Metallica by Metallica

Metallica

Metallica

3.76
Rating
30829
Votes
1
3%
2
9%
3
24%
4
35%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 16)

And nothing else matters…

Yep, that was Metallica. Had this on cassette tape, from Columbia House! Haven’t listened to it since and it didn’t take long to remember why. Not necessarily bad, but predictable and that’s bad.

“Enter the Sandman” is a superb way to begin an album. I like this album. Brings out the teen boy in me. Another album that’s popular for a reason. album. Not an uplifting album by any means (“My Friend of Misery,” “Through the Never” are glaring clues), but a good one.

Metallica automatisch 5 Sterne. Zweit bestes Album nach Master of Puppets.

🎸🎸

- enter sandman: i have been listening to this since 2023 when i was 15, this one genuinely changed my life, mostly because i had nightmares every freaking night and this one resonated a lot with me. - sad but true: how the hell have I never heard this before - holier than thou: my dad should listen to this ( love the drums in this ) - the unforgiven: I liked the last 2:40min I just don’t think this song should’ve been that long. - wherever I may roam: also should not be this long, but who is the other person singing in this? I like it, also in the unforgiven. - don’t tread on me: kind of getting bored - through the never: this is what I’m talking about, love it - nothing else matters: great fucking song but my divorced parents had their first dance to this in their wedding so not many good memories I’m afraid. - of wolf and man: I don’t really get this, why are we shapeshifting lil bro - the god that failed: I like the lyrics, but wouldn’t exactly listen to this a lot - my friend of misery: oh 15 year old me would’ve ate this up - the struggle within: oh I love this, yup 15 year old me also would’ve loved this.

it's really good but i just can't get into it. my favourites are probably "the unforgiven", "nothing else matters", and obv "enter sandman" is immortal at this point. but i get so tired listening to this. maybe that's the point but what i love about music is that it fills me with some kind of energy. this is more on the draining side. metallica is one of the few metal bands that i've listened to that let their albums breathe, and taking my headphones off after this still felt like coming up to the surface after being underwater for too long. ehh maybe just not my cup of tea, that's ok!

Through the Never and Nothing Else Matters are bangers, but the rest is pop metal garbage. Justice for Jason Newsted.

Ohhh hell yeah. Anything that starts off with enter sandman is gonna be a great time. Sad but true is a rocking track that doesn’t have many words to describe it other than awesome. That drop out and then coming back in with the solo was awesome. The energy carried into holier than thou was phenomenal. It didn’t slow for a second. It then goes into the unforgiving which is great placement as it’s a different sounding track. It’s also the best song recommendation I’ve ever gotten from reddit. I quite liked wherever we may roam too. It was a bit of a slow down but I didn’t mind it. Don’t tread on me had a nice beat to it. Nothing else matters was very pretty. Of wolf and man was pretty great. My friend of misery was so beautiful in a misshapen way. The struggle within was a great way to end this off. Great energy, just so much fun. 5/5 ⭐️ easy 201/1089

This is just so not my thing - sludgy, plodding, monotonous Nickelback-esque music with no finesse, wit or really anything much of anything redeeming. 2 stars because I guess I'm not utterly horrified by it, but it's really close to 1.

Hab's nochmal ganz gehört...

Schon einfach immer wieder geil. Mir fehlt bisschen das thrash-metal von älteren Alben deshalb "nur" 4.5/5

Este álbum es poderoso tiene canciones muy emblemáticas de la banda Especialmente para mí Nothing Else Matters Me parece curioso que históricamente hablando (al parecer) este álbum representa un cambio de enfoque para poder mostrar resultados que puedan ser más abiertos a otras audiencias Algunas de las pistas en el álbum son buenas pero no memorables Pero si está reescuchable y se aprecia mejor conforme avanza el tiempo, estoy convencido de que hay álbumes más cohesivos que este, pero de nuevo, este es un muy buen álbum, sus estadísticas lo ratifican

This is very very good. Just so.

Pretty solid album from them. I like the music a lot more than the vocals - his voice gets old quick. I can dig Nothing Else Matters almost always - great song.

I thought I was lukewarm on Metallica but those riffs are irresistible.

I still listen.

some bangers on here

Metallica is a band I've heard basically since I was born. One of my dad's favorites so a lot of these songs are burned in to my memory after hundreds upon hundreds of plays. The legendary act's shift away from a thrash focus, a controversial decision among hardcore fans accusing them of "selling out" but a homerun commercially became the bands biggest release and the most successful metal album of all time. Of course, you don't need me to tell you that. Everyone has heard at least one song from this album, its that widespread. Despite the controversy with in their core fans this was generational on release and holds up extremely well today. Enter Sandman is an insane start to this album going on to become their biggest hit still to this day. From the iconic opening riff, to the crescendo led by Lar's drums, to that outstanding chorus every single aspect of this song works. An awesome exploration of the theme here as well led to this track deserving the praise and adoration its received over the years. The hard hitting drums of Sad But True take stage front and center and create a very stead rhythm just for another iconic chorus to come in and tie the song together. Holier Than Thou is a tongue in cheek jab at the hypocrisy of thinking yourself better than other and has a tight fast past solo that completely makes the track. The Unforgiven is maybe my favorite song here and one of my favorite Metallica songs period. Almost feels like the soundtrack to an old western and it makes for an engaging listen. The atmosphere is fucking perfect the opening guitar sets up a stellar mood for the more vulnerable song writing on more of these tracks to come, but especially here. Every verse is performed through the eyes of a man who finally had enough and is just completely burned out, not in a completely angry way but almost more apathetic and defeated and is a soaring high point in James' performance throughout their entire career. That guitar tone in the solo is legitimately beautiful and is the best guitar playing on the entire project for my money. Further amazing light strings that break into to a much punchier instrumentation once the drums come in on Wherever I May Roam. Again just another fantastic song. Don't Tread On Me is one of the weaker songs here but that is not to say its is a bad song at all as that guitar is wonderful. Through The Never once again has a solo that absolutely rips. Just breath taking guitar work throughout which was most definitely to be expected of these guys at the time. Nothing Else Matters is yet another masterpiece that completely mesmerizes anytime it comes on. A slow gorgeous guitar, subdued but still hard hitting drums, a perfect baseline, and the hushed vocals all create a mood that had yet to be seen from these fellas, but my god do they knock it out of the park. Even that solo is gently weeping and says just as much as the vocals without any words. Following up that absolute peak is no easy feat, but Of Wolf and Man does an admirable job at bring the energy back up. I cannot praise the guitar here enough, James and Kirk put in all their effort into a set of incredibly catchy riffs. The God That Failed was definitely the song I slept on most, what a banger. An interesting inspiration behind this track too, continues to add to the more emotional feel this record works towards. In an album full of stellar solos, My Friend of Misery stands near the top because holy shit I was ascending through the whole thing. What sounds like a tambourine too just invokes the feeling of a rattlesnake that reminds me of the by simple but superb cover art, The closing song, The Struggle Within is definitely the weakest track here, but still a completely competent song just a bit of a weak way to close out a landmark album. I love this album unsurprisingly after that long winded review. It was what I knew Metallica for most growing up and it was really one of my early introductions to metal and I can respect what it did for both this band and genre.

A great album which I do not think I ever listened to in sequence. Some songs I do not like (Enter Sandman, Of Wolf and Man) because I find them uninteresting and sort of forced upon me. Some are different than what they did before and feel interesting (The Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters) and some are similar to the old albums in a good way (The God that Failed, My Friend of Misery).

4/5 not their best more mainstream

I'm going light 3 on this one because even though I found it really boring and repetitive by the end, I feel like I would have had a pretty good time if the album was just Nothing Else Matters, The Unforgiven, Enter Sandman, and maybe any 3-4 of the filler tracks. I just can't get that excited about a band that varies its sound as little as this and isn't doing anything all that interesting when it does. I prefer metal like Lacuna Coil or Rammstein where synths and vocals add more interesting layers. This thing is just a dull monolith of gloom.

It's quite long. A few bangers but ends up samey. James Hatfield's voice is so corny.

It was cool. I've never heard deeply Metallica before, and I think they are a very good band, with an amazing solos and a very good sound-narrative inside each song. I enjoy it so much. Particularly, there's not my genre.

Really liked the energy, but I think I would have appreciated it more when I was younger.

Me gusta mas otros albunes de metallica

I liked this album a lot better when it was called And Justice For All and was good.

The ballad nonsense can get on the bin, other than that it's Metallica, albeit a bloated version. It's on my shelves - obviously. Heard before ✅️ Listened this time ✅️ Revisit ✅️ ★★★★☆(7/10) Total reviewed : 384 Already owned : 85 Purchased : 16 To buy : 7 Nope : 276

j'ai failli mettre le 3 pour nothing else matters

Top to bottom perfection

I know I'm a broken record on this topic, but while I love music like this, I prefer when it has lengthy instrumentals and less singing. Or all instrumentals! - that would be even better. The music on this record is marvelously intense, though. 3

Enter Sandman is bearable but after that it was an hour of noise that put me on edge whilst I was attempting a relaxing drive. No thanks.

