Arthur (Or the Decline and Fall of the British Empire) by The Kinks

Arthur (Or the Decline and Fall of the British Empire)

The Kinks

3.38
Rating
29586
Votes
1
3%
2
13%
3
40%
4
32%
5
12%
Distribution

Album Summary

Arthur (Or the Decline and Fall of the British Empire), often referred to as just Arthur, is the seventh studio album by the English rock band the Kinks, released in October 1969. Kinks frontman Ray Davies constructed the concept album as the soundtrack to a Granada Television play and developed the storyline with novelist Julian Mitchell; the television programme was never produced. The rough plot revolved around Arthur Morgan, a carpet-layer, who was based on Ray and guitarist Dave Davies' brother-in-law Arthur Anning. A stereo version was released internationally. A mono version was released in the UK, but not in the US. The album was met with poor sales but nearly unanimous acclaim, especially among the American music press. Although Arthur and its first two singles, "Drivin’" and "Shangri-La", failed to chart in the UK, the Kinks returned to the Billboard charts after a two-year absence with "Victoria", the lead single in the US, peaking at number 62. The album itself reached number 105 on the Billboard album chart, their highest position since 1965. Arthur paved the way for the further success of the Kinks’ 1970 comeback album Lola Versus Powerman and the Moneygoround, Part One.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Absolutely brilliant album with so many great songs, not a miss on the entire album. Shanri-La is one of the great songs from the 60s.

After Ray Charles, Ray Davies is probably the other great musician of that name. Unlike Charles though, the strength here is in the songwriting and lyricism rather than singing or arrangement. There are some decent arrangements on this album, but the primary strength is in the class-conscious lyrics and thematic tapestry of the whole. I understood the theme to be the plight of the working class in an Empire. We hear songs about them dying in wars that don't benefit them, and winning petty rewards of their labors like fancy hats and televisions. Musically, the Kinks aren't very ambitious, but I find their songs to be effective and enjoyable in the immediate way that pop should be. Some songs fall flat or get annoying, but I'm glad to have listened to the album.

I am not particularly fond of concept albums, let alone "rock operas". This one -- that I did not know at all: until yesterday I thought Victoria was written by the Fall... what a discovery! -- is not that pretentious though, and the working-class perspective on war, exploitation and alienation sounds fresh and powerful today too. Especially compared to the ludicrous concept of Tommy (same year!). Musically, it also reminds me a little of Tommy but is much better: while Tommy, besides a few cool songs, is littered with lame tracks, this one remains enjoyable all along.

I really like this album. The combination of ironic humour and earnest melancholy is so compelling. Ray Davies has such a warm, playful style of singing that lines like "back home they put his picture in a frame, but all dead soldiers look the same" come as a gut punch.

The Kinks album is centred around this guy called Arthur and his living predicament. It has all that classic snappy British wit and deadpan humour to attack certain things like complacency in society and war. Speaking of war I believe this has some of the best anti-war music/lyrics ever in recorded music history. The narrative takes you on a journey and allows the listener to immerse themselves into Arthur and his story. It eventually pays off so well once you get to the final song. An example of a lyric that attacks complacency is in the song "Brainwashed": "You've got a job and a house And a wife and your kids and your car Yeah, you're conditioned to think What they want you to think and be happy to be where you are Yes you are Get down on your knees Get down on your knees" That is so punk! I had such a good time with this album, I'd recommend it time after time. Highlight Song/s: "Yes Sir, No Sir", "Brainwashed" and "Mr. Churchill Says"

Album was good for the time period. It had a fairly smooth flow from song to song and kept a good beat. Not sure I would listen to it again, but it was decent. Seemed to be well put together. It was a solid 6/10 and I gave it 3 stars.

A kinks fan is born

Esta guay el concepto, el album suena bien, pero es un sonido que tengo muy visto, innovador para su epoca supongo

Last Kinks album for my group, and this is certainly an interesting one to go out on. Solid 4 Stars.

