always find myself completely enthralled by the longer tracks on here, such effective mood-setting that I don't notice the time going by. essential my-mom-core
one of the Big Time Rock & Roll Bands whose popularity truly confounds me. i really don't think i'd be able to tell the difference between these tracks & anything on their other albums (though i don't mind you shook me all night long)
the notion of this as some grandiose comeback falls short when the songwriting is stale after one verse/chorus cycle; most of these riffs sound like examples from the cd that comes with an introductory guitar lesson book
this is great music for car sex after prom but not much else!
the first of the "formative" Stones albums i've gotten around to (anything before Beggars Banquet)! being someone who's only checked them out via similar album challenges, it's hard to stop myself from looking at their music in the context of their contemporaries. especially with this album drawing comparisons to Rubber Soul, i struggle to find many thematical or musical similarities other than both of them being released in the same six-month window. the few uncommon instrumental choices, while interesting, don't do a whole lot to reshape the Stones' identity as a blues rock band, though it is a style that fits their skillset. Jagger's vocals & the rhythm section at large (the organ parts are cool!) do a lot to individualize the group's sound, i've just never understood the perception of them as pioneering anything that wasn't already being done by the Bob/Beach/Beatle/Kink sector of mid-60's rock innovation.
the acoustic moments interspersed throughout are a nice change of pace & generally my favorite songs of theirs; Brian Jones is just as vital an ingredient to their sound as Jagger/Richards imo. the runtime is a liiiiittle much for the lack of variety (Going Home does not help) but i can appreciate that as some element of statement-making! if we could award half-star ratings this would be a perfect candidate for 2.5, i don't actively dislike anything besides the misogyny but i doubt i'd find myself repeating any of these tracks except Paint It Black (which isn't even on the version of this i listened to)
invasion by association
i'll never forget dragging my family to go look at these buildings on an NYC trip when i was 13. Zeppelin were the first band i properly found on my own when i stopped getting my taste from video games or whatever was being played around me, and this album in particular had a real hold on me for a while. i spent a lot of time in middle school talking this up as my all-time favorite, and while that doesn't ring true anymore i still find myself drawn to the same things about it
this record draws from both the rugged sound of their first two eponymous albums & the mystic introspection of the latter two, and would be my pick for the album most representative of the band overall. it makes sense considering that a number of these songs were taken from sessions for previous albums, and the sequencing here does a great job to keep that balance intact & not lean too much into one particular sound. the exception to that is the final side, where they cram all the shitty blues rock songs into the last 15 minutes (on that note, Sick Again has somehow the grossest lyrics of any song so far)
JPJ remains the unsung hero of this band, and the varied sound of this record is largely due to his contributions. Bonham rarely sounded better than he did here; the presence of the drums on tracks like In My Time of Dying/Trampled Under Foot/Night Flight is just so effective. the kick squeaks so much!
this is a double album that doesn't feel its length to me, which is especially impressive given the 11-minute song. the stretch of tracks from the beginning til about 10-11 songs in has some of their best moments in their catalog music, and a level of consistency that i don't think quite exists on any of their other records. it holds up quite well for me & i'd probably put it 1st or 2nd among their albums; i guess we'll see for sure when other ones pop up on this list
god chase utley was so cool
as a child who grew up on music from guitar hero, Deep Purple were an early favorite of mine whose records i sought out when i first started collecting. even if i like some songs from other eras more this is probably the most consistent lineup Deep Purple ever had, with everyone really holding their own. Ian Paice was one of my favorite drummers back then & i still love his filling, Ian Gillan can be corny as fuck but i still love him (and Jesus Christ Superstar), Blackmore rocks and is the only time i'll accept neoclassical guitar noodling, and Jon Lord's organ defines the sound of this record
the notable songs on here are more notable for a reason, and while the shuffle & soloing on Lazy are fun it feels like this just alternates between great rocker & middling letdown. this was not as enjoyable as i remember it being the last time i heard it but the highs are still high!
unsurprisingly miserable experience! i've always hated Clapton & never been a big blues fan, especially of something as reductive as this. the instrumental tracks are far more tolerable than anything with lyrics (Little Girl is a bit on the nose, no?) but there's less than nothing here outside of a couple harmonica licks to latch onto
does this list know that there are blues musicians other than white people
was not able to find an english translation for any songs besides the first one (after looking for 30 seconds) which dulled my experience a little bit. the vocals are emotive & the clear focal point here; the way seemingly control the music is neat. the orchestral accompaniment has some neat moments (the theremin bro?) but ultimately takes a backseat. there's a few pleasant songs throughout the very short runtime but regardless of the sophistication level of the frenchman involved this kind of thing goes in one ear & out the other. if it was Tom Waits this would be a different story
live show sounds like it would've been a blast though those french people were eating that shit up
first half of this carries... likely not a podium Dan album for me but it was the first of theirs i bought & has a couple favorite tracks. lacks the same refinement as the records that would follow it, but maintains its own identity in their discog with a heavier lean on bop phrasing. Rikki is an alltimer & Barrytown is one of my favorite underrated tracks of theirs
is horace silver gonna show up on this list too
plays its hand a bit early doesn’t it? excellent verses for most of the runtime but the repetitive instrumentals can become a little grating after a while. one of those albums that i can appreciate for its impact while not being fully in love with it & that’s ok!
