Reviews (page 2 of 15)
This was fine but not as interesting or engaging as I expected It could be.
A classic - a stone cold classic. Two minutes with this album is like going on a journey (good). Favourite track: Shhh/Peaceful
Amazing, amazing wow wow
This is music for the thinking man. I’ll be honest I started losing hope for this when listening to the first track and started losing interest around maybe 5 minutes, but then I started paying attention again and I didn’t even notice the gradual increase in the amount the musicians were playing, but it drew me back in. Everything about this is so atmospheric and interesting and it really plays with the emotions. The thing that really draws me in is how difficult it is to create a piece of music like this and have it not be boring, had almost anybody else try to create something like this I would have thought “this fucking sucks”. But I really felt this. The whole album feels like it’s building tension which only gets released at the very end but in a way that doesn’t feel good. It’s almost like a reflection of the life of somebody that never finds their purpose. It maintains this tension that feels stressful and uncomfortable and then tapers off at the end before quickly fading into nothing. The drums also seem reminiscent of a ticking clock, counting down the years until death. It’s not sad and it’s not happy but it feels kind of mysterious and almost sorrowful. It makes you reflect on your own life. And maybe the music has nothing to do with all that, but that’s how it feels to me. In terms of the actual music though, it sounds absolutely phenomenal. Everything feels massive like you’re actually in the room with them and the droning organ adds so much atmosphere. The melodies feel like their both fighting for the spotlight at times which adds another element into the mix, you start wondering if one of them will actually take the lead. The music definitely starts to fully develop into the second half where you start to notice a lot more going on. The first half feels purely suspenseful which is then releases into the second half which then continues the build suspense up to the end. I absolutely love this album which I never would have thought if I hadn’t listened to the full thing. Hearing it from start to finish is the only way to have an opinion on it in full, because you seem to get a new idea every 5 minutes and then they all come together at the end where you come to your final decision. I will definitely come back to this at some point and I think it would be even better on vinyl if I owned it which I will now be considering. I’m not rating this 5 stars because I think the music is absolutely spectacular, I’m voting it because I think everybody should hear this just to see if they get it. This will be absolutely immense for some and not so good for others but I think it’s important that people hear this before they die.
3 eme album après ‘Kind of Blue’ (5/5) et ‘Bitches Brew’ (4/5). Cet album est très relaxant, avec de belles improvisations. Il n’est certes pas au même niveau que ‘kind of blue’, mais il reste très agréable à écouter. Il va rejoindre ma collection. =>4/5
Vou fazer uma comparação besta. Ouvir In A Silent Way é como comer uma boa salada, muito bem temperada. É uma refeição leve, porém saborosa e muito satisfatória. Nada nela ataca seu paladar, cada um dos seus elementos está bem colocado e possui seu perfil próprio. Ela nutre e preenche sem exagero. Simples, mas magistralmente executada. Uma aposta fácil e segura quando se quer comer bem. 5/5
yeh, it was alright, maybe I just don't get it?
3.9
Enjoyable
genius and gorgeous. a painting of an album
I liked it. I'm not much of a jazz fan, but this felt good and accessible. That's a good thing in my opinion. I've seen some jazz live on stage and it made my head hurt. This didn't.
pulling this as my first experience w/ miles davis (and basically first jazz album in general), this wasn't exactly what i had in mind, but that's far from a negative in this case. this ended up being a much easier listen than i expected from the genre the way the album revolves around constant chords/scales, particularly neutral-sounding ones at that (particularly the first half), along with the very chill drums and soft keys form this dream-like haze that only miles' trumpet work manages to cut through i'd probably need to read a book or ten on jazz harmony/vocabulary or whatever to really understand what's happening here, but all i really know or care about for now is that all the sounds are really nice on the ear holes favourite songs: lol least favourite song: lol
That was incredibly relaxing.
Good? I enjoyed it, but I'm sure I didn't adequately appreciate it.
More like in a loud way haha lol just kidding. This is my first ever time listening to Miles Davis and it is a little underwhelming. I didn’t hate this, it’s just alright.
Poetry in musical form. The soft swells and rhythmic patterns feel improvised without losing purpose. Each section is given space to breathe. What’s that saying about jazz, “it’s about the notes you don’t play”? This beautifully shows that in full. How can an instrument as abrasive as a trumpet, come off sounds so melodic and chill? Certainly it takes a mixture of skill and genius.
Ever since we got John Zorn’s Spy vs. Spy, I’ve been listening to jazz nonstop. From Stan Getz to Anthony Braxton, I’ve become obsessed with the genre. Ironically, one of its most significant figures—Miles Davis—remains an enigma to me. I’ll readily acknowledge that he produced several masterpieces, particularly during the celebrated run with his Second Great Quintet from Miles Smiles through Nefertiti. Even so, I still struggle to grasp the through-line of his work and what he was ultimately after, especially in his jazz fusion period. In a Silent Way is, without question, a phenomenal record—one I could listen to on repeat. I love the keys, the atmosphere, and the moments when Miles steps forward and truly shines. Yet part of me is still left wanting something more, or at least with the persistent sense that I don’t fully understand it.
A wall of electric pianos (three?! what in the world!), guitar like warm lapping waves, and...very, very little Miles Davis, lol. And it's amazing. I would love to know exactly how much trumpet is on the album...has to be less than 15% of the runtime. I'd also love to know what exactly "Davis as bandleader" meant...there aren't really solos, so what IS HE DOING DURING HIS SILENCE? His spirit is everywhere, that much is sure. So inscrutable and mystical and wonderful. Those ambient, almost-drone sections at the start and close of the title track...holy cow! I could listen forever.
