I was quite excited when this popped up, as I remember really liking it, but good grief was it dull. Lukewarm, overly sentimental middle of the road indie pop, albeit with a place in my heart. Maybe it’s because I’ve spent so much more time with other albums of theirs since last listening to this… nearly dropped another star because Tidal rolled onto Counting Crows straight after and I nearly vomited, but that’s hardly their fault.
Wow, that ultra high sheen orchestral soul hip-hop production really places this squarely in 2006 eh? Was a fan of Kick Push from back then but hadn’t listened to the rest. I think his bars are wicked, and are done dirty by the cheese of the production, would be keen to hear other stuff of his with a different sound
This would be 3.5 but the draconian system of ranking has tied my hands. It’s real nice, and I’m sure much more interesting in 2001 before the wave of minimalist, melancholic alt country.
The most impressive thing about this is how I’ve spent my entire life thinking that that cover art was a 90s Best Of. Graphic design decades ahead of its time! I love the title track but a whole album of swaggering this earnestly is TOO MUCH! Give me Asbury Park instead please!
I find the Stones very boring and their swagger quite off putting, but this album has always been a preferred one of theirs, and it has some nostalgia for me so I will look past all that.
See, to me this should be in the 1001 Albums To Avoid At All Costs Before You Die. I like Hüsker Dü a lot, and this has really tainted Bob Mould’s legacy for me. It’s just annoying! Whiney vocals, horrible production on the guitars, silly pop punk melodies but played in a dreary middle-of-the-road indie way. Christ, Bob, you really lost your edge huh?
My most unfairly neglected Radiohead album by far (Pablo Honey is much more neglected but that’s entirely fair).
Every time I come back to it I realise it’s actually brilliant, but somehow it’s never really stuck?
In a way it’s the most Radiohead Radiohead album, it’s almost as though they knew they only had one more album in them with this sound and would be take a fairly dramatic left turn with their next so they went hell for leather making every melody and harmony absolutely textbook “RADIOHEAD”
I’ve barely listened to them for years thanks to the sour taste left by all the mealy mouthed inability to condemn the genocide in Gaza, but in the name of statistical fairness I gave this another spin and I fucking loved it.
Against the rest of their catalogue: 3.5/4 Stars
Against music in general 5 stars without a shadow of a doubt
Jam bands have a certain you-had-to-be-there element to their appeal, eh?
I do broadly like blues rock, and certain jam bands I like a lot, but I find the bluesier jam bands tend to fall back on just soloing on a very well trodden riff for far too long.
By the time this gets to Elizabeth Reed there are some super great vibes going, but the fact that it opens straight into extremely middle of the road blues stompers that feel like middle of the set filler type tracks is absolutely heinous to me. Where’s the sense of vision, atmosphere and journey? If you’re going to play long form psychedelic music I need to be taken on a full arc, not just dropped in to a lukewarm riff and have that extended into a bunch of show-off solos.
Obviously this absolutely slaps. I had always thought I liked this best of all their albums but last night I listened to this and then Toxicity and the latter was actually a fair bit better.
Still, petty squabbles, absolute banger, 4.5 stars (but I guess it’ll need to be 5)
It’s a classic for a reason, and an undeniably huge part of my musical development as a 10/11 year old, but I’m not sure I’ve ever listened to it of my own volition as an adult. There’s definitely going to be a lot of albums on this list that that is true for, and how pleased I am with being presented with it will be a good guide for my ranking… make what you will of these 3 stars
Eeehhhh, I’m very grateful to the place in history that this has, and I love the sound that The Clash went on to forge… but I just never ever want to actually listen to this era. The tone, pacing, feel of every track is just a bit too samey, there’s barely any atmosphere or dynamics, and it doesn’t feel anywhere near as raw or powerful as proto-punk did 10 years before it.
Peter Gabriel would be so good if only he’d shut the hell up.
Musically a lot of this album is absolutely incredible, but he pretty much ruins it with his insufferably earnest vocals.
The mid-00s speakeasy jazz throwback aesthetic is perhaps my least favourite vibe of anything ever, so the nerve it took to listen through this album was not inconsiderable. You can imagine my horror then, after deciding that enough was enough, that there was an entire second disc still to go?! And it’s even worse!!
I remember Ain’t No Other Man (and I think Oh Mother) from the time and I’m quite furious about now having that stuck in my head.
There are moments of decent songwriting, some of the production is kinda cool, but the best bits feel directly ripped off from much better RnB 10 years previous, and the worst bits are insufferable.
