Horses by Patti Smith

Horses

Patti Smith

3.3
Rating
28590
Votes
1
6%
2
18%
3
32%
4
28%
5
16%
Distribution

Album Summary

Horses is the debut studio album by American musician Patti Smith. It was released on November 10, 1975 by Arista Records. A fixture of the mid-1970s underground rock music scene in New York City, Smith signed to Arista in 1975 and recorded Horses with her band at Electric Lady Studios in August and September of that year. She enlisted former Velvet Underground member John Cale to produce the album. The music on Horses was informed by the minimalist aesthetic of the punk rock genre, then in its formative years. Smith and her band composed the album's songs using simple chord progressions, while also breaking from punk tradition in their propensity for improvisation and embrace of ideas from avant-garde and other musical styles. Smith's lyrics on Horses were alternately rooted in her own personal experiences, particularly with her family, and in more fantastical imagery. The album also features adaptations of the rock standards "Gloria" and "Land of a Thousand Dances". At the time of its release, Horses experienced modest commercial success and placed in the top 50 of the American Billboard 200 albums chart, while being widely acclaimed by music critics. Recognized as a seminal recording in the history of punk and later rock movements, Horses has frequently appeared in professional lists of the greatest albums of all time. In 2009, it was selected by the Library of Congress for preservation into the National Recording Registry as a "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant" work.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

(3/5) This is punk? I'm not convinced. Her attitude and persona may have been, but this isn't punk. It's, politely, OK but she ain't that great of a singer. This album lands at a 2.5 for me, but I'll round up cuz she's a woman and they're underrepresented on the list.

Nah crazy

Okay! Some arty beat poetry proto-punk. I’ve had very little exposure yo Patti Smith, though I do think I’ve heard Land before. This album surprised me. The driving guitar sound that escalates when she gets going was a real pleasure. That “Free Money” track was a banger. “Land” too. Put me in mind of Velvet Underground that I’ve heard previously on the list. It’s a 3.5 that I listened enough to round up to a 4.

This is a foundational album of punk rock. Patti Smith will always be iconic, and she came out the gate swinging with Horses. I think one of the issues people might have with Horses, is its punk in the same way Velvet Underground and Lou Reed are rock. For a mainstream audience its too artsy, or too different from the expected sound. Horses is part punk rock, part spoken word, pure poetry and filtered through a minimalist approach to the actual music. I don't think there's a bad or weak song on the album, and love ever second of it.

OMG I LOVE THIS. I definitely need to read just kids next and I also need to see her at Roskilde festival… THIS HURTS THE WALLET. Anyway! I really like the sound and she’s giving a little bit of Stevie nicks vibes and I love it! Very 70s in the best possible way. It’s truly wonderful how the sound is magnificent if that’s what your listening for but the lyrics are so good as well. Fav track (I think): break it up

Great work ❤️

Awful. What the fuck. Can’t understand anybody listening to that more than once, I barely made it through

Är en femma fram till sista två kanske men om jag verkligen skulle hänge mig är de också säkert femmor. Varför inte? Ordentligt ballt.

Another prominent album that disappoints me. Sure side-A is a solid one ("Free Money", "Kimberly") But side-B for me - mainly because of her vocals - ist annoying! 1,5

Did not enjoy this much at all, unfortunate given my love for horses

love it. also daisy jones and the six song! want to read her memoir sometime

I bet this album went hard in 70s alt culture.

Considered the godmother of Rock/Punk. many women artists site her as an influence. In my opinion, "Horses" is one of those albums that critics adore and I do not. i always found her stuff over-rated.

A hard alblum to get through.

Interesting

I do get the comparison to Dylan in terms of songwriting. This album didn't tickle my particular fancies but it wasn't bad. That's me giving a bit because I really dislike Dylan. I get his place in history but I don't care for the lyrical style personally.

I knew the legend but I didn’t know the album. It starts incredibly strong, but then settles into a minimalism, like a Bresson film, that does a so much with seemingly so little. Brilliant album.

This album is fantastic, so beautifully made, poetic and confronting at the same time. It is bewitching, such an astonishing record with such great songs. It is very eclectic and so well-written. And it is sweet, powerful and brilliant. Patti Smith really put in Horses what may be one of the best albums ever made, so unique and interesting, even folkish at times, and very peculiar, very hers.