I’m way above a 5. Not quite a 10, but there’s a chance it might get there someday. It’s just a great album, honestly; it’s not doing anything overly special, but it does everything right at a really high level. It’s a good critique of British politics of the era, framed via a look back at the first half of the 20th century from a normal guy named Arthur. The title track calls him “a plain simple man in a plain simple working class position”, and I’m inclined to believe it. Arthur doesn’t really have a starry-eyed gaze towards Britain’s role in World War 1 or World War 2; he had family members who died, and he found his living conditions diminished. This album sits in the aftermath of those rather expensive ventures, both of which have left him without much opportunity for growth in a much more scarce society following the wars. He’s pretty comfortable, and it’s all adequate (including some fashion like the upper class gets to wear), but it just leaves him stuck in a rut that lets the world pass him by. There’s always Australia, though. All of these tracks are based on the lives of one of Ray Davies’ sisters & her husband, and the songwriting that results feels surprisingly vivid for the time. This is only 25 years after 1944 after all, so I’m sure a lot of these wounds hadn’t totally healed. I’m sure there’s plenty of Arthurs who existed in the aftermath of World War 1, hence ‘the Lost Generation’ & all that. For as plain & simple as Arthur’s viewpoint is, the instrumentation here is anything but plain & simple. It feels like a healthy take on what the Beatles were doing after Sgt. Pepper’s, combined with just a bit of edge from their slightly harder contemporaries. This album is at its best when it’s pushing hard rock sensibilities to the forefront of its Beatles-y structures, and it’s doing that for most of the album. It’s not consistently as tight as a Beatles album, but it makes up for it with some strong dynamic shifts in each track, great vocal work & a lot more bite in the lyrics than say, Ringo Starr singing about an octopus’s garden. It also knows when to go softer too, and those moments make for welcome changes of pace. This album is just unassumingly great; there’s really not a dull moment on each track, and the energy from the rest of the band feels like it’s on another level compared to the other Kinks albums we’ve gotten on the list. You have to have a healthy respect for the actual lyricism at hand here to really get into it, as it occasionally does feel a bit rambly otherwise, but I think it’s impossible to ignore the social commentary here. I think if you’re listening to it casually, there’s just a natural lift in each track that keeps them engaging & fresh, and it feels surprisingly modern at points. “Brainwashed” in particular felt way more like a 2000s track than I would’ve thought, and “Shangri-La” has a vocal structure that somehow felt like a prototype Oasis with just a hint of R.E.M. in there. Of course, it’s all still rather Beatles-y, but at least they still tried to do something unique in the space. All in all, I’m well above a 5; it’s not quite a 10 on account of the intangibles (which is to say it doesn’t *feel* like a 10 on a first pass & I’m sure I’ll discover something my brain isn’t as keen on with a relisten), but maybe I’ll prove myself wrong and it’ll get to a 10 someday. I can see why other people might go to a 4 here, but the floor is surely a 3. For me, I found a lot of this hit just a bit close to home & felt a bit relevant even now. It’s also just a great listen to my ears. Hence, something well above a 5.

OK mais ceci était tout à fait excellent

Distraught at his sister Rosie and brother-in-law Arthur's emigration to Australia, Ray Davies widened his ire into a musically epic assault on the British Empire and deathly suburbia. I actually quite like the divisive "Australia", although far more for the proto-psych rock jam band nature than any of its social commentary, but in general songs are running too long and the vaudeville and the aimless nostalgic pining gets boring fast as I dont give a fuck about the whole concept album stichk. I kinda-kinda respect trying to make a sprawling concept rock opera out of the British 20th century, but a) that’s a harder challenge than I think they could pull off and b) it’s just reflective of a sort of introspective Britishness that I don’t care for in the Kinks still even when it has less nostalgia ironic or otherwise.