the first album in their true form, showing some hints of the longform EPIC songwriting that would fully come to fruition on future albums. never found myself attached to this one outside of a couple moments, namely the main riff of Starship Trooper & the very end of Perpetual Change. several of the tracks are unnecessarily long & not in a noodly prog way; it feels like something is established & then stretched really thin when it could have been 3+ minutes shorter. The Clap is kinda cool & you go "wow that was a neat change of pace glad it didn't overstay its welcome!" and then the next track has another section just like it. best parts of this for me are easily Chris Squire's unmistakable bass tone that always stands out in the mix, & Bill Bruford doing some wacky broken figures in his grooves that open up the kit in a really cool way.
i'm a little tough on this album for only containing fragments of what make the next few of their records so good, better things to come!!!
apple music says the genre for this is "south africa"
unmistakable vocal prowess & a scaled back ensemble that gives her voice the spotlight it deserves. such a peaceful feeling to this record, though that can lead it to playing things a bit safe at times.
not sure that Harry Belfafonte's description of her music ("a startling blend of the highly sophisticated and the primitive" :| ) holds up but it isn't hard to see how captivating her identity as a performer must have been in that jazz landscape. the traditional/cover songs are nice but the real highlights are her original songs, which are a great vessel for her vocal ability. the bar is low but this is one of my favorites so far, wish there was more information about it online
wtf is this guy laughing about
broadcast the boom, broadcast the boom to you
i was out on this as soon as the midi horns came in. this is like wistful college party hot tub pop but even though she was 20 when she made it it sounds like a person in their mid-30s trying to write relatable songs for teenagers. probably her best album compared to what i remember about the others
i give this album 2 booms out of 5
the big frank! probably his least obnoxious album? even the other mostly instrumental ones have some hokey bullshit, this one sticks to the jazz-rock outside of a Beefheart verse. seeing dweezil zappa live was one of the more formative experiences i've had as far as getting into more experimental music & i got VERY into zappa stuff for a while after that. this album has always stood out to me as the most """"sophisticated"""" he ever got while still infusing his sense of comedy into the composition (like the never-ending ending of Gumbo Variations or the stupid blues mellotron thingy on Green Genes). there's glimpses of jams like this on some of his other records but nothing quite matches the spontaneous cohesion of the band on this
5 stars for the multiple violin solos & Beefheart screaming
one of my alltime favorite openings to an album too
update: listened to this 4 times over the weekend and fully cemented my rating; Willie the Pimp has one of my favorite gtr solos period & Peaches has that legit emotional range brother. also did you know that's not Zappa on the cover
*scrambling to say something intelligent*
uhhhhh this is the Dragon New Warm Mountain of White Albums
this record's biggest offense is that a lot of it sounds verrry similar. there's some definite standouts but across 1h15m it can be hard not to get lost in the sameness of it
feel like there’s a lot of jazz you can look at & go “this came out in x year? woah!!!” but this one & Monk in general stand out to me with how effortlessly he blends bop & trolling. swapping on a dime from the swing feel to the dirge-like sound of the melody on the title track is genuinely hilarious. where are the Thelonious Monk Funny Moments compilations. also can you imagine having Mr. PC & Max Roach on your album & they don’t even make the mentions on the cover?
this has me hopeful for more even slightly out there jazz on this list though i wouldn’t be surprised if they stopped with Out to Lunch
hilarious the way that streaming lists artists for jazz, i loved the guest verse from Sonny Rollins (crazier part is that he’s still alive!)
their namesake describes them perfectly
generally inoffensive but i'm giving it a 1 on premise. grateful it's only 30 minutes & that it's not the one with Shooting Star
enough of this please
pleasant rock songwriting in that this could have come out any year from like 1972 onward. never gonna argue with some fun power pop influenced stuff even if it isn’t doing much to stand out
my reviews will not be as detailed while i’m in school :(
i've always been more interested in Janis Joplin the persona than the musician & this just reinforced that belief for me. everything going on with the rest of the rhythm section is a lot more captivating than any of the lead guitar noodling or vocals for me, which is tough when so much of the music relies on the vocals being cool. her style gets a little grating after a while even if its technically impressive & she clearly has a unique way of using blues vocab. most of this plays like a live album (sounds like some it was recorded live?) which is fun & boosts the improvised parts a bit; the energy never really falters
side note that i have a pet peeve for album covers that have cartoon representations of every track it's kinda corny!!!
