Harvest by Neil Young

Harvest

Neil Young

3.8
Rating
30402
Votes
1
2%
2
8%
3
26%
4
36%
5
28%
Distribution

Album Summary

Harvest is the fourth studio album by Canadian-American musician Neil Young, released February 1, 1972 by Reprise Records, catalogue number MS 2032. It featured the London Symphony Orchestra on two tracks and vocals by noted guests David Crosby, Graham Nash, Linda Ronstadt, Stephen Stills, and James Taylor. It topped the Billboard 200 album chart for two weeks, and spawned two hit singles, "Old Man", which peaked at No. 31 on the US Billboard Hot 100, and "Heart of Gold", which reached No. 1. It was the best-selling album of 1972 in the United States. The album has since remained Neil Young's signature album as well as his best selling.In 2015, Harvest was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Its just not my tempo

Very chill, easy listening.

the opening track ‘out on the weekend’ has a really cosy autumnal feel about it. not sure it’s the kind of thing i’d normally like/listen to however it is very fitting for this time of year i like the upbeat instrumentals in heart of gold, definitely get the hype for this one & love the beautiful backing vocals boring at times, overall a pretty average album

I think this album is overrated. It did very well commercially. Young reacted to this success by making two of his best albums On the Beach and Tonight’s the Night. They were commercial failures. Neil didn’t mind at all. As Neil said he preferred life in the ditch. Harvest was recorded mostly in Nashville with the Stray Gators. Neil has high prized help from Linda Ronstadt, James Taylor and CSN. The album is mostly country and folk songs. This is easy listening music. It does not challenge its listeners in anyway. Let’s look at the songs. The big hit Heart of Gold is okay. Nice harmony singing on it. A man needs a maid is a feminist classic. Old man is the best song on the album. Great lyrics. Alabama is another song about rednecks in the south. Not to be confused with Sweet Home Alabama. The needle and the damage done is a song about the dangers of heroin use and addiction. This is not one of Neil’s best. Just an average album. Three stars.

I feel he applied a few lessons from earlier work when making this record, only to forget those same lessons later on.

Not a bad album. Like the use of instruments, but not what id listen to every day. But Id still diffidently listen to it some time. I like the harmonica and some of the songs lyrics. I like a man needs a made, the piano and emotional lyrics. Good live listened to. violin nice and soothing. Wouldn't listen to this every day probably not my favourite.

Album cover fits the album, its pretty solid. Neil Young is an interesting figure for sure. He is still making music in 2026, which is absolutely crazy. "Heart of Gold" is a far-and-away success and clearly a standout. "Heart of Gold" is a popular song done right, it is his best song, and his most popular. Other than that, nothing in this album is offensive, and it did have some good messages. "The Needle and the Damage Done" in particular has some interesting views of drugs, which at the time were in somewhat of a renaissance. "Old Man" was decent as well. Everything else is middle of the road. So far, my favorite Neil Young album.Best Song: Heart of Gold. Worst Song: A Man needs a Maid.

I fell asleep listening to this, so I had to relisten, reluctantly. Many of the songs are slow in a way that sounds dull. I liked "On the Beach," his other album, for its melancholy, but on this album it does not work well. Harvest has "Heart of Gold" and "Old Man," two great songs which partially redeem it, but the rest are repetitive and predictable. It's clear what to expect when one song ends — another sluggish Country song with a vaguely Rock riff. It's likely I won't listen again, or even remember what the album is, so I'll describe it for future me. Listen to the first song, and that's what the whole album is, minus two tracks. "Out on the Weekend" starts the record with plucking a few strings on an acoustic guitar, drums, and a mellow harmonica. Then the vocals come out. On the whole album these vocals are drawn out, almost feeling slowed down. They are also monotone, conveying zero emotion. This continues for 35 more minutes, broken up by two songs, which, I must say are good. "Heart of Gold" is every other song, but sped up by 1.5x and vocals are truly emotional. "Old Man" is the other hit, and while better than the rest of the album, it's not close to "Heart of Gold," unfortunately. There are some cool instrumental breaks, but it all comes down to poor, uninspired vocals, and an overused harmonica. Skim through a couple of songs, and you've heard the full album.