The Kinks don't get enough respect. Of the British Invasion bands, it seems like they tend to come in a distant fourth after The Beatles, The Stones, and The Who. But in my personal estimate, I think they're the second best after The Beatles. Arthur is not their best record by any means (that would be The Village Green Preservation Society), but I don't know how anyone can come away from this whimsical and satirical collection of songs without being at least a little charmed. Plus, Victoria is an all time classic..

I've always had a massive love for this record. It's just so fun, and has so many memorable songs. There's some that I can take or leave but on the whole it's one of my imperfect favourites.

first kinks album. 01. good. vocal performance and guitar are nice. 3.5/5 02. 1:50, change into smooth guitar and vocal, interesting. 3.5/5 03. nice melodies, thoughtful lyrics. 3.5/5 04. good chrous. do feel like 60s music. 3.5/5 05. like the sax in it.smooth melody. 3.5/5 06. another good chrous here. beautiful vocal. mid part arrangement is quite interesting. 3.5/5 07. quite more emotional than others. the kind of 60s songs i like. 4/5 08. they have great chrous. i like the up&down of melodies. 3.5/5 09. good and quiet intro. then it goes into a more groove part. 3.5/5 10. young and innocent days. 3.5/5 11. quiet sad lyrics. such bands are good at using happy songs to describe sad things. 4/5 12. not bad ending. 3.5/5 all are nice, but just feel like some places can be better. also sound quailty isn't so good. just can't reach my standard of 4/5 album. final: 3.5/5. 261116_1713

nope. not interested

A rather boring album, a few decent songs but most songs feel very samey

another kinks album, and I still think these blokes are pretty talented and creative. It sounds clunky and British at times, but mostly pretty enjoyable. I especially appreciate their anti-establishment , anti-war messaging. Strong 3 to a light 4

The songs I knew previously here are "Victoria" (which I've loved since I first heard it, as a kid), and "Shangri-La," which is also a very good song. The other 9 songs weren't at the same level, for me. Nothing objectionable, but also nothing too special, that I could hear. And I like the Kinks, but I see that there are 4 Kinks albums on this list, which seems a bit high (a bit of the 'Brit bias' that we've detected, previously?) - and I think this might have been one that could have been left off. Don't get me wrong: there have already been (what are we, about 260 albums so far?) plenty of albums that I've liked less than this Kinks album. But if I did my own 1001 albums list, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't have 4 Kinks albums (probably 1, or *possibly* 2). Brit bias here, too, in the subject matter of the songs (though I'm probably more tolerant of/interested in this than most other non-Brits). The bigger problem for me isn't the lyrics themselves, but that the lyrics strike me as being very important to the songs, but I'm probably less interested in lyrics than most people: good lyrics aren't going to make me like a mediocre song more. Anyway, I was actually glad to be introduced (just this once) to this Kinks album, and I liked it well enough to give it 3 stars. 5 stars for Victoria, and 4 for Shangri-La; but none of the other songs made me hope to hear them again (though I did enjoy hearing them this once), so a 3, overall.

I really enjoyed listening to this! I've always been a casual Kinks fan, but the more I dive into their albums the more I realize how much great music they have to offer. Great early rock opera too. Will definitely give this one a relisten in the future. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

It's good until that one guy who can't sing starts singing.

Boring. Sounds like a Beatles cover band. The Kinks are better than this. Thought Australia was a good song and was ready to wrap it up only to find there was half an album left.

I don’t think I have heard a Kinks album that I disliked yet, but I haven’t gone too far into their later catalog so I am probably jinxing myself. This was another fun one. I’m guessing it’s a concept album, so maybe that’s why it feels a little disjointed. Some of the songs didn’t feel like they were from the same band. Overall, I enjoyed the listen. 4 stars

guet lune musig, aber nid spezieu berüehrend. paae einzelni cooli lieder

i mean iiiits alriiiight

i already got this album. not sure why it gave it to me again but it’s one of my favs from the project

Concept albums are a dubious undertaking. It's not enough to have some solid hits on the album, there's got to be a cohesive story element that audiences can actually pick up on. In that, I think The Kinks succeeded. This is not my favorite album from them however. It's decent, and has some fun songs, but nothing really stood out to me. This is not an album I'd be inclined to actively seek out again.

