Reviews (page 8 of 8)
Low-key amazing debut album. Mixing glam rock with electronica. Awesome.
7/10
Van ser una de les grans alegries que ens va deparar la primera meitat dels 00's. Havíem tingut pocs anys abans la recuperació del rock com a moviment cool de la mà dels Strokes, White Stripes, Kings of Leon, etc, i estava a punt d'arribar la recuperació de la new wave per part de Franz Ferdinand, Hot Hot Heat, Bloc Party, etc. Entre uns i uns altres, Jake Shears, Ana Matronic i cia es van treure de la màniga aquets treball tan absorbent i disfrutable. Gairebé tots els temes tenien esperit de single, cada un millor que l'altre. Entre tots ells, sobresurtia l'experiment tan exitós en què van convertir 'Comfortably Numb' de Pink Floyd. Tan insolent com irressistible, va ser "la" cançó del 2004
My view in 2004: Laura is a 5 star song. The Pink Floyd cover is good. Other songs are OK in general, but a bit too much pastiche. My view in 2023: exactly the same, and I do not feel this album belongs to the list despite its sale success. Score: 5/10.
Heard the name before, but never checked out their music. This actually was a pretty good album with strong, well executed songs. Very enjoyable.
Not sure whether to take this seriously but it is overall not a bad listen.
Les Scissor Sisters ont été adoptées par Elton John et les Bee Gees, et l'influence de cette co-parentalité se ressent à chaque instant à l'écoute de cet album de coiffure-pop.
Les soeurs ciseaux nous ont proposé un excellent album de coiffure pop. Les contours sont absolument impeccables, et un bon volume de chevelure est conservé sur le dessus. Les soeurs ciseaux nous proposeront d'ajouter de la cire en touche finale, que nous refuserons poliment, avant de regler la prestation avec le sourire. Un super moment passé en compagnie de toute l'équipe.
3.5 - Back in the early 2000's, with the advent of legal and unfettered access to ALL music, there was this surge in bands whose seemingly sole purpose was to recombine nuggets from passé genres unearthed within the depths of YouTube. This album reflects that rummaging spirit, melding Elton John-informed piano balladry ("Marie") with Pink Floyd-styled psych-prog ("Return to Oz") with bits of 70's swamp-funk. A thick irony binds everything together as well as lots of cheeky falsetto. Mostly this sounds like the playlist for a "Pimps 'N' Hoes"-themed house party.
Colin Farrell introduced them on snl
Scissor sisters is one of those bands that sounds great for a few songs, but gets old. It's fucking catchy in places though. A lot of it sounds vaguely like other songs, like if Elton bummed Bowie, but in a good way. 4/5.
Didn’t care then and, after listening again, I don’t care now, sadly. I was hoping to dig it.
It's fun to take a non-disco song from the disco era and do a disco cover. I'm sure a lot of Pink Floyd fans cringed but I liked it.
The album gets off to a terrible start with the faux R&B vocalist and a couple of songs that sound contrived. The “Staying Alive” version of Comfortably Numb is a nice novelty track. It’s interesting that this American band barely cracked the Billboard 200 but went 9X Platinum in the UK. I side with the Americans.
A blast from the recent past.. forgot about this album and band really, but their hits are instantly remembered and the album is actually really good. Deserves to be on this list.
Funky pop, fun but okay overall. Did not like the voice
Filthy/Gorgeous gives me memories of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater games.
Fun in places, but just feels messy in others.
Take Your Mama is one of the greatest singles of all time.
Reminds me of a very specific time in mu life. I actually think it pretty solid catchy pop, the opening 4 tracks are great and the ending track is same level
I've heard of the Scissor Sisters, but I couldn't tell you from where. Listening to the album it was hard to determine the time frame when it was released. There is a mix of disco, and late 90s alternative. There were parts of the album that were okay, but several tracks that I don't want to hear again because of the content. The music was okay.
It was fine. I’d give it more of a review, but I don’t really want to. It was fine.
At least it's over and I don't have to listen to this again.