Perhaps the most creative album ever made at the time it was released. That’s a gross exaggeration obviously. Meet The Residents came out a year prior, and even that probably doesn’t deserve that title. But it’s a nice thought, and a plausible one if you don’t think too hard. Because this is a creative fucking album. “Gloria: In Excelsis Deo” is the obvious highlight. The best moment of 1975 is the first “AH-AH, MAKE HER MINE!!!” When it switches from swing to even rhythm. It’s an anthemic, sexy, momentous song, just an absolute banger. “Redondo Beach” is another favorite, a really nice reggae song that fits in well with the album, and it’s like actually pretty good for white people reggae. Other highlights include “Free Money,” “Birdland,” and “Land,” which are all these really delirious and surreal poetry numbers that really add an interesting slant to the album. They all see Smith one way or another bending her voice to its most wild tendency, with deeply surreal and oft-disturbing lyrics to match (try not to instinctively cringe when, in “Land,” she describes the way Johnny sets the blade to his throat). This is one of the wildest, most insane albums out there. It is a must-listen that I cannot recommend enough. If you claim to be a hardcore rock fan and you haven’t heard this, stop lying to yourself. This is the shit. 10/10 DOES IT BELONG ON THE LIST: YESSSS REASON: pivotal, incredible, important, amazing

Quelques trucs très bien au milieu de trucs moins biens

What happens when two creative forces meet, This. John Cales' no-frills production of the Patti Smith group is a match made in heaven. Direct is the best way to describe the genius within. Every bent note, smashed cymbal, chest thumped, and chord played is not only enhanced by the production but given the freedom to truly guide, accompany, and become the streetwise beat-poetry of Patti Smith. An never-ending well of inspiration for millions of musicians past, present, and future. A Monumental Masterpiece. 5/5

Important and brave album.

Pre-listen: Never heard of this, but i'm getting the feeling this is going to be something punk, considering that gorgeous mop of hair and butch outfitting, 1970s leaves me a bit on the fence though as i'm much more of a fan how the genre evolved rather than when it started Notes: Starting off on a high-note with Gloria, is this prog rock??? With queer undertones???? That's a keeper I'm a fan of the use of piano in a few amount of these songs so far, it's an underutilized instrument that i've really come to love for the genre ever since i first listened to Ben Folds Five's debut album A lot of these songs kind of have the similar kind of vibe to them? Not that they're like bad or anything, but it's a bit same-y, Horses/Land of a Thousand Dances is a good song to start closing out the album on, being a lot longer and leaning back into that more prog element Elegie is a pretty poor ending point I'll say though, I think this and Horses should have been swapped, but maybe it's just meant to have a more somber ending point? Solid 3/5 though, would probably check some of these out again.

Pre Listen: Haven't heard the name Patti Smith before, or maybe I have, it's a rather generic name. The album cover also looks pretty generic. The girl on it is giving me proto-1970's manic pixie energy. Low expectations. Notable Tracks: Birdland - Least favorite track. I'm already so done with Patti's style of singing, I couldn't finish this one. It's like an unholy mix of David Byrne, Bob Dylan, and a 3-5 cocktailed mix of various stimulants and depressants. Free Money - Best track on the album, Patti's singing is still not great, but the melody and instrumentation sound best here I think. Land: Horse (etc.) - Another low point. Just goes on for way too long, Patti's having an episode again through it, and the instrumentation is just sort of alright. Post Listen: This was so close to being a 1, Patti's vocals are so miserable. Many such cases. The only things that dragged this up to a 2 was that the instrumentation had some pretty banger moments. Not songs, merely moments. Specifically the piano and bass, I quite liked both of them the most consistently, the guitar too had some cool moments though, but was messier overall. Points too for the album having a fairly modern sound to it, if someone had made me guess the year before listening I would've placed it in the 90's. I can tell the Talking Heads drew some inspiration from this group, and certainly polished their style. Blondie too, I think I can note some influence upon. That said, the album itself plays like a weird mix between classic rock and punk, overdubbed by someone going through a maniac-depressive episode. Not a fan of Patti's whoops, hollers, slurs and hiccups, nor her flowery lyrics. Music for people with BPD. 2/5

Pleasant with some great guitar but I'm downgrading slightly due to spoken word which just for me and music doesn't work

I want to like it as I’ve heard so much about her and this album. That said, just wasn’t for me.

I totally understand why so many artists look to her for inspiration. Her artistic skills are unquestionable. But with that being said, I didn't love this.

Lyrically and musically great.

