Album Summary
The Marshall Mathers LP is the third studio album by American rapper Eminem, released on May 23, 2000, by Aftermath Entertainment and Interscope Records. The album was produced mostly by Dr. Dre and Eminem, along with The 45 King, the Bass Brothers, and Mel-Man. Recorded over a two-month period in several studios around Detroit, the album features more introspective lyricism, including Eminem's thoughts on his rise from rags to riches, the criticism of his music, and his estrangement from his family and wife. A transgressive work, it incorporates horrorcore and hardcore hip hop, while also featuring satirical songs. Featured appearances include Dido, RBX, Sticky Fingaz, Bizarre, Snoop Dogg, Xzibit, Nate Dogg, and D12. Like its predecessor, The Marshall Mathers LP was surrounded by significant controversy upon its release, while also propelling Eminem to the forefront of American pop culture. Criticism centered on lyrics that were considered violent, homophobic, misogynistic, as well as the reference to the Columbine High School massacre. Lynne Cheney criticized the lyrics at a United States Senate hearing, while the Canadian government considered refusing Eminem's entry into the country. Despite the controversy of the album, it received acclaim from critics, who praised Eminem's lyrical ability and considered the album to have emotional depth. The album debuted at number one on the Billboard 200, staying atop for eight consecutive weeks. A significant commercial success compared to the release of The Slim Shady LP just the previous year, the album sold 1.78 million copies in its first week, which made it among the fastest-selling studio albums in the United States. The album produced the singles "The Real Slim Shady", "The Way I Am", "Stan", "I'm Back" and "Bitch Please II". Among other publications, Rolling Stone named it the best album of 2000. The Marshall Mathers LP has been included in several lists of the greatest albums of all time and is widely regarded as Eminem's best album. It has sold 21 million copies worldwide, making it one of the best-selling albums of all time, and is certified 11× platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). It was nominated for Album of the Year and won Best Rap Album at the 2001 Grammy Awards, while "The Real Slim Shady" won Best Rap Solo Performance. The Marshall Mathers LP 2, the album's sequel, was released in 2013.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Legendary album. And if it upsets you or you’re offended, that’s exactly what he wants.
Relistening to this for the first time in a while, it took me back to when I bought it as a teenager upon its release. It's still feels just as angry and ferocious, in a very authentic way. The dude is fucking MAD at everybody and the shit that he was getting from the press and his haters. Not for nothing, it shouldn't be controversial to say that the homophobic/sexist stuff is very uncomfortable to listen to (I assume that's the point) and even if Eminem says he's joking about it to make us mad... is that payoff worth it for what's being put into the world? I dunno. His rhyming structure is seriously next-level and really intricate, and it's wild to go on the trips that this guy is taking with his lyrics as you're wondering where they're going to land in the end. The beats are timeless, warm and precise and accentuating every mood on the album. Truly a very important record and one for the ages. I think it's okay that some of it didn't age well.
glorious flow, great bragging - state of the art for 2000 hip hop. unfortunately, that also includes packing every possible second on to the CD, ending up with an exhausting listen, despite a clutch of highlights.
Legendary, funny, rude and groundbreaking! Love it in particular Stan.
I have listened to this album a few dozen times, but never with real intention, and probably never on anything but shitty car speakers and not in YEARS. After only a few tracks, I'm reminded that I love this album. Unparalleled rhyme arrangements, one of the best flows in all of rap, and some of the most truthful, disturbing reflections and scathing indictments of the hypocritical country I live in. I also don't think I can point to a rapper that gives such a transparently emotional delivery either. People got pissed at Eminem because he reflected their values back at them without the thin veneer of "polite and civilized." They somehow think they're different than what he's talking about. He makes great points about the US, and won't allow himself to be blamed for people's unwillingness to have difficult conversations with their kids about art, sex, drugs, and violence. I think a lot of people tend to dismiss the argument he makes, but I'd wager those people aren't introspective enough to see he's talking about them specifically. We pretend a lot here, and if people want change, we need to be honest with ourselves about who we really are. Fat fucking chance though, right? Eminem is a generational talent. I'll die on this hill. I normally write these reviews while I'm listening, and there have been maybe 3 albums of 600+ that have kept me so involved and paying strict attention that I find it hard to write at the same time. This is the most difficult one of those so far. I can't even take notes. His imagery and delivery are cinematic and demand my full attention. I enjoyed this more today than I ever have, in large part because I UNDERSTOOD it this time. I understand that it's a black mirror he aims at us all, and I understand who and what I'm seeing within it. I saw reviews talking about how the lyrics have aged poorly over the last 25 years, but I'd say they were of their time, and as much as we'd like to think it's true, it's a lie that things are any different today. I truly cannot wait until the lyrics are a time capsule and not reflective of who we are as a country. That day damned sure isn't today Outstanding album. Definitely listening again during my workout tonight ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
"Half the shit I say, I just make it up to make you mad, so kiss my white naked ass" Oh nooo he says awful, crude things and I'm offended!! Pfft babies
Fav song: Stan
One of the top if not the top Hip Hop album ever IMHO
Put it in a rocket and launch it into the outer space, so the 1st thing aliens hear from Earth realm is this piece of art ❣️
Had to wash my ears out with soap after this one.
