1001 Albums Summary

BEFORE: Had this CD as a teenager but haven't listened in years, although I still have Ready or Not on a few playlists. Let's see how it holds up... AFTER: First version of this I found was censored. No thanks. The beats and hooks mostly hold up well and Lauryn Hill was clearly an outstanding talent. Wyclef holds his own. The rhymes are hit and miss and it is hard to work out what Pras actually brought to the table, if anything. Falls off hard in the second half. Highlights: Ready or Not, Fu-Gee-La, Zealots, Family Business, Lauryn Hill when they let her sing without interrupting. Lowlights: Pras trying to rap, the racist nonsense after The Beast, The Mask, No Woman No Cry (I like Wyclef but he has no business covering Bob Marley and needs to stop trying). VERDICT: 3.5/5. Some hidden gems on there beyond the singles, but too uneven to be a classic.

BEFORE: I've definitely heard it before, I know and like a lot of the songs and already I know it's a massively influential album. Outside The Clash and Refused, I've never been a big punk guy. AFTER: 29 minutes. Banger after banger. Nothing outstays its welcome. Like AC/DC, they have a formula that works and don't stray too far from it. Joey's idiosyncratic delivery, the early rock and roll influences and the backing vocals really elevate these simple but powerful songs. An absolute classic and worth listening with a pair of decent headphones. It's also nice to hear a band who are so upfront about what they want. HIGHLIGHTS: Everything. LOWLIGHTS N/A VERDICT: A wonderful album. Influential and catchy as hell. 5 stars.

BEFORE: I haven't listened to this in full before but I did pick up a very worn copy on vinyl a few weeks ago that I've been meaning to listen to. My FIL was a big Willie Nelson fan and I'm familiar with Stardust and Georgia On My Mind. Funnily enough, I'm the same age as Willie was when he released Stardust. AFTER: Willie Nelson has one of the most beautiful voices of all time. Smooth but never too smooth. I don't listen to a lot of music this mellow but I'm a big Ray Charles fan and this scratches the same itch. HIGHLIGHTS: Georgia On My Mind, Blue Skies, Unchained Melody, On the Sunny Side of the Street, Moonlight in Vermont. LOWLIGHTS: Parts of September Song are a little soporific. I also struggle with this much harmonica. I know it's an essential part of the genre but it always reminds me of fucking Blues Traveler. VERDICT: 5 stars. A gentle, warm and beautifully realised album. The few elements I don't love are really just a matter of personal preference.

BEFORE: I'm generally with Jeff Lebowski when it comes to the Eagles. I was over-exposed to their earlier Greatest Hits by various drunk bogan relatives at family holidays, wedding receptions etc. but I'm a little more open-minded with this album and even partial to the singles in the right context. AFTER: The production is incredible. Every instrument sounds crystal-clear in the mix while preserving a strong sense of dynamics. The music itself is more of a mixed bag. HIGHLIGHTS: The guitar work on Hotel California, Life in the Fast Lane (I like Joe Walsh), Victim of Love apart from the the chorus, Try And Love Again even the ridiculous falsetto outro, the harmonies and production throughout. LOWLIGHTS: Wasted Time is turgid and forgettable in a way that no string section can fix. A Peter Cetera-level turd rolled in glitter. The Last Resort is a better ballad but is at least 2 minutes too long. Pretty Maids All In A Row is forgettable and the intro is cheesy. VERDICT: A light 4 stars. Too many ballads but otherwise better than I expected.

BEFORE: I have never really dug into Harry Nilsson but I know Without You, Coconut, Everybody's Talkin' etc. AFTER: This really caught me by surprise. I was expecting more retrospective singer-songwriter stuff, and while there is some of that it is also by turns raucous, weird, cinematic and angry - and always inventive. Even the songs that start out with familiar structures and chords go somewhere you aren't expecting. Nilsson also had an incredible voice. HIGHLIGHTS: The highlights for me here were songs I hadn't heard before and loved: Gotta Get Up, Early In The Morning, Jump In The Fire, I'll Never Leave You. LOWLIGHTS: None that jump out at me and I will definitely be listening to this again. VERDICT: An easy 5 stars. An unexpected delight.

BEFORE: Perfect timing - I just watched Apocalypse Now for the first time. I am a casual Doors fan, had the greatest hits on CD (including four tracks off here) but always found Jim Morrison a little silly. AFTER: This album creates its own unsettling, immersive world which i really like, and I don't think the occasional weaker moments detract from that in any way. HIGHLIGHTS: Of the tracks I haven't heard before, The Crystal Ship and Take It As It Comes were definitely highlights and I already loved Break On Through, Light My Fire, Alabama Song and The End (shout out Martin Sheen). LOWLIGHTS: Twentieth Century Fox is a forgettable song written around a corny pun. A couple of the later songs washed over me a bit and my attention slipped but they certainly weren't bad. VERDICT: 5 stars. I may have been a little harsh on The Doors in the past, or at least this earlier version before the drugs really took held.