one of those albums that wears its influences on its sleeve while still breaking boundaries in the genre. amazing amazing guitar work, really love this one!!
real case for the worst one so far. i can’t recall a single redeemable moment from any of this
waiting for the day we land on phil spector christmas or all things must pass so i can give him his two deserved flowers. i dont even necessarily dislike his production style but it’s so thin on this record it gives me a headache. doesn’t help that there isn’t much substance in the majority of tracks; they’d be better suited for an obscure needle drop in a 70s set coming of age movie
New York City song is nice though! i wish there were a couple more tracks like it
um yeah it exists! don't feel strongly enough to slap it with a 1 but i would really like that hour back
#1 bruce dickinson hater reporting for duty, good god that man is so annoying. this does not have NEARLY the amount of sauce i remember, but i guess not hearing an album since high school can have that effect. title track is an undeniable banger but i may be swayed by the Vincent Price appearance setting the mood. really enjoy the bass work on this but that's not exclusive to this record, i feel like if a Maiden greatest hits comp popped up on here i would eat that shit up
Iron Maiden do have some tunes but they are sadly not to be found on here!
wow this RIPS
still not a fan of we got the beat but the energy throughout this whole thing utterly rules. will be coming back
sucks
cornball metal to the n-th degree
i’ll take this over like Metallica Cumshot Album but this is bargain bin big 4 core
this has more classics every time i come back to it. it’s a shame Skunk Baxter is the way that he is because my lord there are some Ripping Guitar Solos to be found on these tracks. blows my mind that this may not even crack my top 3 of theirs
ELO without the juice? (not saying much)
i'm generally not one for the prog pop style unless the songwriting is super compelling & i just don't find that to be the case here. the consistent 5:30+ minute song length doesn't do this any favors either. appropriately synthy & spacey but there isn't much that sticks out past a couple vocal moments. excited for Brunch in Tanzania or whatever its called
no idea what my past self was thinking when they heard this for the first time, undeniably effective vocals & a really great variety of stylings all executed flawlessly. was genuinely floored by this yes even hallelujah
what if we made a song about fucking your mom and then followed it up with a cover of comfortably numb
nothing like the britpop album opening with the wonderwall chords
makes sense that nigel godrich produced this considering it sounds like an extended version of the dreamier bends stuff. a couple nice songs! inoffensive
not sure how many boundaries this breaks but i had a good time with it. the on the dime genre switches are pretty compelling & the horn parts were fun!
the who have always seemed like a band you're supposed to like when you're a rock musician & especially when you're a drummer- nobody tell my dad but i'm just not that into it. i can appreciate their individual skill but outside of the bookends there isn't much on here for me. what happened to writing garage rock adjacent bangers Mr. The Who? i don't think it's a coincidence that the Hits album came sandwiched between rock operas right after they told everybody they sold out
i'm just going to enjoy that sick violin solo & be grateful it isn't Tommy instead
those keys have a nice touch.... pump it up is cool?
add this to the growing list of new wave albums i’ve come to have some new appreciation for because of this list. this one fits nicely into the man uncomfortably yell-sings over weird synth category, and even though it really loses its mojo after the first 2 tracks i’m a fan of the overall sound. Infected is the only record of theirs i’ve heard prior & i do quite like that one so hopefully it pops up too
just gorgeous!!! the story behind this is absolutely worth reading too. mind-boggling solo lines over ever-evolving progressions; it's amazing how engaging he manages to keep this over the span of an hour plus. one of those jazz records where i can't help but imagine the performer in front of me
kinda rips. idgaf about straight edge culture but the bass tone is pretty silly
some eternal bangers on here but the Tom Morello schtick gets old pretty quickly
lately my buddy has been giving me clues to guess the day's new album before i see it. the clue that gave this one away was that despite the acclaim it's not an important album in the slightest & i think that's all that needs to be said about it
fortunately there won’t be any other derivative pop rock albums by bands from Liverpool on this list!
i fully expect this list to completely ignore innovative black electronic artists in favor of whatever this is. vocal samples were lame & none of the songs justified their runtime
man idk i was not struck by any of this. a couple of the slower moments were nice but ???
only knew one track from this but i was pleasantly surprised by the variety, the dance influence is a lot more prevalent than i would have thought going in!
