Album Summary
All Things Must Pass is the third studio album by English rock musician George Harrison. Released as a triple album in November 1970, it was Harrison's first solo work after the break-up of the Beatles in April that year. It includes the hit singles "My Sweet Lord" and "What Is Life", as well as songs such as "Isn't It a Pity" and the title track that had been overlooked for inclusion on releases by the Beatles. The album reflects the influence of Harrison's musical activities with artists such as Bob Dylan, the Band, Delaney & Bonnie and Friends and Billy Preston during 1968–70, and his growth as an artist beyond his supporting role to former bandmates John Lennon and Paul McCartney. All Things Must Pass introduced Harrison's signature slide guitar sound and the spiritual themes present throughout his subsequent solo work. The original vinyl release consisted of two LPs of songs and a third disc of informal jams titled Apple Jam. Several commentators interpret Barry Feinstein's album cover photo, showing Harrison surrounded by four garden gnomes, as a statement on his independence from the Beatles. Production began at London's EMI Studios in May 1970, with extensive overdubbing and mixing continuing through October. Among the large cast of backing musicians were Eric Clapton and members of Delaney & Bonnie's Friends band – three of whom formed Derek and the Dominos with Clapton during the recording – as well as Ringo Starr, Gary Wright, Billy Preston, Klaus Voormann, John Barham, Badfinger and Pete Drake. The sessions produced a double album's worth of extra material, most of which remains unissued. All Things Must Pass was critically and commercially successful on release, with long stays at number one on charts worldwide. Co-producer Phil Spector employed his Wall of Sound production technique to notable effect; Ben Gerson of Rolling Stone described the sound as "Wagnerian, Brucknerian, the music of mountain tops and vast horizons". Reflecting the widespread surprise at the assuredness of Harrison's post-Beatles debut, Melody Maker's Richard Williams likened the album to Greta Garbo's first role in a talking picture and declared: "Garbo talks! – Harrison is free!" According to Colin Larkin, writing in the 2011 edition of his Encyclopedia of Popular Music, All Things Must Pass is "generally rated" as the best of all the former Beatles' solo albums. During the final year of his life, Harrison oversaw a successful reissue campaign to mark the 30th anniversary of the album's release. After this reissue, the Recording Industry Association of America certified the album six-times platinum. It has since been certified seven-times platinum. Among its appearances on critics' best-album lists, All Things Must Pass was ranked 79th on The Times' "The 100 Best Albums of All Time" in 1993, while Rolling Stone placed it 368th on the magazine's 2020 update of "The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time". In 2014, All Things Must Pass was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
(4/5) Man.. that was long.
I think I understand the problem artists faced in the vinyl era: you either released a single LP of about 40–45 minutes, or you went for a double album. And if you had more material than would fit on one record, you suddenly had a lot more space to fill. I had a similar issue with Pink Floyd’s The Wall. One LP wouldn’t have been enough to tell the whole story, but two felt excessive, as though some material was there just to fill the sides. And now George Harrison takes it even further! I understand that he’d accumulated years of unreleased songs during his time with The Beatles. And there’s some truly excellent music here. Harrison is a fantastic guitarist, songwriter, and singer. I genuinely think a carefully selected single LP could have been a 5/5 album. But somewhere during the second LP, I started losing interest. Not because the songs were bad, but because there was simply too much of the same good thing. And then there’s an entire third LP of instrumental jams! Yesterday I listened to Miles Davis’s Bitches Brew. It’s over an hour and a half long, but somehow every minute felt justified. So it’s not the length itself that bothers me. It’s the OVERSHARING! George, I admire your talent, but come on! Nearly two hours? You made this for yourself, not for the audience!
It took until I was nearly 40 to dive into the Beatles discography, you'll have to forgive me if I've never touched their solo works. To be honest, the only one I was really aware had a career following the breakup was John and that was due in large part to hearing Happy Xmas (War is Over) on the radio every December. I was surprised to learn "Wonderful Christmastime" was a former Beatle as well. Don't ask how old I was when that realization happened though. See George Harrison passed when I was in college (2001) and I had no idea who he was. Time is the great equalizer y'all. Someday in the not too distant future kids won't know who Taylor Swift is either. Time marches on. All things must pass. Isn't it a pity. I've come to appreciate Harrison a lot in my middle age. When I listen to the Beatles I tend to favor the Paul songs, but after that I think I prefer George songs to John too. Isn't that the nature of this album though, to linger on the recent (to this 1970 release date) breakup of the band. To compare, to feel the absence on "All Things Must Pass." This sounded like a Beatles album to me in the best way. With a tighter focus. Its the Beatles without the frivolities. Its good. Harrison seemed to have carried quite a few good tracks off in his saddlebags when he rode out. But the thing I think the frivolities were part of the charm and this album is slightly less memorable. We were lucky that following the biggest band ever we got to follow the divergent paths of their careers so we could keep comparing and playing the "What if..." game. The opening stretch of "I'd Have You Anytime" to "If Not For You" was a great run. Really digged "My Sweet Lord" and "What is Life." 4/5
You know, it never occured to me just how much George Harrison actually sounds like Bob Dylan, half the time it almost could have been him singing. I can definitely see why many people consider this to be the best Beatles solo album, but I'm gonna have to disagree. I think in terms of individual songs, some of the all time best ones are definitely on here, but the album as a whole I think could have been a lot better. I hate to be that person to make this criticism because of how much it gets thrown around with albums that don't deserve it, but I do think that it's far too long. Like I said, lots of absolutely amazing individual songs, but the album is just too long to hold my attention. Especially the medley of instrumental tracks at the end, that just feels so pointless. And I'm an avid listener of post rock and ambient music, so long instrumental parts are my favourite, but here it really drags on way longer than it needs to. This is definitely an album that could be worthy of being over 60 minutes, there is definitely something special about it and the way it feels. But the pure length of it and the huge instrumental sections do unfortunately drag it down a lot, as there is a universe where I could definitely see this as the best Beatles solo album if it were just a bit shorter.