Gloria - 5/5 Redondo Beach - 3.5/5 Birdland - 4/5 Free Money - 5/5 Kimberly - 4/5 Break It Up - 4/5 Land - 5/5 Elegie - 4/5 Could this really be called the first post-punk album in the States? I mean, sort of. It feels about as equal amount of punk as other bands in the CBGB scene were, and that really makes it shine for me. I had no idea this came out a few years before Television's debut, but some of the songs surely seem to be cut from the same cloth. It really shines when she leans into the more punkish elements on here, though the other tracks certainly do sound like they were produced by the Velvet Underground. It's got just enough of that artsy flair to make it stand out amongst its counterparts and make it uniquely hers. Amazing debut. Overall: 5/5 Favorites: Gloria, Free Money, Land

Wat een top album is Horses ook, door zo'n ontiegelijk coole vrouw gemaakt. Gloria is denk ik een van mijn favoriete albumopeners ooit.

Ooit hoop ik half zo cool te zijn als Patti Smith. Horses is zo uniek: poëzie en punk, zoals ze nooit eerder samen kwamen en naar mijn mening ook nooit meer samen gaan komen. Lees 'Just Kids'!!! En luister meer Horses.

PUNK ROCK! FINALLY! I've never listened to this before but I immediately loved Gloria. Been a while since this project fed me some punk drum beats. Redondo Beach is almost reggae? Birdland was not it (early punk, still hadn't quite ironed out some of the 9 minute compositions lol) but Free Money is good. Side B was similar, I didn't take explicit track of the names but for the most part, I really enjoyed them. Slowed a little at times (give me fast punk rock!) but still a very good record.

Favorite tracks: Gloria, Kimberly I really don't know anything about Patti Smith; I didn't expect this album to sound so strange! Great energy, excellent lyrics. I could see this being one that grows with time.

Lots of passion in lyrics, if not more spoken-word than I was expecting. Instrumentation had good flow, but lyrics didn’t necessarily seem to fit the rhythm. Not a dealbreaker for me, but takes some getting used to. 2.0-2.5/5.0

I thought this was awesome. She's super unique and complex and interesting. Some songs are more like poems, and some rock incredibly hard. I'll listen to more of this.

A hard listen. Smith embraces the weird, and I don't quite like that.

I was of course familiar with the name, but almost ashamed to say that I'd never even shallowly explored her work. There is some really interesting stuff here that sasheys around the edges of punk, but the extended bouts of beat poetry never do a whole lot to draw me in, and by the time it was over there wasn't anything in particular that called me back for a second listen. Still, it opened the door to exploring more of her long and illustrious career, which earns it a 3.5/5 that I'm not prepared to round up just yet.

