American Girl and Fooled Again favourites! Really cool straight-up American rock music.
Cry Baby is an obvious classic and this has my favourite JJ track on it, Me and Bobby Mc-Gee!
Some really beautiful songs on here, and Murder Mystery is just so ahead of its time!
Ball and Chain is excellent and everything about this is great!
One of the best album's I've ever heard in terms of pure song-writing. Faves are Father & Son, and Wild World, because I'm basic as fuck :)
Definitely got a bit samey but the harmonies were great and the songs were fun!
I hadn't listened to much later era Cohen and the way his voice matured and gained grit was just fantastic! Not a million miles away from Tom Waits/Iggy's radio voice
Insane that Meg’s drumming catches so much flack when this album is mixed the way it is and has Jack White all over it
I loved this more than I could have imagined! Very specific highlight was that crazily panned drum fill on Se a Cabó
A couple of harmonic choices which felt a little too jazzy for the context, but so many amazing songs on here! Highlights: Boogie On Reggae Woman and that weird noise in Bird of Beauty
This has every different kind of rock on it! Punk, psych, & roll, blues! Great fun.
I have no frame of reference for this music!
I first heard this on a slate video and now it’s one of my favourite jazz records
If the sax solo in Jungleland could be another 45 minutes please that would be great!
I'm maybe not enough of a lyrics guy to appreciate this, but the songs are well written and the harmonies are nice :)
The second half of this might be my favourite thing of Bowie's I've ever heard?
Loved this, reminds me of the folksy bits of Pink Floyd
Feeling like an angry teenage fuelled my journey to work
This is a protest rating, the album is fine but I would like Frank Ocean to be able to put Nostalgia ULTRA on streaming services and for the HHGTTG vinyl to be able to use the actual theme song not that shite Tomita-sounding (in a bad way) midi version
Forgettable, over produced, I will never think about this record again as long as I live
Still yet to be convinced of a double album’s length, but if this was edited down a fair bit it would be great!
Incredible to know that his voice could manage a whole set like that with no loss of tone! Favourite - Bring It On Home To Me
I guess I like country music now! Johnny Cash is so funny, charming and charismatic here in both song and talk, what a delight.
Favourites - title track, Orange Blossom Special, and Give My Love To Rose
i think i just don't like REM
Karma Chameleon: The Album feat. A Bunch of Worse Songs
I love Britpop, I love Robbie, I will watch the monkey film
This isn't really my thing and I'll probably never listen to the album all the way through but there's something here I can't quite put my finger on that's really good? Like I don't know if the acoustic approach is what puts me off and I'd love these songs played by The Adolescents or something? A 3, but a weak one.
This guy’s really in love and pretty sad about it
A lot of potential and I'm glad, given the band's origins, to find out they're still going, although this very much has a first album feel
Worth it if only for Freebird
Perfectly okay first album with little hints at the variety they'd come to write later on, but more interesting as a time capsule/prequel type situation that as the sort of essential Strokes contempories the music pressed seemed to position the band as at this time. 2.5*.
Yo, what if hiphop was, like, fun?? Is that anything??
If this was the only album they released that year it would still have been an achievement
lounge country isn’t a genre I know for sure exists, but I like it if it does!
I really hate the new wave vocal style but the sounds and melodies had some cool moments here
This one's really hard. So many of these are stone cold bangers but every track on here INCLUDING those are mired in some of the most dated production and vocal delivery I've heard in a long time. If you're into that, fine, and this is a decent historical document, but I won't be coming back to most of this unless someone puts it on at a party in which case I will go absolutely crazy. 3*
This is the first 'proper' Elvis album I've listened to and it's the closest I feel like I've come to getting it. If I'm right in my understanding this represented a change of approach for him, and it definitely works - having his vocals (excellent) atop these cool soulful instrumentals is a really refreshing take on what I view as the classic Elvis sound and it was a great listen!
Lol I wrote an essay about this in uni
It's so crass and gross but pulls it off?