y u so mad bro
The good stuff is good but you're trapped with the less good stuff for at least 5 minutes a pop. 7 keepers in 18 (39%) 3 klunkers (17%) 22
8/10 - besides being unable to listen to kim, no skip album even the skits Fav Tracks: the hits Heard before? --------–- ✅ Saved a new Song? ----- ❌ Saved Album? -------–-- ✅ Will Listen Again? ---––– ✅ Album Cover ----------– *whisper whisper whisper* / 10
Проблема рэп альбомов в том, что львиная доля обсуждений приходится на лирику, ну и типа, я чутка послушал, понял что речь там о некоторой рефлексии по популярности, про сбежавшего батька и т.д., но зачем об этом говорить если вы можете почитать об этом в описании на странице? Очевидные бенгеры Stan и The Real Slim Shady действительно хороши, помимо них понравилась Remeber Me У альбома прикольный семплинг и продюсирование, задающее интересную атмосферу, киношностью напоминающее ву-танг, разве что без сюрреализма. Много шуток и поп-культурных приколов, в итоге альбом балансирует на контрастах эдакой угрожающей атмосферы и приколяндриев. Ну и ещё любопытна подача, много игры голосом, разные стили читки и вот это всё, всё же бро талантлив, базару нет. итс окей. Ема увожаю, но альбомами, всё же, не слухаю.
Sos la p*ta cabra Eminem. Buen LP del artista, único como él.
Como álbum se me hizo largo y con muchas canciones que no. Pero “Stan” es de las mejores canciones que escuché con esta página. Es como una película en canción, un viaje.
I liked the skits in between
Feigned anger in every song. Once you think you’ve figured out the formula why change? No thanks
Listens: 3 (and many more over the years) Standout Tracks: Stan, Remember Me, Criminal I've basically been listening to this album since it came out. I was 12. I probably should not have been listening to Eminem at 12, but oh well. I turned out to be a perfectly normal adult, so, like, whatever. If you can get past all of the anger, fake murder, blowjob sounds and alleged homophobia, there are some real introspective themes going on in this album: - hero/celebrity worship and obsession - drug use - feelings of inadequacy (in your career, in life, in relationships) - dealing with overwhelming attention and popularity in the media - the appalling hypocrisy in the media and in popular culture (the insinuation of being indirectly responsible for school shootings à la being a bad role model, on the heels of then-president Clinton getting his dick sucked in the Oval office by his ) - all manner of family relationship problems - censorship - not big screen TVs, blunts, 40s and bitches He also clearly tapped into something that especially resonated with suburban white kids; whether it was genuine or kids just "thought it was cool" is up for debate. I am not sure if this is a "Middle America" thing or if there is some sort of class divide here, but many kids looking to "rebel" against their parents in the 2000s were listening to Eminem and wearing baggy pants below their ass and bleaching their hair... or trying to. For a lot of people my age, and for me specifically, this was the first rap music we ever heard. It was explicit, hardcore, and a lot of stuff went over my head at 12 years old. It was not at all appropriate for me to be experiencing. But then again, neither was watching South Park (MOM! Kitty's being a dildo!), trawling adult AOL chat rooms, scamming kids on Neopets, downloading porn and pirating music on Kazaa/Limewire/Bearshare and whatever else I got up to on the computer. Needless to say, this album is great.