It’s crazy how many sounds the Kinks have. I loved this album.

simply a very enjoyable classic pop rock sound.

Wow, this was very British haha. Pretty good but I found some of the songs topics to be a bit depressing. I get it's part of the concept for this album, but I probably wouldn't listen again.

Zany Kinks, ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Ehh, it was okay. Nothing grabbed me but I didn't mind listening to it.

Fun time with The Kinks

This isn't bad at all. Something my parents used to listen to back in the day. Is this better than Morrissey? Yes, it damn for sure well is. 3/5.

I’m cool with the Kinks. They’ve got a dated sound, but I like their style.

Great album. They are better than their collected singles.

I’m gradually coming round to the idea that the Kinks are the most overlooked band of all time.

Some cracking tunes on this, especially Victoria.

Not there best

Альбом открывает прекрасная Виктория. К сожалению, ни одна песня, следующая после неё, не дотягивает до уровня первой

A wonderfully weird album. A few of the tracks had a bit too much going on for me - just sounded like a lot of noise. Overall I liked it, though. I’d give it a 3.5 based on my initial listen.

This was so good.

Solid album with some of their better hits. Very whimsical and doesn’t take itself too serious. Kinks always get left behind when talking about the greats during the British Invasion but they consistently put out interesting and different music from their peers

TL;DR: A varied and solid collection of songs with plenty of hooks and some wonderful details, even if it doesn't always hold your attention. Skip the song about the hat. BEFORE: Second Kinks album in a week. First one was mid. Ah well. I honestly don't know any of these songs. AFTER: This is a lot better than the fine but underwhelming Face to Face. HIGHLIGHTS: The production and instrumentation is a lot more complex, and I especially enjoyed the brass arrangements, backing vocals and guitar work. Victoria is a banger and it turns out I did know it. Some Mother's Son is an effective ballad. Australia runs through multiple movements and some fairly complex arrangements and great extended outro without losing its groove. Shangri-La starts with a gentle acoustic arrangement before building to a huge chorus. Young and Innocent Days is melodic and wistful with an almost baroque arrangement. Nothing To Say is an upbeat, rockier song with a great brass arrangement. Arthur has excellent guitar work that reminds me of Graham Coxon, although the song doesn't always live up to it. LOWLIGHTS: She's Bought A Hat Like Princess Marina brings the Knees Up Mother Brown vibes. It's aggressively annoying. VERDICT: Much better than the other one I had to review but the Princess Marina song is dire. 4 stars.

I don't think I fully understand the breadth and depth of this album. At surface value it definitely feels like I'm missing context and it sounds good but also competitive. It's definitely trying to do something here that's competing with another band or within a genre but I am not in-the-know. It's overall a pretty decent album and has some really interesting stereo moments. Stand out song is "Shangri-la". Overall rating is a 6/10.

great run of kinks records

Heard better kinks songs idk might just be me

I went through a massive The Kinks phase back in the day, but I haven't listened to them in ages. My favorite albums are Lola versus Powerman and Village Green Preservation Society, but this one is excellent too. Close to five stars.

Great album

I just find The Kinks to be very safe and uninspiring. Don’t get me wrong they obviously did something right, and I fully think this is a me thing moreso, but they just don’t really move me. There was nothing wrong with this, but then there wasn’t anything to get me up of my seat either.

Really not very good.

I enjoy The Kinks, but this album was nothing to write home about.

Fun pop rock album. I guess it was what I expected, The Kinks haven't missed for me so far. A cool mix of some more rocky tunes and some quirky and joyous piano based songs. Pretty harmonies as well. Favourite songs: Victoria, Australia, Shangri-La, Arthur

Probably my favorite of theirs.