Frustrating amounts of variety here and there but too often he resorts to what sounds like a sampled drum loops over lazy guitar and it's only fun so many times
Lots of fun, silly, catchy tunes, but the style can get a bit grating after a while
This album absolutely fucken rips
I like a couple of the singles but otherwise this is just not my cup of tea
I like a few of the talking heads songs but this doesn't have any of those on it
The more racist Rod Stewart is revealed to be, the less surprising it is that his music is trying this desperately hard to be american
The Weatherman is great fun, and I'm a sucker for some lap steel
the sax on this album absolutely FUCKS
Bowie is doing everything he can and I'm loving it
++ little surprise beatles cover
Sometimes an album just needs to be fun!
The production aesthetic of this doesn't use sounds I like and I'm not a lyrics listener unless I love a record, so while I'm sure this is good it isn't really for me.
I like metal and listen to plenty of it so it’s not a genre thing, this is just so boring
Me: (not being able to under stand a single lyrics) Hell yeah, brother
I'll confess that Fairytale of New York was all I had previously heard but consider this my minting as a new Pogues fan!
Overrated but not like "bad". Just keep doing the freak outs, not trying to force those parts and actual songs together?
Nice mix of garage styles, remains cohesive and varied in a way few producer-led albums manage to by bringing in consistent guest vocalists
Great singles and great cover art, 3.5*
Wow! Britpop Ween! What an absolute treat! 4.5*!
Not a patch on Electric Ladyland, but still fine- Hendrix is remembered as one of the best guitarists of all time for a reason!
This is viewed as one of jazz's all-time greats for a reason!
How was this their first album? Such a complete sound, so many bangers, what a treat.
often i think double albums could be markedly improved by cutting out the rubbish tracks to just leave the really good stuff, but this album is just all kind of okay
I think I only like old depressed Cohen
What's Golden is an all-timer, and the bars and beats on the rest of this are good fun
There's a lot of "cool" on this album that doesn't entirely make up for some of the clashes in sound, or the fact that a lot of this sounds like one track played through over and over
This just feels like a very typical example of the sort of rock music that the US was making at the time. Good, but as is often the case I just don't see why it's on this list as one of the greats. 3.5*
I'm really not sure when some of the entries here were considered, because while I can imagine this could have sounded pretty vital in 1993 I just don't get that listening for the first time 32 years later.
This album needs to exist to leapfrog Bowie from his latter-era floundering to the jewel in the crown that is Blackstar, and for that I am glad it exists, but I'll probably not listen to it again
Cool funk bits, nice psychey sections, and a thirteen minute jam? What's not to like?
Funkier, more alt-rock sounding Minutemen? I mean, yeah, it's not Double Nickels On The Dime, but this is more than worth a listen! Strong 3.5*
I just love the vibe of a Willie Nelson album
A few good songs and quite a few less good ones, all totally dominated by horrible 80's drum mixes. Purple Rain is a brilliant song, but that doesn't save this.
I've tried so hard to "get" this album, I even made a video essay about it, but even though I know each and every point in this thing's favour, something about it doesn't ever quite click for me, a defeated 3*
This is hard bop... that bops!
Horrid vocals, repetitive songs, just bad.
We need to stop pretending and just admit this is a psychedelic rock album
This was absolutely not what I was expecting but what a nice surprise! I was expecting very much 00's NY scene indie rock but TVOTR must have been some of the most inventive to come out of that whole time
Like most of the Stones' output, this is pretty good, yeah, 3.5*
When Queen are good they're great, and when they're bad they're total shit, 2.5*
A lot of this is good, but a chunk of it is just kinda 'fine', 3*5
One of my favourite discoveries of this process so far, almost like prog Refused? The two long songs are my favourite and I'll definitely be returning to this one! 4.5*
Everyone has heard and enjoyed songs from this album. The new sounds created for it are still in use today!
Good but I'm not seeing the same thing that people who label this a classic are, low 3.5*
Stairway is great and everyone needs to accept that, despite that some of this album is meandering and directionless, 3.5*
This is so much cooler than I was expecting! New wave without having that dreadful plastic sound which so came to represent the genre. 4*
Elton John's career has maybe now been long enough that his discography is seen a a monolith - not something where people speak about albums, but just "what he's done", generally, or individual songs. Well, Mr John, I had underestimated you, this album is great and so much more that the handful of signal for which I know Elton John, especially for what is actually one of the more justified double albums I've heard!
