User Submitted Album
View Submitter's ProfileAlbum Summary
Blueberry Boat is the second album by American indie rock band The Fiery Furnaces. It was released on July 13, 2004, just over ten months following their debut album, Gallowsbird's Bark. Blueberry Boat polarized music critics due to its long, complex songs and esoteric lyrics.
Reviews
"The kind of album a theater kid corners you at a college party to talk to you about like it’s urgent" goes a one-star review. I can "objectively" understand why the person who dropped this scathing review would write such hilarious words. I just find it *even more hilarious* that it's the same person who selected Tally Hall's *Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum* for the users' list. I mean, have you ever thought of that paradox, dear anonymous reviewer? I think I have interacted with you before on the Discord server, so if ever you are reading this one day, please don't take it the wrong way. Sure, you can see what's obviously self-indulgent (and maybe even a little pretentious) in the "quirky" artistry of The Fiery Furnaces. And yet you can't see the same warts -- admittedly displayed in quite a different fashion -- in Tally Hall's music, which is filled to the brim with overtly chatty and perfunctory endeavors, and therefore feels even MORE rudderless and gratuitous for me. In France, we have a saying for that sort of situation: it's like warning someone they have straw in their eye when you have a big log sticking out from yours. But more power to you, of course. It is probably fitting that I use such a bizarre saying in a foreign language to defend *Blueberry Boat*. There are some things in that album harboring long songs displaying all sorts of various stylistic shelvings and jarring 180-degree turns that don't *translate* that well on a first listen. But there's one asset in the meanderings of *Blueberry Boat* that I will never find in the ones of *Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum*: *genuine* musical imagination, laced with a poetic power that owes as much to the lyrics as it owes to the notes and tones that are played. In my own eyes -- whether they are unencumbered or beset with very subjective "matter" sticking out from them -- this here points to a clear difference that makes *Blueberry Boat* a vastly superior work of art compared to Tally Hall's album. And even if you probably need quite some time to let the long and complex compositions of that Fiery Furnaces album sink into your soul, I can still sense that difference right away. The problem with Tally Hall's meanderings is that they're played and recorded in such a professional, "no-nonsense" fashion, they end up sounding flattened and devoid of real stakes. Nothing stands out in that record for me. In comparison, so many things can stand out and catch my ears in *Blueberry Boat*. *Too many things*, actually -- and not all of them are, quote-unquote, "pleasant". When Eleanor Friedberger's unrefined and amateurish vocals surge after the two-minute electronic introduction at the start of the ten-minute long "Quay Cur", for instance, the experience is disorienting for sure. But once you get your footing, you can be charmed by the surreal odyssey -- here using the metaphor of a sea voyage where you meet all sorts of oddly-named creatures harking back to Lewis Carroll to evoke an initiation into the hardships of young adulthood. Matthew Friedberger's vocals are a little more self-assured than the one of his sister, fortunately. And I ended up getting used to Eleanor's very expressive voice as well anyway. All in all, that first long track was a nice little adventure, just like the title-track and third cut was, as it picked up on that metaphor of a sea voyage to expand the cryptical universe of the band even further. Is listening to the start of this record a baffling experience? It sure is. Is it a *grating* listen, though? Absolutely not, not for me. The Fiery Furnaces were originally slotted in that early noughts retro-rock wave because of the tones found in their previous album and debut, or so I hear. But they obviously had so much more to offer than that! Which doesn't mean they fully gave up on the retro-rock tones for their second record. They just made those retro flourishes sound more interesting, and therefore managed to stand the test of time in ways few retro acts from the 2000s have. Just to take one example out of many other ones, by the time the shorter second song in the album, "Straight Street", surges to your ears, one point of reference becomes clear to make sense of the mess (here a blues-rock-meets-psychedelia-meets-ragtime (?) extravaganza which will surely puzzle every normie listener out there). That point of reference is The Velvet Underground, and more particularly two elements found in the seminal New York act's artistry: their abrasive guitar "drilling", and the idiosyncratic and "airy" contributions of Maureen Tucker to their music (both as a drummer and as a part-time vocalist). Those elements are prominent in "Paw Paw Tree" and "My Dog Was Lost And Now He's Found". The melancholic balladry of The VU can also be spotted in the enticing and mesmerizing ending of "Mason City", still punctured by wailing electric guitar bends. That cut is definitely a highlight within the tracklist. The cheap electronica tones also return once in a while. Case in point, the first seconds in each one