User Submitted Album
View Submitter's ProfileAlbum Summary
You Forgot It in People is the second studio album by Canadian indie rock band Broken Social Scene, released on October 15, 2002. It was the band's commercial breakthrough. You Forgot It in People features intricate, experimental production techniques and a large number of instruments coinciding with the band's vastly expanded size. Local excitement for the album was so big that initial pressings sold out quickly, necessitating a 2003 reissue. Music videos were made for "Stars and Sons," "Cause = Time," "Almost Crimes (Radio Kills Remix)," "Lover's Spit," and "I'm Still Your Fag." The songs that did not make it onto the album were featured in a B-sides compilation entitled Bee Hives, released in 2004.
Reviews
Probably a 4.5, but very personally special & marks a really key period in my life which bumps it up to a 5.
I love the amount of aughts era indie people have been adding to this list. This is another tentpole release from that period with a lot of the big players featured on it. It's really gorgeous and lush.
Now that's the Broken Social Scene album that's worthy of this list -- far more than that later eponymous LP suggested by another user before. Both in terms of contents and impact on indie-rock fans, *You Forgot It In People* slaps. There are so many highlights on this breakout album, and they are as effective as they are endearing: "KC Accidental" and its obsessive interruptions, before aiming to the sky again ; "Star and Sons" and its infectious bassline ; the messy "Almost Crimes", laced with angular guitars, ominous bass drops, crazed-out background vocals an an unhinged saxophone ; the pretty yet also slightly off-kilter "Looks Like The Sun", graced with subliminal latin-american inflexions ; "Anthems For A Seventeen Year Old Girl", a weird-as-f*ck cut at first, with its heavily processed vocals and "backwards guitar" sounding like a banjo, then developing into a strings-laden wonder ; the epic centerpiece "Because = Time" growing into a towering and cinematic platonic ideal of an indie-rock song ; and towards the end of the tracklist, "Lover's Spit" and "I'm Still Your Fag" are two fantastic ballads -- the first just as expansive and iconic-sounding as the second feels unobtrusive, discreet and even restrained. Those two songs, placed just before the short instrumental closer whose strings pick up the main theme of "Anthems For A 17-year Old Girl", are not merely tender, heartfelt and moving. They are also cool as f*ck. Most of the rest of the tracklist explores atmospheric post-rock turf that will feel less striking on a first listen, but it's the sort of adventurous post-rock only Canadian wizards can come up with. So many different tones in this record, so many different touches... Yet they are all refracted into a wonderful whole that feels so tight, while always remaining playful and evocative at the same time. Thank you for adding this, whoever you are. I often "forget it in people", but there are still so many of them able to sort out the wheat from the chaff. Glad that they are using this generator as well. 4.5/5 for the purposes of this list dedicated to essential albums, rounded up to 5 9.5/10 for more general purposes (5 for the musicianship and production values + 4.5 for the artistry) ---- Number of albums from the original list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 466 Albums from the original list I *might* select for mine later on: 293 Albums from the original list I won't select for mine: 343 ---- Number of albums from the users list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 127 (including this one) Albums from the users list I *might* select for mine later on: 147 Albums from the users list I won't select for mine: 335
This really felt ambitious and refreshing. Needs a relisten.
KC Accidental // Almost Crimes // Pacific Theme // Shampoo Suicide //
Meh. Wasn't terrible but also wasn't a valuable listen.
One of my faves
Aika hyvä nollari-indie. Kolmosen ja nelosen välillä seilataan.
It was ok I guess, but nothing that made me sit up and listen.
Will definitely listen again. Very well put together.
Yeah, not bad
Not bad
It was ok
This is probablu pretty good, but I don't think this band is for me 3 Also Broken ocial scene -yu frgt it in popl saoooee
This is the best indie album I've had on wither list so far. I actually enjoyed this one and I may listen again. It was really refreshing to finally understand what this genre is capable of providing.
Sounds like about half the country was involved at some point - a dazzling range of voices and instruments. Pleasant enough musically, perhaps lyrically lacking a little.
Above Average. Heard it a few times 3.5
This is incredible indie rock. It's in the sweet spot of being slightly less sad than Bon Iver, but still in the same radius.