Songs are simple and slow (lars probably can't play fast) but this causes the riffs to have a sinister vibe - cool, James does play faster (chug). Probably their best album considering Kirk is not playing shit yet. James' lyrics are a bit like they are written by a child that just watched monsters inc, yet it is catchy in an anthem like way. Also James cooks with the acoustic.

must have thundercunted its way through America, great but not quite black sabbath for me

An hour is a long time to listen to Lars Ulrich

was nice to listen to de not so popular Songs on the Album again!

відчуваю себе американським підлітком в сша в 94му

Do you remember when you were younger and certain stimuli used feel like electricity coursing through your body when you were excited? "Enter Sandman" used to give me that feeling. Before learning about the band and their history, I heard the Black Album. It's a great starting point for most listeners, because this is Metallica at their most radio-friendly, while still retaining the metal edge that made them superstars. I get it, anthemic tracks like "Enter Sandman", ballads like "Unforgiven" and "Nothing Else Matters" are new tricks for the then-biggest metal band on the planet. However, once I explored Metallica's discography, the Black Album seemed less interesting. The 80's albums are just so incredibly strong that the Black Album feels watered down by comparison. It's also unfortunate because the success of the Black Album inspired a lot of generic sounding radio rock copy-cats for the next two decades. Have I spent hours listening to this and pouring over the insert, yes; did I memorize the lyrics, absolutely; that said, this album has not aged as well as Metallica's earlier, more interesting work.

it’s not horrible but it’s just not my thing. i’m not an instrument music kind of person. i can objectively appreciate all the guitar solos and nice drums but ultimately it’s just not my favourite genre. some good gems here like nothing else matters, enter sandman and the god that failed. but as i am not super familiar with the band and genre it just sounds like generic no copyright metal music which makes sense because this is where they all took inspiration from. also weird seeing dont tread on me here (song imagery etc) and seeing what it means nowadays #awkward

Gran disco

Massive album, I know most if not all of the songs. It was ubiquitous in my youth and that was at a time when Nirvana, Pearl Jam and Achtung Baby were fighting for air space. I won't deny that the songs are catchy, to a point, but the same self seriousness of all Metallica songs is even sillier as I have grown older. Unforgiven sounds like it was written by a 5th grader. Don't Tread on Me...utter nonsense. I know this isn't Shakespeare or even Dylan but it's just so sophomoric. I will give it a 3 because it was important during it's time but I don't think it influenced a thing. There was no metal revival that came of it. If anything, it was the last vestige holding on as alternative definitively put a stake in the heart of 80's metal in the coming months.

The hits are amazing. The rest is pretty samey. 4/5

8/10 album <3 this was actually way better than I thought. I like 4 songs from the album and the rest are equally just as good, I gave it an 8 because I think it’s amazing but also could use maybe another slow song or just James and a guitar, just my personal opinion. Totally cool for new metallica fans 🫶🏽

Probably the album on this list so far I've unintentionally listened to the most, every gym has most if not all of this album on repeat. I don't know if I would actually say this is a great album musically, but in terms of cultural impact and staying power it's hard to rate it anything other than a 5. "Enter Sandman" "Don't Tread On Me" and "Of Wolf and Man" are the ones on here I enjoy the most, but of course "Sad But True" "The Unforgiven" "Wherever I May Roam" and "Nothing Else Matters" are noteworthy too. The one song on here I hadn't really caught before but did enjoy is "The God That Failed"

Far from being my favorite Metallica album yet there's still this very heavy sound that make this release very enjoyable. Favorite songs: Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven

This is the album that got me into my Metallica phase!

Si me gusto mi fav fue the unforgiven 10/10

Tows the line between hard rock and metal like no other, no wonder it was their most mainstream, however I'm still waiting to find their best... ahem Master of Puppets

This album really blended into my morning commute. Chugging riffs, chugging train, chugging coffee. But for a heavy metal record, it left me feeling rather sleepy.

high 1 so many albums like this on the challenge. some somehow win me over, this is not one of them. boring, samey, formulaic, not even a good example of what it is i checked the track listing thinking it must be nearly over only to discover im on track 5/12

I mean in this group it's five, for Metallica, not

Standouts Enter Sandman Sad But True The Unforgiven Wherever I May Roam Don't Tread on Me Through the Never Nothing Else Matters

On the last Metallica record I heard about a year ago (AJFA...), I praised the band for adding depth to what I believed to be a shallow genre. Metal to me was always stubborn blast beats and hair-flailing guitar tricks that impressed me as much as Brad Pitt impressed Shania Twain. That album was cool because despite the lack of bass, the band still had some progressive ideas. That's not really the case with their self-titled. I'm sure I can call this Metallica's full-dive into the mainstream. After all, it's an album synonymous with the genre which means it sold a shit ton of copies. Plus people tend to like it and consider it the last great Metallica album before they arguably lost their footing. That should give me enough reason to believe in it! So I turn it on and it's Enter Sandman! I know this one and it's good! Kick-ass riff, off to the NeverNeverLand, YEAHHHHHH!!! All the goods. Then like 5 songs happen where it's all dramatic and shit. Through The Never's a bit notable, Nothing Else Matters is great and it goes out from there. So I leave this album having heard it twice and both times I thought "Man, that was mostly wasted time". And Justice is the longer album by 3 minutes, but again, the time they fill on that is meaningful and warranted. This is just basic bitch pedal to the metal that everyone got on the train for. At least that's how I hear it. It's in no means a bad album but, massively overrated to me. That doesn't mean its success is undeserved; the songs that kick ass do indeed kick ass. I just don't feel the need to fill 62 minutes of my day with the same 7-8 sounding songs. You know it's sad but true (5/10, 2/5 on this scale)

I love lars simple drumming against these awesome songs. By the back end I’m starting to lose interest, because every song is similar, but you can’t deny the front end of this album is full of classics. It’s the kind of album that puts a smile on your face.

Can’t believe I liked this as much as I did. Loved the guitar solos.

There’s some good drums here but honestly, this genre has always been an uphill climb for me and this album is no exception. Likes: Enter Sandman; The Unforgiven

Already heard. No bad tracks. However very few peak tracks

I swear every song sounds exactly the same. I mean that one song is okay but does grate a bit after an hour of it

A staple of rock radio with 5 of the 12 tracks on heavy rotation this is what comes to mind for me when I think of Metallica. It's hard to set that to the side and evaluate. The singles are stand out good, though again is that just familiarity? The non-singles don't really do much for me. Lars continues to be a white bread and mayo sandwich. With all of the truly talented drummers out there it's a shame that he was able to hitch his wagon to superstardom with such lack luster talent, and then have the audacity to act like all of the criticisms about him are unfounded.

I remember a lot of Metallica fans being upset with this album because the band was "abandoning their roots." Of course, it also turned them into worldwide superstars and made them millionaires, so I imagine the band members don't feel too bad about it. This is more enjoyable to me than earlier Metallica. I'm still not a huge fan of Hetfield's vocals, and "Don't Tread On Me" gets massive negative points for inspiring an entire generation of right-wing militant assholes. As a rock album, though, it's pretty good.

I'm sure they're great musicians but this is sooo tedious.

Sorry, I can't do an hour of this

Old man, rock ‘n’ roll/heavy metal not for me except the first song, which is very Poppy

Not a massive metal head and find some of this kind of thing inpenterable, but I really enjoyed this. A lot of the songs are such classics they are inbedded in my conciousness even though I've never really gone out of my way to take an intense listen. My least favourite thing was James Hetfield's vocals, my favourite thing was the drums although I hated the horrible snare sound. Worth another listen.

Probably the best to ever do it

Had to listen to it twice cause the first time I thought it was shit, but it grew on me. If you pretend to be someone's 50-year-old dad, then it works better

didn’t finish but i was waiting for the generator to give me this album

It might not even be my favorite Metallica album, but this is one of the first CDs I ever bought, and i have so many memories of listening to this over the years. Still a fun record!

Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters!

Unfortunately, there is nothing I like about heavy metal. Just painful noise to me.

Metallica's big commercial statement brings pop crunch and a handful of killer tunes highlighted by the ubiquitous "Enter Sandman", but overall the record doesn't stand up to their earlier masterpieces. That said, its crunchy pop metal of the highest order.