BEFORE: The run of oldies continues. Everything since my first album was released before I was born, and I am solidly middle-aged. I only know All The Young Dudes, which isn't on this and their name is stupid. This should be interesting. AFTER: I love Bowie. I like T-Rex. I can endure Sweet and Slade in small doses. At first, this felt like a lesser facsimile of those things. Very little of this works for me. I found the vocals and lyrics aggressively annoying and I really don't understand the acclaim for this one. HIGHLIGHTS: I had to dig pretty deep for these, but I liked the intro and ending of Hymn for the Dudes and the verses and guitar work on Violence. I'm a Cadillac / El Domino Dolo Roso's instrumental section. LOWLIGHTS: The off-key vocals, particularly on Whizz Kid. The barrelhouse piano. The cliched mess of Honaloochie Boogie. Ballad of Mott the Hoople felt like it would never end but is somehow only 5:40. VERDICT: 2 Stars. My relief was palpable after this. I just don't get it but there is obviously some skill and inspiration there - just nothing that works for me. The first real miss from the generator. I'm sure it won't be the last. At least it was short.

BEFORE: I know nothing about these guys except that they're Australian. Should be fun. I'm just going to listen to the original 10 tracks - not all this bonus stuff. AFTER: Interesting album. Reminds me a bit of Hunters and Collectors, Waterboys and The Cure's more upbeat stuff (this is a compliment). Emotional without being overwrought. HIGHLIGHTS: The strings - always adding something but never excessive. The Robert Smith-y lead guitar work. Favourite tracks were Love Goes On!, You Can't Say No Forever, The Streets of Your Town, Was There Anything I Could Do, LOWLIGHTS: The arrangements and production can feel a little too similar at times and I can't help but feel that a few different elements (like the outro to You Can't Say No Forever or the drums on Clouds) would have brought some of these tracks to life, but given the quality of the songwriting that is a very minor quibble. Also maybe that's just me - most of my favourite stuff is a bit more weird and cross-genre. I had kind of run out of interest by the last 2 tracks, and there are only 10. I could also have done without the oboe. Sometimes it works OK. Not here. VERDICT: 4 stars. Immaculate songwriting even if this style of jangly indie pop isn't generally for me. A huge breath of fresh air after Mott the Hoople, apart from the oboe.

BEFORE: Good stuff. Love The Stooges and Down On The Street is my favourite Stooges song. Don't listen to them enough. AFTER: Yeah this is great. Love the shorter, punkier songs. Love the heavy, psychedelic freakouts and the weird jazz. Production is perfect for this kind of music. Everything is a highlight and there are no lowlights. VERDICT: An easy 5 stars.

BEFORE: This should be pretty straightforward. One of my favourite albums of all time. Bought it on cassette when it came out and thrashed it. Have owned it in some format and listened at least semi-regularly ever since. Good excuse to listen to it again. AFTER: Perfect album. No wasted time. I even love Endless, Nameless. HIGHLIGHTS: Everything, but special shout-out to Side 2 which doesn't get the same attention. Territorial Pissings, Drain You, Lounge Act and On A Plain are all incredible tracks. LOWLIGHTS: Nope. VERDICT: An easy, easy 5 stars.

BEFORE: Never really clicked with me as a group when I heard them from time to time in my 20s, although I know What's Golden and I like Ozomatli's first album. Even caught Chali 2Na solo at a festival recently that The Roots headlined. It should be in my wheelhouse so going into this with an open mind. AFTER: I really enjoyed the beats and production on this. The vocals are decent but don't stand out as much as the bouncy, jazzy instrumentals - there is a little too much reverence to the culture at the expense of trying new things. Having said that, there is plenty of skill on display, especially on the faster tracks. I'd listen to this again just to enjoy the grooves and production. The Cut Chemist productions here are especially strong and I will be seeking out his solo work. HIGHLIGHTS: Freedom, Break (a bit more A-game here from the rappers), A Day At the Races, Hey, Acetate Prophets. LOWLIGHTS: Remember His Name is a little tedious and the back half of the album dragged a little more, but overall this was a pleasant surprise even if the vocals don't always reach the level of the music. VERDICT: A strong 4 star album. Glad to have my mind changed and worth revisiting in the future.

BEFORE: I know this very well. It's not my absolute favourite Beatles album (that will always be Abbey Road) but still excellent and I love the unifying concept. Should be a pretty clear-cut 5 stars. AFTER: Yep. 5 stars. It's perfect. A few favourite tracks: Lucy In the Sky With Diamonds still sounds absolutely luminous. Fixing A Hole has a fantastic ominous tone that creeps into the song. So does Being For the Benefit of Mr. Kite. Within You Without You is wonderfully psychedelic. A Day In The Life remains one of the most incredible songs ever written. VERDICT: 5 stars. One of the greatest albums ever written.

