Reviews (page 2 of 15)
Ну можно же писать красивую и интересную музыку с одной акустической гитарой. А когда еще и оркестр вступает, мама миа. Тоже жду Harvest Moon)
Harvest, конечно, не harvest moon, но тоже красиво. На этом альбоме так же есть песня, из-за которой Lynyrd Skynyrd задиссили Нила Янга и написали свит хоум алабамыч.
любимые песни собрались на этом альбоме, потому все таки 4 проставлю
i can see why ppl like him
Not what I expected since I've never really listened to Neil before, The album reminded me a lot of Gary Fanes constellations album. The album is full of sadness, softness and hope. Favourite song/s is out on the the weekend, Alabama, the needle and the damage and words. There is a sense of a loving and losing the past, the moments you had and the people you shared them with but knowing it's not over and although you may never have those moments again, you can have other new ones
Dope
Holds up
En stark trea. Mysigt album och tycker om Neils stämma. Väldigt enkla låtar och lite förutsägbara men positivt överraskad ändå.
7/10
Coño, la realidad es que no me espera que me gustara un album de country tanto
I own this one. Lots of love for this album and I expect that there are more Neil Young albums on this list. Some things I love: "Out on the Weekend" - the single note drone during the chorus; "A Man Needs a Maid" - the first low entrance of the strings of the LSO under the piano in the first chorus and the huge build at the end; "Old Man" - written for a landlord of Young's, but with a message that reaches into the soul of father/son/male relationship dynamics; "The Needle and the Damage Done" - like Tom Petty's "Don't Fade On Me" or Elliott Smith's "Needle in the Hay", a cutting, solitary, emotion filled plea to someone the author deeply cares about, almost uncomfortable in its intimacy. Essential listening. 5 Stars.
Great Stuff
Mediocre sadboy country.
It was a comforting album
Great music, great lyrics, the slightly annoying (but less annoying with repeated exposure) voice keeps it from being a fiver.
5 stars aren’t enough.
Just not for me
Nice fall vibes, sad of course, a little melancholy but bright. Like a warm October afternoon with the light fading but winter is starting to remind you it's coming. I'd only heard the 2 famous songs on here, Heart of Gold (forgot how groovy this one is) and Needle and the Damage Done. Don't especially love his voice, a little to high and reedy. Also a Man Needs A Maid, really?? Stand out tracks: Out of the Weekend, Harvest, Alabama, Heart of Gold
Another artist I have heard of but never actually listened to… and I’ve been missing out! I really enjoyed my first Neil Young experience and will definitely be listening again. I feel like one of my favourite albums, Plans by Death Cab for Cutie, was heavily influenced by NY and was really struck by similar aspects in this album. It’s always good to hear the “first”! I loved NY’s voice and its unusual sound. Matched with great guitars, and some very cinematic-style tracks it was very captivating. I honestly enjoyed every track on this album for one reason or another and feel very late to the NY party! Looking forward to listening to more (apparently he’s the godfather of grunge so I’m excited to hear that segway!) Highlight: NY’s gorgeous tenor voice that at times is ethereal, matched with great lyrics, harmonica and guitars. Gorgeous! Lowlights: I don’t know why fade outs were ever popular. Top tracks: Man needs a Maid, Heart of gold, Needle and the Damage Done. Rating: 4
4.5/5 - love
I didn’t listen to it
Listened to this in bits due to his Amazon boycott ( new fact for me). Genuinely deserves its place on the list. There are some weaker tunes but also 2 or 3 classics. 3.2/5
Yawn. Neil Young's voice does nothing to elevate standard folk style. The only bright spots in the album were the upbeat instrumental segments - which are sadly short lived. The less said about "maids" the better.
Love this album, some great tracks. It’s aged well. I find the lyrics interesting and I enjoy how the instruments build throughout the album. Looking forward to my next listen.
A new discovery for me. I really enjoyed this album and it’s definitely one I’ll revisit. Found myself humming Heart of Gold after listening. Highlights: I actually enjoyed every song on this album but especially the opening track and The Needle and the Damage Done. Rating: 4.0
Could have been a 5, Neil, but Maid is one of the worst songs I've ever heard.
Goes deep
I like the album. Excellent production and heartfelt lyrics.
I'm glad I got a Neil Young album today! Autumn has come and this is my favourite time of year to listen to him :) This isn't a top 5 Neil Young album, mostly due to awkward lows (I think we all know the 2 that don't quite fit here), though I have a growing soft spot for "A Man Needs a Maid", mostly for the parts that aren't the chorus. The other lowish spot besides the two orchestral pieces is "Are You Ready For the Country, which isn't bad, but it's a little slight compared to the other songs here, not much interesting about it. But the highs are obviously really high. The first two songs are two underappreciated favourites of mine, big emotional works for me. "Heart of Gold" is probably one of my all time favourite big Canadian songs, and "Old Man" is up there too. "Alabama" became a pretty polarizing track, and for what it's worth, it's better than "Sweet Home Alabama". The final two songs feel kind of like a suite, I love the instant transition between "Needle" and "Words", and the contrast between the lyrics looking back at one's own self destruction of the former, and the sort of fantastical and vague ones of the latter works really well. Great album!!
a musica que eu mais escutei 1 dia após o maior término que já tive foi heart of gold. música muito importante para mim.
Great album, lots of hits, some classic folk and some more powerful songs as well.
After having just pulled a CSN album from the 1001 a few days ago, I really thing Young is what was missing on that album. His haunting voice and melancholy tone give even his more "upbeat" songs a spooky quality that's perfect for fall- the Harvest time.