The black album is on this list? Now this is a sound of my teenage years. It's entry level metal, more hard rock with a slight edge. Which is why as an adult 25 years later I can see this for what it is. It's Metallica cleaning up their sound and seeking mass appeal. I'm thinking - when was the last time I listened to this album? I was probably 17. In the last 22 years I haven't put it on. I've listened to the odd song from time to time. Since then I've gone through the archives of metal. I probably sit as a black metal man at the minute, but had phases of power/symphonic, doom/sludge, and death being the dominant forces. Can this appeal with my developed tastes? I'm apprehensive. ----------------- Reflection It's easy listening hard rock/metal. It achieved it's goals and Metallica became icons. The production is very clean. The pace slower. The bass actually audible. The songs have simple hooks that make for radio friendly hard rock. The guitar is prominent and technically proficient. The drums are there and the vocals bark and croon as the songs dictate. As an album it feels very polished. It doesn't challenge or deviate from it's formula. And yet that formula provides toe tapping rhythms, memorable hooks and undeniable success. There are at least 5 songs that are Metallica classics but honestly there is quality throughout. An iconic album in the trajectory of hard rock and metal, no doubt.

Oh hé, du metal ! Incroyable, il y en a, dans cette liste ? Bon, soyons sérieux 5 minutes, évidemment qu'il y aurait Metallica et Robert Dimery faisant du Robert Dimery, évidemment qu'il allait mettre le Black Album. Si c'est le seul album de Metallica dans la liste, ça va un peu m'énerver. L'album Metallica, c'est un peu le gros album controversé de Metallica. Parce que St. Anger, il est pas controversé : tout le monde le trouve nul, et à juste titre, mais on va éviter de parler de cette purge. La particularité de cet album, c'est le changement de style du groupe. Et qu'on soit d'accord : je ne pense pas qu'un changement de style soit une raison pour maudire un groupe. Mais là, c'est quand même un peu particulier. Parce que Metallica, c'est un titan du metal. Avec Kill'Em All, le groupe a ni plus ni moins fondé le thrash metal, en concomitance avec Slayer. Et ses trois albums suivants sont tous cultes, des exemples de thrash nerveux parmi les plus influents de l'histoire. Je vais pas m'étaler plus que de raison sur cette période de l'histoire du groupe, parce qu'il y a beaucoup de choses à dire et de nuances à apporter (comme la prod assez infâme de ...And Justice For All). Ce qu'il faut retenir, c'est que dans les années 80, avec ses 4 premiers albums, Metallica s'est démarqué en étant un monstre du thrash et son influence sur tout le metal extrême, de façon directe ou indirecte, est fondamentale. C'était un groupe révéré du genre, l'un des plus populaires au monde, voire même le plus populaire. Oui mais voilà, alors qu'on arrive dans les années 90, Metallica voit plus grand. Metallica veut remplir les stades, attirer les foules, vendre des albums par palettes entières. Et c'est pas avec du thrash que tu peux faire ça. Alors, sur le Black Album, le groupe se métamorphose. Finis, les titres rapides, rageurs. On ralentit le tempo. Et on ajoute plein de parties mélodies et accessibles qui parlerons au grand public. Et pour faire bonne mesure, on met une balade presque consensuelle. Metallica avait déjà de l'entraînement dans le style, avec le début de Fade to Black qui préfigurait un peu Nothing Else Matters, sauf que cette fois, pas de déchaînement, on reste sage et tout doux jusqu'à la fin. Et le pire, c'est que le groupe arrive à ses fins. Le Black Album a été un succès monstrueux. C'est l'album le plus vendu du groupe et, si je ne m'abuse, du metal tout entier. Un succès phénoménal, donc ? Si on regarde les ventes, oui. Sauf que ce qui fait la qualité d'un album, c'est pas les chiffres des ventes. Et c'est là qu'on entre dans la controverse : pour beaucoup, cet album est une pure trahison, un scandale que beaucoup n'ont pas digéré et maintenant, même des petits jeunes qui n'étaient pas nés à l'époque détestent Metallica par principe, juste à cause du Black Album (ok, ils sont assez rares, surtout hors d'internet, mais le simple fait qu'ils existent, je trouve ça dingue). Beaucoup de gens détestent cet album qu'ils voient comme une aseptisation du groupe, dans le but de faire plus de ventes. Et difficile de leur donner tort, à mon avis. Ceux que je comprends moins, c'est ceux qui adorent cet album. Parce que, et là, on entre dans mon avis personnel, c'est quand même pas dingue, comme album. Je ne fais pas partie de ceux qui le détestent, je trouve qu'il a des qualités, mais bon sang, que les parties metal peuvent être mollassonnes ! Il y a vraiment des passages lourdingues, où il ne se passe rien. Et limite, je trouve que c'est quand Metallica assume le plus ses ambitions commerciales que l'album fonctionne le mieux. Je parlais de mélodies accessibles un peu plus tôt et on pourrait croire que c'était péjoratif, mais en fait, trouve que c'est les moments qui fonctionnent le mieux. Mais pour moi, ça ne sauve pas entièrement cet album que j'aime vraiment pas trop, même s'il a ses qualités. Je comprends ceux qui le détestent, je ne comprends pas ceux qui l'adorent. Pour moi, c'est un 3, parce que c'est pro, c'est bien joué et il y a de vrais passages de qualité, mais c'est un net recul après 4 albums presque irréprochables.

It's been so long since I listened to this, I'd forgotten that it's just absolute wall to wall bangers. Imagine not liking this. Boring people.

There are some absolutely outstanding tracks on this album - Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, and Nothing Else Matters are incredible. Sad But True and Wherever I May Roam are great. The rest? ok to somewhat good.

There is nothing about this album that appeals to me in any way. I’d rather listen to a constipated capybara perform the complete works of Edgar Winter on harmonica than listen to this again.

Back to front iconic. Every song has potential to be a lead single. These guys perfected thrash and that's why they broke the mainstream. Fitting as I saw them only last week and boy do they still have it

it's not enough my type but good music

Not so much that there’s any bad songs, it’s just that the album is too long at a bit over an hour and whether or not I like the sound now as much as I did as a teenager, it does feel like a bit of a wash across so many of the tracks. I think part of the trouble is that, in stripping back to a simpler, more live approach to the music (which was a good choice for the band clearly), you lose the proggy variance through the songs themselves of the earlier thrashier albums. Instead it’s kind of like 5 minute tracks supposedly designed for easier listening and radio play and the like (but I’ll grant them, they absolutely hit it on the initial tracks).

I’m torn here: do I rate it according to “objectively” how good it is or according to how much I like it. It’s really not my type of music, but much like it happened to me with “ten” by pearl jam I discovered this album had classic songs I’d heard a thousand times before.

I like the Black Album, but I do feel it is a step or two down from their first four records. Metallica had a great 5 album run, but to me this is an unfortunately the first sign of where they end up going. 4/5

Slick, overproduced, glorious. Best sell out album ever?

Some standout tracks on here that aren't the ones everyone knows.

Again not my thing, but extremely well done and influential

i have this in my collection :) been listening to black album for half my life at this point because my mum passed down all her old music to me, i remember listening to friend of misery on the school bus in the morning and thinking i was the shit

This month has been an incredible run of rock albums that have been great and we can add this one to the pile. In some respects, it's ironic I got this one immediately after Coldplay's A Rush Of Blood To The Head, as I commented in that review how commercialized Coldplay had gotten and that they were mainly producing slop recently. It blew me away to go back and listen to that album before they sold their souls, as their original sound was truly special. Perhaps some would say the same about Metallica with this album as evidence that they gave up who they were, since they vaulted much more onto widespread radio airplay with the Black Album. The difference, at least for me, is that while Coldplay became much more watered down and programmed, Metallica never really lost their identity. This album, instead of giving into the machine, shows a level of maturity for Metallica, as they create a sound that still has those hard driving roots, but is much more refined and melodic, all while demonstrating their ability to be incredibly diverse within a single record. There's still a lot of heavier songs like The God That Failed, Holier Than Though, and the amazing Of Wolf and Man. There are tracks that still have an edge but crossed into the mainstream like Whenever I May Roam, Sad But True, and my personal favorite, Enter Sandman (love it when my Iowa Hawkeyes storm the field when this is played). But that's not enough, they also pack in two really well constructed ballads like The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters, the latter of which even the great Elton John called one of the best songs ever written. There are purists who will say they sold out. I get it. But I just don't see it, at least with this record. They just composed a complete sound that the public latched onto because the compositions were that good. 5 stars. A truly fantastic album.