BEFORE: Don't mind a bit of Neil Young. Relieved to find that he is now on Spotify. I've listened to a fair bit of his Crazy Horse stuff and Harvest and enjoyed most of it. Let's see how we go... AFTER: This was a trip. I really enjoyed it. There is a kind of sloppy, woozy aspect to the playing and a few odd choices in terms of chords, melodies, arrangements etc. that reminded me, weirdly, of Captain Beefheart's more accessible music. Those choices lift this above bog standard blues- or country-rock and elements that I often struggle to enjoy (like barrelhouse piano and harmonica) work realy well in this context. As an expression of the loss of Danny Whitten and Bruce Berry, the emotion here feels raw, specific and real rather than abstract or carefully rehearsed. HIGHLIGHTS: Speakin' Out, Come On Baby Let's Go Downtown, Mellow My Mind, Roll Another Number (For the Road), New Mama, Tired Eyes. I mean, there are a lot of great tracks here. LOWLIGHTS: Nothing really stands out. It's a strong collection of tracks with a unifying vibe that I really enjoyed - sometimes fun, sometimes deeply sad, sometimes both at the same time. VERDICT: 5 stars. This project keeps delivering.

BEFORE: Fine. I don't love Paul Simon's music but more as matter of personal preference - he's obviously an incredibly talented guy. Outside of greatest hits collections, I can honestly say I've never listened to an entire Paul Simon or even a Simon & Garfunkel album. AFTER: This was a weird one. There are a couple of tracks on here that are experimental in a good way, some that are more traditional Paul Simon and some that just sound incredibly dated. HIGHLIGHTS: Allergies and Think Too Much (a) are pleasingly weird but catchy with Talking Heads vibes. Hearts and Bones is a lovely song and the orchestral section of The Late Great Johnny Ace is also great (but also not Paul Simon's). LOWLIGHTS: Cars are Cars shits the bed pretty aggressively. One of the most irritating songs I've heard in recent memory. The reggae-yacht rock hybrid of When Numbers Get Serious and the baby goat noise on Think Too Much (b) are also pretty bad. Some of the ballads are just kind of there and the sprinkling of "world" percussion, fretless bass and nearly blues guitar evokes the incidental music from Weekend At Bernie's 2. VERDICT: The high points are few and far between and, if I'm being honest, just OK. The lows are very low indeed. I honestly don't know why this album is on this list. 2 stars.

BEFORE: I really like REM and respect that they knew when to call it quits. Unfortunately, my wife doesn't like them so I don't listen to them that often. The only REM album I ever really got into was Automatic From The People, which I had on cassette years ago. I have fond memories of the singles from this album and plenty of others, especially in that late 80s through late 90s period, as well as the albums Monster and New Adventures in Hi-Fi. I know and love Stand (shout out to Chris Elliot's sitcom Get A Life), Orange Crush and Pop Song '89 but the rest of this will be new to me. AFTER: Firstly, this sounds amazing. The chiming guitars, Michael Stipe's yearning vocals, the harmonies, Bill Berry's fantastic drumming. Beautiful. The songwriting is at turns surprising and familiar, and REM fit a lot into these 3-5 minute songs. HIGHLIGHTS: Get Up and Untitled are both fantastic songs, Stand is still lots of fun (cheesy key-changes and all), World Leader Pretend is brilliant with Bill Berry's contributions there particularly effective, Orange Crush is epic and remains one of REM's very best songs, Turn You Inside-Out is lifted by the drum production, percussion, unexpected chord changes and anthemic backing vocals, I Remember California is haunting. LOWLIGHTS: I get that mandolins are part of the deal with REM but I had enough by the end of The Wrong Child. No shade on the songs that feature it - they are all still strong - but for me it's a very specific sound that is better used sparingly outside of folk, bluegrass etc. VERDIT: Subjectively, this was a toss up between 4 and 5 stars for me. I'm giving it 5 because the few things I don't like about it are really a matter of personal preference.

