Perfect listening. Made me cry for obvious reasons

The beginning of the album was okay but by the last couple songs I was feeling a little over it… not bad but I probably wouldn’t go out of my way to listen to the full album again!

I’m just gonna say it… I think every song on the album sounds basically the same except I’m on Fire and Dancing in the Dark.

I didn’t listen to the whole thing but I liked what I did listen to and I think the chicks would like it hehe

Perfect listening. Made me cry for obvious reasons

I really liked this one. I knew a lot of the songs already but didn’t realize they’re all on this album. I remember learning to play Iron Man on guitar and showing Collin how to do that long note at the beginning (hold on the string above the fret board) I’d do 4.5/5 if I could — just not a 5 because I think I’d have to be in the right mood for this one

Honestly I can never decide if I like Silver Jews or not… I’m constantly going back & forth on it. But this album is pretty solid. A lot of the songs stood out for me — I think I liked “room games & diamond rain” and “death of an heir of sorrows” the most. From Horselegs Swastikas: “I wanna be like water if I can, ‘cause water doesn’t give a damn.”

Love this one and I’m gonna save it. Good sounds all around and I think Collin would like it too! Would listen again

didn't listen to the whole thing this time but i've listened before ... pretty good album but not one i usually go out of my way for

Didn’t finish but it was fine!

YES ALL TIME FAVE. I love this album. It’s Too Late is one of the best breakup songs ever written if you ask me.

Very fun. Sounds like something bob reid would play in p.e. class!

Not for me. Didn’t finish - couldn’t do a full hour of this

One of the best albums of all time honestly … no notes! “if not for you” played at 4:44pm for me — angel sign! Thanks collin :)

I like this album! Would listen again.

Side A was a 2 but side B a solid 4! I wasn’t really into it at first but I liked the second half a lot more with the violins and such. Fave track was stroke it noel

Oasis really put all of their best songs on one album… maybe it’s boring to give this a 5/5 but honestly I had a lot of fun listening to this in the car. And I do believe that “Don’t Look Back in Anger” is one of the best songs ever :D

Elliott Smith is always being recommended to me and I never really feel here nor there about him. This album was fine, don’t know if I’d go out of my way but if it came on I’d probably feel neutral.

Well honestly I feel like this kinda sounds like every other little folk/singer songwriter band from the 60s so nothing really stood out to me

Bob Marley... what's not to like?

Meh I don’t love u2????

It’s perfectly fine

To be honest I really don’t like this genre // like the way old school rock-n-roll sounds

Kind of a cross between beach boys & bruce springsteen…….interesting