Not for me.
On several tracks I found myself thinking, "Wow, this hasn't aged well"... but this was pretty controversial stuff even when it was first released. That's the point. I remember itching to get his CDs as soon as they dropped knowing in the back of my head that they were likely to upset my parents, and that was part of the allure. Now, listening as an adult, the subject matter is challenging, but much of it is written with the idea that it will offend SOMEONE and Eminem puts that disclaimer out there throughout the album. Eminem's delivery makes his albums worth the listen.
A bit conflicted on this. It's obviously groundbreaking and perhaps reshaped rap, and I'm sure Em was playing a character. However, taken literally, it's a pretty hard listen. Age does things to music, sometimes. Middle of the road mid 2s.
I need to come back to write a longer review for this because I have a lot of thoughts! Eminem was a staple of my TRL upbringing. Would I think differently of his, admittedly dated and at-times cringey, provocative schtick if it were not for nostalgia? Probably. But, whether its for the way that songs like The Real Slim Shady evoke a specific time and place for me or the fact that in 2026 tracks like Kim and Stan can still make me viscerally feel something (even if that something is disgust), I think Marshall Mathers is a genius. I can't quite give this a 5 because of the skits and because it is a tough listen all the way through, but it has been a real delight to revisit this era of Eminem.
My overriding feeling about this album is one of fuck around and find out. Em is quick to blame others for their reaction to his first album when the whole premise of the album was to elicit a reaction by saying stuff that was deliberately provocative. If you don’t want controversy, don’t court it. It shouldn’t be a surprise that writing lyrics to shock, causes shock and so I can’t help but think that he wants the controversy, probably because that’s his brand. If he is genuinely upset about it, I’d be surprised at as it would make him stupid. More likely he knows and is using that as his fuel. Often throughout the album he uses the ‘this is happening which is worse than me just saying it’ argument as if that absolves him of saying what he does. Two wrongs don’t make a right though Em….sorry. And whilst he may be right to point out some of the hypocrisy, and focus of media attention away from real issues, it’s also hypocritical of himself to claim some moral high ground. Not all criminality is on the same level but it’s still all crime. So whilst he’s right in some senses when he says in Who knew that there are things ‘worse’ than he is in terms of bad influence, that doesn’t negate him from being a bad influence also.
Genuinely transgressive and innovative at a key moment for rap music. Eminem has fallen so far, but only because he started so high.
Legende, aber die Beats sind nicht alle gut gealtert.
I was around fourteen when I heard "My Name Is" on the radio and naturally loved it—I was fourteen, after all! However, about a year later, I just couldn't get into The Marshall Mathers LP anymore. Sure, the album has plenty of great beats (like "The Real Slim Shady") and you can't really deny Eminem's skills, but unfortunately, he wastes his gifts on misogyny, homophobia, and other toxic behavior. This makes the record completely unlistenable and off-putting. Besides, I doubt anyone needs to hear "Stan" ever again.
Og eminem 5/5
Kuten jo puhuttiin, old eminen could never be topped. Stan on myös yksk surillisimmista kappaleista mitä ole koskaan kuullut
Yeah man. I get it.
What a strange album to deal with, and a strange artist. Parts of this (Kim?!?!) do make me genuinely shocked this guy was once one of the biggest artists in America. Other parts are just juvenile and idiotic rather than intimidating as he intended. Parts of this force me to respect his massive chops as a rapper, while others make me suspect he’s always been wildly overrated as the Great White Hope of hip-hop. And then there is Stan, which I do genuinely believe is one of the greatest songs of all time. The ironic thing about it is that the song doesn’t really work at all without the surrounding album, which I like much less. How can Eminem’s confrontation with his own image and negative influence have any impact if the rest of the album isn’t full of his signature murder fantasies and petty dickery? So tl;dr: I don’t know how to feel about Eminem. He’s a clear talent who I think has spent 90%+ of his career wasting that talent, but who am I to say what’s a waste and what’s not? Either way, this album will almost certainly be his lasting monument through music history.
No.