258. Horses - Patti Smith (1975) 11.7.26 Variety: 4 Adequacy: 5 Listenability: 5 Uniqueness: 5 Emotionality: 5 = 4.8 rounded up to a 5 "And I rolled in the grass and I spit out the gas/ And I lit a match and the void went flash/ And the sky split/And the planets hit" Horses is another one of those albums I came late to. I had heard Smith's version of "Gloria" somewhere before ( I doubt it was the radio) and was familiar with the album cover having seen it reproduced so many times. I think I finally got around to it in my mid 20s after reading about so many artists that I like who cited it as an influence. And not just punk musicians. The ripples from this one are still very huge and having been strengthened themselves by all the influences Smith herself took in ( Jim Morrison, Iggy Pop, Van Morrison, etc) has maybe even grown in size to begin overtaking or at least obscuring those ripples, amplitude decreasing with each year as more and more female artists, queer artists and people with more esoteric interests are everywhere now. Back in 1975, Smith was SO unique that the album cover alone was seen as a major artistic statement on gender norms with her androgynous dress style, and general untouched and natural look. It just was not done by female artists at the time. Even the ones who were already making strong social statements. Smith herself claims that's just how she liked dressing at the time, and seems to take the whole "voice of a generation" thing with a big grain of salt. I've come to really like this lady, and she comes across as genuine and enthusiastic about art in her interviews. Even just recently I think I saw her on the Late Show talking with Steven Colbert before that show ended and seemed so much less affected and more interesting than so many of her peers in the elders of rock. Her and David Byrne seem to be the two from that general era who still have a lot of interesting things to say. We'll get into some of those influences below ( so I 'll still have something to talk about) but I'll at least mention that at the VERY least, punk rock and New Wave sounds a lot different without Smith's voice in the mix. If you've read that the music itself is less important than the legacy, but have never actually heard this before, I urge you to remember this came out in 1975, months before the Ramones debut dropped. That was the era of Elton John's Greatest Hits, Linda Ronstadt, Olivia Newton-John, the Eagles', Chicago, John Denver, and Jefferson Starship. Not that good meaty stuff wasn't coming out from the likes of Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, and others. But it was a LOT of what we'd now call dude-centric "classic rock" and chintzy pop, and culturally we were in between the hippie hangover with bellbottoms and beards, and the cocaine, big hair era. Smith must have looked as much liek an alien as Bowie had a few years before. This album gets lumped in with punk in a lot of discussion, which I think can be confusing for younger listeners who are expecting the stereotypical Sex Pistols template stuff, but I urge you to go in thinking of punk as the attitude, with the musical form as secondary. Sure maybe art-punk is more descriptive. I personally still see it as protopunk and would lump her in with Iggy and the Stooges, the Modern Lovers, and the Velvet Underground, rather than the more aurally assaultive bands that would come in their wake. Been looking forward to this one for a while, and it's showed up in a TON of the further listening and precursor sections of my reviews, so it's been in the back of my mind for a while. It's been a few years, but I can't think my opinion has done anything but grow. THE TRACKS Side one "Gloria" - Smith opens things up with a reworking of the hit song by Van Morrison's old group, Them. It begins with a slow piano and gradually and slowly builds pace so that by the time it's screeching along at a clip you don't even realize you've been dragged along on a ride through .... someone's libidinous inner monologue. This shit is awesome, guys. This is solid, incontrovertible proof that you don't need to be a technically gifted singer to be an EFFECTTIVE singer. When the chorus finally hits and the backing vocals come in, and the guitar scratches grooves into your brain, it's too late. The doors of the Tilt-A-Whirl have been closed and you're gonna have to ride it out. The energy on this is pure 100% rock n roll and a stone cold classic and it feels fresh and as full if life as ever. I guess you might say I like it. "Redondo Beach" - A reggae inspired number ( who else was stealing this sound back then?) that makes great use of Smith's softer, yet still snarling, and dynamic delivery. In stark contrast to the upbeat sounds we get a tale of a woman who drowns herself at the beach after an argument with the narrator. This is hardly what I think people expect when they see "punk" on the label and it's a great example of how catchy Smith's songs can be, when her reputation I think is much more steeped in stuff like what we get next. "Birdland" - I read that the music on this was largely improvised over top of Smith's mix of spoken word, stream of consciousness style poetry and raw emotional sung sections. It's all very pretty, especially the piano, and Smith's manic tale of a boy left after his father's funeral to experience either some divine or alien visitation of maybe a vision of medical event builds to a crescendo with the music underneath, and the feedback heavy guitar effects add an eerie vibe. It's all very largely effective and builds an excellent mood. Can you hum it? No, but I don't much care cause it's beautiful and it's something I can sit in and soak up the weird, sad and somewhat mystical atmosphere. "Free Money" - If someone were played the first 15 seconds of this, they might be forgiven for thinking it was maybe a Tori Amos song, and it's only when the groove kicks in around a minute in that comparison becomes harder to make and Smith and company start laying down combinations of sounds that I think wormed their way via the chain of influence to a LOT of new wave guitar centric acts. It just does NOT sound like 1975 to me. I love it when I get this feeling from a song that feels out of it's time somehow. It's a driving rocker and it's so absent of all the tropes of the era that it I can't help but be impressed. Side two "Kimberly" - An upbeat, almost poppy number where Smith seems to be trying to capture the confused feelings of a child and their mixed but reverential feelings about a new baby sister. It reads almost like when you're a kid and you're trying to describe something but you don't yet have the vocabulary. It's catchy and it's got handclaps I love it. "Break It Up" - Tom Verlaine of Television joins on this track, which has a sort of melancholy and epic feel and which is accented by rising choruses that sounds chaotic and like some sort of catharsis in music form, with Smith pushing her voice as far as it will