This is waaaaay too front heavy but even with that being the case, the a-side is fantastic and the second side is competent... 3*
I never realised how much S and the B's have been getting ripped off these days!
I feel like this rewards deep and background listening. Really well written, played, and recorded music, that is also great just for vibes.
More albums where the first half is songs and the second half is ambient, please!
The slightly heavier, more angular sounding tunes on here are great - 4st 7lb through to The Intense Humming of Evil, mainly - but they make me wish the rest of the record had the same grit. 3.5*
Billy Corgan's voice only suits the heavy stuff on this and those are the songs I like least. The songs I like most are ruined by his totally out of place vocals.
Hey, I found something to say about this beyond the fact that it's too long, nice!
The songs I know are good, the versions of others are often terrible, and the less well known stuff is a waste of time
Tricky. I don't want to say all these songs sound the same, because they don't. What the DO sound like is a lot of songs played by the same people in a genre with some pretty distinct sonic traits, by which I mean that any saminess might well have been alleviated if there wasn't just so much of this album. With that being said, 3*
Forgettable until that awful closing track
Turns out I actually did listen to this and forgot to log it on here! RYM tells me I gave it 4*!
This is brilliant only in how forgettable and inoffensive it manages to be. If you want some music that sounds like it's in the background of a schmaltzy scene in a 90's romcom this is for you but otherwise I learnt Everybody Hurts in guitar around '09 and if my relationship with this album had ended there I don't know that I would mind. 2.5*
I actually liked this a lot more than I was expecting! At it's best when there's minimal distortion and melodies can come to the fore, but with some really nice big-sounding production too! Strong 3.5*
There are flashes of real brilliance here but they don't quite make up for the rest of the runtime which veers wildly between uninspired and borderline offensive. A light 2.5*
This was absolutely excellent! I'd never heard the full version of 'Rolling Stone from these guys before!
The worst aspects of Talking Heads, Primal Scream, and the very 80's as-yet unrealised potential of the synthesiser.
Having listened to, I think, synchronicity (not sure on spelling or if that's just a song) and having found said listening experience a bit whack, this was a nice surprise! Lots of good songs! Strong 3.5*!
Good, but I'm not really getting the hype as one of the best live albums of all time?
Any band who rhymes Picasso with asshole is alright by me, but I can't help feel the producer on this album who isn't John Cale should have wasted less time trying to emulate him.
Very nice surprise! Turns out when they stop banging on about the beach and lean into arrangement techniques beyond vocal harmonies that the Beach Boys have go some serious chops! High 4.5
Yeah it’s probably nostalgia but I love this album. The only really overlong anniversary reissue where I don’t mind the extra fluff
People who don’t like Moby just aren’t comfortable with sincerity
There are a couple of moments in the back half of this, but even those (Sad Song, I'm looking at you) go on waaaaay too long. Two stars and Lou can thank me for them.
High highs and low, forgettable lows. 2.5*
I read a bunch of reviews that said the long sections that lead into the actual structured bits of the songs are annoying when those are obviously the best bit
This is one of those albums that calls the whole list in to question not for being bad, but for being just ok-ish
"Other Assorted Love Songs" really makes the other 13 tracks on here sounds as identical and unnecessary as they are - thanks for the head's up, Eric! 2.5*
Common’s lyrics are great but I think this album is really made by Kanye’s (and occasionally Dilla’s) production. Incredible tunes back to back, 4.5*
I think this loses 1.5 stars because of the back half because after satellite of love this just doesn't do anything for me
I am still yet to hear a double album that wouldn't be improved by being a single disc. 4*
Tight enough in its lyrics focus that this ALMOST feels like an early concept album? I liked a lot of these, and although it can get a bit one-note you've got to remember the time it was made! strong 3.5*
so this is good but it went on forever (writing this not including the japanese bonus track) and doesn't feel quite as focussed and vital as the earlier work. Light 3.5*
This album has a lot of totally fine songs but that's all most of them are. Yeah, there are a couple of greats on there, but it just isn't consistent enough for me to think it's a classic to the extent many people seem to. 3*
The back half suffers a little from three Meat Puppets songs in a row, but beyond that this is complete and utterly fantastic. (I want to say Dumb isn't great, but plenty of people love it so?) 4* but like, almost a 4.5*?
