Of course, this album is not new to me. Nonetheless, it is a masterpiece, filled with classic tracks. But the Abbey Road Medley is the icing on top. 5/5
Solid soul album, but bettered by others from the same year
First half is far superior to the second half
Quite literally does what it says on the tin
Gloria and Land are the standouts but others fall flat
Solid, but there’s better Steely Dan albums
I probably shouldn’t like this as much as I did. Oozing with charisma, a tribal chanting hit
Not much to say. Probably a top 10 album of all time. The first 5 songs are nearly flawless.
Solid if not revolutionary
Not for me at all. It was a slog to get through
Cosy, and classy
This surprised me. It’s slap bang in the middle of a 3 and a 4, but alas, there are no half stars here.
Just cool, Prowler is an awesome song
This album didn’t click for me the first time I listened. Today it seemed way better than I remembered. The second half especially is full of good songs. I’m not a rap fan as such, but I thoroughly appreciate the production in particular of this album
Glory box is a perfect song, but the rest don’t really come close bar roads
I think this album gets longer everytime I listen to it. It has some of the best Beatles songs (while my guitar gently weeps) alongside some of the worst (revolution 9)
Not much here beyond the two songs I already know. Quite forgettable
Appreciate that it’s one of many acclaimed albums by The Cure, but there wasn’t much here that blew me away. Probably because I know Disintegration exists
This is actually a brilliant album. Like Blondie crossed with The Cars. It’s a damn shame pop music doesn’t sound like this these days
Sure, it’s not The Beach Boys. But this is a lovely little album, and one I’ll probably give more time to in the future
Another album that doesn’t do much beyond the song everyone knows. But Run Charlie Run is a wild, wild song, that somehow isn’t even marked as explicit on Spotify
Started the week on a double album, and ended it on a double album. I’ve never been a massive smashing pumpkins fan, although 1979 has increasingly been on my rotation recently. There’s some hidden gems in here too, namely Thru The Eyes of Ruby. But again, and as with almost all double albums, there’s a bit too much that’s forgettable
Suppose this is a concept album of sorts. The production is surprisingly clean, not bad at all
An album in an unfamiliar language will always be one I struggle to attach to. Musically, it’s actually pretty solid. But it’s just spoken word French, from a guy who sounds like a creep. Then I found out Melody is supposedly 14 in this, while the narrator is 20 years older. Yeah, not for me.
Sure, people can say it’s overrated. I don’t care, it’s a masterpiece. I’ve listened to it countless times. It shaped my music taste, it evokes memories of listening with my dad as a kid. The Chain brings back watching F1 with him at the weekend. Never Going Back Again is one of the greatest guitar riffs of all time. Gold Dust Woman is an exceptional album closer. Just imagine if Silver Springs had made the cut ahead of Oh Daddy…
Another solid Pumpkins album, probably helped by being picked so close to Mellon Collie. This just edges that as an album
Paul Simon is actually a very good guitar player. This is decent, but knowing Bridge Over Troubled Water had already come out by this point, it’s not his best work
God knows how many times I’ve listened to this album, and now it takes me back to summer 2025. It can only be a 5/5 for me
Yeahhhhhh, boyyyyyeeeeee
Imagine if every artist just did covers of one another, music would be pretty boring
Sure, there are some lovely songs in here. There’s plenty of rubbish songs too. It’s just too long, I will never complain about a double album again
Another album I grew up on. So there’s a lot of sentimental value to this rating but the opening run of American idiot, Jesus of suburbia, holiday and boulevard of broken dreams is a near perfect run of music.
I’m not the clientele for this album, but if I was, I would love this.
Plenty of songs here that are commercially successful makes it an album I’m actually quite familiar with
Listening to Randy Newman feels like it should be accompanied by a montage of Buzz and Woody, which makes it feel very innocent and comforting. Even though at the heart of it this is an album about racism and the Deep South, which isn’t very innocent at all
Funky, but it gets repetitive and isn’t helped by 3x 10 minute tracks back to back.
It’s solid enough, but musically it falls so short of anything Smiths related.
Can’t lie, after hearing the masterpiece that is ‘Underground’ I spent the majority of the album distracted by the animated masterpiece ‘Robots’ and the scene that features that song.