Sorry to all the jazz heads, I recognise that these are fantastic musicians at the top of their game. I really tried to give it a fair go but despite a maturing ear it's not for me,
The Miles Davis run from In a Silent Way through to On the Corner are all fantastic albums. I might prefer this to Bitches Brew as well. I saw one review saying that they thought they could play the trumpet parts on this album. Perhaps, but the point is they wouldn’t play them.
Album is decent and is an easy listen but as I have said previously jazz is not my vibe by any means. I will give Miles his props as he was a great musician. For me it was just a 6/10 and got 3 stars.
One of my favorite Miles albums. Calming and interesting, reflective and inspiring.
‘Bliss’ is the word you were looking for.
Très intéressant comme musique d'accompagnement, à garder en mémoire pour les sessions de travail ou de JV.
Simply beautiful, start to finish. In A Silent Way will be getting a permanent spot in my playlist. You can find something new with each listen.
Je n’aime pas les prétentions electro jazz que veut introduire cet album. Mais cela a été une introduction au jazz de manière générale que j’ai beaucoup apprécié.
I appreciate the fact that Miles Davis was constantly trying to reinvent his music, creating sounds that were truly unique and ultimately influencing music across numerous genres that followed. Part of what gave him such freedom was that Davis and his band were such outstanding musicians. “In a Silent Way” is considered by many to be the first fusion album bridging rock and jazz. It is also the first album in Davis’s Electric Period, which is my personal favorite—jazz purists be damned. This is a brilliant album, especially late at night with the family in bed, and a glass of whiskey in my hand. This is how I choose to listen to Miles Davis and he rarely disappoints.
This was a really cool album! Hearing him go electric was pretty cool and it was just a vibe!
It’s fine.
What a cool album. And it was a perfect night for it. It was a little rainy and dark. My suburban setting maybe wasn't perfect but a downstairs bar in a city with neon lights and the rain beating down on the half windows up toward the ceiling. I could see these guys just going to town on their instruments in a smokey corner. Thats the vibe I got. And they all are great at smacking the shit outta their instruments. Eveyone is in synch and havr standout moments. You would think the trumpet would be the star of the show with the name on the cover but he dips in and out here and there. He does get some spotlight but no more than anyone else. The organ and keys, bass, drums all work together so well. As much as I liked it im not too sure if I can give it full points and thats nothing to do with the music recorded. Its a me thing. Like I know very little about jazz. This site has pushed a decent bit of it at me so far but im still such a novice. I dont know what the best jazz is at all. I dont even know what elements it has. All I know is I hear music that feels improvised and it works. Thats all I need. The differnt players killing it in their own way is a touch. I did reallt like this though. Alot even. Im just too inexperienced to say its the best ever 5 stars epic. Its great all the same
This album is really good and different from something like Bitches Brew or Kind Of Blue. It shows how versatile Miles Davis can be, and how creative he is. The instrumentation is peak, naturally. He truly is the goat, and having a 2 song album that's nearly 40 minutes is insane work. Incredible album
Two fantastic songs. Really enjoyed the musicality of it - and now I am gonna go down a Miles Davis-shaped rabbit hole. God I love this project.
I get lost in it.
Enjoyment: 5/10 Replayability: 5/10 Cohesion: 6/10 Flow/Pacing: 5/10 Artistic Merit: 4/10 Weighted Average: 5/10 Review: Two songs is a bold choice for a 38 minute album, but jazz-rock noodling would be the time to do it. I was hoping for something faster paced to give me an anthem to work to, but instead Miles and his crew provide a leisurely yet rhythmic beat to relax to. I wouldn't add either song to a playlist, but I would definitely listen to this album again. Liked Song(s): (None) Disliked Song(s): (None) Recommend? Maybe Heard Before? No
Whoa this is awesome! Only 2 instrumental tracks, both masterpieces.
there are moments in the title track that were quite emotionally effecting. and other portions that slipped by. enjoyed it! will relisten
This is an interesting one...it's already in my rotation for when I'm cooking dinner or at work, but I don't love it as much as I thought? The first half is great but the second half...drags. Still, I like the dreamy vibe of this, and there's something beguiling that brings me back again and again.
I'm not jazz to it
Excellent
i hate jazz
Beautiful album, especially the second more calmer half was very very very good and moving!
perfect
Enjoyable jazz. Maybe little more low key than some of the other jazz entries on the list, but quite enjoyable.
This album is a great one if you love smith jazz with so up beat in it.
5/10 A step up from elevator music (derogatory) but not interesting enough to get me to engage or listen to the music with any emotion resembling pleasure.
Ist nicht meins, obwohl ich Miles sehr mag. Aber das ist mir zu "Free"
Yyy... qué decir... Medio aburrido la verdad. No me gustó. Por lo menos es tranquilo.
Really enjoyed this. Shocked at how different it was. Starts to be an electronic ambient album in parts. Which given its age is incredible.
The second track is Post-rock about 30 years before post-rock existed. Phenomenal.
Me gusto un poco, no suelo escuchar este tipo de música. Me imagino en una cafetería con este álbum de fondo.
Amazing!
One of my favourite jazz albums. It manages to be smooth and relaxed yet moves with urgency and pace. Works first thing in the morning or late at night.
Jazz not my thing but this is now the second Miles Davis album I've listened to and this one also has parts I actually quite enjoy, especially in the second half.
The worst kind of Jazz.
Musical onanism.