Really enjoyed this one. Dark and serious in parts, fun and upbeat in parts. Excellent sounding. Really feels like it belongs in that American anti-Vietnam era, thematically, even though it’s a British band. Very good.

i like its good clear message and sounds nice

i already got this album. not sure why it gave it to me again but it’s one of my favs from the project

A great album that blends classic rock sounds of the Kinks with lyrics about breaking free from the chains of everyday life and living for yourself. The highs are high and the lows are low on this album, with songs like “Brainwashed”, “Arthur”, and “Some Mother’s Son” being great tracks, while other like “Drivin’” just fall flat. “Mr. Churchill Says” is a real highlight bring in real lines from his speeches and even an air raid siren. A great album that could maybe lean into its concept a bit more.

2.5 stars, not bad but nothing great

ok álbum

Incredible story of post war Britain

Interesting, but no song sticks out to me.

Can’t believe this cans out in the late 60s. I always thought links were more recent. Ahead of thier time. 3.8

I don’t vibe that much with 60s music. But this is great for the period. I’d happily listen to this next to the Beatles. 7/10 Quite Likeable

if you put this on and told me it was The Beatles I'd say okay! and if you asked if I liked it I'd say yeah it was fine!

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

day 24 of not rolling Aja by Steely Dan my first exposure to The Kinks was in 9th grade when my "band" (lol) did a cover of Harry Rag and then the lyrics became our vocal stims for the next like... year. This may have been one point of origin for my British hate. there were two people named Alex in this "band" (we played two shows, one at a church and one at Thursday Night Live and that's literally it) but I was the first one to join the band, so everyone started calling me "Proper" because-- according to them-- it was a Britishism to call the first-to-arrive person in a duo of same-named people "Proper" instead of their given name. So I was the proper Alex, I suppose. At first I thought it was cool. Then I grew to hate it. Maybe it planted a seed. i don't have a sense for how popular The Kinks were (are?), but i felt at the time of my introduction that they really deserved a bigger spotlight than they had. lots of great British musical acts in the 60s obviously, but by the time i was 15 i was sure i'd heard of all of them, and yet The Kinks were new to me. This album and Something Else were pretty frequent plays on my 2009 iPod Touch (how i miss you, wherever you are, dear sweet iPod Touch). the most common comment, i feel certain, is that this album has pretty significant Beatles vibes. i can't imagine The Kinks trying to actually compete, so in my mind this is a love letter to that same pop rock sound. there are some really fun riffs in these songs, and i really enjoy Ray Davies's voice. "Drivin'" is really the only song I don't like.

this was fun

I seesawed back and forth between loving this and hating this and ultimately landed on enjoying this one. I have loved "Victoria" forever because of its feature in an episode of 'How I Met Your Mother,' but I've never heard any other Kinks besides the stray single. It's weird but it's not too off-putting to where it doesn't work. Lol at the one 1969 review that's like "the Beatles still have a lot of catching up to do" as if the Beatles didn't make it possible for this sound to be popular in the US AND like they weren't at their peak during this same year.

Does not reach the heights of Village Green Preservation society but magnificent record

Wide ranging and a bit flamboyant for the rockers

Yep, Australia is just that good.

Decent album this, enjoyed it more than I thought I would

Another Kinks album that is just mid to me. Like if someone asked me to give them a random psychedelic album to give them an idea of what 60s music is like, I'd give them this one. I'd use it as a baseline before sending something much better, so they would be able to discern good from great. Highlight: Mr. Churchill Says

This album is not what the Kinks radio hits sound like. It’s a concept album and those are always weird, but it was a solid listen.

Pretty good, had listened to this previously and enjoyed it a bit more this time around.

Enjoyed this from beginning to end and could hear how this would've influenced groups like Of Montreal and other bands that don't take themselves too seriously. The production value is a bit low, but the way the songs morph into other creations is next level. Might get to a 4.5 for me.

