Album Summary
Metallica is the fifth studio album by American heavy metal band Metallica. Released on August 12, 1991, by Elektra Records, it is commonly referred to as The Black Album because of its packaging design. Its recording took place at One on One Studios in Los Angeles over an eight-month span that frequently found Metallica at odds with their new producer Bob Rock. The album marked a change in the band's music from the thrash metal style of their previous four albums to a slower, heavier, and more refined sound. Metallica promoted Metallica with a series of tours. They also released five singles to promote the album: "Enter Sandman", "The Unforgiven", "Nothing Else Matters", "Wherever I May Roam", and "Sad but True", all of which have been considered to be among the band's best-known songs. The song "Don't Tread on Me" was also issued to rock radio shortly after the album's release but did not receive a commercial single release. Metallica received widespread critical acclaim and became the band's best-selling album. It debuted at number one in ten countries and spent four consecutive weeks at the top of the Billboard 200, making it Metallica's first album to top the album charts. Metallica is one of the best-selling albums worldwide, and also one of the best-selling albums in the United States since Nielsen SoundScan tracking began. The album was certified 16× platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) in 2012, and has sold over sixteen million copies in the United States, being the first album in the SoundScan era to do so. Metallica played Metallica in its entirety during the 2012 European Black Album Tour. In 2020, the album was ranked number 235 on Rolling Stone's The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list. In December 2019, Metallica became the fourth release in American history to enter the 550-week milestone on the Billboard 200. It also became the second longest-charting traditional title in history, and the second to spend 550 weeks on the album charts.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Darn it! I was digging the opening track, till the dude pops in with that heavy metal singing, which just kind of makes me want to laugh (but, over the course of the album, or even the first song, really, becomes tiresome, oppressive, and annoying). Yes, the guitars kind of sound like that, too, but I could live with that, if the singing weren't so clipped and stilted. Come to think of it, that's kind of what Smashing Pumpkins (who we just reviewed) did, isn't it: heavy metal guitars (at least at times), but more "normal" singing (Corgan's not a great singer, and his voice is, well, his voice, but at least he didn't try to do heavy metal singing). Anyway, as *this* album goes on, it becomes more and more clear that my initial hope was a false hope, and the album becomes more and more annoying, and I find myself getting impatient for it to finish. I think I had a little hope (despite knowing that Metallica is - duh - a metal band) because of having picked up a vague sense, somehow, that they're somehow better than most other metal bands; broader appeal, or higher quality, or whatever. But, I have to say, I'm not seeing it. Just didn't enjoy any of this very much. Instructive that this album comes the day after Rush for us, since I'm having a similar reaction. Rush and Metallica makes me appreciate even more SOOOO much other music that I enjoy listening to, that makes me happy. 1 star. Even Rush is better than this. Hoping for a better album tomorrow!
A masterpiece. Perhaps the best heavy metal album of all time. Front to back, it’s powerful, angry, and hard, while also being emotional and passionate and downright soulful. This a certainly a must hear album.
I'm of the firm opinion Metallica's first four albums are by far the best they ever produced. Ground breaking, genre defining masterpieces. The rest of their catalog I can do without. That said, I like the Black album. In fact I like it more now than I did when it was released. Which may be yet another example of today me being lame af, but whatever. Enter Sandman is a monster, legendary metal song. Holier than Thou and Through the Never absolutely shred, my two favorites on the album. Couple other great songs on here, but there is definately some trash on this track list. Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, and Nothing Else Matters are so bad they anger me. Well anger is a bit dramatic, but they irk the hell out of me, thats for sure. Far more good than bad, overall a great radio friendly metal album.
TIL this is a s/t album. this is a great, accessible metal album. heavy enough and still melodic and a marked shift in their direction to flirt with commercial viability. this shift would eventually destroy the band’s likability and ability to play their instruments. it would result in. albums like “st. anger” and “72 seasons” and “the mission: impossible ii soundtrack”. i prefer the more ambitious stuff that came before however.