Long jazz pieces are kind of weird for me. Because there are parts I absolutely love, and parts I could care less about. This is still a good album, but it's not entirely my thing. I know it might sound kind of shallow, but I prefer more energetic jazz music. I'm gonna give this a mid to high 3
Miles Davis saw that Jazz was dying, an in an attempt to change that, built this. And with Herbie Hancock and John McLaughlin’s playing here, this album becomes a new corner of the what could be in the world of Jazz.
These post-war jazz albums are really testing my patience.
- I usually default to 4 stars for jazz albums because 1) I do find jazz interesting (and often relaxing), 2) I have basically no technical know-how of the genre, and 3) it is made by people way more musically talented than myself. But this did not spark my interest in quite the same way? - I did not mind "Shhh / Peaceful," though it never felt that peaceful given the underlying, frenetic percussion. Nothing bad here, though I once again find myself at odds with electric keyboards. - Legitimately liked the beginning and end of "In A Silent Way," which was almost post-rock in nature. But the middle, which is the vast majority of the track felt less engaging in comparison.
Life changing beauty.
Muy disfrutable, pero depende un poco del estado de ánimo que se tiene al escucharla
Epic album! Felt like a never ending jam session the entire way through
i liked it but not really my style
Jazz fusion, jazz rock.
My favourite Miles Davis album!
Very relaxed. Like how it slowly changes without needing to get loud. Great atmosphere.
Davis is in terrific, lyrical form on this record and drummer Tony Williams is a steady anchor for these tracks, but the guitar and electric piano work amounts to little more than noodling.
Good album
I didn't dislike it, but didn't love it either!
This was beautifully captivating. Soulful and spare at times. This really hit something for me. 5/5
”Asiakaspalvelussamme on ruuhkaa, vastaamme puheluusi mahdollisimman pian”. Ei jatkoon. 2/5
Incredibol. Cocaína. 4/5.
Really nice for some background music. Not quite perfect through the whole way. That being said, I’d be a bit shocked if you told me that this album would be this good considering it is only two songs.
Ooo this one was fantastic…
This is the year I discovered every single album by miles Davis and I got surprised by every pieced music that is inspired and beautifully crafted and composed
Just two songs? I think perhaps improvisational jazz isn’t for me…or maybe I like the idea of jazz more than jazz itself. Either way, I listened to this while cooking dinner and it was perfectly acceptable background music, but I can’t see myself going back to it. I guess that makes it a 2.5/5.
Miles fuckin rips this
3 Stars Miles first "electric" album. First jazz album for me on the list. Im not the biggest Miles fan. As far as trumpeters, Lee Henderson or Donald Bryd make more enjoyable music to me. Maybe I have to play an instrument to "get it". Idk. Either way this album, which consist of two songs, gets three stars because the title track is great, would listen to it again. However, the first song is just ok. It's not terrible but I wouldn't seek it out. Wouldnt buy this album, but would accept it as a gift. Would most likely just listen to side B though. Shhh/Peaceful: Has a fun vibe to it. However, the song kind of rambles, even by jazz standards. Easy to put on and focus on something else. In a Silent Way: this song is journey. Staring slow, almost dreamlike with the electric piano. The electric guitar comes in, and the song gets into its main groove. Miles Davis riffing of the repetitive rhythm keeps the song interesting. Once the drums bring the cymbals into it, the song reaches its apex.
I listened while walking or reading and so was slightly distracted but liked what I heard and will definitely listen again.
das fangt seeehr vielversprechend aah. rhodes jazz i like groovy shit und s baut meega uuf hets überhaupt changes?? nöd so richtig, aber sie fitzed ane waaayne shorter omg. ah es isch so richtig gschnitte worde und so dases so halbe e sonateform git?? fun. sehr sehr spannend dass domols rock kritiker:inne meeega freud gha hend dass de miles öpis rockmässigs macht und jazzlüt hend gaaaar kei freud gha. finds fuuuucking guet what the hell.
This was alright. If I liked jazz more I’m sure I’d love it. Two songs, 30 minutes total. Very chill background music. (4)
Miles Davis > Duke Ellington
I mean it's Miles Davis what do you expect. One of the pillars and pinnacles of jazz. Wonderful stuff
To have witness this live!
Really great album. This is one of my exceptions to the jazz randomness sucks philosophy. I feel like there is quite a bit of random improv here but it is done so well that I don't mind it and in fact think it is really really well done. Keeps you guessing and nodding your head. It's a really fascinating and enjoyable listen.
realmente soa como um jazz inovador apesar de eu não entender nada sobre
Прямо очень хорошо. Точно не хуже чем A kind of blue
I love the guitar + trumpet interplay, and the guitar playing itself. Was a very nice meditative morning listen. Brilliant improvisations.
Best miles lid
Behagelig jazz at lytte til om morgenen, når man laver spejlæg med avocado sammen med Ebbe
Not much to say about this one, liked the second track a little more than the first
Kind of smooth jazz, which is an unforgivable thing to say about Miles, but it’s his most accessible work (I think). It doesn’t challenge my brain aa much as his other records, but has enough invention and energy to make it worth a listen.
Absolute respect for what it is, but I’m not in this moment ready to listen more. I need to listen to more Miles tho
Just incredible. Some of the best jazz musicians of their time all working at their upper limit to produce one of the most hypnotizing records ever made.
got crazy with this one and listened to it on shuffle
Its Miles Davis at the end of the 60s, it could only be a masterpiece.
Miles Davis can do both wrong
Miles Davis meets early Pink Floyd. Good stuff, to be honest.
Not my favourite Miles album, but it's still a solid record.
Not my cup of tea
I mean it’s Miles Davis’s he’s great, but this didn’t feel like anything ground breaking to me despite its controversy. It was nice to listen to though
ehh this was good but I was bored
It's like a classical piece, with multiple movements and one coherent theme, all fits together. Makes me feel like I'm waiting for a train
Very cool combination of electric instruments with jazz.
