Album Summary
Too-Rye-Ay is the second studio album by English pop band Dexys Midnight Runners, released in July 1982 by Mercury Records. The album is best known for the hit single "Come On Eileen", which included the refrain that inspired the album's title. It was the band's most successful album, debuting at number two on the UK Albums Chart.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
The only song I know by them is “come on Eileen”. Let the adventure begin! Track one is really good right from the start. Nice bounce and just fun. Up to track four. I really like the album so far. I write these guys off as a one hit wonder, but this album is really good.
Not sure why but his voice and just whole composition of every piece awoke something primal in me that hated this with every bit of my essence. Maybe I’m being unreasonably judgmental, but this is like top 2 most hated albums right behind Smile… which I had the same reaction to.
Just a bummer to have to listen to this
Stop telling me to listen to this terrible band
solid, 6/10
Eclectic (complimentary). Also, I'd never realized that the title for the album that "Come On Eileen" is on is just the gibberish refrain from the song and I'm going to be chuckling about that all day.
Loved this back when it came out, and even more now. Great fusion of Irish music and Philly soul.
Album two they are now Kevin Rowland and Dexys... By album three, they make one of the worst things I've ever heard, but that's another story. This is actually decent, retains the early fun and pop punch. Rowland may be a egotistical wanker, but he writes a good tune, over the course of an album his voice is a bit much.
Dancing Queen last week, now Come On Eileen. Seems I’ve hit the wedding disco part of the 1001 list. This album is actually quite decent but Come On Eileen is just an overplayed nonsense. On the other hand, Jocky Wilson is a belter of a track!!
come on eileen is a banger tho
Appreciating the sweat and momentum but waiting for substance to reveal itself. It leans into a "promising but not profound" territory, and captures a specific Celtic soul energy without committing to a love affair. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions - The Celtic Soul Brothers (More, Please, Thank You) - Jackie Wilson Said (I'm in Heaven When You Smile) - Come On Eileen
Very not for me. I think this checks all the boxes of stuff I can’t stand in songs - Celtic, fiddles, horns, glam style singing, soul sounding backup singers.
Completely unremarkable.
I enjoyed listening to this album - many good songs. 3/5
Never heard so much Come on Eileen outside of a wedding. It's a fun song but it's really all that stood out to me. The other songs didn't seem as fun.
I know Come On Eileen, but nothing else here: that song is still catchy, with strong hooks, range of styles, and rhythmic shift between verse and chorus, but I never liked Rowland's singing (and always distrusted the video). Reading about Rowland and the band (its various incarnations) is quite off-putting - domineering ambition, investing in made-up images, media shenanigans. But I'll see if I can put that aside to assess the music on the album. I don't mind the idea of "Celtic soul", arrangements with strings as well as horns could be okay or even good, but the first three songs are rubbish (hard to listen all the way through), fourth song is much better but it's a cover, next five also rubbish. Poor lyrics, and very, very poor lead singing: the arrangements and rest of the band are better than the lead vocalist / auteur, it can easily happen. The album is Really Poor, 2/10.
This was a lot of fun, but besides Eileen, I'm not sure I'd listen again.
Pop, 1982 -> 3
3.3
7/10
unique sound but not misical enough for me
Love it.
Now, listen. I’m not a monster, and I’m not an idiot either. I love “Come On, Eileen.” And this belongs on here. That’s what I know. It’s foundational Irish rock, foundational 80s pop rock, it has one of the best pop rock songs of all time on it, and yet… Ehhh. It’s fine. The highlights are highlights but they’re few and far between in all honesty. I don’t care for most of the songs, other than the charming opener which I enjoy plenty, the main attraction, that being “Eileen,” and “Plan B/Show Me,” which by any measure is a pretty alright song. I don’t really know what to say. I don’t love it, but I don’t dislike it. Maybe I don’t like it. Maybe I won’t think of it. What I know is it’s listenable, and you should hear its biggest song. That’s good enough for me. 6.2/10 DOES IT BELONG ON THE LIST: YES REASON: foundational, fun, charming, has “Come On Eileen” on it.
Eillen but what else?
Good bouncy fun. I liked this far more than I expected. Not just an album you could sing asking to, but one to dance along to also.