Top. J’aime bcp Unforgiven
I like it better than lots of other metal albums, but it’s still metal, which is not my jam. I could give it 2.5 stars but don’t think I can get up to three. My friend Dave is going to be so mad!
schon mehr mein geschmack, würde öfter hören
I really liked the guitar tones on this one. Felt the production was clean. Liked the songwriting, lots of songs felt the same but the classics hit. Think I’m just not into the lead singers voice and vocal styling. The guitar riffs were immaculate on this one. But Metallica really ain’t my thing
Some absolutely killer tracks. Not my favorite Metallica album, but does have some of my favorite songs by them. Fully enjoyed it. 4/5
(Light 6/10) Do not understand why this album is rated so highly. It's not even a good rock album. What gets panned as "Butt Rock" sounds much better than this which actually sounds like rock from a butt. There are a few good songs, "Nothing Else Matters" is an all time fav for me, and "The Unforgiven" is pretty good, if overplayed. "Wherever I May Roam" is actually fire, I forgot how good that one is. The rest of the deep cuts are merely okay with some flat out bad songs too. "Don't Tread On Me" is cringe, "Of Wolf and Man" makes me think of those cringe graphics of a were wolf ripping his flannel off, and "Enter Sandman" is literally one of the worst songs ever written IMO. Yeah this album not only started a bad trend in Metallica's songwriting, but it also signified that Metal Music was destined for commercial marketability and whether you think that's a good thing or not, it made it pretty clear that Metallica was losing hold of their roots as a subversive act in rock music and the phrase "Selling Out" was actually being used in earnest for this group. Take a shot every time Hetfield does a "YEAYAUH" or a "WHOAOHAHOH". Damn.
good
I just read the 33 1/3 book on this album! So if you want a super glazing read go read it. The 33 1/3 book series is great. As someone that witnessed this album and is a fan of Metallica this is what you need to know. It was fucking huge. It was everywhere forever. Literally they toured the world for like 3 years on this album. Look up them playing Moscow absolutely crazy how this album hit. I know hip hop kids that know this album. It started the second phase of Metallica where they wrote trash metal for the radio. This album is just so good I think the entire thing became singles even years after. Yes the super hardcore fans will tell you this is when they sold out. I always respond yes they did, every arena and stadium after this album. Yeah it is a departure from phase one Metallica, but it's still damn good metal. Holier than Thou? Through the Never? Wherever I may Roam? These are just so good it's amazing these are on the same album then you add in Struggle Within, God that Failed, the Unforgiven and Nothing Else matters?! Seriously this album is great.
Trading the thrash for some tenderness - not my favorite! but enter sandman went hard as fuck on my 1st gen ipod shuffle in 3rd grade
Great album
if i had to choose one.
An album that brought Metal music to everyone. The singles off this record alone probably helped hard music make it to many more people than it would have otherwise. Truly a great A side, and killer singles. Some of the b side tracks are middling, but this album's importance cannot be understated.
bastante suave para ser metalica, algunas canciones famosas, relevante historicamente pero meh para mi
Lowkey streamlined.
Metallica is another throwback album which creates memories of metal at its best
One of my top 10 albums ever. Heavy, catchy songs and not really a bad track on it
Yeah it's fine. I know they're a big deal, I know this is probably super iconic. It's all a bit samey for me. Nothing Else Matters is a masterpiece though
There are some phenomenal songs on here, with hits like 'Enter Sandman', 'The Unforgiven' and 'Nothing Else Matters', but the amount of filler is mindblowing! I didn't like 'Don't Tread On Me', 'Through The Never' or most of the tracks after 'Nothing Else Matters'. I also didn't like 'Sad But True' as much as some people, and it definitely isn't one of the band's greatest tracks. I do like some Metal music, but this really isn't it; it's too polished and grand to be something shocking or really interesting, but too 'Metal' to be enjoyable to people who aren't fans of the genre. I didn't hate this, and the highlights were REALLY strong, but so much of this album was boring to me, that I really couldn't justify a high score.
