Album Summary
Happy Sad is the third album by American singer-songwriter Tim Buckley, released in April 1969. It was recorded at Elektra Sound Recorders in Los Angeles, California and was produced by former Lovin' Spoonful members Zal Yanovsky and, coincidentally, his subsequent replacement Jerry Yester. It marked the beginning of Buckley's experimental period, as it incorporated elements of jazz that he had never used before. Many of the songs here represent a departure from the binary form that dominated much of his previous work. The sound of the album is characterized by David Friedman's vibraphone, an instrument which gives the album a more relaxed tone than Buckley's earlier work. The songs are much longer than on previous releases and this style continued through to later works. The vocals on the album are more drawn out than earlier performances and this represents the beginning of Buckley using his voice like an instrument. The lyrics on Happy Sad represent a change as Buckley stopped working with Larry Beckett, his lyricist on the two previous albums Tim Buckley and Goodbye and Hello, and began writing the lyrics himself. Buckley's self-penned efforts stand in contrast to Beckett's occasionally political and literary-style work. Buckley would also go on to author all his own material on the following two albums.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Happy Sad This is the Tim Buckley album I remember really liking from the Anthology, not least for the excellent Buzzin’ Fly (never noticed the Stones Roses lift at the coda before), and it's by far his best album. He’s kind of like a lighter weight Californian John Martyn on here, the merging of west coast singer songwriter folk and jazz working really well (if not quite reaching his emotional depth and complexity) Strange Feelin’ is a lovely jazz-dreamy opener, I love its slow moving droning ambience, a real mood setter, before Buzzin’ Fly’s more conventional folk rock feel. Love From Room 109 at the Islander really shows its inspiration inJazz in the vibraphone and 10 minute run time incorporating different movements, even if soundwise its more psychedelic folk rock. Dream Letter is another meandering beauty, the baleful cello echoing the apologetic lyrics, the double bass also giving a blueness to its feel. Gypsy Woman gets perilously close to senseless blues jamming, but it just about keeps the right side of it, even if I’m not sure it needs to be 12 minutes. Sing a Song For You employs a more baritone quality to his voice in places, contrasting with his normal voice, the double bass again is great, and it recalls Astral Weeks somewhat. This is a cracking album, slow moving and melancholic, and comfortably the only time he really nails a tone and style that works. 5. 🪰🪰🪰🪰🪰 Playlist submission: Buzzin’ Fly
Better than other stuff of his I've heard. Still not really my thing, but it's not bad.
nulla di speciale, il figlio mi piace di più
Mostly famous to me for being the late Jeff Buckley's dad. Let's see what this holds (it's only 6 tracks! I'm excited it's not a double album!). Sorta mellow. There's a marimba or some kind of chime-y idiophone and that's an unusual choice but is pleasant (ed. note -- it's a vibraphone). It's got a bit of The Doors about it, a bit of melancholy Dylan, a bit of Laurel Canyon. On doing a little reading, apparently the album is a result of Tim Buckley changing from using a lyricist (Larry Beckett) to write the words to his songs and, simultaneously, treating his voice more like an instrument and less like a tool for communicating song lyrics via singing. In that way, it is sort of emblematic of the long shift in popular music that ran from Tin Pan Alley through to the experimental musical forms of the Sixties and Seventies. Buckley has a great voice and the instrumentation is interesting. I'd say 'Gypsy Woman' (his title, not mine) is the standout track, as he really stretches his singing chops and meanders away from a strict song structure. At the same time, it's a bit of a caricature of experimental Californian rock music -- it's got bongos and a guy wailing about a woman and it runs over twelve minutes long. What's in it for you, the listener? It's an example of what musical experimentation sounds like, as well as what happens when a more passive performer takes control over their musical direction. That's nice. It actually feels a little bit long, I'll admit: these experimental forms are lovely and have moments of interest and even excitement but you do have to sit through a lot of quiet, reflective parts to get there. Tim Buckley's internal reflection doesn't always make for an enjoyable experience for the external observer. Anway, it sure is one of the albums of all time. It's a turning point for Tim Buckley, who is famous. It's also a bit of Boomer nostalgia marking this as essential (I still think Tim Buckley's greatest musical contribution was his son, Jeff; no disrespect to his adopted son, Taylor). In fairness to him, he also died at 28, so his productive years were short and intense. In summary: it was the 81st biggest album of 1969. 3/5
Pappa Buckley. Psykedeelistä folkkia, jopa sillein aika stereotypisen psykedeelisen kuuloista. Maalailevaa ja hypnotisoivaa psykedeliaa. Parhaat: Dream Letter, Sing a Song for You
Sounds like Bob Dylan mixed with John Denver and a little Roy Orbison. Wholly unfamiliar to me.
