In A Silent Way by Miles Davis

In A Silent Way

Miles Davis

3.62
Rating
30565
Votes
1
3%
2
12%
3
29%
4
32%
5
24%
Distribution

Album Summary

In a Silent Way is a studio album by American jazz trumpeter, composer, and bandleader Miles Davis, released on July 30, 1969, on Columbia Records. Produced by Teo Macero, the album was recorded in one session date on February 18, 1969, at CBS 30th Street Studio in New York City. Macero edited and arranged Davis's recordings from the session to produce the album. Marking the beginning of his "electric" period, In a Silent Way has been regarded by music writers as Davis's first fusion recording, following a stylistic shift toward the genre in his previous records and live performances. Upon its release, the album was met by controversy among music critics, particularly those of jazz and rock music, who were divided in their reaction to its experimental musical structure and Davis's electric approach. Since its initial reception, it has been regarded by fans and critics as one of Davis's greatest and most influential works. In 2001, Columbia Legacy and Sony Music released the three-disc box set The Complete In a Silent Way Sessions, which includes additional tracks.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

My usual routine with these albums is to start listening with my morning coffee as I potter round the house and continue as I go out for a walk before work. Sometimes I’ll listen again as I’m jotting down my thoughts. Once in a (kind of) blue moon an album will go on repeat for the whole day. This is one of those. This album marks the transition from modal jazz to the fusion sound that was to be fully realised in Bitches Brew a year later. The electric piano sounds of Chick Corea and Herbie Hancock dance around the funky electric guitar of John McLaughlin in as radical a departure from trad jazz as Dylan going electric a few years earlier. The two sides of the album comprise two works, each made up of an introduction, a development of the theme and a reprise that returns to the start. I genuinely listened all day, finding new things each time and never tiring of them, sometimes zoning out and sometimes focusing on one instrument for a while. A genuinely seminal album.

Rate: 7.5/10

Feel like a lot of people we're influenced by this one because I kept hearing familiar riffs. I liked it but not as much as Kind of Blue. Cool either way.

Phenomenal staging, Miles Davis doing his thing, this slaps

This was lovely and really set my day off right.

Miles Davis — In a Silent Way (1969) Shhh/Peaceful Goodness, this is from 1969? And wow, is this a transition piece! The bass is steady, holding everything together. The percussion is driving. It's soft, but it's urgent. The piano has nothing to do with anything. It's in a whole different era. It lilts and goes forward and back. The organ is trying to bring these two planes together, in a bit of a middle earth, and it's working sometimes, and sometimes it doesn't. The discordance is just there. And then, bam, Miles Davis comes in with his trumpet, and forget it. He's urgent. He's warning of something. He's seeing these levels that do not work together. And the name of the piece? Wow - there's no PEACE here. There's no resolution here. The world is changing. Music is absolutely not the same. There's the past and the future, all at once. Wow. There's a lot there. In a Silent Way/It's About That Time This one starts out pretty much on the moon. You hear that space and that silence, and then the trumpet seems to come from over the horizon. It reminds me of Strauss's Also sprach Zarathustra in 2001: A Space Odyssey. That sense of something emerging over the horizon. Then there's a break, and suddenly it seems like you're back on Earth. You have that driving percussion again, the bass driving you on, like a train carrying you back to Earth. So you're not silent anymore. In a Silent Way. It's silent in space, but down on Earth, it's busy again. Pushing forward. You hear that chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga of the percussion, like a train driving you forward. Everything's working together. It feels like a busy city. And it seems, again, that we're taking different views. We've looked out to the moon. We've looked out into the quiet beyond. But then you come back into yourself, and you look around, and honestly, not a whole lot has changed. It's still the same. But this piece has such a positive feeling. You're back on Earth, and it's driving, but it's also hopeful, joyful. All of the instruments are really working together. And yeah, there's some hope here, huh? Then the track closes back on that gaze into space again, making you wonder: where is reality? Somewhere between that gaze and the busyness of Earth? And the hope is that things are wide open.