Never heard it before, but loved it.
Interesting album that gets better on each listen. Especially enjoyed John McLaughlin's guitar playing. I was surprised to read that this album is from late sixties as it sounded much more modern to me.
This is cool, just cool.
I’ve complained about a lot of albums on this list, but In a Silent Way completely makes sense, and while I usually enjoy this kind of jazz live and lack the stamina for the studio records, this was a total exception. Its smooth, two-track ambient structure feels so timeless you can’t tell if it was recorded in 1969 or yesterday.
#478 / 1089 Heard before? ❌ Revisit? ❌ I'm so so picky about my jazz and none of the Miles' albums I've listened have done anything positive for me as a whole. I noticed quite a few names in its credits that I know and of which some raise positive feelings in me, that I am cautiously optimistic about it. It was fine, no need to skip or switch off so I guess I liked it a bit, but I don't think I'll be returning to this one. Middle of the road 3/5 I guess
wonderful listening at a bus stop in the soft fall drizzle
7.5
6/10 Buen album pero podría estar mucho mejor. Medio aburrido se me hizo
Nope, jazz definitely isn't my thing. 2/5
There's hardly any music that reaches for God like Miles Davis
When I saw the words "Jazz Fusion" associated with this album I was not expecting to enjoy it. I was wrong about that and liked this one very much.
It’s fine I guess, there was very little here that grabbed my attention to make me want to ever voluntarily listen to it again.
It’s not for me, but I was able to listen to it all the way through.
Instrumental
Not my taste.
топ
Back with another jazz album, and you know what? I ended up liking this one quite a bit more than a lot of the jazz I’ve heard so far. I think a big reason is just the atmosphere. This album has such a chill, laid-back vibe that it feels perfect for putting on at night and just relaxing. I also think the fusion works really well here because it never completely stops feeling like jazz. There are definitely some soul and R&B influences mixed in, and apparently some jazz-rock too, although I honestly didn’t hear a whole lot of rock in it myself. Either way, those extra influences give the album a little more flavor and make it feel more accessible without taking away from what Miles Davis is doing. Of course, this being jazz, the tracks are very long, and I’m still not someone who gets wildly excited about sitting through an almost 20-minute piece. But this album gets away with it better than most because it creates such a strong mood. It’s less about waiting for a big hook or dramatic moment and more about just settling into the sound. And for once, I was completely fine with that. Definitely one of the jazz albums from this challenge that I could actually see myself putting on again. 3.5/5
I'm not the biggest fan of jazz, but I liked how the album started. There was an non jazz like start that I enjoyed as it reminded me of experimental music. Also, at under 40 minutes, it's a fairly quick listen.
no thing to complain
Innovative. Love Miles.
To me this is the mount Rushmore of the music, simply breathtaking and beautiful in every conceivable way. One of Miles masterpieces and this one is probably my favourite, one of the first works of jazz fusion, an album I just never get tired listening to as you always notice something new, of course it's 5 stars and even that doesn't do this beauty a justice!
Perfect for a mellow morning with a great cup of coffee.
It was good. Miles Davis is always good. Preferred the first half to the second half. 8/10.
The best Miles album out there. In my big 3 jazz albums with A Love Supreme & The Black Saint And The Sinner Lady. And if this is "hold music" then Breaking Bad is just a soap opera. Some people's takes are ridiculous.
Way over my head. I’m only giving two stars because it’s miles Davis. I feel like this is the musical equivalent of the doodle pad beside your phone.
Enjoyable. Dissonant and peaceful
There's only two tracks on this one people. First track sounds like it could be played under the world's longest montage of museum art robbers getting into place. Second track starts off as whimsical wind chimes, then picks it up and you start to think "here we go" but then it jumps down into the slow jazz that I don't think anyone likes. Picks back up again a tiny bit towards the end but by that point, too little too late, what else do you want me to say
I can hear prog stuff in there in the keyboard/organ(?). Pretty cool.
Decent Jazz, but not the best Miles Davis that I've heard. Fine for assume background music but not pushing it beyond that
Chilling
If writing improvisational noodly albums is cool, consider him miles davis. One night in Morocco was pretty good
Första sidan är en 3/5 och andra är en 5/5 såååå
Mysig med jazz när man jobbar. Det här är väl inte Miles största verk i min mening, men bra musik i en genre jag gillar.
Myyyyys
4,5/5
Awesome awesome change of pace album
I didn’t really understand the appeal of jazz before this album, and this album didn’t help. It’s probably objectively great. But I just don’t get it…
I wish I liked jazz more because I'm sure this album slaps on a way I'm not connecting with. it was an easy listen, but not one I'd put on rotation
Was beginning to think this was a trumpet-free Miles Davis record. 5
Liked the development in style, much funkier than earlier Davies (kind of blue/cool) than I was aware of. I absolutely loved the keys playing both as comping and solos on this Piano/Rhodes and Hammond really elevated the arrangements. 1st track 4/5 2nd 5/5 Loved it.
ihan ok, vaikka jazz ei lempparigenre
First time listening to this. Wow.
OMG, the band has stretched every note.
Heard before?:❌️ Will listen again?:✔️
Hard to rate compared to "Kind of Blue", this one needs more time than a single day before I can give a rating
I wish I had better jazz knowledge because I thought this was superb. I am always saying to my self that I should listen to more jazz and I never know where to start.
