Metallica by Metallica

Metallica

Metallica

3.76
Rating
30829
Votes
1
3%
2
9%
3
24%
4
35%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 2 of 16)

Album length - long Memorable songs/melodies - enter sandman, the unforgiven, wherever i may roam Could I listen to the album completely - yes Other remarks - lost score because they are ‘apolitical’ now

wow…I did not expect to like this THAT much. I haven’t listened to a lot of metal other than the 2 other metal albums that I’ve gotten on this list so tbh I just expected alot if screaming and blaring electric guitars but no, there was a bit of screaming but overall the singer had a really wonderful voice and there were also some really beautiful melody’s to especially on nothing else matters. And the lyrics…well they were very depressing and melancholic which I’m starting to think is a staple for the metal genre and tbh I don’t mind. But yeah I loved the instrumentals, loved the singing and loved the energy of this album. I never thought I would like a metal album this much but here we are, 5/5

Yes! Landmark album for sure

Iconic, but not my jam.

Absolute classic Does wander a bit in the second half but I feel like that is the case with many classic albums

metallica is always good, not always the biggest metal fan

не найкращий альбом металіки хоча до нього входять легенди пєсні класіка, але я він мені якийсь наче недоконаний і наче чогось не вистачає, є пісні які хочеться скіпнути. 5/10

Fucking rad, great energy throughout - I think I still like Master of Puppets best but this one really nipping at the heels for me. Favorite Track: Sad but true (Sue me!)

God awful band

It might not be this bad, I even liked the first track, but it becomes so brickwalled and repetitive after a while (plus lots of bizarre moments like ballads, weird grunge imitations, the don't tread on me track) and I really cba

Some great tracks. Listen to 3 albums today to catch up, the black album best of the three. Over an hour is a stupid length for an album though, if they cut it down, all killed less filler

Genomgående bra och topparna är några av alla tiders bangers.

Innehåller flera av bandets bästa låtar, men som med de flesta av deras album så innehåller detta för många störigt ointressantal låtar för att det ska gå hela vägen hem. Dock överlag mycket bra!

Banger central.

Отмечали День металлурга в Новокузнецке - порвали три баяна и одну голосовую связку. Но все выжили and nothing else matters

Когда опопсились правильно. Даже если бы на альбоме был только рифф Enter Sandman и 50 минут того, как Ларс Ульрих рассказывает о вреде пиратства, это все равно было бы 5

Бас слышно

начали норм, но потом как-то пошло не туда, первично хотелось поставить выше, НО слишком много проходняка - 4

first time i get an album i already know, a bit more up my alley. know some songs on here, def a classic & genre defining for a reason, but still not my favourite vibe necessarily.

Oof. I was not happy when this popped up. HOWEVER, I was pleasantly surprised. Not a homerun, a little repetitive, but overall, not horrible.

No thanks

La mejor banda de heavy metal que hay y su mejor album, no se puede replicar lo iconico que es esto. 10/10

Yeahhhhh dude

I know from listening to music long enough that Metallica is not my jam, but I'll give it 3 stars (without listening) just bcuz I know that C likes them!

Heavy metal is really not my thing, but I respect the craftsmanship and musical abilities of Metallica.

Bien pero me gustan mas otros albumes del grupo

A staple of Metallicas discography, and an enjoyable one at that. 5/5

The big breakthrough album!!

YEEEEEHHEEEAHHHH

I prefer the older ones

Metallica (both the album and the band's work as a whole) have this magical amazing effect that listening to their music makes you feel badass in literally whatever you're doing. Feeding your cat? Hell yeah. Sending Emails? Hell yeah. Smashing a bunch of twisted alternate-world versions of bats in a transgalactic bridge? hell yeah. And it does so in a way that is in no way "corny". I mean... it's freaking metallica.

Great from start to finish

Solid with a few standouts. Not as good as ...And Justice For All, but still good. Love the guitar intro to Nothing Else Matters....the rest of the song is meh.

Decent Hard Rock Album. Not really that special

Vintage rock

Man, this album was huge for me but it hasn’t stood the test of time.

I thought Enter Sandman was older, like early 80s, not early 90s. The album's okay, not something I normally listen to but it's okay for background music.

DAMN Ts fire. Notable tracks: Sad but True Holier than Thou Through the Never Of Wolf and Man

I couldn’t take this seriously it’s so over the top

inoffensive but not my album of choice

오오 메탈하네

Perhaps the one post-80s metal album I truly enjoyed.

Metal music just isn't my thing. You got some good ones, but most of the songs are too generic and go on for far too long.

There is just something about Metallica that rubs me the wrong way, and this time I'm not even talking about the drums.

YE-HEAHH

Metallica was the first band I ever was a fan of.

Wow! What a cracking album. I’ve never given Metallica much of a chance before having grown up with a family who were staunchly against “metal”. So glad to have finally gotten around to listening properly. I’ll be popping this on at the gym or on the bike for sure! 4.5/5 - fantastic. Just missed out on a 5 because there are other albums I know I enjoy more

Proof that ‘metal’ can be great and have tunes. Bit repetitive though. Still worth a low 3 2.7/5

Not much to say. It's Metallica Good songs, slightly over long

Very pleased I’ve listened to this. Metallica are a band that I thought I’d enjoy the more mainstream singles but not the albums, I was wrong. It gives Led Zep vibes at times and the lead singer has a great voice. 3.7/5

Another completely new album for me and one that's very far outside my usual taste in music. I've never really been a fan of heavy metal, so I wasn't expecting to enjoy this anywhere near as much as I did. However, it's pretty clear why Metallica are so highly regarded, and if this is heavy metal at its best, I can definitely appreciate the genre a lot more than I thought I would! What I found particularly impressive was how cleverly they move between softer, more melodic moments and the really heavy stuff. The way some of the songs build up and then suddenly explode into something much more intense is brilliant, and gives the music a lot more variety than I was expecting. The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam and Nothing Else Matters were particular highlights for me, and I loved how they showed different sides of the band's sound. Rating: 3.5

Classic album, good hits, and good album in total.

Did you ever notice the songs "Sad But True" and "The Unforgiven" both employ the same narrative trick, namely the reveal at the end that this person or being James Hetfield is talking about is "you" or "him" respectively ("I'm you!" In SBT and "That old man here is me" in Unforgiven). It's a very Twilight Zone trick, which tracks for Metallica. For all their reputation of being meatheads, they actually have somewhat nerdy tastes that pop up in their songs. This record is pure, distilled (undistilled?) Metallica. I'd reckon 90% of people who shit on this record in favor as a sell-out album would never have listened to "Master of Puppets" were it not for this. Which, of course, has no bearing on the quality of this album, I'm just sayin'. "Puppets" may indeed be the superior record, but it's sort of apples and oranges. They're both very different and have such different goals that it's sort of dumb to compare the two (in a way it's not dumb to compare any of the four original records, say). Anyway, this record kicks ass. Easy five.

Not really my cup of tea but I see why people are into it

Grande album, sou normie

Im sick of thos shit

Wolf print shirts khaki shorts and no high school diploma, the vibes are great

Tributallica did it better

This is my least favorite out of the Metallica albums that I like, but I can’t deny that it’s a good time

the hits make me smile and make my heart warm but its actually mostly stinky dogshit

I love Metallica and this is such nostalgia for me. I’ve always felt that this album has some certified bangers but also some silly ones that I can never wrap my head around. I respect the shift they made but it will always be where their decline started. 3.5

its the black album

Пахнет юностью и вонючим потом

Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, and Nothing Else Matters on the same album? Iconic.

Really enjoyed, made me think of what my dad would listen to when he was my age. 4/5.

Maybe I’m becoming socialised to all the Metal as I didn’t think this was awful. Never the less I didn’t think it that good either

Flawless. From the first note of Enter Sandman to the end of the album. A pivotal album for metal music. "OhHhH but tHiS iSnT mEtAl" Shut up. Yes it is.

