Album Summary
Siamese Dream is the second studio album by American alternative rock band the Smashing Pumpkins, released on July 27, 1993, on Virgin Records. The album has received widespread acclaim by audiences and critics alike, with the album's musical influences and lyrical material standing out compared to other alternative records released during its time. The album has since been considered "one of the finest alt-rock albums of all time".Despite recording sessions fraught with difficulties and tensions, Siamese Dream debuted at number ten on the Billboard charts, and eventually was certified 4× Platinum, with the album selling over six million copies worldwide, cementing the Smashing Pumpkins as an important group in alternative rock music. Four singles were released in support of Siamese Dream: "Cherub Rock", "Today", "Disarm", and "Rocket". In addition to receiving widespread critical acclaim upon its release, Siamese Dream has widely been regarded as one of the greatest albums of the 1990s, and one of the greatest albums of all time. Rolling Stone magazine has ranked it between numbers 341 - 362 on various versions of their 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Already on my shelf, Pure nineties rush in every groove, Soaring sonic waves.
I just can't get past my dislike for Billy Corgans voice. I've always thought the Pumpkins were a bit boring, but I was wrong and there is actually some good tracks on here, with a different vocalist this could be a pretty good album. But. It's still a good 3* album.
This was at least better than Mellon Collie. I actually made it through this one
Riktigt bra rakt igenom. Vissa låtar är väldigt lika varandra men jag klagar inte!
An excellent album the whole way through
Meh
“Jeremy loves Smashing Pumpkins…5 stars for Jeremy.” -H
Honestly thought i would hate this. The first song had me headbanging so hard. Not normally into this type of rock but I liked way more songs on this that i thought I would
Bien.
Smashing Pumpkins – Siamese Dream (1993) Rating: 6.6/10 I’ve always liked but never loved the Smashing Pumpkins. I like but don’t love Siamese Dream. I like but don’t love Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. If you took all of their greatest hits and put them together on one record, I’d probably love that record. But for me, the Pumpkins have always been more of a singles band than an albums band. I was a little too young to fully appreciate the first wave of grunge and alternative rock. When Nevermind came out in 1991, I was five years old. I was certainly aware of Nirvana and Pearl Jam, but I was too young to really care about music. When Siamese Dream came out in 1993, I was seven. Again, I was aware of the general musical zeitgeist, but I wasn’t exactly sitting around listening to alternative rock albums. My first vivid memories of the Smashing Pumpkins come from around 1995, when Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness was released. I remember being at a family friend’s house watching MTV and seeing the band perform, or perhaps appearing at an awards show. They seemed like the biggest band in the world. “Bullet with Butterfly Wings” was absolutely everywhere. I remember the “Tonight, Tonight” music video vividly, with its fantastical imagery, the moon with the face, and the whole silent-film aesthetic. The Pumpkins were ubiquitous. They were even on The Simpsons, for Christ’s sake. Throughout my life, I’ve always enjoyed their radio hits, but I never paid much attention to their full records. Sometime in my twenties, I finally listened to Siamese Dream and Mellon Collie in their entirety, and I remember coming away underwhelmed. I think I preferred Mellon Collie because it was a little more pop-forward and accessible, but I also found it exhausting. Two discs of this stuff? Jesus Christ. So many songs, so much of the same sound. Revisiting Siamese Dream now, I find myself having much the same reaction. My biggest issue with this album is the production. I understand what Billy Corgan and Butch Vig were going for. There’s a huge shoegaze influence here, particularly My Bloody Valentine, with these enormous, layered walls of distorted guitar. And I can appreciate that aesthetic. But there’s a point at which it becomes too much. The guitars are so saturated, so maxed out, that they begin to lose definition. I keep finding myself wondering whether my headphones or speakers are good enough. But they are. It’s the record. I want the guitars to be heavy, but I also want them to be crisp. I want to hear the individual instruments rather than having everything dissolve into one gigantic wave of fuzz. And the frustrating thing is that there are some absolutely phenomenal songs buried in all that distortion. “Cherub Rock” is an all-time great album opener. That opening drum fill, followed by that incredible guitar riff and the groove that develops underneath it, is just fantastic. It’s one of the high-water marks of the album and probably of the Pumpkins’ entire career. Jimmy Chamberlin’s drumming is tremendous, and I love the juxtaposition between those massive guitars and Corgan’s delicate, nasal, almost falsetto singing voice. There’s nobody who sounds quite like Billy Corgan. He can go from a whisper to this strained, anguished scream, and that contrast is one of the most compelling things about the band. I should also mention that I find Corgan himself almost insufferable. I’ve heard enough interviews with the guy over the years to develop a pretty strong dislike for his public persona. He’s so self-important, so convinced of his own genius, forever talking about how he invented this or influenced that or how Kurt Cobain stole his guitar sound. He comes across as a tremendous asshole. But there’s no denying that he’s an extraordinarily distinctive