Crack the Skye by Mastodon

Crack the Skye

Mastodon

2009
3.09
Rating
53
Votes
1
9%
2
19%
3
38%
4
21%
5
13%
Distribution
User Submitted Album

Album Summary

Crack the Skye is the fourth studio album by American heavy metal band Mastodon, released on March 24, 2009, through Reprise, Sire and Relapse Records. The album debuted at number 11 on the Billboard 200, selling 41,000 copies in its first week. In Australia, the album debuted at number 19. It had sold 200,000 copies in the US as of September 2010, making it one of their highest-selling albums to date. According to an interview on the DVD The Making of Crack the Skye, the album represents the element of aether, which is represented by the souls and spirits of all things, a theme closely related to the context of the album. Because the elements of fire, water and earth have already been represented by the band's first three albums Remission, Leviathan, Blood Mountain and the band's seventh album Emperor of Sand, respectively, the element of air is the only classical element which has yet to be represented by a Mastodon album, as their follow-up studio albums The Hunter and Once More 'Round the Sun do not represent an element, nor are they concept albums. Crack the Skye is the first studio album to feature drummer Brann Dailor as the band's third lead vocalist.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Reviews

Sort by: Top Date
Filter by rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Dec 08 2025 Author
5
The masters of unconventional rhytms and melody changes
Dec 11 2025 Author
5
This is much rockier and less metal than I expected, but in the best way. Dreamy but loud and intense. Mastodon pushed technical boundaries on earlier albums; here they're all about mystery, depth, emotion, and atmosphere. "Quintessence" opens epically and shifts into progressive grooves with vocals that elevate everything. "The Czar" reminds me of Opeth. "The Last Baron" goes off at 13 minutes and earns every second. "Oblivion" and "The Ghost of Karelia" also stand out. The production is thick and full. Every layer is audible, which makes for an incredible listening experience, but also a tiring one. It demands your full attention in a way that's both a strength and a limitation. I might not always reach for this even though I have starting to really love this album, simply because it's so dense and exhausting. The vocals took some getting used to as well. Multiple singers, none technically great, plus guest vocals. But it all works perfectly for the vibe. Way better than I expected. A killer album that rewards the effort it demands. 4,5*
Dec 16 2025 Author
4
Mammoth
Dec 17 2025 Author
4
Rating: 7/10 Best songs: Oblivion, The czar, The last baron
Dec 18 2025 Author
4
I've heard a bit of Mastodon before, and it was good but never something I've really loved. This album was surprisingly good, I've never heard anything from it, but I like it a lot. A good solid drone, and a lot of Ozzy baked in. Still not something I'd want to hear every day, but a good addition to the list and to my library.
Dec 22 2025 Author
4
This fourth album of Mastodon is less aggressive, prog and sludge than earlier work. I like this evolution and compared to for example Blood Mountain this album sounds more original, fresher and energetic. Though it's not exactly my cup of tea, it's certainly enjoyable and a good album within the progressive metal genre with a great production and good musicians.
Dec 08 2025 Author
3
Not totally my kind of music, but considering I do not follow the progressive metal scene and even I know who Mastodon is tells me all I really need to know. That, or I've played too many fan charts for Guitar Hero.
Dec 09 2025 Author
3
Solid metal LP, vocals felt a bit unsuited for the instrumentals at times but I enjoyed a heavier addition to the list.
Dec 12 2025 Author
3
Found this more enjoyable than I expected. I kind of wish it were more metal though. Sort of a cousin to TOOL or Metallica.
Dec 12 2025 Author
3
Apple Music said it was metal but okay idk
Dec 15 2025 Author
3
Pretty kick ass
Dec 16 2025 Author
3
moar Moeritherium
Dec 18 2025 Author
3
Not really my thing but seems decently performed.
Dec 20 2025 Author
3
Solid metal/heavy rock album
Dec 28 2025 Author
3
Aware of this band but never listened to much, metal being a niche genre in my usual rotations. Solid fairly traditional metal, well done.
Dec 31 2025 Author
3
I was put on mastodon by my friend who is a huge metal/djent/prog guy and basically told me mastodon was simpler metal music. Yeah that may just be why I enjoy this album a good bit. Mastodons early work is some solid stuff. They are hardcore and technical without going to the extreme that some metal becomes hard to listen to. This album starts great and then levels off a bit but it remains pretty solid. Nice choice. 7.4/10
Dec 09 2025 Author
2
I’m not into this kind of heavy rock so this album is not for me.
Jan 05 2026 Author
2
Det är för mycket metal på den här listan. Jag gillar inte metal.