Sep 08 2025
4
A third Tragically Hip album? Absolutely not necessary. It's fine and I recognise New Orleans is Sinking from the rock radio station I used to listen to time to time as a teenager.
Otherwise, I think we've gotten enough Tragically Hip albums!
My personal rating: 3/5
My rating relative to the list: 4/5
Should this have been included on the original list? No.
👍
Sep 17 2025
4
Up To Here is the debut album of The Tragically Hip. It is not as good as what is to follow (Fully Completely, Road Apples and Phantom Power), but still a fine piece of music on it's own. It has all the elements (energy, drive and good guitar licks) that can be found on the albums that will follow.
👍
Sep 10 2025
5
I love The Hip and you should too
👍
Sep 06 2025
4
This album feels like a more natural choice than a previous user album from this band (Phantom Power) which I still have to listen to so I might be wrong...
..in any case, OtH contains New Orleans Is Sinking: one of their best songs. Overall, this is a solid album (had to get onto it again and it got better after a few listens). Still had expected to see Fully Completely, a classic album that could have been included in the 1001 list.
👍
Sep 09 2025
4
Yeah I like this. Good rock - I really enjoyed the opening track Blow at High Dough. While I don’t think I’d put three albums on this list from The Tragically Hip, I’m happy to have become acquainted with the group.
👍
Sep 10 2025
4
This album is fun and good and I loved it. Still don’t *quite* get their totemic status in Canada but who am I to disagree?
👍
Sep 11 2025
4
Some blues rock, some regular rock and some more folkish rock. It was okay
👍
Sep 12 2025
4
Excellent. 4 stars.
👍
Sep 18 2025
4
Alternative rock, roots rock, folk rock, country rock, blues rock. Me ha gustado. Un 4.
👍
Sep 19 2025
4
This is pretty good. I didn't know what to expect, but was pleasantly surprised. Opening track is solid. Good rock album, enjoyed it.
👍
Sep 07 2025
3
This Tragically Hip album wasn’t as good as Fully Completely but it still was a pretty good album. For a Canadian band they have a good sound of bluesy rock with an occasional country element, maybe Kingston is the Atlanta of Canada. Overall it’s another good album by them with a good range on their sound while still that late 80s early 90s flannel rock sound. 6.8/10
👍
Sep 09 2025
3
When you order R.E.M. from Temu.
👍
Sep 10 2025
3
This Canadian favorite has made the fan list once or twice before - and I never remember exactly what they are about. Which turns out to be pretty straight ahead rock and roll in my book, smart lyrics without being pretentious, the singing nothing life-changing but fit to purpose. Some of it gets into a little monotonous riffing around stock progressions, some of it runs a bit long, but enjoyable overall and I'd happily listen to it any time.
👍
Sep 11 2025
3
Another tragically hip album, can’t really complain i like these guys. I’d find a way to squeeze it on the list.
👍
Sep 11 2025
3
Pretty fun
👍
Sep 12 2025
3
Wait is the version on Apple Music ripped from vinyl? You hear the needle drop at the start of “Boots or Hearts” and if it’s a sample/sound effect, it’s really well done.
That’s all I got, really…the music is fine. This sort of heartland rock isn’t really for me, but it had some very enjoyable moments.
👍
Sep 25 2025
3
Rick of various shades. Ok.
👍
Sep 26 2025
3
Aldrig hört talas om gruppen men det här var ju klart godkänt. 3+
👍
Sep 08 2025
2
It’s nice to see the Tragically Hip on here but I’m not feeling it. I think it’s the curse of the jam band - great live, not so great when recorded.
Still, it’s nice.
👍
Sep 14 2025
2
Pretty bad
2
👍