rock vocalist and a gifted songwriter. “Quiet” is another tremendous song. Just an absolutely ripping, heavy guitar riff and a fantastic solo. Again, though, I wish the production had a little more clarity. It’s heavy, but not crispy. “Today” is unquestionably one of the great radio singles of the 1990s. That beautiful, almost innocent opening melody followed by those enormous distorted guitars is quintessential Smashing Pumpkins. It’s probably one of Corgan’s signature songs, and deservedly so. “Hummer” and “Rocket” are kind of two of a kind for me. They’re both very good songs, but neither is particularly memorable. And both suffer from my biggest complaint about the record. There’s just too much sound. I particularly like the ending of “Rocket,” where these searing fuzz guitars are layered over one another, but then Corgan adds another guitar, and another, and another, until there’s simply no room left for anything to breathe. Sometimes less really is more. “Disarm,” on the other hand, is one of my favorite tracks on the album. It’s a genuinely beautiful song, and Corgan’s vocal performance is terrific. He moves between this tender, fragile delivery and a raspy, pained emotional intensity. That dramatic descending musical movement is tremendous. And the arrangement demonstrates that the Pumpkins don’t need twenty layers of distorted guitars to create something powerful. “Soma” doesn’t really work for me. I find the underlying song melodically uninteresting and frankly kind of boring. And this is where the production really becomes a problem. When the distorted guitars come crashing into the chorus, they’re so loud that they practically drown out Corgan’s voice. But I will say this: the guitar solo toward the end is absolutely magnificent. Probably the best solo on the record. It has some of the epic, soaring grandiosity of Slash’s playing, combined with that strange, electronic, live-wire quality of Tom Morello’s guitar work. It’s a fantastic solo trapped inside a song I otherwise don’t particularly enjoy. Then comes “Geek U.S.A.,” which is absolutely fucking awesome. This song works for me in a big way. The riff is unbelievably heavy, almost like something you’d hear from Soundgarden, Alice in Chains, or even a traditional metal band like Metallica or Pantera. The way that riff plays against Chamberlin’s drumming is incredible. It’s aggressive, intricate, and rhythmically exciting. And here’s the thing: the production sounds great! The guitars are enormous, but there’s definition. Everything has its place. The solo is even more Tom Morello-esque than the one on “Soma,” with that almost electronically manipulated guitar sound. And toward the end, the song settles into this thick, hypnotic groove that reminds me of Kyuss and the whole desert-rock, stoner-metal sound. It’s fantastic. This is proof that I don’t have a problem with heavy guitars or maximalist production. I just want the heaviness to serve the music. “Mayonaise” is another song I like quite a bit. It’s got a really cool groove and a memorable melody. But holy shit, it’s like somebody stepped on every distortion pedal in the studio simultaneously. Just this enormous wave of distorted guitar. And there’s this high-pitched, squealing guitar sound between some of the chords that I really don’t care for. It reminds me of the sort of guitar effects that would become popular with late-‘90s nu-metal bands like Korn and Limp Bizkit. That’s not a compliment. Still, the song itself is strong enough that I enjoy it despite those reservations. “Spaceboy” is pretty forgettable, although by this point my ears appreciate the reprieve from the relentless distortion. “Silverfuck” is perhaps the most frustrating song on the entire album. It starts with an absolutely killer riff. It’s probably the heaviest thing on the record, and when it’s rocking, it really fucking rocks. But why does this need to be nine minutes long? There’s an extended, echoey, reverb-soaked interlude that goes on forever, followed by what feels like two minutes of sheer noise. It takes a song with an incredible riff and stretches it until listening becomes almost painful. By the end, I’m thinking, put me out of my fucking misery. And that’s really the problem with this record in a nutshell. “Sweet Sweet” and “Luna” are fine. They’re pretty, gentle, somewhat forgettable songs, much like “Soma” without the spectacular guitar solo. But by this point, I’m checking the track list to see how many songs are left. And that’s how I know I like but don’t love Siamese Dream. Throughout this listen, I repeatedly found myself wondering, both during songs and between them, is this over yet? That’s not a good sign. The album is too long. Some of the individual songs are too long. The production is often so relentlessly saturated that listening becomes physically tiring. There are moments of extraordinary musicianship, incredible riffs, fantastic melodies, and some truly inspired guitar playing. But there are also long stretches where I feel like I’m enduring the record rather than enjoying it. And I feel doubly that way about Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. Two fucking discs of this? Jesus. I understand why Siamese Dream is considered a landmark alternative-rock album. Its influence is undeniable, and at its best, it’s absolutely brilliant. “Cherub Rock,” “Today,” “Disarm,” and “Geek U.S.A.” are phenomenal songs. There are plenty of other terrific musical moments scattered throughout. But a collection of great moments doesn’t necessarily make a great album. At least not for me. Give me a Smashing Pumpkins greatest-hits record, and I’ll happily listen to it all day. Give me Siamese Dream from beginning to end, and somewhere around the forty-minute mark, I’m probably going to start looking at my watch. 6.6/10.