3.5/5 stars. (70/100)

I expected nothing less

Good to listen to in the background. 2 long pieces which I would have preferred to be broken up further

Nojoo jazziahan tämä, edelleen oikeassa kontsekstissa, miljöössä ja fiiliksessä oikein toimivaa

Opin ehkä vähän enemmän arvostamaan

Great. Really Great. Nice. Wonderful. Wunderbar. Crazy. Schmokin' Superb. So: 4/5

This was actually the first album I got on my solo project. It really deserves its position in the canon of music history. Lovely, interesting, and never overstays its welcome.

Absolutely love this album. Herbie Hancock really kills it and Miles Davis proves the jazz oldheads and rock stalwarts wrong by being fucking fearless. Love this. Great precursor to Bitches Brew.

I can't imagine why anyone took offense to this album upon release. But different times I guess. It's only 2 songs but really its more like 6. Its good. Listenable and mostly smooth. Most of the jazz I like is big bang (think Count Basie) or very noisy horns. This fills the inbetween void for me. I'd listen again

I've enjoyed more modern jazz and jazz elements present in progressive rock and other genres. In spite of it's importance, this is like a pizza without any toppings. It may be great pizza crust, but it's not pizza. In a vacuum it's inoffensive, but just kind of there. I enjoy pockets of it, but I don't think I'd actively listen to it again.

"Shhh""/""Peaceful ""Shhh"" ""Peaceful"" ""Shhh"" " 4 In a Silent Way / It's About That Time :In a Silent Way : It's About That Time: In a Silent Way 3.5 Score: 3.75

9.0 Amazing late jazz album in three layers. Drums. Organ. Brass. Incredible work from Evans, Handcock and McLaughlin

Jazz. Disc de 38mins amb només dues cançons. No es un format que m'encanti. No hi ha veu. Chill per estudiar

More rocky of a Davis album

While Simple Minds needed to be played at a certain volume yesterday, Miles Davis is best enjoyed "In A Silent Way". Until now, I thought “Kind of Blue” was already his ultimate benchmark, but in fact, this album strikes me as even better, more important, and more relevant. Looking back, he once again assembled the who’s who of jazz for this album, but of course one has to take into account that some of the musicians only achieved worldwide fame through this very album. Typical of Miles Davis, the two tracks are only subtly virtuosic, yet they pay no heed to genre boundaries. It’s easy to imagine that the press didn’t like the music because it didn’t fit into any familiar category. In any case, it’s a fantastically beautiful, very early fusion work - and perhaps the best album on the list so far that I hadn’t heard a single track from before.

non fa per me il jazz purtroppo cioè la ascolterei volentieri in un bar tipo però da solo non riesco ad ascoltare musica d’ambiente perché mi sembra di impazzire

No, I don’t like this 😐 Two stars…

Not my thing

I like Jazz, but this sounds like they got in the studio the morning after a massive session and realised the deadline to record was today. So they hit record and fucked around for a bit.

Not by any means a jazz man (!) but this was really good, lovely stuff.

Was chill, found myself vibing away and not paying too much attention.

몰입하기 어려웠다. 어떤 감정을 느껴야 할지를 모르겠다.

Oh look another Five Star Miles David album bloody HELL this was such a bit of me, I’m really into Miles at the moment so hopefully I’ll lighten up on more of the experimental stuff he did that I know I’m missing out on. In the meantime, I’ll be jamming this.

First track irritated me at first but I soon found myself tuning in to the way of thinking and letting my worries and stressful life drift away. Easy listening that I could easily put on again to ease off the tension of life. The second track a lot smoother and a better listen. I’ve said before Jazz is not my thing but this was decent enough to pass the time this Friday morning. 6/10

Miles Davis - In a Silent Way Jazz! Really nice 😎 listening. Second track was better than the first - last three minutes or so are almost transcendental. Dunno when I would listen again though. But looking forward to some more Miles on this journey Best Track - In a Silent Way Worst Track - Shhh/Peaceful 7/10

Something on this album connected with me in a way no other jazz album did before. I am not versed in jazz at all so i won't even try to describe the music itself. The album simply sounds like floating on a beautiful river in spring and allowed me to get fully lost in it. So yeah, i really love it.

Heard of artist: Yes Heard before: Don't think so, not this album Yeah banger jams, love how different the experience is for each ear :D

Beautiful, entertaining, smooth, intriguing. You can tune in to it or tune it out.