Fantastic Album - 5/5
Listened before? Yes Thoughts: - This one is an immediate 5 for me, in large part due to nostalgia. . . It's my dad's favourite album, and one I heard hundreds of times growing up. I was woken up to it blasting throughout the house many times when I slept in too late, and even that didn't make me dislike it 😂 - Hadn't really noticed before, but I kind of laughed at the swing between the normal folk / rock instrumentation of most of the songs, and the dramatic orchestration of "A Man Needs a Maid" and "There's a World." - There's really not a song here I don't love; it's probably my personal favourite that's come up so far in the project. Favorite track(s): Heart of Gold
If you sing like Neil Young, you shouldn't make a bunch of slow, soft ballads
Just like Hotel California a few days earlier this album is a pleasant listen, but aside from ‘Heart of Gold’ never really gets beyond that. It made a fine accompaniment to a sunny autumn Sunday morning, but didn’t remain much in the memory beyond when I was actively listening to it
This has been my favourite of the Neil Young albums so far - probably because it’s not the most obvious sounding Neil Young album. There are moments where it sounds like you’re about to listen to a song in a musical (“There’s a World”); then there are moments it’s stripped back to only an acoustic guitar and hard-hitting lyrics (“The Needle and the Damage Done”). I’ve always loved “Heart of Gold”, especially the backing vocals. None of the other tracks reach that height for me individually, but I enjoyed the album overall.
I still don't like his voice, so the exposure therapy the generator seems to be subjecting me to is clearly failing. The first song: bit boring. The second song: ditto. The third song: a man needs a maid? Fuck off! I actually like the music a lot more, but I was so put out by the lyrics, I think I dislike this the most so far. The fourth song: don't mind it at all, especially when the backing vocals kick in. The fifth song: finally one I'd actually say I like. The sixth song: I quite like but wish it was being sung by almost anyone except Neil (again the backing vocals make this a more enjoyable listen for me). The seventh song: back to the orchestral stuff but this time with lyrics that don't make me want to throw stuff. Like. The eighth song: starting to really run of of patience with his voice, but I don't mind the actual song. The ninth song: I really like the name (The Needle and the Damage Done) and the storytelling, but some of the singing is the most egregious on the record. Last track: is soooooooo looooonnnnngggg. Would have been a 2.5 with half stars probably, but I'm not stretching to a 3, so: 2/5
The highs are very high, with incredible, evocative, and introspective lyrics. Some tracks I just don't personally connect with, and the lows can get a bit dull. I love the production for the most part. As someone who usually loves the use of strings and wind instruments in modern music, I actually prefer the more stripped-down, earthier production to the grand, soaring orchestral sound for this album specifically. There are some gorgeous moments with these arrangements, though. Standout tracks: Out on the Weekend, Heart of Gold, Old Man, Needle and the Damage Done
6-7/10
I'm not a fan of country, but I have a deep soft spot for folk rock (think noah kahan, labi siffre, the waterboys) and so this album was tied between 3 and 4 stars. I hands down adored Old Man and Out on The Weekend, pulled at my heartstrings with a gorgeous melody. The rest were honestly enjoyable, but I wouldn't say I loved them as much. Excited to hear other Neil Young albums.
Huge fan of this album it's been in my rotation before I got it here.
Superb album. Neil has made so many great albums over nearly six decades, but I honestly think is his best.
If you bracket out the two orchestral songs, this is a perfect album. (Neil literally never made another song with that kind of orchestral arrangement, so I argue it's perfectly valid to do so.) More barn!
There are some really good fucking songs on here. He's really good at writing lyrics... the harmonica pisses me off. It sounds really infantile.
Out on the Weekend - 4/5 Harvest - 4/5 A Man Needs a Maid - 3.5/5 Heart of Gold - 4.5/5 Are You Ready for the Country - 3.5/5 Old Man - 4/5 There's a World - 3/5 Alabama - 4/5 The Needle and the Damage Done - 4/5 Worlds (Between the Lines of Age) - 4/5 Neil Young finally broke into the mainstream as a solo artist, and the more "pop"-influenced tracks definitely helped him. Heart of Gold is the most obvious standout, though most of the others on here are also pretty good. Although pulling the London Symphony Orchestra for the worst track on the album is definitely a choice for how overproduced that track is. It's not my favorite Young album that's on the list (that goes to Rust Never Sleeps), but I do understand why it gave Young the credit he deserved. Overall: 4/5 Favorites: Heart of Gold
Moon?
I inherited this on vinyl long ago. Never could get into Neil Young. It's deservedly a classic. Just not my tastes overall.
Just chill country, nothing special
Harvest was better than the first three Neil Young albums I was served, and I enjoyed those... but hopefully it ends here... how much more Neil Young could I possibly need?
Best Track - "Heart Of Gold"
this was pretty good ig, what really surprised me was the big orchestral sections on this album... i'm not really sure if this album needed that. the last song on the album reminded me of the song Rocky Raccoon by the Beatles
Already loved this album lol, Neil Young is the goat. Listened while working on my QGIS homework so not too too focused. Just added Out On the Weekend to the mega playlist! Harvest is great Man Needs a Maid was alright, not my favorite so far Heart of Gold is a classic "And I'm getting old" Are You Ready For the Country had big Muppets vibes lol Love love love Old Man, easily my favorite song There's a World... kinda spooky if I'm being honest Alabama was good, Ohio better The Needle and the Damage Done was probably my favorite new song Ended well too on Words
that’s a man
this album really got y'alls fingers goin, didn't it? bring back fingering instead
Genuinely pleasant
Neil Young at his most approachable and low-key. The album's vibe is nostalgic, plaintive, and melancholy. His two most popular songs- possibly his best, too- with "Old Man" and "Heart of Gold," plus a few really great deep tracks- the emotive and bombastic "A Man Needs a Maid" and the dark anti-drug "The Needle and the Damage Done."
Banger honestly
not bad
Nooit groot fan geweest van Harvest, maar het is wel gewoon een goed folk album, al zijn sommige nummers wel een beetje forgettable
Ik hou hou hou van Harvest. 'On The Beach' was de grote verrassing, van deze wist ik al dat ik het vet vond. Gewoon super mooie folk, beter dan dit wordt het niet in deze stijl. De title track is één van mijn favoriete nummers uit de jaren 70.
One of the best albums of all time. Listen to it many many times.
Loved this. Almost every song has a strong sense of place. Just a joy start to end.