Cherub Rock would make a good tv series intro
very nice.
Can I juat watch an episode of NWA Powerrr instead?
I don’t care what Garg says, Billy Big Muff has chops. A little long but a solid 4.
Really liked this. I think billy corgan has always put meo off listening to… his records. Turns out this one is good.
I don't love the guys voice. like at all... and it's an alright album. I just really can't get into his voice.
Quintessential 90s rock. I recently saw the pumpkins and they still have such a unique and ambitious sound. 4.4
I love this album a lot, and I’ve been listening to it for a while. It’s one of the best grunge albums behind only one or two others, and everything about it is awesome. The instrumentals, the guitar tone (god I love the guitar tone), the vocals, all of it. They’re all mixed fantastically, and this is both technically and emotionally a near perfect record. A shame their later works could never match this level of quality. 4.5/5
After struggling with Melon Collie a few weeks, I was a bit stressed about Siamese Dreams - because while not two hours, Siamese Dream is yet another album on the longer side of things. Thankfully, alas, I had a really good time with the album. The grungy guitars on songs like Cherub Rock or Geek U.S.A. just blow me away, they create such a full sound that pierces through every other layer that might be found on the album. They almost trend towards creating static noise but luckily have enough melodic movement going on to not get disorienting. The vocals are often neither amazing nor terrible - I think it's to the overall benefit of the songs that the vocals are drowned out by the guitars often. When Corgan sings "Let Me Out" on the album opener, it really sounds like he's trapped inside a storm. This, again, could be to the album's detriment, but I think it works quite well stylistically and thankfully I didn't have a hard time understanding the lyrics. Though the biggest strength of the album is how the Pumpkins interlace explosive and loud songs with quieter moments. Disarm especially blew me away the first time I heard it. But songs like Hummer also Soma (while overly long in my opinion) show interesting and well executed dynamic movements. I still think the album is too long, Silverfuck could've been left on the cutting room floor, and generally the second half of the album lost me a bit. But hey, overall a great album and my happy reconciliation with the Pumpkins!
All killer.
Love it. Check Unterschied zu foo Fighters
Just last week I stumbled on a recent interview with Billy Corgan in which he rails against Pitchfork because they "stabbed alternative artists in the back." Bold words from someone whose most famous album is, beneath the power chords and distortion, so dang poppy, lol! My first time listening the whole way through. Love how soft this gets sometimes (right before it gets majorly loud).
Not my cup of tea, but still good
Very mediocre
Never gave smashing pumpkins much thought but some banging tunes and ahead of their time
Smashing Pumpkins were always a bit strange for me. Being an early 90s teenager, I knew them ,and new their hits. Their albums, however, were a bit to heavy sounding for me. And I had Nirvana and Pearl Jam anyway. SO I never took the time to listen to them in full. This is the first time I did, and it was a very pleasing experience. the fact that I used good earphones, that managed to play the heavy guitar riffs without swallowing all the other minute details, really helped. This one goes to my permanent library
Not a big smashing pumpkins fan, but wasn’t that bad
second studio album by alt-rock group the smashing pumpkins, release during a time when grunge rock started to achieve a historic peak. after achieving surprising success on their first album, the group were eager to record new material to blow the socks off rock listeners across the nation. many band members felt pressured during this recording process, the band members going through their own personal struggles, especially front member billy corgan; the lyrics for the album quickly went deep and talked about his own past, stressors and insecurities. hiring alan moulder, who mixed mbv's loveless, the album was completed after a few months and released to extreme critical acclaim, achieving platinum certifications and billboard spots. it's said to be one of the band's most successful records ever. the last album i reviewed, one of the things i really talked a bit about was "guitars that never stop" in music, and this album has that going for it as well. i will never get tired of this sound. it all flows wonderfully from loud and sludgy to gentle and dim. as the resident stoner who's often moody, this is the perfect album to sit there and think about your life, all buzzed and feeling like a disgusting person. i can't really get all verbose with it, but it's really good music. an essential album for those getting aquainted with 90s grunge and you're sick of nirvana.