Shit fuckin' rocks.

Pretty great album

Yes, Enter Sandman is overplayed but it is still one of the best album openers of all time. This was my first Metallica album and it is still an all time classic. This is the crossover album that introduced metal to the mainstream.

5 - Duh, this album is awesome.

A weak 3. So much filler.

It wasn’t terrible but it’s just not my thing.

A fantastic album full of widely recognizable songs. The music is crisp and the lyrics are on point. I also enjoy the upbeat tempo of most of Metallica’s songs. The drumming on this album is really, really good. A solid addition to this project.

It’s Metallica. It is what it is. Nothing to shatter any illusions.

Great album from beginning to end. Although I grew up with quite some metalheads in my school, this might be the first ‘metal’ album that I listened to, liked and bought. Mainly because of Enter Sandman. As mentioned in the 1001 albums complains podcast. This is metal you can listen with your mother. It’s less speed than their previous work and maybe too commercial for the more experienced metalheads. But it is so good with a perfect mix of doomy hardrock riffs and great melodies and solos. It’s just a perfect album

Exit light

Last good one from Metallica.

not really for me

Great album, almost all songs are in my playlists. Too bad they became boomers (state of mind, not age).

wow tbh i should get more into metal

Just like some other releases from 1991, Metallica’s Black Album is a turning point—you can still hear traces of the ’80s, but the focus has shifted. Anyone expecting thrash metal back then was completely disappointed, because there’s none of that on *Metallica* at all. Instead, a whole new door opened. Behind it lay (at the time, at least—later, Metallica would evolve more into a pop-rock band) heavy metal, but in a form that was completely new to the mainstream. On “Don’t Tread On Me,” for example, you can already sense Pantera’s riffs—though in standard tuning, which, from today’s perspective, can only be described as cute. But ultimately, this was an effective way to set themselves apart from the Eb tuning of Van Halen & Co. The same applies to the (by the standards of the time) heavily distorted but midrange-deficient guitar sound, James Hetfield’s (again, by the standards of the time) rather deep voice, and, of course, Lars Ulrich’s technically primitive but rhythmically (at the time) quite complex drumming. You don’t have to love this album, but it was definitely a very important milestone!

Maybe I just wasn’t in the mood but god i was not into this AT ALL. Unforgiven was the best i guess.

Two things while I was listening: 1. Wow pretty good 2. Wow I want this to be over

I liked this way more than I think I should have. But then I thought about a conversation I had with one of my coworkers where he told me the music he listened to was broadway and Metallica and at the time I thought he was weird for that... I take all of my judgement back felix. I guess I am also in the broadway to Metallica pipeline.

My dad loves metallica and he must've put it on when I was in the womb or something because this really hit for me. SLEEP WITH ONE EYE OPEN!!!!

not rlly my vibe

“Enter Sandman” - what a banger!! Although overall, Metallica is a bit tooo edgy for me lyrics- and soundscape-wise.

While technically impressive at many points, "Don't Tread On Me" was a real turning point in this album for me—nothing makes me lose interest faster than learning that a band prides themselves on being "apolitical."

I scroll down and see the various criticisms and look, I get it. Lars is a sloppy drummer, this album was a "sell-out", it's one-dimensional etc etc. But my God what an album this is. There's not a weak track on it, and the breadth on display is pretty impressive, not least on "Nothing Else". Saw them this summer on M72 (first time) and when the final section kicks in after 4:50, it feels like all that raw emotion is still just pouring out. Top 10 - it comes with me to the desert island

Klassiker

This was in heavy rotation for me from age 10 to 30. Such a great album, heavy in just the right way.

Initially I remembered this album as a 4/5 but I don't think there's a bad track on the album Great variety, very accessible for metal, just flawless 5/5

Metallica, yksi tärkeimmistä ellei tärkein bändi elämässäni. Tarina Metallican kelkassa alkoi kuudennen luokan syksyllä 1989 kun sain kaverin isoveljeltä C-kasettikopion …And justice for allista. Ja se oli menoa samoin tein! Näin ollen seuraajaa odotettiin kuin kuuta nousevaa. Ja kyllähän se odotus palkittiinkin kasiluokan alkajaisiksi! Tämä osui musiikillisesti hyvin tärkeisiin teinivuosiin joten tämän merkitys on ISO minulle henkilökohtaisesti. Jopa siinä määrin, että tämä levy on tullut opetettua rummuilla jokseenkin iskulleen kuten albumilla. Eli kuunneltu on. Don’t tread on me ja Sad but true ehkä ne isoimmat biisit minulle. Ei ehkä ihan täydellinen albumi enää aikuisen minun mittapuulla mutta helkutin rokkaava edelleen. Vahva 4/5

"Sad But True" is the only halfway decent song here. It is very difficult to listen to this knowing they were such a good band for the three previous albums. Also hard to listen to because Lars is a such a fucking joke of a drummer. He's the Mike Love of metal - the guy who is superfluous and it would by all accounts be better if he were replaced, but he's convinced he's the most important person ever.

Rate: 100/10. They were just a band LOCKED IN with a purpose.

The sandman song is cool but I prefer the other sandman song

I feel like I should have a strong opinion about this, but I honestly don't. It's great heavy rock music and Enter Sandman is a classic and a top-tier rock song, but everything else kind of blended together and was sort of one note. They do their one thing really though. Top Songs: Enter Sandman, Wherever I May Roam, Nothing Else Matters

The Black Album produced by Bob Rock has all their biggest hits. It was a breakout album and was really popular but is it good. I’m not fully sure it great. The big songs are great but the rest are just there. I didn’t care for them. I would want to listen to them. I can listen to Enter Sandman, Sad but True, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, and Nothing Else Matters. That’s a lot of good songs but the rest are just kind of okay. I do not think they were as good as thrash Metallica but you can’t play fast forever I guess.

Fast ne 5

Enter sandman is def the best song on here for me but not really my bag

Uznávam ich prínos pre metalové žánre, ale to je tak všetko.

I'd never listened to a Metallica album before, and I really loved this!

Top album! Life long fan

Boring and corny

Metallica's introduction to stadium rock and the second concert I ever saw.

A pretty alright metal album. Interesting instrumentation and melodies before/after the metal parts, which seems not to be my cup of tea. A strong album regardless.

Some greats on there. But I never felt it flowed together. And some songs I just don’t like

A lot of it sounds the same lol

Couple unreal songs, sounded a bit samey throughout though

This is another classic example of an album that comes so close to having everything, but it just gets held back by that one thing. Like on the one hand, this has some of their most effective writing. Songs like Sad But True and Of Wolf and Man are the classic sound they're known for, but they've learned to slow it down and they wrote some pretty powerful ballads in Wherever I May Roam (I'm counting it) and Nothing Else Matters. But on the other hand, Don't Tread On Me. Favorites: Sad But True, Wherever I May Roam, Nothing Else Matters

This is probably one of the most important albums that shaped my musical journey through life. It came out when I was 16, and up to that point my musical taste had largely been influenced by my parents’ and my older sister’s taste. I had started to listen to more rock, but had always shied away from heavy metal as a bit scary … and then this album opened the gate for me. I loved this album. I had been teaching myself to play guitar for a year or so before I heard this, then once I heard this I knew I wanted to play like James Hetfield. I was asked to join a covers band at school based on my ability to play most of this album, and that opened up a new aspect to my social life. I listened to other bands that were similar, bands that had influenced Metallica or been influenced by them, and my musical horizons expanded dramatically. I saw them live twice in support of this album including the legendary open air gig at Milton Keynes Bowl, which is probably my most “I was there!” moment. This is not the best album in the world, in fact it’s a bit bloated and over long in parts, and it’s not the best Metallica album, not by a long way. It’s not even very representative of what made Metallica one of the biggest bands in the world. But what this album is, for me, is a huge turning point in my life, and a founding document of the person I became, and for that I whole heartedly thank James, Lars, Jason and Kirk. They gave me a place where I belonged.