Long form jazz that I just couldn't get into. But I'll appreciate and judge it on its merits and not on my ambivalence towards the genre
Eh
Yea, on hold/elevator music. Not a big fan of jazz
Jazz is such a cool art form. It takes a ton of talent to be able to improvise, noodle around, and gel with the other players...oh and do so while making it sound good! Miles Davis was truly a gifted jazz musician, no doubt, and well, I respect the talent that went into this album, it's nothing I would ever choose to listen to on a regular basis. Two extremely long songs - I like a bit more variety.
Ganska mid idk
So intersting how the abulm is made up by two songs, but that does make it impossible to put on the radio. I love the energy to the slow down, wonder if its part of the jazz genre. I dont know mich about jazz fusion or jazz in general so I dont think I could connect fully, but it was still good to listen to.
Great relaxing jazz for working
Weird pick fit a top 1001
Peaceful
Ya like jazz?
Gorgeous
не моё, но качает
I still dont understand jazz
It is not silent.
Delightful!
this made me tense
Has to be 5. It's Miles Davis
Two lengthy tracks that seem to be very ahead of their time stylistically. Great, but not my favourite Miles Davis album.
Wow, just 2 songs but two of my new favorites. 9/10
amazing
Definitivno je kao remekdelo i vidim zašto ga ljudi tako gledaju ali za mene je mozda previše background music, doduše odličan u tome ali jbg ne znam dal bih pustio sam, nisam baš džez lik.
-Introduction very mellow i like it -Genre: jazz fusion
Зацикленные барабаны просто сводят меня с ума. Когда за шесть минут до конца пластики барабанщику наконец дали волю, я испытал такие облегчение и восторг, которые, к сожалению, не продлились долго. Не будь здесь барабанов совсем, пластинка была бы замечтательной, но с ними я никак не могу поставить больше трёх звёзд
not bad, just a bit monotonous in parts
Loved 1, 2 was creepy.
Really nice album, gentle, makes you feel calmed. Its amazing how Miles Davis finds complicity in simplicity because he uses very repetitive patterns in whichs he partially adds some guitar, piano fixes that add amazing tones to the tune. Just really great.
AH ! Je ne connaissais pas cet album, je connais assez mal Miles Davis, je n'ai que quelques albums. Donc m'aventurer sur un album du bonhomme, dont je sais la carrière très variée, peut être source de sacrées surprises. Et bordel, je m'attendais pas à celui-là. Je sais que la suite de la carrière de Miles Davis est pas mal marquée par le jazz fusion et les expérimentations, là où les premières années de sa carrière correspondent davantage au style classique qu'on attend du jazz dans l'imaginaire collectif. Donc j'aurais pu m'attendre à ce que cet album soit un entre-deux. On a droit à un parfait équilibre entre du jazz assez classique et du jazz fusion, avec de la guitare très présente. L'album est bien de son temps, dans le sens où à l'époque, il devait retourner le cerveau de l'auditeur pour son aspect visionnaire. Perso, j'ai adoré.
Probably my favorite / the most accessible of Miles' electric period. Its not quite jazz and not quite rock, just actually skilled improvisational music
2 long tracks totaling 40 minutes. Definitely deserves another listen.
A classic pivotal recording for Miles Davis and the history of jazz!!!!!
This Miles Davis albums was in his sweet spot of experimental and listenable. The right length for this sort of album, interesting all the way through but never a tough listen. I'll never be a complete jazz fan but this is the sort of thing id happily listen to again.
Really liked the second half of the second song, really chill, mildly experimental, but structured. The refrain in the first half is cool too. A good listen, but I wouldn't choose to listen again.
I suspect this is really good, but it's just not really my thing. I thought the second half of in a silent way was really good though, the most interesting of it all, but if I'm being honest, I'm never going to choose to listen to this. Still probably the best jazz we've had 2.5
one of the most critically acclaimed jazz albums from profilic musician miles davis, and said to be one of the earliest albums in his "electric period", a period of his discography where he started to incorporate some electronic instruments. you should see his discography. it's horrifyingly massive. collaborating with a group of talents, the record is composed of two hefty tracks, both about 20 minutes each. the switch in sound originally turned listeners off, but as time has went on, many people consider in a silent way to be one of the most important jazz records ever made. i've definitely heard of this album (or at least have seen the cover) before listening to it, and i can hear as to why it's so beloved in only a few minutes. this album is very groovy, very soft too. it's probably one of the best examples of a slow-burn jazz album; you really have to sit down and immerse yourself all the way through, which might prove difficult depending on your attention span. a lot of jazz albums, fusion jazz albums included go up and down and all around, but this album takes things slow and steady. believe me, players wander and riff, but it's got a solid theme for both sides; to me it feels like each side of the record is a room and all the musicians take their time decorating it. i feel like this album would be a 4 for a lot of people, but i enjoyed it. loosened me up a bit while i was working.
Shhh/Peaceful - 4.5/5 In a Silent Way/It's About That Time - 4.5/5 The first jazz-rock fusion piece is a delight to listen to. You know its good if the only complaint you have is that the outro at the end seems a bit too long compared to everything else. They call this the beginning of his "electric era", and the way he plays certainly makes it seem like that. Overall: 5/5 Favorites: Shhh/Peaceful, In a Silent Way
I knew i was gonna be sad when this was over.
Probably shocking to many, but I have never listened to Miles Davis before. I listened while working and it was very enjoyable. I could definitely throw this on and just sit and read with a nice cup of coffee. This will definitely be added to the consistent rotation.
In places, this reminds me of those mindfulness CDs with whale noises that you used to be able to buy in National Trust gift shops. The musicianship is top notch, but it really is just background noise you'd put on to relax at the end of a stressful day. Nothing wrong with that.
First half is a jam that finds its place over time with some piano, horn and drums. Second half is chill.