Have obviously heard of Metallica, own this album but never listened end to end. Starts off with an all timer. Enter sandman is a top 50 song ever. Drums, guitar lyrics all so good. Don’t want it to ever end. Guitar and drums so good again on sad but true. Definitely not as catchy but not a terrible chorus. Awesome solo. Holier than thou is very well written. Cool guitar again but not as cool drums. Unforgiven is a nice change of pace. Not as metal, a lot more emotion to this one. Cook strings. Solo again is so good. What a guitar player. Great riff to open wherever I may roam. Good bass on it too. Good lyrics too. This song is another banger. Good guitar on tread on me, rest of it is just eh. Not my fave. Through the never is classic Metallica. Very metal. Sweet guitar solo. Nothing else matters is another nice change of pace to open. Good vocals/lyrics. Honestly surprised that this song didn’t have more commercial success. Back to heavy metal with of wolf and man. Well written and good guitar but too much for me. The god that failed is a banger. Awesome guitar all the way through. Good enough lyrics to back it up. And then my friend of misery might be even better. Best guitar solo so far I think. Just awesome song after awesome song. Struggle within is a pretty good song, just not sure it works as a closer. But with that being said I don’t really think any heavy metal song would. 0 outright skips which immediately puts it in the 4s. This album is really good, would be even better if I enjoyed heavy metal. I’d say this record is an all timer. 4.6/5 stars.

Yep. Five stars.

i like this

Feels raw. Some of it felt same-ish. I was surprised about how much pointless rage seems to be in this album.

Um dos maiores e mais revolucionários discos do metal. Acredito que não tenha muito o que falar sobre Black Album, é difícil gostar de heavy metal e não conhecer o disco e a grandeza dele. Repertório marcante, músicas que se tornam ícones da banda e do gênero, performances históricas e um disco que dividiu, mas também surpreendeu os fãs da banda. Depois disso, a banda se perdeu muito tentando se diversificar e experimentar e demorou muito tempo pra voltar aos trilhos. Por isso, talvez o auto intitulado seja o último disco bom da banda para muitos dos fãs.

I understand why it’s influential and good but at this point in my life it just sounds like the nonsense I’d hear from a motorcycle bar or mechanic shop

Dios sabe que lo intenté (parte dos). Dos días seguidos que me toca un género así, ¿qué estoy pagando?

Klassisches Rockalbum, tolle Songs. Sehr melodisch und eingängig. Mit einigen Bangers und Evergreens.

nothing memorable. rah rah rah rah!

Yeaaahhh! Arrgghhhaaaa. Repetitive testosterone and kak lyrics. Giving points for 3 pretty good songs. The rest so skippable. Yaaawn. Might need to calibrate if there are more Metallica LPs on this list so I don't end up in negative score. But it's a no for me, dawg.

A classic I spent a ton of my time as a 16-17 old year listening to, and memorizing.

Difficult to rate. Love it or hate it, this record contains some iconics tracks. It also contains songs that you will most likely never hear outside of the context of the album as they are completely forgettable. Not bad, just kind of metallica flavoured white noise. Don't get me wrong, this record has some great highs with an excellent start in Enter Sandman. However, it quickly loses steam and sticks to repetetive riffs that sound the same across songs. I thought "...And Justice For All" was a little bit simple at times, but here they seemed to have turned up the dial to max. I get it, everything for commercial success, but it's kinda sad. Especially when they do somethhing different such as in "Wherever I may Roam" where they actually use an arabian scale the song instantly becomes 10x more interesting. But maybe I am just a music hipster. Still the riffs are generally good, the drums punchy and you can actually hear the bass in this mix for a change! This record could have easily become a 10/10 if they tried a little harder instead of making songs that sound like the sole purpose is to complete a tracklist so they have a place to sell their singles. 8/10

Aah, the quintescential Metallica album, the one album that every other band hopes that their self-titles album will become with the amount of hits that this album contains. It genuinely contains most of the greatest hits of Metallica (not to say that the other albums don't have those).

Hörku solid. Metallica eins og maður þekkir þá. Góðu lögin eru það góð að þau hífa hin aðeins upp.

3.5 favs: enter sandman, don't tread on me, nothing else matters

240626 13:42 3.5

yeah pretty solid, I like it the note i gave isnt real though i dont like rating when i JUST listened to the album

Their best-selling album, where Metallica jumped the shark into a gigantic pile of money. The dividing line between 4 amazing works of Thrash rock (And some fantasic EPs) and the load of horrible schlock to follow.

As a huge Metallica fan, it almost makes me cry to see so many bad reviews. I honestly think this album is legendary. Sure, some people say it's more commercial or dated compared to their earlier thrash records, but that doesn't take away from how incredible these songs are. Kirk absolutely shreds, and James Hetfield is simply one of the most talented front men in metal. I just love, love, love his voice and songwriting. From start to finish, this album is packed with unforgettable riffs and songs that still hit just as hard today. It's an absolute banger and easily one of my all-time favorite albums.

I can’t believe this album has as much hate as it does. I have never listened to the whole album but it has many hits, and I think the album ends on a high.

People can say whatever they want about this album. But it fires on all cylinders and checks all of the same boxes as the prior albums. Front to back great songs with plenty of thrash. Sets a high bar for this genre

This is #day684 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… here's to my final record by Metallica, represented on the list, aka the slow, deep, and hard one. Now, I've known plenty of songs before, but it has been my first time blasting it from start to end. What is there to say? A whole hour of goddamn heavy metal and... nothing else matters. "My Friend Of Misery" has always been one of my all-time favorites of theirs. This is a 5 out of 5. Looking forward to #day685.

Some of my favorite Metallica tracks are on this album. Sad but true.

Aivan absoluuttisia klassikkolevyjä itelle. 6/5.

Solid song

What can I say, it’s fucking Metallica

What can you say that hasn't been said about the Black Album? Far from perfect, not their best, maybe a little too rocky, but there's just so much that's killer on here.

started with a classic naruto amv banger and continued to some very listenable proto? metal? idk, i fuck with ~80s metal more than a lot of modern metal subgenres i’m aware of because it seems to be busy/cluttered and as a result more listenable for me. i'm def a musical ignoramus but i thought the guitar riffs were fun to and the sound is almost camp? which i enjoy in theory, but little actually stood out to me past track 1. i'd pick a copy of this up on cd if i saw it at a thrift for Angry Apartment Cleaning though. fav: enter sandman

Come on. Anything less from me would be a sin to me and my family.

even if you completely hate metal, you know this album. has to be 5 stars just for that. let alone it not having a bad track on it.

No es para mi

I've heard all of these tracks many times before, but this might be the first time I've listened start to finish. I can't imagine the impact this would have had if I discovered this in full as a 12 year old.

2.5 There’s too much Metallica on this list. At least this one has some radio hits on it.

Finally, an album that I was excited to listen to (again). The Black Album is an absolute monster in terms of its cultural and musical impact. Some fans felt it was a sell out by Metallica, but it was the opposite. The world finally caught up with metal’s greatest band and we are all better off for it. Every track here is fantastic. There is literally nothing that doesn’t hit exactly. A total master work. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

The black album. First time I actually listened to it. Surprised how much I knew past Enter the Sandman and Nothing Else Matters. Definitely soundtracked my morning run into my morning errands nicely. Usually wouldn’t go all the way to 5 for an album this long… but guess I’m feeling it today. 5 Boolean: true

Metallica (1991) - Metallica (6.75) Enter sandman 8/10 Sad but true 7/10 holier than thou 6/10 the unforgiven 8/10 Wherever i may roam 6/10 dont tread om me 6/10 through the never 6/10 nothing else matters 8/10 of wolf and man 7/10 the god that failed 6/10 My friend of misery 7/10 struggle within 6/10

Didn't liked it that much. Too much metal

This is a classic, not much more to say. Favorite track(s) Wherever I May Roam Nothing Else Matters

1hr 2mins of basically the same track over and over again. They're like the Oasis of Heavy Metal (Or Oasis are the Metallica of Brit Pop). Find sound, keep sound, bore the shit out of people.

hmm, a kaj je to

does what it says on the cover ...not a lot

Quelques bangers au milieu de trucs loin d'être nuls.

I can understand why people like this album, personally I don’t think it’s for me. But who knows the more I listen…

Nothing else matters is a great song. The rest I don’t love as much. Objectively Metallica are quite talented, it’s just not quite my thing.

This one surprised be - I did not expect to like this going in. I enjoyed the more laid back songs on this album as compared to the other Metallic albums.

'Enter Sandman' is an amazing track! The rest was good too.

Excited for this one; grew up listening to Metallica & know Enter Sandman & Nothing Else Matters Idk those 2 were great but other than that it’s good but kinda blends together Might be a hot take but I think I prefer Nothing Else Matters w Miley Cyrus

Very overrated. Three decent tracks and the rest just sounds like repetitive noise

Plodcore. BORING.