Have I listened to this album before No How familiar am I with this album Somewhat familiar How do I feel about this artist? Sometimes I like Neil Young more than other times Pre-Listen Thoughts: This seems like a really nice album to get right at the start of fall, it’ll be my last album for a week or so because I’m going on vacation so I hope it’s good Favorite track(s): There’s a World Post-Listen Thoughts: I liked this a lot more than Gold Rush. I know Neil Young’s voice isn’t it for everybody, and sometimes it gets old to me but I enjoyed this album.
this has some absolute bops and some absolute opposute of bops, sorry neil
This record gives me peace
LOL. Just finished reviewing yesterday's album, Neil's *Tonight's the Night* which I compared against this. In those notes, I had it in my head that Harvest is the cozy good-feeling record, while Tonight's the Night is the messy damaged record. That's mostly true. From "Out on the Weekend" through "There's a World" there's a lot of warm sounds, the loping rhythms, that thumping throbbing rhythm section that's so locked in that the bass guitar and kickdrum sound like one instrument, the wistful nostalgia of one's twenties and thinking about oneself as one who will become old, sweet piano instrumentation, backing vocals by the soothingest singers in the day, and the London Symphony Orchestra for fuck's sake. "Heart of Gold"! But then it concludes with the blunt anger of "Alabama." Then "The Needle and the Damage Done," the most loveliest song about the devastation of addiction ever, concluding with a jarring stab of applause from a live audience that's cut off abruptly by the menacing paranoia of "Words" and its wild guitar freakout. Those last three songs really elevate this from great album to an astounding classic. I'd forgotten how great this is.
24/09/2026 It was a slow burn this album, it did slowly pick up, but not enough to save it. Spotify listeners: 12.2 million
Iconic, very quirky instrumentation
It’s not Neil’s best but it might be his most accessible. A great entry point.
Wow this was gorgeous, Cheers Neil. Standouts are A Man Needs A Maid, Heart Of Gold and Words.
Perfectly produced. Songs are both compelling and carry emotional weight. Musicianship is on point. Love how the songs are never boring and never feel samey. All-in-all, an excellent collection of Folk Rock tunes and impeccably produced.
My third Neil Young from this list, perhaps the first album of his I became familiar with. I guess his vocal quirks had not started to grate enough. This one I’ll grant as being influential.
Yeahhhh it’s okay!
Man needs a maid may be the most melodramatic song I've encountered thus far. Then it jumps to clean guitar. Then honky tonk piano. The music is all over the place, the only constant is the whiney nasal depressing Kermit the frog vocals. He sings about Country a lot so I'm sure the hicks and yehaws love him
Not the worst Neil Young album I've heard, but I wouldn't choose to listen to this.
Some Neil Young albums have good lyrics and bad singing. This one has some pretty bad lyrics and still has bad singing. The band is great though. That is usually the only saving grace on most of his albums.
Old man en heart of gold zijn wel de enige knallers
Wanne zeikmuziek!!
Prima voor het genre maar ouwe lullen muziek tot de max! Niks voor mij, maar vast voor iemand anders. Geen bangers
I really thought I was making progress with Neil Young, adjusting to his whiny yowl and starting to appreciate his ability to rock out now and then, but then I get handed this one. Pretty certain I have heard this before, or more specifically, I think this is one of the ones that I tried desperately to ignore as I heard it too much while I was growing up. I just found most of this too slow- to mid-tempo; impressive songwriting but just not gripping enough to get me past my issues with the vocals.
Awesome before-sleeping-yellow-light night album w kate and muffin
La harmonics suena bien, me he dormido
Kinda milquetoast and/or low-key, barring a couple of decent tracks overall.
what i didnt really realize i was loving when I listened to dr. dog.
As I said for the previous 3 Neil Young albums. I think he is very talented and I do like the music but his voice/style starts to piss me off after a while. 'Heart of Gold' is incredible though, as is 'Old Man'.
I thought I would hate this album. I didn’t. I didn’t love it though, it was just better than expected. Might even listen to it again someday. 3 stars
Buen álbum. pensé q iba a ser todo country y me emocioné…
Certified classic album for sure. To be honest this is one though that if I had the option to give it 4.5 stars instead I probably would, only because at times Neil Young's voice gets a little mopey to me. But that's a "me" nitpick, as this is still a fantastic album.
I really enjoyed this but honestly had thought I liked this album more than I actually did. Still such a classic with enough 11/10 songs on it to make a 5 out of 5 stars. I will say that sometimes it did feel like a parody of itself. Favorite Tracks: Alabama, The Needle and the Damage Done, Old Man***, Heart of Gold
Annnnd third time’s the charm
Very beautiful
Didn't expect to like it but I was pleasantly surprised. B side in particular was solid
I still don't like Neil Young.
This is a lovely album. Well sung, eell played, heart and doyl went into it by the sound of it.
I liked a couple of songs, but in general I’m not a big fan of country music
Yeah I'll also listen to that again
2/10 damn how many neil young albums are going to pop up
Love Neil Young
Another classic but toned down some. A moment to take a breather and enjoy the music.
Some golden heavyweight oldies which were pleasant to revisit. Made me think of chewing tobacco in a wheatfield in the mid-west, strumming a guitar, with a whiskey in hand. I like the banjos. Overall the same mellow temperature throughout, save for a pleasant symphonic surprise on one of the tracks - but this felt like an unusual peak given the slightly undulating vibe of the album as a whole.
Great album, songs and recording. The best Neil Young album ever, I love the orchestration on some of the songs he and the pure live acoustic energy on “the needle and the damage done”
I enjoyed this. I like Neil Young's voice. I love the songs Old Man and Heart of Gold. It was good.
Thought I'd like it more than I did, struggled to get through it
This was good Neil young, i liked this album.
I know the influence that Neil Young has had on music as a whole. I respect the legacy, however, this album falls short in a lot of places. I don't love the vocals on it, I don't really like the orchestral bits because they sound extremely unnecessary and like...i don't know, "disney music" levels of theater? They're soooo grand and they swallow his vocals and he's singing about simple life topics. I don't know, it's just not for me.
A Man Needs a Maid always makes me laugh - it sounds so overwrought, and it’s just Neil Young moaning about wanting someone to pick up after him. You know what, Neil, I’m a woman and I’d also quite like a relationship where someone does my housework, cooks my dinner and then fucks off back to their own house. Also, I have to imagine There’s a World sounded more epic when you didn’t hear the intro and expect it to go into Hot in Herre by Nelly. But while Harvest may be unintentionally funny and short on feminist anthems, it does have some very good songs.