Pretty good album. Some big songs on here, and some background stuff. Overall fairly solid.
I’d go 3.5 if I could. Like the song writing but want a little more variety.
I love dick in the morning I love dick in the evening I love dick
I knew nothing of Harrison’s solo stuff. I listened to a few, it was ok. I’m not doing the whole album, stupidly too long!
REALLY good but long as FUCKKKK my god took me all day. but so good
One of the best non-Beatles Beatles album. George finally got the chance to show his creative genius. Wish he had more cuts with the Fab Four. One of my favs' s the title cut - All Things Must Pass
Just a great album
3.5
Favorite Song: Hear Me Lord Least Favorite: I Dig Love
Really want to give it a four but I think this is dire to my love of The Beatles.
I always said George was my favorite Beatle, but I think I was just trying to be alternative. Now I know he actually is.
I'd Have You Anytime - 4/5 My Sweet Lord - 5/5 Wah-Wah - 4.5/5 Isn't It a Pity (Version One) - 4.5/5 What Is Life - 4.5/5 If Not For You - 4.5/5 Behind That Locked Door - 4/5 Let It Down - 4.5/5 Run of the Mill - 4/5 Beware of Darkness - 4/5 Apple Scruffs - 4/5 Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let It Roll) - 4.5/5 Awaiting on You All - 4/5 All Things Must Pass - 4.5/5 I Dig Love - 4/5 Art of Dying - 4/5 Isn't It a Pity (Version Two) - 4/5 Hear Me Lord - 4/5 Out of the Blue - 4/5 It's Johnny's Birthday - 3/5 Plug Me In - 4/5 I Remember Jeep - 4/5 Thanks for the Pepperoni - 4/5 I think if the final "Apple Jams" part of this triple album was removed then this would be teetering on a 5* for me. The first side of the first album set a great tone, improving upon the Beatles' sound with more folk inspiration that makes this still feel like them but sounds like something new and/or improved. Once you get to the third side (which was supposed to be an extra thing tacked on because of the high price of this album), then the wheels start to fall off. The sound quality also feels slightly off, and it's because of the Wall of Sound that makes it sound way too muddy at times. If this was maybe a disk shorter then I would rate it higher but a solid 4* is still good for what at points seems to be Harrison flipping the bird at his former bandmates. Overall: 4/5 Favorites: My Sweet Lord
Can’t say I listened to the whole thing yesterday, but I’ve heard this album a bunch of times in my life and a lot of it is really great. The not-so-great? The jam sessions that cover the entire final two sides of the album. Seems like a gimmicky way to make a triple album.
Peak
Great Rock n Roll album with some amazing songs and Jams
love,love, love
Why was this so long? Probably 2014 version’s fault.
Harrison responds to being sidelined for a decade by making a double album where he covers about eighteen different types of rock music and nails it on each song. Say what you will about each Beatle - Paul never made something so ambitious <i>and</i> consistent, John never ran the table like this, and Ringo just wanted to make Ringo music. It's a pretty sick statement of intent.
I absolutely with no exaggeration at all love this album. Every song on it is a solid masterpiece, even the blues jams. This album got me through my father's final days and eventual death. I cannot accurately explain my love for this and George Harrison. Excellent. 5/5
Enjoying the album a lot. 2 hours though? damn..
The first post-Beatles release by any of them and it shows what George is fully capable of. I’m not sure I needed a full triple albums worth of material at once but there are some gems here.
It finally happened! I got this album! As time went on, as I got closer to the end, this album loomed larger and larger in my mind. Just because I knew it was on the list, and it was a big one that took a significant time investment to get through, and the longer I didn’t get it, the more I expected it every day. And, ya know what? Thank god for it! This week has been pretty dire with albums. What was it? 2 or 3 new one-star albums? I barely give out ones, but there was no denying the garbage I got this week. So thank fucking god for a Beatle! Even though I think of George as my least favorite Beatle - I find his voice annoyingly sleepy and his songwriting a bit up its own ass - he felt like an oasis in the trash. And while I think my original criticisms stand, this album is kinda undeniable. Spector’s production is often bad too, evening out everything so NOTHING stands out. It’s long, but not annoyingly so, and even the half hour of instrumentals that end the album are fairly pleasant. Most double albums could probably be cut down to ten or twelve great songs and be a better album, and this one doesn’t change that, but ultimately, it’s good! I appreciated it more after a week of crap. 3.75 rounded to a 4
An album this long shouldn’t be this consistently good, but George just keeps delivering. A masterpiece
Album 378. All Things Must Pass (https://open.spotify.com/album/7j7lsExGJtBHLgDYzjclwk?si=K7EGvqCtQIeeTxpMzxBLVw&utm_source=copy-link) — George Harrison (1970) Oh boy, 2 hours of George Harrison. Luckily I love the album. Throughout the day, I thought about who my favorite Beatle is. Probably him, but I'm not sure yet — at least I should listen to dozen of their albums in total Shit, I don't really know what to write about it. It's crazy comfortable music for me. Some of songs aren't popular, but I tremendously love them — like Art of Dying. The guitar playing on most of them is mindblowing and that's is no surprise lol, Harrison is a great guitarist George Harrison is like: you start playing the album and fall into rabbit hole the size of eternity, and when you eventually regain consciousness — your life has already been changed forever 5/5 Liked: — I'd Have You Anytime — My Sweet Lord — Wah-Wah — Isn't It a Pity — What Is Life — If Not for You — Run of the Mill — I Live for You — Let It Down - Original Guitar and Vocal — Beware of Darkness — Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let It Roll) — Awaiting on You All — All Things Must Pass — Art of Dying — Hear Me Lord — Plug Me In — Thanks for the Pepperoni — Out of the Blue
better than paul mccartney
Very folky for my taste, but I love George Harrison
An album with a great flow. Even though it is older, it feels fresh & relevant.