This played and I barely noticed. It's an album that didn't stir any emotions, positive nor negative.

Just really bad 🫠

i’ve heard this before and i hated it. it really grew on me this time

𝘏𝘢𝘳𝘷𝘦𝘴𝘵 is probably Neil Young’s best-known album outside his work with Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young, and I can’t think of many records that deserve their reputation more. It’s a country-rock classic in every sense, filled with gorgeous melodies, heartfelt songwriting, and that unmistakable combination of melancholy and warmth that Young does so well. What makes this album so special is how much emotion Young can convey without making a big fuss about it. His fragile, slightly nasal voice might not be everyone’s idea of a great singer, but I honestly can’t imagine anyone else delivering these songs quite the same way. 𝗛𝗲𝗮𝗿𝘁 𝗼𝗳 𝗚𝗼𝗹𝗱 and 𝗢𝗹𝗱 𝗠𝗮𝗻 are obvious highlights, with melodies that seem almost ridiculously simple until you realize how difficult they are to get out of your head. And then there’s 𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗡𝗲𝗲𝗱𝗹𝗲 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗗𝗮𝗺𝗮𝗴𝗲 𝗗𝗼𝗻𝗲, which manages to be absolutely heartbreaking in barely two minutes. Sometimes a voice and an acoustic guitar really are all you need. I also love how the album balances its intimate acoustic moments with occasional bursts of electric guitar and even orchestral arrangements. On paper, that might sound like a slightly strange combination, but somehow it all fits together. The songs have enough character to stand on their own while still feeling like parts of a coherent whole. For me, 𝘏𝘢𝘳𝘷𝘦𝘴𝘵 is one of those rare albums where widespread popularity and musical quality go hand in hand. It’s accessible without being shallow, emotional without becoming overly sentimental, and packed with songs that have lost none of their appeal. If someone asked me why Neil Young is considered one of the greats, I’d probably just hand them this record and let the music do the explaining.

I really liked this album when I first heard it, so was looking forward to listening again and expecting some familiarity bias. enjoyed a re-listen but not as much as I was expecting to.

No too bad there’s a would made me feel like I’m trying to beat bowser’s castle verry nastalgic personally

Kinda surprised I never got into Neil Young. I really like folk music but I've never explored the genre deeply, usually sticking to what I organically came across. Well here's my chance with Neil Young and I'm glad it's happening now. ((I always mixed him up with Neil Diamond)) this was good, I enjoyed this. I always respect when an artist can be vulnerable in their lyric writing. the orchestral tracks here feel kinda out of place but I don't dislike it, gives it a musical quality. makes me wanna sit on the porch on a hot day chewing on a piece of wheat. <3 words, Alabama, the needle and the damage done, heart of gold<3

*deep breath* So this was one of my grandfathers favorite records & dang does it bring back a lot of nostalgic memories. Summer time, school is out, hanging at my grandparents house with some sort of auto racing on in the background and coffee scent in the air. Legit crying while typing this!! As my grandfather was not a music guy, he had this one album on CD and would play it in his car. Even without the nostalgia, this is such a solid album. Truly supplements a certain sadness and joy with being human. I guess this showcases a much calmer and worry-free time in my life... Something thats dead and gone, yet I will forever be reaching for fleeting threads of it. The instrumentation and mold around the guitar, with the silky smooth backup vocals just does it for me. So good. Favs: Out on the weekend, old man, heart of gold,

3/5, i can see why people like it but it’s not for me. i can also see how country music used to be good. old man is the only song i was previously familiar with and i can see why (it’s the best)

not my type of music

Always captures my nostalgia for a NorCal hippie life I never led

It’s a fine harvest

Palatable and comforting energy

I so do not get the hype with this album.

