Album Summary
Honky Tonk Masquerade is the second album by country singer-songwriter Joe Ely, released in 1978. Ely's second album has been highly regarded by critics around the world. It was included in the 2005 book, 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. Writer Steve Pond places the album at number 40 on Rolling Stone's list of "50 Essential Albums of the 70s", calling it "the decade's most sure-footed country-rock collaboration". Pond places the album in the same class as such 1970s "country landmarks" as Guy Clark's Old No. 1, Willie Nelson's Red Headed Stranger, and Terry Allen's Lubbock (On Everything). In addition, New Zealand critic Fred Muller places the album on his list of the top ten "best albums of the rock era".
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Who? I heard the name once or twice. No one else has apparently listened to him though, the listener counts are mostly under 100K per song. What merits does this album have to get on the list of 1001 must hear records?? The biggest songs for listener counts were "Boxcars" and the title track. It's all just average, very forgettable country. Are these amazingly written songs? I can't put my finger on why this is a must-hear. Never heard anyone cover any of these tracks. I tried. I just don't dig steel guitar and that whiny vibe at all. This did nothing for me. 2 stars, I could suffer through it, but I'm choosing not to listen to every song until the end.
This was pretty generic stuff. It felt a lot longer than it's 33 minute runtime.
TL;DR: Country-rock with plenty of energy and a healthy amount of weirdness, despite the odd dull track. BEFORE: Never heard of him. I'm always wary of country but even if I don't like it this looks mercifully short. AFTER: This guy really likes honky tonks. A few tracks here are almost psychedelic, and some of the arrangements and instrumentation are a cut above bog-standard country rock although the middle section of the album is a bit more generic. HIGHLIGHTS: Cornbread Moon is fast and unpredictable with multiple sections. Boxcars is sinister with distorted lead guitar line that sounds more like new-wave than country, including a fantastic solo. I'll Be Your Fool takes some vocal risks that elevate a simple composition. West Texas Waltz and Honky Tonkin' are fun with a few musical surprises, including that weird lead guitar coming back on the latter. LOWLIGHTS: I don't feel like all of the accordion was necessary. Tonight I Think I'm Gonna Go Downtown and the title track are a bit nondescript. Fingernails is standard issue boogie-woogie with weird lyrics and some kind of electronic organ at the end. OTHER: Jericho sounds like the theme song of a weird biblical sitcom and I can't work out if that's good or bad but I'm leaning towards good. VERDICT: There is some interesting stuff on here and a few songs that won me over. I'm giving it a 4, mostly because there is some weird stuff here that I really liked and probably a little more if I keep listening.
I love good country music. This is not good country music.
I'm not in the camp of most users here; I love country music. I don't like this. I did learn, though, where Jay Faraar learned to sing.
hard-nosed, dusty roots music from the flatlands of East Texas - songs of real life at the margins
Pretty formulaic and one-dimensional country album, but Boxcars is a great tune. The rest barely made me feel anything. He is a capable vocalist, but the music leaves a lot to be desired.
Another album that just has me thinking about all the great albums that aren't on this list.
hm, očekivo sam loš kantri album, a ovo je bilo sasvim solidno. kratko i trunku raznovrsno, neloše sve u svemu. no je li fraza »honky tonk« morala dospjeti u baš dva naslova pjesama? [odslušao i napisao 12/11/26]
normales Country, nix zu sagen
Classic and beautiful honky tonk, from one of the best two ever do it.
3.5 really not bad. Not like my new favorite artist; but was pleasantly surprised. It’s got some interesting wrinkles musically and some more depth than its genre counterparts. Especially for the 70s!
Really not for me. Country has surprised me a couple of times on this list, but this just doesn't bring up anything for me. Just seems completely uninteresting. None of that charm and intelligent songwriting and artistry and delicate arrangements that I've heard on other records. I mean.. I'm sure there must be artistry.. But it's not reaching me
Not heard of Joe and hate Honky Tonk but this was surprisingly lovely country rock.
Quirky country rock. Not awful but also not great or memorable and the best I can say is it passed 33 minutes with the enjoyment levels just the right side of par for it to have been worthwhile.
Look I'm not a country fan but this was interesting enough. I was kind of dreading it to start with as have had some country that just didn't like at all. Enough variety so not just the same old, same old every track. Had enough slide guitar by the end of it 'tho.
