Desire, I Want To Turn Into You by Caroline Polachek

Desire, I Want To Turn Into You

Caroline Polachek

2.96
Rating
189
Votes
1
6%
2
29%
3
37%
4
20%
5
8%
Distribution

User Submitted Album

View Submitter's Profile

Album Summary

Desire, I Want to Turn Into You is the fourth studio album by American singer-songwriter and producer Caroline Polachek. It was released on February 14, 2023, by Polachek's imprint Perpetual Novice. Polachek produced most of the album alongside Danny L Harle. The album received widespread acclaim from critics, with several calling it Polachek's best work and acclaiming its experimentation. It charted in Belgium, New Zealand, Spain, Switzerland, the UK, and the US. It received a nomination for Best Engineered Album, Non-Classical at the 66th Grammy Awards. It was supported by the singles "Bunny Is a Rider", "Billions", "Sunset", "Welcome to My Island", "Blood and Butter" and "Smoke". A reissue of the album, subtitled Everasking Edition, was released on February 14, 2024, the standard edition's first anniversary. It was supported by the singles "Dang" and a new version of "Butterfly Net" featuring Weyes Blood.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Beyond the insane critical hype that followed the release of *Desire I Want To Turn Into You*, one has to admit that Caroline Polachek is a very intriguing figure. She has one foot planted in postmodernist irony, and yet she never *fully* embraces hyperpop aesthetics the way Charli XCX does. She has powerful pipes -- sometimes overindulging in those technical capacities -- and yet she's OK sprinkling a little autotune here and there. She's unafraid to experiment, as her participation in British post-rock act Caroline's latest LP also proves (maybe said post-rock act going by her first name as a moniker helped connect those very different artists with each other, who knows?). And even when she doesn't "experiment" per se, some chord changes and left-turns found in a bunch of her songs can be very bold and sophisticated. And yet, at the same time, she can also rely on tried and true nineties and noughts pop formulas that may sound a little tired to some ears -- because they're not revitalized enough by the hyperpop treatment, once again. Polachek almost comes off as an updated version of Kate Bush once in a while, but her far less reliable instincts still make her stumble sometimes. To put it in a nutshell, I don't think she's fully formed as a quote-unquote "essential" artist yet, raving reviews by mainstream music publications be damned. *Desire, I Want To Turn Into You* perfectly exemplifies all I have mentioned above. Its first half is strong in the multifaceted pop genre Polachek joyfully dabbles in. The second half is far more underwhelming, bar one stellar exception. Here's my little breakdown of the tracklist, song by song: As "cheesy" as some of its elements are, "Welcome To My Island" is a fun romp to start the whole thing, all things considered. The admittedly tongue-in-cheek "rapping" Polachek performs towards the end of that song is... an acquired state, let's say, ha ha. But as an opening statement, this composition still does its job right, I guess. Irony and earnestness are seemingly present in equal measure in the tune, and in that case at least, the ambiguity is interesting. Can't help imagining this as a very sarcastic soundtrack to a documentary about Jeffrey Epstein's "private island" these days, make of that bad taste take what you will... There are so many ways to "read" the song that everything is possible. "Pretty In Possible" is one example of Polachek and her producers using "da da da" ditties over nineties breakbeat in quite an endearing fashion -- think DNA's remix of Suzanne Vega's "Tom's Diner", upgraded with more 2020s-sounding production values. The soaring, sensual wail Polachek lets out at some point in the song is a thing of wonder! Wish there were more consistent vocal lines in the composition, but that's only a minor grudge. As for "Bunny Is A Rider", it is an absolute banger, thanks to its mock-Jamaican rhythmic drive and vocal accentuations, then giving way to a very sweet chorus sprinkled with even sweeter whistling. Clearly the stand-out track in the livelier cuts. This hit should be bigger than it currently is on streaming services. Earworm "Sunset" goes from Jamaica to Spanish parts of the American continent, thanks to its Latin and Afro-Cuban acoustic guitars. Very airy and naive-sounding, and yet warm enough for me to ultimately let down my guard. And the tender and excellent chorus in that song brings a needed extra dimension to what would have ended up being a secondary exercise-in-style without it. Concluding this pretty neat first half, "Crude Drawing Of An Angel" makes a complete 180-degree turn and goes full impressionistic on your ears. Tropical birds are heard in the background of this very sensual and poetic cut -- experimental in all the right senses of the word, because said experimentation is here emphasizing the expression of emotions instead