One of the better post Beatles albums
Easy five out of five if they had have copy the third disc. Just jams, which I’m sure were fun to play on but get tedious. Rest of the album is a straight classic
A singer-musician who finally reveals himself. Very very melancholic i like it
I really enjoyed this one. Nice listening to him post Beatles. Still really good music but different.
This feels like an album that actually set out as one of those deluxe anniversary edition albums that retrospectively include the B-sides, In George's own words, it's all too much, long long long or something.
This was really fun, so many different textures here. It also makes me realize how much of the Beatles sound he was responsible for. If I had to have one knock against it, it's a bit long for me
Disc 1 was a solid 4 star listen. The sound was pretty cohesive. But halfway through Disc 2, it started to feel like a hostage situation. What felt like cohesion felt too much the same.
some great songs, good vibes all through, but way too long, nothing standout
This was one of my favorite albums growing up. I didn't appreciate that George had written these songs during the later years of the Beatles and there just wasn't room for them on Beatles albums. But he was able to cherry pick years of songwriting efforts and the result was akin to a greatest hits album and one of the best solo efforts in rock history.
Good
It’s been a long time since I’ve heard this one! So, here’s the deal. Harrison, battered and a bit burned out from his time with the Beatles, where many of his compositions were brushed aside, decided to show what he’d had to offer all along: soulful, spiritual, melodic pop-rock songs with lots of different influences. Phil Spector reportedly said Harrison show him "hundreds" of new songs, and I suppose everyone involved was so excited that quality control went out the window. Still, as others have remarked here, there’s a 5-star album in here somewhere, depending on how you cut it. So let’s focus on the strengths. The first record is pretty much excellent and could easily have earned a perfect score on its own. “I’d Have You Anytime”, co-written with his good friend Bob Dylan, is an unsung classic in both their catalogues: a truly melancholy, melodic ode to longing. As much attention as “My Sweet Lord” gets (for its melody, but also for famously borrowing from the Chiffons’ “He’s So Fine”), it’s songs like “Isn’t It a Pity”, “Wah-Wah”, “What Is Life” and the beautiful Dylan cover “If Not for You” that get me every time. These are walls of sound full of color and texture, with tons of instruments and passionately played guitar lines from Harrison and co. The second record also has great tracks, but it starts to run out of gas. I love the second version of “Isn’t It a Pity”, the Lennon-esque “I Dig Love” and the somber “Beware of Darkness”, but it’s more introspective overall, which is a strange comedown after such a lively first record. Ditto for the third record, “Apple Jam”, done with members of Derek and the Dominos. As fun as it is, and as much as it shows that Harrison just wanted to have fun and jam, it often veers into throwaway blues-rock and doesn’t tell us much we didn’t already know. Still, it was ambitious for its time and a great start to his post-Beatles career, so 3.5 stars here. It suffers from some of the same self-indulgence as Blonde on Blonde, but there are so many great tracks regardless.
Surprised by how many of the songs I already knew. A good album, though too long. A single album probably would have sufficed, particularly since several later songs were just alt versions of earlier ones.
There is a reason the Beatles created so many great songs, and their music will last long after we have died from listening to this list. It was from the collaboration of the band. Separate ... they feel like just pieces of a bigger picture. I was never a big fan of the Beatles solo efforts after the band broke up. Much like I am not going to go out and listen to Paul McCartney, John Lennon or Robert Plant, Jimmy Page or Ozzy Osborne, Tony Iommi records. They are all good, but just not the same as the original collaborative efforts that made them legends. Also this album is way too long!
I enjoyed it at first, but the album is definitely too long. Makes it somewhat quite repetitive, sadly.
George is probably my favourite Beatle but I don't think I'd ever made the concerted effort to get to the end of this. It's great but it's a lot – everything and the kitchen sink, plus a bonus sink that the kitchen didn't really need. It's so bloated and fluffy, exuberantly unrestrained, but all pretty lovely to hear. I'm certain there's a tight 5-star album in here, but I'm a bit too sleepy to work it out today.
Ok - it's a long triple album but there is so much good stuff here that he has to be forgiven. All those years with the fab four and his contributions overshadowed meant all this just had to come out. The Apple Jam instrumentals are interesting but not for repeated listening. A truly amazing single album could be made from this lot if the best tracks only were included - but that of course is always a subjective choice. Art of Dying is my favourite track and the best Beatle's song that never happened. At least Ringo got back on his drums for that one and Billy Preston appeared amongst others to make it something which would still work today I reckon. Great to have the opportunity to play it through in its entirety again at least. On a par with Lennon's Imagine and McCartney's Band on The Run - this is his best solo album by far. If you like this then also hear anything (or even everything) by The Traveling Wilburys to hear more of his magic with equally impressive chums.