I would get on board with Stripped being iconic enough for inclusion on this list but what possible grounds was this deemed vital to listen to before I die?
Absolutely phenomenal. Loved it when it came out but it still lived in Good Kid Mad City’s shadow for me. Not listened for ages and hooooooly shit does it SLAP.
My one reservation is the repetition of the spoken word bit that runs through it, I’m not sure we need the full thing quite so many times, but it’s a very minor gripe.
Uurrgh, another R.E.M. album so soon? And another I thought I liked, but this had almost no truly redeeming features at all. Maybe 3 decent tracks (Orange Crush probably the highlight? And I’m not generally a singles guy) and those came much too long after I was thoroughly sick of the album. The first half has almost variation whatsoever, and when it does come in the form of an irrepressibly major key, oh boy does it stink!
Stand is the kind of track that makes me wonder how the band retained any credibility at all. At best it’s music for a toddler to bounce up and down on their seat to at a baseball game. Its catchiness is in the same malignant earworm category as local radio advert jingles, and it’s advertising a family pack of the world’s blandest cheese.
As a moderately large Beatles fan, this was almost totally new to me.
I can’t say my life has been made any richer for having now heard it.
Unsurprisingly it’s a fair bit more inventive than everything it’s mimicking/covering, and it’s interesting to hear their arrangements playing on more traditional mid century pop/rock n roll.
It does feel kind of remarkable in how little like “The Beatles” it sounds compared to Please Please Me, and actually sandwiched between that and A Hard Days Night it fees like quite an outlier, and weirdly bereft of their absolutely classic songwriting. Maybe that’s justification for its inclusion in this list, but overall it’s pretty dull and certainly not a worthwhile and essential part of their legacy, and it does worry me that maybe all of their albums are going to be included if this has been chosen?!
Would be 2.5 if there was any justice in this rating system
So, so lovely. Not listened for so many years/maybe ever front-to-back in one go.
I can absolutely sympathise with any boring/morose/depressing allegations towards it, and I feel bad for anyone who reacts to it that way, but I think that might be a you problem.
There’s definitely a time/place/headspace to be listening to it and I do think the vocals can drag a bit at times, but broadly speaking I think it’s extremely beautiful and the production is an absolute masterclass in how textured and interesting you can make very restrained songwriting.
Definitely worth its place on the list!
One of my less preferred Radiohead albums, but still an absolute banger and filled with amazing songs.
I hadn’t listened in years and I do think it has a significant number of quite dull/of their time tracks. High and Dry through to Nice Dream is a pretty skippable run with tracks that sound like a lot of other bands from the era could have made them, in the way that Iron Lung, Just, Telex really don’t.
Surprising myself by giving this 4 stars (probably an extra 1/2 in there), was expecting to give it 5 without even listening, but it’s not quite made it to the peerless heights that they’d reach by OK Computer.
One of the Talking Heads albums I know less well, I haven’t listened properly in yonks.
It’s very interesting how foundational to their sound it is, certain elements really wouldn’t change much at all, and yet there’s a naivety and looseness to it all that’s really endearing in how much of a debut it is.
The guitar tone is absolutely gorgeous on it, and although I love how razor sharp it got by Speaking In Tongues there’s a softness and a fullness to this that is really lush whilst also keeping that textbook TH spidery sound.
Ultimately I think it is a little too basic and wholesome to stand up to their later material and to really blow me away, but it’s a wonderful debut and I’m very glad it’s on the list.
Raspy voiced geezers singing classic rock with this sorta swagger just isn’t for me. The folk component of this is by far my favourite element, and I think with a different vocalist and bit more emphasis on harmony I could probably enjoy this. But that’s not what’s here, and no amount of wishing is going to turn it into CSN&Y, so I’ll just give it 2.5 stars and move on.
Time was I would have described myself as a big double album guy. I love the long form ambition, I like the double dip structuring…
But listening through again now after a few years aff it, I can’t help feeling like this would have been better as one 50ish minute album.
The good songs are some of the best they’ve ever written, absolutely massive sound and so much excitement. The combination of snarling goth rock songwriting and ecstatic choral arrangements is absolutely doing bits. The mellow songs are incredible too, Spell and O Children in particular are stunning.
Buuut it does edge over into cheese a few times and there’s also some absolutely horrifying lyrics on there too, the second disc title track as a gleaming example.