Альбом о жизни Эминема. Не особо слушаю реп, но пара крутых треков есть. Оценка: 8/10
‘Kill You’ almost made me turn off the album. ‘Stan’ is such a better song. A few of the lyrics come across as too ‘edgy’. Maybe because in 2000’s it wasn’t? Now, I feel like a lot of these lyrics belong on a bad TikTok music compilation. Beats are good but couldn’t finish
kinda hard to sit through tbh
Has some interesting hits but often settles for shock value. It would benefit from a tighter Playlist. Bloated and ok
Good album
A few good tracks in isolation, but a very depressing album that I wouldn't revisit.
Masterpiece Si acaso no me encantó una, pero acá prácticamente no hay fallos, que beats más potentes se arrojaron en este álbumsote Es también muy particular la forma en la que utiliza la narrativa o tal vez este elemento de "salir de la 4ta pared" durante muchas partes del álbum Recomendado y para reescuchar full
I used to love Eminem as a kid, but drifted away from his music. This album reminded me why I enjoyed his music in the first place. Real Slim Shady is just an amazing song. The rest of the project flows great with the rest continuing his narrative about his life.
OK ya 2 ou 3 tubes absolus mais le reste est assez ... mid ?
Never been a fan
Nice album. The lyrics are great, he is a great writer, although sometimes he is too hard for me, clearly due to his experiences in that kind of environment. But my main problem is with the kind of beat he uses. Not my favourite.
fun
The only Eminem song I listened to before I did this challenge was Stan. And well, anyone growing up in the 2000s also has heard The Real Slim Shady in some parodic form at the very least if they didn't know the song before. I preferred the group he was apart of in D12. As a white person (because when you want to critically talk about Eminem it's important to state your race), I just preferred the classics like Public Enemy and De La Soul when getting into hip hop. But I always found too many other white people that, when having to name a rapper they liked or whatever any kind of hip hop they would ever want to listen to, the answer was always this fucking guy. Every time. And man, does The Marshall Mathers LP sound exactly like the year 2000. At least all the pop culture stuff, that precious pre-9/11 2000s culture preserved in amber. Especially the homophobia (something he meta-references in his 'Steve Berman' skit and his verse on Bitch Please II). Eminem's rapping, flow, technique are his real calling cards among his, say, South Park-esque approach to songwriting aside from a few more serious songs on the album. The Way I Am, for me, might be the best song off this album because you can hear how he has to weigh late 90s/2000's news media's blaming society's woes on him in the era of Columbine, 'violent video games', and whatever shit Oprah was going on about. Amityville also reminded me of his time with D12, wish he did more songs like that. Kim is weird in that I like the beat and how the song could go if it didn't sound overly misogynistic. Like, way too over the top. And we could go on and on about the overt homophobia that he's also known for on this album, that's a whole fucking saga I'm not going to hash out. The edgelord schtick is basically what runs America these days, but like the shit he raps about is just a bit too vivid in description before it sounds like a fun fuck yeah rock and roll kind of adventure. At the very least, it detracts from the strengths of himself as a rapper and the lasting quality of The Marshall Mathers LP. While it's transgressive at its best, it is still a double edged sword that is very hard to make it work, let alone age well. The Marshall Mathers LP is very much of its time, but the artistic talents of Eminem are still right there which are what made him into a household name. The edgey/humor edgelord schtick, as he does point out in The Way I Am, predates him and he's not some creative innovative force in laying out misogynistic/homophobic verses. That stuff was always baked into our society and later on hip hop. And I do think that news media and the forces of media conglomerates at play did try to prop him up too much as a negative influence on kids, as though parental or other environmental factors didn't cause kids to act in some behavior or manner that Eminem allegedly condones. It's just that at the end of the day, I just prefer hearing other rappers than wanting to go hear Eminem's line of work. The Marshall Mathers LP is certainly a hip hop classic, but Operation: Doomsday came out the year before and is just a significantly better album than The Marshall Mathers LP could ever be. It even has better usages of homophobia. To keep it slim: this record is fine I guess.