A bit inconsistent, unlike his best albums, but it also carries some of his best ever tracks. Overall, an album I really enjoy with each listen and this time is no exception. Favourite track: Heart of Gold

After a long journey on this site full of Neil Young showings, it's nice to close the book on his representation with a solid magnum opus, great album with nice variety, good sound, and engaging lyrics The biggest hits still stand out pretty strongly, but the album certainly deserves listening

This is my fourth Neil Young record of this project, if you include CSNY. I have discovered how much I really love Neil Young. This is another record that I was somewhat familiar with previously. While it doesn’t quite rise to the level of After the Goldrush or—my absolute favorite so far—Rust Never Sleeps, this is lovely.

Good stuff

great album!! loved the chill vibes, the lyrics are good too

#138 An absolute masterpiece of folk rock, and my favorite Neil Young album. Perfect Fall vibes. Highlights: Out On The Weekend, Harvest, Heart Of Gold, Old Man, Alabama, The Needle And The Damage Done, Words.

Some of the songs are classics and trigger feelings which are seldom in these days. The lyrics are smart and still relevant.

Slightly underwhelming although I really like the opening track

really cool country/rock album! rating: 3/5* almost got an heart attack when I saw people in the comments saying that the album wasn't on spotify😭

Classic and flawless

Amazing album, one of my favorites, so good I listened to it twice back to back. Heart of gold is such an great song, and old man is a pure classic

This was pleasant.

Great album, harvest moon, old man and heart of gold are my faves. Reserving 5 stars for my absolute top albums

YAYAYAYAYAYAYYAYAYAYAYYAYA

Great album, obviously very slow. A classic, some really nice cord progressions and lovely vocal melodies

I don't typically enjoy Neil Young's voice but on this album he's at his best. I truly think this is one of my favorite albums by him. I'm still never going to be a great big fan, but this album highlights his songwriting beautifully.

Classic. Still sounds as good as ever

Harvest Moon is one of my favourite songs, it feels very nostalgic and comforting (in a reminiscing way) - so I was expecting big things. However, this album feels very disjointed, it feels as if the songs were produced as fillers around Heart of Gold and Old Man. Little dissapointed :(

Neil doesn’t have a great voice but he makes it work for him. “Old Man” and the “The Needle and the Damage Done” are my favorites on the album.

Out on the Weekend→9/10 Harvest→8/10 A Man Needs a Maid→10/10 Heart of Gold→10/10 Are You Ready for the Country→9/10 Old Man→10/10 There's a World→10/10 Alabama→10/10 The Needle and the Damage Done→8.5/10 Words (Between the Lines of Age)→10/10 best→ Alabama worst→ The Needle and the Damage Done overrated→ Out on the Weekend underrated→ There's a World overall→ 90/100 MUST HEAR My review matched what everyone else is saying, but I think the specific songs I think it's good are completely different. Orchestral-style tracks like “There’s a World” always get not high ratings, but I absolutely love that type of music also i like when the sound is rich and full, so I rate them really highly. To sum it up, this is a CLASSIC.

Perfect album for fall. I enjoyed the instrumentals especially on Heart of Gold and A Man Needs a Maid.

He could have a really good greatest hits album and it would probably include most of this album. The rest of his stuff I could do without.

Fantastic. Neil Young is a struggle for some. This and Ragged Glory are in my opinion the gateway drugs to his catalogue

Great. Very strong record. 4.5/5

This grew on me a bit the second time through. His voice doesn’t do much for me but it works with some of these songs and there are some absolute classics on here. Solid 3 from me.

Melancholy, some problematic songs.

I like the mood of it.

When I hear Neil Young, these songs are the classic folk-country songs I think of. Old Man, The needle and the Damage done, and Heart of Gold are all easy listening tunes.

