one disc. The music is pleasingly diverse and sounds great even when the vocals irritate. Both discs balance the heavy and abrasive with the soft, even sweet, very well. Disc 1 has all the hits that rock hardest, but I enjoy Disc 2's lullaby wind-down just as much. Anyway, I highly recommend the Spin magazine interview with Soundgarden's Kim Thayil, circa 1994, where Billy keeps butting in and pestering Kim about star signs, getting increasingly short shrift. "I'm a Pisces. We pick up on those things..."

I seem to remember liking this band - a little. I'm still in two minds really. I enjoyed the first of the double album but could take or leave the first half of the second. Have always loved any word play however so the title alone scores some points from me. Yes - yet another double album to work through. For this one though it could have easily been two separate albums as the feel of each was somewhat different. Good that they made such intelligent, well-crafted and varied music but just not sure if I get much from the noisier sounds on a lot of the second disc.

This record is far too long but it has huge nostalgia for me and I still enjoy it. Corgans voice is terrible but its never really bothered me (although its really really bad on some of the songs on this album!!) Theres a 45 min 5 star album in there somewhere

The obvious shame of SP is that with pretty much anyone else singing they would be a much better band. 'Tonight, Tonight', for instance, is a perfectly cromulent '90s indie classic, except for the fact Corgan is so, so, so unlistenable and I don't understand how someone at some point didn't have a quiet word and say dude, you can clearly write a tune, but just hire a singer. Well, I guess it didn't exactly hold them back, but I have never been able to stomach more than the odd song because of his hideous snarl. (Also, beyond the hits, this album is kinda mostly a turgid slog).

the album is good. there are some great tracks ("zero", "bullet with butterfly wings") but everything else is pretty solid. it's just too long. after the first "cd side" ends, it feels like a natural conclusion. but then it starts up again. whittle this down to one cd, and you could have an all timer, but it's a bit too much for me without enough variation to give it that status. even two separate releases would have been really solid.

Number: 314 Familiarity: Well-versed (4) Rating: 3 Before: ======= I don't always listen to The Smashing Pumpkins, but when I do, it's usually Siamese Dream. I'm not sure I've ever listened to this one in it's entirety during one sitting. Let's get started. After : ======= Wow, that was really long. I see now why I've never listened to the whole thing in one sitting. If one were to take 40 minutes of the best songs and put on one album, that might be 5 or high 4. However, I have to rate this collection a 3 overall.

I’ve heard this before. I never bought this one since I didn’t like it that much, since Billy Corgan’s obnoxious personality really shines through and overshadows the paisley psychedelia enough to make it less enjoyable. This is also when they started moving away from that sound and he started looking and dressing like uncle fester. It’s good when artists try to expand their range but the electronic stuff just doesn’t work for them. I like most of the singles from this except 1979, which never did anything for me, and Bullet With Butterfly Wings, which has always annoyed the hell out of me. The deep cuts are a mixed bag, with some being very good and some being very middling. I would probably like this album a lot more if anyone but Billy Corgan was singing just because he sucks so bad and his voice is so annoying. And maybe I would like this better if I had bought it in 1996 and listened to it over and over again, or if it was split into two albums, because listening to that jackass whine for more than 2 hours straight is a chore.

Thoroughly enjoyed this, definitely too long. Am I a Smashing Pumpkins fan? Playlist add: “Thru the Eyes of Ruby”

this could be an absolute 5 stars but it is so bloated. I cant find the LP tracks but I would definitely never flip to side 6. l love this as a tight 2 LP album it has enough to carry that off and be complete replay through. but as a 3 LP it has too many skips.

This album is definitely right up my alley - infact I think there is a 5/5 album in here somewhere… but at over 2hrs long it’s messy. 4/5 feels correct here. The curse of a double LP strikes again (maybe it’s just me but I can’t name on that would be worse at 45mins.) anyway, good album - one I’ll definitely return too (even if I skip some of the fluff).

An all-time teen Sarah fave!! Do I think Billy Corgan is a good guy? No, hes like evil bald Gerard Way! But the year was 1995, I'd just been born and BOY did he slap some banging music out. We can't sit here and lie.

Like most double albums it would be better if they'd just edited down the best stuff to one hour rather than letting it sprawl over two, but ya know what the hit rate is still pretty high here, particularly the first disc which is pretty much banger after banger for the first 7 songs or so. Billy Corgan is a massive gimp but at his best he could really do some good shit.

pompous essential my annoying teenage self is all over this

I think there's a legitimate argument to be made that any double album could be improved with some ruthless editing. Even the greatest of bands can't create all solid gold material all the time. If you cut away the weaker material, then what's left should be left all the better for it. And this should be especially true for a band as prone to extravagance and needless maximalism as The Smashing Pumpkins. So why do I still give this five stars? Why do I have no problem playing the entire two hours from start to finish? Why do I seem to enjoy this every bit as much as I did as a 16-year-old? Maybe it's just the nostalgia. But I also think it's because this is such a sonically diverse album. Styles and tones shift wildly from one song to the next, so it feels like the album is constantly evolving. I've never tried to read any kind of narrative into it, but there are clearly emotional arcs. It feels like we're being taken on a journey, and I enjoy every twist and turn.