of the couple of utterly bizarre songs "Chief Inspector Blancheflower" and "Spaniolated", which also oscillate between the twee intents of Belle And Sebastian, piano-laden novelty tones, and more psychedelic urges totally at odds with the rest. And the duo takes the melancholy a notch further towards the end of the record, with "1917", "Birdie Brown" and "Turning Round". When you reach the closer "Wolf Notes", it is undeniable that fatigue takes a toll on your listening abilities after so many twists and turns -- and "Wolf Notes" is certainly one of the weakest compositions in the tracklist, and definitely not the best choice to cap things off, which makes matters worse. There are other shortcomings like that which make listening to the overlong *Blueberry Boat* a difficult experience at times, I am not gonna deny it. When you factor all the warts in, it's hard to state this album could reasonably be labelled as an "essential listen" right away. But the one-album-a-day a thing will always do some disservice to that sort of project, because this can't be the sort of LP that you can fully understand with a couple of spins only. I always raise an eyebrow when people say there are experimental albums you need to listen to nine or ten times to fully understand them (you probably know which "legendary" album I am referring to here). But without going as far as using ten spins to "get it", I could see myself listening to *Blueberry Boat* again soon. Because there's still a mystery in it that sounds fascinating to me. Maybe that "theater kid" at the college party is right after all. Maybe he is himself taking part in a masterpiece this academic year -- one that will never be known outside of the ten people who will attend the show in that college town. And maybe in their old age, one of those ten people will remember that surreal kitchen-sink drama they saw as a university student, and keep on telling their grandkids about it -- the latter rolling their eyes in response before giving out the same gentle reply, again and again: "yes, grandpa / yes grandma... You *did* tell me what a wonderful show that *Blueberry Boat* adaptation was. Now please, let me have that slice of pie if you're not eating it...". Can we accept that the most personal and idiosyncratic forms of art out there may have value beyond the expected musical tropes? Can we agree that those sorts of list are also made to take you out of your comfort zone, once in a while? That's what The Fiery Furnaces (and the user who selected it) are attempting to do here. Whether they're *fully* successful or not, I am not sure yet. I hate *Trout Mask Replica*, as you probably understood from my innuendo in a previous paragraph -- I think that album left no recognizable musical legacy beyond the unwarranted hype it triggered, and that it's anything but a nice listen. Yet I am glad that it exists. I'm glad it's part of our culture. And it would be the same for me if *Blueberry Boat* reached the same cult status one day, no matter how deep into their rabbit hole I may fall in the near-future. Hence my very benevolent grade for this pick, as of now at least. 3.5/5 for the purposes of this list dedicated to essential albums, rounded up to 4. 8.5/10 for more general purposes (5 for the musicianship and production values + 3.5 for the artistry) ---- Number of albums from the original list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 466 Albums from the original list I *might* select for mine later on: 293 Albums from the original list I won't select for mine: 343 ---- Number of albums from the users list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 124 Albums from the users list I *might* select for mine later on: 143 (including this one) Albums from the users list I won't select for mine: 319
Really oddball sound that’s impressive for having been released 2004 and flown under the radar this long. Arty indie that threatened to get on my nerves at the start, but then ended up working it’s magic on me as it went on. Dunno exactly what clicked, but it won me over
What a delightfully playful album. So much weirdness that totally grabs me and feels like a treasure hunt. Standouts: Quay Cur (certainly sets the scene), Straight Street, Blueberry Boat (we have an awesome blueberry farm nearby and they're in season!), Paw Paw Tree, My Dog Was Lost But Now He's Found (I have a feeling it's not actually about a dog), Mason City, Chief Inspector Blancheflower, Birdie Brain.
Pretty cool
I don't get it
Extremely quirked-up millennial hipster bullshit. This album does a lot in its runtime and seemingly never sticks to one sound or style for very long. It's a lot to digest, especially over the course of 70 minutes, but I think the novelty of such an unhindered album makes it all the more memorable. Definitely one worth revisiting. CONTENDER FOR THE LIST: Probably not? Too niche too weird.
Kokeellisuus tavallaan kiintoisaa, mutta en tästä joikumisesta nyt innostunut.
I liked the start of many of the songs but when they all run 12 minutes, the initial blush of delight quickly fades. Why they all gotta be so long and drawn out?
I found this style of music quite jarring. It wasn’t a nice album to listen to, the aural equivalent of a dining experience rather than a nourishing meal.
Really cool album! I think I’ve seen this cover before but never knew the music behind it. Proggy in an original way. Will be listening more!