ok…
TL;DR: Anything worthwhile was released as a single. The rest is indefensible. Don't waste your time. BEFORE: Never been a fan but at least this is his older stuff and Stan is a classic. Not sure I am up for 72 minutes of this. AFTER: While I knew some of this stuff by reputation, I was still not prepared for the level of violent misogyny and homophobia in this. While I can see the obvious skill of his delivery, the lyrics are often abhorrent and lazily hateful. There are a handful of interesting beats but a lot of this is very samey - a basic beat with some jaunty but minor key synths and an underwhelming hook. This does not hold up nearly as well as the best of his contemporaries, and most of the appeal seems to come from shock value which does nothing for me. HIGHLIGHTS: Stan is still a classic. The Way I Am is a powerful slice of self-awareness that throws the rest of the album into relief. The Real Slim Shady has a playful tone that is enough to overcome its worst lyrics. Drug Ballad was less repellent that some of the other songs and the guest spots on Bitch Please II were a welcome nostalgia hit - RIP Nate Dogg. LOWLIGHTS: Kill You, Who Knew, Amityville, Kim, Under the Influence and Criminal pair hateful lyrics with mediocre music - Kim adding a furious delivery that is hard to listen to. Marshall Mathers has a better backing track that it wastes on relentless homophobia. Remember Me and I'm Back are completely forgettable and might as well be the same song. The skits range from inessential to genuinely disgusting. This album is way too long given the quality. VERDICT: One genuine classic and two decent singles are not enough to overcome the overall impression of an obviously skilled rapper wasting his time spraying irredeemable edgelord nonsense over mediocre instrumentals. I felt like I needed a shower after listening to this. 1 star.
When I worked in a record store in 1999-2000, we sold so many damn copies of this and I was amazed at how people of all races loved Eminem. I was really turned off back then by the misogyny and homophobia and just generally did not listen to this kind of thing. Still am turned off by it, but I (rightly or wrongly) don't necessarily feel as offended by it now - life has gone on and turns out there are things much worse than edgy lyrics. Never listened to this before, will likely never listen to it again, but it was an extremely compelling listen and I give it credit for that.
Two things can be possible at once. The Marshall Mathers LP is an artistic breakthrough AND inexcusably misogynistic, homophobic, and sophomoric. Twenty-five years later, this sounds like edgelord rap, basically a 4chan full-length. Eminem can talk about Slim Shady being a character and how the Marshall Mathers LP reflected his real experiences and mindset at the time. Fine. But none of this shit is OK, and I can't get beyond its more noxious moments ("Kill You," "Who Knew," "The Way I Am," "Under the Influence," etc.) Dre's production is great, Eminem is undeniably talented, and the Marshall Mathers LP sold 25 million copies, so its legacy is set. Counterpoint: Fuck this album. Rounding up to two stars because of "Stan," which owes as much to Dido as it does Em's lyrics.
There's a lot of "slut" mentions in this album. The only song I think I truly liked was "Stan." There were others that were catchy but said "slut" a lot which dampened the song. The whole album he's like "you guys don't understand me" and "they punish me even though I'm saying the things they're thinking" like shut up bruh. He thinks he's special for sure
Holy this album would not fly if released today, but at least theres some good flows Top 5: Stan, The Real Slim Shady, Kill You, Drug Ballad, Kim
Good album, want to kisten again looking at the lyrics
Almost got a 4, but too many skits
So many of the lyrics are inexcusable. A bunch of big hits and great production though.
Oh, directo a mi infancia. Qué manera de escuchar estos temas. Que locurita la de MM. Y así todo metiendo hitazos mundiales como Stan o The real slim shady. Seguramente un dos o tres ambientes se compró con éste disco. Gran produ de los hermanos Bass. Las instrumentales son buenisimas. Puntos altos: The way I am, Stan, The way I am y Under the influence. Le baja una estrella los (por los menos) dos temas femicidas.
“Mi disco favorito” ~ Tadeo, 14 años de edad. Muy bueno, me gusto.
Los primeros 10 temas son una joya. Después se hace demasiado largo y repetitivo. Qué picante era Marshall
He’s such a good rapper and I will say it feels *slightly* less misogynistic than the slim shady LP but the homophobia really jumps out. Idk. I still remember so many of the songs so well and I do think it’s a remarkable album but it’s a tough listen at times.
This album has one of the greatest millennial songs of all time. Nobody would remember the Bum Bum Song if it wasn't for Eminem. I thank him for making the most perfect '00 pop culture references. The interpolation of Summer Girls is another moment that shines. Where this album falls apart is the skits and the domestic violence- it's really graphic and disturbing. oh, & +1 for Devon Sawa.