Патужна, пойдет

Pedazo de discazo. No me gusta mucho este tipo de música generalmente, pero es que este disco es increible. Nothing else matters es una obra de arte. Enter Sandman increible y The Unforgiven también. Con otros buenos temas acompañando. Algunos otros temas son un poco más pesados pero igual no esta tan mal. 9.5/10

Big hits are big hits!

I think it's a good thing I listened to this at the gym. I wouldn't have enjoyed it nearly as much at night in bed. James Hetfield is an amazing vocalist, by the way.

Icónico álbum. Si durara algo menos, es un 10. Tiene hits a reventar, pero algún que otro tema de relleno. Lo que sí me sorprende es que sigue sonando potente y llenador. Clásico total. 8/10

Καλά ριφ κλπ αλλά από ένα σημείο και μετά το αισθάνθηκα κάπως επαναλαμβανόμενο και κουραστικό

Metallica’s self-titled 1991 album is one of those records that feels huge from the very first track. It’s heavy, sharp, and incredibly well-produced, but it also has a sense of melody and songwriting that makes it much more than just a collection of hard-hitting metal songs. What really stands out is how strong the tracklist is. “Enter Sandman” is an obvious classic, but songs like “Sad but True,” “The Unforgiven,” “Wherever I May Roam,” and “Nothing Else Matters” show just how much range the band had at this point. They could go from crushing riffs to quieter, more emotional moments without it feeling out of place. “Through the Never” and “Holier Than Thou” bring plenty of speed and aggression too. The production is a big part of the album’s appeal. The guitars sound massive, the drums hit hard, and everything feels polished without completely losing Metallica’s edge. It’s easy to see why the album became such a major crossover moment for the band and for heavy metal in general. Even after all these years, Metallica still sounds powerful and surprisingly accessible. Whether you’re already a metal fan or just getting into the genre, there’s a lot to enjoy here. A great album from start to finish and probably one of Metallica’s most important records.

I Metallican't listen to this stuff.

I’ve found every person I’ve met who says Metallica is their favourite band to have questionable taste. It’s a lot of banging from a mediocre drummer and a lot of pretend gruff singing and A LOT of repetitive guitar riffs. It’s music for people who want to like metal but don’t want to try too hard. That being said, the Unforgiven isn’t terrible.

Some real all-timers on this one.

Great heavy guitar sound. More straightforward songs but really strong ones. Loved this.

Get rid of the genera, their vocalist, and lead guitarist and they might be worth listening to.

Metallica exploded with this album with a more polished and better-produced version of their sound. The result is not bad, but I miss the epic direction they seem to be heading in with And Justice for All.

9/10 Metallica is an interesting departure for the band. Gone are the lengthy prog-thrash epics and complex compositional works, replaced by a more traditional rock approach to song structure, with an emphasis and focus on central hooks and motifs that often appear across a tracks full length. They also chucked out the thrashy pace and intensity in favour of a slower paced direction, balanced by a weightier production style. I know this album incredibly well already, but listening to it today with a specifically critical ear, I was surprised by quite how slow it is. What that allows for is a sense of groove that wasn’t really prominent in their previous work. It also means that Lars doesn’t have to stretch himself to the end of his talent to keep up, which is nice. What they haven’t changed is their talent for writing great hooks and riffs. Songs like Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven and Sad But True display an ear for catchy songwriting that pretty much lays it at the doors of pop music, albeit through a heavy, pulsing lens. The new production style also offers a more cinematic edge to the sound that gives it a more wide open tone, while also extending the sound palette through a range of effects processes and even the inclusion of a string section for Nothing Else Matters (which is a beautiful piece of heartfelt melodic writing and also probably the definitive metal ballad). With all that being said, I can completely see why traditional Metallica fans often turn their nose up at this record. Essentially what the band have done with this record is to create the Sunday morning cartoon version of themselves. The roughest edges are smoothed off, the hooks are given increased prominence, and the performances turned up to 11, with James Hetfield’s vocal in particular at its most cartoonishly Hetfield. In some ways, this album is to the gritty world of heavy metal what WWE is to bare-knuckle boxing. But while some may consider that to be a weakness, I think that by grabbing hold of an opportunity to make a play for mainstream success, Metallica successfully kicked down the doors of a more underground world of metal and opened it up to a whole new audience, and that should be applauded. So what we end up with is a powerful, heavy and overall fun take on 80s metal distilled into an easy to digest package, while still making enough references to their old work to not completely disconnect. It’s an incredibly solid album and, while it’s a touch too long and there are a few weaker spots, it’s still well worth a five star review, even if it can’t quite make it to a full ten out of ten. Enter Sandman - A classic. Overplayed, yes, but still excellent. The riffs are strong, it feels weighty and powerful and it’s stuffed full of hooks. It’s not the paciest, but it’s so cinematic and the aforementioned weight of the production makes up for the more restrained pace against their previous work. The funny thing is that, looking at this objectively, there’s an almost cartoony edge to it with the subject matter and Hetfield’s throaty chuckles, but I’m totally buying what they’re selling regardless. A brilliant opener that sets the tone for what’s to come. Sad But True - Again, the power of this is in its weight. There are some fantastic riffs and the underlying groove is great, with some cool rhythmic switch-ups in places. The chorus is great too. The main thrust of this song is just built for slow headbanging with a stank face. There’s nothing vastly complicated or adventurous about it, but it does exactly what it promises with great quality. Holier Than Thou - They pick up the pace a bit now and lean more into swagger and attitude without letting go of the riff quality and hook writing chops. They throw in a bit of range with the guitar solo sections, but it’s another brilliantly executed example of simplified songwriting that has enough quality to keep you engaged despite the relative lack of development compared to their previous releases. The Unforgiven - And now we roll into an intro that feels heavily inspired by Ennio Morricone’s Ecstasy of Gold, which Metallica typically use as intro music at concerts. It’s got great dynamic and textural range to it and it’s a nice step back into groove and power, with a cinematic approach to the production and arrangement. Again, great riffs, and more of that face-wrinckling drive and weight in between the more restrained and subtle sections. The melodic chops on this record are actually one of its biggest strengths up to this point, but there’s an extra bit of that cartoonish charm from James Hetfield’s vocal style. It’s good stuff. Wherever I May Roam - There’s actually a decent amount of range and textural interest on this track in a way that the more straightforward tracks on the record have avoided thus far. We do get a bit of Lars Ulrich’s more staccato, machine drum fills here, but I’ll forgive them for the general groove that they build in the rhythm between his straight drum performance and the bit of swing generated by the bass and guitars. It’s a brief but anthemic chorus and, as with much of the record, the cinematic nature of the production is great. Don't Tread On Me - Why not kick off a metal song with a riff from West Side Story? Again, this is fairly slow but oh, so heavy. Great riffs, a cool swagger and more great attitude across the board. There’s something so fun and engaging about this in that it kind of feels like they’ve stripped out the complexity of their music and distilled it into a simpler format, but it’s still pure Metallica. It’s hard not to get on board with the weighty punch of it and, while it’s not musically spectacular, it still ticks a lot of boxes. Through The Never - There’s more range to the pace of this and we get something that starts to approach a more traditional Metallica thrash style in places here. It chuggs along through the slower sections and then when it picks up the pace, they smash in some more great riffs. There are some solid rhythmic stops in the composition that give an extra bit of punch too. This feels a little bit more compositionally adventurous and it’s nice to have something that does a little bit more at this point on the record, while retaining the cinematic feel of the rest of the record. Nothing Else Matters - Time to be objective about the song that my wife walked down the aisle to? Fuck that. This is a gorgeous song that showcases the deftness and melodic quality of James Hetfield’s songwriting. It still has a decent punch to it, despite the focus leaning more towards the melodic. There’s great dynamic range, a heartfelt vocal performance and, despite it having a distinct waft of cheese, it’s executed so perfectly without losing the Metallica edge to the sound that it’s hard not to just get caught up in. It’s probably one of the finest examples of a metal ballad ever committed to tape. Of Wolf And Man - How do we follow that, Lars? How about I hit the drums really hard? Ok, do that then. From a very straight beat, they build a really good groove actually. I think the progression of the chord structure and melody in the chorus is great and quite different from some of the more straightforward riff focused sections on the album. This is not as hook heavy as some of the early record, but it feels like it’s a bit more interesting from a compositional point of view, while again retaining the punch and weight that the album has kept at the forefront. The God That Failed - Weight and punch. The two key words for this album, and they’re here in force again. The swagger and groove of this is what sells it completely because, looking at it objectively, this is probably one of the weaker tracks on the album, but it’s still so full of chugging quality and attitude. There are some great rhythmic choices in the vocal that give this an extra bit of range, especially set against the chugging guitar work. More great stuff. My Friend Of Misery - It’s a really nice bit of bass work to roll us in to this one. As with some of the other later tracks on the record, there’s a bit more development of themes here, although they don’t stray too far. There’s a nice breakdown in the middle and the cinematic flavour of the production add an extra depth of quality to the work. The texture of the different guitar tones rubbing up against one another is pretty cool, although I’m not completely sold on the guitar solo tone about two thirds of the way through. The Struggle Within - And we close off with something that calls back to the pace of previous Metallica records to show they’ve still got that arrow in their quiver. The vocal hooks are top notch, especially the call and response stuff, and we get some more quality riffs, all delivered with the bottom end weight that this album has delivered in spades. I love it when they peel off into the solo section on this one, just with how committed they are to the pace and power of it. It’s just great fun.