Went in thinking I’d write this off because I’m not a big fan of Billy Corgans voice, but honestly it was a great album. They’re all great instrumentalists, and Corgans voice really captures some sort of nostalgia for me. Album reminds me of being a teenager
It might not be Mellon Collie but it’s still 5 stars to me.
6/10 Best songs: Disarm The production on this album is very standard for early 90s (indie) rock: it emphasizes the instrumentation to the point of occasionally (often) drowning out the vocals. This is not necessarily a bad thing, particularly considering how Billy Corgan's vocals are... not my favorite. I do find that it dates the album a bit. That being said, the instrumentation is great. This is going to be a weird comparison, but just go with me: the instrumentation of every song is kind of reminiscent of 70s heavy metal or rock, in that they are treated as individual compositions where the music plays just as (if not more) important a role as the vocals. Every track ends up crazy long as a result. So, why am I only giving this album 3 stars? For the exact reasons listed above: the songs are too long and I don't like Billy Corgan's voice. I think I'd like the album more if it were 20 minutes shorter - either by cutting down the song lengths or dropping 4-5 songs.
You gotta admire the nerve of Billy Corgan pressing on with being a lead vocalist sounding the way he does. I suppose against the nugget munching, dick swinging, swaggering cursive drawl of Pearl Jam and Alice In Chains and so on this sorta creepy whining was probably quite refreshing, but he really is quite annoying. I only knew a few tracks off this, but I’m super into the songwriting and the heaviness of the playing. I didn’t realise they shredded so much! With a different singer this would be a solid 4/4.5, but with Corgan it can’t really be higher than a 3
An all time favourite for me so many late night memories with this album playing.
ive been waiting for these guys
I Love Love Love this album. I played this CD straight through for months. T
Mayonaise.
Ah, album, za katerega imam cd! Torej mi je dobro poznan. In všeč. Pozabila sem, da je "Silverfuck" tok fajn. Na splošno, všečen mi album. Mal je tud nostalgije kle, ampak ne velik. Dejansko se mi zdi, da it holds up.
3 estrelas
Fuck yeah.
I had higher hopes for this album in my head. I was thinking of Mellon Collie.
Really liked Disarm and Spaceboy. Giving it a 3, but I almost rated two. Genre isn’t my favorite, but it’s a solid album in its lane.
Siamese Dream is a phenomenal rock album, a contender for the best of the 90s, contrasting expansive rock armadas and heavy overdubs with introspective lyrics. This is a special album and its influence is still felt today.
no és el meu rollo honestament, massa ruidosso messy i intentant nirvana. hi ha algunes cançons que m'agraden tho, com Luna...DIsarm..
Bon album de rock. Je connaissais pas le groupe, c'est une belle découverte
3.5
Decent album
classic 90's rock. 4.5/5*
boring for me disarm is fire tho
I fucking loathe this band.
Das Album pulsiert vor Energie – kraftvolle Gitarrenwände, treibende Drums und Billy Corgans markante Stimme verschmelzen zu einem Sound, der gleichzeitig roh und atmosphärisch wirkt. Besonders beeindruckend ist, wie die Songs zwischen melancholischen Momenten und explosiven Ausbrüchen wechseln, ohne an Spannung zu verlieren. Tracks wie “Cherub Rock” und “Today” liefern genau die Art von musikalischem Adrenalinschub, dieses Albums dass ich “zufällig” an Helloween bekam. Auch die ruhigeren Stücke behalten eine emotionale Intensität, die das Album insgesamt sehr rund wirken lässt. Zwar gibt es ein paar Passagen, die sich etwas ziehen, doch die Gesamtwirkung bleibt stark und mitreißend. Ein energiegeladenes, kraftvolles Album, das auch Jahrzehnte nach seiner Veröffentlichung nichts von seiner Wirkung verloren hat. Geheimtipp: das Depeche Mode Cover “Never let me down” I’m Bonusmaterial.
If you like music where the lead singer is completely unintelligible, you’ll like this. (I liked this)
Nothing stood out to me, either good or bad.
Takes me back to my glory days of being a clinically depressed teen
Just whiny, incoherent noise.
cute picture
First listened on 16th, 18th and 19th October 2024. Favourite songs are Today and Luna.
