Album Summary
If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears is the debut album by the Mamas and the Papas (written as The Mama's and the Papa's [sic]), released in 1966. The stereo mix of the album is included in its entirety on All the Leaves are Brown (2001), a two-CD retrospective compilation of the band's first four albums and various singles, as well as on The Mamas & the Papas Complete Anthology (2004), a four-CD box-set collection released in the UK. The mono mix of the album was remastered and reissued on vinyl by Sundazed Records in 2010, and on CD the following year. It is the band's only album to reach number one on the Billboard 200. In 2003, If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears was ranked number 127 on Rolling Stone magazine's list of the 500 greatest albums of all time, with its rank rising to number 112 in the 2012 revision.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
snoozefest. +1 star for california dreamin
5 stars all day long if you grew up on these vocals and harmonies. Too bad John Phillips raped his daughter while she was blacked out.
Well that was pleasant and dreamy as fuck
This is some pretty basic 60s pop. Feels like the thing they carved all other 60s pop out of. There's nothing wrong with it (and I even liked Monday Monday and California Dreamin' quite a bit) but there's also nothing really that interesting about it.
At its best, really good. But there's more than few songs on here that really drag the album down for me.
Very 60's
Bueno, solo conocía California Dreamin'.
A lot of 70s music is this sort of folky pop ethereal stuff. It’s not bad but it all kind of melds together. Also: unrelated to the actual music but the unnecessary apostrophes on the album cover grinds my gears
I'm come to the realization that The Mamas & The Papas might well have invented the "60s sound".
Classic album and sound. The Mamas and the Papas were a great blend of folk, rock and pop with great songs filled with beautiful harmonies. This was a very consistent album and I'm glad I finally had a chance to listen to it. Liked Songs Added: Monday, Monday Straight Shooter Go Where You Wanna Go California Dreamin'
Fabulous harmonies and great melodies on this short but sweet pop album. Like taking a trip back to the sixties. 4
“You like loud music” “Yes, the noisier the better. What do you like?” beckons closer “Chef’s Salad” Ayyyyyyyyy I originally thought California Dreaming was just an alright song but after hearing it played a million times in Chungking Express I’ve come to think it’s one of the greatest things ever
Awesome from start to finish. The harmonies really are magical and dreamy, and perfect for an early morning listen. Also, my Grandpa, born in 1925, did not care for my mother's music AT ALL in the 60's. Thought it was all screeching guitars and hippie bullshit, ya know, sex, drugs and rock n roll. But I'll be damned if he didn't ADORE The Mamas and the Papas and probably had no idea what those damn hippies were up to. He just loved the music and I always thought that was cute. Miss that guy a lot.
1 hitje dat wel fun is.
I’ve always found the Mamas and the Papas to be pleasant listening. Cass Elliot’s voice is especially pleasing to me. It’s enjoyable stuff. I love the cover art! Added to liked list: Monday, Monday, Straight Shooter, California Dreamin’, In Crowd.
Short & Sweet
One great hit we all know, other than that... nothingburger old music I am sorry
Reminds me of my dad, he enjoyed this album. Lots of simple, yet catchy, songs. I don’t love all of them, but I do appreciate then
Um ótimo híbrido entre Beach Boys e Beatles. Um registro contundente do que foi a metade pro final da década de 60.
California Dreaminnn
amazing 60s vibes
Bit poppy- one or two good tracks- love mamma cass
The vocal harmonies, songwriting, and arranging work here is phenomenal, shame that John Phillips was an actual monster
I was expecting insipid hippie nonsense, so was pleasantly suprised here. Strong pop craft and some utterly gorgeous harmonies. Far safer and poppier, but the more enjoyable for it.
Pleasant, an easy listen.
I don't think I'll ever tire of this sound! Cass Elliot has a beautiful voice. Too bad this band's memory is tainted by John Phillips, Rest in Piss to that one.
Fine and enjoyable. California Dreaming and some of the other hits definitely feel more inspired than the rest. I don't think I can rate it as highly as other 60s vocal-centric music.
wikipedia very specifically calls them a vocal group as opposed to a band and i think that makes sense. i'm not usually a vocals guy but everyone's voice here is just so lovely. harmonies and all that. good one to throw on, makes me want to get a cool record player. high bar but California Dreamin' can't be beat. very strong 3
6/10. Very 60's with a couple of classics
California Dreamin' adds a star to this album. It is sounds like it is straight from the mid 1960s and I don't necessarily mind that. I think a 5.5/10 is fair. Top song... California Dreamin'
This is great
Liked this, some good tunes on here
First track Monday, Monday and I'm loving it, the harmonies are gorgeous it feels sunny and warm and I feel transported to a distant land. Next couple of tracks I'm liking but it's beginning to wear when we get another absolute classic California Dreamin' and I'm back to thinking this is a great album, then after a few more tracks again my interest is ebbing again. It's not they the album tracks are bad or filler per se, they are kind of decent in their own right but somehow placed next to the great singles I feel like I want to skip them and I'm not generally a skipper at all.