I love Thr Kinks. I feel like they got overlooked in their prime, but you can still hear their influence in so many styles today.

Solid album. I have never listened to the Kinks before. Reminds me of the Beatles a lot. Nothing skippable but also nothing is a standout. Worthy of further listens and adding to library.

Rock, baroque pop.

Vähä rasittavaa wanhaa rallattelua.

Hitusen tavanomaista mielenkiintosempi perus rokkilevy kyseiseltä ajalta, mutta silti peus rokkilevy kyseiseltä ajalta. Läpi kuunneltu, ei paljoa kotio vietävää.

Really enjoyed this. Particularly as I don't know much of the Kinks outside the big hits. They've got something so British about them that I enjoy and makes me a bit wistful for a time my parents would have even been a bit too young to live through. Some good stuff on here.

What a weird fuckin' album. A proper sine wave of tone. Dude just repeats 'Australia' over and over again until you have to unbuckle the belt from the semantic satiation. then you get the contemplative quiet Shangri-La goes so incredibly hard. Then you're hearing kazoos and... I don't know, man. It's a lot. It sounds a bit discount Beatles to me, and in chasing that high they don't tap into the same font of imagination they do in everywhere else. I'm a big fan of The Kink's other works, but Arthur is a bit middle of the road. Fav tracks: Shangri-La

Honestly, this felt like a bad copy of the Beatles, and I couldn't really get into it. I can see what The Kinks were going for, but the whole thing just didn't click for me. The melodies and harmonies often felt like they were trying too hard to capture that Beatles-esque sound without bringing much of their own magic to the table. The songwriting has its moments, but nothing really stood out enough to keep me interested. Even when the album tries to be clever or satirical, it doesn't always land the way it should. I also found the whole theatrical, concept-album approach a bit tiresome after a while. There are some decent ideas here, and I can appreciate the ambition behind the project, but the execution left me pretty cold. The production and arrangements didn't do much to change my mind either. Maybe it works better if you're already a big fan of The Kinks, but I just wasn't feeling it. Overall, this was a pretty forgettable listen for me. Not terrible in every aspect, but definitely not an album I'd be in a hurry to revisit.

A 4; I fully understand that it made its mark and was significant at the time, but I found it a bit mundane now! However, I loved “Yes Sir, No Sir,” “Sangri-La,” and a few other tracks - a truly respectable album, but one that, for me, won’t get more than a 4 today And it’s one more on the list for that question: “Is it really essential to listen to this before I die?” I confess that, in this case, I’m torn :-( But it’s perfect for clearing my ears of all the crap I’ve heard here. Thank goodness for that :-)

A la seconde écoute, une note de 3. 3.5 en réalité Australia et mr churchill says=4

I always thought I liked the ‘old’ Kinks albums best. Not so much a fan of their concept albums, but I was pleasantly surprised on relistening Arthur. Australia was my standout track and Victoria a nice trip down memory lane

Starts and ends with great songs. Oh, the songs in between are also great. Finding albums like this are why I decided to do this project.

724/1001 2026.10.15 🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑

I really enjoyed this album,

i hate this so much please RELEASE MEEEEEEEEEEEEEE yes so no sir :nerd: like this is not a nursery rhyme gang dnfed this alvum bro get out 1/10

I appreciate anyone poking fun at the British Empire. However I’m not a fan. A tad bored, but didn’t actively dislike it. 2.5/5

I wanted to like this more than I did. 3 Boolean: True?

Listening session: october 15th, while getting ready in the morning Listened to before: no Thoughts: the Kinks are classic but somehow most of this didn’t really stand out to me Favourite tracks: Victoria & Shangri-La

It's a perfectly cromulent pop record of its activist era. The songs are catchy in the moment, but I didn't come away from it with anything particularly memorable.

Best so far, but should have given Amy a 4 lol