saw them live with my brother in 2023. I liked this album more than I thought | would.

Classic album all around. Trasher fans or whatever accuse tallica of going mainstream with this one, but Hetfield couldn't sing on the other albums and this is just better music. But yes, tallica is corporate tame metal. They're not wrong there.

Amazing rock album

A transition album for metallica away from the pure thrash. But still hugely influential in the alt-metal and hard rock genres

A very polarizing album in the metal community. A huge shift in style that payed off well for the band. The black album lacks what made Metallicas early albums great, but were it not for its success, those earlier albums probably would not be as well kmown and as highly regarded. It is a great introduction inti the metal world. In a bubble, it is a good album. It falls short when compared to wgat came before it

I'm not generally a fan of Metallica, and that sentiment has strengthened over the years, but goddamn this one slaps. Start to finish, this one is a masterpiece. Hits all over this album,, and it can still get the adrenaline pumping. Well recorded, musicianship and theatrics on display, hats off to them for this.

Metallica (1991), das „Black Album“, ist pure, monumentale Präzision. Jeder Track sitzt wie ein Stahlträger: „Enter Sandman“ ikonisch, „Sad But True“ schwer wie ein Presslufthammer, „The Unforgiven“ emotional und perfekt gebaut. Die Produktion ist glasklar, die Songs zeitlos – ein Album, das Metal nicht nur definiert, sondern global geöffnet hat. Mit „Nothing Else Matters“ zeigt die Band eine ungewohnte, fast intime Seite – ein Song, der Metallica endgültig aus dem Genre-Käfig befreite und weltweit zu einer der größten Rockbands machte 🤘🏽.

Not only was this one of the first albums I ever owned, it was absolutely foundational in building my musical identity. I was learning guitar at the time and you better believe I spent some hours learning these riffs. Although I love all kinds of music, there was a period in my life where I was a dyed-in-the-wool metal head and this album is probably the primary reason why. Even listening today, 35 years after release, this album feels immediate, alive, and absolutely essential.

Classic album, very very easily cements itself on the list. For some reason I, not a metal head, always quote the lists to Nothing Else Matters, so that means something.

This album has one of the best intros of any album, but it kind of falls off after the first song. Nothing Else Matters is still a good song, but honestly, I think I fell for the hype. I'm not the biggest fan of Hetfield's vocals or how he uses his voice (which is common in this genre), and that takes away from what otherwise would have been an awesome album. The album does drag a bit, but otherwise it's not bad.

Nisu mi se svidjele samo dvije pjesme. Ostale su bangeri(s obzirom na to da sam vec poslusala dvije).

It's an historic album. Metallica just can't be 5-stars though.

A monster of a record. Yeah, the gagillion-selling Black Album is played to death, but that’s not really the band’s fault. These songs have become the DNA of hard rock, and knowing them, playing them on guitar, rocking out in the car, is as much a right of passage as graduating high school. Shorter songs, paired down solos, actual choruses, and fuller production make this maybe the most successful crossover/sell-out record of all time. The song quality meant Metallica didn’t lose its base fans, and the switch from thrash metal to hard rock introduced heavy music to a generation. It’s my fifth favorite Metallica album, but really is one of the very very few “time-capsule” type records that is genuinely an essential cog in the American cultural experience.

Positives: Bass and drums on Enter Sandman rip. Way downhill after first song. All very familiar and slightly nostalgic. I never liked Metallica, but I had a roommate and good friend who loved it. So not all bad feelings. Didn't hate "My Friend of Misery" sounded slightly different at least. That's about it. Negatives: This is over an hour long, way too much, could have been an email. Hard to imagine just listening to this back to front in any normal context. Mostly soulless pop-metal A lot of these songs I think are going to be cool for about 20 seconds then I'm just waiting for them to end. Never liked Hetfield's voice or style, still don't 2 Stars, barely interesting to note that I'm in a phase where I'm pretty into "angry" music, but this doesn't move me at all.

This is an album whose relevance lies in containing some of the most significant hits in the band's discography. To that end, it remains a meaningful record but its longer runtime makes it feel a little one-dimensional and flat compared to earlier records in their discography. For that reason I might prefer 'Ride the Lightning' as a more enjoyable listen. 8/10 [KEEP]

This album transformed my youth

Still an amazing album that came out in a year of amazing albums. The world changed at that time meaning Metallica could get airplay without compromising their sound.

Oh ffs, not another one…I just picture a goatee cunt in a Land Rover defender who likes to lift occasionally because they feel emasculated by the dysfunctional family they’ve created. It’s just the most overrated shit ever isn’t it.

Olkoot kuinka mainstream tahansa nii olihan tää loistava albumi

Aivan absoluuttinen legenda. Erinomaista musiikkia alusta loppuun. Olen tietoinen Lars Ulrich hate-liikkeestä mutta itse ihmisenä joka ei ole ala-asteen jälkeen rumpuja soittaneena tietoinen mistä vitusta puhutaan vaikka olen asiaa yrittänyt selvittää joten en voi alentaa siitä pisteitä. Haluisin antaa 5/5 mutta en tiedä ansaitseeko tämä sitä. Mulla ollut kriteerinä että ansaitakseen täydet 5/5 sen pitää olla minulle jotenkin oikasti säväyttävä kokemus. Myöskin pitää olla jotenkin merkityksellistä musiikkia. Yksikään rap-albumi ei tule milloinkaan saamaan täysiä pisteitä, koska sama konsepti on toisettu jo tuhansia kertoja ja kaikki sielu on lähtenyt musiikista. Kanye West on ehkä ainut poikkeus mikäli sellainen tulee joskus vastaan. Tulin tuon tekstin kirjoittaneena tulokseen että asaitsee täydet pisteet. Musiikki erinomaista, kokonaisuus hyvä ja albumi ylipäätään on ollut aika merkittävä trash-tyylinen albumi ja pioneeri skenessä

Disappointing. Birth of butt rock? YAE-YUH!

So familiar that I actually can't tell where this fit in the history of modern rock. Was this genre altering or just a really strong entry in a bunch of good music? I wish I knew.