BEFORE: An old favourite. I can't believe this came out 22 years ago. I was already 1 year out of university. Fuck I'm old. Obviously Kanye is a terrible person now, but I have good memories of this album. It's probably a little bloated and not his absolute best, but there are still so many incredible tracks. I try to avoid his stuff now but happy to make an exception today. Also I know this is blasphemy but I don't like Through The Wire. Yes I know about the back story. AFTER: A lot of the songs on here are undeniable but from Breathe In Breathe Out onwards the album really drags, School Spirit and Two Hands excepted. HIGH POINTS: Jesus Walks is an all-time classic. All Falls Down, Spaceship, The New Workout Plan (it's stupid but so much fun), Slow Jamz, We Don't Care and School Spirit are also fantastic. The hooks, the production, the guest spots from Syleena Johnson, Jay Z, Twista, Jamie Foxx and others. LOW POINTS: Kanye was never the greatest rapper and this is some of his weaker work, although even then he still had a way with memorable lyrics. Skits are almost always unnecessary, and this is no exception. 3 in the space of 4 tracks really kills the momentum. Through The Wire is just OK despite the back story. Family Business is saccharine and cloying with a pedestrian beat. Last Call has some interesting moments but it's way too long and the sped-up sample trick is getting very old by that point. VERDICT: This is a tough one - both because of what Kanye West has become and because there are some great songs on here but not really a cohesive album. On the strength of those tracks, I'm giving this 4 stars but it's more like 3.6. Would be close to a 5 without the skits and if the album ended at Two Hands.

BEFORE: I know Buffalo Stance, a couple of her later singles and her song with Gorillaz. I can see that the Massive Attack and Bomb the Bass guys worked on this so I'm looking forward to digging in. AFTER: I really like the sound of this album and a lot of the dance-pop from this era, maybe because I grew up with it – the late 80s synths, crisp drum machines and gratuitous scratching. Buffalo Stance is iconic. A stone-cold classic and a tough act for the rest of the album to follow. Manchild and Kisses On The Wind are nearly as catchy – both fantastic electro-pop songs. The second half is a bit more downbeat but still catchy. It evokes a strong sense of time and place, although that can leave the odd track feeling dated. HIGHLIGHTS: Those three opening tracks are hard to beat. Love Ghetto is a nice change of pace, and Heart is full of attitude with a solid chorus. Phoney Ladies pairs synths reminiscent of Pretty Hate Machine-era NIN with layered vocals and might be nearly as good as Buffalo Stance. The production is fantastic throughout. LOWLIGHTS: The Next Generation hasn’t aged as well as some of the other tracks. It’s fine and has a good break but lacks a strong hook. Outré Risqué Locomotive suffers from the same issues at time, although it’s a much more dynamic track that improves from the floaty bridge onwards. My Bitch – which I know is a bonus track but I listened anyway – is let down by the chintzy synthesized brass. VERDICT: I’m giving it a strong 4. Really glad I listened to it. There are a lot of hidden gems here and the vibe is totally different from anything else I’ve reviewed so far, even if this is very much an artifact of its time with a few weaker spots.

BEFORE: I already know this really well. Big fan of Elbow going right back to Asleep In The Back (which should be on this list for Newborn and Powder Blue alone) and I've seen them live a couple of times. We used Starlings as a reading at our wedding and I love this album, so this is going to be an automatic 5 stars for me but I'm more than happy to listen to this again. Guy Garvey is one of the best lyricists and singers around and the band are inventive and tight without showing off. I can accept Radiohead comparisons as they're both very good, although good luck finding any tech-driven paranoia here. If you can't distinguish this from Keane's two (2) decent songs or Coldplay's vegan stadium-pop you have no business reviewing music. AFTER: No technology-driven anxiety or bland anthems here - just incredible songwriting that makes the specific feel universal. The music on here is less obviously experimental than their earlier work but there is still plenty of unusual stuff going on if you care to look. Given I know this inside out, I am going to listen for new things and try to highlight some less well-known tracks. HIGHLIGHTS: Everything, obviously. The Loneliness of a Tower Crane Driver is majestic. Some Riot and Friend Of Ours are heart-wrenching. The weird guitar figure on Starlings just before the crescendo, the fuzz bass on The Bones of You, Garvey's restrained vocal on Mirrorball. The bass dropping in on Grounds for Divorce (Pete Turner is amazing), the looped vocal on Weather To Fly, the piano and ominous cello of Some Riot, the extended outro of One Day Like This (best enjoyed live). LOWLIGHTS: None. Fuck off. OK maybe Audience With The Pope isn't my favourite. VERDICT: 5 stars. No notes.

BEFORE: I've heard of this guy but otherwise I am going in totally blind, which is exciting. The only Brazilian music I listen to on the regular is Sepultura. Let's go! AFTER: Straight off the bat, way more bluesy and psychedelic than I expected. This is pretty awesome tbh. Catchy as hell and the second half of the album is particularly strong. I wish I understood Portuguese. I didn't take detailed track notes but just let the vibe of the album wash over me given it was all new. There is a lot going on - traditional rock instruments alongside a huge range of Afro-Brazilian and Afro-Cuban percussion, keys, brass, Ron Burgundy jazz flute etc. Also I did recognise one of the tracks, Xica Da Silva. No idea where from - maybe a DJ with much better taste than me? HIGHLIGHTS: The whole album is a lot of fun - kinetic, funky and full of passion. My favourite tracks on first listen were Ponta De Lanca Africano, Taj Mahal, Xica Da Silva. A Historia De Jorge, Cavaleiro Do Cavalo Imaculado and Africa Brasil (Zumbi). This will be going into the rotation so will be interesting to see what else emerges. LOWLIGHTS: Nothing that stands out. I enjoyed some tracks more than others on first listen but I think the quality here is pretty consistent. I guess if you don't like the overall vibe this might be a tough listen, but that also means that you're probably a knob. VERDICT: An easy 5 stars. Magic.