The main reason for my rating is California Dreamin'. The rest of the album was okay, but not on the same level.
Flott album
good, but nothing extraordinary
Belter of an album. Monday, Monday was a great opener. I really liked their take on Do You Wanna Dance. I do prefer The Ramones version but this is right up there. Obviously California Dreamin’ is the big hit from this, it’s an absolute classic. Thing is though it’s been used in so many movies, shows etc that I’ve heard it countless times so it doesn’t really stand out to me as much as it probably should. After that there was nothing bad but the album did fall away a wee bit for me which ultimately stopped it from getting a five. Top Track - Do You Wanna Dance
This was fantastic! A little eclectic but very good.
7 - GOOD
Now ain't this a swell lil listen. Very enjoyable, happy vibes, heavily reminiscent of the fall season, and still holds up even though it was released in 1966.
the pamas and the mapas
Meh. Not awful, but nothing I'm gonna seek out.
I think this is a 3.5 for me. I kind of put them in a similar bracket to the Beach Boys, both in terms of musical sound (great harmonies, breezy sound, all connected to the California takeover of the 60's) and also being absolute musical icons, but having songs like Monday, Monday and California Dreamin' on here do act to (maybe unfairly) to juxtapose against some of the other songs. Don't get me wrong, they're all pretty high quality and I enjoyed the album as a whole, but if this were a little more constant, like Pet Sounds for instance, we'd be talking an easy 4.
Some great tunes. Some not so much.
Besides California Dreamin' dont care much about the rest
60s Folk pop, decent production. California Dreaming is the best song on here.
favorite tracks: Monday Monday, Straight Shooter, Got A Feelin’, I Call Your Name, Go Where You Wanna Go, California Dreamin’
An enjoyable and interesting listen. The vocal harmonies paired with folky sounds make this a kind of eerie Beach Boys, with the sunny California of their early work substituted for pining for a more troubled place. The classics, headlined by California Dreamin’ are of course great. In all I didn’t think any of the songs new to me were that amazing, so that keeps this at 4. But still well worth your time.
A nostalgic listen for me, as my mum had a compilation CD of Mamas and Papas songs that she used to play in the car. 'Monday, Monday' and 'California Dreamin'' are the big hitters here, but I was also very taken with the quieter, folkier, and more melancholic 'Got A Feelin'' where the beautiful vocal harmonies are complimented by a more understated instrumental accompaniment. A slice of California sunshine, although its brilliance fades somewhat in the second half.
NB: I strongly recommend listening to the mono version. A quintessential album of the 1960s Californian ‘sunshine pop’ sound, based around their beautiful vocal harmonies. ‘Monday, Monday’ and ‘California Dreamin’’ were the two big hits, and sure enough they are the two best tracks, but there are plenty of other highlights here, including slightly rockier numbers like ‘Straight Shooter’, ‘Go Where You Wanna Go’ and ‘Somebody Groovy’, and an interesting honky-tonk interpretation of the Beatles’ ‘I Call Your Name’. The other tracks (covers and originals) aren’t quite as interesting, though they’re still decent. Just enough for a low 4 stars.
Monday - appropriate day to have this album pop up. I forgot that some of the albums in this project would already be familiar and loved by me. Nostalgic and grinning to see this as my assignment today the harmonies and vocal layering - effortless Ahhh the tambourine (straight shooter)- I want to join in Impossible to give this album an objective rating - it automatically puts me in the car as a kid with my dad singing along and hands dancing while steering the car. Automatic 5* Not a fan of “do you wanna dance” “If it’s square, we ain’t there.” - the “In” Crowd
I'm giving this 5 stars based upon the nostalgia factor coupled with the fact that "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreaming" are really great songs.