I think it can be universally agreed that this album is too too long - however, I have had to completely rewrite my review as my husband pointed out that I had the record on shuffle hense the weird flow and instrumental stuff. Im so glad I listened to it again as the actual album itself is brilliant and really enjoyable.
So much of this album is fantastic, even if a lot of songs are a bit too long. You can kinda forgive George stretching out a bit now he's solo - you just know that 'Isn't it a Pity' and its ilk would have been interrupted after three minutes by McCartney-led skiffle interlude or brass band. The album is of course too long, and that's before you even get to the completely pointless Apple Jam sides. Still very, very good though.
Full disclosure, I'd never, ever heard this album, and wasn't previously aware it was a double. It's good. It's really, really good. I don't think it's the best solo album by any of the Beatles (still giving that to McCartney and Wings even if it was not, strictly speaking, a solo project). But this one is chock full of some decent material that could easily have been of several of the Beatles later albums. It does just keep going, and going, and going, though, and much like The White Album, could have done with some paring down (particularly the remaster, which clocked in at over two hours). Still earns a 4.5/5 that I'm willing to round up due to hero status, and I'll happily revisit and recommend this one to folks who have yet to experience it.
257. All Things Must Pass - George Harrison (1970) 11.6.26 Variety: 5 Adequacy: 5 Listenability: 5 Uniqueness: 4 Emotionality: 5 = 4.8 rounded up to a 5 "Watch out now/ Take care, beware of falling swingers/ Dropping all around you/ The pain that often mingles/ In your fingertips/ Beware of darkness" The Beatles are the only act I can think of where all the members have clearly defined ( however erroneously) and recognizably distinct qualities, in both their personas and their music. It's become a pop culture game if sorts to try and slot people into the various Beatle archetypes. John is the serious one, George is the spiritual one, etc... That's a fun diversion and one I have definitely thought about, but I find it so much more fascinating that the same thing applies to their music. Mostly. John, Paul, and George, probably through the sheer availability and preponderance of their catalogs, as a band and slightly less as solo acts all have an output that most people familiar with rock and pop of the last 60+ years can identify, more or less quickly (depending on just how big a nerd you are) based on a turn in melody, a specific guitar tone, or whatever certain combination of elements that happens to flash that particular synaptic web where all your Beatlesy knowledge is stored. Ringo maybe not so much, though many claim his drumming is very distinct. This is so much the case that you will regularly see in print people describing a particular song element as Lennonesque ( pick your Liam Gallagher vocals), McCartneyesque ( Emmitt Rhodes's whole vibe), Harrisonesque ( the singing, sliding guitar lines in Gerry Rafferty's "Right Down the Line") and so on... The Beatles themselves do it not infrequently, either in a mocking way or as a little tribute on their solo albums where they dip into their colleagues' styles occasionally. Harrison I think does so on here, but we'll get to that in a few. I guess my long rambling point is that these guys were massively influential even AFTER they broke up. And this album was maybe one of the more influential ones. Its fingerprints can be felt on a TON of releases all the way up to modern times, and on its own merits, aside from the still huge Beatles influence. All Things Must Pass is one that I came to relatively late for a dyed in the wool Beatles fan. It always seemed so daunting as a kid, and besides back then I was all about Paul ( still my favorite). George was a distant third. John was briefly a favorite, but only for a small window in my teens. I knew the hits from this one, like anyone who ever listened to the radio, but assumed that was the only stuff probably worth listening to, and the rest was probably some hippy dippy spiritual mumbo jumbo. I mean, it kind of is, but when I finally listened to the whole thing sometimes in my 20s I was pretty blown away at how damn GOOD that spiritual mumbo jumbo was, and base mainly on that ( and his 80s comeback stuff) George jumped up way past John, whose personality and try hard artsy fartsyness came off as more obnoxious than it did when I was younger. I've since owned this on both CD and a couple of times on vinyl. When I made the hard choice to get rid of my Beatles records a few years ago, this was one I actually considered keeping, but eventually it went with the rest. All things must pass, indeed. My feelings on the guys didn't change, I just already had so much of their stuff in other formats, and I know for a fact it will ever be out of print, so why not make some shelf space. I'm really looking forward to this one and will try not to gush too much, but expect a lot of high praise and some rambling. THE TRACKS Side one "I'd Have You Anytime" - We start things off with a beautiful and lilting piece, co-written with Bob Dylan a couple of years earlier at Woodstock apparently. Like a lot of the stuff on here, it's very pretty and prepares the listener for the almost worshipful tone we'll hear throughout. Much is made about George and his journey to try and find enlightenment via Eastern religions, and I think pieces like this really help get across that it wasn't just some fad for a bored rich guy. He felt this stuff deeply enough that even something as light and charming and sort of quietly celebratory and romantic has that vibe about it. Though that could just be the next track and its much more on the nose messaging echoing backwards in time to retrospectively frame this one with the same subject matter. "My Sweet Lord" - I mean, what could I say about this that hasn't already been said. There's the lawsuit stuff, the fear George had that people would "get weird" of he used such obvious religious imagery in his music. And he had good reason to be gun shy after the whole "bigger than Jesus" thing. Putting all that aside, this is maybe one of the most gentle, perfectly crafted, and ear pleasing songs I've had the pleasure to have ever heard. And I've heard it a LOT. It's one