So yeah… with like 4 or 5 songs axed, an absolutely brilliant piece of work, a career peak for sure… as it is? 4 stars? Aye something like that.
Wow.
I was fully expecting this to be one of those where I have a particularly strong personal vendetta and have to concede that the one star is mostly out of spite and the album has more merit than I’d given it credit for.
But this really is astonishingly bad.
One riff throughout, one drum beat throughout, and they’re not even good?! The most rancid vocal delivery I’ve ever heard, moronically coarse lyrics.
Just irredeemably awful.
I don’t know enough about the late 60s music scene to know if this was considered weird at the time, but given Scott Walker’s wholesale departure into extremely peculiar music in his later career it’s hard not to hear a touch of the bizarre through this, despite being ostensibly quite schmaltzy pop.
Absurdist vaudeville crooning? Haunted baroque pop?
Anyway I love it, but it’s definitely not something I can stomach all the time!
Heck yeah. This is my kinda blues/americana rock type stuff! Compared to so many others who play this sound it’s warm, sincere, playful and without all the incredible smugness and swagger that is rife amongst this sound.
I only really knew Music From The Big Pink and a couple of other singles before this, but it’s another quality helping of altogether solid tunes.
Seminal blues for sure, but I’m just not thaaat fussed. Too much jaunty swing/boogie feel in it to appeal to me that much.
I feel like giving any less than a 4 is historically moronic, but I can’t in good conscience give any more to an album said to have so heavily influenced Eric Clapton and John Mayer.
I admire the maximalist ambition of this a great deal. But it’s just so annoying isn’t it?
I think I was expecting this to be schmaltzier, perhaps on the basis of My Girl (which I do noot like) being the only Temptations song I really knew, but this is great!
Felt like it was maybe dropping a bit in the second half, with some of the quieter tracks compared to the energy of Funky Music and Run Charlie, but it’s gorgeous melodically and harmonically, wicked atmospherics, and super interesting arrangements.
Also packed with bits I recognise from samples which is always fun.
I’m never sure with the The Kinks… the ultra twee English life thing must surely be somewhat ironic, or at least layered with some wry look at a darkness beneath the surface, but listening to through a whole album it does feel like there’s a bit too much that is just sickly twee…
There’s a lot of really nice stuff here, of course, and maybe at a time before most music had any edge it was dripping with cynical nuance, but the end result is just a bit too twee!
So much fun!
Just What I Needed is one of those tunes I put on in my headphones when I’m a bit drunk and listen to 5 times in a row and get mad kicks from.
And it’s feels like it’s probably the only track on here that’ll keep that status, but the rest sure are fun too.
3.5 stars really, and 5 for the drunken headphone sessions
Absolute banger album. Genre defining masterpiece and a pinnacle of one of the coolest sounds in the continuum of punk, dance, rhythm based music. Love love love.
Weird one to rate!
When it was released I remember having a bit of a funny journey with it. Disliking the lead single Where Are We Now? a fair bit and preemptively writing the album off as another late-career Bowie dud. Then having my mind absolutely blown by the title track and getting really into a lot of the other album tracks, the two closers being particular standouts. At that point it felt like a total return to form, his best in 30 years by some margin. A Bowie album released in my lifetime that I genuinely loved was something I never thought I’d experience, so I was absolutely stoked! At that point this would have been a super strong 4 if not a 5.
Then he released Black Star, promptly died and overshadowed near enough everything else he’d ever done with the most poignantly executed departure from this life that the world has ever seen (honourable mention to Leonard Cohen). I’m not sure I’ve listened to The Next Day since Black Star came out? And certainly 10 years on it feels like a pretty distant memory.
And you know what? Listening again now, it’s pretty good! To me now, it feels like a slightly middle of the road victory lap giving comfortable nods to the iconic highlights of his career and as a result sounding a lot like the people he influenced along the way.
The opener and final two tracks are still head and shoulders standouts, and the flawless Scott Walker homage of Heat still makes me smile, especially in the context of how the Berlin/Eno/Trevor Jones (yeah you heard) sound might have influenced Scott…
Soooo, all things considered, 4 stars but that’s a bit of a generous upgrade from a 3.5
What it lacks in all time classics I think it more than makes up for in structure, pacing and flawless grooves.
I would maybe take a bit more psychedelic freakout along the way, making the title track an extra few minutes to go out with a bang would have been very cool, but broadly I think the brevity and punch of the album really enhances the impact.