Depresivo, me dio rabia escucharlo. Supongo que eso es lo que queria transmitir m y m considerando el momento y lo que queria lograr.
This is one of very few hiphop/rap albums I really like. I guess it's because the songs also have a musical element so not "pure" rapping. Anyway for me a good album.
You can't deny the lyricism and self awareness. A cultural phenomenon at the time, not sure it resonates with me as I've grown up and there's a good percentage of angry teenager in the songs.
noi lyriikat o kyl välil vähä liian nasty
Dreadful
M+m is chill and too angry
fun, interesting, good
Masterpiece of anger and harbinger of things to come
I first heard Eminem on the radio about 25 years ago. I don't remember what song it was, but every other word seemed to be me... and I dismissed him as a self-centered douche with a whiney nasally voice. Since that time, I never indulged in his music, but I have admired his charity and humanitarian efforts. And those efforts helped me to approach this album with an open mind and hope. After finishing, I'm finding that my initial impression was on the nose... at least as far as this album is concerned. This album embodies the worst human traits; hate, misogyny, homophobia, violence (including murder) and unfettered egotism. How many times did he say that if the listener didn't like this they should suck his d***??? Sure, the production is pristine... but to use the expression, it's lipstick on a pig. There is not one song on here that I would ever care to hear again. Clearly Eminem is working through deeply troubling personal issues in this album, and on a human level I really hope that he has found a modicum of solace since recording this. His charity and humanitarian work would seem to be evidence of that, and if that's reflected in future music, I'm certainly open to it. But The Marshall Mathers LP just isn't for me.
The Marshall Mathers LP is undoubtedly one of the most polarizing records and interesting discussions in hip-hop history. The lines between Marshall and his music, in this early era especially, are blurry to the point where no one is entirely certain of where one persona begins and another ends, not even he himself, and that is what much of this trio of records is about. Despite this, thanks to the necessary structural pillar that Stan is, and a quarter century having passed, it's much easier to look at this as a gripping artistic introspection with fitting moments of horrocore than something that is reliant on pure shock value. It all comes down to a matter of opinion, even more so than with most music, and while I still find myself divided I find myself more intrigued by the approach than merely disgusted. I am often still disgusted, but I think that is undoubtedly part of the point and a goal of the listening experience here. That is also to say that much of the subject matter and lyrical focus here is profound in it's portrayal of Marshall's family struggles, drug problems, and how success is changing his life in ways that are not always for the better. When looking at any facet of the record beyond the lyrics, everything is outstanding. The production and the rapping ability are top notch, even in the darker moments it is difficult not to look at the rhymes as supremely clever and well put together, his talent was unmatched at the time. While I don't gravitate towards Eminem's music as much as other hip-hop greats but I think is may be his peak and I could see myself coming back to some tracks here, at least, more often. 1 re-listen Favorite Tracks: Stan, The Way I Am, The Real Slim Shady, Criminal, Drug Ballad
I remember hearing The Real Slim Shady on the radio. Yes, public radio. Heavy play time. To be clear, alter ego Slim Shady and I do not share the same moral code. To anyone who grades this a one for obvious reasons, I fully respect that. Could an album be more polarizing? I would imagine that there are more 1s and 5s than anything in between. This album is so much harder to tolerate than it was at age 20-something. There is so much wrong and inappropriate here. Still, it was a huge success and culture-changing. If you don't suspend reality and alter your mind/approach when listening, this has to be an instant shut-off. Ultimately, for me, a 5 with a big fat asterisk.
This is fine, he’s a capable rapper and lyricist and Dre brings his customary magic but it veers towards juvenelia quite a lot and the misogyny while about “characters” is often hard to swallow. It’s entertaining but a bit unremitting for 75 minutes
Don't understand why this album is here? One of the worst "big" rap albums of all time.
Outstanding
Very funny and very very good.
Rap is not my bag at all but this was at least better than The Slim Shady LP
One of my favorites. I’ve listened to it a ton. As a teen, I was more into SSLP, but, once I hit college, I got way into this. Truthfully, I like all aspects of the Slim Shady persona; I think a lot of what he pulls off is even more brilliant than it at first seems. It goes beyond just the wordplay and the flow. Every song is on my liked list. (No skits, though; some of those are crazy).