This is the album of his I find most similar to his son’s work, which is not a bad thing. I enjoy the loose, jazz-inflected compositions, but not quite as much as the more tightly structured pieces on his earlier record.
This is the second of three Tim Buckley albums that we get. While listening to this, I wasn't happy and I wasn't sad. I was mostly slightly bored, wondering why the songs were so long and downbeat. I found Gypsy Woman to be outright annoying, but otherwise the music is downbeat and fine. I see Buckley as another artist who apparently had a huge fan club among the editors of the book, because this album was just "meh" for me. My favorite songs: Strange Feelin' Buzzin' Fly Sing a Song for You
I'm for familiar with Jeff, but enjoy the music of both. I hadn't listened to this album before, that I recall anyway. But, after Gypsy Woman, I finally hear a commonality in their vocals. This, I give a 4, thoroughly enjoyable but mostly sad.
I'm shocked that this guy has this much of a presence on this list. This whole album seems to lean more on the "Sad" side of the album title. Each track seems to linger on too long as well, with some basically delving into jam sessions. There's almost too much marimba presence here, if such a thing is even possible.
This was not what I expected. I expected folk in the style of Dylan, but this transcended that. Loved this, all the way through.
I really like Tim Buckley. He seems to have to gone into his son's shadow, but he left a fine body of work. This is a very good album.
This is certainly a weird album, but in a good way. It has a lot of jazz, some blues, and quite a lot of folk vibes going on. The vibraphone gives it a touch of joyful drama, which contrasts with a lot of the other elements. Tim Buckley's voice is also interesting, at times it feels like it could fit a country song, but at others it's like a premonition for britpop. I haven't heard of Tim Buckley before, and it turns out he's the father of Jeff Buckley. That means the song "Dream Letter" is about Jeff, which I'll use as a fun trivia from now on. I don't know if everyone needs to hear this album before they die, but I'm happy I heard it. We need quirky music.
was gonna give it a 3 but failed to notice when it ended bc i got so zoned out by it so. maybe a 2. easy listening but kinda boring if u ask me
Quite boring
Middling for me. Quite a pleasant listen but nothing stand out
mheehm,
Folks, ethereal; and eclectic mix of songs in this [tracklist-wise] shorter album.
Mellow, did not really stand out, was okay
Very pretty and calm. I enjoyed it.
I was initially more positive about this album compared to the last one, as we have an intriguing new fusion for the time of 'Jazz folk' and the presence of a vibraphone with a largely acoustic backing (occasional electric guitar licks). I didn't mind the first two tracks and the short last song had hallmarks of 'song to the siren', but the third and fifth really are annoyingly meandering and bereft of sufficient ideas to warrant their 10minute plus lengths. Despite having a unique voice, with touches of John Denver and Glen Campbell as well as histrionics more influencing Robert Plant, Buckley to me is overrated and I',m surprised he has two albums in this list.
Significantly better album than I was expecting, I really didn’t like the other one he had on this list. I enjoyed all of these tracks, even if they do run a little bit longer for my test. Four stars.
It was ok like I didn’t hate it but I don’t think I enjoyed it either
Alright folky jazzy tunes
Very good Tim Buckley album, I liked it a lot, lyrics are great here. 7.5/10 overall
The first to songs were really good, and then it turned into a slow boring and mediocre album. What a shame… Favourites: Strange Feelin’ and Buzzin’ Fly
This is great! The two 10+ minute songs on here are absolutely perfect, and I love his voice and guitar playing! I heard Jeff Buckleys album a little over a year ago, and I gotta say, this is better! It feels more timeless, y’know? But yeah, overall an incredible album! 4.5/5!
I fucking love Jeff Buckley. His deadbeat dad has a nice voice and some pretty boring music to go with it!
This guy again. This is a very specific 70s music that doesn’t do it for me. Had to intersperse my listen with songs I actually like
It was alright - nothing to come back to in the future though.