my FAVOURITE band, FAVOURITE album, and FAVOURITE song... FINALLY got here after 132 other albums... i wish i could give it a special rating above all others... Enter Sandman, I love you...
rock on
The last 'good' Metallica album to most, but to me that was really Master of Puppets. I don't care much for the super dry sound of AJFA, and at least this album doesn't continue in the same direction. This is really their transition to the mainstream - most accessible songs, most melodic hooks, almost pop-like song structures on many of these songs. There are songs everybody knows, like Enter Sandman, which remains a slapper with that super iconic (tho stolen from Deep Purple) riff at the chorus, energetic vocals and a great solo in the back half. The Unforgiven is of course one of their biggest songs too, and it's different. More of a ballad, with slower paced riffs and some pianos around the chorus, but it is very passionate and heartfelt so it works. Nothing Else Matters I would say already crosses the line of the amount of camp I can tolerate for a Metallica song, and kinda shows my main issue with this album - it feels too watered down. In the process of making their sound more accessible, they lost a lot of bite. That's why the guitars here sound a lot more tame, the riffs don't hit, and some of the slower songs really don't work. Don't Tread on Me and Of Wolf and Man are some of the least exciting the band has sounded up until that point. Of course all of that becomes less and less clear as you dive deeper into their catalogue, but leaves me disappointed when I know what the band is capable of.
I was really looking forward to this one. Enter Sandman is A++, and theres a lot of big songs on this album. But I was kind of disappointed? Other than the singles, the album was just repetitive. I was bored! What I've listened to so far of Metallica has been very overhyped 3 ⭐️
I like this, though isn’t my favourite Metallica album. Slight knocks against it are really bad guitar tone, being overly long, and some slightly corny lyrics. But it’s a great more mainstream metal record.
This is the point at which Metallica started moving on from their thrash metal roots and adopted a more commercial heavy metal style, which has often brought mixed reactions from fans, especially with their later albums throughout the 90s. However this album manages to balance out the two styles really well, making the riffs more catchy, the songs shorter and the melodies carrying over to a much bigger stadium sized area. This is why, despite some lackluster albums during the second half of their career, They are still one of the biggest bands on the planet. Ageing like fine wine despite not every member performing at their best these days. Lets be honest, ride the lightning and Master of Puppets are really good albums, but I consider this and Kill them all to be just slightly better.
hmmm
It was okay but I wasn’t particularly into it and took a while get through the whole thing. I think, much like Master Of Puppets which I got a few days ago, the songs go on for longer than they should and there just isn’t enough power in the vocals to match the rest of it.
Das ist mal guter metal 4/5
3,5 stars
1991, the summer (and subsequently a sizeable chunk of autumn) where Bryan Adams' Everything I Do (I Do it for you) topped the UK charts for sixteen weeks. Yet away from the singles chart in the same period the 'Groover from Vancouver' topped the hit parade a number of now lauded albums were released, including 'The Black Album' by Metallica. Though before getting to Metallica I need to address what was probably the most anticipated album of 1991, namely Use Your Illusion the new Guns n' Roses album. As it turned out it was albums plural, G n' R fans were given two and half hours of 'new material'. It's with this is mind that some of the tracks on the 'Black Album' feel at least a minute too long. Like a more leaner album coming in at around fifty minutes would be seen as not giving their fans comparative bang for their buck. I get why the Black Album is lauded. Yes this a band refining their sound, this is metal for the MTV age, but in retrospect it was well timed with the emergence of grunge. Certainly more so than either of the Use Your Illusion albums were.
Not a fan of Metallica, but I give them credit for the scope and solidity of this album. They get a 4 instead of 5 because Hetfield's growling vocal style drives me crazy.
Great album. Would definitely go back and listen. Helps that I’ve listened to it previously and enjoyed it and listen to several of the songs regularly. Not sure what about this album I like but something just clicks with me and sits really nicely in what I enjoy listening to.
I still don't get how a band can go from writing class conscious anti-war anti-establishment art and then get high on the hog to go full sellout like how Metallica speed-ran to.
oooh noo dont twead on me. Wonder how many people listened to only Metallica & said “I don’t like metal” cuz damn I think they blow.