Alright, here’s the album. Their self-titled album has also been submitted, but this I think is the the more essential entry in their discography. Just an excellent showcase of indie, crossing with post-rock, expansive and lively. Really like it
I didn't enjoy You Forgot It In People much, it's still indie at heart even if they do some weird stuff over the top if it, and at no point did it really stand out and grab me. Anthems For A Seventeen Year-Old Girl was good, the rest pretty middling, and ultimately circles back to a pretty dull set of indie foundations. 2.
Heard of BSS before but never listened to them. I enjoyed this a lot; wasn't at all what I expected. Definitely will listen again.
Stream of consciousness review time. Aware of the name but never listened. First two tracks are interesting, more pieces than songs. Almost Crimes is great. I enjoy the guitars being low in the mix, feels more of a blended sound. The anthem for 17 year old girls I can't decide if I liked or not as was slightly annoying by the end, Cause=Time feels more solid ground, breezy. Shampoo Suicide was also lovely, no idea what the lyrics are to this as the vocals are almost inaudible in the mix. Looks like I have already liked Lover's Spit and indeed that is OK. This feels like something I should revisit. I listen to a lot of different music so whether I'll return remains to be seen. Thanks for the listen though.
Wow this was an elaborate, very interesting album - I almost felt like I was listening to classical pieces at times yet it all feels very modern. Repeated listens will yield new discoveries!
Really loved this a lot more than I thought I would.
I don't really get Broken Social Scene tbh. This feels like something I should eat up hook, line, and sinker, but it never registers as anything more than "Pretty good indie rock". So.. this was some pretty good indie rock. Better than the other album by them that was on here.
Better than average indie/alternate rock, though generally I thought it was pretty middle of the road for the genre and not quite up to the mostly glowing reviews.
Every time I see their band name I brace for something whiny, and every time I actually listen I get pretty decent post-rock. I didn't care for their other one on here, but I liked this one quite a bit.
This is right up my street- it's got a lot of different bits that makes it a puzzle. Worth relistening.
Nice
Good stuff, very interesting. 4 stars.
A BSS effort that still feels like an enigma to me for how many times I've listened. Compared to the unfettered optimism of their preceding S/T record, 'People' is tinged with a more mature outlook that at times almost borders on cynicism. It's this slight bitterness that makes this LP feel so distinct from its successor despite sharing in the same instrumental tapestry, the sprawling tracks filled with jaded corners and emotional pitfalls. Just feels so much more dimensional than S/T (which is saying something, given how rich and lively that album is on its own), the emotional push-and-pull more satisfying across a full listen. 'Time=Cause' is my fav BSS track by far, but nearly every song here reaches some incredible heights. Incredible album, amazing band, great add to the user list all in all.
It wasn't bad, just generic indie rock that went a bit maudlin by the end. I liked some bits more than others. Three stars.
It's fine. My personal rating: 3/5 My rating relative to the list: 3/5 Should this have been included on the original list? No.
Huh. I'd never heard this band before. Only of them. This was okay. A little bit time wasting? But good generally.
"You Forgot It In People" is the second album by indie/post rock band Broken Social Scene. On this album the band parts with the more tradional rock that was on their debut album ("Feel Good Lost"). This album is well produced and strange song structures are kept within reasonable bounds. Personally I prefer their third, eponymous album ("Broken Social Scene"). "Anthems for a Seventeen Year-Old Girl", "Almost Crimes (Radio Kills Remix)" and "Cause = Time" are the best tracks, but the rest is excellent too.
I love the work of some of the artists that come together to form Broken Social Scene, especially Emily Haines and Metric. But BSS wavers too much between overlapping excess and barely-restrained brilliance. "Cause=Time" has gotta be a top 10 Canadian indie rock song, but the rest of "You Forgot It In People" is too scattered and never achieves those heights anywhere else. It's pretty cool though that Kevin Drew, Emily Haines, and Amy Millan all went to high school together.
Rating: 7/10 Best songs: Almost crimes, Shampoo suicide
Wait this is actually good?!
One of the greatest albums of its time of its genre.
Nice album for your late teens
That teenage girl song rules but otherwise I just kinda don’t get this band no matter how many of their albums you force on me.
One of the great 00’s indie albums already in my frequent rotation.
Indie rock. Rollo. Un 2.