Not much to say on this apart from I didn't like it. Simple as. Come On Eileen is a banger tho
Compared to its predecessor, 𝘛𝘰𝘰-𝘙𝘺𝘦-𝘈𝘺 leans much more heavily into soul. Unfortunately, that doesn’t exactly help its chances with me, as blue-eyed soul and I still haven’t become particularly good friends. There’s certainly some charm to the album, and I can understand why people enjoy this kind of sound, even if it doesn’t always click with me. It’s not a bad record by any means, just one that doesn’t quite match my personal taste. The obvious exception is 𝗖𝗼𝗺𝗲 𝗢𝗻 𝗘𝗶𝗹𝗲𝗲𝗻, which is easily the highlight of the album. It’s ridiculously catchy, full of energy, and one of those songs that are almost impossible not to enjoy. The rest of the record is perfectly enjoyable in places, but nothing else really comes close to that level of excitement. Overall, a solid album with some undeniable charm, even if it hasn’t convinced me to join the blue-eyed soul fan club just yet.
Fun theatrical energy.
Come on Eileen is an absolute banger still. The rest of the album is pretty good. 3.5 rounding up.
Trop bien 🥰
Nope.
Not bad! Generally catchy. Come on Eileen is the best song on the album.
This was my first time listening to this album, and “Come On Eileen” basically sums up everything you need to know about what the entire album sounds like. Overall, it was a decent album. I would say most of the songs would get a 3.5 rating out of 5 on their own merit.
A super hit and some okay stuff but not enough to be above average.
A one song album, who’s one song was an absolute smash hit, but isn’t a song that’s revolutionary by any means.
OK, not much to write home about after Come on Eileen - Given a 4 because this one song is such a classic
Fun listen.
Matey's voice is a bit irritating but for the most part it's catchy enough
This album is pretty good, not great, but I can still tap my foot to it. I love the use of the horns even if their all used the exact same way throughout the entire album and it's very same-sies. Best song Dubious Worst song: Until I Believe in My Soul 6/10
A little tiny bit weirder than I expected. nice.
Of course Eileen
Partly heard before Saved 3/10 Top track: Come On Eileen
me encontré con un hit? me encontré con un hit.
Fue como comer un pancho que no tenías ganas de comer pero no era feo
Come on Eileen! This alone gives it a high rating, but I did enjoy the album overall.
Well I mean, if anyone bought this record after hearing Come On Eileen, they would have known exactly what they were getting - it's all very much in a single vein. It's not a good vein, but i guess it's consistent? At least it isn't Don't Stand Me Down i guess, but that last song comes dangerously close
I enjoyed this much more than I thought I would!
It’s alright.
This often feels like an album of Celtic folk as performed by a ska band. I would prefer if they went full ska, as I personally don't enjoy folk music very much. As it is, I thought this was not nearly as interesting or good as their debut. It's not helped by the fact that Come On Eileen continues to be overplayed 45 years later. I always think negatively about that song and I never listen to it on purpose, but hearing it here? I get it. The band definitely has a crooning, whiny singer, typical of British New Wave music, and I really don't like that vocal style. I don't think I would listen to this album again.
Do one, Eileen. Although a lot of the album tracks are considerably better than the overplayed finale, a lot of it is pretty grating stuff.
fun little listen carried by come on eileen 6/10 best songs - come on eileen
A British band but I don’t mind them as much as others. More folk influenced.
Marked improvement over their other album
Rock with a kind of celtic folk vibe. I love music with lots of different instruments and the violin, horns, piano and banjo worked really well together with the guitar/bass/drums. I really liked the vibe and energy. Come On Eileen has been overplayed but it is a great song. Apart from that , my favourite two tracks were bonus tracks and not on the original album though (Show Me and Dubious).
This is my second Dexys Midnight Runners album and, from what I remember of Don't Stand Me Down (which I rated 2/5), Too Rye Ay is soooo much better. Very fun, and the compositions are great.
I had obviously heard of DMR before starting the 1001 albums list, but I had never listened to an album. Don't stand me down is my favourite album, that I hadn't heard before on this list thus far. This album has some superb songs and songwriting and again, the difficulty of being an irish immigrant comes through although less than DSMD. maith an fear Caoimhin
Every song above 3 minutes on this album is a slog except the obvious. It's interesting they were a 1 hit wonder, definitely think they could have been more if they didn't seem so generic.