I'd only ever heard I can't decide by this band and I had no idea that they were from the early 2000s. I assumed that it was an 80s thing but after listening to this whole thing I can see the early 2000s vibes. It was pretty good overall, with the first half being way better than the second half, and was a fun 2004-version-of-synth/glam-rock type thing. My favs were Laura and take your mama and the comfortably numb cover was my least fav.
So this was definitely a strange one that I couldn't decide how to rate. Basically, I was stuck anywhere between 2 and 5 for the first few tracks - the cover of Comfortably Numb, the original of which I absolutely love, was actually painful to listen to the first time. Given these mixed feelings, I gave it a second spin the day after. This second spin let me enjoy the most enjoyable parts more and see the other parts in the context of the whole - important for such a strange album. It's actually some sort of wild pastiche, somewhere inbetween Elton John, Appollo 440, Dire Straits and Depeche Mode. All artists I enjoy, but vastly different from each other. It took time to get into Scissor Sisters. But after the second spin, I'm convinced.
I have questions. Two and a half stars
Eh
Didn't do much for me.
A bit too happy for me. But ok, Take your Mama. Great song, at least as a party song
Thumping! Laura starts with the big hooky swinging and I am here for it. The lead singer's voice is so fucking high. Lovers In The Back Seat has so much groove. THERE AIN"T NO TITS ON THE RADIO!!
It was alright! I liked a few tracks more than others.
3.25
Pretty good overall.
Well... am I a fan of the falsetto? The comfortably numb cover is not my favorite. Ugh. There are a bunch of other albums that are rated at a 3 that are worse than this. But I just can't get why you'd want to do a bee-gees version of Comfortably Numb. Did disco have a renaissance that I didn't know about?
Solid and fun. The first few bars of Laura are incredibly catchy and just have me bouncing along. A lot of the other track and similarly fun and a bit of a modern, peppy electronic elton john. I was intrigued by their Comfortably Numb cover, but that was probably the track that landed least with me. Still enjoyable.
It had been a long time since I listened to this fun album
Not exactly a masterpiece, but does exactly what it sets out to do: to be a relatively simple but well-crafted pop album! Love the production and instrumentation throughout (manages to be extremely catchy without being overly simplified), and while the lyrics weren’t anything to write home about, the vocalists all hold their own weight well. Definitely will give this a re-listen soon! (Favorite Tracks: Take Your Mama, Lovers in the Backseat, It Can’t Come Quickly Enough)
Alright alright. Sounds like nothing of its time. Bee Gees and Elton John meet the 2010s. Except it was 2004.
Pretty overrated imo. Bought this album on hype when it came out and this was the first time I had ever heard the whole thing. 2/5
Pop
I prefer Twisted Sister
bad aged
Fun as hell.
The Scissor Sisters should not be on a must-listen list of this depth and breadth. They are not original, they are not interesting, entertaining, ground-breaking or special, it's paint-by-numbers pop masquerading as alternative and it's just sinfully boring, annoyingly overplayed and they bastardised Comfortably Numb, making me uncomfortably angry. 1, fuck off.
A real mixed bag, this. Some funky electro pop, a couple of nice ballads, a fair bit of trash, and an excruciating cover of Comfortably Numb. Just squeaks a 3 on the strength of most of the first half, but that does feel pretty generous (and probably helped by me being a teenager when this came out).
Veel positivisme. Kon het pop-gehalte wel smaken
I don't know if this album was so good or if I was just happy to not listen to the previous one. That being said, I did thoroughly enjoy every song.
first time listening i liked the first half of the album better than the back half
Energetic, fun, irreverent and, really, who hasn't wanted to know what Tits On The Radio sound like?
Fav filthy/gorgeous Least fav Mary I was very uncomfortable listening to this idk why. Maybe I just don’t like the genre?
This is one of the first albums I ever downloaded from Limewire. (I got so many viruses on my computer...) It's actually relieving to see something on the list that I've heard before. Of course, I haven't heard it in ten years, but it was a fun romp down memory lane. I remember putting this on a mix for an ex-girlfriend and thinking I was really cool. (I wasn't really cool.) Anyways. Great album. Perfect for driving. Kids dug it. Great vibes all around. Lots of attitude.