TL;DR: One of finest rock albums of all time in any genre with a guitar sound that is like slipping into a warm bath. BEFORE: Billy Corgan is a dick but this is a classic and one of my favourite albums. I even have it on vinyl. Best produced guitar I've ever heard. AFTER: There are no bad tracks on here. It's great from top to bottom. If anything, the singles include some of the weaker tracks on here. HIGHLIGHTS: The guitar sound. What Butch Vig and Corgan did on this album is miraculous. This is also Corgan's finest songwriting - Gish is a bit noodly and Melon Collie is great but a little bloated. He would disappear up his own arse shortly after, but we'll always have this. Favourite tracks on here are Cherub Rock, Hummer, Rocket, Soma, Geek USA, Mayonaise, and Silverfuck but YMMV. That three track run from Soma to Mayonaise is an all-timer. LOWLIGHTS: None. VERDICT: 5 stars, you simpleton. You absolute rube.
I love this band.
Jeder Song ein Hit, was ist das denn für ein Album?? Eins der besten Rock Alben das ich je gehört habe.
Awesome probably my favourite Pumpkins Album. Today, Luna, Disarm and Cherub all fantastic Billy Corgans vocals are great and the ruffs keep coming clever layered heavy bass and drums marry well with his vocal range. They rock but with his unusual voice add something different.
On va commencer par mettre les pendules à l’heure et froisser d’entrée les intégristes du double album : pour une écrasante majorité de la critique et des nostalgiques en chemise de flanelle, Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness représente le chef-d’œuvre indéboulonnable des Citrouilles de Chicago. C’est le disque que tout le monde cite quand il s’agit de prouver au monde que les années 90 savaient encore accoucher d'opéras rock babyloniens de deux heures. Grand bien leur fasse, mais si vous voulez mon avis, leur véritable Everest musical ne se trouve pas dans ce barnum grandiloquent étalé sur deux galettes. Le zénith absolu de Billy Corgan, son coup de génie le plus incandescent et sa catharsis la plus viscérale, c’est très exactement Siamese Dream, largué en plein visage du monde à l’été 1993. Moins m’as-tu-vu, moins boursouflé d’arrogance symphonique, infiniment moins luxuriant et foisonnant que son successeur, mais bordel, tellement plus attachant, plus resserré, plus pur et désarmant d’authenticité. C’est simple : là où Mellon Collie s’éparpille en fresque tentaculaire, Siamese Dream est une déflagration compacte qui vous prend aux tripes pour ne plus jamais vous lâcher. Il faut se replacer un instant dans le marasme de l'époque pour mesurer l’exploit que représente ce disque. En 1993, le tsunami Nevermind a tout rasé sur son passage, les majors signent n'importe quel groupe qui sait faire du larsen dans un garage crasseux, et l’étiquette « grunge » est devenue le nouveau produit d'appel pour refourguer du désespoir frelaté aux adolescents en crise. Les Smashing Pumpkins sortent d’un premier disque prometteur mais encore un peu brouillon (Gish), et Billy Corgan sent le souffle de la faillite créative lui caresser la nuque. Le type est au bord du gouffre, ravagé par une dépression, paralysé par le syndrome de la page blanche et terrifié à l’idée de se faire écraser par la concurrence. Pour couronner le tout, le groupe implose de l'intérieur : James Iha et D’arcy Wretzky viennent de rompre après une relation toxique et refusent de s’adresser la parole en studio, tandis que Jimmy Chamberlin, batteur virtuose aux mains en or, disparaît des jours entiers dans les bas-fonds de Marietta en Géorgie pour s’injecter de l'héroïne. C’est dans ce climat toxique, au fond d'un trou noir d'angoisse et de rancœur, que Corgan décide de jouer le tout pour le tout. Ce disque aurait dû crever sous le poids des névroses de son créateur, et pourtant, il en sort un chef-d’œuvre d'une intensité folle. Épaulé du producteur Butch Vig – qui venait déjà de bâtir le son cathédrale de Nirvana –, Billy Corgan se transforme en tyran obsessionnel et en véritable forçat de la console. Il s’enferme des semaines entières pour empiler les prises, il envoie paître le reste du groupe, il rejoue lui-même la quasi-totalité des guitares et des basses avec une maniaquerie confinant à la folie pure, il passe des nuits blanches à superposer jusqu’à quarante couches de guitares sur une seule et même chanson pour obtenir ce fameux « mur du son » compact, duveté et incandescent. C’est une méthode totalement mégalo, un comportement de dictateur imbuvable qui aurait brisé