Good for the genre, just not my thing
Over two years ago, I was pleasantly surprised by the band’s first album in this project. At the time, I wondered if I should change my negative opinion of the band. Now that I’ve listened to this album, I know I was right. The album was pretty boring. “Come On Eileen” has a certain appeal for me for nostalgic reasons. But that appeal only lasts until the first chorus—then I’ve had enough. I won’t be listening to that again. 2/5
I remember the video for Come On Eileen, with the urban overalls and quasi-hick portrayal. It set a visual bias toward what the rest of the album was probably like, and boy was I wrong. This was surprisingly jazzier than I expected. The song Dubious was like Tower of Power level jazzy. It was interesting, too, because I was getting Oingo Boingo vibes throughout this album and my lovely in-home Boingo-lover hates this album. Let’s Get this Straight was very Sgt. Pepper-ish. Other songs were very ska, like I’ll Show You. My fav track was still Come On Eileen, but that is probably due to historical bias, and ai actually like the Save Ferris homage better. This was an interesting album but necessarily a go-to.
Random thoughts: * Fun listen to hear other Dexy's songs besides Come On Eileen. * Solid outing and should be the only Dexys album on this list. There is no way we need three Dexy's albums. The author must be a huge fan. * I liked the old-timey/reminiscing theme throughout. The cover of Jackie Wilson Said was nicely done. * I'm not sure I will pull this out often but it was a fun listen with an all-time song in Come On Eileen.
Man, was this fun. I knew one song of theirs only, in my mind the band was one of those one-hit wonders, but what a pleasant surprise this album proved to be.
Love this. It's not quite a 5 maybe but the self-belief and passion drives it along, and it's a pretty singular vision. Shame about the official live version of Come on Eileen though - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3rg4psdHxw
Some of this album was great. Some of it was not so great...
I've never heard of this group before. But I like them.
It's fine overall, even with Eileen
I wanted to like this more. Come on Eileen is one of the best songs of the 80s. And it started so well with the Celtic Soul Brothers. Then it lost me, So I listened again. And there it was. It held up very well. All in All really stood out too. Been meaning to listen to more Dexys and this was a good start. A little more of the celtic folk over the pop would be nice, but they aren't the Pogues are they.
this is a weird one. the longer it went on, the less i liked it. i love come on eileen as much as the next person, but i don’t understand why we need a live version two tracks later. low 3, high 2? somewhere there.
For most of my life I hated come on Eileen as it was a wedding/naff 80s night staple, but I have come to appreciate it in the last few years. This album feels like it is all in a similar vein to that, so at this point I thought I would like it, but for all it's catchy hooks it just all felt a bit flat to me. All a bit ploddy and even when Eileen came on it still felt ploddy until the build up bit. Not sure why. Individually I liked the elements I think, but as a whole it left me a bit blah. I listened to it twice to try to figure it out, but I'm no closer. Not a dislike, definitely a disappointment, but mostly just a bit of a shrug.
High 3 for me as don’t find it a consistently great album, but I do enjoy their musicianship, instrumentation and authenticity and the energy they convey in some of the best songs. And they completely bottled lightning in *that single.*
Quite enjoyed this, even apart from its god tier one hit wonder
I admire their commitment to a sound, I just don't like the sound that much. And Come On Eileen, as good as it is, I don't ever listen to on purpose.
Not my happy place. I'm genuinely wondering what is wrong with me that I find this kind of music gratingly unbearable. It's just happy. Maybe I'm an old cynic. Things I like: Some of the big band bits. Things I find less enjoyable: The style of singing (but I don't know why - usually I like unfettered expression verging on the weird, but something about its combination with chart music from the 80s). It's a bit doobeeedoobeee do. Clacky percussion and perky bass. I think that's as far as my analysis can go at the moment. I think if it was playing loudly at a night out I'd not hold back dancing to (some of) it. But not something I would choose to listen to. I struggle to get to the end of the album. In which case it's a grumpy 2. Fave track: Dubious. For the brass. It's an instrumental as well I realise. hahah. Why are there only fucking deluxe albums available on spotify? I could have managed a 40 minute original release, but have to sit through 1h 3m.
I liked this for the most part. Not super exciting or interesting, but had some songs that were fun to listen to. 3/5
I enjoyed this one, thanks.
Did we need another from these guys on the list?