Banger
Once again I’m left feeling like a bit of a philistine for having to say that while I massively appreciate this album’s place in history (and whole heartedly think it is essential listening for anyone who somehow didn’t know it before) I just don’t want to listen to it myself.
It just has such a particular and inescapable vibe that I always feel like I’m doing a bit for the sake of being deliberately retro whenever I listen to stuff like this. And it all kinda sounds the same in a way I get extremely tired of.
3.5, 4.5 for innovation, 2.5 for actual desire to listen.
Not gonna over think this one, just damn good fun swamp rock.
Perhaps to my own surprise I’m actually noticing a fair bias against things released pre-1970s in my feelings about these albums.
I’m a moderate jazz fan, especially on the central/south American and Afro/Caribbean end of the spectrum, and a big fan of rhythm forward genres. So on paper this should really hit! I think in a live setting I would absolutely love it, but as a record I must reluctantly agree with a lot of the other reviews here that say that there’s just a bit too much straight conga here and not enough melodic element.
Probably a 3.5 for its wider context.
I wasn’t much into this when it came out, found it quite dull and a bit annoying, and that’s coming from a position of having really liked YYY’s first EP and Fever To Tell, and also really liking synth pop and more melodic, flamboyant indie.
Listening so many years on it’s almost embarrassing how much of a guitar-band-go-synth bandwagon jump this is, and particularly in how late to the party it was. The songs feel uninspired and played out, Moroder by numbers and super on the nose euphoric/melancholic synth pop melodies, and the played-safe plasticky tone of the instrumentation makes Karen-O’s voice sound lurchy, yelping and grating. Also, Heads Will Roll has been done soo dirty by the big remix that was everywhere. I didn’t like that either but this version sounds so drab and lifeless now.
I’m not too big to admit I’ve broadly written off Tina Turner as raspy old mum rock. And tbf you can see why I would say that, but this slaps way harder than I would ever have expected!
Big fun belters, super cool production and the most deranged Beatles cover ever. Loses considerable traction for me on some of the ballads, but I can get over that.
I remember this being the first Björk album where for me the concept massively outstripped the output. Really cool idea that I wanted to get into, but I found the final thing quite alienating and overall just didn’t land for me.
There are several absolutely stunning songs, and in lots of places the full vocal arrangements sound amazing, but in lots of others I feel the concept is laboured to the point of heavily detracting from what could have been really beautiful songwriting an production and sounding like a bit of a corny gimmick.
The beatboxing really pulls me out of being able to enjoy it, and a lot of the choral backings sound very am dram (a problem I frequently find with experimental choirs)
It’s a shame because listening again now I’m quite taken aback by how great so many of the songs are (obviously, it’s Björk!). Would love a reproduced version of it with different instrumental arrangements… does that exist??
4 stars for the writing
4 stars for the vision in the concept
2 stars for the execution
Can I give this 5 stars? Can I give it any less than 5?!
It’s a lifelong love, and I admit it’s schmaltzy as hell, pretty corny in lots of places, the upbeat tracks are cheesy as anything. I wish Walk of Life wasn’t on there, could maybe skip Money For Nothing too (though more out of being overplayed than anything else)…
But the rest of it is one of the most effective and delightful routes to putting me in a very specific nostalgic headspace, and for that I am eternally grateful.
God damn I really don’t like this.
I liked their first two albums a fair bit when they had a bit of spark to them, but good GRIEF this is tedious stadium drawl isn’t it?
I can’t really tell where in the continuum of millennial chanting Use Somebody came, but it either has a lot to answer for or it’s derivative of one of the worst sounds of the decade.
Miserable, pompous, dreary, swaggering, bleurghoo
I’ve listened to this once or twice before a few years back but pretty much forgotten it all. But for a Stones record it’s actually pretty good and relatively free of “that riff” (minus Happy and maybe a couple of others…)
The strengths here are very much when they play into other sounds than their usual blues rock swagger, and there’s quite a few tunes with great arrangements that steer well away from what I find annoying about the Stones.
This could not have come at a better time. Kate Bush is perfect autumn into winter music, there’s a playful nostalgia and cosiness to it that is so perfect for putting on a big jacket and walking around in the fallen leaves and the alarmingly early dusk.
I’ve also started getting a bit exhausted with how many dull old geezers these albums tend to be by, so this has given me a well needed boost.
