Now I love this album. I've seen the show 3 times and I really like Anais Mitchell. However, I can imagine this is hard to enjoy without context. But overall, I first heard this in 2011 way before the broadway version was done and I loved it. The music is so good, great story telling, great vocals. Big fan of Anais Mitchell.

I really hated this. The vocal effects were so annoying. The songs were so earnest and trying to sound epic but it's just reeks of garage band presets to me.

Great album, I love it. Favourite song is Depreston, it really gets me going that one.

I liked this, it was pretty cool and reminded me of bits of other artists.

I really hated this. The vocal effects were so annoying. The songs were so earnest and trying to sound epic but it's just reeks of garage band presets to me.

No thanks you. This was like all rock bands smushed together to make some incredibly bland.

I enjoyed this, it was varied and interesting. Can't say I'd listen over and over but definitely fun.

Didn't mind this. It was varied enough and some good lyrics but a bit too much mum music

A beautiful album, I love it. I love how it's clearly Big Thief style but they really tried some newer experimental stuff and sounds in this one. Great choice.

Thank you, I hated that so much. Now and again it would do something that sounded like it had the potential to be good. Frog on the floor was okay and did some okay bits. I got my tooth removed felt a bit ska and fun but the vocals were so grating. Whole thing sounded like an A-level students just getting drunk on effects and trying whatever the hell they like.

Great album, I love it. Favourite song is Depreston, it really gets me going that one.

This was okay. The vocals annoy me but I guess it's just not my thing, doesn't mean it's bad. Overall it all sounded fairly the same.

I didn't hate this. I nearly did, but I found some of the music was really good. Didn't really mix with the lyrics but generally it was interesting.

This album is such a belter. It's so catchy and imaginative, really love it.

I found this all a bit meh. I hated the album cover, but that's by the by, it was generally just a bit flat for me, but I also couldn't really find a reason to dislike it either.

I really liked this.

This was great fun. Not sure I'd listen to it again but I can imagine seeing this band at a festival and absolutely loving it.

I didn't really hate this but it was quite all over the place, didn't really know what to make of it.

I liked this, it was pretty cool and reminded me of bits of other artists.

I can't say I hated this but I just found it quite boring.

Now I love this album. I've seen the show 3 times and I really like Anais Mitchell. However, I can imagine this is hard to enjoy without context. But overall, I first heard this in 2011 way before the broadway version was done and I loved it. The music is so good, great story telling, great vocals. Big fan of Anais Mitchell.

I liked this a lot. Great fun!!

Well I absolutely love this album. Listening to this album as a kid lead to some many bands that I love. Sublime were such a great starting point for me getting into ska and punk etc. This album has some absolute classic bangers but also some great deeper cuts. There are so so many bands that I love that were influenced by Sublime.

This was fine, a bit repetitive but good background music.

Ermm, I know Primus but I find them hard to enjoy. It's neither side of the comedy/serious side for me to understand if I'm honest.

I really liked this. Good old rock 'n' roll but didn't felt cliche.

This was quite fun, I enjoyed listening to it sure but I can't imagine I'd go back to it

This was nice but I got a bit bored.

This is a banger, a real soundscape, I loved it.

I really enjoyed this. This would be absolute perfect late night festival party vibes, real good.

I generally say I like the Decemberists but I definitely don't love that. I felt this album was a bit all over the place. It has some fantastic bits but it wasn't cohesive enough for me

I really enjoyed this. Good fun. It did sound a little simple in places and it reminded me of what the kind of thing everyone starts making when they Garageband or Ableton but it was cool.

Ermmm, this was okay. It was quite varied and interesting but I can't say it was that good.

I absolutely adore this album. It was a proper formative album for me. I was massively into this as a teenager and I still love it. I do think it holds up really well. Streetlight are a very good group of musicians, they make ska punk but with proper musical style. The basslines are so good, the music changes rhythm all the time, lyrics are fantastic. It feels a shame to me that they can get banded together with Less Than Jake and Reel Big Fish (who I do also love), but they are completely different.

I bloody love this album. In fact, I was wearing my Martha tshirt whilst listening. I don't know what it is about Martha but they really get me going. I think their lyrics and style just fit my demographic perfectly. It's that style of grown up po-p-punk, emo indie and taking that same style and feeling but it's grown up with the audience,

I'm really that big a fan of Bon Iver. I can see why this is good though, it's very imaginative and varied and what not. But for some reason it doesn't click with me. Also I've always found the song names really up themselves, get a grip.

Okay that was surprisingly good. It wasn't all brilliant but it was pretty good. It felt very Kylie or Sophie Ellis Bextor. I imagine that's the kind of thing they were trying to get on board with at the end. I especially enjoyed the lyric 'I'm going to stand the test of time'. Sorry Rachel, you didn't, unless you meant appearing on this challenge.

This is a banger of an album, really takes me back.

This was okay. It was quite forgettable. He sounds like Michael Stipe.

People bloody love Death Cab for Cutie. I understand why but I just found this quite wet. It was all very similar too. But it didn't annoy me.

This was cool. I really liked the blues tracks, they were great

Oh yes one of my favourite albums. Absolute banger in my opinion, really atmosphere, great lyrics, lovely sounds, banging.

This was eye-wateringly bad. Complete dross. Terrible lyrics, horrible sounds. I guess the only redeemable thing was his voice isn't bad. This is 80s landfill music and deserves to stay on the landfill in my opinion.