There's a really nice four track run in the middle of this (The Walk - This Is The House) and I like the last one. There's some cool sound selection here too but it still comes to an even 3*
Remember after Blond dropped when everyone was trying to be Frank Ocean?
An early career, undeveloped Miles Davis + bad recording + a collection of singles retrofitted into an album = an interesting curio and document of this period of his career, but ultimately barely a footnote. 2.5*
Annoying 2*, here, because there are little flashes of cool here. Reservations, and that american flag on were pretty cool, but that's the only replayability here, for me.
Some classics but that's all very much confined to the first half, after which point this loses steam a bit. 3.5*
this one's complicated, i've got a big mix of nosalgia, sustained love for trent reznor's production, dislike of camp, and a bit of cringe at my former self who would have loved these bad, bad, BAD lyrics. still, the singles are great and a couple of the album tracks surprised me! 3*
I've heard Back to Black and I think I expected more from this on that basis? Nice production, but definitely something produced a little while before her peak. 3*
You Shook Me has been my favourite blues-adjacent number for years now, an easy 4*
Listened to this a while back and it's a good document but the recording is a bit naff, and I just don't really "get" the whole TL thing. 2.5*
This is very good fun indeed!
Lazy sounding vocals, weak production, dull songwriting, this album has it all! 1.5*
RIP OZZY!
Really impressive album where the band, now well established, got an opportunity to show off that there was more to Black Sabbath than doom
There's more than a bit of Moon Safari hiding in this production, and with some excellent vocals on top this was just what I needed! 4*
This sounds in all ways like a parody record of what is wrong with this sort of music. Too long, horrible sounding synths, painful vocals. The one redeeming feature of Prince as an artist is his guitar playing and that's almost totally missing here. A touch listen. 1.5*
Especially now it's easy to forget that Green Day used to be a punk band, but it sure was fun when they were!
paul was clearly the pop songwriter in the beatles 4*
I'm gonna have the refrain from both title tracks stuck in my head forever and that's no bad thing! 4.5*
The skits on this need more appreciation they're fucking hilarious 4*
When are we going to admin that Gimme Shelter is just ok?
My head was nodding this entire time! Lots of fun samples to recognise, nice beats, and cool scratching! 4*
The post rock I like and the post hardcore I like both have much more in the way of production than this. It's like sitting in a room with a bunch of boring miserable men having a moan while a just-ok band practices next door. 2*
If you've ever thought, "gosh, I wish I could listen to Mr. Blue Sky 17 times but on 16 out of those 17 times it was a bit less good," then boy have I got an album for you!
I think there's definitely an element of the one single being so typical of this group, and being so fucking great that it ruins the rest of the record, because there's good stuff here but ELO just very much have a certain style.
HELL YEAH! I grew up with some of these tunes and I'm biased but fuck you I don't care, FOUR STARS!
Sometimes there's an obvious reason why they chose the singles to be singles. Two truly iconic tunes on here with another ten less successful attempts. 3*
Okay, so obviously this doesn't measure up to the titan of Demon Days that was to follow but still, for this to come from nowhere was incredible back in the day. Maybe a biased score, but this gets a STRONG 4*, kept at that level just because Demon Days is perfect and my ratings need somewhere to go.
I've got to be honest and say that I thought of The Verve as a poundshop Oasis but I was pleasantly surprised!
This is my first full Bjork album, and it definitely won't be my last!
Maybe I was just too disconnected when this came out, but it obviously doesn't measure up to 21.
A perfectly fine album crushed under the weight of overrating. 3.5*
This is the most surprising album I've so far heard on this list! It's not what I thought The Roots were about, and even when I thought I'd got my head around what to expect they kept flipping on me!