I've been listening to hip hop since 1980.This record here is rap. Mr. Inem is a damn good rapper and the Dr. makes good sounding beats that are technically advanced but seem to have zero connection to hip hop. G Funk was old, I 'spose, and this is new..no need to pay out on all those samples.Keep all the money in house. The aspiration seems to be full crossover, without losing "authenticity.." Eminem is aware and good on him. He knows he didn't invent shocking tales of violence or bragging about drug use...he knows who Schooly D is and the Geto Boys and horrorcore in general. He knows they procede him by more than a decade in some cases. He is part of the culture and steeped in it. Eminem is just fine, I don't hate him at all. Would I rather listen to Kool Keith or MF Doom...you bet.
I mean some of the tunes on this man, unreal
I remember trying to buy this album on release day, but not being old enough because it was labelled as “explicit” so I had to go home and get my brother who was over 16 to get it for me. It was a popular album for a while for me in my youth. Listening to it now, it hasn’t aged very well, even if we know more about Eminem now and what he was dealing with at the time. Anyway, the hits still hit.
To say the least the last Eminem album did not sit well with me. I am not excited for this. Oh my god. I don't even wanna say anything about this it just sucks. It's just horrible. He looks like he belongs in an aquarium. This was a good song before he started singing. Genuinely what is this. Fuck you Eminem. I wish Christina Aguilera killed you. I wish this goddamn alum didn't get published. I enjoy exactly one (1) Eminem song and that's only because Rihanna's on it. Fuck you Eminem. I truly feel bad for his daughters imagine your dad spews this kinda filth. Fuck you Eminem. It's not even a matter of prudism or anything it's just not good. Favourite: The Real Slim Shady Least favourite: Kim
Did the real slim shady ever stand up?
I recognize that Eminem is a wordsmith and an excellent rapper. I'm also not a prude. Profanity doesn't bother me, but I don't like hearing about abuse so this one's a hard pass. As I've gotten older, I like rap less than I did when I was younger and thought it was the cool thing to do.
That’s why they call him the goat
His rapping is nimble and sharp, but the content is too socially disaffected for my enjoyment. On the gardening to rap rating scale, this is 3 - bring out the sheers and violently deadhead.
Sad, undernourished human. Sad, undernourished ideas. Sad, undernourished music. He's got skills but he's a moron and this is an expression of that
9.5/10
I was very surprised how good this album was. Really enjoyed it.
I can absolutely appreciate the skill and talent involved, and I generally appreciate satire in most forms. But some of the references to the violence are hard to listen to, especially knowing how real that violence is for so many women. I loved this when I was younger, but having experienced violence in relationships myself it hits differently now.
I heard Gen Z is trying to cancel this guy.
Los primeros 10 temas son una joya. Después se hace demasiado largo y repetitivo. Qué picante era Marshall
Don't need to listen to this to know it's getting the full 5 stars. Had it on day of release at 15 so it's in that sweet spot for music you love when you're becoming a real person. A load of this is nostalgia but there's no doubt Eminem is an amazing talent. If Ice Cube agrees then it's probably true. Are there issues with the lyrics with 25 years of hindsight, of course but put that against a song like Stan and nothing is black and white. The Eminem v Slim Shady element was never so pronounced. Childish nonsense meets an artist at the top of their game. Great to hear this again.
Revolutionary for the time. Man, should it be a 5? I think I am going 5 on this.
Masterpiece.
Hype at times, utterly harrowing at others
A couple too many songs leaning on samples for the hook for me
esse álbum é exageradamente triste e meio violento, não me passou uma sensação boa, mas tem músicas boas, como stan!
I really did try but could not finish this one. So violent and the production/lyricism/music couldn’t make it tolerable
Definitely was offended by his lyrics but that doesn’t mean I didn’t enjoy listening
Wow. I mean I don’t like rap but that was some display of emotion. Extremely controversial but very clever. Marshall Mathers is truly something different.
Beste rap album dat ik ken. Ik ken er eigenlijk maar 1 🤭 wel veel goede liedjes