of those songs that's entirely made up of melodic hooks. Not only does George's singing, electric slide guitar sounds like it's talking to you, the strumming acoustic guitar line is iconic in and of itself. I'm in no way a spiritual person myself, and I'm definitely not religious. I did grow up Southern Baptist though, and I think there must still be some sort of weird sense of, if not spirituality, then at least an appreciation of unearthly sounding music. In fact music itself might be as close as I could ever get to the concept of spirituality as it can and has put me into a sort of meditative state where I am fully open to soaking in the feelings the musicians are trying t o get across. More so now in life I find that music affects me in oddly emotional ways it never did when I was younger. This is one of them. I can relax and put myself in George's shoes for the little while the song is going on and maybe get a contact high of sorts off of his ecstatic devotion and yearning to be part of something much larger than himself. An all-time classic, and one I'll never grow tired of. "Wah-Wah" - Supposedly written as a response to feeling like the fifth wheel during the Let It Be sessions, and as catchy as it is, buoyed into a sort of spaceyness by Phil Spector's wall of sound approach, it feels a little bit clumsy, and a little bit whiny and there's more than a little "fuck you" in the chorus especially. This is the first track I remember hearing and regretting I'd waited so long. "Isn't It a Pity (Version One)" - Achingly pretty and sad at the same time, this one sounds to me as close as George ever gets to sounding like he's imitating John ( consciously or not) with the reverbed vocals, and the distinctly percussive piano playing. This kind of bittersweet, insanely catchy bit of pop is a frontrunner for favorite tracks and is a perfect closer for side one, seeming to expound on the bad feelings from the Beatles breakup and feel universal all at once. I find it the height of craziness that Harrison supposedly presented this to the group in '66 and it was rejected many times over. As much as I love that period of the Beatles, this kind of thing makes Paul and John seem like some cunty bitches. Side two "What Is Life" - Damn. What an opener for side two. I guess the second biggest hit off the album, and the other big one I heard on the radio all the time, this one leans hard into the whole Phil Spectory, 60s girl group sound. I could very easily imagine the Ronettes or Crystals doing a version of this. George is joined by old Slowhand himself, along with members of Delaney and Bonnie and Badfinger to get this soaring love song off the ground. It's wonderfully busy and catchy as all get out and sure, maybe THE ode to codependency, but it totally fits with George's questioning and devotional messaging. "If Not for You" - I think this is the only song written entirely by someone else on the album, being as it is a cover of the Dylan song from his New Morning album. It's very pretty and very obviously a Dylan track, though George messes with the arrangement, adding more soul and a sort of etherealness Dylan I'm not sure us capable of. Both versions are great though. "Behind That Locked Door" - George dips his toe into some country and western sounds on this one, with some beautiful pedal steel guitar laying down the heavy vibes, and a shuffling beat to tie them together. It's got just the right mix of sorrowfulness and lovely dancing melody that keep that bittersweet feeling that I love so much going strong. He does this so well and is so seemingly casually great at it, that he makes guys like Gram Parsons and Gene Clark and all of the Eagles look like chumps for devoting so much time to the country rock genre and never producing anything as pretty or moving. And he can toss that cowboy hat aside on a whim and climb right into a bit of progressively soft rock, almost like it was a lark. "Let It Down" - And that bit of soft pop is soooooooooo friendly and warm and full of tension, and when it briefly explodes into heavy guitars and pounding drums in the chorus it feels just a tiny bit apocalyptic and as close to being sexy as anything on here. The dynamic son this track are killer. We're winding down the first disc and holy shit I realized we have yet to hit a single bump in the road so far. "Run of the Mill" - This one is pretty enough, and rolls along at a steady pace and doesn't rock the boat too much. George's vocal melody and the downbeat horns and organ accents make this one feel somehow sadder than any of the other ones we've had yet, maybe made more so my the almost pleading sounding lyrics. It's teh first B-tier track, but it's still pretty danged good. Side three "Beware of Darkness" - As great as "My Sweet Lord" and "Isn't It a Pity" are I think this one has worked its way up to being my favorite track on the album. It's full of wisdom and pain and is so beautifully delivered, and I think is George's finest emotional moment on the album. I remember at some time in the past listening to this song and thinking if you had to boil down a lifetime of advice into the shortest, most meaningful and affecting format, this might be it. I could have died early, before imparting any life lessons, and left a note for my kids to play this song, and I think it might have turned out a little bit ok if they took George's advice in my stead. "Apple Scruffs" - Supposedly George's tribute to the hard core fans, this is the first song on the album that I might just be able to live without. It's fine enough, but it just doesn't play up at the level of most everything else and feels like the throwaway that it is. It's still full of catchy little bits though, and I've heaped loads of praise on plenty of Paul songs for doing much the same thing. There's a bit of a Simon and Garfunkel feel to it which I think throws me off as well. "Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let It Roll)" - Some more of those country and western vibes, but applied to the pop mode and with a ton of atmosphere. In fact there's so much damn atmosphere that you can barely hear George at work behind it. The Phil Spector stuff is maybe overkill here, but the catchy, melancholy feeling is so strong on this that I don't really mind it all that much. "Awaiting on You All" - The wall of sound stays at full force on this very gospely and fun piece that also had more than a little of that