Review - I'll begin by saying this album is better than American's who only know Eileen would give it credit for. I'll also say it has it's fair share of misses. Hadn't realised it was only the second album. How confusing must it have been as a British fan like "oh nice Dexys are back, I loved Geno" then it's all violins and shit. A good album and ahead of it's time in bringing in Celtic influences. But it was done better later by the Waterboys. Still an ok album Score - 5.5/10 Need to listen? YES
I was expecting it to be a bore, but it’s actually pretty good
Come on Eileen is one of the most famous songs ever, a fun song, and actually the whole album sounded like that. Enjoyably upbeat and fun.
3.5 stars I love “Come on Eileen” and I remember my brother told me this record was actually good. I got it on vinyl for cheap and it’s got a lot of loud pops, but I think it was a good listen in this way. Haven’t played it through in maybe a decade and it does hold up as a fun record. Some songs are a little overlong and repetitive, but an enjoyable listen on most tracks.
favs tracks - "old" and "come on eileen" 3,5
Ok
I mean its ok. Might even call it enjoyable. How many Dexys Midnight Runners albums do I really need to listen to before I die? I'd wager its certainly less than 3.
Before going in, I am sceptical; this seems like one of those albums that was only included for one song, this one being "Come On Eileen", and even at that, I hate the song. I already rated one of their albums low; I believe a 2, but it should have been a 1 because I did not enjoy it at all. Yeah I did not enjoy the music, but I could at least see some good, feels very positive with the upbeat violin but the songs were not exciting at all
Yeah, you're waiting for "Come On Elileen," but the journey there is more than worth it.
Until I Believe in My Soul is the longest song I've ever heard in my damn life and it's immediately followed by Come On Eileen. I have to admit there is a pretty nice stretch of this near the end when the guy shuts the fuck up (update: it turns out these were the bonus tracks lmao)
Glad to hear the Celtic touches back on this one alongside the more soulful sound, and of course Come On Eileen is a classic. Overall I think this one falls between Don't Stand Me Down and whatever the first one was called in my ranking, not quite a 4-star but more than a bare 3-star.
At the very least, I understand now why Dexys Midnight Runners were one-hit wonders: their albums were full of a bunch of bullshit
I mean yeah, the singer gets goofy with it as usual, but the mood the music sets is nothing but carefree and fun, so in the end it all comes together pretty nicely. Standouts: Let's Make This Precious • Old • Until I Believe In My Soul • Come On Eileen
Perfectly cromulent album. In a list that inexplicably has three Dexys Midnight Runners albums on it, this is the one that I think they should've picked. It's accessible, it has some nice string touches, but it's also too long. While it descends into noodling at the end it is a welcome break from the affected singing.
In a nutshell: The UK's guilty pleasure. Every nation has a handful of artists that are like Dexy's Midnight Runners. The artist and/or their music is a little weird, sometimes endearing. It has songs that are easy to sing along to. You get that distinct chuckle and a small smile when you hear their hit single somewhere. You might even feel embarrassed to admit liking them. It's fine for what it is. Overall: 4/10
Let's be real here. frfr, if you will. It has suck that you favourite band is condemned to be 'one hit wonders' by the masses. DMR are clearly more than that (I'm looking at you Deee-Lite) But three (3) entries on this list (before you die, you say?) is just silly. Do I really need to relitigate who isn't here?
Come on Eileen? I barely know her! Do the midnight runners deserve two entries on this list? Certainly not, but I’ll give them credit for being more than a one hit wonder, this album was a good time all the way through. I bet they were a blast to see live. Then would rock the shit out of the Starlite room in 1985, I can just picture Glenn Anderson doing coke in the bathroom between sets.
2.7 Just truly awful vocals, but for the songs that were available on spotify, fun enough listen
Look if you love “come on Eileen” this is the album for you. I will admit I liked this album more than I thought I would and “Jackie Wilson” is also another banger song. I mean going in to this I didn’t know much about the Dexy Midnight Runners except that when my aunt was a teenager she was obsessed with them and bought overalls for herself because of them, and you know what I can see why. I rank this as a 3.5/5
Come On Eileen is a certified classic, but I was pleasantly surprised that this whole album has the same vibe. Hooky as hell, lead singers voice is infectious, and you can feel the inspiration of Irish trad throughout. My mam was a big fan when I was growing up, and I can see why. Super enjoyable.
Probably fine live in a crowded bar for 20 minutes (where they play Come on Eileen three times over). But this is a slog
They definitely have a recognisable sound. Some fun songs but felt some were a bit samey!
Foot tapping fun.
Quite a fun album, but a little tedious