BEFORE: OK - back into more familiar territory. I like rather than love The Band but I've listened to this before, although I only really remember The Weight. AFTER: This is more rootsy and low key than most of my favourite music and it was hard to put that aside at times, although the playing and some of the singing (see below) is impressive. HIGHLIGHTS: The Weight is a classic - that should go without saying. Tears of Rage does what it says on the tin. Caledonia Mission is fun. The vocal interplay on Long Black Veil and I Shall Be Released is magic. Chest Fever is pleasingly weird - I like the doom-y organ. This Wheel's On Fire has a great chorus. LOWLIGHTS: I listened to a remastered version and the production was pretty muddy - I hate to think how this originally sounded. Even at a relatively short 42 minutes, the slow pacing drags at times and the sheer effort of the singing is exhausting. I wonder if anyone herniated during the recording. We Can Talk should have been a B-side and I rolled my eyes through the cliches of Lonesome Suzie. VERDICT: I know it's a significant album in terms of influence etc. and I can certainly appreciate this but I don't love it. 3 stars.

BEFORE: Another album that is totally new to me. Looking forward to it as it isn't something I would ever have chosen to listen to. Interesting to see that the orchestra is still going (albeit without Count Basie). AFTER: I don't know much about this music but it's definitely a vibe. Upbeat instrumental big band / swing that sounds like incidental music for a film set in Las Vegas with Lil Darlin' as a slower palate-cleanser at the end. I really enjoyed it but, other than Duet, it did kind of wash over me. HIGHLIGHTS: The delicate solos on Duet, the change of pace on Lil Darlin', the general vibe, not too long. LOWLIGHTS: I like variety and this felt a bit samey, although I did enjoy it and might put it on again for fancy cocktails or something. VERDICT: 4 stars. Very good for what it is, even if it isn't really my jam.

BEFORE: Ian Dury! My local pool hall used to play him a fair bit but I don't know his stuff that well. Looking forward to this... AFTER: I know his vocals won't be too everyone's tastes but I like the Cockney accent and idiosyncratic delivery really enjoyed the variety of genres deployed in service of subversion and social commentary. In that sense, it shares some DNA with The Clash and David Bowie. Also TIL that the Spray n Wipe theme song played in ads here in the 80s and 90s was just a rip-off of Billericay Dickie. HIGHLIGHTS: The lead guitar work across the album is great and there are some incredible basslines as well - particularly on My Old Man and Wake Up And Make Love With Me. The latter in particular is funkier than it has any right to be. But for Dury's vocal, Clever Trevor could be a lost Stevie Wonder track. If I Was With A Woman has a jangly, slightly dissonant chorus that comes out of leftfield, a fantastic guitar solo and a deeply weird ending. Blockheads is a hell of a mission statement, and the venom across Blockheads, Plaistow Patricia and Blackmail album keep the foot on the gas right until the bitter end. Sex & Drugs & Rock & Roll (which was the final track on my streaming version) is a wonderful song with an unexpectedly delicate piano solo. A great way to sign off. LOWLIGHTS: Some of the knees up, cheeky chappy moments are less to my tastes but they work in the context of the album (a bit like Paul's "granny shit" with the Beatles). VERDICT: Loved it. It is, by turns, familiar, weird, catchy, dissonant, funky and furious. I can see why it has polarised reviewers, but that's what the best music does.

BEFORE: I don't even really need to listen to this to review it, but I will anyway. I still remember hearing Jeff Buckley for the first time, our local alternative music TV channel adding So Real to its rotation in 1995, and then picking up Last Goodbye and the title track. I bought this album on CD shortly after and have listened to it ever since. It's magic. Streaming copy has something called Forget Her at the end but I am choosing to ignore it - it's not on the original album. AFTER: As expected, it's still close to perfect. I know everyone talks about Buckley's incredible, haunting voice but the musicianship on here is spectacular across the board. The spidery guitar riffs on Grace and So Real, and the bizarre solo on the latter. The string arrangements on Last Goodbye and Eternal Life. The intro to Hallelujah. The organ on Lover, You Should've Come Over. HIGHLIGHTS: This album is an all-time favourite. Just about everything is a highlight. My favourite tracks are Mojo Pin, Grace, Last Goodbye, So Real, Lover You Should've Come Over and Dream Brother. LOWLIGHTS: Corpus Christi Carol is a bit lowkey and churchy for me outside the context of the album, but it's a good palate cleanser after what is probably the high point of the album. VERDICT: 5 stars and I don't know how you could give it anything else. Some of the other reviews of this are frankly embarrassing.