George Lopez reviews Metallica - “We’re Metalli-ca’s not Metalli-can’ts” My only take away is that I wish AFI did a cover of Nothing Else Matters because they can do it better
I don't listen to a lot of heavy metal, but this could change my mind. It's a great album.
3.5
6.6/10
Has some songs I've enjoyed in the past, but kept feeling like it was musically basic
LOVE
cool 8/10 best song - sad but true
Ok liked this a lot more than I thought I would, maybe you just had to be there in the 90s, but also it's Metallica ew lol
The album carries the title of a masterpiece for a reason. For me personally, the “The God That Failed” song is a massive highlight in lyrical and musical content with its a fatter yet sharper opening riff, groovy guitar tones, and heavy, rhythmic tempo.
This was like pleasantly catching up with an old friend I'd grown apart from. When I was first developing my musical tastes, multiple songs from the black album were still in heavy rotation on the local hard rock station, and I end up picking up the album. My dad walks in on me listening to it and says, "this is what you're into now? Let me play you some real shit" and hands me his copy of Ministry's Psalm 69. I fell in love with industrial and metal took a backseat. When I did get back into Metallica, it was their thrashier '80s albums I gravitated towards, but the black album is still loaded with classics, and holds a place in my heart. ✅️ STILL BANGS favorite songs: Enter Sandman Wherever I May Roam The Unforgiven Nothing Else Matters
musically, this is good. lyrically, this feels so performative oh my god 😭 i feel like metallica is only heralded as being so good because of nostalgia from millennials
This genre isn’t really my cup of tea, but I didn’t hate this album. I really like “Wherever I May Roam”. However , the songs were way too long, and I found some of the lyrics and the vocal style kinda cringe. Not for me, but that doesn’t me it’s bad.
Such an easy 5 star from me. I adore this album (almost) cover to cover. Its like born to die where I love it all till the last song and it doesnt stick the landing. But its not bad, and certainly not bad enough for me to dock a star. YEAHHHHHHHH
i like dis one. no notes. mup lars
I’m so glad he sings like that cause every time I was able to make out the lyrics I was a bit unimpressed. That said some pretty good songs on this probably too long album. Highlights: The unforgiven
oh boy, metallica is soooooo boring. however, this release, has so many nice tracks, that i'm inclined to give it a 4. don't tell anyone!
3.5
Nostalgic for me, so a bit biased. Love some of the songs on here, but still think Master of puppets is better
Metallica fucking blows and I'm tired of pretending they don't.
Mid un peut comparer a tout leur autres album
It's too cheesy for me to really take seriously. Getting hit with Enter Sandman as the first track is a little ridiculous. Its place in pop culture makes it hard for me to judge as a piece of music. I think it's good? Overall the production on this album is really impressive. It's pretty cool that they managed to distill and refine metal into something palatable for the masses. The slower songs and the way this album is sung aren't for me, and I suspect there's Metallica out there that I'll like more. Somewhere...
fuck metallica does rule huh. like sure it's wicked sick or whatever, but i don't think i got before just how crazy catchy some of these songs can be. i have some dim understanding that metallica isn't high art but when you're in the thick of a chunky ass track and the solo starts you just get swept up in it. but yeah Enter Sandman does insist upon itself. favorite song is My Friend Of Misery, just goes so hard. very strong 4
sin dudas un muy buen disco que ha dejado clasicazos, sin embargo no hay nada que supere esos cuatro primeros discos de metallica
nothing else matters is a holy banger but at the end of the day metallica isn’t really my cup of tea
aa
1. 5 2. 4.5 3. 4 4. 5 5. 4.5 6. 3.5 7. 3.5 8. 5 9. 4.5 10. 4 11. 4.5 12. 4.5
Starts with Enter Sandman, perhaps the catchiest hard rock/metal songs ever written. Does it stay as good? Sad But True has a crushing pounding riff. Holier Than Thou too. Riffs and tone are on-point. Don't Tread on Me has a medolic metal vibe at the start. Either riffs start to run out, or it's just about 2 songs too long. Best track (new to me) - Sad But True 4 stars - at its peak it's unassailable, but a few tracks too long.