Kinda hard to rate this album. Really like metallica and this is a classic. But a lot fo the greatness has been really played out over 35 years. And there are some skips for me. 4 stars which feels harsh

-75% of the band were going through a divorce when they made this, and it really shows. This might be the Most Divorced Guy Album ever made. -I came into this listen thinking I would know 3-4 songs, and I actually knew almost the whole album; there's probably 3-4 songs I DIDN'T know. Credit where credit's due, these guys knew exactly the right formula to earn constant rock radio rotation. I sort of enjoyed revisiting these songs, which I hadn't properly listened to in about 25 years. For all the tough guy posturing, these songs are candy coated pop. -I now understand why my metalhead friends see this album as a major sell out moment -- it is insanely overproduced. There's 800 Hetfield voices on every track, tons of studio tricks, and a bunch of buried (uncredited) synthesizers all over this album. -In a lot of ways, Metallica are a VERY funny band. These are some real dumb guys who take themselves so seriously. The lyrics on this album are ridiculous; even if there wasn't a literal Gadsden snake on the cover, you could derive their macho "lone wolf" libertarianism from almost every song. -Lars is an utterly swagless drummer and they STILL buried Jason's bass -- there's probably 2 songs on the entire album where the bass plays a meaningful role.

another record I used to practice to, though there are better Metallica albums

Strong opening track, just as strong closing track. Full of bangers.

Just so good

peak, lowk always the same thing tho, nothing else matters🫪

The beginning of the end for Metallica. If I never hear this record again I’ll be ok.

Incredibly front loaded but listening to Metallica is worth it so you can get a glimpse at how much Metallica fans fucking hate Metallica. Even this one. Especially this one. But not as much as that one or that one or that other one, and especially not as much as that particular one.

Es como Rodrigo De Paul puntuando: Dale pasá boló...10.

It’s not a bad album, but it’s such a marked step down from Metallicas first four and a huge sign post as they transitioned into the Load era. Still some good songs though.

I’m not saying this is bad, I do enjoy some of it. But this is just not what I listen to Metallica for

Not terrible, just not my cup of tea. Overly long too, with most of the tracks indistinguishable from each other. The opener and Nothing Else Matters are decent enough though.

"Enter Sandman" is great but the rest just blends together and is often not even that heavy. This is metal?

Metallica is awesome and I'm really glad I saw them at lolla because I never would've appreciated them

First time listening to Metallica album. I’m positively surprised, I really liked it!! Some of these songs were slower than I anticipated. The whole sound was really similar to ac/dc.

Listened to this at the gym, was a great experience

Hey, you can actually hear Jason Newsted on this one! Honestly just a really good hard rock album - if very commercial. I haven't listened to much of it in a while, but it still hits for me. Some of my favorites: "Sad But True", "Wherever I May Roam", "Of Wolf and Man", "The God That Failed". "Enter Sandman" is overplayed to hell, but still a great song of course.

Boring but would be happy to see live

Lotta heaters at the start, brings back memories of listening to a bunch of them off an mp3 player my brothers mate gave us which was the first time really listening to music that we were choosing to put on, last 4 songs do drag though

llegué hasta god that failed. No quiero decir que sea malo, pero no es mi estilo. EL MEJOR TEMA ES NOTHING ELSE MATTERS

No me gusta el metal, no pude terminarlo. Aun asi tuvo buenas canciones, enter sandman es un banger, the Unforgiven tambien. Si te gusta el metal es un clasico, guitarras fuertes, buena bateria. El bajo flojo, me gusta la voz del chabon como disco 4.1 personal 3.0

Albúm que se siente un punto y aparte en la trayectoria de la banda. Se explora nuevos estilos y posiciona a la banda como una de las principales agrupaciones musicales del mundo. Crea himnos que envejecen bien al paso del tiempo y que hoy en día siguen siendo piezas clave en lo que al Metal refiere. Obras como "Enter Sandman", "Sad but True", "The Unforgiven", "Nothing Else Matters" o "My Friend of Misery", son auténticas composiciones que demuestra la versatilidad compositora de una gran banda como lo es Metallica.

Solid album, liked it a lot. Drums have a very rich, punchy mix, use of a lot of low end in the tracks. Enjoyed the production of it mostly, guitars sound a little scratchy in places for me.

The first song 🔥🔥🔥

Boring, samey, overwraught. Think the problem I have with metal is that it all takes itself so seriously. Music for greasy incels who think life is totally unfair.

I mean yeah this album is awesome. So coherent throughout and just sounds sooo good. There are some absolute classics on here. Liked Songs: "Enter Sandman" , "Sad But True" , 'Hollier Than Thou" , "The Unforgiven" , "Wherever I May Roam" , "Through the Never" , "Nothing Else Matters" , "Of Wolf and Man" , "The God That Failed" , "The Struggle Within"

Great. Iconic. Even though they lost some of the thrash, this was a turning point in rock music mainly because of how huge the drums sound.

Most refined heavy metal album I’ve ever listened to. Simply beautiful, and instantly replayable. Point off for a couple samey sounding songs.

No es mucho mi estilo, pero es impresionante

Mehtallica

I laughed at it, loud, when it came out. What pop music it was after the albums before it - although it has a very strong and heavy sound. Bass is a new guest after ... And Justice For All. Listening to it now I can say I like this album - maybe because their albums after this one are even weaker. Melodies and most of the songs are good, that is how pop music works, but these are all on my pros list. Meowings are not guitar solos. This band is very limited.

nice rock

Сара 5 Марко 5 Један од бољих

Oh god no!!! Awful.

Before this album Metallica was for the grits, Sandman blew up and brought metal to the masses. I was a little familiar with some of their music but never really got into it until the release of The Black Album. It opens with a couple great metal songs, and there are a handful of good ones (mostly the singles) here but overall it is a bit one note. It is a decent album, a bit formulaic, I definitely prefer some of there early work over this one.

Yes, thanks to Jethro Tull for not releasing an album when this came out. Otherwise, we wouldn’t be talking about it… Anyway, it’s not my style of music, but there were a couple of songs that I liked.

I think this album rules *because* it’s the album where Metallica sold out and got poppier. The further metal bands stray away from being metal bands the better they get. this is one of the reasons why, despite both bands having All-Time Assholes in the form of Lars Ulrich and Dave Mustaine, Metallica is fun and Megadeth sucks anyway I listened to this religiously in high school, there’s this fun depressing dark tone to all the songs on here,and I love everything about this album that isn’t Don’t Tread On Me. or the band members because let’s face it they are all kinda turds yes it is kind of adolescent but we were all young and overly dramatic and super into The Unforgiven once, it’s ok for music to be a little embarrassing that way

2nd best and last good one.

круто, класс. Лютый кал

Well, this did nothing to challenge my opinion of Metallica as a band that's boring and annoying apart from the big hits that everyone knows and likes.

Metallica has some undeniably good metal riffs but, man, they don’t know when to end a song and their “ballads” flat out suck. If metal is your thing I’m sure this is a 4 or 5. I gave it as high as a 3 because I get that it’s good for what it is but James Hetfield takes his junior high level lyrics seriously enough that I certainly don’t have to.

Great album. Actually, this album used to be one of my favourites while growing up. I've seen them live 3 times and many of these songs were played. As for this album, there are several really great songs: "Enter Sandman", "Sad But True", "Nothing Else Matters", "The Unforgiven", "Wherever I May Roam" (probably my favourite), "Through The Never", "The God that Failed".. It's difficult to keep the excitement of my first (many) listens of this album, but this is still definitely good. At least 4 stars. Could be 5 stars (and it would definitely be if we skip a couple of tracks). Btw, my favourite album, "Kill'em All" is not part of this project, so I may give it a listen ;-)

I'm sorry but I like it

This is so lameeeeee. I used to like it and didn't get all the critics but to be honest, listening to it as a whole in my late 30s is just a bland experience. The corny intro of Don't tread on me makes me wanna puke. Songs are not bad but all the time that mid tempo for stupid beer drinkers that say "'tallica" is just boring boring boring. Giving 3 stars though due to the huge amount of shit that there's in this list. This record at least has effective songs and a killer production (those arrangements in Sad But True are amazing, despite the song itself).

Opinion: Perfection. Favorite songs: (1) Enter Sandman (2) Sad but true & Nothing else matters (3) Wherever I may roam Overall Album Rating (Pitchfork rating system): 9.5/10

3.5/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/metallica/metallica/ The album with which Metallica 'sold out'. Of course it's not a necessarily bad album; they are (were?) too good a band for that (although later albums were actually bad...), but it's just a bit boring. It's long and very few songs really do anything interesting.

Smiths ahh

Its not my cup of tea but I can see why people that are into this genre love these guys. I mean I like them, I just have to be in the right mood.

Metallica by Metallica is a good album. I liked a lot of the album quite a bit, I think it may be another 5 star. The instrumental was heavy but nice and i like the lead singers voice. You know the album is going to be good when it starts with a song as strong as Enter Sandman. Top three: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, Nothing Else Matters

Not my favorite Metallica album because it’s not flawless but damn there’s some great songs on here. Beyond Sandman, you have bangers like Sad But True, Wherever I May Roam, Of Wolf And Man, Unforgiven, Through The Never and Nothing Else Matters. Metallica took their foot off the gas just enough to go from thrash kings to hard rock gods. This album catapulted them to one of the biggest bands in the world. Fans like me may have preferred another Master of Puppets but hard to argue with where they landed.