BEFORE: More familiar territory. I have this on CD somewhere. This is a classic, foundational metal album. It's kind of wild to think this came out in 1970, although I know music was already getting heavier by then. AFTER: Just as good as I remember. I enjoyed focusing on some of the tracks I don't know as well - particularly through the second side. I don't really have a lot of say about this. It's just classic, early heavy metal. HIGHLIGHTS: The compositions and musicianship is exceptional, Tony Iommi's guitar work laid the foundation for countless bands to come - so many of these riffs have been adapted and recycled over the years - and Ozzy's voice is an absolute force of nature. Some of the sonic effects on here - treated vocals, the guitar work - are way ahead of their time. Bill Ward is an incredible versatile drummer across the 8 tracks here. The more familiar tracks (basically all of Side One) are always welcome, but I really enjoyed the second side this time through. LOWLIGHTS: None for me, but then I love this music. Sure the lyrics can get a bit silly, but I think metal works best when it retains a sense of fun. VERDICT: 5 stars. This is a heavy metal classic and anyone with even a passing interest in metal or hard rock should be all over this. MISC: My reviews so far really lean towards 4 and 5 stars. When I look up others' reviews, I am always kind of shocked that there are so many lower scores for albums considered classics (although to be fair I have encountered a few lesser efforts and have been surprised at their inclusion), often from people who just outright reject certain genres or styles of music. I'm lucky to have very broad tastes and most of these albums are in these books for very good reason, even if some of the music is outside my usual listening preference. It's a shame more people don't approach this with quite such an open mind, and I honestly wonder what people with narrow tastes and obvious prejudices expect to get out of such a wide-ranging exercise.

BEFORE: More Iggy! My first repeat artist - already reviewed and loved Fun House. This is also familiar so I'm looking forward to getting into it again. AFTER: The production is dogshit and it just doesn't matter. The music is primal, raw, heavy and yet somehow still really catchy. I imagine that people who prefer clean, shiny production will struggle with this. If you like lo-fi, punk, garage rock etc. then this is as good as it gets. Iggy Pop's vocals are relentless and James Williamson is an immense guitarist. HIGHLIGHTS: I really love Search and Destroy, Penetration, Shake Appeal and the title track but there really are no bad tracks here. LOWLIGHTS: I mentioned the production, but that doesn't really detract from the music. VERDICT: 5 stars, baby.

BEFORE: I don't love much folk music but given their pedigree and work with Neil Young I am optimistic. I will be skipping the bonus tracks. I don't think I know any of this stuff although I do recognise a few titles so maybe I do. AFTER: Musically, this was more varied than I expected. Probably half of the songs didn't really grab me on first listen - I found them pleasant but better as background music. I hear a lot of Simon and Garfunkel and Cat Stevens and a little bit of early Eagles in the music. HIGHLIGHTS: The harmonies are nice and Stephen Stills is a great guitarist - I love the backwards guitar on Pre-Road Downs. Also enjoyed the ambitious structure of Suite: Judy Blue Eyes (particularly the final section). You Don't Have To Cry is a lovely song and Wooden Ships' psychedelia is a welcome change of pace. LOWLIGHTS: Marrakesh Express sounds like a Monkees cast-off. Beyond that, some of the tracks were just a little forgettable. VERDICT: I think it's a solid 4. I will probably listen to it a few more times just to see if some of the other songs sink in, but the good bits were really good.

BEFORE: Never heard of it. Fair play. It's a welcome change from all the 60s and 70s mainstream rock. I did find a slightly confusing version on Spotify attributed to all 3 original artists - Hariprasad Chaurasia, Brij Bhushan Kabra and Pandi Shivkuma Sharma. It's in a different order but still the same recordings, with one original track split into two and some bonus tracks (one of which is combined with an the original tracks - I skipped the bonus tracks for the sake of time). AFTER: The music is beautiful. Gentle and meditative but with some great tension and release created by the instrumentation - the drones, microtonal runs, mix of major, minor and microtonal intervals, notes bending in and out of harmony. The percussion is propulsive and the flute adds something different. I don't think I lost too much here by listening to the tracks out of order - you still get a clear sense of the pastoral narrative. HIGHLIGHTS: Nat Bhairav unfolds and then accelerates with propulsive tabla. The modal mixture and microtonal runs of Piloo are otherworldly . I loved the flute, guitar and santoor working in unison on Desh. LOWLIGHTS: None for me. The music ebbs and flows, but my interest never did. This was just so different for me that it was never less than captivating. VERDICT: 5 stars. Beautiful. Totally different to anything I've listened to before. This would go well with an edible, if that's your thing.