early 60s R&B feel about it. It bounces along and feels uplifting and happy and you barely notice that it's George playing at trying to save your soul. "All Things Must Pass" - The closer to side three feels like it should be the end of the album. It's supposedly a tribute to his friends in the Band, it mixes that sad country rock vibe with an sweet orchestral arrangement that gives it a bit of an epic feel. It might be my least favorite of the well recognized tracks on the album, but it's still very good. Side four "I Dig Love" - This one gets a bad rap I think as being the weakest song on the album. Sure, it's not the deepest thing on here, and it's got a much different sound with the piano and Hammond organ ( played by Gary Wright and Billy Preston respectively) and falling down the stairs drum fills. It's simple, but has a strong groove and is pretty catchy. "Art of Dying" - Maybe it's because we just listened to a Chic album and it's on teh mind, but I can't help bit hear a sort of proto-disco sound on this track because of the driving rhythms on this. It doesn't entirely work for me, and I'd probably give it the title that "I Dig Love" doesn't really deserve as the weakest track. --- The demo version blows it out of the water in my opinion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6aj77ecC0Ms&list=RD6aj77ecC0Ms&start_radio=1 "Isn't It a Pity (Version Two)" - Much slower, of not more considered, this one feels more like a reprise than an alternate take as it's way shorter, and is delivered with a sort of "THIS IS THE END, GUYS" bit of epicness lacking in the original. I wonder if any members of Pink Floyd had this in mind when they were coming up with the end of Dark Side of the Moon. It's great, but I like the first version better. This would have been another good album closer ( for anyone out there looking to make some fantasy cuts). "Hear Me Lord" - ... and would have been a much better closer than this, which feels kind of tired and middle of the road compared to everything else on around it, with its overblown gospel stylings and choir like backing vocals. It's still not awful my any means though, and feels of a piece with everything thematically. EXTRAS: There are a lot of bonus tracks, alternate takes, and songs left off the original album that have been cleaned up and re-ossued on a remaster that are WELL worth your time to check out. Some of them would have been very fine additions to the orginal had there been space. I won't be covering them all, nor will I be spending any time on the Apple Jam pieces as they are really just that, as fun as they are. Noted below are the ones that especially stood out for me. * "I live For You" - I love the pedal steel guitar paying on this, and it's a very cool trick that it doesn't feel completely like a country rock song despite that instrument being so synonymous with it. It's used in such a unique way and is so balanced by the poppy parts that it lives as some weirdly perfect chimaera. Neither fish nor fowl, but retaining the best parts of both. * "Beware of Darkness" (acoustic demo) - All I said about the original goes double for the version you can find on the remaster that's listed as the (1st version recorded at Abbey Road studios. It's way less lush and produced and has an almost choked, super emotional vocal that the original album cut lacks, as great as it is. It's raw and real, and immediate and puts a lump in my throat when I hear it. There's even a bitterly funny dig at the former manager and all round piece of work Allen Klein. --- 1st Take: - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xhnIeM7x_Bk&list=OLAK5uy_mZ571YNm6BjDdUQeShO0u0vgnKJmK3qM0&index=12 * "Let It Down" (alternate version) - Much as I love the original, I think the stripped down vocal and guitar version form the remaster outclasses it, and makes it sound SO modern it's eerie. --- Stripped down version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ct3Md60cdnY&list=OLAK5uy_mZ571YNm6BjDdUQeShO0u0vgnKJmK3qM0&index=13 HIGHLIGHTS - "I'd Have You Anytime" - "My Sweet Lord" - "Wah-Wah" - "Isn't It a Pity (Version One)" - "What Is Life" - "If Not for You" - "Behind That Locked Door" - "Let It Down" - "Beware of Darkness" - "Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let It Roll)" - "Awaiting on You All" - "All Things Must Pass" - "I Dig Love" MIDLIGHTS - "Run of the Mill" - "Apple Scruffs" - "Art of Dying" - "Hear Me Lord" LOWLIGHTS - FINAL THOUGHTS I think it's pretty common knowledge that a lot of the material on this album was stuff George had been saving up for a very long time, with so many of his efforts vetoed by John and Paul for prior Beatles albums. He no doubt reworked a lot of it, but it's remarkable how well these things fit together so well. More than any other solo album by the guys, it lives in my mind as the most cohesive and well structured and measured. Knowing that he polished up some old pieces doesn't change how impressive it is though. Maybe even more so that he was able to take all these pieces from various jigsaw puzzles, meticulously shave the edges and make them fit together seamlessly. And he did it with a little help from his friends. A lot of them. Peter Frampton, Eric Clapton, Billy Preston, Ringo Starr, Gary Wright, Ginger Baker, Phil Collins, members of Badfinger, Procol Harum, Manfred Mann, Derek and the Dominoes and more. John Lennon was even rumored to have dropped by, but I can't find any confirmation on what he might have done. It seems like a massive undertaking, and must have felt like a weight had been lifted after all these songs his former bandmates had rejected were almost immediately beloved. It's been a while since I've listened to this one and while I wasn't planning on dipping into much of the extra stuff due to time limitations, I couldn't help it and I'm glad I did. There are quite a few of the rawer acoustic demos and earlier takes that I like even more than the already great originals that I plan on making a playlist for an alternate acoustic version of the album if I can find the time. Even though they are not my favorite band, I think the Beatles are possibly up there at the very top as far as having a rewarding and ever fascinating catalogue of leftover bits and pieces. You could spend years just listening to alternate takes, and diving down into the details on specific recording sessions. This becomes less of a fruitful proposition the