Kurpitsat on jäänyt itellä jostain syystä vähän vieraammaksi grungebändiksi. Hyvän kuuloinen tupla-albumi, joka kärsii vähän liiallisesta massiivisuudesta. Paljon kuitenkin hyvän kuuloisia biisejä jotka tarttui korvaan jo ekalla kuuntelulla.

i’m seeing my chemical romance tonight so this could not have come at a better time :) when i was 13 love was my morning alarm and i wrote the lyrics to take me down in the back of my student handbook so i could read them in class it was that serious

This was a pretty good album, but REALLY long oh my god. For me, the sweet spot in length is probably 50-80 minutes. 121 minutes though? I think that’s a bit excessive. Look, most of the songs were good and I enjoyed them, but not all of them needed to be on the same album. Probably a 7.5/10 for that reason.

God that voice is awful. 4 for the sheer effort and size of the thing. pretty inventive stuff. would've loved to hear Cobain sing it. Corgan got the other chops though

It really envelopes it and draws you - a real mix of emotions and styles

some bangers, but overwrought and I much prefer siamese dream

The only songs I'd heard going in were Bullet With Butterfly Wings and 1979. I was excited to get this because I like the album cover but I was intimidated by the crazy run time. There's a lot of great songs on this album and a couple that I didn't like, mostly the heavier ones where he's screaming. I feel like I need more time with this one to give it a fair chance since it's so long, I'll probably go back to it at some point. My favourites were Tonight Tonight, To Forgive, Cupid De Locke, Tale Me Down, 1979, Lily, and Farewell and Goodnight.

Would not recommend. It's a good album that's just too long.

The man has a lot of feelings and apparently zero editor. Two discs of pure emotional sprawl and honestly I forgive the length because the payoff keeps coming. Spins: 3 Playlist Additions - Tonight, Tonight - Zero - Bullet with Butterfly Wings - Galapogos - Muzzle - Thirty-Three - 1979 - Tales of a Scorched Earth - X.Y.U. - We Only Come Out at Night - By Starlight

Fantastic album! So many good songs, a classic you could say lol but for reals this one of those albums that you lose yourself in and just can't stop listening to!

Really good but if Siamese Dream is a 5, this is probably a 4. Could be a 5 with some editing though.

Not as good as Siamese Dream but still a terrific album. Great variety of songs with some incorporating some orchestral sections. Maybe a bit too long but enjoyable listen

I remember hearing Smashing Pumpkins for the first time in school. Everything about them seemed strange, exotic, Avant Garde! And those vocals? Who let this alien sing on these records? I then got to know more about the band and realised Billy Corgan is not very exotic at all. Less of an alien, more of a nasally goblin. Still, the music holds up. And on this record we have a whole buffet of fuzzy alternative rock and gentle finger picked ballads. Like a lot of listeners, I too thought leaving a few tracks out would have improved the experience but I have to say, after revisiting Mellon Collie today it's all surprisingly cohesive and musically strong. I will always consider Siamese Dream their 'best' record but I think we have another 5 here.

Nokre bangers, nokre kjedelege. Spanande tekstar her og der. Ein stad mellom 2 og 3 for min del. Er raus i dag, så blir 3.

Big fan of this, and will definitely listen again. It is too long to listen in one sitting so I split it in two. There were a few highlights for me; Tonight Tonight, Zero, We only come out at night, By starlight and 1979. No skips for me. I think it was better when it was a bit lighter, but even the heavier stuff was really good. Must be sweet to watch like. 4.5/5

Too punk for me

Not for me but I don't hate it. I wouldn't listen again, it's too long! But, I like some of the songs individually. Cupid de Locke is where I started enjoying it - much less rocky. I'd listen to that again. Muzzle was also decent. 1979 sounds familiar and I really like it. I've added it to my November playlist :) same with 'We only come out at night' Honestly I enjoyed it more than I thought I would - not a fan of the rock/metal vibe songs but I like a few of the songs. I'd say 2.5 total

A little long of an album...It is still the pumpkins though. Great stuff.