This is kind of a hard one to be objective with. I grew up with metal, especially the first 4 Metallica albums, so for a while I had kind of a weird relationship with The Black Album. But I am now at a point in my life where I can admit that this is a really good album. It's also, verifiably, the best selling metal album of all time, and 5 of these songs (Enter Sandman, Sad But True, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, and Nothing Else Matters) totaling about 32 of the 62 minutes here, are immortal hits that still receive *way* too much airplay on rock radio. Now, these are all great songs; *BUT* I really do *not* need to hear any of them ever again. If I wanted to, I could probably hear any of them in full in my head. Thankfully, the deep cuts here are also really good. The dominant sound here is kind of a perfect example of arena metal. These are all thudding, mid-tempo bangers, with strong hooks, interesting lyrics, and great solos. And these draws are maintained throughout this album due to the *very* strong songwriting here. Personally, I'd like to shout out the run from Of Wolf And Man through The Struggle Within for having some of the best songs on the album. It's also very impressive that for how much of a departure The Black Album was, it still *very much* sounds like Metallica. The production is right, the vocals are right, the riffs are right, the solos are right. It's proof of just how successful Metallica was on this album. The band worked with Bob Rock here, and he kind of got Metallica to shave down the 9 minute songs, and write some choruses, and the result was the most popular metal album ever. General overplay here does dampen my enthusiasm here, and you also kind of can't take the first 4 Metallica albums out of me, but The Black Album is still a *really* strong statement.

boring. this can’t be the band everyone was hyping up for metal. i feel nothing from this

am I the only one that thinks this is a banger?

holy dad rock. Wherever I May Roam is one of my favorite songs period god bless

I know and quite like the singles - but rest of album was new to me. On first listen it was quite relentless and fairly joyless. Although it was starting to grow on me by the second listen - which is the most positive response I have had to any metal album so far. Not sure I would readily listen by choice as just not my bag - but beginning to understand it a little.

Metallica Enter Sandman is of course brilliant, a truly great song. I’m of course also aware of The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters Beyond that there isn’t a great deal that sparks much interest, although it's certainly better than the feeble and wretched And Justice For All. As I’m not really into metal I suppose I’m responding to the slowed down tempos, simplified structures and more commercial polish, and it does have some decent songs. But no matter what they do they always feel so creatively and emotionally stunted, in a genre that is broadly creatively and emotionally stunted, that a full album is a bit of a struggle, especially when you add Hetfield’s voice, Lar's drumming and that it is over an hour long. Enter Sandman is great, a five star track for certain, I quite like The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters, and overall it is much better than And Justice For All, but the sense of turgid juvenile heaviness is pervasive, and there’s really not much else to pull it above a 2. ◼️◼️ Playlist submission: Enter Sandman

'Enter Sandman' as an album intro is up there with the best of any hard rock album. A towering contribution to rock (it apparently gets 1 million streams on Spotify per day!). The first three singles form the enjoyable core of the album. Lyrically it's often awkward. Hetfield took some inspiration from Lennon amongst others, and 'Unforgiven' seemed like a 'Working Class Hero' retread lyrically, but disregarding Lennon's caustic narrative for clanky prose. 'Dont Tread on Me' with its "fangs of rage" and instruction "to secure peace, prepare for war" feels like the original incel manual. So three massive tracks, and a bit of good filler, and the rest expendable. Which leaves it the wrong side of three. As for the album cover - how much more black could it be?

Meant a lot to me many years ago. I can’t say that I love it as much as I used to. Not to be “that guy” but I definitely prefer the previous four albums. The thing that’s missing for me is a solid sense of swing, a la Black Sabbath. My nostalgic affection won’t let me rate it any lower than four stars though.

I can't count the number of times I listened to this record back in the day when I was a teen. Absolute classic of my youth, but I don't know that it aged all that well. knowing what I know about heavy music now this was mainly special due to its reach and popularity. Still has some serious bangers but also some that were overplayed to death.

This album was my real introduction to Metallica, it was really Reload, but let's pretend that didn't happen. Similar to Back in Black from ACDC (there, we covered Beavis and Butthead), the singles are inescapable, the deep cuts are not great but fit in with the rest of the album, the difference is that this was hated by OG fans I don't know why. I suppose that before you listen to the album, if you start with Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters does sound like the band completely changed derection, but all their previous albums also have the metal ballad, the so-so hard rock singles, this one is just a slight slant out of metal, nothing compared to the Load-Reload era. Sad But True and Wherever have always been my favorites of the album, Unforgiven is a close next and deep cuts like Of Wolf and Man, God Who Failed and Hollier than thou are pretty memorable, but i'll have to deduct points because of Don't Tread On Me, dumb song, can't stand it. If not for that and a very weak ending, this would be a perfect album. but it goes so strong until 3/4 of the way there, the end is a bit of a let down.

One of the best albums of all time!

The first two tracks are bangers but this album isn't as good as "Master of Puppets" for example.

Thick neck vocals, Iconic riffs, deep percussion= quality thrash. Can see why they got so big, yet can’t believe how big they are.

Classic and for a reason

bom mas algumas musicas pareciam iguais, o album todo é meio *solo de guitarra maneiro* e só enter sandman é a maior

Quality.

This album is the fulcrum where Metallica tipped from a great metal band to years adrift in the hard-rock-meets-pop wilderness, until Death Magnetic and the albums that followed, which are fine, but sound like mere imitations of their peak work from the 80s. The Black Album was so big, and so inescapable that it overshadows what had been Metallica’s signature sound—thrash metal—and replaced it with something slower, thumping, but still very heavy and distinctive. There are maybe three thrash songs here (“Holier Than Thou” “Through the Never” “The Struggle Within”). The rest is still metal as hell, but generally more palatable for normies, particularly in terms of the four big hits it spawned: “Enter Sandman,” “Sad But True,” “The Unforgiven,” and “Nothing Else Matters.” It’s those songs, and “Sandman” especially, that most people think of when they think of Metallica. I realize this sounds like I’m here to bury those songs, but I’m not at all! They’re all great! I’ll also say that I’m not some purist who cares about them crossing over or selling out. For one thing, I was nine when this album came out, so it’s not like I was even conscious of their earlier work. Second, IF the music is good and it gets you the bag, that’s fine by me. I gave up being a punk purist decades ago. And here, the music is definitely good. The slow build of the “Sandman” riff is deservedly legendary, instantly unforgettable, and still hits like crazy. Mount Rushmore riff, that one. And the main riffs on pretty much every song on this album are great, and, as per usual, Hammett makes it seem like he can simply roll out of bed and throw down a laser-sharp solo. They lean harder on the vocal overdubs here, but it doesn’t feel overproduced. Instead, it adds some gravitas to lyrics that might not otherwise warrant them (I’m thinking here of “The Unforgiven” and “Wherever I May Roam” in particular). I also continue to think that their sound benefits from James consciously trying to sing cleaner and with a little less growl (I assume to save his vocal cords) because the man actually can sing pretty damn well. (For this reason, as I’ve commented elsewhere, I think more recent live versions of 80s classics (“Master of Puppets” “For Whom the Bell Tolls” etc.) actually benefit from being less self-consciously growly and metal-y.) This is not a perfect album, nor is it their best album. Some of the deep tracks are really weak. “Don’t Tread on Me” is boring and lame and these days sadly serves as a reminder that these dudes are almost all certainly MAGA chuds. “Holier Than Thou” has an awesome sound but stupid, trite lyrics. “Of Wolf and Man” is a terrible song all around, even though James is probably the closest thing rock ‘n’ roll has to a wolfman. A brief aside --- SONGS ABOUT WEREWOLVES, RANKED 1. Werewolf Bar Mitzvah 2. Wolf Like Me 3. Werewolves of London 4. Being eaten by a wolf 5. Of Wolf and Man All told, I was pleasantly reminded that some of the other deep tracks are actually really great and I had listened to them in a long time. Great album, it deserved to be a big hit, it’s just not, for me, the best Metallica has to offer.

Rode the lightning

How is every single song here good. Genuinely.

This album is really good and I enjoyed listening to it again.

Me sorprendió que me guste tanto

I struggle with this genre. I can appreciate the technical wizardry, and some of the melodies and compositions, but ultimately I'm unmoved by it all. The vocals, the guitars, everything - it didn't affect me. (Listened in the evening, at home)

nunca imaginei que ia gostar tanto de um álbum do metallica assim, sendo de um gênero que não sou assim tão fã, mas aqui tem várias músicas interessantíssimas.