n'importe quel autre projet collectif mais le résultat sonore, lui, met tout le monde à genoux dès les premières secondes d'écoute. Car ce qui frappe immédiatement avec Siamese Dream, c’est cette production gargantuesque et cette dynamique sonore impitoyable. À l’inverse de ses contemporains de Seattle qui ne juraient que par la crasse brute, Billy Corgan assume sans honte son amour honni pour les monstres sacrés des années 70. Il marie la déflagration des amplis Marshall et de la pédale Big Muff d'un Black Sabbath avec la précision rythmique d'un Led Zeppelin et les enluminures psychédéliques d'un Pink Floyd, tout en l'habillant d'un sens de la mélodie pop qui n'appartient qu'à lui. Les guitares ne se contentent pas de rugir : elles carillonnent, tourbillonnent, rugissent comme un escadron de bombardiers tout en conservant une limpidité cristalline. Et que dire de la batterie de Jimmy Chamberlin ? Loin des bûcherons basiques du rock alternatif de l’époque, ce mec apporte une frappe jazzy, aérienne, d'une vélocité phénoménale, ponctuée de roulements mitraillettes et d'une finesse qui propulse chaque titre sur orbite. C'est un moteur monstrueux qui empêche le disque de sombrer dans la boue sonique, même quand les amplis sont poussés au bord de la rupture. Mais la véritable grandeur de Siamese Dream ne réside pas uniquement dans ses acrobaties de studio ni dans ses murs de distorsion : elle tient dans son écriture, nue, frontale et déchirante. Quand Billy Corgan ouvre l'album avec la claque de « Cherub Rock », il crache tout son venin sur l'hypocrisie de la scène indie et le cynisme de l'industrie musicale, tout en emballant sa rancœur dans un riff dévastateur qui ferait rougir n'importe quel vétéran du hard rock. On n'a même pas le temps de reprendre son souffle que le groupe assène des classiques impérissables comme « Today » ou « Disarm ». Sur le papier, signer un hymne fédérateur à partir d’une pulsion suicidaire (« Today ») ou convoquer un carillon et des violons pour régler ses comptes avec des parents maltraitants (« Disarm ») aurait pu virer au mélo larmoyant le plus insupportable. Sauf qu'entre les mains de Corgan, cela devient une transcendance cathartique, une mise à nu universelle qui touche à l'essence même de l'adolescence écorchée et des traumatismes de l'enfance. L'album brille par cet équilibre miraculeux entre sauvagerie métallique et délicatesse feutrée. Prenez un monument comme « Mayonaise » et sa montée en puissance magistrale, ces guitares éraillées qui grincent sur des larsens accidentels découverts sur une guitare bon marché, cette mélodie poignante qui plane au-dessus du vide... C'est l'essence même des années 90 résumée en six minutes de grâce absolue. Et quand le groupe décide d'enfoncer la pédale d'accélérateur sur les cavalcades furieuses de « Geek U.S.A. » ou de s'étaler dans la transe hypnotique et psychédélique d'un mammouth sonique comme « Silverfuck », on comprend que ce groupe jouait alors dans une catégorie à part. Il n'y a aucun temps mort, aucun remplissage complaisant pour meubler l'espace. Même les respirations nocturnes comme « Spaceboy », ode bouleversante dédiée à son frère handicapé, ou la berceuse finale « Luna », apportent une lumière fragile et une tendresse inattendue qui achèvent de désarmer l'auditeur. C’est précisément là que réside toute la différence avec Mellon Collie. Deux ans plus tard, les Smashing Pumpkins choisiront l'opulence baroque, le double album écrasant, le maquillage victorien, les concepts filés et l'étalage étourdissant de virtuosité. C'était brillant, certes, mais c'était aussi le début de la démesure et de la pose pour un groupe qui commençait déjà à se regarder le nombril. Sur Siamese Dream, Billy Corgan n'a pas encore le temps de faire le malin ou de jouer les divas intouchables, il joue sa peau, son âme et sa raison sur chaque prise car c'est l'album d'un homme qui met ses tripes sur la table pour éviter de crever, et cela s'entend à chaque seconde, dans chaque hurlement étranglé et chaque mur de larsen. Alors oui, la postérité et les charts continueront sans doute de glorifier le double géant de 1995 pour son audace pyrotechnique. Mais pour quiconque cherche le cœur battant, la flamme originelle et l'émotion à vif des Citrouilles de Chicago, Siamese Dream reste indétrônable. C’est un chef-d’œuvre sans compromis, un disque d’une beauté toxique et salvatrice qui n’a pas pris une seule ride en plus de trois décennies. Un putain de 5 sur 5 éclatant, monumental et indiscutable.