Great record, strong 4.5*
I once listened to Narayan while I was tripping on a train and didn't realise it had been looping for half an hour.
My relationship with SOAD is odd because whenever I listen to them I fucking love it but I never think to put them on? Either way, this is so much fun and so heavy and so weird, big ol' 4.5*
"Mum, can we listen to Nirvana?"
"We have Nirvana at home."
Decent three star record, this!
I feel like I only ever hear people saying they fucking love this album or it's complete ass where in actuality it's pretty good 3.5*
i wish this site gave me the ability to rate things zero.
Brian I'm so so sorry I love you and Thursday Afternoon, DM, and Airports are some of my favourite albums but I just don't get this.
This is fine and all but the campiness hasn't aged amazing. Also Bolan singing with an American drawl then pronouncing a long soft 'a' in words like "dance" just takes me out of it.
An absolutely titanic pop album! Haters will still point out that it's pop and lacks a bit in the low end, but there's still an art to make music that you can tap your foot to that nobody's going to exactly hate. 3.5*
Dreampop isn't a genre I've paid much attention to, and when I've had I haven't always liked it. Hardly surprising, though, that the best album the genre has produced is actually quite good!
There's definitely something here, it's a lot of great Bri'ish guitar music all put in a big pot and stirred up! 3.5*
Yeah, 1001 is loads, but there are also fucking LOADS of albums and I just don't think this is one that feels necessary to listen to. Just very okay. 2.5*
You call a mf Thelonious and he's gonna make great jazz, you know this to be true. 3.5* (aware that's a little low but trade jazz like this doesn't necessarily move me although it's technically impressive)
I thought at least two songs on this were 'Losing My Religion', there's a TV show or something that uses the opening couple of seconds of 'Stand' as a recurring bit, and there are too many R.E.M. albums on this list. 2* out of spite.
An absolutely wonderful fusion of heavy metal and psychedelic rock! 4*
Psycho Killer justifies this album's existence, and it's impressive how fully formed TH's sound is from the word go, but I also don't like Talking Heads that much. 3*
I know a lot has been said of the vocals, here, but the guitar recording is just so crisp! Wonderful stuff :) 4*
This comes out at a 3.5* because each point I would like to add for making music that's horny without being creepy (a lost art) is just a little bit undercut by how god damn long all these neo-soul albums are
Groovy and obviously cool organ playing but there's nothing really exceptional here
I kinda just wish the double bass thing had been carried through a little harder? Bars go crazy though. 4*
This almost sounds like an album of stuff that wasn't quite good enough to make it on to Graceland, except made before Graceland? 2.5*
Bruce Petty and the Dylans
My brother fairly pointed out that it would be much easier to be in the mood for some of this if they just split the songs into separate tracks.
I know that might upset some purists but when you consider that a lot of them are just cobbled together from bits the members had individually written anyway it's really not too much of a reach from the final product.
With that being said, I'm bang into prog and this is towards the better end of it so 4*
This is better than I thought but another album where once you've heard the big singles you might as well not bother
The first half of this and Champagne Supernova are mostly good, well done to Liam and The Oases!
There are some great moments on here but the vocals just feel hampered by ability rather than chosen with intent. Sea Breezes is great and there are some crazy advanced ideas for the time but I don't know if I'll ever listen to this again. 3.5*
The sampling on this record is absolutely insane. 4*
Willie makes some big calls when choosing what to cover, here, but honestly these all now sound like Willie Nelson songs which, when you consider how huge some of the songs this album are, says a lot!