I like Metallica decently enough, here they are really in their element. The guitar rips and the songs really get you moving. It's not something I'd consistently come back to tbh, but the big hits off this are big for a reason. Great tracks, only wish they had a little more differentiation between them. Otherwise pretty good. Fav Track: Enter Sandman

The album that pushed Metallica from a fringy thrash metal band to a metal band capable of mainstream radio. Even though the filler tracks aren't exceptional, the hits are such fucking classics that it pulls the whole thing into classic status.

For some reason I was under the impression that I didn't like Metallica. I was wrong. I do like Metallica. That was a good album. Not all the songs were good. But most of them were good. I had a fun time.

Enter Sandman absolutely rules. (note: if you're ever in the mood to run through a brick wall, listen to the Mexico City version, it's insane. Maybe the best opening to a metal concert ever) However, this album, like a lot of others runs out of steam pretty quick. There are some heaters in there, but I found myself waiting for it to be over a lot of the time.

I only knew "Enter Sandman" before listening to this, and that remains the highlight of the album for me. I didn't realize how much growling there was gonna be. I was expecting to be more impressed with the rest of it, but alas. I laughed when I got to the part where they interpolate "America" from West Side Story into "Don't Tread on Me"

One subplot of this list for me has been reckoning with my lifelong distaste for hard rock and heavy metal. I got little exposure to it growing up and it never hit me viscerally when I did listen to it. So a question going through my mind was would Metallica be like reactionary politics, which I’ve only grown more disdainful of as I’ve gotten older, or maybe like rollercoasters, which I used to be terrified of but now ride all the time? Nah, this shit is music for orcs.

Not my thing

I've never heard of any of them except for the first track. Sorry.

I think Metallica's 1991 self-titled offering is a very funny starting point. Self-titled albums sort of piss me of though, with an exception for debut albums. Was everything up to this point not "Metallica" enough for Metallica and this was when they really felt the stars align? The self-titled practice may also be appropriate for a band deliberately creating the last album they ever will, but I am not aware of any instances of that. The only track I already knew going in was the first track "Enter Sandman." Not without good reason, it's probably the only metal song anyone who does their eight hours in pleated khakis can name before saying something by Guns N' Roses and admitting defeat. The rest afterwards was fine but nothing stuck out to me too much. The start of "The Unforgiven" had a cool western opening that would have been at home in a Clint Eastward western, but then sort of goes into some standard riffs. A pattern in general I noticed here was that each track has a solid and interesting hook but when you open the can it's all spam. Delicious but totally homogenous meat. I can know what people say abou Lars Ulrich and I sort of agree, but I'm not ready to roll out the guilloutine just yet. I'll wait until I hit Metallica again on the six-hundreth and sixty-sixth day before passing divine judgement. I have a bad history of misunderstanding or straight up not comprehending lyrics in my native tongue, so going forward don't expect much analysis of prose and content. That said, I feel like everything here was completely digestible. I like that several tracks seem to be written from the first-person POV of abstract concepts. P.S. Thankful there's an edit feature, even if it's weird. Guess I should write these in a notes app and sit on them for a bit before posting. Just wanted to add that "Nothing Else Matters" is a needed change of pace to break up the album into clean halves, and "Of Wolf And Men" is probably a furry tf anthem or something idk.

I hate Metallica, but it's got the only Metallica song I like on it, Enter Sandman. Maybe the rest of the album will also be good? Well most of it was actually. Still think the lyrics are laughably peurile. And Don't Tread On Me is a load of bollocks. I like this album I think. Still hate Metallica though. Bellends.

You might be labelled a hipster to think that Metallica were better in the eighties before they blew up, but I think the hipsters might be right on this one. After putting out 4 landmark metal albums, Metallica drop the thrash and dumb down their sound for the masses so that even the most inbred hick can get plastered to 'Enter Sandman' and not feel left out! Perhaps I'm being too harsh, 'The Unforgiven', 'Sad But True' and a selection of other tracks are great hard rock staples. I just wish we got more experimentation seeing as they were incorporating progressive rock elements on their previous record and nothing like that is found here. The hardcore Metallica elitists treat this record like the plague and it does not deserve that type of bashing, but I was certainly underwhelmed after listening to this for the very first time in full today.

This was awesome. Could have been a bit shorter

It's a staple of a genre and entire movement. It was always going to be a decent listen

Una maldita obra maestra

The singles are of course tried and true classics. In terms of album-only cuts, its a mixed bag, as some songs didn't stick out to me. Overall, not a bad time/first album, though i'd cut it down a bit as it felt like a bit of a drag at points. Highlights-The singles, Holier Than Thou, Don't Tread On Me(guilty pleasure), and Through The Never.

C L A S S I C - The album that put Metallica into the mainstream music scene. This album has a lot to offer however there are a few pitfalls in this project that most fans of metallica would not have expected to hear this late into their careers. To start, this project is deathly slow compared to earlier works. The complete tonal shift from 'And justice for all..' to this is a big jump. Although this new style isn't horrible, it is noticeable for those looking for more of metallicas thrash sound. With that said this album felt more like a victory lap than another thrash project which is respectable. Given the style of music Metallica made prior to this release goes to show how influential their sound is, it managed to transcend the need for genre labels and unified people under the art of sound. Best song - Sad But True

Very radio friendly rock, verging on metal, but soft when compared to earlier efforts. Less speed more composure,

Cartoonish, corny and absolutely stuffed with memorable songs and just a bit of boneheaded "USA! USA!" warmongering

Not my cup of tea, but I can recognize what an amazing production it has and the deep feelings that can be heard through the album.

The highlights on this album are eternal, obviously. But it's also clearly the turning point when the band moved away from the crunchy, often almost math-y structures of Master of Puppets towards a more straightforward sound. And it just makes me sad! Less polish, more grit please!

not interesting and many of the songs sound the same

This is the first album where I felt that the 'got to listen to it before you die' part was 100% true. Enter sandman, sad but true, holier than thou, the unforgiven, then wherever I may roam. These are just the first five songs in succession. There are established bands whose greatest hits albums have fewer timeless classics than this. Peak.

It's great but the first albums are better.

Mmm meh. The two tracks I already knew are good. The heavy tracks are too heavy for me, not giving me much. Fave Tracks: Enter Sandman, Nothing Else Matters 3.1/5

Aucun mot n'est nécessaire.

Oui, c'est metallica quoi

Metallica qui comprend que le metal est commercialisable, et qui le fait de manière magistrale. La moitié des chansons est géniale, l'autre est dispensable et un album de 40 min aurait frappé plus fort, mais bon c'était les années 90. On apprécie quand même beaucoup. Playlist pick : The Unforgiven

Went into this thinking I hated Metallica. Now there just meh. 3 stars

I love this album. Such good memories. Great energy. The line, 'they say the empty can rattles the most.' always stuck with me. Classic

Staggering riffs, soaring vocals, gigantic drum hits- this is a stone-cold classic metal release. To imbue metal music with this much of a pop sound without losing what makes this band special, with this much care given to a diverse sound (from balladry, to chorus-driven bangers, to slow chuggers, to fast thrash tracks)- there is no denying the power of the Black Album. I love each and every song, and to show that, I'm going to "rank 'em all" here and give a little blurb about why each one works: 12. "The Struggle Within"- military drums at beginning firmly anchor this in the Persian Gulf-era 11. "Don't Tread On Me"- an infectious chorus 10. "Through the Never"- that riff at the end is an all-timer 9. "Enter Sandman"- a classic? yes. but there are even better tracks 8. "The God That Failed"- great bass work and lyrical content 7. "Wherever I May Roam"- sitar intro???? YES 6. "Holier Than Thou"- the pissed-off feeling/attitude permeating from this one has always stuck with me 5. "The Unforgiven"- have always been drawn to the excellent vocal perf on this and 1997's part II in the same series 4. "Sad But True"- it's just so badass- so deliberately dramatic with those drum entrances and insanely well-produced guitar solo work 3. "Of Wolf and Man"- Catchy but still heavy- this one has aged really well production-wise and essentially launched Avenged Sevenfold's entire sound 2. "My Friend of Misery"- that atmospheric section in the middle with the reverb-y guitar laid over the orchestra is just orgasmic 1. "Nothing Else Matters"- a haunting piece of legitimately epic songwriting like no other in the power ballad oeuvre

Bit noisy

All down hill from here haha. Can't deny the hits though.

17.5.2026

Not really my type of music but I can see why this album is so highly rated. The writing is super catchy and the instruments sound great. I probably won’t go back to it much but I still enjoyed my listen for the most part.

Shut up, Beavis.