of stifling them. The song is slow. It's hypnotic. It's also cinematic ("camera one... camera two..."). The best example of high art and pop impulses going hand in hand in the album. All of this up there is fine, but we're now reaching the limp and sagging "belly" of the tracklist, and this is where many problems start to abound. "I Believe" is memorable, but maybe not in the best sense of the word, for instance. Listeners' cheesometers may break down due to an excess of information here, between the blatantly lame dance music instrumentation (Ariel Rechtshaid produced this? Really???) and the quite annoyingly naive chorus, with no redeeming artful features this time around. Yeah, I caught that one callback to the whistled gimmick from "Bunny Is A Rider" towards the end. But it's not as if this endearing self-referential wink can make it up for the horrid blasts of fake synth horns ruining the whole track before. Final verdict on the song? Complacent and even grating. Contrary to "I Believe", "Fly To You" is instantly forgettable, and that's for the best given how terrible that track also is. The thing is supposedly a lively composition but it's actually a total borefest, both tonally, harmonically, and rhythmically (that cliched drum'n'bass pattern, made a hundred times better elsewhere!). Grimes and Dido's interventions in the song also feel very hackneyed and lazy (as can be logically expected from them) and the whole track is lame and very linear anyway, devoid of any interesting dynamics and arrangements as it is. Hard pass. Right after that debacle, "Blood And Butter" is not so terrible, yet it still feels like it should have been named "meat and potatoes" instead, in spite of a very cool bagpipes solo and a lush vocal adlib towards its conclusion. And if "Hopedrunk Everasking" is yet another 180-degree turn with great chord modulations that's way more interesting than what directly preceded it, its impressionistic contents don't exactly reach the high level of "Crude Drawing Of An Angel". A short pause on my song-by-song breakdown here, giving some context to what I'm about to say about the next track... I actually have a physical copy of *Desire I Want To Turn Into You* on my shelves, and the deciding factor that made me buy it is actually the track which is about to follow. I really enjoyed the first side of the LP, but I was still unsure I needed a physical copy of it. And what made me decide to get my hands on it is therefore that one cut in its second half, an island of bliss in a sea of "whatever"... And that cut is "Butterfly Net", folks! It's a timeless ballad graced by a marvellous chorus, a love song whose music and lyrics will have you believe you are floating in space in front of the Earth's blue marble, trying to catch the titular butterflies flying out from there with your cosmic net. The harmonic switches and chord changes just feel perfect on this track. And the Procul Harum-inspired organ solo before the last chorus is, simply put, a genius idea to propel the whole ballad into the stars. Awesome work here! After that last highlight, "Smoke" tries to return to the realm of energetic songs, but partly fails for lack of salient details production-wise, once again. Closer "Billions" fortunately fares a little better, especially during its climactic section going "I never felt so close to you". In spite of how wildly uneven its whole second side is, the album ends on a high note, at least. So that's it, that's the thoughts and impressions this hyped-to-death record elicits in me. Without "Butterfly Net", there was zero chance *Desire I Want To Turn Into You* would have reached my four-star gallery, so that was a very close call. Yet it did make it. Only time will tell if Caroline Polachek will double down on the hype for her next LP, not out yet, or if more people will start to see the little warts in her overall current artistry, just as I do. It all depends on how she navigates the waters leading to her next LP. My humble advice would be more "Bunny Is A Rider", more "Crude Drawing Of An Angel", more "Butterfly Net", and less "I Believe" or "Fly To You". Which means more genuinely thrilling bangers, more heartfelt, impressionistic experiments, and more timeless ballad songwriting. Polachek just needs to "desire" the right things to stand the test of time beyond ephemeral fads. And she's got it in herself to pull it off, so go girl! 3.5/5 for the purposes of this list dedicated to essential albums. 8.5/10 for more general purposes (5 for the musicianship and production values + 3.5 for the artistry) ---- Number of albums from the original list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 466 Albums from the original list I *might* select for mine later on: 293 Albums from the original list I won't select for mine: 343 ---- Number of albums from the users list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 126 Albums from the users list I *might* select for mine later on: 144 Albums from the users list I won't select for mine: 330 (including this one)