It’s not my favourite of hers, but still head and shoulders above a lot of other artists. The maximalist theatre school whimsy is in full effect, to a point that’s almost a detriment to the album (and certainly a good few songs are borderline unlistenable out of context), but in a way that makes it even more fond of it, like an annoying friend who you’ll defend to the ends of the earth secretly despite agreeing with any bullies.
Realistically 4.5 (gotta keep the half star back to mark out the best of her albums) but it feels churlish to knock it down here.
You gotta admire the nerve of Billy Corgan pressing on with being a lead vocalist sounding the way he does. I suppose against the nugget munching, dick swinging, swaggering cursive drawl of Pearl Jam and Alice In Chains and so on this sorta creepy whining was probably quite refreshing, but he really is quite annoying.
I only knew a few tracks off this, but I’m super into the songwriting and the heaviness of the playing. I didn’t realise they shredded so much!
With a different singer this would be a solid 4/4.5, but with Corgan it can’t really be higher than a 3
It's definitely not an album for all situations and moods, but when it hits it really hits! Been a big fan for a long time and I'm very pleased to see it here!
Thought I'd enjoy listening to this a lot more than I ended up. I've always held it as top tier hip hop, and it's such a semnial piece, but I did find it a bit dull going through today... The flows felt kinda basic and childish, the beats were a bit flat and repetitive... I guess my taste in hip hop has changed a fair bit since I last listened about 15 years ago?
In terms of its place in history a solid 4, but for my actual enjoyment of listening today... 3.5
The only reason I've slightly cooled on this album in the last 20 odd years is that it's so iconic and influential that it has tipped over into feeling slightly cliched, and certain songs overplayed. But having stayed well away for a good while and then listened front to back rather than just hearing Glory Box or Numb in the wild it's really reminded me how stunning it is, and how totally and utterly it nailed the sound and atmosphere it created.
My one hesitation is that that they really do dine out on that sound quite heavily across the course of one thing. I actually think Third (which I can never believe came out as early as 2008) is much richer in terms of diversity and journey through an album. But you can entirely sympathise with the fact that they must have not wanted to stray from this vibe they'd created for fear of shattering the intensity of the mood.
Funny story… I accidently not-so-microdosed myself yesterday and ended up very mildly tripping for a lot of the day, so it was the perfect road test for this.
I’ve always struggled with how little most first wave psychedelic rock actually captures the essence of the psychedelic experience… I really like it, but it’s essentially raucous garage rock with some weird noises and almost no atmosphere or sense of transcendence. But I guess that’s the thing about being first wave or proto or whatever, you’re still figuring it all out… but for me the incessant tooting of an electric jug and some eerie chord progressions doesn’t really transport my mind to a fascinating new place.
I will say this though… yesterday was by far the most I’ve appreciated this album and its psychedelic properties!
But yeah, a cool album and super important in the history of counterculture music, but this scene didn’t start really getting interesting for me until bands started putting a bit more thought into experimentation that created atmosphere, told stories, built worlds, made things feel dreamlike and transportive… ironically something that the distinctly not groovy world of classic music had been doing for centuries, and the extremely academic world of early electronic music had been sending into hyperspace for decades. But I appreciate that the era of not-very-thoughtful guitar music to take drugs to is a necessary step on the route to the likes of Can and Pink Floyd and so on.
This sorta fusion is a hard sell isn’t it? I do quite like it but it’s just so weird and goofy, but maybe not quite weird enough? Just goofy, really cheesy and goofy and kinda stupid, which is crazy when you think how musically complex and skilful it is. Really drives home just how fuuucking goofy the goofy component is huh?
If you don’t think this is one of the best hip hop albums of all time then what are you even on about?
Hadn’t listened in many, many years but holy smokes it held up even better than I was hoping.
Flows are unreal, beats are sick, vibe is flawless. 10/10 seminal hip hop record.
This is the first time I’ve listened to a Rush album front to back…
They’ve always been a band I felt like I wanted to get into but never could and now I see why… It’s because their music is incredibly annoying.
Please stop trying to cram so many ideas into such a short space of time, especially when they’re all these slightly jarring combination of notes played in such a charmlessly reedy tone.
Nope.
By all accounts this must have really slapped at the time, and in the context of the likes of Sugarhill Gang it must have seemed super raw and cool. The enormous use of that orchestra hit sample does get pretty tiresome, and the call/response/shared lines delivery gets a bit old, but it’s a seminal piece of work and pretty unfair to judge against more contemporary hip hop!
3.5(4 in historical context) 3 for pure listening