Overall: 5/10 Innofensive, bland country music. Nothing to get upset about, but there's not really anything for me to love here on a personal level. The perfect example of an album that just exists. Fav Song: I'll Be Your Fool
Punanska kantria tämä oli
Fine pretty boring
Solid, lush country Favourite tracks: Boxcars, Honky Tonk Masquerade, I'll Be Your Fool
A serviceable country album, this is the kind of generic music you'd hear in some dusty bar in the middle of nowhere Texas. Not much to this one, the songs and artist are both fine, so I won't put much effort in beyond that. If you like older country, you'll like it; lots of chuds in the reviews just automatically hate it because it's country music, without even listening, and that's disappointing, because even I give every electronica album a chance. 3/5
Sehr krass country. Isch nöd so mis aber ich check das es uf dere liste isch. Ich denke für en country künschtler isch es es sehr guetes Album und ich chan mer au vorstelle wie anderi das gnüssed, aber ich finds eif nöd geil
This was a fun album. Kind of a hard left on Fingernails, but overall very enjoyable. Good thing nobody foisted Joe Ely on me like u2 did.
I don't know what y'all are talking about, that was fun as hell. Short, sweet, honky tonkin good time
#70 Saw the genre, didn't listen
This is only the 2nd album I’ve come across that makes me glad I’m doing this. Late 60s to early 80s was a great time for country music and this guy is really good.
didn't expect to enjoy another country record from this list to this level, but this is awesome. the frequently employed rock elements are an excellent addition.
Rätt så intetsägande country
Disco mediano, apresentando canções country ordinárias.
okay
This is a country album mixed with some sort of honky tonk bluesy undertone. It’s still country and I am not a fan of that genre and no amount of blues undertone is going to change that! Not my cup of tea but I did make it to the end as it’s mercifully quite short!
Joe Ely was a singer-songwriter at the forefront of Austin's eclectic country-rock scene. He started his music career in the country band The Flatlanders with Jimmie Dale Gilmore and Butch Hancock, though they broke up after one year and wouldn't reunite until decades later. But Joe carried on, releasing two solo albums, including this one, Honky Tonk Masquerade. While playing in London, Joe befriended The Clash of all bands. They were so impressed with each other that Joe Ely wound up opening for The Clash during their London Calling tour. This partnership would last through the rest of The Clash's career, including Joe Ely's appearance in the gang vocals on "Should I Stay or Should I Go". So yeah, Joe Ely got a lot of notoriety and inclusion in the 1001 Albums books because of his connection to The Clash. Does it once again feed into the UK bias that Robert Dimery and his editorial team lean on? Yes, and it's hard to deny that. But here's the thing - I do recognize the artistic merit of Joe Ely and his backing band, between Joe's smooth vocal delivery, Lloyd Maines's prominent steel guitar flourishes, Ponty Bone's emphatic accordion playing, and Shane Keister's Moog synth nestled into the mix without overwhelming the other instruments, all while the band played around with complex song structures. It's more progressive than your average honky-tonk music, which I dig. Sure, some songs and lyrics get cheesy, such as Joe comparing the moon to cornbread, using the biblical fall of the Walls of Jericho as a metaphor for a woman to enjoy the moment, and wanting to keep his fingernails long so they click when he plays the piano. Not to mention, there's an admittedly on-the-nose cover of an old Hank Williams tune in "Honky Tonkin'". But these songs are delivered with such earnestness and unassuming nature that I can't help but be smitten, especially with the more pensive deep cuts like "Tonight I Think I'm Gonna Go Downtown" and "Boxcars, the latter opposite that warm synth motif. So yeah, I had a good time at this Honky Tonk Masquerade that Joe Ely held. Joe enjoyed a long, successful music career until his passing last year from a bout with Parkinson's, dementia, and pneumonia. Rest in peace.
Never heard of this before and it was ok!
Oh... THAT is just bad country.
Hillbilly musix
Bit basic. I enjoy this kind of country, but not enough here to grab me.
I really vibed with this album, the bridge between country and blues made this a really smooth listen, and as soon as it finished I started it all over again
10/26/26. Country isn't my genre but appreciated hearing straightforward songs that sound just like the title of the album! I imagine this is what classic country sounds like but could be very wrong.