further you get out into the solo careers, but it's still better documented than most. I stand by my assessment of this being the objectively best Beatles solo album due to how well put together it is. Those few songs that didn't connect with me still fit right in, and it's an extra impressive feat given how long, long, long the album is. a double album is notoriously difficult to pull off for even the best of the best. A triple album though...? I never said it was my favorite though. We don't have as many of the guys' solo albums on here as I'd like, so we won't get to all the ones I do like better 9 no Ram! No Venus and Mars!), but I guess some spots were needed for Dexys Midnight Runners and Morrisey. Possible turn-Offs might include: - run time - the Phil Spector of it all - a spiritual thread running throughout that might prove cloying to some You Might enjoy this if you: - love you some catchy as hell music that also feels like it's trying to comfort you - are already a Beatles fan and have somehow never heard this one - have a couple of hours to kill and would like to hear some demos and alternate takes that are better than a lot of the polished studio hits from some of the more well regarded albums on the list PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - As I can't resist monkeying around with some Beatles related stuff, I would likely cut those 4 midlights for time, and sub in a bunch of alternate acoustic takes. If I get around to it, I might come back and update this with the playlist, but I the next album is calling my name, so until next time... FURTHER LISTENING Precursors: - Three Ragas – Ravi Shankar - The Chiffons (Sing the Hits of the 50's) – The Chiffons - Music from Big Pink by The Band - Nashville Skyline by Bob Dylan - Abbey Road by the Beatles - Blind Faith by Blind Faith - That’s the Way God Planned It – Billy Preston Contemporaries: - On Tour with Eric Clapton by Delaney & Bonnie and Friends - Bridge over Troubled Water by Simon & Garfunkel - John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band by John Lennon - McCartney by Paul McCartney - Sentimental Journey by Ringo Starr - After the Gold Rush by Neil Young - Mad Dogs & Englishmen by Joe Cocker - Tumbleweed Connection by Elton John - Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs – Derek and the Dominos - No Dice by Badfinger Descendants: - Pink Moon by Nick Drake - #1 Record by Big Star - Discovery by E.L.O. - Hearts by America - City to City by Gerry Rafferty - Full Moon Fever by Tom Petty - Traveling Wilburys Vol. 1 by The Traveling Wilburys - Third Eye by Redd Kross - Thirteen by Teenage Fanclub
George Harrison was a brilliant songwriter. His work with the Beatles and solo made an impact on so many artists around him and beyond him. I knew several of the songs on this album, but had never listened to the album in full. Yes, it is long and feels like a vast compilation of things he had been stashing away, but no, it never gets boring. From classics like "What Is Life," to Dylan-esque songs like "If Not for You" and "I Live for You," to fun alternate versions and demo tracks, to the brilliant instrumental jams "I Remember Jeep," "Thanks for the Pepperoni," and "Out of the Blue," this album has everything. It's a musical haven!
A two-hour slog through what sounds like a bunch of Beatles outtakes.
Pretty chilled out album with several big hit songs. I have never actually listened to this album before today. It's really good if you are in a relaxed mood. Has a Beetles kind of vibe to it for obvious reasons.
one of my fav albums of all time! great start!
89
i did like parts a lot and knew some of it already of course, but dear god why is this 2 hours long and why did i forget a lot of it... that being said it has potential in my book
My Sweet Lord - **** Wah Wah - ****
pretty typical Beatles-adjacent album
Excellent tunes. Too long. Too many versions. Cult and idolatry adulterating the main body of work. Derek & the Dominoes probably contribute to this. Wish we knew a bit more about who was doing what on this album. Sweet Lord and Wah-wah have great sounds and Harrison's voice is so earnest you could weep. I don’t have a conception of this album due to the many changes of order and track additions and removals. If only they had let it pass.
George really just threw everything at the wall and what didn't stick he just piled into here
Phil spector produced george Harrison solo album first since beatles triple album number one
Amazing album; George finally got to spread his wings, and he knocked it out of the park. Such great guitar work, great lyrics, fun collaborations.
This was. Long. Still good though, made me happy the Beatles broke up. Highlights: My sweet lord (fav) Wah-wah What is life Hear me lord
very much could have been two albums but two albums that were made specifically for me (thank you george!). i loved this so much, so perfect for a cloudy day like today. The melodies and the lyrics and his voice and when it starts to ramp up a bit and get really fun just make for a great time. so lovely. (kind of super glad the beatles broke up)
Long, a lot of it I felt like sounded the same tbh
Really really great. Long but vast. I like when he says words but the guitar parts are absurdly good too.
Barely excuses being 2 hours long
10/30 Don't like the Beatles and this album is way too long
This isn’t a great album… it’s two great albums packed together. I can hear Beatles, Hendrix, Chuck Berry, Phil Spector, Bob Dylan at times but it is all filtered through George’s own sense of melody and structure. This is far better than anything that Lennon or McCartney ever produced solo or as Beatles in my opinion. It’s a long listen though, realistically most will dip in and out rather than set aside over 2 hrs to experience it as a while. I just don’t understand why the record label didn’t encourage him release two separate albums, his accountant must have been raging. 4.7
An absolutely brilliant album packed with well-written, beautifully crafted songs. Superb. 4.6/5
Very good. A hell of a lot better than some of the other Beatles solo records on this fucking list that's for sure.
Giving my usual diatribe that the Beatles are greater than the sum of their parts, and most of their solo projects wouldn't have had much success without name recognition. For this album it's made even worse because it's 7 hours long (give or take, I wasn't looking at the clock).