go, falling into a ragged and desperate yowling by the end. "Land" - The longest piece on the album is a very successful medley of sorts, with everything built around a take on "Land of a Thousand Dances" as Smith weaves a tale of a kid names Johnny whose brain gets ignited by some chance violent encounter that sends him into a death spiral of hallucinations and maybe a life that never was that flashes before his eyes as he lies bleeding to death from stab wounds. I'm fairly certain Smith had seen Suicide play well before she started writing and recording this and have to wonder if she took some inspiration, as this sounds like a much more melodic and rocking take on some of the stuff they were doing. As far as the spoken word parts go, as much as I like "The End" by the Doors, I think this is a prime example of how much better Smith does this sort of thing than Morrison. Maybe not as iconic, but certainly better thought out and not as goofy. "Elegie" - Two eerie piano chords slam down with a weird wobbly, echoey guitar affect over top that sets the tone on this one, and we get a strange and almost disorienting vibe that seems like a meditation on loss and a memory of all the "friends can't be with us today". It's beautiful and creepy and makes me think Nick Cave must have been paying VERY close attention to this one. * "My Generation" - an extra but well worth seeking out if you want to hear what Smith sounds like doing a much more stereotypically "PUNK" sounding dong. It's raw and full of anger and the kind of sloppy amateurishness you would expect from a lot of the people she helped inspire. HIGHLIGHTS - "Gloria" - "Redondo Beach" - "Birdland" - "Kimberly" - "Break It Up" - "Land" - "Elegie" MIDLIGHTS - LOWLIGHTS - FINAL THOUGHTS Smith remains a weird sort of act. A more or less non-musician who would have described herself as a poet and visual artist, she got pulled into the music scene after she befriended and began working with musicians. She was very heavily influenced by Arthur Rimbaud's poetry and fashion sense, was a lover of both William Blake and William S. Burroughs, Allen Ginsburg and others. High brow stuff , some would argue. On the musical side though, her interests veered more towards the raw explosiveness of garage, and hard rock and loved Jimi Hendrix and early Van Morrison and the like. She especially adored Jim Morrison and the Doors who - say what you will about how well Morrison's poetry stands up ( I think a lot of it is pretty sophomoric and too impressed with itself) Smith at least must have appreciated the effort and the idea that Morrison seemed to embody that one could take somewhat pretentious and self-consciously "arty" words and pair them with that raw, sexual energy she saw on display elsewhere. And she did it. Far better than Morrison in my opinion. I can read her lyrics on paper without musical accompaniment and not feel embarrassed for her anyway. This approach in an of itself, while not wholly original ( Dylan had already given THE proof of concept after all) I think her idea to combine it with the almost completely opposite feel in music, the almost amateurish, rough around the edges sound is her unique contribution. A "what if the Stooges and Dylan teamed up?" scenario is not exactly what we got, but as close to that as had been done before maybe. And if you want to get into the if's and but's of it all - by that last track where she covers the Who's "My Generation" I think we more or less have arrived at the traditional punk SOUND even. It's sloppy, angry, and full of life, and maybe the perfect nugget to reach back and remove some of the polish from t make her statement. So is it Punk Rock? Yeah, definitely in attitude, and concept. And most definitely in execution and sound by that last track. It was a template though, and while she certainly didn't invent punk rock I think she was right on the cusp and heavily inspired those who would take the torch and run, and what are the next 20 years after but a reaction to and evolution of those ideas in rock music. This was a pleasure to revisit and makes me regret getting rid of the vinyl record a few years back. It's one I should have held on to. Its a quietly perfect album in my opinion, and if I had to criticize it in any way, it would be that it's got such a reputation that I think it's almost impossible to come to it as a new listener and have it live up to all the expectations. What helps is if you like and can recognize a lot of what it influenced. If you're not already primed, it's just less effective. Still great, but it loses something. I really wish she had a bigger discography from this era, but I fully respect her decision to step away for a while and have a real life. I have not looked much into her post-70s stuff, but maybe it's a good time while she's fresh in my mind. Possible turn-Offs might include: - some inclusion of poetry.... ewww - a lack of any fast paced and raucous punk you might have expected form the label - some vocals that could be an acquired taste for some You Might enjoy this if you: - love your rock on the garage side, but also appreciate the literary - love a lot of modern art rock and would like to investigate one of the progenitors - want some intensity in your music but not in terms of volume PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - Nah FURTHER LISTENING Precursors: - the poetry of Arthur Rimbaud - Call Me Burroughs by William S. Burroughs - The Angry Young Them by Them - Highway 61 Revisited by Bob Dylan - The Velvet Underground & Nico by The Velvet Underground - The Doors by The Doors - New York Dolls by New York Dolls - Are You Experienced by Jimi Hendrix Experience - The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars by David Bowie - Berlin by Lou Reed - Here Come the Warm Jets by Brian Eno - Fear by John Cale - Raw Power by The Stooges Contemporaries: - Go Girl Crazy! by The Dictators - Down by the Jetty by Dr. Feelgood - Nadir's Big Chance by Peter Hammill - Another Green World by Brian Eno - Blood on the Tracks by Bob Dylan - Born to Run by Bruce Springsteen - Young Americans by David Bowie - Siren by Roxy Music - Tonight's the Night by Neil Young - The Day the Earth Met the Rocket From the Tombs by Rocket from the Tombs Descendants: - Marquee Moon by Television - Cut by the Slits - Pink Flag by Wire - The Scream by Siouxsie and the Banshees - The Raincoats by The Raincoats - Germfree Adolescents by X-Ray Spex - Another Music in a Different Kitchen by Buzzcocks - Murmur by R.E.M - Bad Moon Rising by Sonic Youth - by the Smiths - Dry by PJ Harvey - Pussy Whipped by Bikini Kill – - From Her to Eternity by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds - Exile in Guyville by Liz Phair - There Is No-One What Will Take Care of You by Will Oldham - Live Through This by Hole - Moon Pix by Cat Power - All Hands on the Bad One by Sleater-Kinney - The Record by Boygenius - Comfort to Me Amyl and the Sniffers - Masseduction by St. Vincent