Surprised to see this here, after Master of Puppets. There are some memorable--even iconic--songs on here, but overall it lacks the ferocity of their prior albums, especially MoP. This album includes their first power ballads (Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters), and the overall production feels more like a Def Leppard album than a garage metal band. That's not to say this is a bad album per se, it's just not what i want out of my metal. It's probably more influential on the Nu-Metal that would rise in the late 90s than MoP is.

Very very produced. Very clean and minimal. Reminds me of Nickelback in that way. I'm not very familiar with either of these bands however

Overplayed, overwrought, and thoroughly overcooked. This is a band trying to be as big and four quadrant as metal could be and in the process watering down what made them good in the first place. Sure, some of these are classics, but it's because they're radio-ready anthems that could match up to the incoming grunge scene and disaffected kids. But these dudes are getting too old for that shtick, and instead it's absolutely watered down, thin, terrible-sounding dumb rock music that has the faintest claim to metal. And it's effectively the end of Metallica - they'd never get back to their heights after this one, because they'd been pegged in this hole. Charmin soft.

Not for me

A couple of great tracks, a couple more good ones, but I don't much like the rest. I just can't get on board with James Hetfield's vocal mannerisms-ah. Enter Sandman is an all-time banger, though, and the only Metallica song I seek out of my own accord, so I can never fully dislike them!

Surprisingly better than I anticipated. I’ve never really given Metallica the time of day, categorising them with all the post-original heavy metal groups that fail to live up to their forerunners. This was powerful stuff though and just shows how inferior their contemporaries such as yesterday’s band, The Black Crowes, were. The thumping bass and percussion kept my attention and the voice often reminded me of Alice Cooper who I’ve always got time for. Reading that this was a change in style to their earlier thrash metal sound may be the reason I like it and also why I had already written them off before this was released. They were even able to produce a softer, slower song in Nothing Else Matters which featured the LSO and at the start reminded me of when Black Sabbath did Changes. I thought the album could have ended there as the final tracks were not as good as the earlier ones. However, on second listen through I liked them a little more. In the main it’s good old-fashioned head-banging stuff which I enjoyed a lot. Think I will have to reassess my previous prejudice and eat humble pie now as I certainly want to hear more Metallica.

I know I should hate it but I don’t! Hetfields voice is a bit much and the lyrics are cringey as is the whole band really but there’s something about Metallica that is just so enjoyable. I also think they are quite talented musicians (I’m not musically talented in anyway so perhaps not the best judge of this!). They are insanely uncool and I do think some of the joy of this record is how seriously they seem to be taking themselves. Much like the vibes from the Metallica Documentary (Some Kind of Monster) which I also enjoyed. The fact this record was made 7 years after Spinal Tap makes me think they may be in on the joke a little but probably not!

'Chug chug', said the guitar. 'Boom boom', replied the drum. In walked James Hetfield. 'Heavy thoughts tonight, and they aren't of Snow White-AH'. Somewhere in the future, a man winces, adjusts his earphone, wonders why he's putting himself through this. He sighs, fetches a cup of tea. Come on, he thinks, be open-minded, lots of people like this, find out why. Track 2 begins. 'Chug chug' the guitar repeats, 'boom boom', the drum dutifully replies. 'You know it's sad but true-AH', Mr. Hetfield gurns. Back in the future, the man has made an effort, and he will do the due diligence and hear the rest of this nonsense, but deep within him another slight fracture cracks across his soul, another hour of existence lost to this torment. His mind wanders, as it often has throughout this process...why does this exist? Who needs to preen and pose like this? Why are guitar solos so boring? How can we all be essentially the same creature, and yet have such vastly different ideas about what is a 5 star album, and what sounds like the inane ramblings of brainless cretins? 'Chug chug', the guitar offers. The man sighs, buckles up, endures another 45 minutes of misery.

I tried to like this because of an alt girl I had a crush on when I was 13. Couldn't do it then. Can't do it now...

Great metal what can you say.

Preemient metal band. One of their best albums. Few great songs. I don't need to listen to this album again. Pitchfork: 7.7 Rolling Stone: Top 500 Albums #235 Best Songs Enter Sandman The Unforgiven Nothing Else Matters

The lyrics + delivery got me cringing. Even if I were an edgy teen in the 90s I wouldn’t fall for this crap. An album full of “badass”, god awful entrance music, one note and repetitive, until the momentary reprieve of Nothing Else Matters, followed by 20 minutes of unintelligible bullshit. I will say, I was jamming a bit during the guitar solos…until the guy starts singing.

A monster album from my teenage era - and a solid classic.

I liked the singles as a 13/14 year old boy when this came out, especially Enter Sandman. I thought I'd be rating this higher but it sounds kind of corny now. I can't help be see Lars Ulrich's stupid face and feel his stupid personality when I hear his shitty drumming. I hate the snare sound, it's too gated... Sounds like a crappy drum machine. Anyways, doesn't hold up for me

i actually think this is a good album. the guitar solos are amazing. the way they go faster and then slower means they're actually connected. the only thing i will say is that the songs might be too long just because the last minute and a half of each song is basically the same repeated one time and another. it gets kinda boring just for that. but, as i said, i really enjoyed it and there are some songs i loved!

they're famous for a dman reason sadly. -1 point bc they kind of suck morally n stuff

literally just awesome

a few classics but honestly thank goodness it's over. enter sandman and nothing else matters are too good to give sub-3, but to be quite honest judging by the album as a whole, this is a 2. so actually, that's what i'm giving it. with the caveat that those two songs are 5/5s.

I don't need to hear this album again, mostly because I can hear it in my head just by looking at this cover. I played the shit out of this album growing up, and through my teenage years. It's an incredible album, but at this point, I'd rather discover something new.

What a fantastic classic album full of bangers! Say what you will about Metallica but this is a fucking legit album that changed their trajectory and metal on general

Another one of my soundtracks to a period in my life. Summer of 1992 - had it going non-stop on cassette in my car. Enter Sandman and Wherever I May Roam are my favorites, and a couple of others are decent. I'm not much of a Heavy Metal fan, and really wasn't a Metallica fan either. Not sure why I had this, as it wasn't my cup of tea at all, but different times and places.

Ah takes me back 🤘

I ant listened to this since I was about 15. I can appreciate it for what it is but I'm not likely to bang it on anytime soon.

Didnt even realise it was Black album. Yeah takes me back to me formative years ...NEVA! Has the right amount of slow prettiness with Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters, which earliwr stuff can be accused of lacking Album to get into Metallica... using (?) Never liked 'Dont Tread On Me' and 'Struggle Within'. So cant give it 5. 4.5

Favourite Track(s): The Unforgiven Nothing Else Matters

🙂‍↕️

Liked the songs

Coming from someone who thinks Metallica is overplayed and a little obnoxious, I didn't expect to enjoy this as much as I did. I'll never forgive Lars for being the face of the anti-Napster movement, but I have to give credit where it's due: this is one of the most approachable metal albums out there. I started listening to this in 5th grade and thought I was going to become a metal fan because I liked this album so much. Turns out, I'm not a big fan of metal at all. Listening to it now, I don't know how much of it is nostalgia, but this album holds up surprisingly well and is still a fun listen.

Good, I mean, theres a reason it is so well listened to. Not the kind of thing I'd normally listen to an I will prolly never listen to ever again.

They certainly set a standard. Never been my kind of music.