Suffering from a severe back injury, Neil Young was forced to construct a predominantly acoustic album. The result, "Harvest", blends acoustic folk, country, and understated rock. While two orchestral tracks branch off into a different production style, the warm acoustic foundation remains the core strength of the record. The album boasts several standout tracks: the ubiquitous 'Heart of Gold', the wonderfully poignant 'Old Man', the chillingly direct 'The Needle and the Damage Done', and the widely misunderstood 'A Man Needs a Maid'. For me, the underrated gem here is "Words (Between the Lines of Age)". It marks one of the few times "electric" Neil Young appears on the record, letting rip with a wonderful, soaring guitar solo. Beyond his loyal fanbase, of which I am one, "Harvest" is likely the single album the casual listener will remember him for. It may not be his absolute best, nor is it my personal favourite Neil Young album, but it remains a wonderful listen. Side one 1 "Out on the Weekend" (5/5) 2 "Harvest" (4/5) 3 "A Man Needs a Maid" (5/5) 4 "Heart of Gold" (5/5) 5 "Are You Ready for the Country?" (4/5) Side two 1 "Old Man" (5/5) 2 "There's a World" (3/5) 3 "Alabama" (5/5) 4 "The Needle and the Damage Done" (5/5) 5 "Words (Between the Lines of Age)" (5/5) Total - 46 Average - 4.6 461/1001 243/461 albums reviewed were new to me.

sorry neil young but i didn't really like "the maid"

Canadian treasure

Now that's an album! Whoa.

This is the Neil I enjoy, though those string arrangements were weird. ‘Old Man’ is worth the price of admissions all on its own.

Veldig fint album

This has been one of my favorites for a long time. This is on the short list of best singer-songwriter albums of all-time for sure.

A brilliant album and yet uneven for all of that. Songs like “Heart of Gold”, “Old Man”, and “Needle and the Damage Done” are almost painfully beautiful. Then there is a second tier. “Out on the Weekend”, “Alabama”. On any other album they would be standouts. Heretically the rest don’t really move me, and some come across as just not good. I’ve seen Neil Young live twice, and unlike a lot of artists he seems to just get better with age. I fully expected to give this a 5/5. However this album as a mix of genius, great, and just OK gets a 4/5.

overrated

He’s a good guy to sit around a fire with and jam with

Really easy listening, don't know if I'll remember it though.

I think that Neil Young is an artist who will grow on me. Obviously the songwriting is great, and the music itself is solid but nothing here wows me. Maybe it just has a bit too much twang for my taste.

Much more of a mixed bag of styles than I expected but still consistently good. Old man has been one of my favorite songs since I was young. Not as big of a fan of the grand orchestral ones.

couple of great singles, did think some of the rest was a bit dull

Fuck Neil Young, and the horse he rode in on.

This one's like an old pair of jeans for me.

Folk rock that takes you on a wheel cart ride in the country side while the sun is setting

Not quite my style of music. Soft rock with some highlights. Neil Youngs voice is good

I wanted to like this more but just don't. Neil Young is best with other musicians to balance him out. Besides the radio staples, this was forgettable. Top tracks: "Heart of Gold," "Old Man"

A classic of the genre, even a genre I don't really love (70s folk rock). Talent undeniable, and the quiet stoicism of Young is hard to match. 4.

great album but the lyrics to “A Man Needs a Maid” are a little…of their time

Great but a few oddities from the style of the times

Too much Neil Young all at once. Old Man and Heart of Gold secure the third star but it's not an album I'll be revisiting in it's entirety.

- anyaek stilusu zene, nagyon jo minoseg

Nice album. But what's that song about men needing a maid??

A real mix this of classic Neil Young style acoustic songs and a few nondescript tracks which don't go anywhere. Overall though a few classics which mean its a 4 for me.

Huge fan of this album. Not sure about the man needing a maid that much, but I can get over that bit. I've listened to it a bunch before and plan to do it again.

The last of the Neil Young solo albums for me and still sad that one of them isn't Harvest Moon. If you haven't listened to that, I highly recommend it for One of These Days alone. But what we have here is Harvest, and frankly the best of the four Neil Young albums in this list. Is it a 5 star - no. But it's a lot better than JAY Z's The Blueprint, which I reluctantly gave 4 stars to yesterday. It's a very high 4. Heart of Gold is a classic for a reason. Old Man is greatly underappreciated. The Needle and the Damage Done and Words really push the album at the end. But there's just something about it that doesn't get it to a 5. You can hear some of that distortion that would show up in Mirror Ball decades later in Words. You get that lyrical depth in Old Man that shines in One of These Days. But there is something flat in the middle too. So it balances into a 4 I'm afraid.