Super chill, easy listening

very beautiful

decent album, sounds a bit like elevator music. 3

miles davies is fantastic. this album however doesnt move the needle too much. it is very nice music but not as intersting and groundbreaking as his others

Amazing fun jazz

I like the blue album better, but this is good stuff too

Enjoyable and listenable proto-ambient 1969 Milestone album in which jazz stops swinging and goes electric, both in terms of the instrumentation (guitars and keyboards), and in terms of the assembly, with Miles cutting up the session tapes and copy/pasting it into some structure. There are moments when you can hear the abrupt change between cuts - like a structural joist suddenly poking through the smooth texture of a modernist building. From moment to moment, there's lots to enjoy - John McLaughlin, Chick Corea, Zawinul, Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter converse pithily over light funk-inflected grooves - but the general stasis, harmonically and texturally, is on such a longform scale that it's easy to lose focus. To my 21st century ears it feels like an electronic dance tune - I was reminded of the early 00s chillout scene of Zero Seven and Nightmares on Wax etc - but to 60s ears it must've felt very radical, and for jazz purists must've seemed like the end was nigh. Which, in a way, it was.

Not sure what I think. On first listen this felt a bit like nice cocktail bar music but I couldn’t get into it, not enough structure or melody or rhythm. But on a second listen later in the day I was much more into it. It’s interesting, and some superb musicians. 6/10

I don't know enough about jazz to really be able to evaluate this -- or any other jazz tbh -- but I enjoyed this fine!

Great miles album if you like good, slow jazz. Give me Fusion Miles Davis (Bitches Brew or Jack Johnson albums) over this though.

The album had some nice music, but was overall unremarkable. I like Miles Davis, but I definitely do not need to hear this before I die.

Mostly some smooth jazz with a splash of experimental sounds here and there. All in all if you like jazz you'd probably like this.

This was calming and relaxing, but grew rather tiresome after about ten minutes. There are two songs and each are longer than eighteen minutes, but neither have much variety and mostly feature the same refrains throughout.

Good music for cooking Lots of fun textural stuff going on, "whitest" Miles album ive heard so far Not a bad thing

Classic Miles! Can’t really go wrong with it!

Yep that sure is some jazz alright

I don't like jazz. I've tried before this list and I've listened to a lot as part of the list. I still don't like jazz. This has some interesting moments and is better than most I've listened to. But I still don't like jazz

I was surprised at how much I liked this. Loved the blend of electric guitar with Jazz. Having limited familiarity with Miles Davis I came into this expecting something much different.

I have never listened to Miles Davis. I know he is a jazz pioneer but I never listened to jazz either, not purposefully. Two long tracks, interesting... - "Shhh / Peaceful": The beginning is give me Curtis Mayfield vibes. That singing trumpet is sure giving me calm. Really good instrumentation. However, after a while it faded to the background. Need more trumpet - - "In a Silent Way": Trumpet is amazing but this one faded to the background as well. I did like the upbeat, more rock-styled parts though - I think I understand why I don't enjoy jazz. It seems like a genre that would mostly be enjoyed by musicians, and I am not one. Maybe I'm just too simple-minded to connect to this type of music. I usually rate albums based on my enjoyment of each individual song and since I didn't really enjoy these two tracks it would normally get a 1. However, out of respect to that beautiful trumpet, Miles Davis, and the other musicians, I will give this a 3. I know, I'm not cool, but Miles Davis sure is.

Masterpiece!

Chill and interesting … good to zone out to 3

As background music for working, this is phenomenal. Could I tell you anything about what I've been listening to though? No, except for that I liked it!

Good album

Lovely. I enjoyed this.

Fav: Shh/Whisper L: In A Quiet Way 3.5 Was expecting more trumpet, but I’m fine with it. I almost feels like an album like this shouldn’t be on the list, not because of its quality or influence but because it’s right on the edge of a bunch of stuff that the list doesn’t include for reasons I don’t understand. Cover: 2.5 not very creative Name: 3 would be a lot cooler if it wasn’t one of the songs Minecraft Parody: Tsss/Creeper; In an Ender’s Way

por acaso eu tava escutando esse de sábado pra domingo enquanto passava 9h dentro do ônibus voltando pra casa, e pqp eu vou cravar aqui que o post-rock foi criado em 1959 com in a silent way, pq é uma composição e execução COMPLETAMENTE A FRENTE DO TEMPO puta que pariu caralho pedrada absoluta pega o homem pega a banda pega tudo caralho vamo porra

o primeiro da fase elétrica dele, hein. jazz fusion de altíssima qualidade, ce ta doido tem umas guitarrinha brutal demais. toda a construção das músicas é muito bonita. bacana ver ele dando um alô pra galera do ROCK sem perder o jazz. bão demais!!!!