I know this album so well, like Metallica as a somewhat cheesy metal band/machine/industry. I love a lot of songs on this album. Point off for just how basic and shit Lars is at drumming. With a better drummer this band could be so much more dynamic.
Despite the presence of two of rock music's biggest chuds, Metallica generally puts out good music. Their first four albums are unassailable. This was the one where things started to slip, and not just in a stylistic manner. The shift from balls-to-the-wall speed metal to radio-friendly hook-filled hard rock didn't bother me. More problematic the shift of crafting albums for LPs to crafting for CDs and making albums longer because they could, adding songs that were too similar to each other with about four or five tracks on here that struggle to differentiate themselves. The production from Bob Rock was probably the best they had to that point (but would steadily get worse on subsequent albums to the point where fans put together a petition for them to find someone else after St. Anger). But "Enter Sandman," "Sad But True," "The Unforgiven," "Wherever I May Roam," (one of my favorites), "Nothing Else Matters" even the very silly "Of Wolf and Men" are all enjoyable.
Suprisingly well-balanced. Songs like 'Nothing Else Matters' help round it out beyond the 'genre classic with big hits'.
Surprisingly varied. Great guitar. Ok vocal.
Look, it’s very good. Enter sandman and nothing else matters are S Tier. I just don’t think I’d go buy the vinyl
Objective 4, subjective 3.
I’m giving it a 3 but it’s really more of a 3.5 It’s a very good crossover album. Too much of the same style musically though.
4.55
Chug chugga chug, chug chug chug.
amo metallica, la mejor banda en vivo que vi
Metal, kinda "trudge"-ey
Not keen
this was painful but we did it. likes one maybe two songs. not our vibe.
I know and quite like the singles - but rest of album was new to me. On first listen it was quite relentless and fairly joyless. Although it was starting to grow on me by the second listen - which is the most positive response I have had to any metal album so far. Not sure I would readily listen by choice as just not my bag - but beginning to understand it a little.
Some of their classics and then some guff. Better sounding than And Justice for All, but gets a bit samey sounding by the end.
Ugh. The start of the decline for one of the best thrash metal bands to ever do it. Good on them for doing what they want I guess....but what they seemed to want is to move units for capital rather than cred and I am not down. The rest is a downhill slide into a radio rock/sports anthem wasteland. When the pendulum swung too far and they tried to return to their thrash roots, they couldn't do it, appearing as a caricature of their former greatness. You can never go home they say. Over polished, over produced, sub par lyrics, and so sonicaly homogenized that only a handful of tracks stick out....and shame on whoever turned Kirk on to the wah pedal. It is certainly abused on this album. That said, My Friend of Misery is probably Newsted's Orion and I can fuck with that. Despite the grumpy review, I am still giving it three stars because you can do a hell of a lot worse than the Black Album and this list reminds me of that regularly.
I like it better now then when it first came out. Too many songs overall (maybe shave 2 off), but enjoyable. 3.5/5.