I wish there were more songs on here when Brian Johnson sung a bit lower - his voice is way better when he does! Otherwise yeah, this is kind of a blueprint type album, hard to overstate the important of. 3.5*
Billy, no! This album starts of so strong but the second half is marred by a lot of forgettable material. Strong 3.5*
There's plenty to like here but there's also kinda too much in terms of both length and the fact that the vocals are at 100% almost the entire time- I'm tired! 3*
I'm not a fan of a band's later work being used too judge their early stuff but favourite worst nightmare is the album following this and just outclasses it in every way. That being said this is still really cool indie that I'm kinda nostalgic over. 3*
I've never listened to a Morrissey solo effort before, but finally having given this a spin I can conclude that what little appeal The Smiths hold was actually in spite of his involvement 1.5* for the work put in by whoever wrote most of this music
I think I understand why this is so popular with depressed people
More classic funk feeling moments that some of the broader Clinton oeuvre, but in no world am I gonna listen to this when Maggot Brain exists, and has a better version of that very same track on it! Strong 3.5*
we need to stop labelling punk albums as post-punk just because they have like three melodic choruses
This is what it sounds like when a few guys are just starting to get with the idea that they're not just a rock band
Feeling like I 'had to be there' for this one but in the sense that I would have absolutely loved being 'there' and especially hearing 'this'
A lot of good stuff here but I don't know if I'm quite seeing the genius through all the 'creativity'. Probably a grower but this is like a 3.5* right now.
Oh Baby (Peter Frampton), I Love Your Way
I don't know enough about this style of music to meaningfully comment, but fair play on making it to 89 years old when you're whole deal is that you're fat
Genuinely one of the longest feeling back halves of an album I've heard, to the point that it actively detracts from the tunes on here that are deservedly viewed as classics. 2.5*
Every song on here that I like was because it sounds like Rumors, and everything else is pointless. 2*
This album was delayed so many times and then it came out and sounded like a collection of beats you could have made in a couple of hours. With that being said the vocals, lyrics, and features are all great, Skepta deserves his flowers for being such a long-term fixture of the scene, and both Shutdown and That's Not Me are all-timers. 3.5*
I'm worried by the idea of an 'essential' album that came out after 2000 but this really should be more popular!
Really unique blend of sounds and well produced, and a nice surprise when the cover looks like a whack 00's indie rock album.
Good country background music, but I struggle to see what makes this unique, or why they opted to just slap a live track right in the middle? Good, but not exceptional. 3*
This is such a okay album. Totally washed over me and inoffensive in quite an offensive way.
The bias that you might assume comes with being a NIN fan just isn't doing anything here - I never really got this album and was far more into With Teeth through Ghosts I - IV - but for some reason, this time, I get it. Fantastic stuff. 5*
The first track's too long, then they find their groove, and then lose it again about three tracks from the end? There's really cool stuff on here, but the inconsistency and vocals (which I'd find goofy in English, too) 2.5*
The bangers here are nicely distributed, the singles are great, Foreplay/Long Time is an amazing new discovery for me, and Smoking is a fantastic tune that reminds me of ayong GTA Sam Andreas as a kid (definitely over 18, of course!)
Strong 4*
Musical simplicity does not mean a lack of reliance on complex theory, and a mastery of one's instrument, and that is demonstrated here better than almost anywhere else. This album is as harmonically rich as it is stripped back an minimal. Absolutely sublime 5*.
I imagine this is very popular with people think that the faster you can play guitar, the better a guitarist you are. 2*
There's a lot of good stuff here, and maybe I'm biased for having come up around this time, but this is a particular type of indie that will always feel forgettable to me. Play Valerie from the second album if you must and move on, 2.5*
Hate to give this three stars, but it feel just a little flat compared to some of what Bob Marley achieved. There's not much in the way of valuable material here that wasn't superseded with a superior live version the following year.
There was a point during this album when I started to think that maybe George was the best Beatle? As ever, though, a double album doesn't need to be as long as it is. 3.5*
I once roadied for Spiritualized at a festival and they were nothing but polite and gave me and some of the other crew who stuck around for load out a load of beers BUT they also had me and this other guy carry a really heavy gong up a big ramp and then they only used it once so for that reason I must give this three stars.
This is one of those albums that was so popular around a certain period of my life that, despite having never put it on, I assume I've heard some of this before.
Well, either I've totally forgotten hearing this before (not a big swing considering how generic a lot of this is) or I've never heard any of it until today, and don't think I've missed out. Three stars on the basis that it's competent and some of the guitar noodling is quite nice.
