Not sure this is an addition to the list

Not a clue

So so. Not a classic or a missing album

An omission from the main list

Divided opinion at the time. I am with those who didn’t rate it.

Excellent. Never heard of them. But resonates with a lot of good music.

It’s a 2.5 for me. The first half is edgey funk which I really enjoyed. But unfortunately this fizzled out.

I thought I had seen the back of late 60s psychedelica.

Love this album. Could have nominated it myself. It’s only negative is that is needs Wikipedia to explain the plot fully

Not bad

Dither why you would add this one. Pretty generic

Resonates with Death Cab for Cutie but songs not as good as

I was going to nominate this. Absolutely 5* album from left field. Who knows what it is about, but who cares. Low fi brilliance. An indie classic.

I don’t see the point of adding this album

So so. Not a classic or a missing album

As an Irishman I feel like I’m betraying Damien by not rating him higher. It is a cover I see everywhere, but it’s quite samey and the lowkey vibe tires after a while. Couple of great tunes, love Cannonball.

Surprisingly very good

Can’t believe this is an important addition

Harmless

Like a poor man’s Weezer

I like it

3rd track by R2D2

Never heard of them. Would like to have attended a gig. However throughout this list I have maintained- live albums are cheating.

Good beat. But forgettable

Hits are good. Some padding there too

Not sure why I ignored this album. It’s quite good

Don’t rate it

It is like The Wall was extended

1 star. Not because it is terrible. It just doesn’t belong on this list. A couple of pop hits does not an album make. Ironically I was a fan back in the day! My brother once called me out for wearing my runners untied a la Nic K. Highly embarrassing.

Passable

Just doesn’t resonate with me

Divided opinion at the time. I am with those who didn’t rate it.

This was not an omission from the original list.

Not entirely brilliant. But a definite addition to the original list.

Not sure this is an addition to the list

Live is cheating. Even if it is good.

Lost in the dream is the one I rate higher. However I like the vibe. As some other reviewers said, let it was over you. Great driving music.

So so

So so

So so

Don’t get it.

Harmless

Don’t get it.

Don’t get it.

Sounds like a mid afternoon festival support act.

As eclectic as they get. Makes a great sound. Glad I heard it. Won’t be going back

Liking this post list list less

Love it. I discovered Teenage Fanclub from their compilation album “Four Thousand….” So I was spoiled and took a while to go back to their discography.

Non eventful

Illinois(e) was the first album of 1001. I’d never heard it and it is one of my favourite albums to this day. Unfortunately not every day was like that 1st. This is not bad, but not as good as

Inoffensive but not a game changer

Shambolic! Surprised that the person who submitted this like much of the same stuff as me from the main list.

The extra list we are following feels a bit like revenge of the metal heads

What’s not to like. 27 songs in 50 mins. Shades of punk, pixies and the clash. Plenty of energy.

It’s OK, not as good as the first reviews I read would suggest.

A favourite of mine. Surprised it didn’t make the main list.

An omission from the main list

Never heard of them. Not bad. Not overly original

Never heard of them or listened to any of it. Quite solid. Some is excellent. Sorry i didn’t discover it in 1994

2 day road trip. This wasn’t the soundtrack I needed.

Not for me

Not the worst. I know people who would like it

I’m full of reggae

Nope

Bizarrely 4 tracks only on Spotify

Better than some. Not misogynistic

Better than expected

Not bad at all

Not bad

Not bad. Not exactly my cup of tea but it has qualities

Not bad at all

Melodic for punk

Cafe jazz. My wife will like it.

Does this album make it the 4th by the stooges on the list!!!

Sounds like many other bands

Nope

Not bad. Some good sound

What’s not to like a good Cure album.

This list is the revenge of the metal heads

Sufjan esque without the extra umph

I like experimental noise. This was a 1 track trick

Stock American sound

Nope

Not feeling it

Surprisingly, not too bad

Surprisingly, not too bad

Don’t get it

Who figured this was missing from the list

Worth a few stars

Feels a bit samey

I had low expectations. Surprisingly not bad

Live albums are cheating

Amazing. Would have nominated it myself. Love this album and band. Solid 5

Better than expected. Not a classic

Never heard of this. Quite good. Will explore more.

Waste of time

Difficult not to like the infectious joy. However not strong throughout

Nope

Ok

I thought we were finished with this shit.

Is there a better album on either list

So so

Not the worst

We have had enough from this genre. Move on.

So so

Don’t get them

Don’t get them

I really don’t get it

No point

No point

No point

Never sent their way. Not bad

Don’t get him / them. Should like it.

I am confusion

Never heard of this

More cafe jazz than indie for me

Wrong list

Quirky

Wouldn’t add a 3rd bjork album

Quirky

Not the worst

Ok

Never heard of this

Always had a soft spot for euro electronica from Tangerine Dream to Kraftwork. Excellent album.

Excellent newish Irish band.

I’d forgotten this one. Excellent

Live albums, like compilations, are cheating. Particularly when full of covers

Should have sought them out beyond Hey Ho. But it is excellent. First 5* in a while. The extra star is awarded cos I have a new artist to discover

Rubbish

Excellent

Not a clue

Unfinished

So so

I don’t mind noise. I’m not an audio snob. But a bad recording is a bad recording.

Surprisingly good

So so. Expecting more

Not my thing

But formulaic

Who dig this one out. A bit desperate to nominate an album

Nope

Good enough. Giving it a 4 cos it’s been a long time since a half decent one.

1 tools album sufficient

Nope

Excellent

Excellent

Excellent

Nope

Amazing album. Complete oversight from the original list as pointed out by most of the recent reviewers. Saw them recently in Dublin, this album still makes up a significant part of their excellent set list. Only downside to them live, is that you don’t get anything extra you just get the songs but that’s a separate discussion.

As bad as I’ve heard

So so

Nope

Couldn’t listen to it on Spotify , not sure I missed anything

Excellent seminal album. Definitely an oversight from the original list

As genre that was covered by the original list

They have a much better album

I like electronics but there is better