Fuck this shit, not listening to any other country album, fuck it! Go fuck yourselfs, you fucking country westerners pieces of shit In my mind I'm giving this a round zeroooooooooooooo
I've come to realise over time that there was a shift in recording quality in the mid-70s and this sounds nice sure, but so did everything else that cared to in the late 70s onwards. It's well-played. It's well-worn in style in that it's very derivative of every other country artist ever. It's not bad, it's not good, it's just average. Wild inclusion for the list.
Pretty good album with the exception of the “Fingernails” song. Hard to get past that one.
A lot of modern country influence in this one I feel like, which is interesting since based on reading about the artist, it seems like the goal is to push back on some of the up-and-coming Nashville sound. I found the lyrics to be a bit repetitive as well, just not much on here to grab me. West Texas waltz was one of the better tunes on there.
Väldigt tråkigt sound. Ointressanta låtar. Lama texter. Inget för mig! 1/5
Durch das Rockige wird's ganz erträglich.
Das Genre, das bei uns in der Gruppe scheinbar am schwierigsten hat. Hat mich schnell verlassen, vom Grundsatz her aber nicht vollkommen nervig, was schon mal mehr als der meiste Country für mich leistet.
This album sucked!
Very honky Tonk! Top bops: Tonight I think I’m gonna go downtown West Texas waltz Honky tonkin’
achei bom, só não é tanto meu estilo mesmo
country normalzinho
Don't tell enyone, but I kinda liked this one. Favorite track: Because Of The Wind
I tend to be a bit meh on a decent amount of older country but this shit slaps. 8/10
This was some pretty classic straightforward country music, but… that didn’t really impress me. A few dashes of zydeco and a Hank Williams cover, but it still felt like a slog.
It was a decent country album! I like country just fine. But I am going to forget about this as soon as I vote and see the next album. :/ 2.5 stars, because it is just about as neutral as it gets for me.
Not my favourite genre but was enjoyable enough
While not a virgin to country music, I’m also not experienced either. This was fun, very bouncy honky Tonk country music. I like it.
Decent country album. A couple of decent songs but some too country for my taste. Not bad though.
I swear the one genre of music I have always been more than impressed with during my entire dive into the 1001 albums to hear before you die list is all of the Country picks. Joe Ely's Honky Tonk Masquerade is once again another addition to these picks blowing my mind in terms of quality. This album comes swinging with a lot of very catchy and fun Outlaw Country tracks that really know how to have a good time with itself. The instrumentation is quite enjoyable and the singing by Joe Ely does the trick in winning you over into having a grand ol' time with this snappy 33 minute project. Not much to say here other than to see it for yourself because this is a blast!
Great older country I had not heard before.
Consider my tonks honked
Looking at the album's title and cover, I was expecting a pretty standard country album. While it feels rather standard in places, the busier production and use of fuzzy guitars and synthesisers help it stick out. What is even more impressive is that that none of the synths parts sound particularly dated. Taking a stronger influence from rock music, this feels like an update to the standard country formula. Although it may not mix things up too much and there are certain moments that feel corny, this still a stomping hoot of a record that has a short runtime that doesn't allow the music to stagnate.
It was good but not my vibe
Nothing special
This is amazing. The singing isn't always great, but this album is just a good time.
Needed a little more Tonk and a little less Honk. Really liked the first song but found it pretty inconsistent after that.
3.0 A touch disappointed in this one, I thought it was over produced for what it is. Songs are solid, if not a bit standard
2.9
More enjoyable than most country music. I like the zydeco flavors in here
Honky tonk masquerading as what, exactly? Bland boring country music?
I didn’t enjoy a single thing about this album. Not one song stood out to me or gave me any reason to revisit it. From beginning to end, nothing appealed to me, making it an entirely unenjoyable listening experience. There wasn’t a single redeeming moment for me. Overall: 0/10.