Rating: 6/10 Best songs: Quay car
I feel like this is one of those albums you kinda need like 10 listens to fully click with. I love me some fucky, kitchen-sink music, so this is absolutely up my alley. Even the backstory here ("album polarized critics due to its long, complex songs and esoteric lyrics") sounds almost exactly the same as my own suggestion, "Sing to God". I liked it, I didn't love it. Come back to me later and I'm gonna be bashing my head over the fact that I didn't give this a 5/5. For a second listen though, it's somewhere in the 3/5 territory for me. This is a major improvement though, because I remember fucking hating it the first time I heard it a year-or-so ago. Clearly we can mathematically see that I'm on track for this being a 13/5 for me in five years.
Long complex songs that were a little all over the place. But I kind of dig the weirdness. Not a regular thing to listen to but I’m not mad about it.
Blueberry Boat is the second album by indie rock band The Fiery Furnaces. It is much too long and the individual songs are too long. Several times I get the feeling a new track is started while it's still the same one. With all that said, I must admit despite these arguments several songs are really good. The psychedelic sound, the dynamic of male and female singers and all the instruments used, make it a pleasure to my ears anyway. At least give the first few songs (Quay Cur, Straight Street and Blueberry Boat) an honest try.
I'm not sure what this is but it played while I listened
The kind of album a theater kid corners you at a college party to talk to you about like it’s urgent
Definition of indie slop
I had to abandon this one halfway through. Is it impressive? Yes, I guess so, but impressive doesn't mean good or enjoyable to listen to. Way too cutesy-fartsy for me. 2 stars.
Na
I'm not wholly convinced this is anything, other than clever kids faffing around... lyrically it felt like I was being called upon to decode someone's highly personal lore dump, and feeling disinclined when I could as easily just treat it as sequences of words strung pleasantly but more or less meaninglessly together. I'll allow it kept me bopping though my workout, and I found myself jamming along with the music regularly. But inevitably not too long later the same music would be doing something seriously irritating. Really on the fence on this one. I might check out some downstream product to see how this wierd thing developed.
Interesting choice. I saw them earlier this year live and I've met Eleanor Friedberger a few times. I think this is a bit too far down the indie rabbit hole. plus it's way too long. I like the band and find it too experimental for them. An attempt that i appreciate they tried but it didn't work. My personal rating: 3/5 My rating relative to the list: 3.5/5 Should this have been included on the original list? No.
All over the place. There are definitely some enjoyable moments buried in here, but the constant changes in style and direction made the whole thing feel pretentious and like it had outstayed its welcome. By the end, I felt like listening to the album was more effort than it was worth.
I found it quite enjoyable. I'll definitely keep listening. Favorite Track: Quay Cur 3.5 / 5
Indie rock, progressive rock, experimental rock, art rock. Rollo y largo. Un 2.
What a mess, The Furnaces shot for the moon on this one and came up incredibly short. While I can’t deny the artistic bravado of the kitchen sink approach, none of the many elements the band throws at the wall work with one another. Every musical idea steps on the toes of another, creating a crowded, discordant listen where nothing makes much sense. Add in perhaps some of the worst lyrical songwriting I’ve heard yet on the list and you’re in for an arduous listening experience. It was disappointing to hear some actually fun melodic ideas buried underneath more bad decisions, though their presence may be more of a stopped clock situation to begin with. Definitely a unique add in context of the user list, but for all the wrong reasons.
This is why I stick with these lists. Something I knew nothing about that turned out to be interesting. I don’t even know how to go about reviewing other than to say I’ve added them as a follow on Spotify so I can come back to explore them a bit more.
Not enjoyed as much as the EP collection, but a joyfully difficult, odd duck of an album which retains a ton of heart in spite of the obtuseness.
This is very weird music. I don't hate it, but it does need some kind of mindset to keep listening. Most song are also a little bit too long. 3m
It's a bit like watching a very long, drawn-out train wreck. It certainly does not lack originality or variation, if anything it should have stayed more consistent within many of the songs. When it comes to the vocals, they're not great, and kind of cringey in how theatrical they often sound. The lyrics are also straight nonsense for like the vast majority of what they're saying. 3/10
Ambitious, aural chaos with absolutely no interest in making things easy for the listener. A very challenging listen. I suspect you either get it and love it, or you simply don't. I found it exhausting and infuriating. I've heard worse, though. Perhaps I'm just an uncultured swine.