Hallgatása közben jöttem rá hogy a női előadókat mennyire nem értékelik és nem próbálják meg népszerűsíteni, hogy úgy beírják magukat a történelembe, mint pl a tegnapi john lennon. Mivel másabb? Sőt, olyan rockballadák vannak ebben az albumban amiket egy napon lehetne emlegetni a férfi társaival:((.

Catch up

will always love patti. even her misses are pretty great. this, this is not one of those. it is glorious, a masterclass in tension, calm, anger, beauty, aggression and peace. a must listen

Some off the dlsings were really bad. Hurt my head

Pretty awesome, lives up to its massive legacy. Both of the 9+ minute songs are first-listen-epic-as-fuck, especially "Land".

Gritty, punk, but the ballads are a little jarring

I went back and fourth on this as there are some really great songs such as Free Money and also songs that just wander along seemingly going nowhere, like Birdland and the Horses medley.

Good album, and I can see the historical importance. This is proto-punk.

Another must, Patti

Kind of unhinged, but somewhat interesting nonetheless.

I could listen to this. It's fine

Listenable but absolutely not my style

Couldn’t finish it. I don’t really understand her voice and all the inflections, even though I love Diamanda Galás and other extreme singing. Just really don’t understand it. I don’t understand how this had such a big impact on music back then, but maybe I had to be there to appreciate it? Cause I don’t hear what’s so special about the songwriting or poetry either, seems pretty generic to me. Overall just not my thing.

didn't love this as much now as I did when I was 15

Впервые я послушал этот альбом ещё очень-очень давно и уже тогда его полюбил. Но по какому-то странному стечению обстоятельств за все эти годы я его переслушивал всего пару раз. Видимо для того, чтобы сегодня по-настоящему кайфануть, во время его прослушивания. Однозначно один из величайших альбомов. Если честно, мне даже сложно выделить лучшие песни на этом альбоме, ведь они все идеальные. Лучшая песня: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo

Patti Smith is punk as fuck, in the real sense. You can tell because her debut album here is weird (affectionate) and sounds kinda silly at times (affectionate) and a bit scary (affectionate). Definitely an album/sound I appreciate more than like, and I feel like I'll need to give this record a couple more spins for the whole package to properly grok, but for now it deserves four stars. Fav tracks: Gloria, Free Money, Elegie

Se le quedó corta a Kate bush

The random selection is favouring me this week. Straight after REM Automatic For The People comes one of my absolute favourite albums of all time. This is always in my Top 10 list. It’s simply an amazing album. I was fortunate enough to see Patti Smith in London last year performing this album in full for its 50th anniversary. Following on in the spirit of the Velvet Underground the album opens with a reworked cover version, the definitive version of Gloria. John Cale’s fingerprints over the instrumentation. Redondo Beach is probably the track that dates slightly worse than anything else on the album with its reggae beat, the upbeat music is at contrast with the darkest of lyrics. Birdland is a beautiful almost spoken word free association poetry against a simple percussive but increasingly violent piano. I think this song is probably the litmus test of the album, if you love this, you’ll love this album. If it leaves you cold then the whole album is going to leave you feeling what is this. For clarity, I absolutely love it. Free Money is the closest this album comes to a straightforward rock song, a love song to boot. Again starting with just vocals and piano, it builds as the band comes in. The drum fills build and build and propel the song into its chorus. Skipping on a couple of tracks as I promised myself I’d stop doing track by track reviews Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de) gives the album its title and is the sprawling masterpiece of the album. A nine minute epic in three parts. Poetry, rock and roll, psychodelia it builds tension and releases throughout the track. At times it resembles a conventional rock and rock track at others it dissolves into barely controlled chaos with multiple ideas running over the top of each other. I don't have the words to really describe how much I love this track and album as a whole so 5 stars will have to do If you enjoy this album I would also recommend checking out the movie In My Fathers Den that features this album prominently

Not for me at all. Didn’t finish

This was my first time listening to Patti Smith intently, and I really enjoyed this album. The only reason it's not a 5/5 is because some songs didn't flow well in succession. In the context of the era, I think this is important, and with some tweaks, it would easily be a 5/5.