A rap album accessible enough that someone who doesn’t really click with rap can still click with this. I consider it made by a different person to the Kanye that exists today
Another album that shaped my youth. I know it back to front and it is a solid album, but I’m not sure that even with nostalgia I can give it more than a 4
I just don’t get Björk, and whoever the other bloke is drops this even further. The kind of album that I was happy to have ended.
Maggie May is fantastic and I suspect on listening to this album more I’d like it more, but I can only think of my Nan and her obsession with Rod
A double album that I prefer the second half on. Not an easy artist to listen to though, you have to be giving the songs your full attention to enjoy them.
For some reason I really struggle with New Order, and this is no different
This is quirky, I feel like XTC are a highly underrated band particularly in the streaming age
There’s some absolute belters on here, and the harpsichord goes hard
Starts off strong but quickly becomes the same song on repeat. Not bad, just not much I’d consider listening to again
The title track, which is one of the best songs of the 80’s, is levels above anything else on this album
Second best Beach Boys album. Enjoyed it a lot
The album cover is more iconic than the songs it contains. Although March Of The Black Queen is a wonderful surprise and a highly underrated Queen song
This is a really cool album, very moody. Unfortunately I listened to it in outside in the sun, which is the completely wrong way of listening to it.
Solid enough debut but that Iron Man cover is a horrendous piece of music.
I remember the first time I listened to this album, I wasn’t massively impacted by it. I think because I knew it was held in the same regard as Ziggy Stardust, or Rumours, or Abbey Road, albums I know front to back, I expected to hear it once and immediately know all the songs. But this isn’t an album for the songs individually, it’s an album that should be played front to back, with no interruptions. Listening to it as a singular piece uncovers the masterpiece that it is. Funky, heartfelt, and as terribly relevant today as it was 55 years ago…
It’s a shame that the rest of the album isn’t on the level of sultans of swing, but I suppose that is an impossible request given how elite that song is
Weird, wacky, but doesn’t quite click with me. Possibly the best band name of all time though
Only listened to the original track listing which brought this down to 35 mins. I’m not a fan of live albums, you cannot replicate being there in person. But The Who sound very good in this, and makes me wish I was alive to see that period of live music
When I was 12, I wasn’t dancing. I was watching a T. Rex tribute with my dad. I think it was especially formative in my love of live music. So for that, I can only thank Marc Bolan.
Jailbait is controversial, but overall it’s a solid and bad ass album. Lemmy rocks
The first proper surprise of this list. I didn’t know what to expect with this album but it’s a collection of beautiful songs, I thoroughly enjoyed it
Shame it’s so short, there’s a couple of cheesy songs on here, but plenty of excellent ones too
Seemingly influential, but I couldn’t connect with it
I don’t get Bjork, and I’m not going to pretend I do. I just don’t like this
Cosy, easy listening
This album will forever make me think of my mum doing the cleaning, going on and on about her love of Simon Le Bon. But as such, this album is familiar, it makes me happy, and although I may have tried desperately to convince her that it was rubbish, maybe she was onto something after all.
Music for a museum
The big songs on here are a way above some of the lesser known ones, but there’s plenty of big songs on here, so it’s class
The first three songs are generational, but it really runs out of steam by the end
Absolutely terrible, no redeeming qualities
Actually not as bad as I thought, but not something I’d ever listen to again
The definition of solid
Of course there’s some legendary songs on here, but this album is let down by the track listing. The flow really lets it down
It’s a travesty there’s no 0/5 option. The single worst album I’ve ever heard, with the exception of the 1 second masterpiece ‘You Suffer’ which ironically made me suffer the least out of any song on the album
Didn’t click at first that this is half a Steely Dan album. Enjoyed it a lot, grooooovvyyy
Janis Joplin is one of the most unique vocalists of all time. Taken far too soon, but she gave us ‘Move Over’ before she left, which is a very underrated song
Convinced this is secretly Elvis Costello. Vocals are uncanny
Dragged on for too long
Awesome album that gets better the further you go into it. Not sure there’s a single bad song on here, and a pretty accessible rap album too
I’m surprised I’ve never listened to this before, but I’ve always known it as Simon’s best solo work. Found myself disappointed that it had ended, which is pretty high praise
More a compilation I suppose. Not quite my genre but I can appreciate the songs on here. Funky
4 songs in an album means each song is a few minutes too long
Right on the cusp of a 5 this, the opening track is simply a masterpiece, and there’s some real gems hidden inside too
The cover is trippy, the music inside matches
Actually don’t think Phil is a particularly good singer. No denying its influence though
Did not expect to like this anywhere near as much as I did. But with each passing song I found it more and more enjoyable, and by the end considered it a masterpiece. There’s no single stand out song on here, but something just clicked for me while listening to it
Them bones, some track. Badass album
Just a very happy album, impossible to not put a smile on your face
Decent, can’t say I’d go back to it
Lowkey think this is even better than Thriller. Unreal album
Nothing noteworthy here
It’s giving Supertramp
Supposed to be based on a fictional movie. Not sure what Letterboxd review I’d give that movie but it would probably match.