cool album thank you for not being butt rock
fun! La Grange pulls a LOT of the weight here though, it's beyond the obvious highlight & i don't think this would be nearly as enjoyable without that song holding things together. some sick solos & the vibes are good despite this being a boomer blues album
file it under “cool riffs but wish he would shut the fuck up”
also “start!” is just taxman
was not aware that they dropped an album last year. far from my favorite in the noisygaze adjacent sound but a welcome sight on this list
CSNY it is not but i really enjoyed this! not many records can say they have a jimi hendrix feature
i tried multiple times to wipe that dot on the bottom of the cover off my screen
wipes the floor with phil collins. first two tracks are all-timers! also love how berlin trilogy the last song is
slam dunk #1 TVU album for me, great pop songwriting & enough experimentation to meet quota with The Murder Mystery
peak
far from my favorite wilco but there are plenty of great ideas. not amazing for a 1h17m album when the first song clears everything else, but i can disable the part of my brain that is annoyed by corny indie rock tropes when wilco does it
definition of a modern classic. the library of congress decided rap was cool this one time
bold to cover timothee's songs like this
stick to the feedback solos fellas
like a nice flowery wallpaper in that it's pretty for a little while but then it starts cracking until all you have left is drywall
off the charts peaceful vibes. love the place a lot of these songs just sit in
alright pearl jam i kinda doubted your game. Alright pearl jam even flow rips. alright pearl jam i kinda doubted your game again this one is cool. alright pearl jam i don’t like this one as much. alright pearl jam i fell asleep for the rest of the album
"i've been art garfunkeled" -bob dylan -paul simon
absolute slog. tom waits without a fraction of the sauce
crying sound effect over one of the songs really sold it
like a really, REALLY watered down version of the songwriting on the TVU self-titled. very grateful this isn't longer than 30 minutes but Paris 1919 is wonderful
gets a 1 on principle. who cares
standouts are obvious but the supporting cast is perfectly satisfactory
greatest album ever made 3/5
fun!
alltime evil riff followed by some mid
well that sucked a lot harder than i remember, at least we're safe until a blur album inevitably appears
story is much cooler than the music
holy ass
very peaceful if a little repetitive
wears on a liiiiittle too long but there are certainly some riffs to be had. i'm reminded in the first 5 seconds of black hole sun why it's such a classic
the placement of hurt on this album is insane
i've come to terms with just how corny queen are but this album still has some cool moments, stone cold crazy especially. not looking forward to more on this list
undeniable
fun for 5 minutes
buh
ran out of gas after like 15 minutes
the songs with nico do absolutely nothing for me but heroin & the last two tracks are so peak. 5/5 importance 3/5 music
every album should just be a collection of little tunes & nothing understands that better than this
slide guitar to open the heavens
beeebeebeebeebeebeebeeeeeeee
friendly. feel like my mom is a fan
heard this one enough times to know my feelings. not doing it today!
fuzz bass to die for
so lush. this is a fav
heaviest album oat
pretty unfair tracklist. first two songs back to back & you forget let me roll it is even there by the time it comes on. paul was just doing whatever but doing it really well
zero reaction to this at all
perfect example of something that's not nearly as compelling musically as it is important
Standard jazz indeed
eminem brings this down even further
my favorite snoop dogg album
rip scott lafaro free jazz legend
some really cool tracks in the back half. forgot how much this rocked
im sooooo high
sleep
if they let me create a genre i would call it baggy
alltime great song followed by some brian eno trolling
what could be better
title track & vincent are really awesome but it does get a little samey in the back half
another typical boring british punk album
i thought this was really cool, one of my favorite new things from this list
yeah guys go ahead just keep inventing metal
when she says its me or the muddy
easily the worst of the first 4
Thank You is so abysmal
tough amount of 7+ minute songs
the title track rips but unfortunately there are 9 other songs after it
life-affirming pop music with one beyond obvious blemish
offensive
sick beats & straight corn
only half of this was on streaming? oh well it's fun
remember when george clinton was in good burger?
hated this less once i realized they were trolling
elite guitar solo on the live track
first song was kinda cool then it got completely insufferable
such a weird blend of influences i kept questioning who this was for. then the saloon organ solo came in & i realized the answer was no one. sunshine of your love interpolation im gonna kill myself
coldplay did this better
the hits are REALLY hits
doesn't sound enough like jethro tull
the second half of this STINKS!!!
impressively boring
amazing bits & pieces. i might be wrong / knives out / life in a glasshouse elevate a weaker supporting cast!
mind-numbingly dull
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
doodie ass
would not recommend
real slog after track 5ish
interesting proof of concept but pretty dull outside sharp dressed man and a couple others
this restored my faith in the harmonica
enjoyable but blends together after a bit
probably my favorite from these weirdos, every track is so compelling
first half is pretty solid but the idea of an acoustic second disc always tends to fall flat. cardinal sin of a double album is that it's just Too Darn Long
the lack of variety becomes apparent suuuper quickly. i'm sure this would be a great live show but it doesn't translate beyond a few more notable tracks
zzzzz
mmm harmonies
very fun even if it runs on slightly too long. they save the real banger for the end
fun psych britpop stuff
i'm not above this! blew my mind was i was 14, formative experience
amazing