My first time listening to Neil Young. I liked the fusion of Country music and rock with the orchestral moments. Standouts are There's a world, A man needs a maid and Alabama.
1. uueekend - 2 2. harvezt - 1 3. maid - 1 4. heart - 2 5. ready - 1 6. man - 2 7. uuorld - 1 8. alabama - 2 9. damage - 2 10. uuordz - 1
oh boy, the end of "The Needle and the Damage Done" going into "Words"... it's always stood out to me as sheer brilliance. I don't love "Are You Ready for the Country?" but otherwise this a generational album. Superb.
Out on the Weekend - 9/10. Classic Neil Young folk style. Awesome. Harvest - 8/10. Excellent. A Man Needs a Maid - 9/10. Hauntingly beautiful. Heart of Gold - 11/10. One of the archetypical Neil Young songs. Absolutely perfect. This one goes to 11. Are You Ready for the Country? - 8/10. Even mediocre Neil Young is excellent. Old Man - 11/10. Another archetypical Neil Young songs. As I get older, I feel BOTH sides of this song and how true they are. Absolutely another 11. There's a World - 9/10. This feels like a song from a movie, and I want to watch it. Alabama - 9/10. An uncompromising indictment of the Civil Rights Era South. The Needle and the Damage Done - 10/10. Heartrending. Words (Between the Lines of Age) - 9/10. The start of the harder, more proto-grunge Neil Young. Overall Rating - 4.65/5 (9.30/10). An absolute classic of an album. Exceptional.
Couple of goodies but didn't tickle my pickle.
Classic sound, Old Man I already heard. Can’t get better than the 70s
Estifi qu'on aime Neil Young.
Disclaimer encore sur la thématique artiste vs personne: je suis un grand fan du musicien Neil Young, mais pas un grand fan de l'activiste Neil. Je trouve que ses motivations sont mercantiles, égoïstes et puériles. Out on the week-end: quelle excellente toune de vendredi. Harvest: chills! L'album a une unité vraiment parfaite sur les thèmes de l'errance, la solitude existentielle. Et Neil Young a un style de jeu de guitare et une technique de voix bien à lui qui est difficile à copier. 5 étoiles!
Ok wow la belle découverte. Je connais Neil mais première fois que j'écoute cet album du début à la fin. Et j'y suis revenu plusieurs fois, même le lendemain. Un grand talent pour l'écriture et la mélodie ici avec de gros tubes. Par contre demander d'avoir une maid, ça fait très 72. Arrive dans le présent Neil!
ABURRIDISIMO
Just beautiful
The original doomer
it's OK, kind of bland. Pleasant enough.
I broadly enjoyed this one. I've had quite a lot of Neil Young now, but I've come to appreciate him as an artist. I like how bold and dramatic this album is at times with the added orchestral elements. Overall it's very good musically. I still wouldn't say I'm loving it, but I'm liking and appreciating it.
Beautiful songwriting, voice and sound
First time listening to Neil. It was a very cool vibe of an album, so much so, I added it to my library.
Listening to this again with a new focus with the 1001 list, only cemented it as a classic.
Unassailable peak
Not bad
One of the greatest folk, country albums of all time. Neil can be hit or miss, but this one is all hits, Alabama, Maid, Old Man, Needle. Just the peak of his work. I am biased because my dad also loved this album and would play it, but it’s just great.
Probably his best album. Just not much of a fan.
This is #day760 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… here's to my third Neil Young record already, not counting Neil Young & Crazy Horse. Honestly, I don't get the praise this guy and this particular record get. "Heart of Gold" is the only listenable song here. "Words (Between the Lines of Age)" is a close second. Otherwise, my relationship with Neil Young isn't changing. I just can't get through his atrocious voice. This is a 2 out of 5. Looking forward to #day761.
Liked it
A slow and uninspiring start opens up into a really nice album from heart of gold onwards. Except for A Man Needs A Maid. Someone should talk to Neil about that…
A very slow start, the first three songs were very forgettable. But the final 2/3 of the album was excellent! Lots of good singles. Not as cohesive as On the Beach.
slow but a few great ones
I think this album has a lot of solid songs on it and one I’m very happy to revisit but as a whole album experience I believe it’s just good. Songs like old man and The needle and the damage done are great tracks but even then it’s hard for me to see it Neil Young’s best. Fav songs: out on the weekend, Are you ready for the country, Old man, Alabama, and The needle and the damage done
Great album overall, Old Man is by far the best track. He is a great lyricist and his voice is truly unique.
All time favourite
Two songs shy of a perfect album.
Enjoyed it much more than expected. I don’t think I really knew his voice sounded like that. Some really great pops of instruments like the strings and harmonica were particular highlights. The second half did feel weaker than the first. It’s a relatively short album but did still have a dip
I liked the first and last song of the album quite a bit and heart of gold is very famous but besides that the album was a bit boring
Only 300 albums in and this is the third Neil Young album.. Not that he's bad, but it's a lot.
Nice listen - not a huge Neil Young fan, but he’s growing on me. Great production that really works for these songs, not hard to see why so many people love this album.
Incredibly well made album, has such good diversity throughout its runtime. The songwriting here is excellent, and almost every song is catchy in one way or another. Also, the instrumentation is outstanding, very forward-thinking with its execution. No surprise that this album is a 10/10.
What the hell is A Man Needs A Maid really about? Such a weird-ass song, like the lyrics are weird, then the music is, like, symphonic? The fuck? Young must've gotten a deal on theatrical symphony players 'cause then we get hit with There's a World which is, uh, like the overture of some fantastical movie that's, like, your life or something? I dunno but it's a little rich. All the other tracks are crucial Young. The movie songs are weird; I like the rest of it.
Not my jam. The songs aren’t great and he’s a terrible singer.
I can't unread the comment that said he sounds like Kermit the Frog. This album is great, full of classic, fleshed-out, earthy tracks. I can see why it is such a hit, some of the songs are very beautiful. There isn't really any filler songs, so it makes for a consistent listen without losing my attention. Overall, I rate this a 4/5, because it's not a love-at-first-listen for me.
