Listening to If I Should Fall from Grace with God by The Pogues is like being catapulted into the most riotous Irish pub you’ve never dared enter—only this time, you’re thrilled to be there. The music grabs you by the collar, shoves a whiskey in your hand, and dares you not to spill it. Every track is a perfectly chaotic blend of drunken revelry, heartfelt poetry, and the kind of energy that makes you feel like you could take on a rugby team in a bar fight and win. By the time “Fiesta” blared, I was clanging pots and pans in my kitchen like a deranged one-woman mariachi band. And don’t even get me started on “Fairytale of New York.” It’s a holiday song, but the kind of holiday where you burn the turkey, chug mulled wine, and cry over your ex before making up and singing carols together off-key. I don’t know if Shane MacGowan wants me to feel like a poetic brawler with a heart of gold, but that’s where I am. Let’s just say this album has me ready to down a Guinness, challenge a stranger to arm wrestling, and write them a heartfelt sonnet afterward. This isn’t just an album; it’s a lifestyle. So, if you’re not ready to fist-pump, dance like a lunatic, and maybe throw a chair (with love), then you’re not ready for The Pogues. But if you are—well, sláinte, my friend. This is your new anthem.

There were a couple of fun, bluesy, folksy songs at the beginning, but I lost interest after that.

It’s half-good. There is certainly some insane piano playing. If tattoos had been a thing back when I was in high-school, the cover graphic would probably be on my body somewhere. 2.5 stars.

Was very pleasantly surprised by this album. I kept pausing and repeating songs to catch a tighter grasp of the lyrics. It was fun, which was something I wasn’t expecting. His voice, though…

I was very surprised by this album. It has notes (haha) of a 60’s vibe that reminded me of the Hollies or the Byrds, yet it also felt very 80’s. My husband and I have totally different musical tastes and we both really enjoyed listening to this one

It was kind of all over the place, stylistically. There were two songs on the album that I did like.

Not my thing. BUT … I did find it useful as ambient noise while I was trying to finish a painting. I tried to pick a favorite out of the six songs that sounded exactly alike. Failed.

Loved listening to this album - especially with the LIVE component. It was a very good way to market JC as the outlaw.

I can’t ever listen to this again.

I hope I never hear another note from Motörhead.

This was fun to listen to. Inventive and unique. I especially loved the title, “Violently Happy”

It was fine. Nothing really stood out for me and it wasn’t the best of Pink Floyd albums, in my opinion.

Was very surprised by this album. It was peaceful, yet really fun to listen to. Expanded the party by listening to some of their other albums afterward.

I’ve heard this album 1001 times, so it is hard to review with an unbiased opinion. I love the drums. I am not a fan of Geddie Lee’s vocals, but am a HUGE fan of him as a person. That’s all I can say about that.

Enjoyed this introduction to Keith Jarrett. It was amazing to hear one instrument sound like many. I am not typically an improvisational-style jazz listener, but found this compelling.

Not for me. It may be great technique, but I really wouldn’t know.

I was looking forward to to hearing this, since the only other song I’ve ever heard from this band was … well, you know what it was. The album didn’t offer me anything new to consider.

I had forgotten about this group and it was fun to remember. Tennessee was the only song I recognized. I heard samples from Schoolhouse Rock and Salt and Pepa that surprised me. It was a fun album and I added a selection to my playlist, “Favorites from 1001 albums”

Listening to If I Should Fall from Grace with God by The Pogues is like being catapulted into the most riotous Irish pub you’ve never dared enter—only this time, you’re thrilled to be there. The music grabs you by the collar, shoves a whiskey in your hand, and dares you not to spill it. Every track is a perfectly chaotic blend of drunken revelry, heartfelt poetry, and the kind of energy that makes you feel like you could take on a rugby team in a bar fight and win. By the time “Fiesta” blared, I was clanging pots and pans in my kitchen like a deranged one-woman mariachi band. And don’t even get me started on “Fairytale of New York.” It’s a holiday song, but the kind of holiday where you burn the turkey, chug mulled wine, and cry over your ex before making up and singing carols together off-key. I don’t know if Shane MacGowan wants me to feel like a poetic brawler with a heart of gold, but that’s where I am. Let’s just say this album has me ready to down a Guinness, challenge a stranger to arm wrestling, and write them a heartfelt sonnet afterward. This isn’t just an album; it’s a lifestyle. So, if you’re not ready to fist-pump, dance like a lunatic, and maybe throw a chair (with love), then you’re not ready for The Pogues. But if you are—well, sláinte, my friend. This is your new anthem.

No. As much as I love the sixties sound, this seemed like a phone in. They were really missing David Crosby.

Brought back high school in a big way.

Iconic. Classic. Perfection. Could listen to this every day.

Jazz all sounds the same to me. Except Dave Brubek. I hope he’s on here.

Listened to this on the road on the way home from celebrating NYE out of town. Really enjoyable to listen to and I was surprised that all the songs had a unique feel to them. What a surprising find!

I didn’t remember that I had heard of them before. There were two songs that I recognized and they were the best on the album. Reminiscent of Green Day.

I love LED Zeppelin, so I was excited to listen to this album. However, when I took a closer listen to the lyrics, I was grossed out. Most of the songs felt as if they were just trying to lure 13 year old girls to their rock God hotel rooms. Disappointed. I wish it had been instrumental.

Boring

Had this album back in high school. It’s not my favorite Who album - would prefer the originals

I would listen to this album over and over. I love the sixties vibe. No standouts, but very enjoyable to listen to.

Forgettable