Very long, but very good
Sad songs, lots of sad songs
A Btec Joy Division
Sure, it’s samey, but the big band songs are a soft spot for me
Pretty pretentious, feels like this album thinks it’s better than it is
A bit front loaded, but a brilliant and influential album
A couple of masterpieces in between a few misses. Not the best Stones album but certainly not the worst
I just listened to this and already I’ve forgotten what it sounds like
Not sure who these guys are, not really my kind of music but not the worst
Fantastic surprise this
The Little Wing riff may be my favourite guitar riff of all time
Solid
Just good music
First half of the album is top class. Second half drops off considerably
Not sure what genre this is meant to be. Wacky
A few songs are a few minutes too long, but I enjoyed this. The sum of its parts makes a very good album
Again, from a purely musical perspective, this is an excellent album
Came out in between two of the greatest albums of all time. Not quite as good, but it’s still well worth a listen, and it’s a travesty it isn’t streamed more
Almost an album or poetry as much as it is music. Compelling to listen to
Plenty of classics on here, and the deeper cuts are also great
Tails off at the end, but a classic album all in all
Enjoyable
Excellent album, a really solid level across the album. Would listen to it again
A bit samey but a cool listen
Title track is excellent but found it to be a bit forgettable other than that. The light my fire cover doesn’t come close to original
Donkey Kong’s Jamboree minigame in album form
A tale of two halves. First half is excellent, the title track especially. But the second half falls into this disjointed collection of instrumentals
The organ had no need to go this hard
Decent but not as good as Wu-Tang
A few hidden gems in here, big fan of Jack White so I hope some Stripes show up later on in this list
Easily the best Elvis album, so long as you include Suspicious Minds in the tracklist
I find myself constantly turning up N.I.B. whenever it comes on. What a debut, game changing
Short and sweet. Certainly not the best of the Beatles but revolutionary in 1964
She’s some lyricist
Surprisingly enjoyable
Deserving of its legacy
Wow, this is a breath of fresh air. Phenomenal album
Swore I saw an eagle fly over me in Romsey while listening to this
So many interludes even if most are a few seconds
Bonus point for being grandads favourite artist
Thoroughly enjoyable
Quite possibly my favourite album of all time. The highs are unbelievable, the lows are non-existent, and then just when you think it’s done, on comes Rock ‘n’ roll suicide…
Lowkey went hard
Pretty stereotypical mid 60s album
Influential but there are plenty of superior albums
Depressing af
As funky as can be
Felt like the kind of songs you’d see a band come up with for their GCSE group compositions
Certainly far from the best Radiohead album
A slightly worse version of 3 Feet High, still enjoyable though
Absolutely hated that cover of Help
Not as good as the Wall, but it came first. And Tommy sure does play a mean pinball
No real standouts on here, very middle of the road
The first time I listened to Pet Sounds I only gave it a 3. Then Brian Wilson died, and I realised that it is truly one of the most important albums of all time. God Only Knows is one of the greatest songs of all time, and listening to this directly after a naff Elvis album really highlights how stupidly ahead of its time it is
People hate on Coldplay too much. So many brilliant songs on here, and the closer Amsterdam is highly underrated
Pretty good
Very front loaded. Found myself losing interest come the end
A bit too long
Just phenomenal from start to finish
Rather enjoyable for a metal album
Very cool and groovy, but let down by Mother’s Lament
Some of these songs are stupidly too long. Lost my interest long before the end of the album
A really fresh pop album, big surprise
He really is a cool guy