Neil Young has a voice that epitomizes that gentle hippie 1970 vibe. This album has some of his better known songs. And some really crazy songs like every man needs a maid. (WTH?)
I thought I had heard this going; turns out it was Harvest Moon I knew. Still, I knew a couple of songs. It's pure Boomer, which is fine when it's good. This tries to sabotage itself with its Country leanings and Young's often not great vocals, but it remains an indelible slice of 20th Century US culture.
Don’t like his voice
Han er virkelig god når han er god, men nogle af sangene bliver lidt for kedelige. Neil Young har ofte været lidt for poleret i stemmen, hvilket godt kan ødelægge den charme hans sangskrivning ellers har. Det tager lige et lille nyk af en ellers fantastisk samling af sange
Heart of Gold fed. Old man fed. Alabama fed. Samlet bare rimelig fed
*92 Nøj det kan jeg godt lide. Høj klasse. Det trækker selvfølgelig heller ikke ned at gode gamle Crosby, Stills & Nash fungerer som backing vokal på nogle af de underskønne tracks.
Synes det er lidt kedeligt for at være ærlig. Jeg har ikke rigtig noget forhold til Neil Young. Synes en del af det lyder svedigt nok, men ikke nok til at jeg rigtigt får lyst til at høre det mere. 3 pæne *EDIT*: Den får 4 efter endnu en gennemlytning. De store bangers trækker op her.
Neil "YOUNG" but he's an "OLD man"??? 🤔🤔🤔🤔 4.9
Egentlig ikke specielt vild med Neil Young. Heller ikke ligefrem min genre. Men kan alligevel ikke komme uden om, at det er et mesterværk.
Amazing album!!!
Masterpiece
I went through this period in my early 20s where everyone I knew was into Neil Young so I bought this album. I get it, it's really good, but it never clicked for me the way it clicked for other people.
Old Man ( it's me)
Only criticism was the cinematic type classical bits. Did not mesh well.
There really was a sweet spot when the post-Summer of Love cynicism was setting in and folk artists were still trying to pry meaning out of the rubble of the collapsed counterculture. Anyway, this is the best album ever made.
A perfect example of his singer-songwriter side
Few hits on here, wuite good but otherwise very droning uneventful work
Really enjoyed
Excellent album, though not my favorite of his. Never get sick of Neil.
4/10 not my favourite I had it on in the background and all the songs sounded very similar to me, also not sure Young's voice has a quality i vibe with massively Not bad tho
like some songs
I'm looking forward to a modern re-listening to the album that contains Neil Young's greatest song, The Needle and the Damage Done. We have 3 great songs and a bunch of OK music filling out the album. I would call the album, "uneven".
Surprisingly, I had never listened to this album before. Of course, I was excited that it was an album by Neil Young and even more so when I saw Heart of Gold, Old Man, and The Needle and the Damage Done were on this album. But many of the song titles were unfamiliar. I thought that I would probably recognize them when they started playing. But I did not - apparently I have never heard more than half the songs on this album. Don't tell anyone! Amazing album and clearly belongs on this list. Gems that I discovered: "A Man Needs A Maid" (wow, the lyrics seem inane and potentially offensive, but the song is great) and "Words (Between the Lines of Age)" which is simply amazing. Not sure why Words does not seem to be on Live Rust or any of the greatest hits albums?
Album got better as it got going
Not bad, but a bit too much Neil Young in this list. 7/10
Fantastic album. Neil is one of my all-time favorite artists, and this album has many phenomenal tracks, exemplifying this era of his work influenced by rock, country, and folk.
I simply cannot fault Neil on this one
- Nice chill vibe - Kinda got boring like I could zone out listening to it - only liked two songs - not my type of music
soothing & mellow
Favorite Song: Old Man
Neil's output over the years is pretty uneven, but when he hits it, he hits it. This is a certified masterpiece, part of the incredible run of Everybody Knows This is Nowhere, After the Gold Rush, and this one. It isn't until 1992 with Harvest Moon he made another album this beautiful. Just preachy enough, still with a great heart.
Neil Young writes and performs these songs like he’s at least twice his age.
It's so beautifully simple. Neil's got a hypnotizing voice i just sunk into. There are two songs that seem very out of place to me, but maybe I just don't get it yet. Anyhow, Words (Between the Lines of Age) may just be one of my favorite songs ever.
JL : 2, Out on the Weekend
Bajo
10
Nice album but short
das gin schnell, schon ok? war Neil young der grunge Gott Vorbild? c
Not my favorite NY album, but an absolute 70s folk-rock-country-blues mesh classic of pain, grief, longing and regret.
Really liked this acoustic folksy album.
It'd be great to have this one on vinyl.
It's another day with Neil Young again. Him, David Bowie, Bob Dylan, The Rolling Stones, and The Beatles are about half of this generator's discography. Honestly, this is probably his best album, even if it does have a bit too much Country. It has one of his biggest hits, and has an overall strong finish. He was finally able to mesh his gifted songwriting with enjoyable melodies. Favorite Track: "Old Man".
I've heard a few of these songs when I was a kid in the 70s. It's a crime that i waited this long to hear this album after all of these years. Very well written melodies. At 57, I finally understand what the beef was with Lynard Skynard...."I hope Neil Young will remember..." Anyway, loved the album!
Oikein mainio
Liian vetelää puuroa.
Hyvä on, on hyvä.
Jos oli edellinen Nipan levy erinomainen, niin tämä on sitten vielä pykälää parempi. Ihan hemmetin hienoja biisejä.
Pretty good
Look, I'm probably never gonna give Neil Young 5 stars. He's just not my favorite artist. But I can recognize a solid album when I hear one, and this is empirically his best. High 4.
I feel like my man Neil couldnt decide if he wanted to be folk or rock.