Really need to separate the art from the artist here, Billy Corgan is a complete narcissistic clown but the man knows his way around a rock song. This was a massive album when I was just seriously getting into music and I loved it back when it was released. The nostalgia factor has to be taken into account here as colouring a record that I rarely listen to nowadays. There are some huge 90s alternative rock songs here though, Bullet, 1979, Zero, Tonight Tonight, define an era. A broader point but the difference a great drummer makes to the sound of a band is insane, Chamberlain was killing it on the first few Pumpkins records, greatly enhances the performances captured here. The run on disc one from the start through To Forgive is basically perfect alt rock. There are some great songs on the second disc including the pick of the album in 1979 but there's also some dreadful missteps like We Only Come Out at Night, and some songs that way over stay their welcome. I could see valid perspectives from listeners that could put this at a 9 or 10/10 down to a 3 or 4/10, it's indulgent stuff no doubt over the course of 2 hours and non 90s rock fans might recoil. My 14 year old self would give this an easy 10 but it's not by any stretch a perfect album in truth, I was happy to revisit my youth for a couple of hours however. 8/10

Over produced and way over hyped.

There are some decade-defining songs on here that I always love returning to, but this has no business being over 2 hours long. Coincidentally, I also listened to Billy Corgan on a podcast the day I listened to this album and he thinks so highly of his musical ability that a 2+ hour album really tracks

Good but I don't love it like Grant and Kim.

Sometimes more is less. Could have been a great album but Billy’s ego got in the way.

Despite all my rage, I am still just a mildly amused by Billy Corgan's whiny voice

Really wanted to give this a five but it just falls short. Some absolute classics of 90s alternative rock here but a few duds as well.

Finally listened to this whole thing and did it in a day. I tried listening to the beginning not that long ago but stopped. My opinions on this are mixed because while it is a masterpiece for the 90s, its just too damn long for my taste and the mix of sounds and styles makes it inconsistent. I still enjoyed the thing at times even when I got bored. The ending was nice as well.

Fryktet en Hawkwind da jeg så dobbeltalbumet, men dette var bra greier. Bullet with Butterfly Wings er rå. Hyvold gir sikkert 5 stjerner for ordspillet i albumtittelen.

Ikke hørt noe særlig på SP før, positivt overrasket! Ikke en soleklar 4, men likevel en 4.

Første sangen var best. Nr to var grei. Likte også "take me down". Foretrakk altså alle sangene som var utypisk Smashing Pumpkins. Skal ha cred for variasjonen, men trekk for to timer album

Dette er kjempebra og veldig nærme 5 for min del. Liker balansen mellom hardere rock og ballader. Ikke hørt så mye på dem før, men det skal jeg definitivt gjøre mer av.

Startet veldig bra de første 6-7 sangene. Og selv om det (med et par unntak) holdt et greit nivå ut, syntes jeg ikke variasjonen rettferdiggjorde lengden, og det skled gradvis nedover fra en sterk til en svak 4er

Closer to like 3.5

I like the ones I like ya know....

"Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness" is an ambitious double-album spanning a collection of genres, drifting from piano lullabies and string arrangements to heavy metal, techno-industrial textures, and razor-edged alternative rock. The result is an album with a lot of filler, but also with some of perhaps the greatest rock songs of all time -- "Tonight, Tonight", "1979", "Zero" and "Bullet with Butterfly Wings" specifically.

no es algo que disfrute tanto por la voz del vocalista, si fuera un album de menos cacniones me encantaria

Eh. Never really liked this one and still don’t feel much. After the crunchy guitars grandeur of Siamese Dream this one just feels flat

Да, просто Да, очень разносторонняя музыка и мне нравятся все стороны

Partially known. Some great songs, obviously, but too fucking long.

This could’ve been an incredible one disc album. Too much cruft, but the bangers are all-timers.

I hate the fucking eagles man

One hell of an album. It's giant and it absolutely rocks. So many brilliant tracks in here and it sounds so wonderfully full. It is so close to a 5* for me but I think I just about prefer Siamese Dream! Favourites: Tonight, Tonight Bullet With Butterfly Wings An Ode To No One 1979

Amazing album, cool that it’s so fleshed out despite the long runtime. The progression on this album is really cool, some songs are calming and nice, others really metal-like. overall cool album from The Smashing Pumpkins, although i think Siamese Dream is better. 88/100

First time listening to this album. From reading about it this was a very popular double CD. I like it generally but the lead singer's voice is annoying and monochromatic to me. My favorite tracks: title song, Cupid De Locke, Porcelina of the Vast Oceans and 1979.

Во время прослушивания этого альбома я убедился, что любой двойной альбом, даже самый великий, стал бы гораздо лучше, если бы его сократили в 2 раза. Но этот альбом ввёл меня в полное замешательство. Первая половина была довольно средняя, да, были хорошие песни, но ничего особенного. Вторая половина была практически вся отличная, кроме последних 4 песен. Жанровое разнообразие тоже не может не впечатлять, мне, пожалуй, более всего нравится гранжевая часть альбома, потому что в ней голос вокалиста звучит по крайней мере органично, чего не скажешь о других песнях. И наконец, хронометраж, разумеется, является главным минусом альбома из-за которого поставить выше 3 рука не поднимается. Здесь есть прекрасные песни, которые я буду переслушивать, но буду ли я второй раз слушать альбом целиком? Нет! Лучшая песня: Bodies

The first album that ever got through to me. The cornerstone of my teenage music taste.