Boring old people music with a harmonica

Harvest is a classic Neil Young album, but it's hard to not simply think about A Man Needs A Maid. Don't get me wrong, as a man, I'd love to have someone do some cleaning, mostly because it would be nice to have that kind of free cash to hire out the drudge work, but it's just so whiny. Literally, Young sounds like Strong Sad leveling a whole city with his whining. It's monumental in its bad vibes, tone deaf in its sentiment, and sounds like the howl of an unthreatening ghost in its delivery. Having this as the first signpost on the album does not make one hopeful. To be fair, though, it is the stoppage point to get to the classics. Heart of Gold is probably as good a Neil song as there is… if we distilled his essence to one track, it ain't my favorite, but it's probably the song to do it. The Needle and the Damage Done is no less iconic, if less obviously catchy and memorable. It's arguably the thru-line that leads to the grunge era, almost literally. And Old Man is as incisive a volley as there is to level at the prior generation, forgetting their idealism and passion, pretending the younger generation is nothing like theirs (though one does wonder if the AI era will change this age old disconnect for the even worse… the kids do seem dramatically worse) And then there is Alabama, which got a group of confederate sympathizing hillbillies’ panties in such a twist that they wrote an entire song praising a racist governor and saying Watergate doesn't bother them. That's reason enough to like it (shout out to Drive By Truckers being removed from the new edition, also. Rest in piss), but it's also the most “rocking” song on the album. It's not even that damning (though if there's anything we should know in the time since this was released, it's that folks who fly the ol' traitor flag are very very sensitive about it), but you can tell Young wants to make his point. It's a shame he backed down on that one. Outside of all that, the dramatic strings of There's a World gives an unexpected mid-album vibe shift, and “Words” gives a little more electrification before the album fades out. But it is one more Neil Young album that manages to both make a case for his legend status and also make a case that he's always been a bit of a doddering old man himself. An uneven but strong ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Ehhh I kinda found it boring

7/10 nie spodziewałam się że mi się spodoba, a spodobało bardzo przyjemne do sluchania, raczej nie jest to typ muzyki jakiego bym słuchała na co dzień, ale jest spoko ulubione piosenki: "...Out on the weekend", "Harvest", "Heart of gold"

Standard Neil Young sound at start. Where will it go... I've had 3 Neil Young albums already, so what could be special about this one to justify its inclusion? Best track - Heart of Gold 3 stars - please don't let there be any more NY

Love it. Grew up hearing songs from this album, it’s great.

favorite tracks: Out on the Weekend, Heart of Gold, Old Man, The Needle and the Damage Done, Words (Between the Lines of Age)

All time fave. This is an actual record everyone should hear

This is such a good album. “Heart of Gold,” in which you can hear the notes and the spaces in between, and “Old Man” are some of the best somgs Young has produced. I seem to use the adjective haunting a lot to describe music I like, so I will describe the sad “Needle and the Damage Done” as funereal.

A very nice album

I remember the album artwork and singles, probably thanks to my father. I enjoy Neil Young but this album in particular didn’t grab me outside of the songs I knew from before.

(Light 8/10) Very good mixture of country folk and rock with excellent songwriting and some of Neil's best songs.

This record is great for a slow weekend morning. I’m not a singer-songwriter person at all, but Neil tiptoes the line for me, and I appreciate that he doesn’t make us sit through a full album of just him and an acoustic guitar. You can tell he has the ability to create robust arrangements for any of his songs and just sometimes decides not to.

I really liked this one. Good chill vibes for good background music.

This was a really enjoyable album. Im already partial to the musician, so I had a feeling id like his work. The album however is a little on the short side but I think the fact I just wanted more is a good sign I really enjoyed the album. Its hard to say it its a four or a five yet though, I'm currently feeling a four.

Neil at his softest - still great, but you can see how he’d fit with the watery limpness of CSN here. Anyway, Harvest (the song) is in my top 5 by him, and Heart of Gold and Old Man are obvious all-timers (if absurdly overplayed).

Зачёт автоматом за песню из Врожденного порока, и пока чувак звучит как ностальгия по неслучившемуся будущему пусть он и дальше собирает урожай моих необъективных оценок