Solid. I prefer this to bitches brew, not as much over kind of blue.
Nice jams that flow like butter. Very accessible yet complex
This is my favorite Davis album. It manages to be so experimental but still sounds so pleasant and playful. It’s an album you can just as easily fall asleep to as listen deeply and feel every note
I am jazz ignorant but I know what I like.
lowkey actual bangers on this thank u for showing me this talented jazz artiste
I’m not the biggest jazz fan and that’s okay.
Very good album. I'm not a jazz expert but I'm a bit familiar with Miles Davis (especially, with his album "Kind of Blue"). I found this album very good, especially the second piece ("In A Silent Way"). Overall, a solid 4 star album for me.
I'm not a jazz girl and this was REALLY not for me in the beginning, but it got a lot more palatable as it went on. Liked the second song a lot better. Maybe jazz is growing on me idk
Relaxing
real nice, I particularly love the title track. It has a very nice structure that’s influence can be seen on post rock albums and such (like gybe). Shhh/peaceful is also very good, the backing cymbals drive it well
Alright, not my favorite miles davis
Is possible for me to give a Miles Davis below 5 stars? So far not looking like it. I loved the 2 long tracks that really breathed and evolved. I love jazz the more I listen to it and I especially love jazz fusion. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
two-song album that is really peaceful, a classic genre of miles davis🤍 8/10
Beautiful. I've listened to this a few different times now, and it's still a lovely set of tunes. I don't know much about jazz so I can't really describe it in detail. The trumpet, the piano, the bass, the drums; it all builds smoothly and when it hits a high, it dances around gracefully. It's a lovely affair that deserves a listen.
4/5 2 tracks, let them take you in
Fusion-era Miles Davis should be a good listen, right? It is a good enough listen-if you like sidelong jazz workouts. This album consists of two sidelong jazz fusion pieces, with "Shhh/Peaceful" being a pretty good extended jazz song. The title track starts less energetic and more intimate than "Shhh/Peaceful" before it ultimately settles into a nice jazz groove. This is a pretty good jazz fusion album that showcases Miles Davis's willingness to experiment with different styles of jazz and his excellent musicianship, allowing for a uniquely great album. I would expect nothing less from the greatest jazz musician of the album era. This album is ranked #8 of 38 albums for 1969. Other 1969 albums rated by me: Abbey Road(1/38)-5 Led Zeppelin(3/38)-4 At San Quentin(5/38)-5 Bayou Country(7/38)-4 In the Court of the Crimson King(9/38)-5 The Velvet Underground(10/38)-4 Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere(11/38)-4 Stand!(16/38)-4 Cloud Nine(17/38)-4 Arthur(18/37)-3 Hot Rats(19/38)-3 From Elvis In Memphis(21/38)-2 Tommy(22/38)-4 Songs From A Room(25/38)-5 Unhalfbricking(26/38)-4 Kick Out The Jams(29/38)-3 The Gilded Palace of Sin(30/38)-3 Odessa(36/38)-2
DNL
Pling plong. Vad är poängen?
Beautiful music. But I have a hard time listening to such ongoing music. Could hardly stand the steamtrain rhythm in the first half, more enjoyed the atmospheric 2nd half. Not going to go back to this any time soon, I don't think.
Dreadful the summed up the reasons I hate Jazz in one album. Just toot and noise really nothing substantial
(I somehow lost the notes that I'd made prior to listening to the album - but I complimented the album cover! it had really sparked my curiosity! I was keen to listen!) but yeah, I think after listening to the album I'll only keep liking the cover. So so so good! I wish I liked the music more - and don't get me wrong, I've always been drawn to Miles based on his genre and his legacy / reputation, but these 2 tracks were putting me to sleep on my Friday afternoon ride from Bratislava to Žilina (and the traffic jam which made it 30-40 minutes longer certainly didn't help). So, not a perfect setting - and Phoebe Bridgers put out an album which is really tough to follow. But I sat through it. And I wouldn't mind putting it on in a café, I'd even go as far to say I'd love it then! I'm grateful for "having to listen to this" and for the opportunity given to me by 1001albums, thank you.
3.5
good for studying
Masterpiece
fine
The more jazz I listen to, the more I realize I like jazz, but don’t really love it
Such a groove with this one.
passeli! kuulemma meillä on tää vinyylinä. pitää ottaa haltuun myös silleen.
Oon ehkä vähän biased koska tää tais olla eka Milesin levy jonka kuulin kokonaan. Potkii edelleen tosi hyvin ja jotenkin koen että tiivistää Milesin modaalisen aikakauden parhaiten. Ihanan lilluva levy, joka kuitenkin pitää otteessaan aktiivisella kuuntelullakin. Bändi on ihan huikee ja ilokseni oon saanu nähä Dave Hollandin ja Herbie Hancockin bändit livenä. Slurp ja lörp ja ahh, tää jatkaa levylautaselle palaamista vuodesta toiseen ja hyvä niin!