Sé lo mal recibido que es este disco hoy en día, el cómo es una "regresión" de sus discos de thrash pero para mí, fuera de ser un poco repetitivo con los últimos tracks, me es mucho más disfrutable que sus predecesores

Enjoyed this way more than I was expecting to

Næsten S tier. Udover Sandman og Nothing else matters (som er lidt overspillede) har albummet kæmpe bangers som Sad but True, Unforgiven, Wherever I may Roam. Alle instrumenter er super tydelige at høre, og James er på sit mest ikoniske niveau. Eneste der trækker ned er nogle lidt svage sange i form af Struggle within og Don't tread on me. 4,5, som må blive rundet op

Man, it's been ages since I've listened to this album in full. Playing it back, it's okay. Obviously we all know it as the turning point in the Metallica catalogue, but some of these simpler tracks still hit - "Wherever I May Roam" and "Sad But True" still fucking rip. On the lesser side, "The Unforgiven" has always been boring and will still be boring. I found myself enjoying "Nothing Else Matters" more than I remembered in the context of this entire album. The deep cuts are all pretty decent, and a few of them harken back slightly to the Metallica that came before this, but Pandora's Box had already been opened and there was no going back. I think it's fine, but runs long considering how many songs are based on one riff.

I’m not even a Metallica fan but even I have to admit they struck gold here. One of the best metal albums of all time.

The opening of the album is so strong with the famous "Enter Sandman" followed by "Sad But True", which was probably my favourite song on the album. I also really enjoyed the rest of the album ("Nothing Else Matters" and "The Unforgiven" being some other standouts), but I'm not sure if I would listen to these other tracks as standalone listens rather than part of the full album. I'm giving it a rating of 5 as I think this album would grow a lot on me over time based on the strength of my first impression.

Très cool

Listening to this since I'm 11 so know it like the back of my hand. Wouldn't put it on much these days but it's a landmark in hard rock/metal, some classic tracks which have crossed over into the mainstream. Sandman, Nothing Else Matters, Unforgiven, Sad but True all hold up still. Few songs which don't hit the same heights and I've never been a huge fan of the closing track but the album hangs together as a coherent end to end listen. The slicker Bob Rock production was a departure at the time but it suits the songs. Plus you can actually hear the bass on this compared to Justice. Hard to mark it down as anything bar a classic. 9/10

Liked it better than I thought i would. Catchy enough songs but it gets a bit repetitive.

Gran album antes del declive

kestää ja kestää ja kestää

Sadly already listened amazing album

god i hate metallica

The gateway Metallica album.

Better Metallica albums

peak metallica!

jaki vibe

bro cmon its metalica ofc its really good

Not bad, not their best but I prefer the thrash stuff (Ride..., Master...)

Oh yeah!! So frickin good!!🤘 One of my favorite albums. Never gets old. Great workout music also.

This review is going to be heavily influenced by altitude brain death. I had heard this whole album before and didn't know it. The vocalist has way more range than I would have given him credit for. Long songs but stayed dynamic and new pieces and lyrics. My Friend Misery was the only one that didn't grab me and was a bit weird

I thought this would be a "Meh" because of over-play of their hits but surprisingly listening to the whole album at once was actually entertaining! So kudos for including this on the list (obviously)!

This album is good. It was written before there were words, writing, or the stars. My highs: - "Enter Sandman" intro - "Unforgiven". Esp if you have speakers up loud and there's a moment of panic at the beginning like 'is this noise gonna keep getting louder and explode my eardrums?' - "Nothing Else Matters" is an island of tranquility in a sea of songs with electric guitar, drum bashing, and Hetfield ayy--yyeyaaaauhhhs!

Not Metallica's best work. They simplified after Justice, but this is still a ripper. Greatest guitar riff of all time here. That's not nothing.

Good album - abit heavier rock than I normally like but enjoyed it. 2 iconic rock songs on this album so it's a 4/5

I didn't hate this, however I don't think I'd make an active choice to listen to it again. But if my partner decided on this for our dinner party background music, I wouldn't object.

Limp lettuce? Maybe that is a little too unkind, fellow listener. Overproduced and commercialized for sure. So much less enjoyable than others - I love Puppets and have a soft spot for Justice based on when I started carrying around a walkman. Definitely some gateway drug material here to introduce the average listener to the older, better material in the catalog. I still would like to see the live despite my being 50+. 3.8

It's meh, but also a classic.

Rock on 🤘

One of my most played/ favourite albums growing up. Maybe hasn’t quite aged as well as I might have thought but still a momentous album with no real duds on there.

Amazing album, already listened 8.5/10.

One of the first albums I ever listened to, certified classic. PF: Unforgiven

A good rock album for its time, even if my tastes have moved on.

To be honest I had a lotta expectation yk cuz it's metallica and I loved tracks like enter sandman, unforgiven, holier than thou, sad but true yk the vocals, guitar riffs and stuff. It's peak but then after that for me it was a downhill like i just wanted to finish this album yk. Maybe this one will grow on me yk. I also liked the nothing else matters track. But yk other tracks felt medicore to me. I noticed this album has a lotta guitar playing, drums, and stuff which is nice but yeah overall felt medicore. But I don't think this is the end maybe it will grow on me. I'll give it a 5.5 tbh

Dios q discaso la verdad, Dios bendiga metalica

Pretty good but not my cup of tea

some of it is good

Their last good album before they leaned to heavily into alt music. I prefer the 80s thrash to any of this, but this album is undeniably one of their best.

Pop songwriting chops with big slow groves. What’s not to like?

I’m very biased, since this was one of the first albums what and really introduced me to heavy metal. It was the gateway for me to discover the older Metallica and other thrash bands. With this album the pendulum swing a bit too far from the roots of the band. But I can’t say there are any real skips on this and the singles they released are all iconic.

no es mí onda pero banco, se nota que es un buen disco de metal, ahr que no sé nada de metal.

I don’t like metal music as a general rule. That being said, this is an iconic album from the 90’s (my teens), and it totally rocks.

Ich habe damals das Album rauf und runter gehört, eines meiner Lieblingsalben von Metallica

Full of bangers. Not their best but there’s a reason this album was so popular - not a bad song on the album

Fine album.

Love Metallica!! This album had all my faves on it

My first love. I was 9-10 years old when an older boy, living on my street, played Enter Sandmann. I was sold. I know this album by heart, even if I haven't listened to The God that Failed in 15-20 years I still know the lyrics. It may be nostalgia, but this was a lock for 5☆ from the moment Enter Sandmann began.

Don’t think I care about Metallica. RYM: N Saved a song: N

Very solid, with some tracks that are undeniable classics – but classics to which I don't have the same level of attachment that some other people do, since I didn't really grow up with them. Still a hell of a good time.

I guess I just don't rock hard enough for this, but I found a lot of the songs too samey. Favorite Songs: Enter Sandman, Wherever I May Roam

Great production, great melodies, great solos, drums sound thunderous, Het's voice never sounded better than here. There's a couple of clunkers and I never need to hear Sandman again as long as I live but it's overall a mainstream metal smash. Proof an 'extreme' genre can break through to the masses. Is it Ride/Puppets/Justice? No. But it's not trying to be. Also My Friend of Misery is the best song on this album, fight me.

Mixed bag. Some really bad stuff and then a couple of bangers and an influential sound

I'm not one of those Metallica fans that sees this as a "sell-out" album. It's an evolution of their sound. It's pretty successful for the most part. I'm on record as not being a fan of a couple of the bigger hits on this (Sad But True and Wherever I May Roam in particular), but the rest holds up pretty well.

This album brings me back to early high school and the shenanigans I got up to on their binge and purge tour in 1994

If I could give a 3.5 I would. Good album for sure, but it isn't really my type of music. Couple of great classics on there too.

677/1001 2026.08.11 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕

There are better and worse choices than this album to represent this band, this seems to be a common theme of the list.