I like every consecutive Tim Buckley album more than the last. Happy Sad is pretty much gorgeous from beginning to end. From what I've heard, this seems to be his magnum opus, the moment where his Earthy folk music was able to meet his jazz influence and slight psychedelia in a way that makes this album feel like it just floats along. The songs are expansive, Buckley is expressive, and the lengthier movements never overstay their welcome. The cumulative effect is just spellbinding. It feels like in this moment, Tim Buckley transcends all of his components and influences and just makes an album outside of scene and time. To the extent that the best moments here remind me of some of my favorite Radiohead songs. And, in fact, I wouldn't be surprised if they were influenced by this, it just makes sense. Anyways, I don't want to call this a 5 yet, because this thing hasn't immediately transcended to the top of my pantheon, and I've spent so little time with it. But it's incredibly strong, and I will be revisiting it. Just an absolutely gorgeous album.
The first time in 139 albums that I’m positively impressed by an album I had not heard before. Really like this, a bit singer-songwriter, a bit jazz, a bit psychedelic and even a bit modern classical. Sad songs make me happy.
First time listening
Puzzling stuff: the vibraphone/marimba is pretty cool, so are the double bass, the vocals and, at times, the lead guitar; one or two songs are quite good (for instance, Buzzin' Fly); still the overall effect is mostly uninteresting and even boring.
Operatic Kermit trying to make as many different noises as possible
Tim’s got some big feelings, and he’s gonna express them through his songs, accompanied by the most prominent vibraphone I’ve ever heard. It’s seriously front and center in the mix on most songs, certainly a choice. This was just OK; he croons on a little too long on most tracks, but it’s nothing unpleasant. 3/5
Excellent standing bass action.
I’ve tried to get into Tim Buckley in the past, but both back then and now it easily just fades into background music. It really should be right up my alley, though.
I agree that 3 Tim Buckley records is too many, even though I like him, and we owe him (genetically at least) for Jeff. This is good, but I wish the author would break the trend of obsessing over lots of average artists.
This was bad.
It was ok but quiet and kinda nothing burger
This album gets the vibraphone buff
Happy? Sad? What’s the difference?? 3.
Another day, another album, and yet another meandering late 1960s record from a singer-songwriter I’ve barely heard of that is somehow regarded as another classic. Another waste of time.
So boring. Just....boring
Not for me
This dude kinda woke sings like a frog but it's a good singing frog
Starts off kinda honkey tonk with dramatic vocals. Hmm. Don’t know what Buzzin Fly is all about, although it’s maybe the best song on the record. Which ain’t sayin much. Then we get to a couple of real downers. Mopey and sobby. And so dramatic. Then back to some attempt at like blues sort of with experimentation and wait… did I hear some glockenspiel in there?! Not helpful. Then we end on a real high note that makes you want to off yourself. I do not like this record very much. About the best I can say for it is that the title makes sense.
Probably my least favourite of the 3 on here.
Not really my speed, and not the biggest fan of a 12 minute "gypsy" song. The a side was pretty solid though. 4/10
1.2/5 I thought he had a great voice but he barely used it to its full potential. Pretty boring and uninteresting but I could see his other albums being better if he uses his voice to the max
Tim Buckley is not really my cup of tea. Probably influential because his sound is very similar to later artists including some right up to modern day. So will give some credit for that
A bit Meh
The xylophone was a great addition
I don’t know if it’s my favorite album I’ve ever heard, but it put me in a peaceful place despite my ride home on the city bus with loud teens. That’s definitely worth something. Worth a second listen.
Kinda good, kinda blah
Standouts Strange Feelin'
Dross
for me personally inconsequential
One good track otherwise dookie.
Never had a feeling for him
This was more like I was expecting from Buckley and although it didn’t hit quite like _Greetings From LA, there was enough of his slightly left of centre folk here to enjoy and return to.
So, this is the third Tim Buckley album that I’ve listened to on this list, and this is the one that sits in the chronology between the one where he abandoned his pregnant wife and the one where he had just about wrecked his voice with booze and drugs. On the positive side, I really liked the laid back, jazzy feel to this (with a nod to Miles Davies who heavily inspired the first track “Strange Feelin’”). There is some nice use of vibraphone in the instrumentation here too. Lyrically speaking, Buckley started writing his own songs around this time and it really shows something of his state of mind. “Dream Letter” is probably the most egregious track, where he is feeling sorry for himself and wondering if the child that he abandoned ever asks about him. I mean, read the room here, Tim. For all of his maudlin self pity he didn’t bother to see his son for another five years. Think I’m all about Tim-Buckleyed out at this point.
Trevligt skval i bakgrunden
This album drifts along like it has nowhere in particular to be.