Unfortunately for me, yesterday's album was Charli xcx, and I'm not generally a big fan of this sort of style. That said, I liked this a bit more than that, so I suppose that's something LOL

Art pop, alternative pop, new-age. Ni fu ni fa.

Nice voice with the auto tune.

Wow. Vapid annoying soulless shit. Just wow.

Fantastic pop. It was a little too over produced and teen girl for my tastes, but I did enjoy it.

One of the better albums of the year when it came out.

Why did I need to listen to this?

I feel like this should have made me angrier than I was but like okay. I mean it was slightly annoying but I don’t have any specific complaint.

Well-produced pop that switches between being minimally catchy and sonically shallow - sometimes within the same line. The extensive vocal tuning is merely annoying until it finally becomes nearly infuriating - the album's biggest downfall. I probably should hate this more than I actually do, but having said that I certainly don't like half of this half as well as I should; and I like less than half of it half as well as it deserves. 5/10 2 stars IMO: Belonged in the book? No.

This was okay, but it felt really generic at a lot of points. Each individual song was fine, and some of them were good, but overall it felt like a bunch of other things I've heard before. I feel like part of the issue is the challenge of evaluating modern music, which is less genre and instrument bound, which means you can have any style of music on any album, but the artist is not necessarily innovating within one style of music, which I find very hard to compare with works from the past. She is versitile in her songwriting definitely, and she has a nice voice. 3/5 I think the album does get better as it goes, but the beginning is definitely feels like a lot of things I've heard before

2.7 First time hearing this/her. It's certainly a lot better than pop back in my day (90s). But still not great. The most serious crime is the saturation of autotune, just a terrible choice all round. If it was her real voice throughout it would be slightly pleasant, but there's no decent hooks or absolute bangers here to really propel it past mediocre

Okay pop music. Nothing really sets it apart from the rest of its genre. Was hoping for something a little more dynamic.

This is an album I really wish I liked more than I actually do, the highs are nothing short of spectacular but to my taste there is only three of them on the entire album (Welcome to My Island, Bunny is a Rider, and Billions) and the rest I find to be rather boring. The album opens in a perfect way with Welcome to My Island. It's playful yet mysterious, and it encourages you to engage with the album. I think this song takes the place of an overture from rock operas, it foreshadows many themes will be expressed throughout the album. She deliberately sets a tone of a tropical island to jam that thought into your head while listening to the album (see the sand on the cover), and she completely succeeded. While talking about this album I actually referred to it as an "island" at several points, that's how well she sets the stage. This is definitely the most fun song, it's borderline dance pop, but later songs will reveal an artsier side. So now we're on Polachek 's island, what does it contain? Well primarily this is a pop album with a lot of British 90s electronic influence (trip hop, downtempo, garage, baggy, just to name a few) which jumps around from song to song. The lush tropical theme from the opener stays through pretty much the whole album, it sticks to it very well. There's a few things I don't like. I feel the auto tune used throughout the album is tacky for the most part, and Sunset just feels like it was hopping on the Latin trend that was budding in 2023 (though it is one of her most popular songs so maybe that's a me problem). The dislikes heavily outweigh the likes so this album is just fortunate that the strengths pull it up. The real gem of the album is the closer, Billions, which is one of my favourite pop songs ever. This Bjork-esque downtempo song uses the most lush instrumentation on the album which climaxes into a children's choir. The end of the song is so transcendental. Should it be on the main list: Yeah probably, you could make a strong case for it. Polachek is regarded as one of the finest pop songwriters of the 21st century, a quality that Dimery holds in high regard according to his book. Top 3 songs: Welcome To My Island, Bunny is a Rider, Billions

Ear-pleasing, mostly, blend of pop and alternative rock. But the vocals on some songs were tweaked and autotuned.

I've listened to this before, when it came out. I like it, particularly the smallpipes on Blood and Butter

Pretty but lacking substance

Just absolutely nothing for me here. It's not unlistenable

I think it's a little too soon to be adding albums from 2023. Especially pop albums which are typically forgotten rather quickly by anyone who isn't specifically a fan of that particular artist. This is fine... In terms of pop, this is just fine. But there is literally nothing here that we have not heard 10000 times already. I feel bad that someone spent their pick on this.

Pop music for cool people? IDK, maybe I'm not hip enough.

Yeah it is pretty good idk why the ninth song has the smoke detector beep tho

Every generation gets the Annie Lennox it deserves.

Mostly tepid pop. Was going to let it get away with 3 stars until “Hopedrunk Evercasking” started playing smoke detector chirps into my ear

I think it's still very early to add this here, but it's a very good example of how good pop music can be in this decade.

I unabashedly love this stuff.

Sort of like Taylor Swift vomiting in the corner at a party.

A perfectly serviceable album. Just not my taste.

Interesting enough to be enjoyable.

Good time. I can’t think of anything clever to say I just like this album

9/10 not much of a pop fan, but I really liked this! better than her first album

Desire, I Want To Turn Into You is alright, more modern pop but a bit too whimsical for me. I liked songs like I Believe where there's a decent flavour of 90s trance-pop stylings but it's overall quite a hit and miss album, songs like Blood and Butter are just crap. I think it gets a low 3 because it's at least interesting to good, and her voice works for the most part.