In my Neil Young renaissance earlier this year, I found that while Harvest was an album contained many of my favorite songs he's ever made (Out on the Weekend, Words, Alabama), the overall album experience didn't quite resonate with me fully. I really dislike the two orchestral tracks, "Man Needs a Maid" and "There's a World," and couldn't even really say why. Something about the mood of those songs really irks me, and just doesn't fit in well with the pastoral grubbiness I like about the rest of the album. That being said, when it's good, it's GOOD. "Out on the Weekend" is one of my favorite songs of all time; "Heart of Gold" is timeless; "Old Man" is a little overrated, but still great; "Alabama" is astounding; and "Words" closes the album on such an epic and sprawling high note. Fav Tracks: Out on the Weekend, Heart of Gold, Alabama, Words (Between the Lines of Age) Least Fav: There's a World Score: 7.5
It’s really hard for me to separate Neil Young’s grating voice from the music, so it’s hard to tolerate listening to this objectively. The music is alright I suppose, but I had to skip through quite a few of the songs on this album before my ears bled. (2)
day 1: not my style. fav: old man
Possibly his best. At least my favorite so far. Great hits on this this album
Banger. Best Neil Young album in my opinion. I can't give it a 5 though. There were several songs I didn't love.
Pretty viby, John Mayer wishes
I was underwhelmed this time around... I love the orchestra on A Man Needs a Maid, but why that song? It's like he only booked an orchestra for two songs and this was the one he chose?
The perfect album that haunted the rest of Neil’s creative career. May not be my favorite Young record but damn if it isn’t the perfect expression of the early 70s Laurel Canyon sounds. There’s whimsy, love, and the pain of being a young man . Plus freaking Alabama, what an iconic kiss off track! (Sorry Lynyrd Skynyrd…). Spent the rest of his career being compared to it and begged to repeat it, that had to be a weight. Sorry man, the ball and chain of finding perfection.
Children of the corn
I'm beginning to think Young is Canada's Bob Dylan. They have a lot of parallels in their career. Both have political songs. Both tend to have non-conventional singing voices & play harmonica. Both had run of records around the 80s that are less than stellar. Although Neil's was to fulfill his record contract. I thought the album was kind of middling but still good. Very depressing & somber. Does Neil Young suffer from depression? It's kind of sounds like it on some tracks. 3
9/10
Ich summe ein Lied von ihm 🫠
Never really listened to this album in its entirety. I was actually quite disappointed. I expected a LOT more . I felt like it was building to an expectation that never really delivered. That said, there were no weak songs and a lot of notable songs, but I was expecting an easy 5 stars and it does not live up to that. It starts of well with Out on the weekend (I am a sucker for a harmonica), and keeps your interest with the well know songs of Heart of Gold and Old Man. Of the songs I was not familiar with, Alabama stood out. The album ended perfectly with words. Standout song outside of old Man was Alabama. 4 stars
8/10. I actually thought I would like this album more. It is very well regarded as far as I can tell. And there are mostly good songs here: Heart of Gold, Old Man, Words, Harvest. But there's also some real stinkers. There's a World isn't great. A Man Needs a Maid is yuck. Doesn't even really seem self aware or cheeky, just whiny and sexist. Alabama is a great song, but as far as activism goes it feels a little half-assed and insincere. Overall I liked it, but its definitely not a perfect album.
Um ótimo disco de folk/rock. Agradável, diversificado, bem harmônico. Da aquela sensação real de início, meio e fim, e a última música é sensacional.
The dad rockiest dad rock to ever dad rock. I mean for me that's all it is. Inoffensive but uninspiring classic rock. I'm not gonna complain about hearing it, but I'd never seek it out. Nice guitar work, but overall very middling for me.
I liked this. 4/5
A great album from Mr Young.
Some better songs and singing here but a bit too folky in places.
Simply packed full of great songs. Neil at his acoustic chilled best.
Good stuff. Not a huge fan of his voice but the songs shine anyways
There's some absolute gold on this album - you might say it had a heart of it - but Young's other albums rock harder than this and he can't quite capture the right energy or mood for all-out folk. On the best tracks the minimal arrangements serve to highlight the wonderfully contemplative lyrics, but on mistakes like A Man Needs a Maid ... the lyrics don't really benefit from being highlighted.
Good album with some great hits on it. I'm not floored, but heart of gold and a few others make it hard to rate low. Still not a 5 though?
Was looking forward to listening to this classic album for the first time (!). Apart from the well known tracks (5 stars) I was a bit underwhelmed by the rest - easy listening Neil?!
My favourite thing about this album is you can from a song that's basically one man and his guitar, to another song that's just one man and the bloody London Symphony Orchestra, not once, but twice. The LSO tracks were definitely the stand out and made me enjoy this more than other Neil Young albums I've heard. 3.75* rounded up to 4*
A mix of historically great songs and absolute duds. The duds are admirably ambitious, though.
Now this is an album! Kind of like Lucinda's Car Wheels, this would be in my Top 10 of all times lists. Great stuff all the way around.
Lots of depth here beyond the hits. There are a couple tracks that don't resonate with me, but those are exceptions. In the top 3 of his records for me.
4/5 - I like Neil Young when he's more cantankerous than wistful, but no denying this is some classic shit here.
It was fine. A little whiney and some songs were questionable, like the one about the Maid. Some bangers, but not enough to bring the whole album to 5 stars.
me gustó. tranqui, suave. no sabia que conocía old man. me gustaria volver a escucharlo
Such a beautiful simple songwriting style. Mostly pretty simple presentations of the material. Grows and feels slightly more epic at the right moments. I didn't think I had that strong a relationship with this record, but the songs all feel like old friends
Best Neil Young album of all time. Simply amazing.
Neil's best album imo, a classic. Favorite track: the needle and the damage done other picks: out on the weekend, heart of gold, old man
This album disappointed me a little bit. I had high hopes, but I found Neil Young's voice to be a poor match for the highly dramatic mood of several songs, and I didn't like anything as much as I like "Harvest Moon." Not even close! Still, it was generally not unpleasant (maybe even pleasant?).
folksy, bluesy, country-ish, rock-ish. this album is a nice blend of a little everything
Gracioso. Uno de los mejores álbumes de country fue hecho por un canadiense.
Onderdeel van m'n leven
perfecte 3.5
Congratulations! You've made it through 4 of the 7 Neil Young records on this list! How are you feeling? Do you require nourishment? Alcohol? Medical assistance? Once again, half a great record mired by half a half-assed record,in my opinion. 3.75/5.