Had its moments but overall it was just so so boring. Let’s just say, the best thing about listening to this album was that it auto played a Jeff Buckley song when it finished…
Not the most exciting album in the world, but it would be a fine record to throw on during a lazy sunday morning. Also sounded amazing on my best pair of Sennheisers.
Moody soft ugh
Ok folk sound
I like it, very slow
Some of this is genuinely cool, which makes me mad because I don't like Tim Buckley. No idea why, cause I love Jeff. Some of this sounded like Led Zeppelin, some of this sounded lowk like Radiohead, a lot of it was kinda an attempt at a Van Morrison thing, kinda like Moondance (though thats next year I know). Most of it kinda was just a shamanistic 60's jam thing. Actually did enjoy this, but can't really bring myself to give it a 3
1969 strikes again. I was gonna give this a 2 for being okay but boring as fuck, however I really dug Gypsy Woman so this is a 3. Favorite Track: Gypsy Woman
Ok 2/5
The first song, Strange Feelin', is an All Blues rip off, right??? This album had an identity crisis to me. Is it folk? Is it jazz? Is it blues? It's a little of each, but overall I didn't find it appealing even though I like all three of those genres. I guess Happy Sad left me more sad than happy.
I don't like this
When he's not being self-indulgent it's not too bad
The two long songs weren't the best in my opinion, they really dragged on but I really liked everything else
Heard before?:❌️ Will listen again?:❌️
A pretty enjoyable collection of songs! Lots of interesting experimentation and instrumentation. Shame about the 5th song on the album.
it was ok, some interesting parts Standout songs: Buzzin Fly Gypsy Woman
Boring and not very happy.
I'm pretty sure "Gypsy Woman" is still going. I'm not sure the song even has an end.
Yawn
Buzzin' Fly is a track I always find myself coming back to and is easily the best song on the album, which I remember liking more a couple years ago. Maybe it was whatever I was on that day but upon giving it another listen, there's really not too much that really stands out. There are some interesting blends of jazz and folk but he never takes it beyond the ground floor. It was a great musical idea in 1969 but I wish he would've played around with the sound a little. The fact that there's still a third Tim Buckley album left for us feels like a little overkill. I know this original list was made decades ago but how much of an impact did Tim Buckley have on contemporary music, even back the list was first published? I'm not saying he wasn't talented, influential, or important to the overarching story, but c'mon...three albums worth?
there was a period of time where i wanted to really like tim buckley because there is some talent there. but then there's the lyrics. and i just don't like his vibe.
Sounds a bit like Neil Diamond but more jazz and psychedelics, hippy schlager. Rufus Wainwright must have worn this record through
Марко 3,5 Сара 3, "једва" каже
If you were hitchhiking to San Francisco in 1969, this would be your soundtrack.
440/1089 crazy that this is the voice of a ~22 year old, love the soulful folkyness, this first track is very much an example of a 60s song that appeals to me in the right way. like it’s weirdly of its time and timeless simultaneously listening to Dream Letter brought me about to tears, especially since i discovered Jeff and Grace through this project (and gave the album 5 stars), what a poignant song… Gypsy Woman i think is the song where i can most hear Jeff in Tim’s voice, there are some moments where he sounds SO similar faves: Dream Letter, Strange Feelin’ 75/100
Christ!
Whatever
Sad sad :(. This one unfortunately did nothing for me.
I’m glad I wasn’t driving during this super sleepy album. I guess I shouldn’t have been surprised given the title of the album.
If this were a review for the quality of his offspring, it would be 5*, but as it's for this record, then it's not.
the guy operates outside and above his surroundings
Sounds like a college hipster sitting in the quad with his guitar and just endlessly noodling and droning acoustic songs. I’d don’t get it.
Pleasant enough but didn’t rock my world. I suspect it may reward repeated listening
He has a nice voice and style but some of these songs can only be described as self-indulgent and over long.
Some good vocals, and not without its merits, but with songs that go on for 9 minutes after they clearly ended, and basically devolve into some form of random drum circle, makes listening to this more tedious than listening to Paul McCartney singing the nanana nas for 6 months whenever he plays hey Jude… glad I listened, won’t be listening to it again
Yeah…I didn’t love this. Gypsy Woman was a bop, albeit a long one. And there’s definitely some interesting stuff going on here, but it was a little too experimental for my taste. I hadn’t heard of Tim Buckley until I watched the Jeff Buckley doc. Interesting, sad life for this dude.