Modern jazz, sounds like everyone's playing a different tune

I am very much a jazz newbie, but this is a smooth album and a pleasant listen. Good emotion in the playing, and sonically interesting. Sort of pulling bits of psychedelic rock into the jazz world, which I respect. Once I have committed to learning more about jazz I may well have more to say. But for now I think this is a very solid piece of art

Another old favorite

Miles Davis is always great. Really enjoyed this one.

surprised at how i enjoyed this more than i expected. engaging music. i don’t know if id listen again. depends on the setting

Another background listen. This was very pleasant to work to!

Background chores, thanks Miles

Most compositions by Miles are worth listening to - this one included. The question this album faces is whether it is worth re-listening to.

Probably extremely important historically, but this far removed and out of that loop, it's mostly just a very pleasant record with some amazing playing.

In terms of its musical personnel this is a 5 star album - Wayne, Herbie, Joe Z, chick corea, John Mc, Tony w. It’s the first album of Miles’s electric era and its two single compositions with 3 part sonata form equivalent structures was difficult for the reviewers initially but naturally gained plaudits with the passing years and is now seen as almost the first fusion album. I find a lot more accessible than Bitches brew probably due to the more obvious sense of recapitulation and the the calmer consistency to the ‘vibe’.

Impressive sure, but nah

Some parts kind of pretty -Mack Not the kind of jazz I like, but not bad either -kaden

Chill but i prefer song structure

Miles at his best

Second song came on, and I legit thought it was some contemporary post-rock. Will listen to this one again and again.

One of the cool parts of sifting through the shit of this list is that when you reach a gem, it is very easy to tell. It is very easy tell a work that stands out from the rest. This is one of those works. It is undeniable from top to bottom and you don't even realize it's just 2 songs. Highlight: Shhh/Peaceful

A very pleasant listen. I liked it a lot.

I don’t love jazz (don’t even really like much of it) but I sure do dig Miles Davis. So smooth and rich. And… too beat a dead horse… just cool. The coolest.

Great working music.

Great album by Miles Davis. Not the best of his but still enjoyable.

Great jazz album

This was actually better than I expected. And, actually enjoyable. Probably wouldn't return to it again if I'm being honest but gonna give it a 4 because out of the respect to Miles Davis. I think he's a way more interesting person than his music is.

- 4 minutes in, liking it so far. Nice consistent bass with trumpet + piano flourishes. Kinda dark, in the sense that I feel like I'm at a jazz club at night. - end of song 1, I'm still in it. This was good to listen to while studying (creating the ASTRO 465 CMD lab) - 4 minutes into 'In a Silent Way', a whole different song just started. - Very chill. good ambient music

nice and moody!

Surprisingly big fan of this, more than other jazz I've heard. I really appreciate how these have a steady, unchanging pattern underlying the improvisation parts above it, which gives a sense of context for it. It's no longer just "here's the notes", but I can think of "here's some notes that are related to, but different from, the last time you heard this measure". It's able to set up expectations in a way that straight improv can't. Enjoyed this a lot!

I take back what I said about miles Davis he is cool

Good jazz music 7/10

One of the most obvious 5 star albums. Revolutionised jazz and still holds up to this day

A little bit keyboard heavy for me. Definitely evokes some type of quiet scary suspenseful feelings. Not sure all the way what to make of this considering I don’t have a refined palate for this type of music so I’ll give it a 3

It’s okay, but I don’t know if I appreciate jazz the way I should. Just not really my taste. Sorry Miles Davis I know you are very influential and talented.

I'm sure this would be good at the right time and right environment, but I listened to it at work, so was a bit lost on me. 2.75

Interesting and pleasant

Jazz gives me anxiety. But sure it’s miles I get it