Another one that’s too long for its own good, but when it’s focused, as on 1979, it really shines. There is magic here and the standard is high, there’s about three albums worth though.

It's impressive to make an album this grandiose while managing to keep things interesting throughout. Favorite track: Zero

Oh the angst and self importance of Billy and crew. Despite the pretentiousness of this group, they put out some great music.

Sounds A LOT like my 90’s

Never heard the album in full before. So good. Ah to be an angst ridden teenanger again.

Do you know how good an album has to be to listen to for 2 hours?

Nostalgic, broader range than I expected from smashing pumpkins

Other than the hits ..it was just ok

Repeat listen. I felt much the same as before. This time around I enjoyed the reprieve of mellow moments, like “Take Me Down,” “We Only Come Out at Night,” and “Beautiful.” Original review: Some great riffs, and some great tracks, but a lot to get through

I'd like to say this was the first album that proved Strings+piano+nasally vocals+heavy bass+twangy guitar=enjoyable listening experience. I'm too young to make that claim though. I hear foundations for the folk movement of the next decade, foundations for "midwest emo", and further support of the interesting direction "Alternative" music was going in 1995. It's important for me to note that only a few tunes stand out as "singles" but combined with the great album art and track structure it all makes for a very listenable (and enjoyable) album in the history of Alternative Rock

This is an album that I feel has aged like wine, getting better as we get further away, partially just because it is one of the last double, epic albums of this sort that could get such a huge budget - including just the time and energy Billy Corgan could put into writing and making it. It is so varied and yet sticks together and has both beautiful and aggressive tracks that stand up to any rock songs out there.

Too much billy Corgan for me, but a handful of excellent songs

This is an easy 5. I know Billy is a bit of an egomaniac but he’s a damn fine musician. Songwise Tonight, Tonight on top for me, it transforms me to a better place in time.

Not awful but his voice gets a bit grating.

Smashing Pumpkins went crazy ambitious on this album, and it sure is interesting. But 28 songs? I liked Smashing Pumpkins back in high school but even then, I was like "Nah, I don't like them enough to buy *this*." This album is made for teens, though. The songs are full of angst, anger, heartbreak, and nobody-understands-me-ness. I started by listening to the first 7 or 8 songs but I got kind of bored (and reeeeeal sick of Billy Corgan's voice) so I searched the Internet for a Top 10 and listened to those. They were fine. After "XYU" I just let the rest of the album play through to the end, and that was probably my favorite section.

This has some epic moments on it like XYU, 1979, where boys fear to tread, tonight tonight, and the SP guitar tones are great. I don't love Billy's vocals though and to have them in your ear for 28 songs is a bit much.

En essentiell del av 90- talets soundtrack

whys this album sooo long? I can understand why it is a cult hit from a cult band, but I am not sure it was for me.

I can see how this is a cult album for people, but it just didn't have that effect on me. It was very up and down in terms of mood and atmosphere that felt a bit like being on a rollercoaster. There were moments where it did sort of click and I started to enjoy it, but it never lasted

"A masterclass in songwriting, it will go down in history as this generation's white album" - Billy Corgan "Pared down to an e.p., this would be spectacular" - Dan Reed 2/5

Great album

I feel the songs from a really good album we're shuffled with songs from a throwaway album, making a sort of mid double album

The guitars are produced to within an inch of their life but they sound amazing and the riffs are great. This might be my highest rated double album but I like everything here and the highs are incredibly high. 4.5/5

Struggled through many of the tracks on disc 2. Could have tightened it up and had a really stellar album for my taste.

3.5 - some great songs but way too much filler

First 5/5 album of this challenge thus far for me. I am SO(!!!!) BIASED. I grew up listening to this album. My parents told me this was the album they played on repeat while I was still in utero. I think it's worked its way into my brain permanently. Generally, I don't regularly listen to metal/heavy rock music (although I can enjoy it when I'm in the mood). Half of this album consists of this album consists of songs I wouldn't reach for on the average day, but when I do listen through I always enjoy the experience. And then, of course, there's the other side of this album, consisting of songs I love and listen to very often. I couldn't write this review without mentioning my two showstopper favorites, Cupid De Locke and 1979. Those opening instrumentals are truly beautiful. It's like a breath of fresh air every single time.

Alternative rock, grunge, alternative metal, art rock, heavy metal.