I know the 2 singles so well, I'theyre so umbiquitous that i"m not sure that I need to hear them again, standard issue mid 60's pop, an advertising agencies dream cut and paste in to sell a bit of California sunshine to dreary old Britain. The US answer to The New Seekers. The rest of the album i don't know at all....in 1966 (before Bob Dylan invented pot) most US pop albums were a couple of hit singles, and a couple of covers surrounded by filler... Teack 1. Big hit single Track 2....it becomes apparent that this was recorded after Bob Dylan etc etc.. Travk 3. Oooh nice harmonies. Sugary but cute.. Track 4. More of the same Track 5. Not sure this was a good idea, genuine filler.... . Track 6, Ooh another advert soundtrack. This song has always irritated mel, no idea why it's just annoying. Track 7 The REALLY big single, i wonder how many ads is has been used in? Google says hundreds...which isnt surprising. Track 8. Is this one of theirs or a cover ? Track 9. This is beginning to wash over me now. Track 10. Have mostly stopped paying attention, its all the same. Track. Another pointless cover and a missed opportunity to rhyme "immitators" with "masturbators" This album is so unthreatening it makes the Simon and Garfunkel sound like The Happy Mondays. How it got on this list i will never know.. Not truly terrible but i'm never going to listen to it again, apart from the singles which i will doubtless be hearing on telly until the sun collapses (if I live that long) 3 stars for the singles, 1 star for the rest...a solid 2 overall.
A cracking effort from the M&Ps. Two stonewall classics in Monday Monday and Californian Dreamin’ surrounded by a great supporting cast of original tunes and decent covers that made me wish for a time machine back to the pinnacle years of popular music. A fantastic 4 for a fantastic 4
I literally knew nothing about them except their name. I vaguely always thought the Mamas and Papas was some Motown outfit....couldn't have been more wrong. Much of it is a warm psych-folk, but much poppier than many of their peers more faithful to the folk influences. Incidentally I'm guessing Stuart Murdoch is a massive fan, so much of it makes me think of Belle & Sebastian, or now I think of it, their contemporaries, The Vaselines. Clearly The Beatles cast a big old shadow over the period, Straight Shooter sounds like a straight up cover of a lost Beatles song. Hell, I think Abba were probably a big fan too. As it goes I really really like it. No especially weak tracks, quite a bit of variety such as the quirky ragtime/showtime blues of I call Your Name, but a consistent quality of songwriting and I love the harmonies. Ooh, California Dreaming, I know this song obviously, clearly I never knew who sung it. An absolute classic of the period obviously, at least I think it is, maybe I just know it from a million adverts. I think I may even stick a 5 on this album, class.
I just love their sound and I believe this is the first full album I’ve heard from them and I was not disappointed
Some classic songs on here.
This was pretty fun! Some songs reminded me of Brill Bruisers with the male and female vocal harmonies over similar sounding instrumentation.
I just really enjoy their sound, it is so cozy. And California Dreaming is just an absolutely fantastic song.
A classic slice of 60s pop/folk. It is more than just California Dreamin’ as there other excellent songs (go where you wanna go, Monday, Monday, Do you wanna dance…). It is safe and would benefit from a bit more edge but the harmonies and melodies carry it.
There’s something very endearing I find about this style of music, where the vocal melody and harmony are so prominent and draws so much on folk roots but also some of the new ‘hip’ pop music likely bring released at the time where it was something of a free for all and of furtive creativity. I couldn’t tell you much about some of the songs looking back on them other than they were ‘nice’ though, but not necessarily memorable.
Got the same after I while. The sound is good tho California dreamin is one of the best songs from the 60s.
The harmonizing is pleasant. Love California Dreaming. The songs are sweet and simple.
Same old problem. Decent popular tracks, not much interest otherwise.
Great album length. Overall can have some slow points, but I enjoyed Monday, Monday, Straight Shooter, I Call Your Name, California Dreamin', and Somebody Groovy.
FIRE AS FUCK
this one's pretty good i think? it's not really my kind of thing but there's a few tracks on here i like, like "california dreamin'", "spanish harlem" and "the "in" crowd", and the sound overall is, if nothing else, very comfortable. its a very soft 60s pop rock feel, very familiar. theres a lot of this sound out there but this is one of the stronger examples of it, i think. and the stereo mix is fun too, i guess being a mid 60s release it was likely around the time people had started to mostly get that stuff figured out, but not entirely? so sometimes there's weird things happening like at the start of "hey girl" where the duelling vocals aren't duelling yet, leaving the first verse with vocals all panned hard to the right. but i think i enjoy stuff like that when its not making the song unlistenable, yknow? anyway thats all the thoughts i have on the music cos i gotta admit ive been mostly distracted by whatever the fuck was going on with the album art. the number of revisions they did just to hide a toilet is so fucking funny. what the hell was going on in 1966......