Seminal and genre defining
As someone who has never listened to metal but is really interested in it, I’ve been thinking: what metal album should I start with? Maybe Black Sabbath, or Judas Priest, or even System of a Down. Ahhh, but of course, it should be Metallica. They even have the genre in their name. They are known for Master of Puppets, and they are the kings of thrash metal. So why on earth would I listen to the album that strayed away from that sound? Having their self-titled album as my introduction to Metallica (and metal) is probably an interesting choice. I am reviewing this album without their prior albums in consideration, and without any established expectations of what metal should sound like, and I honestly think that makes my perspective on this album much more interesting. Having prepped myself with hard rock albums, Metallica’s self-titled album sounds sick as hell. One thing I know about metal is that the riffs are crazy. The first thing I noticed about the riffs in this album is how dark it sounds compared to the usual riffs I listen to. The chugging and palm-muting of the guitars give off that metal sound that I’ve been dying to listen to before my metal deep dive. Enter Sandman’s main riff is so iconic, even beyond the whole metal space. I like the faster riffs in Holier Than Thou and Through the Never. The songs on this album are usually midtempo, so these songs were a nice change of pace. My favorite tracks here (aside from Enter Sandman) are the slower songs like The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters. There’s a feeling of introspection in these tracks, and the inclusion of acoustic guitars and strings provides contrast to those much heavier tracks. Together, they round out the album into a cohesive experience. The vocals here are another highlight. James’s voice is just so memorable, and his delivery has a certain charm to it. It can be rough, but it can be emotional at times too. Nothing Else Matters is proof of this. Overall, a great introduction to metal. It is fast, intense, groovy, but somehow still accessible. This album is catchy, and my goodness, this shit is just wonderful. I love the darker atmosphere of metal music, and I am looking forward to listening to more soon. Great album. Fav track: Enter Sandman Least fav: Of Wolf and Man
I reckon if you thrive in the heavy metal genre this album is at the top of your list. Hard for me to like even though all the vocals, arrangements & production are likely well done.
do not like.
Musically it's a masterpiece. Albumifically, it's so repetitive that I struggled to differentiate any tracks
It happens to be a transitional time for them too, while Justice for All had social commentary and a rougher edge, this is meticulously produced, clean, and from what I gleaned the themes are just feelings on the human condition, stuff that everyone goes through. It’s not bad, it’s got some moves here and there, but it’s made to sound good to a wider audience In some ways I don’t think selling out is a bad thing, if you want to, if you’re selling any kind of art you’re doing so to hopefully sell out of it. I think in this case they’re compromising their sound. Ulrich says they would splice many different drum takes into one fill or solo, there’s something inorganic/disingenuous about that All signs of selling out
Not a fan of Heavy Metal but this album wasn't bad!
hetfield and co sound like a caricature of themselves. 2.5
Not for me
Mid ion rlly like metalica
J adore 🥰
6.5/10 - This album definitely belongs on the list. It’s one of the few (or only) Thrash albums to enter into the mainstream cultural zeitgeist. This is the album many metal, Metallica, or music fans were introduced to. Enter Sandman has 2.3 billion streams and launched Metallica into mainstream superstardom. This was the band your parents were afraid of in the 90s. It was Metallicas foray into the mainstream and thus their most palatable to date. That being said, the thing that made Metallica great was that they were largely unpalatable to the masses. The best bands and the best albums of the Alternative music scene (meaning not Pop or rock music for the radio) hold the mirror up to society in often uncomfortable ways with the hope of the listener examining their own experience and ideas. Because of that, I actually prefer Metallicas first four albums because those albums set out to do what good art does. Everyone of those albums sticks with you and makes you examine the horrors of war, drug addiction, the death penalty, loss of loved ones, and corruption. The Black Album was influential but missed the mark of what Metallica was prior.
I can see why this is popular but it doesn't move me. 4/10
Self-serious lyrics. Too brooding for workout. Singer inserts random yeahs into places they are not needed. About as long as a famine year. And I have two more to go...
Maybe a bit blinded by nostalgia. But the album just is good to listen to front to back. I didnt mind the runtime.
It has stood the test of time (which is more than I can say for Robert Christgau). 5 stars
I am not partial to this kind of music whatsoever, but I can see how Metallica could be one of the more respected artists in the genre. At least, with my listening priorities, I noticed decent harmonic interest and some enjoyable guitar playing and impressive solos. I don't mind the vocals, but the lyrics can be cringey. They can also be kind of cool/unique I guess, but It's not definitely not enough for me to give this a 3, sadly
rock music for dummies!
It opens with Enter Sandman, what am I supposed to do after that? I actually prefer this album quite a bit over Master of Puppets and ...And Justice For All. More dynamics, less brute force...I'm not sure what it is, but I do think I enjoy James more when he's just a touch less snarly and the music behind him is a little more varied and not just a wall of sound.