BEFORE: I love Queen as a singles band but haven't listened to their albums much. Grew up on their greatest hits collections but I only really know Seven Seas of Rhye from this. Just watched Bohemian Rhapsody with the kids (it remains pretty average, the music aside). I know early Queen was a little more proggy, which I am up for. Let's go. AFTER: I was surprised how many elements of peak Queen were already in place here - the harmonies, Freddy's incredible voice, the multi-layered guitar, the complex compositions and genre-hopping, letting Roger sing one of the album cuts. Some of the proggier strong structures - Father to Son and March of the Black Queen - prove that the multiple movements of Bohemian Rhapsody are not an outlier (even if the opera section is out of the box). HIGHLIGHTS: Father to Son is fantastic, inventive and compelling across its multiple movements. Some Day One Day builds up to a triumphant guitar solo. Ogre Battle, The Fairy Feller's Master-Stroke and March of the Black Queen are unhinged in the best possible way and the harmonies and compositions are both epic and ridiculous. I really enjoyed the fantasy-themed songs on Side 2 - reminiscent of Led Zep and a reminder that a lot of rock stars are dorks at heart. Nevermore is a beautiful, brief showcase for Mercury. Funny How Love Is is catchy and buoyed by Taylor's unconventional drumming. Seven Seas of Rhye sets the template for Bat Out of Hell. LOWLIGHTS: The intro is a bit rum. There is also something a bit off with the production on Some Day One Day - some kind of weird flanging effect maybe - but it's still a great song. VERDICT: 5 stars. I'm a lifelong fan of Queen and this one still really took me by surprise - proggy, catchy, wonderfully played and produced (Some Day One Day aside). This is the sound of 4 very talented musicians pushing themselves to the limit in the service of something deeply weird, which I really appreciate. It won't be for everyone - some of it is very silly - but I loved it.

BEFORE: I know this, but not well. Pretty classic punk album, if memory serves. AFTER: D. Boon was an incredible talent taken too soon. I love complex compositions deployed in the service of a punk attitude. Everyone here is at the absolute top of their game. While it's musically very different and far less polished, this reminded me of Refused's The Shape of Punk to Come in the scale of its ambition and quality of execution. There is definitely more jazz / funk / post-punk influence than I remember from previous listens. Will try to keep this high level given the album is so long. HIGHLIGHTS: Favourite tracks here were Theatre Is The Life Of You, Cohesion, Two Beads At The End, Maybe Partying Will Help, Retreat, Corona (the soundtrack to a thousand gratuitous injuries), History Lesson Part 2, You Need the Glory, The Roar of the Masses Could Be Farts, The Politics of Time, Jesus and Tequila, Storm in My House, Love Dance. LOWLIGHTS: Few and far between. I guess the CCR and Steely Dan covers are a bit unnecessary when the originals here are so strong. VERDICT: 5 stars. An incredible record. Going into my regular rotation.

BEFORE: I don't love folk but Joni Mitchell is pretty unique - the crazy guitar tunings, complicated chord progressions and deeply personal lyrics. Calling it folk almost seems a bit reductive. I'm looking forward to this. I know River pretty well because it's on my Christmas playlist, and I also like A Case of You. AFTER: Right from the start, this sounds like nothing else. Mitchell wrings so much invention and feeling from just a guitar or piano, her crystal clear voice and very little else. Her singular vocals cut through everything so well. None of these songs are much over 4 minutes but they still contain so much detail, different movements etc. HIGHLIGHTS: It's all pretty special. Favourite tracks are Little Green, Carey, California, This Flight Tonight, River, The Last Time I Saw Richard. LOWLIGHTS: Don't be silly. VERDICT: 5 stars.

BEFORE: More familiar territory. Should I be worried by how much of this list is pulled from the 60s and 70s? I know that was an important time for the development of rock and popular music, but some newer / more experimental stuff would be welcome. At any rate, I love the Rolling Stones in general and this album in particular so this should be fun. AFTER: Yep it's just as good as it was the previous 50 times I listened to it. The Rolling Stones successfully synthesize blues, country, rock and a few more experimental elements in a way that no one else. The songs are fantastic, the playing is tight. This might be their best album. HIGHLIGHTS: Wild Horses is a fantastic. Can't You Hear Me Knocking earns all 7 minutes and is a great showcase for Mick Taylor (far and away their best lead guitarist). Sister Morphine is harrowing, one of the darkest songs they ever released. Moonlight Mile is still my favourite Stones song (Let It Loose runs it close). LOWLIGHTS: There's a reason they don't play Brown Sugar on the radio anymore. The music is great but the lyrics have aged like milk. I Got The Blues is one of their more forgettable compositions until the Stax-style brass really gets going. In the context of the album, those weaker moments don't really matter. VERDICT: 5 stars. It's a classic and it was a pleasure to listen to it again. Although I am maybe ready for something newer and/or weirder at this point...