Opening track is very familiar. Tracks 2&3 are a bit by the numbers Baby do you want to dance is solid Overall too much of the same
Harmonies so tight it could rip apart time and space
Things were better back then
i was born in the wrong era
Review - Never dove deep into this bands discography, basically just heard singles here and there. The album is good. Lovely vocal harmonies. A bit overproduced upok occasion but that's very of it's era. Worth a listen Score - 7/10 Need to listen? YES
Some bops on here but no so much for me. Its kind of to whispy for my taste.
I knew this album thanks to California Dreamin' but I never listened to the rest of the album up until now.
psychedelic
the hits are good but also the rest is kind of too twee for me
Meh, folk pop that sounds a bit Beach Boys in places. Heard the hits way to often and the other tracks are bland and slightly miserable even though the vocals swing towards upbeat. Bored me.
Very reminiscent of early Beatles work with all the harmonies but a nice change of pace with women vocalists in the mix. California Dreamin’ is definitely the standout but there’s a good mix of originals and covers too.
California dreaming was the only standout the rest of it was just kind of mediocre in my opinion good for its time I guess
Definitely Dated, but pretty good. reminds me of the old 80's mormon movies.
This has some bangers. Still sounds good 3.4
Extremely 60s. But not bad, honestly! I wouldn’t choose to put it on, but it wasn’t the slog I was expecting. 7/10 Quite Likeable
The Mamas & The Papas created some of the best singles of the 60s but their albums were only ever okay. The music isn't bad, just stuck in that time period where the albums were sample platters of things the artists could do rather than full artistic statements.
Labai gražūs balsai
Patika viena dziesma. Uzmini kura🤣
Man ļoti patika :)
“I would like to sing this song, it's about love, and hate. Psychedelically speaking I am talking about the power.” The Producers (1967)
Great album
Es un disco que en su epoca estaría muy bien. No ha envejecido mal, pero si que es verdad que el disco no es el mejor de todos. Mola el rollo y vaya banger california dreamin'
Album: 54/ 1102 Songs know going in : 1 Favourite song : california dreamin Rating : 4/10 notes : the vibes were nice but nothing stood out to me i really thought i was going to like this more than i do
Veeeeery 60s. “California Dreamin” is an awesome voice of course, but the rest really doesn’t do much for me.
Frühstücksmusik
Interesting listen here. I only knew California Dreaming, so I didn’t know what to expect of this album. I can’t say that I was surprised, but sometimes, I thought I was in a gospel choir, with the back vocals and the orchestrations. The In Crowd at the end sounds like straight out of Tapestry by Carole King, with the piano melody. 3/5. It’s wasn’t great, but I enjoyed it. The big songs carry the record though. Monday, Monday: 5 Straight Shooter: 3,5 Got a Feelin': 3 I Call Your Name: 3 Do You Wanna Dance: 3 Go Where You Wanna Go: 4 California Dreamin': 5 Spanish Harlem: 2 Somebody Groovy: 3 Hey Girl: 3 You Baby: 3 The "In" Crowd: 4 Monday, Monday: 5 Straight Shooter: 3,5 Got a Feelin': 3 I Call Your Name: 3 Do You Wanna Dance: 3 Go Where You Wanna Go: 4 California Dreamin': 5 Spanish Harlem: 2 Somebody Groovy: 3 Hey Girl: 3 You Baby: 3 The "In" Crowd: 4
a perfectly pleasant bit of pop-rock, with good harmonies and singing, a really tight studio band, but inconsistent lyrics (and it suffers a bit from the recording technology of the era).
I went into this album just assuming I would love it. I am a sucker for the 60s—hard rock, psychedelic, anything even remotely Beatles-esque, Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young (and any variations thereof), the smooth alto of Karen Carpenter's vocals—give it ALL to me. But I did not expect to find this album quite so ... twee. Obviously California Dreaming is a song for the ages but I never need to hear the rest of this album ever again. I also find the band name itself off-putting and have to question the judgement of whoever thought having a toilet take up a full fifth of the album cover was a good idea.
I was a lil distracted ngl but it was kinda filler music for the background, not bad but I wonder if I would think so if I were more actively listening, some klezmer feeling tracks so that was poggers
Great, an excuse to listen to California Dreaming 4 times on repeat and engage in euphoric recall of the karaoke bar I sang this at in Xishuangbanna. Rest of the album is sweet, fun and has a couple of other songs I recognize. Definitely fuck with this band, but it's definitely of a time and place.
A lot of classics I did not expect on this album. Exceeded expectations
All the leaves are brown
Álbum foda. 4 músicas da minha lista aqui. O som deles é muito aconchegante pra mim, me lembra o tempo que passei nos EUA na liberdade, dirigindo na California ouvindo essas músicas enquanto passava pela Golden Gate Bridge. Traz uma sensação de conforto e liberdade.