One of the best albums of the decade so far. Catchy as hell pop with experimental instrumentation and vocal layering, and a step up from Polachek’s already solid debut Pang. Welcome to my Island is such an incredible opener, and we’ve also got the flamenco-guitar-led Sunset, the absolute bop I Believe, and the gorgeous Butterfly Net. A stunning record that really grew on me throughout 2023; a really forward thinking album that makes me excited for the future of pop music

It was fine

I'm glad Olaf from Frozen could make a cameo on this album in the literal first seconds of the first song..... Kids who haven't been alive long enough to know what music is shouldn't be allowed to recommend albums. Also, something that was nominated for Best Engineered Album at the 2023 Grammy's should be automatically deleted from any list of albums, unless it is a list of albums that mark mankind's downfall. At what point does music stop being music and start being the brain droppings of computer AI software? Caroline Polachek contributed literally nothing to this album except some lyrics which were then auto tuned to holy hell and laid over regurgitated computer pop noises. This is truly awful, and makes me sad for humanity. If you are someone who considers this music, I truly feel sorry for you. This is nothing but a computer science experiment. Government agencies should use this album as a form of torture. Favourite songs: Sunset Least favourite songs: Bunny is a Rider (who thinks a baby crying would make a satisfying back beat? 44 million people apparently.... I weap for humanity... ), Hopedrunk Everasking (please change the batteries in your smoke detector before recording any more tracks....) and the rest of this gross drivel.... 1/5

yeah not for me.

Love this album. Saw her live twice when she was touring this in 2023. Bangers from start to finish. My personal rating: 5/5 My rating relative to the list: 5/5 Should this have been included on the original list? Yes.

This literally sounds like a parody album making fun of bland pop music. I feel like you have to put in a conscious effort to surgically extract any shred of /anything/ from an album like this. They're printing this shit in an evil laboratory, man. Always the same boring production, vocal style, lyrical themes. Absolute zero sauce in a hundred mile radius.

More modern day emotionless autotuned garbage.

Inte särskilt imponerad. Hittar ingen låt som sätter sig.

Kind of emulating Imogen Heap, pretty nice

Well, this is a glitzy pop album that dips into various music styles that I really don't enjoy. What am I supposed to be listening out for?

Fun dance/electronica LP from an indie artist I've seen everywhere but have never suitably listened to. Really enjoyed wall-to-wall production and lush synths, which formed a great platform for Polachek's substantive vocals. The LP does seem to lose some of its initial energy in the back half, growing a bit tired as it inches toward the finish line, but is still a fun listen overall. Good add, Caroline Polachek seems to put out albums all the time and constantly be abuzz in the indie world so it was nice to get a good intro to her work.

Interesting album with some pretty diverse sounds. Definitely sounds like its from this century with some different styles from an artist I hadn’t heard of before. Enjoyable!

Like an American fun Imogen Heap sometimes? Poppy stuff

Sort of like an Imogen Heap album. Lots of fun boops and beeps, and a good voice from Caroline.

Art pop, alternative pop, new-age. Ni fu ni fa.

Rating: 9/10 Best songs: Welcome to my island, Bunny is a rider, Sunset

Very much within a particular strata of recent alternative pop. This was good but a little over-produced for me. Lyrically clever but I was ended up without much sense of anything being said.

Generic pop music with way too much use of auto-tune

I don't get this kind of music

Never really cared too much for this one

It's a level above a pop album- lots of interesting things going on. Not what I woulld choose to listen to on a cold evening but my kids like it.

How does this have a 2.92 average I don’t even want to read what y’all are saying about my girl Caroline

You guys gotta stop adding albums I'm excited to listen to for the first time, they always seem to disappoint.

I remember this album getting a lot of hype a couple of years ago, it never clicked with my at the time, listening back now I agree this is really good. One to be added to a list of great new music, but just not my personal taste for a frequent rotation.

Hopedrunk Everasking - did anyone else hear the smoke alarm that needs new batteries? Other than that I really enjoyed this album. Something different but familiar enough to feel comfortable.

Pop just doesn’t have the same stadium busting sounds as it used to. This is still pretty good but it’s softer in tone with modern production of flowing beats. Polachek has a good voice and listening to this album wasn’t hard at all. I could see how younger people would enjoy this if this is what pop is limited to. 6.0/10

This is pretty good. I like it best when she's not trying to get too cutesy. 3 stars.

“Desire, I Want To Turn Into You” is my favorite album of 2023. It is a collection of near perfect pop songs. Though pop music is not realy my genre and is often too shallow and commercial, this album has enough depth in lyrics, composition, performance and production to make me love it.

I love the idea of this album 4