Nyt meni kyllä niin pahasti vahingossa taustamusana muun tekemisen ohella etten osaa oikein mitään sanoa tästä levystä 🥲 Tähdetki vähän sinne päin että toisaalta ei jääny mielee mitenkää mutta ei myöskää mitää pahaa sanottavaa xd
”Miles Davis ja Kalevi Sorsa Kirjuriluodol - Se oli jatsii”. Huh! Olippa tiukka pläjäys 🤩 Toki uskals paljon odottaakkin, mut yllätti silti kuinka smuuttii ja kiinnostavaa kampetta. Upeiden urkujen, puhaltimien yms lisäks upeet sähkökitarafiilistelyt oli mieluisa yllätys 🎷✨
No nyt on kunnon tsäässiä. Kun suljen silmäni, näen edessäni Larpan Puokkarin-kämpän beigen sohvan (huom. ei koiranhajua), kirsikkapuunväriset TV-kalusteet, keltaisenkelmeän valon ja seinällä Joanna Newsom -julisteen, jolle olin salaa vähän mustasukkainen. Oh sweet youngen days. Tää on taas näitä "helmiä sioille, en osaa arvostella", mut hyvinhän toi toimi, mukavasti soljui ja pistin useamman kerran soimaan työn oheen. Musta on tainnut nuorena aikuisena altistumisen takia tulla pienimuotoinen jazznautiskelija.
Enjoyed
Es bastante interesante creo que en mi caso funciona para ponerlo mientras leo no trabajo porque le chequé las canciones sean tan largas, me permite concentrarme mejor y ponerle atención mejor a la música sin que me desespere
Otro disco sorprendente del genio del jazz, me ha encantado
In A Silent Way
i dont remember any of it but it was fire they cooked by adding electric guitars 8/10 best song - in a silent way
Early fusion could be, but the drums are annoying, endlessly repeating patterns
Great Songs: In a Silent Way Good Songs: Shh / Peaceful Mid Songs: Bad Songs:
Gear: Penon FAN 3s Artwork: 👀⚫📷 Production: 🎧😘🤌 Music: 🎺🧭🚂 Rating: 🤫🤫🤫(🤫)/5
Great album, love miles 4/5
Awful
how many perfect miles albums will be on this list? this makes two. ima guess 4 more.
Miles fuses jazz and rock nicely to create a very smooth and calm, wave-like atmosphere; the intro to the title track best displays such an effect. Although noodling around a single chord (as in "Shh/Peaceful") can make the album feel messy at times, Miles' honing into a vibe makes up for it.
I know jack shit about jazz but this is great
Pretty accessible for a Jazz album. The noodling is mostly tasteful and restrained, the songs have groove and structure
A sprawling, approachable jazz record. I'd say 40 minutes is about right for instrumental jazz; this was much more palatable than Bitches Brew. Track 1 is a little more upbeat and bright, but even through the more melancholy notes of In A Silent Way, this album is very pleasant.
Miles Davis is jazz that I can handle! So yes, I really enjoyed this album.
The first time I gave this a listen I completely zoned out; I felt it wouldn't be fair to give my thoughts at that point though and since it was only two (albeit incredibly long) songs, I gave it a second listen where I started noticing the complexities in the instrumentation a lot more. My opinions on jazz seem to fluctuate all the time, but to say the least I can appreciate this if not "love" it. I liked the second track more than the first, though.
i cant really get down with this style of jazz on a record - live would be a different story
Really nice. Funky, artistic, groovy. Made me feel like I was in a very cool movie. Didn't want to stop listening tbh. 4.5 stars.
It's really good music. I can sit and chill, have it play in the background or even while I drive. But AS an album it doesn't speak to me. It's quality, though.
Day 1 Miles Davis does not disappoint. Really, this just goes to show how PHENOMENAL jazz is 😫 Fav track: In a Silent Way EDIT: In hindsight, no wasted momentum, bumped to a 5/5
Aside from Silent Way and Bitches Brew and a Weather Report album, this list is disappointingly lacking in jazz fusion. In A Silent Way was when Miles was already a big name and decided to make one of the greatest creative leaps a mainstream exposure (nay, a household name back then) and get even bigger. There's a lot of details in the music and Miles picked pretty much the best musicians available to play with him. A masterclass in jazz that deserves to be listened to and not read about to understand.
I’ve always been a little hesitant about Miles Davis. While I do enjoy listening to jazz, there are some musicians and their songs in that genre that I just don’t get. I felt the same way about Miles Davis. Now that I’ve listened to this album, I really liked it, and I’ll definitely listen to this and other Miles Davis albums again. 4/5
Heard before. Just absolute peak jazz-fusion. What else could you want in a somber, ambient exploration of sound?
Despite it's influence and torrents of accolades from music critics, this is one of my least favorite Miles Davis albums (and I've got them all). Side 1 is groovy, but meandering. Side 2 is more interesting musically, but still meandering. 3/5.
I really love this record from the bottom of my heart. Bitches Brew (which I also love) might be Miles' magnum opus, but it's this more accessible record that I return to more often.
i knew as soon as i saw that this was just two 20 minute jazz songs that i was gonna love this. i like the organ and the drums and the jazz guitar. very soothing. feels more modern than 1969.
Shhh / Peaceful > In A Silent Way It makes sense that this came out the same year as Abbey Road. You can hear a lot of the same influences.
Bien.
Jazz. Nice! I'm not much into jazz, not that I don't like it - this album was really good. It just doesn't appeal to me as much. But I own a bit of Miles Davis and Glenn Miller, so I enjoyed this. I'm assuming it's two sides to a vinyl record with it only being two songs. It flew by, was so easy and nice to listen to.
I liked it more than I thought I would
no comment really, solid jazz
Super relaxing but not in a boring way. Sort of atmospheric as well 9/10
Gentle, meandering, trumpet-driven jazz
Nice.
Enjoyed that. But still background music to me. Would never really listen to this on purpose.
Not the biggest fan of instrumental only.
Always.
4/10
Love a good jazz album. And this is absolutely one of those. I did two listens to it in one day. I barely ever double dip like that, so just know it's a delight. Whether the music is improvised or all written down, I have no idea. All I know is that it was a very chill experience. The instrumental variety is wonderful. The musical production is great when listened to over a speaker. But in headphones I found the electric organ on the second song to be a bit much. Altogether, it's an excellent listen, it's succinct, it doesn't get all weird and esoteric like some jazz albums do, and I really enjoyed my time with it.