BEFORE: I was after something outside that 60s / 70s era that seems to dominate these lists. I didn't get it. I don't love Rod Stewart other than the odd single here and there - his voice is decent but he has made some terrible musical choices over the years. This does seem to be mostly covers which might be a good sign? AFTER: Rod Stewart really only has two modes - gravelly and slow or gravelly and fast. I am in no hurry to listen to this much of his music in one session again, although this was not without its high points. At least he isn't singing about his libido or attempting disco. The playing here is mostly strong, the odd over-ambitious drum-fill aside. HIGHLIGHTS: Gasoline Alley is a fine, upbeat acoustic song. Only A Hobo is well-arranged and performed, particularly the instrumental sections. The instrumental work on Cut Across Shorty is fantastic (see below for the rest). Lady Day and Jo's Lament make much better use of Stewart's vocals - maybe because he wrote them (although the latter owes a debt to Norwegian Wood). You're My Girl isn't bad, although it's an odd choice for an album closer. LOWLIGHTS: It's All Over Now is generic blues-rock that does not need to be 6 minutes long, although the guitar solo is nice enough. Whoever blew that whistle 5 minutes in should have been ejected from the studio. Country Comfort is a lesser Elton John song that can't be improved by Stewart's one-trick vocals, and Jack Reynolds' backing vocals are painfully bad - he sounds like he won a radio competition to be on the album. Stewart's oddly tuneless, over-sung vocals and howling aren't quite enough to ruin Cut Across Shorty, but it does make you wish he would just get out of the way. VERDICT: 2 stars. This is a mixed bag, and I am really not sure why this album is on this list, especially when you look at the full list and see all the amazing stuff that isn't on it. Even the best tracks on here feel inessential - 3 decent originals, some well-rendered versions of middling songs, a couple of outright trainwrecks and more gravel than an abandoned quarry.

TL;DR: Puts the ass in Manassas. BEFORE: FFS. This rootsy 70s shit is really starting to grind me down. I also see that this is a double album. This is why Boomers shouldn't be allowed to make lists. I'm going to need a death metal power cleanse before I listen to this. AFTER: Threw this on before I went out to grab some lunch. It's just so forgettable and way too long. HIGHLIGHTS: There's an OK bluegrass song in there somewhere - maybe on Side 2? It Doesn't Matter has a bit of an early Eagles vibe that I liked. Bound To Fall is decent - it should have been longer. Move Around isn't good but at least it's weird. The guitar work on Blues Man is very good. I'd rather hear someone try something new and fail than 15 tasteful, boring songs that all sound the same. It took until Side 3 of a double album for anything to stick which isn't great. LOWLIGHTS: Kind of all of it apart from the occasional interesting song. Jesus Gave Love Away For Free was particularly off-putting. The lyrics to Johnny's Garden are shite. I felt genuine dread when the tuneless vocals to The Treasure kicked in and saw that it had 8 minutes to go. VERDICT: My first 1 star. Might have been 2 if there was less filler alongside all the handful of decent songs. Tedious, pointless and Stephen Stills seems like an abject dickhead. I was relieved when it was over. I would like a word with whatever failed hippie decided this list needed so many middling albums from the 60s and 70s. I'm only 33 albums in, which is sobering.

TL;DR: Lyrically and sonically brutal. Great if you're into that kind of thing. BEFORE: Is this my reward for slogging through Manassas? AFTER: This is great. Brutal punk / noise with dark lyrics and programmed drums that sometimes veer into industrial territory. If you like this kind of stuff, it's absolutely top tier. If you're not, it's a challenging listen and you have my sympathy. I'm a big fan of Chat Pile, and there are some definitely similarities in the lyrical subject matter, use of repetition with the vocals and dissonant, spidery guitar lines. There are still grooves and catchy moments in here under all the noise, which makes these songs memorable in a way some noise-rock can fail to achieve HIGHLIGHTS: Jordan, Minnesota is an absolutely harrowing way to start an album. Kerosene is fantastic and keeps finding extra gears. Fists of Love is propulsive and dissonant, reminiscent of early Ministry. Strange Things is almost upbeat. The guitars in Cables sound like a sheet metal fabricator tearing itself to pieces (that's a compliment). LOWLIGHTS: None. VERDICT: 5 stars. Heavy as fuck but beautiful as well. A musical kick in the balls. RIP Steve Albini - you were a real one.