This is the definitive cover of Gloria. It drops off that opening track for me at least. I have a couple other Patti Smith albums, none of which I have felt the need to listen to in a long time.

Classic!!!!

Loved Blinded

Some of these songs annoyed me

I don’t like this as much as her other record on here but it’s improvisational energy is definitely something, especially after the first few tracks which I wasn’t digging as much.

It's 4.5

Mixed feelings on this one, some of the songs are fantastic compositions where the music matches the vocals perfectly. Then some of songs were just a cacophony, where Patti’s voice sounded grating as fuck to add to the shit show of a sound. I felt like Patti must’ve been a massive influence on PJ Harvey, a lot of the songs I felt would sound great as a PJ song, or an unrefined version of one of her songs. I actually did some research after having this epiphany, and found that PJ Harvey has categorically denied Patti’s influence on her music, calling the link “lazy journalism”, despite that I don’t think she’s beating the charges

This is Patti Smith’s first record and it took the rock and roll world by storm. It has aa authentic gritty underground feel to it that I love. The lyrics are interesting and provocative as you would expect from a poet who decided to put her poetry to music. The vocals are strong and evocative and the music is excellent. The whole thing is by turns gritty, raw, and underproduced and beautiful, powerful, and engaging. You can hear her influence in a lot of what would become American punk.

I've only listened to Patti Smith a bit -- I own an lp copy of Wave, which I liked ok, but never really connected with. The first three songs on that album are really good. After that ... eh. I think I was too young when I listened to it. But now, listening to Patti as a more mature listener ... not sure how different it is, truly Apple Music named this to their top 100 ever list, and in the headnote raised the question of what does punk mean, exactly. I think that is an interesting question, especially when you think about the New York scene alongside the London one. Gloria is really interesting ... it seems to forge a direct connection between garage and punk. Redondo Beach and Free Money both sound like early Blondie, which comes as a surprise, but also makes a lot of sense. Birdland is a reminder of why I'm a Patti Smith skeptic ... it sounds like the more experimental side of Velvety Underground, if they swapped out Nico for a Beat poet. Not a big fan. (Musically, it sounds a lot like VU's Heroin, actually.) But on the second go round I liked it better, so maybe if I listened to this album several times, everything would be different. Who can say? Land is interesting. It combines all of it ... including the draw from Sixties pop that is a critical component of Blondie's vocabulary. It builds into a masterpiece of ... whatever you would call this. You could connect it to the better / jamming side of Them or the Yardbirds, or early Stooges, or ... not sure. It cooks, but doesn't constrain her verbal riffing, the reaching for what's just beyond the horizon side of her approach. Good album. In my earliest encounters with the PS Situation, I felt like a big part of her mystique was always that she was a Poet. That set her apart. Not just some civilian songwriter, but -- an actual, official Poet. But ... the first thing of hers I ever encountered was, of all places, on the back of a used copy of the lp Edgar Winter's White Trash which I picked up at Cheapo Records in Cambridge on a whim. The album was supposed to be good, according to the Rolling Stone Record Guide. I found it boring. On the back was a poem by Patti Smith, which seemed to me (I was 15, so -- who knows) like self-consciously Arty gobbledygook. And on this album (Horses), at one point, there's this thing in Kimberly about bats -- and the "violet, violent sky" ... that seems obvious and gimmicky to me. And a little bit representative of her writing. That's the Beat side of things for me. Not a compliment. Anyway ... I just find that the thing that's supposed to be her superpower is much dodgier than her reputation leads one to expect. That's what I'm trying to convey. It doesn't matter, really. But if you're not buying the poetry, then the whole enterprise shifts. Basically, I'm saying that Patti Smith tracks with Velvet Underground -- for me, I like certain songs, but I'm just not an enthusiast. My appreciation is more intellectual than felt. I can see why they're important to rock history and why people love them, but I'm just not really ever going to make that kind of connection.

I enjoyed this album for its spirit and bravery as opposed to hearing songs that I really love. It's funny, I had completely forgotten "Free Money" and as soon as it started I had a vivid recollection of a mixed tape from a long-ago beau, because he had put that song on it, and I never really liked the song that much, although I loyally listened to it a million times. I was very moved by "Kimberly," probably my favorite song on here.

Der er noget nostalgi, der trækker op.