Listened whilst doing one of my first solo drives. Felt like a real teenage experience
Pretty sick
oozes early 90s alt-rock greatness Rating: 9/10
I think I'm just a smashing head
Decent, enjoyed that more than I thought I would
They’re okay! I like it but not all of their songs (luna is pretty nice)
Legit one of my favorite albums of all time. This is one I can put on at any moment and just let it take me to a head space of when I was a teen at release.
Not bad
"Words defy the plan. When I can I will" There's a poetic symmetry between Mayonnaise and Pink Floyd's Fearless that is eternal. Just like this album is eternal. I love every note, every sonic fuzz, every word and every song. I begged a friend of mine to let me borrow the cd in fifth grade (back when cds were like 24 dollars or some other insurmountable amount of money to a 10 year old. And when he finally relented and I was able to move beyond the Cherub Rocks, and the Disarms and the Todays I had heard hundreds of times on the radio I rapidly had a new favorite band that lasted at least through MCIS and maybe even through Adore.
My dislike of Billy Corgans voice made listening to the entire album such a chore. The songs aren't bad by any means, but the whiny vocals are difficult to overlook when it comes to Smashing Pumpkins. 2.5 rounded down.
A solid start. The album had good range, and I particularly enjoyed the grungier tracks like Quiet. Top Tracks: Quiet, Mayonaise
Great sounding album. Couldn't quite click with the style of the singing personally but can't deny there are some good songs on there.
Such a great album, I mean you got Cherub Rock, Luna, Disarm, Spacebar, all on here. Amazing. It's such a unique vibe for me that I just cannot get enough of.
A few good ones
Such a mixed bag for me. A couple of songs I really like, but others were too heavy to sit through
I think I enjoy this enough to give it a light 3. It's punk, it's distorted, but it also has a modern sensibility and harmonic style that I like. In its best moments, the album can sound almost like shoegaze, kind of like my bloody valentine. But there are also several tracks that fall flat as tends to be the case with these longer albums.
Just as I (partially) came around to liking my former hometown (Jacksonville) band, Lynyrd Skynyrd, I've also (partially) come around to liking my current hometown (Chicago) band, Smashing Pumpkins. I was already living here when this came out (1993), and have heard plenty of them on the radio ever since. This was their second album, and launched them to major popular success; tracks 3 and 6 still get a lot of play on WXRT. Billy Corgan's voice is an acquired taste which I still haven't fully acquired, but I guess I've become inured to it, via repeated long-term exposure. Anyway, how do I rate this? Gonna go with a high 3. Don't think I can quite justify a 4 (the voice problem, plus not a style of music that I love), although I will say that they combined hard/guitar-driven rock and alternative rock in an interesting way - which, come to think of it, is, I guess, kind of what grunge is -- so I can see why they're sometimes lumped in with that).
I'm surprising myself by giving four stars here. I don't like the whiny singer, and I don't like music that has a wash of guitars the whole time. It's a low four for those reasons. But this album is more than that. It's more ambitious than just a rock album. "Disarm" is a beautiful message, great song. Same with "Today." The album effectively conveys different emotions and moods. Melancholia is the most common one, and one that I admittedly have a soft spot for. Also, there are some good riffs It should have ended with Silverfuck, it's a bit too long
Another band that I think that I dislike but it turns out, whoops, I actually like a few of their songs. A few. I think I just dislike Billy Corgan. No particular reason. Just one of those things. This album was fine. Certainly of its time. The next album is a killer. 3 stars
always amazing
One of the best album intros ever Sort of sands the edges off of shoegaze to deliver these phenomenal walls of layered (seriously layered, like nearly 100 times apparently on some songs?) guitar in a more straightforward alt rock grungy package. But then some of the quieter tracks like disarm and luna are fantastic too, and kind of tease what songs like “tonight tonight” were going to sound like on mellon collie Today has such a catchy yet simple riff running through it, and I really like most of the other tracks, though it’s not quite an album I’ve played to death, which I suppose is a good thing. Mayonaise (sic) might be my favourite, stood out more to me after hearing it in the finale of that Netflix show Beef a few years ago
for how noisy this was it was disappointingly forgettable and didnt have any where near as many other critically acclaimed grunge albums (nevermind) 3
JL : 3, Geek U.S.A. (might have been a 4 if it had less annoying vocals)
While the album's overall mastering feels noticeably compressed and a bit unusual at times, Siamese Dream by The Smashing Pumpkins remains a strong and captivating alt-rock showcase driven by memorable songwriting and stellar guitar work. The tracklist is hit-and-miss across its runtime—stretching from uninspired spots like "Rocket" and "Disarm" to overlong entries like "Hummer"—yet its highest points deliver tremendous payoff. Standout tracks shine bright through beautiful melodic hooks ("Today," "Soma"), energetic and title-defining drives ("Geek USA"), and explosive, unforgettable climaxes ("Silverfuck"), all anchored by impressive solos and surprisingly intimate vocal moments ("Spaceboy"). Ultimately, despite its slightly bizarre audio production, the sheer quality and dynamic variety of the music make Siamese Dream a thoroughly enjoyable listen.