Essential Texas music. The guy opened for the Clash on their first tour of the US for crying out loud! Joe's best record 4.5 stars
Je sais pas rien d’extraordinaire
Enjoyment: 8/10 Replayability: 7/10 Cohesion: 7/10 Flow/Pacing: 8/10 Artistic Merit: 6/10 Weighted Average: 7.3/10 Review: Now this is some classic, honky tonk sound - I just wanted to jump out of my seat and start square dancing with it. Some of the synthesizer portions didn't fit as well as they could, but the melodies easily counteracted any bad will that was mustered. Liked Song(s): Jericho (You Walls Must Come Tumbling Down), Honky Tonk Masquerade, I'll Be Your Fool, Fingernails, West Texas Waltz Disliked Song(s): (None) Recommend? Yes Heard Before? No
Sounds like a pretty representative album of the genre. It's good, but not sure it's good enough to get past my bias against default country. Later tracks were enjoyable. I suppose it's not a bad cover of honky tonkin' though i like Van Zandt's more. Overall not a bad country album.
There've been a lot of "not like the other girls!!" country albums on this list, things that bait out comments like "I can't get into most country, but this one's different!" This album is a healthy break from that; the one that'll absolutely make no new believers, the one that plays it straight and has little going for it to make the urban, the british, and the liberal say "not all country music!" Unless you're the world's biggest accordion fan. Or Robert Dimery, I suppose
I like a lot of this well enough, but not enough to revisit it, probably ever. 7/10
This album started out strong (for a country album), but as it went on it got more and more honky and I got less and less interested. High 2.
This was fine, just another 70s country album that I’ll forget I listened to Playlist add: “Jericho (Your Walls Must Come Tumbling Down)”
Do you know what a honky-tonk is? If not, that’s fine — after all, you probably aren’t American. It’s an inexpensive bar featuring live music that mostly attracts working-class folks — a dive bar, basically. Later on, the term was also applied to the genre of music played in these establishments. And do you know who Joe Ely is? If not, that’s understandable; even not all Americans know him. It turns out he’s a country artist who played exactly that kind of honky-tonk music. To put it simply: imagine rockabilly without the upright bass and keyboards. That’s roughly what this album sounds like. The occasional, unexpected appearance of an accordion adds a bit of variety to the mix. I haven’t the faintest idea why this record made the list of essential albums. The songs are decent, soulful Texas tunes, but there’s nothing particularly special about them. Presumably, the people who compiled the list were simply surprised that, by the late 70s, someone was still capable of bringing something new to country music.
This is some very creatively composed country. It has some velocity I don't often hear in the genre. I love the accordion especially, but there are tons of cool arrangement details across this thing. I may have to revisit this and give it a more in depth review, but I loved this quite a bit!
Ughh. Man I have gotten a string of bad to just fine albums, and this one is not helping. Guess that's what I get for having a really damn good string of 4s and 5s recently. I'm sure it's fine for country, but this stuff does nothing for me and a lot of times verges on annoying. I will say Boxcars is a pretty good song though, since it's darker and got more of a vibe to it beyond just standard old country. But yeah. Not enjoying this one.
This really isn’t good
First impression: wow, this is bad. The first song sounds like a Paperback Writer ripoff, then it morphs into an upbeat bluesy-jazz feel. Yikes. The rest is cliched country that's a little over-produced. No thanks.
I don't like it
I did not hate this! Pretty enjoyable romp all told. Was expecting something a lot less upbeat and a lot more droney. Result.
Pretty generic 70s country. Joe Ely is talented, but this isn't great.
Sometimes I can't help but feel like all country music can be classified in two: good sounding music, and circus music. I will let the rating speak for me.
Not terrible, but it felt a lot longer than 34 minutes.
The fast songs are good. The slow songs are a saccharine slog
You know, if anything, I think this could have been honkier AND tonkier. I was generally pretty up on the upbeat songs with prominent gee-tar. Other parts are proper country, but it's decent enough. I like his singing voice. I was maybe less enthused as it went on, but overall I was pretty happy with this!
I thought this was a fun listen
Nope. Fairly poor
Not for me
Decent album. Not a fan of country, but some of his songs sounded good when they had some blues to it and I can appreciate his guitar play. I also like that he's not doing the whole country drawl that has gotten popular with current country.
Sometimes country catches my ear - this didn't album really didn't do that till the last song. I'd give this album a 2.5, but I'm okay with 3.
Honkey Tonk ist one of the most stupid names that have ever been created by men
Well, this was surprising.
A bit too cheesy for me..
Really liked it. I like classic country that’s a distinct genre from pop.
As country music goes, this shit legendary. Proper country stuff. Fantasied about working on a texas ranch while listening to the whole album.
The name really says it all with this one.