1991: what a year in popular rock music! This, Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Gn'R, Soundgarden, RHCP, U2, R.E.M. all with classic or near-classic albums. The first CD's I ever purchased were Stevie Ray Vaughn's The Sky Is Crying and this album, from the Sam Goody in Town and Country Mall. The cover was so badass - you couldn't see the snack unless you angled it just so in the light. This album was the gateway for me into earlier Metallica like 'Ride the Lighting' and '...And Justice', but I never quite latched on to the speed metal. This self-titled album was the sweet spot with it's moderate tempos and huge hooks. 'Metallica' was a bold swing for the mainstream fences that wildly succeeded on the back of 'Enter Sandman'. Plenty of other good songs on the album, but Sandman's sinister riff coupled with it's haunting dream imagery made for the perfect translation of metal's anguish to a Rock-Pop idiom. Even bolder, 'The Unforgiven' comes in shockingly early at track 4 sounding unlike anything else the band has done, with it's Morricone-light stylings and nylon string guitars. I was personally inclined to like 'Wherever I May Roam' with it's epic and majestic intensity. And of course, boldest of all, 'Nothing Else Matters', with nary a growl in sight, a string arrangement and which every burgeoning pre-teen guitar player soon learned was easily played with open strings. Otherwise, like most albums in the CD era, it could stand to lose 3-5 tracks. The production wears thin after awhile - there's too much reverb and the drums are too big for these tempos. The bass drum is practically the lead instrument, even on the ballads. Listening back now, what's jumping out at me the most is how emotionally vulnerable the lyrics and vocal performances are. Hetfield is clearly working through some demons and unafraid to show his sensitive side. It's the boldest aspect of the album and underscores what a risk this direction was for the band. It sure as hell paid off, even if they would soon take it a bridge too far.

Era destino il doverlo ascoltare...

black snakey boi turns out it's a good album doesn't feel like "metallica" though, can see why it was polarizing but also massively successful not as much gold as i remember tho back half in particular drags a bit 💥enter sandman 💥the unforgiven 💥wherever i may roam 💥nothing else matters

An excellent album. I knew most of these songs already but the way they are linked together in the album is incredible. The benchmark for metal albums, although it is probably just as much a rock album.

So many thoughts…. Influence: 5 stars Songwriting: 3 1/2 stars … the good is great, the rest is between “standard” and shit Performance: man, Lars really isn’t very good. And a lot of the solos are bland. Overall: this album has gotten worse and worse every time I’ve listened to it. 3 stars. I could live the rest of my life and never hear a song off it again.

It was okay, but I believe there's a reason that the only song anyone knows from this album is Enter Sandman. If I were rating albums on song titles alone, though, this album would get 5/5.

very 'clean' metal, but not in a way it would ruin the sound and experience of the album

Really didn't like this first time around, but it's actually quite good. The album is extremely front loaded, all the bangers are on the first five tracks or so. The album tracks here are all decent, but not really anything to write home about. Still, just having such classic hits right after one another gives it some bragging rights. It kind of represents the downfall of what Metallica would eventually become, but for this release they were still making pretty decent commercial Metal. I guess helping Metal out of the underground isn't all that bad.

I came to The Black Album expecting to endure it. My mental image of Metallica remains two men in a pawn shop shouting at each other while occasionally throwing guitars. What I wasn’t expecting was an album largely concerned with making itself understood. The word I kept coming back to was legibility. This is the record where Metallica simplify, but simplicity isn’t necessarily the same thing as dumbing down. One dominant riff can give an actual song room to emerge. The vocals are front and centre. The structures are clear. There’s an almost pop instinct at work: if you’ve got something to say, don’t hide it behind another six riffs. And they do have something to say. Sad But True is about the shadow self, the psychological permissions we construct to do things we’d rather not admit to ourselves. Holier Than Thou turns towards judgement, gossip and received certainty. Then The Unforgiven does something particularly clever: the verses are oppressive and heavy while the chorus opens out. It reverses the usual rock-ballad grammar. Once you’ve decoded it, it seems obvious, but somebody had to think of it. Gradually I began hearing the album as a journey towards self-determination. Don’t Tread on Me nearly derailed the whole thing for me. I cannot stand that strain of Boys’ Own metal: heroic individualism, flags, slogans and the conviction that having a very large sense of yourself constitutes a philosophy. My rating briefly plunged. Then Through the Never comes along and almost acts as a corrective. It reminded me of Powers of Ten: zoom out and this heroic individual is an infinitesimal dot in an incomprehensibly large universe; zoom sufficiently far in and he’s mostly interatomic space anyway. Get over yourself. Then Nothing Else Matters brings everything back to the personal. For all the songs metal has produced about women, there’s something unexpectedly affecting about a man simply admitting that another person matters to him. The road towards being comfortable with yourself sometimes includes admitting that you need somebody else. At this point I started thinking that Metallica had been through therapy. The God That Failed makes that particularly explicit once you know about James Hetfield losing his mother, a Christian Scientist who refused medical treatment for cancer. The lyric stops sounding like an articulate teenager berating religious parents and becomes something much more specific: someone trying to make sense of a loss he believes needn’t have happened. My Friend of Misery may contain the most interesting idea on the album. People can become evangelical about their suffering. Misery can become identity. I’ve encountered versions of that in peer-support work: when everything eventually becomes okay, what happens if you’ve become emotionally dependent upon the response you receive for telling everyone how badly things are going? Recovery eventually asks the awkward question: who are you when misery is no longer your defining characteristic? Even Of Wolf and Man, which I initially filed under “mandatory metal song about how cool werewolves are”, eventually made more sense. The wolf is the elemental self, the instinctive human underneath civilisation. Myth being used to examine psychology rather than merely because wolves are cool. Although wolves are cool. The album also clarified something I find difficult about metal itself. It frequently heightens everything until the effect becomes strangely flat. It reminds me of driving through the Cascades from the Willamette Valley into the high desert of Oregon. You’re suddenly four or five thousand feet above sea level, yet the landscape can look almost as flat as Lincolnshire. Everything has been elevated, so nothing feels elevated. Metal sometimes mistakes altitude for relief. Every riff is enormous. Every drum hit is enormous. Every guitar solo announces that an enormous emotion is occurring. But if grief, anger, triumph and crossing the road successfully all receive essentially the same intricate distorted-guitar vocabulary, emotional distinction starts disappearing. Compare that with Maggot Brain, where Eddie Hazel’s guitar develops a specific emotional argument rather than merely announcing “guitar solo expressing strong feelings”. The Black Album is at its best when Metallica escape that limitation. They create valleys as well as summits. They leave space. They let Hetfield sing. They allow the words to carry meaning rather than asking volume to do all the work. And the final The Struggle Within brings the argument somewhere useful. Struggle is not something to externalise indefinitely and make everyone else’s problem. Part of the dignity of struggling is recognising that the struggle is yours, while still allowing other people to help you through it. So I ended somewhere I absolutely didn’t expect. At its best, The Black Album is Metallica doing therapy in public. At its worst, it’s mythic comfort food and werewolves. Sometimes the apparent mythic comfort food turns out to be part of the therapy anyway. I won’t be listening to it every day, and Don’t Tread on Me can get in the sea on its own, but this is a very well-made album that succeeds at what it attempts. Four stars. And it taught me something I probably needed teaching. Metal can think.

it's lwk like good tone and good progression of the instruments but I don't like the vocals

Prefer earlier Metallica, but this album is not terrible. Enter Sandman is just an incredible track.

Enter sandman - 5 Sad but true - 5 Holier than thou - 4 The unforgiven - 5 Wherever i may roam - 5 Don't tread on me - 4 Through the never - 3 Nothing else matters - 5 Of wolf and man - 3 The god that failed - 3 My friend of misery - 4 The struggle within - 3

Pretty fun.

This is when they lost it

Top end of a 2 for the great guitar riffs and solo’s. Otherwise I just find this kind of music boring and can’t listen to more than 2 songs at a time

Better than last Metallica album. Still a slog. Devastated to learn that there are another two of their albums on the list.

Jeez another Metallica album already. I thought this was an upgrade on master of puppets though. Contains the big hit and it was generally more refined.

The music is amazing but the vocals sound like pirates.

Yes, I suppose this is baby’s first metal album and it drags a bit in the middle, but I still it deserves a 5

I regret to inform you that the butt-rock version of Metallica is better than the earlier thrashier version.