Alright, I'm going to leave this one short and sweet. Not too short, but shorter than my last Metallica review. Metallica is my all time favorite band. While this isn't my favorite Metallica album, it's still a 5, and I've been dying to roll it. I love when the bot blesses me with two 5 star albums in a row. Yesterday, I got freaking Abbey Road, and now I get the Black Album for my weekend enjoyment. This is the second Metallica album I have rolled for this project, following the also very much 5 star album, ...And Justice for All. Ironically, the black/grey snake with the black background is pretty comparable to Abbey Road, as they're both up there with some of the other all time best, most recognizable albums arts of all time. I'd get it on a shirt in a heartbeat. One thing I've started doing because of this project is listening to entire albums from start to finish instead of just the hits. Now, you might find that a pretty ridiculous thing to say, who doesn't listen to entire albums?? Then you realize we're living in an era where you can just do that very easily with things like YouTube and Spotify. I have nothing to base this on, but I'd say a majority of people listening to music these days aren't going to pop on an entire album if it's at their disposal, they'll stick to the hits. Exceptions are going to be made with new albums, of course, but the premise remains the same. That was a long way to go, but the point is that I am VERY familiar with this album top to bottom already. I've heard this whole god damn album 1000 times from start to finish, and it's all good. Picking a favorite when every song is this good is actually impossible. It would be easier just flipping a damn coin. Nobody shreds quite like Metallica, and no one ever will. The chords are immaculate on every single song, from the hardcore rockers, to the softer but still equally heavy hitters like "The Unforgiven". Of course I'm biased because I grew up with them, so I'm always going to judge them a bit differently, but the fact that I've been listening to this my entire life and I can still turn it on whenever to enjoy myself is emblematic of sheer perfection. Some days I want to jam out to "Enter Sandman", others I'll put on "Nothing Else Matters", but then I have to hear the entire album again. It's not possible for me to just put on 1. I've gotta play the whole album. Do you know how rare that is, even with the albums I've rated a 5?? It's pretty rare. So, I'm not going to pick a favorite for this one, because the whole damn album is already in my favorites. Metallica forever. I think that's good enough for now, until the next one that I give a 5. Man, I'd hate to be whatever album follows this one on my list. I guess we'll find out when I vote here in a second. Will we get the fabled three 5's in a row?? It could happen, you never know.

Listen, I’m a huge Metallica fan. I’ve seen them probably 10 times in 5 or 6 different cities, and my love for Metallica is only topped by the Beatles. I say all that to say this is still the most overrated album in their whole catalog. Fans talk about this thing like it’s untouchable, and for me it just isn’t. In fact, the best Metallica show I ever went to didn’t have a single Black Album song in the setlist. I can still respect what they were doing, though. Going from their proggiest album ever to one built around nothing but radio friendly songs was a hell of a pivot, and sonically it obviously worked. Kirk’s solo on “Nothing Else Matters” is phenomenal, and while I love Rob’s bass playing now, Jason as a backup vocalist is unmatched here. This album also gave us the start of the “Unforgiven” trilogy, which counts for a lot. I’ll talk shit about the Black Album all day, but I’m also not gonna sit here and pretend I won’t jam out when they close with “Enter Sandman.” Favorite song: “God That Failed”

Pretty dam good👍

Sorry but cmon now I love some songs but minus 1 star for being over rated

All time metal album. So many classics and anthems you hear during sports events and pop culture. Some filler songs and Lars Ulrich's drums piss me off but still a great album.

I'm stunned by the number of non-5 star reviews this gets. But then again, it's their first "transition" album, moving from Cliff's pounding bass, to 90s alternative soaked Load. There are two people that don't give this 5 stars: non-metallica fans, and the purity testers of Metallica's original fan base. Stop the virtue signally, and embrace their best work.

i'm big enough to separate the negative associations i have with this album and the people who love it and admit that for the genre - which i generally despise - this is a "great" album.

as someone who is not a fan of thrash metal, this transitional album was welcome to me. Gets the head banging going, just in a more reserved way. The hits are what they are; nothing in the deeper cuts that was memorable to me.

Yessss, finally a metal album!!! Love Metallica

Enter Sandman is 5+ min long? I liked this album better than I expected and less than I wanted to.

Not that into metal but I can see why this album is legendary

It’s all one song no?

My Balls exploded

I'm very conflicted on this album. On one hand this album does have some of their best songs and some absolute bangers, but on the other hand, they kinda sold out and I'm at a point in my life I don't really care much about Metallica anymore. Metallica are a great gateway band to get into metal, but once you're in, you don't really come back to them much. That being said, this is a great album. I think I would give it a 4.5 if I could, because it does go on a tad too long, and the 2nd half has a couple of songs I just don't care about. Low 5.

A classic, not super my taste

Enter sandman and sad but true make for a really cool start to the album, but after that, it’s pretty much just a lot of Metallica, isn’t it?

Metallica clearly rocks hard- especially in this era. I think the thing I appreciate the most is their songs still have lyricality and a certain "catchiness" that you don't always find in metal. Plus their instrumentation is clearly on point. My only critique is it lost a little steam toward the end- the songs started to blend together. Overall- great album with great energy. 4.5/5, not quite a 5

Yes there's better metal albums (assuming this is metal and not hard rock), yea Metallica have better albums, but still - the iconic riffs and crunchy sounds are indelibly etched in my musical identity and sensibility and I can't really go below 4 for this

I don't own any Metallica albums, nor have I ever listened to a Metallica album in full before today, but I have all but two of this album's tracks in my music collection, so I know it well, and really like almost all of them. I think they got some flack when this album came out about it being less thrashy and hardcore than their previous work, but I really love the melodies and harmonies (quote of "America" from West Side Story!") of this album. I listened to it twice. Five stars.

The pace feels a lot slower than I remember classic metal being, and it leans quite a bit more into ballads than I would've expected.

I still dont really like this kind of metal, and are you kidding me? Did every single song have a guitar solo? Even the slow songs. ..

I was one of those people who dismissed this album when it came out as a sell-out album. The song should be long and intricate, and these songs were too short and radio-friendly. I still generally feel that, but I have to say that Enter Sandman is one of the best things they've done and an amazing song. The album goes downhill after that.

Yeah, this is not my jam. Much like Master of Puppets, I got bored fast here. Same old mid tempo chug, predictable drums, same guitar solo cut and pasted throughout. Oh, and sometimes it gets quiet and acoustic! Wow! I just don't get the appeal. Enter Sandman is alright, the rest is utterly forgettable. 1/5

I’ve been looking forward to getting this one! Easily Metallica’s best album, it’s angry, punchy, and deep. Each track sounds similar enough to belong with the others, yet each one is unique and memorable in its own way. I love the strong guitar melodies that just run continuously throughout this album, that’s one of my favorite features in metal. One of my easiest 5s yet

Is a bit long but the classics do hit. 4/5

I'm starting to suspect this generator isn't really random, because I tend to get albums from same artists few days apart. I don't think i like the sound here. I was expecting more after listening to And Justice for All. First two songs have good riffs, but the vocals are just not my favorite aspect of Metallica. And I think I enjoye more the heavier riffs, like song 3. Listen, I like James Hatfield as a character, I really do. But his vocals a consistently ruining the songs in this album. If a better singer was involved in a song like The Unforgiven, for example, it would all be a different story. I think 7 is my favorite here so far. Better dynamics than other songs here. Nothing Else Matters is a very good song. Like it or not, there's nothing you can do about it. Even the vocals work quit well on this one. Nice riff on 9. The three final songs are the best on the album. This is how I prefer my Metallica, more aggressive. I think I enjoyed this one less than and justice for all. It's more predictable and less raw. The riffs don't hit as hard. I think it's a classic 2.5

First album I ever owned. Still holds up all these years later as one of the best ever.

Good album. One of the best heavy metal albums produced.

One of the best metal albums of all time. Every song is a belter. Top production too.

Not my favourite type of music but it’s undeniably good

Not a big metalica guy, but this album bangs.

oui monpapa

Solid pop metal, part of my high school years, with a few solid hits.

Even if you're not in the metal, this is one of the most roundly well constructed elbows of its year. Incredible! Used Harmony. Great production excellent pacing. I used to listen to this album over and over again when I was 12 or so. I would run through Walkman batteries. The screen of my parents. It's equal parts power fantasy and encouragement. Just what a troubled youth would be attractive to. Probably why when Platinum. In either case, I love this album. I listened to the whole thing and thought about going back for a second lap. Perhaps later this afternoon.

An 8.5/10. Pure power. Not every track hits the same, but when it lands, it really lands. A powerful record and definitely one I enjoy coming back to.

No thanks.

The album flows from each song to the next really well.

Really polished metal that saw a shift from the previous speed metal style to pomp and spaghetti western influenced twang. Full of chart topping ambition and catchy tunes that shifted metal landscape when it came out. Just a bit boring in my opinion compared to their early records where things felt a bit less contrived and better to headbang the shit out of.