This was actually kinda good. Far better than the other Beatles solo stuff. It was just way, way too long.
like a guy who brings a 6-pack to a party: is appreciated, thanked for the good stuff, but overstays his welcome. thank you for the beer, George, but please leave. 6/10 FAVOURITE SONGS: WAH-WAH, LET IT DOWN, ART OF DYING
3.5
4.0
I mean, it's good. I guess the main reason it's here is it's a Beatle? I enjoyed it quit a lot, but it does lack a certain something. Closer to a 3 than a 5.
This album means so much to me. First of all, I’m a massive Beatles fan of over 35 years. This particular album was very moving and comforting when George passed away. Then a month later my grandfather unexpectedly passed away too. This album was a great friend in that period.
yes
Amazing album with so many melodic masterpieces, and many that I had never heard before. The only letdown was the last 3 songs that had such a different vibe and dragged on and on. When I revisit this album it will end with Plug me in. Favorite track: Run of the Mill
3/5 not a beatles fan, so i'm sure the nuances of this flew over my head. i did enjoy some of the melodies, but this is a longggg album. started to sound the same a quarter of the way through. best song: art of dying
Phenomenal album. He’s my favorite Beatle. I had thought that 2 of these songs were Beatles’ songs, not just his!
This was so lovely and thoughtful and sweet and weird and interesting. George has now officially become the Beatle with my favorite solo career
My favorite album from a Beatle that isn't from The Beatles.
Just chill perfect for a ride
This is really difficult to rate when I don't care about the last 30 minutes of the album. If this was paired down to 15 songs even, it would be much stronger. That being said, I love a lot of this album and I think it shows how he was being underutilized in The Beatles. Light 8/10 but could've been much higher.
Of course I know who George Harrison is but I can only think of 2 solo songs of his I know. Holy moly, 23 tracks! This is going to be a long listen. "I'd Have You Anytime": Not the strongest start. Great guitar but feels like a generic 70's slow tune the rest of the way - "My Sweet Lord": One of the Harrison songs I have heard. This was already in my playlist. It's a good one. + "Wah-Wah": This one has a very Beatles feel. It's ok, a bit long. + "Isn't it a Pity": Slow start but builds beautifully. Drags quite a bit towards the end + "What Is Life": I have heard this before, I think. I like it + "If Not for You": It's alright but didn't catch me - "Behind That Locked Door": Am I hearing a slide guitar? A country feel and I don't like country music much, but I like this one + "Let It Down": I liked the chorus bit in this but overall it was a let down - "Run of the Mill": This is soulful. Short and sweet + "Beware of Darkness": A beautiful song. This one got me in the feelings + "Apple Scruffs": Sounds Dylan influenced. Didn't like it. - "Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let it Roll)": This has an uplifting feel to it. I like it + "Awaiting on You All": This sounded like the Beatles did gospel. The chorus felt out of place. - "All Things Must Pass": The title track. A great song about looking ahead. + "I Dig Love": Not bad. Not a playlist type song but a fun little ditty. + "Art of Dying": Fast paced and bluesy. Oh yeah + "Isn't it a Pity (Version 2)": I think I like this stripped down version better than the other one. + "Hear Me Lord": For some reason, I'm reminded of Pink Floyd in this song, which is a good thing + "Out of the Blue": An 11-minute jam session. Too long and not for me - "It's Johnny's Birthday": A goofy song/interlude - "Plug Me In": Another jam session but much shorter - "I Remember Jeep": More instrumentals with lasers - "Thanks for the Pepperoni": Another rocking jam instrumental - Songs added to playlist: What is Life, Behind That Locked Door, Run Of the Mill, Beware of Darkness, Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let it Roll), All Things Must Pass, Art of Dying, Isn't It a Pity (version 2), Hear me Lord I really enjoyed this listen until I came to the last 5 tracks of instrumentals. Then I read this was a triple album and the instrumentals were sort of like a bonus inclusion to the double album. This is a really good to great rock album. I give it 4 stars.
Hippie music.
A strong, strong 4.5, likely a bump to 5 upon project end final review. A lush, dense, beautiful record from my favorite Beatle. A double LP that never feels like a slog, ATMP is a success on all levels (writing/performance/production)
Proof that less is more
Not the best post-Beatle album but still fantasic.
Quite good. I don't know if I have the attention span to listen to the whole thing. This is one I'll come back to.
Really nice, will definitely listen to again, not a fan of a good percentage of Beatles and Beatles members output but this is good and has a really honest feeling.
Per usual, I have the same complaint about really long albums. There’s no reason why you can’t just break it into 2 or 3 albums. It’s doing too much and after a certain point, everything sounded so similar. It was a drag.
First LP was perfect. Second started great, but got weaker as time progresses towards the end. (4.0/5.0)
Oh boy. George Harrison's first solo album, and a colossal piece of work- One of the first notable triple albums ever released, All Things Must pass is a soft-rock odyssey from one of the best songwriters to ever live. Runs a bit long at times, but a great time. 8.5/10.
I love George Harrison. He’s always been my favorite Beatle and has been behind some of my favorite songs. There is absolutely a 5 star album here somewhere, but it is bogged down by the sheer breadth and length of it. I still enjoy it quite a bit, but wouldn’t listen to it fully like this. 4/5
Ну такой комонный Но зато песню нашел которую овер дохуя лет не слышал и в конце инструменталы прикольные
Made it to the half