Band I should like but don't: round 2. It's fine. Bit of the guitar and drum work stood out from time to time but otherwise I still don't find The Smashing Pumpkins to be all that interesting. I was too young in '93 to go for depressing teen angst so I guess I just missed the boat with these guys.
Ok
One song covers it.
Skilful guitar riffs by Corgan, good variety in the album whilst maintaining sonic cohesiveness throughput. This is a blast of nostalgia back to the 90s accompanied with Corgan’s nasally vocals, which grow on you.
Liebs, dass ein Song namens Mayonnaise auf dem Album ist
5/10
Thumbs up!
I can see why this was big in the 90s, but unfortunatly an hour of this doesn't really do anything for me
Wow.
Practicamente solo habia escuchado Today, grata sorpresa
Listened before? No, but I know several of the songs. Familiar with the artist? Yes Thoughts: - I never really got into the Smashing Pumpkins for some reason, but I do like all the hits. - Today is the greatest.. song on this album (sorry) - Wait maybe Disarm is actually the greatest song. I think I prefer their slower songs because I can actually understand what he's saying, lol. Spaceboy is also great. Favorite track(s): Today, Disarm
Siamese Dream — Smashing Pumpkins Pre-listening: Know it like my family phone number. Let’s avoid the classics (Cherub Rock, Today, Disarm) for the top 3. Best: Hummer Runner-up: Silverfuck Third: Mayonnaise Post-listening: Absolutely love this album and my bias will show. Always have. It roped me in from the very beginning with one of my favorite album openers of all time; Cherub Rock. A heavy guitar sound with a running base line with loud ass drums and lyrics like “Who wants honey? As long as there’s some money!” How can it not glue you in? The album covers all grunge the bases: angry (Cherub Rock), sad (Soma), really sad (Disarm), happy-sad/sad-happy (Today), existentialism (Hummer), oddly appreciative (Spaceboy), inner tranquility/acceptance (Quiet/Mayonnaise), mistaking love for lust (Luna — FU Courtney Love), and alienation (Geek UsA). While I always love listening to it, I do realize that Corgan is off-putting to many. But you can’t deny this album. It’s just too essential to grunge, the 90s, and allowed for emo, shoegaze, and alternative to grow. The album reminds us about the beauty of looking deeper than the surface. While most of the catchy songs are sadder than the melancholy songs, it begs you as the listener to dig deeper. And if lyrical analysis isn’t your gig, they give you a fallback with instrumentation that’s both obtainable but mastery. What I love so much about Siamese is that Corgan isn’t and absolutely is the focal point of the album. Almost all of the songs are about some aspect of his life, painting the troubled upbringing and (at the time) current situations of his life, but the instrumentals are what make it so melodic and make you want to put the album in your rotation again and again. This is The Smashing Pumpkins at their best. I will die on that hill. It might not have the hits of Melancholy and might not have the ready for radio quality that Adore had, but it isn’t as hard to get through as Melancholy or as forgettable as Adore. My only critique is that they should have ended the album on Silverfuck that ends with a sound that screams the essence of grunge music and not Luna (some bullshit profession of love to Courtney Love (pre-Cobain)). Rating: 10/10 Stars: 5/5
Legendary 90's release, solid from top to bottom. Starting off with a banger in "Cherub Rock" and finishing with the slow "Luna" after an exhaustingly good 10 songs in between. 5 stars, easily. This album encapsulates the 90's sound, it was such a huge hit album and you couldn't get away from it at parties, at bars, on the radio. This is their finest album and is so creative with not just hard grunge songs and screaming guitars but with lovely melodies and heartfelt lyrics. "Today" (425M listens), "Cherub Rock" (233M) and the timeless "Disarm" (333M) were the big radio hits but glue tracks and fan favs like "Mayonaise", "Spaceboy" (personal fav), "Luna" & "Rocket". The only song I'd jettison is "Silverfuck", it just never fit and still doesn't. Masterpiece. 5 stars
Ok - I'll admit it, not a Pumpkins fan. They came out when music was doing its upheaval in early 90's - sort of a grunge/alt/prog band. meh
My main take away from this project so far is that I don’t really like rock, but I can at least say this one didn’t sound like all the other rock albums I heard from the list so far