I can appreciate the musicianship, I can appreciate the innovative things he's doing here with new instruments brought into the jazz sphere, but it's just still not for me, I'm afraid. Improvisational jazz is never going to be something I want to sit and listen to. Does this album deserve more than 2 stars? You bet. But is it more than 2 stars for me? No. I will never sit and listen to it. ⭐️⭐️
Only 2 songs, felt classy, liked song #2 better
Great listen at work. The music begs you to stay focused on it, which makes you focused on what you are doing. It sounds like the musical equivalent of drinking coffee.
RATING: 8/10 HIGHLIGHT: In a Silent Way LOWLIGHT: Shhh/Peaceful
I enjoy his music much more than I think I will!
Some of the reviews on this site are actually insane. What do you mean one of this album's top reviews is them thinking they could make this album if they had a trumpet? Did we listen to the same album? "On Hold Music" being the top review????? Are you guys okay????? Anyway, this is his best album out of the ones I've heard. Might be my favorite jazz album of all time. It's an extremely propulsive album: despite how comparatively mellow it is compared to some of his other works, it has a psychedelic, almost jam rock feel to it that's really fun and keeps me coming back to this. It's excellent.
Enjoyed the second side far more than the first
from trailblazing jazz fusion, with electric guitar flourishes, masterful brass, incredibly crisp drums and the most solid upright bass foundations to what ended in ambient soundscapes of ethereal electric pianos, moody chord flourishes and somber low tones. I was going to originally list this as a 4/5 because I feel it's more of a 9 than a 10, but that would be incredibly disrespectful to this masterpiece. You don't even feel the time go by.
Very enjoyable!
conceptually challenging, but it doesn't do it for me. I can perhaps feel my neurons growing, but not in a pleasant way.
i'm not smart enough for jazz. i liked this plenty, but can't articulate why.
Fact I have gotten this guy twice in the past couple weeks is insane.... Still mid, elevator snooze music
I’ll give it a two since it was only two songs 🙏🏼
An obviously talented guy making music i cant understand and dont like. In a parallel universe this guy got an electric guitar when he was 12 - Id be excited to hear what that universe sounds like
I'm very, very tired this morning, and I'll be honest - the first few minutes of this were well on their way to a 2-star review. But it grew on me. I started bored with it, but then I realised it wasn't dragging. I let myself just kind of let it happen. And before I knew it I was telling someone "I'll be 45 seconds late to our meeting" so I could let it finish naturally. It both felt like standing on a salt flat staring at eternity, and laying in a eucalypt forest on a calm, quiet morning. It doesn't conjure anything grand. It's not huge snowy mountains or a forest in a storm. But it definitely conjures something at a more fundamental level. It's the ground and the sky with me in the middle.
Nice first album to start with.
Enjoyed this. Easier going than Bitches Brew on a first listen that's for sure. Having said that, I think I accidentally listened to this once earlier when I drew another Miles record, so maybe it's more familiar than I realise.
It’s kind of a vibe.
Not to "person who's only exposure to jazz is hadestown listens to their second jazz album" this but I'm getting a lot of hadestown vibes :) it probably doesn't help that as I'm listening to this I JUST came back from watching hadestown. Luckily I LOVE hadestown so I'm loving this.
It was okay, got boring after awhile
One of my favorite artists of all time and this is well within his top 3-5 for me. It works so well as a whole movement of music. Sooooo many fuckin riffs.
- shhh / peaceful: I ain’t listening to 17 mins of the same thing bro. - in a silent way: ANOTHER 19 MINUTES goodbye. ( I’m not saying it doesn’t sound nice but I just can’t bro, I need lyrics and there isn’t any, I like the vibe though, but just no- this ain’t even an album man )
This one didn't pull me in but it's okay.
I enjoyed it but I don't know enough about jazz to say much more.
Exactly the stuff I love from Miles.
Jazzy instrumental No vocals Often just piano key mashing
Day 3: Not for us
Yet again I leave a review and somehow it doesn't save. Great. I enjoyed this one of course even if its only two tracks, but its definitely something you'd listen when you're trying to sleep.
First listen, mellow stuff to listen to while smoking a doob.
Inoffensive background music
The first half of this album was two stars but second half was three. I will round up to 3 from 2.5.
The swinging beat, the rhythms, Miles’ trumpet: so good.
Masterfully made, flowy, emotional. A virtuoso at work. I cannot do anything else than take my hat off. Chapeau. Great work.
I was very surprised when I saw the album was 2 songs yet managed to be 38 minutes long. It is literally just jazz music and not a single word is said on the whole album so its not really my type of music but is still an overall okay experience. There is obviously talent in the album but this just isn't my idea of a good listen.
Wide-ranging, innovative in its improvisations, but likely to be pretty inaccessible for many
I'm sure the best way to introduce jazz to someone who hasn't listened to much of the genre is a two-track album that still manages to last almost 40 minutes. Starts nice! Yeah I'm enjoying the second to last track. The rhythm's so cool. I fucking loved that. The title track (which is also the second track, and also the closing track) goes into a completely different sound and mood. Still great, but I loved the first one much more (which is the reason the score isn't a 5). This was so good. I can't claim to be surprised that it's good, but I am surprised that I managed to enjoy it this much. Guess I like jazz now. Yey!
4.5
The advice Len Houmous gave Miles Davis when he asked how he could improve his music 2.2 2/2 In a Silent Way
Weird as fuck. I like it!