Messy and never perfect. The way blues based rock and roll should be. Aside from White Album, best double album in rock history

Early fall is hilarious in its shoddiness

Title track is brilliant. Bloated and fun

Give me things

Definitely better in as it should be beard mix

Never the great album people want it to be

Never consistent on albums, this was their weakest.

Taught me never to trust girls who suck beer thru straws

My Dylan resides here

Indie rock ain’t noise pollution

somehow overrated and underrated at same time. Classic

much better than it should be

Bleh mostly

Just a damn good rock album

Nah, it sits there and bores me. In a Silent Way blows it away

Pink Moon is too much for me albeit it is Great. So this is one for me

His finest

listen to AB or some other Great pressing. It deserves its praise

I never warmed to this. Last 3 are nothing to me

Side 4 is boring ballads. Some other duds. But this is 1990. Like it or not

first masterpiece

messy punk n wave. Their finest

I love this thing. Cocaine anger never came across so good

Sea breezes and the Bob are boring prog. Production is awful. Still squeezes out a brilliant first half and a great last 2

Docked because of last track

Can’t find a fault here

Like a prayer the song is a stunner. And all the other singles work great. But non singles including duet with Prince are mediocre to bad. Glad she tried though

Even album tracks are mostly great. Parklife aside. THIS IS BEST IN BRITPOP

Some is too simple (sugar spun sister) but the highs (I wanna be adored, I am the resurrection, this is the one) make this the classic it is

Like speaking to someone who is high but really is speaking truth. Just hard to get figure out where they are initially

It’s…good. Not for me I guess

Get behind me sucks. Most of the rest is great. Old man never left

Not the masterpiece it has the reputation as but still damn solid.

Incredibly flawed in the first half (long promised road aside). Second half hits all the depressing highs.

Return to this more than Closer. So it has to be their best for me

Messy and never perfect. The way blues based rock and roll should be. Aside from White Album, best double album in rock history

Sometimes funny, sometimes groovy, always nasty and mean (in a good way). Not going to return to it, but its reputation is valid. Funny enough, collabs with PE folk are weak tracks.

Has good elements to it. But it lacks the humor and melody of early 10cc, the popcrsft of Roxy Music, and the muscle of King Crimson. More Yes than those bands, not a positive for me

Have always liked this album. “Being Boring” and “Jealousy” make a nice bookend of slower songs. Yet it’s the faster paced songs “How Can You…” and “So Hard” that show more that PSB wit. The rest is ‘fine’ to mediocre though, and creates too much ennui. Prefer the album before (“Introspective”) and after (“Very”).

Positive: great sounding album. Creates a vibe like making an album late night on good substances with your buds Negative: at best pleasant, and at worst boring. not an album I would return to. If Crosby’s name wasn’t attached it would be a curio from the period with a small cult

Standard stuff. Couple of a good numbers but no better than most stuff you here in any bar in town

Solid soul album.