A solid Neil Young effort on this folk and country rock album. A few classics, a fairly lean 37 minutes. There’s a few songs I could toss (I don’t think the orchestral arrangements do him well), but largely tracks 4 - end are spot on. Finds a nice, simple groove with the band, but no heavy-onslaught rock. A few of just the man and his guitar. It’s not my top choice Neil, but it’s still Neil in great form.
Truly a great album; just not my favorite.
Great voice and instrumentals slower oldie vibe favs: heart of gold und old man
he was in his danny elfman bag for man needs a maid and there's a world. kinda brings the album down a bit, but still so so so so good... we wouldnt have alex g without neil young so im happy to gas him up :)
This is my 3rd Neil Young album and, honestly, I'm finding it tough to find much more to say about the tracks individually; I still don't know anything about harmonies, symphonies, scales, sequence, phrases and all the rest of it. Neil very much has his own style that has carried through these 3 albums (After the Gold Rush / On the Beach / Harvest), leaving a lowly music listener like me to only write down my favourite tracks and slap a number on this puppy. His style, though, is one that has grown on me as the albums have creeped past; I wasn't overly fond of After the Gold Rush in the end, but loved On the Beach. Let's see how this fairs. "Harvest", "A Man needs a Maid", "Heart of Gold", "Old Man", "There's a World", "Alabama", "Words (Between the Lines of Age".
Never got Neil young and I don’t think I ever will. This does however sound newer than it is
Enjoyed this more than I expected to, some really nice songs here. Also some that didn't seem to fit the album as a whole but whatever you fancy Neil.
Young is an iconoclast. His songwriting is top shelf, as always. Here, he goes big with orchestration from some epic movie — strings, bells, harp — and it works! The storytelling is compelling and organic. Lyrics are unforced and do not comply with usual pop song strictures. He tells a story and the rhymes land where they do. His own vocals are aided by adding Linda Ronstadt on backup harmonies. This is a classic that I’ll add to the desert Island collection. A 5.
5eme album avec NY proposé par le générateur. Pas mieux que les 4 autres, rien d'original. Aucune envie de l'écouter une seconde fois. =>2/5
Pretty nice album. The songs here are all pleasant, but it never gets better than Heart of Gold. Old Man comes close though. The use of orchestras at times is welcome, it makes for powerful songs.
I thought this was Dennis DeYoung
What I expected: an album full of pastoral, introspective folk songs. What I got: an incredibly mixed bag, ingredients being: - A few kind of pastoral folk songs, ranging from good to great. - Two country rock masterpieces (Alabama and Words) - Two alright bluesy tracks - A bit of overly bombastic orchestral bullshit which does not fit Neil's voice or style at all. Three stars, I suppose? Very strange album to rate, with its contents being so incredibly varying in quality.
awesome
100
typical Neil Young. Its a bit meh, but Heart of Gold is still a classic so extra point for that
Its got some alright neily stuff But god i hate his voice
While listening to “Heart of Gold” the car in front of me had its turn signal blinking to the tempo of the song. That was a 5/5 experience on a 4/5 album.
Nästan en femma, men han skulle inte haft med låtarna med orkester.
Nope. Still don't like Neil Young. I had to sit through Heart of Gold on the muzak at a job many years ago, countless times. Now, in the context of the entire album, I can say that my problem is not the songs themselves. It's his vocals. They sound like an endless whine to me. I don't think I'll ever get past it.
😃
I mean, it's another Neil Young album. I love Neil Young and this is a great album but I could use some more variety.
Some bangers, some dullards.
Heart of Gold. Sounds a bit different than regular Neil Young but still carries his charms and sound.
‘Harvest’ feels like a zeitgeist album to me. Young takes everything he has done musically before and drops it into a newly created musical context that the public couldn’t get enough of. Add to that a selection of songs that, in typical Neil Young fashion, address his personal feelings but with enough mystery to make them seem universal, except this time the people of the US and beyond were already feeling the same as he was. World weary, the dream of the 60s long gone, and the effects of the Nixon presidency had more than Neil Young dealing with depression. The mood is understandably ponderous, low-key, largely down-tempo, and underpinned throughout with an undeniable melancholy. The trick though is to turn all of that into something of immense beauty, but it’s a trick that Neil Young and his assemblage of Stray Gators (and occasionally the London Symphony Orchestra) pull off over and over again across ‘Harvest’. The success of the album may have ended up feeling like a burden causing Young to consider it middle-of-the-road and to (in his words) head for the ditch over his next few albums, but ‘Harvest’ is MOR in radio friendly recording quality alone. The content is heavy going, but like many masterpieces, everything is in the balance.
Ye haw or something
really nice album. A couple of his really well known songs are on this album (Heart of Gold, Old Man). Not one of his best in my opinion but overall still very good. Not one I would buy so probably a 3 star rating
This a great Neil Young album. I say that but I don't really ever dig deep down into Neil Young albums. Most of the time that I hear him its mostly the hits. That said, when it comes time to listen to an album like this you already know some of the songs. The rest of the songs on the album fit really well around these two bigger songs. The sound does not change much throughout which plays into how good it is. I am not going to deep dive lyrics here but definitely worth a listen. Biggest Hit - Heart of Gold Biggest Miss (if I had to choose) - There's A World Not So Hidden Gem - Out On the Weekend
Amei.
One of those albums I recognise from the cover without ever having listened to it before. Very mellow, and of its 70s era. Not sure about the two tracks with the orchestra which seemed like bolt-ons. But otherwise quite enjoyed.
Surprised at just how much of this I liked, definitely needs more listens.
Not bad, not good, just boring.
Ha can't fucking sing but he can write a song
One banger after another.
2.7/5 Some really great songs and some just ok ones.
Alabama feud
The first Neil album that's not getting a five. Great songs on here, but I don't like the more theatrical stuff he indulges. "A Man Needs a Maid" doesn't really fit on a record that also has "Out on the Weekend" (maybe my favorite NY song of all. Love how he takes a huge shit all over Alabama though.
I think I've come to terms with the fact that Neil Young is a bit shit Heart of Gold is pretty good, but that's as far as my appreciation for this album goes
My blood boils every time I get another goddamn Neil young album from this list.