I listen to these albums on my 46 year old hot dad walks around the neighborhood (ladies calm down, I'm married). If I find myself doing little two steps to the songs, it's closer to a 5. If I'm staring at my phone seeing how much longer I have to pound the pavement to the tracks, it's closer to a 1. This one I kind of just zoned out while Patti was speaking about God knows what but it went on forever. The whole album kind of felt like it was winged in the studio. Stream of consciousness style, especially with whatever "Land" is all about. There's enough musically that this got to a 2 but just barely.

As some point, you can hear the moment she went insane (pretty sure around song 10). 2 stars

Was a 3 for me until the final two songs, which are amazing!

"Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine." Damn, that's a great lyric! And perhaps one of the greatest opening lines for an album. It signifies that this album is going to break the rules of conventionality. The rules of what popular music, and poetry, are supposed to be are subverted throughout. A monumental achievement.

Don't love it

never listened to patti smith prior to this but i fully thought she was a folk singer lol. this was a bit too jarring for me today im afraid but some were okay

6/10… art rock / proto punk / *1975

I didn't like this! 2

She's from Deptford so thats cool, but the music isn't really for me.

Listened to this years ago and didn't get it at all. Was looking forward to a fresh listen but it still didn't land so I've concluded I just don't really like it!

It's horses by Patti smith there's little better still quiet a lot, but in the grand scheme of released music, little is better

Not for me

Já ouvi tanto esse nome, e já vi em tantos lugares a capa desse disco, que acabei criando uma alta expectativa. Às vezes não gosto do vocal dela, quando ela o estende em longos momentos. Parece uma Bob Dylan feminina. Porém… O disco não é composto apenas desses momentos mais “Folk”. Possui horas que o ritmo aperta, e guitarras impressionantes tomam conta, e a voz de Smith lança vôo. Nessas horas, o disco me conquista inteiramente. E esses momentos são tão bons que deixaram minha opinião do álbum sólida. Gostaria que o disco inteiro fosse assim! Quem sabe outro dela? Muito bom. 4/5

This album was an overload to my senses

She sounds like a human airhorn on „Birdland“ so that‘s got to account for something. No but seriously, very influential album.

I wont front like I had any intention to enjoy this album. The second I saw the album cover I was like 'this is gonna be ass' and I was right. Not a single good song, hated the singers voice, no musically impressive segments and writing tries to draw meaning from nonsense. Fuck it, 1 on the board for this dookie shit

Svårt att bestämma mig vad jag tycker, trots att jag lyssnat några varv nu. Svag fyra landar jag väl i till slut.

Stark trea! Gillar sound och drag, men var några låtar jag inte riktigt pallade.

I knew the name Patti Smith. I knew she was a musician and that’s about it, so this is my introduction. It is certainly different. I appreciate that she did what she wanted and made her own sound. Is this supposed to be punk? I don’t even know what that word means anymore. Ultimately I liked it. I’m not sure if I like it enough to check out more from her, but I like what it was for its time. 3.5 stars

Ok classic

- Tracks longer than 3:59: Yes -Long tracks interesting or special: Nit as far as I’m concern. -Album shorter than 58 minutes: Yes. -Will listen to album again: Not a chance -Overall: I always thought I didn’t like Patty Smith. I’m not 100% sure why, so I figured maybe this was going to be one of those albums that set me straight. It did not; I was right. I usually really try to listen to every song on an album even if I don’t enjoy the first few. With this one I simply couldn’t. Her voice was so grating to my ears I had to stop after track three. Looking at the review stats it looks like I’m in the minority. So be it.

Not really my speed but had some cool moments nonetheless

Initially didn’t like it and then it grew on me as I kept listening. I think if it caught me at the right moment I would love it, but this isn’t that moment. I thought it was at times enjoyable and at times repetitive and grating. Interesting to listen to but not something I think I’ll listen to again. Fav song: Break It Up Least fav: Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de)

Not the biggest fan of this. Liked the cover though Specific rating - 3.4 Fav song - free money Least fav - Land:Horses / Land of a thousand Dances

I don’t mean to compare Patti Smith to Maryanne Faithful (there is no comparison, really), but i just listened to them back-to-back. Smith has the talent and the confidence to *own* her material that MF abundantly lacks. Smith’s power ballads have a masculine, muscular quality — they’re not always my cup of tea musically (though some are just great!), but I’m impressed and entertained by her creativity and self-possession. Without “Land; Horses/Land of a Thousand Dances,” (which is epic) there is probably no “Flying Cowboys” by Rickie Lee Jones, a favorite album of mine. A solid 4.