🐺🎸😴🌚⛓️

Легенда. Мощь. Удар. Плотнючий жёсткий мощный альбом. Он гораздо чище первого их альбома, что разочаровывает, но здесь прям полностью ощущается что они нащупали они нашли они сделали. Неимоверно заряжающие барабаны несмотря на все брошенные камни в технику Ларса - на этом альбома звучит и партии великолепны. Да может этот альбом слышатся как уже состоявшийся коммерческий, а не вульгарный и грязный, но это звучание мне нравится гораздо больше и подчеркивает их идентичность и узнаваемость. Оценка 8/10.

Couldn't finish the whole album. Less angry/metal than I thought, the songs just sounded the same to me after a while.

Damn, I came to this party late! It took my teen son to bring me around to the fold. This album is a classic, and these musicians are the kings of Metal. God bless Metallica!

These lads do take themselves seriously don't they? A few days back I had another album with a black cover assigned to me and AC/DC are a lot more fun, in a sort of seaside postcard manner. Still, you can't deny the talent on display here. In the "crunching bass / thumping drums / frantic guitar shredding" sort of thing they're probably peerless. There is a lot of testosterone seeping out of the speakers while you play this and I can't help thinking that teenaged boys faced with the howling abyss of existential dread would lap it up and come back for more. I'm not sure it needed to be an hour long. And the big ballads are a bit dull. The trouble with them slowing down and actually singing, is that you get to hear the lyrics. It's not edifying. But it's pretty impressive when it's firing on all cylinders

I have listened to the album circa 1994 around 13 year old and the first metal album i ever experienced.. the moment it hit my ear i was blown away by the sound and to me it is majestic. Disclaimer: i listen to a lot of genre so its hard to focus to one genre or artist.. i enjoy all..

Goated album, starting off with enter sandman an absolute staple. Didn't listen to the album very intently, just had it in the background but it was overall very good listen. 8.5/10

Hush little baby don't make me listen to this ever again.

So there’s a nostalgic spot for this album for me because it was the first metal album I ever heard. That said, it absolutely does not hold up. The first 4 songs rule, so does Nothing Else Matters. But the rest? Woof. I’ve long said if you took the best songs from this, Load, and Reload you could have a solid 45 minute album. Giving it the benefit of a round up since it was my first.

i dont like metallica

It’s the black album. It’s obviously 5 star.

It's fine. Whatever

not my style but also not it

I will never voluntarily listen to Enter Sandman again, nice try. Lars Ulrich sucks, almost as bad as James Hetfield. You don't gotta hear this.

starts strong, ends strong, gets a little lost in the middle. On the long side, but still emblematic of the rise of mainstream Metallica.

I was 15 when this came out so of course I knew Enter Sandman, Sad But True, Wherever I May Roam, and Nothing Else Matters from MTV. Even though I enjoyed hearing them when they came on, I never felt the desire to seek out more. That year I buy CD’s for Badmotorfinger, Nevermind, and Ten.

Floyd rose, wah wah scooped mids.. Why not

It’s not good. It’s like the worst junk food. You can excuse someone liking it when you’re young. But as an adult a little goes a long way. Enter the sandman is fun. Then the rest of the album just drags out.

Some people call the black album the last truly great Metallica album. It isn’t. It’s their first embarrassing one and it only gets worse from here on in their discography. I’d put the average age of a fan of this album at 14. These guys were nearing 30 when they put this out.

Day 349 Easy 5, Metallicas best album imo Highlights Holier than thou The unforgiven The god that failed

Metal royalty. Hard to find a more locked in moment in a band's history.

It's been over a year and a half since I got my last Metallica album on my journey, and it's time to talk about the self-titled release, aka The Black Album. While the band started to gain more traction from their prior release, ...And Justice for All, particularly off the music video for "One", it was The Black Album that broke them, and metal in general, into the mainstream. It's to the point where not only do all the singles still get radio airplay, but for the album's 30th anniversary, a tribute album was released, illustrating how The Black Album had a profound impact across many genres. I don't consider it hyperbole for me to say that this record's had quite the legacy. It certainly helps that The Black Album still holds up. I think the main factor in the record's mass appeal is the mature songwriting. Before this, Metallica lyrics largely dealt with relentless violence and destruction to the surrounding world. With The Black Album, the lyrics got more personal and introspective, as James Hetfield, with the guidance of Lars Ulrich and producer Bob Rock, dug deeper within himself and his background to find something more profound. His struggles with addiction are alluded to on "Sad But True", his bitterness over his father leaving his family is felt on "The Unforgiven", life out on the road is expressed with reverence on "Wherever I May Roam", and the heartfelt message toward his then-girlfriend on "Nothing Else Matters" ends up rather touching. Probably the most profound of these songs is "The God That Failed", written after James's mother passed away after refusing to receive cancer treatment over her religious beliefs. His absolute disdain towards Christian Science is palpable on this track. That said, not every song is directly linked to James's background, as other tunes express more universal themes. The nightmare fuel of "Enter Sandman", the calling out of self-righteousness on "Holier Than Thou", the badassery of "Don't Tread on Me", the endless search for enlightenment on "Through the Never", the primal instincts on "Of Wolf and Man", the existential dread on "My Friend of Misery", and the suicidal ideation on "The Struggle Within" all carry a good emotional weight to them. If anything, these songs encapsulate the confidence that James has built as a songwriter. Alongside the lyrics, the music itself is just as menacing. While there are trace elements of their earlier thrash sound on cuts like "Through the Never" and "The Struggle Within", the overall style on The Black Album is a lot slower and tuned down, making the catchy guitar riffs, Jason Newsted's bass lines, James's gruff vocals, and Lars's hard-hitting drumming all the more prominent. Credit to Bob Rock for making the production on this record as layered and dense as it is, while also bringing in the orchestration for "Nothing Else Matters" to elevate that track. Hell, even the cowbell on the chorus of "My Friend of Misery" goes hard. All in all, The Black Album certainly justified its notoriety with an impressive stylistic change that Metallica pulled off. Of course, the band would continue down this experimental rabbit hole with the bloated Load and ReLoad records to mixed results. Regardless, this album is quite the triumph for heavy music.

I am already familiar with this album so happy to see it on the list. Not a huge metal fan, but I can definitely see the appeal after listening again. Enter Sandman goes so hard. Top songs: Enter Sandman, Holier Than Thou, Nothing Else Matters

I'll be honest, I was a little tuned out while listening to this one. Unfortunately, I don't think that speaks well to this album as everything kind of blended into one for me. I know that cohesiveness is sometimes what makes for a great album, but in this case I think it instead led to something pretty boring and one-dimensional. It made me realize that I think Metallica is kind of corny, and I don't think I'll be a metalhead any time soon. 2.5/5 Favorite tracks: Enter Sandman (yes I know this is a basic choice, and yes I did know this one beforehand)

I liked this and was interested the whole time.

enter sandman is the best amongs other songs, overtime you just get bored cause the beat is almost the same everytime

Very powerful riff-heavy hard rock and metal album that took the metal genre to new heights. The heavy-hitting songs on this record have not lost their bang at all. They sound as menacing as they did in the early 90's. However, as someone who is not a huge fan of this record, some of the longer tracks definitely drag on. The tail end of the record overstays its welcome for a bit longer than liked. All in all, great record to sparse within a hard rock playlist and the beginning of the metal genre going mainstream.

Sad but true, Unforgiven, Wherever I may roam...didn't remember that so many classics and even Nothing Else Matters are on this one. I reckon that the speed is lacking compared to their previous efforts, but the melodies, the riffing and the songwriting are fantastic on the Black Album.

Seen them live, got to the t-shirt. A classic for the ages.

La verdad tiene unos temones, qué decir.

No need to overthink this. This is a seminal, genre defining icon of an album.

Slower, heavier more refined Enter sandman Nohing else matters

I hate Metallica gng