Malheureusement un album classique du Rock, pas très bon avec des toune classiques également pas très bonnes, sauf la sept et la neuf, ce qui rajoute peut-être une étoile à cet album médiocre.
Quand même chill, c’est vraiment un classique
For some reason this one didn't hit quite as hard as the other Neil albums we've gotten so far in this challenge, but make no mistake, this is still an excellent album, rife with all the pain and strife of Neil's life at that point in time.
Ehhhhhh Neil ain’t for me
Every Neil Young album has him pouring his whole damn heart and soul out as I inevitably sit there not knowing what to do with it. I dunno. I can't seem to engage with his music in the way I at least can with, for example, Bob Dylan's. Standout: Heart of Gold
If ever an album were in need of a remaster, surely it's this one. I didn't expect to have to blast a Neil Young album to get the full flavor and hear everything but here we are. There are one or two inexplicable land mines on the album (hello A Man Needs a Maid) but this is outweighed by the absolute classics of Heart of Gold, Alabama and Old Man. I wish the entire album was of that quality but I don't actually think this is his best work. I think Neil Young is doing his best with Crazy Horse. But this is good stuff.
I'm not particularly familiar with Neil Young, so I was very caught off guard (not in a bad way) by some of the crashing build ups that feel very cinematic. I don't know what I thought Neil Young music was supposed to sound like, but I'm now forced to reconsider. Interesting listen!
Listened to this on vinyl! A good one.
Nostalgia inducing. Some songs I truly love on this album. Old Man and The Needle ...
Me encantó este álbum, me encanta como los instrumentos juegan un papel principal es bastante melancólico bastante sentimental
Neil at his country best
Exceptional album from the master.
Singer-songwriter stuff usually does not appeal too much to me, but with this album, I liked what I heard more and more as I was progressing. Young successfully plays with country motives, various instruments, incorporates backing vocals that even reminded me of gospel. The music is very warm, Sourtern American-like, and all through the record it could be felt that the author has a good taste in music and knows how to do both the instrumentals and his singing well. So I was sure it was a B, but in the end I found that I added literally half of this record, and also the closing track "Words (Between the Lines of Age)" has exceptional solo parts. Overall a highly enjoyable album with masterful changes between the moods and styles, which is why I'd call it singer-songwriter music done right. A–.
very american, and slightly cinematic
Not my favorite Neil Young record. His voice sounds extra whiny against the country backbone, though I deeply appreciate his ability to work through difficult moments in health. Very Matisse, very much the work of a dedicated creative. I wish it had elements beyond the lyrics that I could appreciate, and frankly, there's a couple of songs I wouldn't mind never hearing again. On the plus side, this is one of my highest rated country-forward records so far on this albums generator, and I'm about to hit my first year. Good job, Neil. Even when I don't like your shit, I'm a fan. 2.9/5
Legendary artist. Not my favorite songs by him, but there’s a reason he has endured so long.
If you know "Heart of Gold" you know the rest of the album. Not bad, but not very interesting either.
Solid. I liked the later tracks the most though that was probably because they were rock leaning. Down-tempo folk songs rarely do it for me. "Man Needs A Maid" gets a special shout out for being the song I have the most mixed feelings about. I think I get was he was going for (Young doesn't literally think that women belong in the kitchen, he's just sad that he's without his lady) but unfortunately the sentiment reminds me of my (not very capable) exes. Weird mixing in the back half of that track.
Well, another album I know but don't know. Five of these songs I know (well) and five I might as well never have heard before, even though I'm pretty sure I've listened to this album all the way through a few times in my life. Listened to as an album, a singular theme really comes through. Neil's been treated badly and now "a man" needs a pickup, a new place to live, a farm, a maid, or something or someone. I guess he's not really sure. Should he keep searching for love? Is he ready for the country? Does he need a preacher? Is it time to die? A lot of this feels on the surface like a yearning for and maybe even a celebration of a simpler time but the message throughout is that the promise will not lead to fulfillment. The introduction to "A Man Needs a Maid" is so reminiscent of "After the Goldrush" from two years before, both heavy with melancholy. The lyrics start out with him rejecting love for a seemingly more pragmatic arrangement, then he falls in love with an image on a screen, and he ends with a forlorn "When will I see you again...?" It's a surprisingly sad album as a whole, sort of Neil saying "we reap [harvest] what we sow" and maybe in that sense "A Man Needs A Maid" contains a note of self-recrimination, too. I'm not sure I fully understand what the song "Harvest" is about, but it evokes regret over something that didn't turn out well, whether it is the relationship of the girl with her mother or the narrator with either or both. The "promise of a man" is a lie, at best a well-intentioned one, but it never had a chance of bearing fruit. Musically, it is surprising that this acoustic "country" themed album ends up having some songs with simple instrumentation, like "Harvest," and some have far more complex arrangements and meandering structures. Only a few of the songs rock, and nothing rocks even close to, for example, "Cowgirl in the Sand." It makes sense if you think of it as an album about being lost, paying the price for your decisions in life, and starting to lose hope of ever finding your way. A good album that was a lot more than I initially took it for. Essential listen: not sure, probably not Desert Island Disc: no, too depressing for someone who is already lost
Тут попадається вдруге. Мені здається, що цей альбом подобається більше ніж попередній.
I really enjoyed listening to Neil Young's voice and some songs in this album really took me by surprise due to how out of pocket they were. great vibes overall.
i think the only song that really stands out to me on this album is old man, but boy do i love that song. that alone gives this album some extra stars, but i do have to take it down a peg because the rest of it wasn’t particularly standout to me. i enjoyed listening, but it didn’t do much besides stay pleasant for me.
Autumn has just begun, haystack bales are being constructed into a maze, and the breeze is making the air smell crisp and cool. The piano sounds like it's being played in a farmhouse living room with the doors propped open. Harvest hit me right where it needed to and i'm sure if I listened to it any other day I wouldn't give it a 5. However the melodies, lyrics, and warm acoustic guitars paint a beautiful album from start to finish and keep it interesting by incorporating female vocals, orchestras, pianos, the whole lot every other track. Brilliant simple folk.
Country blues pas désagréable
Oui !
J'ai hésité entre 3 et 4 mais je reste sur 3 car peut être un peu trop lent
Lovely album 4/5