Great surprise here. Awesome songs that defy genre.
Pretty average
3/5. The first half of the album contains some very important and danceable songs. The second half is a little less fortunate. Also, as innovative the Comfortably Numb song is, hard to beat the original. Best Song: Take Your Mama.
Better than I remembered
'twas aight
Cool, I got an album that was missing! I didn't expect it to be so electronic, as I didn't read the genres before listening, but it was cool. This was pretty good. A couple songs I disliked, but I think I quite enjoyed the sound overall. I definitely have more interest in this band than I did before. My favourite songs were Laura and Comfortably Numb.
I had no clue what was up with this group before hearing this and was surprised at how poppy it was. Lots of Prince, MJ, and Bowie influence here, but I think those artists just do it much better. 4/10
4 stars
This record is weird though not altogether terrible. IMHO it ranges from ‘sort of comedic but still not good’ (Tits On The Radio) to awful (Laura) to reprehensible (Comfortably Numb like WTF seriously) then later kind of Bran-Van eclectic (Filthy/Gorgeous, though TBF they don’t quite pull this off) to ‘hey that’s not /bad/“ (Music Is The Victim, It Can’t Come Quickly Enough) I’m really confused haha
Good, kind of dancey. I think I’m legally obligated to give this at most a 4 since I’m not gay, though.
These songs suggest - if they don't demand - more radical hairstyles. Nevertheless, Scissor Sisters is a bright debut which fairly rounds itself out.
Loses steam towards the end
Good album, high energy and original
I own this album, but this is my first time listening to it from start to finish (I'm pretty sure I bought it just for their cover of "Comfortably Numb," but I eventually also fell in love with "Take Your Mama"). I'm so mad at myself for not having listened to all of this album sooner, because I really enjoyed it. Every song has so much going on lyrically, but every song is also really fun instrumentally. I'm a big fan of keyboards and synthesizers, and the keyboards here are fantastic, giving each song a familiarity of disco, while still managing to create a very unique sound. "Take Your Mama" is my favorite track on this album, and lyrically, it's just absolutely brilliant; the band does a great job of taking such a serious topic as coming out to a family member, but stripping away all of the anxiety, and just jumping in with both feet. Pure mastery as far as I'm concerned. "Filthy/Gorgeous," "Comfortably Numb," "Laura," and "It Can't Come Quickly Enough" are also fantastic tracks.
It's a bop
Fun, Happy Pop Rock.
Pretty fun album. Lots of energy.
I was happily impressed with this album. I pretty much liked all of it and VERY much liked much of it. probably a solid 85 or something. Haven't seen the next album yet but I will probably end up listening to this again after I trudge through that one, lolz.
Fine, some catchy some weird.
Lots of fun. Good get psyched music.
Pretty fun album
Great album! It’s like 70s disco rock! Listen again: yes Purchase for my collection: possibly Favourite Song: Take Your Mama Out Worst Song:
Nice enough
Was never really into them, but I remember the music being a bit more fun.
Fun enough and I remember this as a breath of fresh air when it came out. The sound and style remind me of Mika a few years after this release.
Not feeling this one. The Comfortably Numb cover is awful. On the other hand, Filthy/Gorgeous and Return to Oz are good. It’s tough for me to judge this objectively because I don’t like “pop band” music at all.
I forgot how many hits they had. My only critique is they try to hit too many styles from disco to funk, etc. But a good disc nonetheless. 3.5/5
Rating: 8/10 Best songs: Laura, Take your mama, Mary, Filthy/gorgeous
I'm sure that there are people reading these reviews who simply don't know how awful music was in the early 2000s. It's difficult for those of us who suffered through that time to express quire how atrociously awful just everything was. We'd had some fun with Britpop in the 1990s, trip-hop had fallen by the wayside. Rock, metal and hip-hop had got it on and spawned the lightly-fried turd that was numetal, and literally the only fun that could ever be found after about 2002 was Mr Scruff. For literally years, the music industry pumped out dismal dirges and post-britpop fart noises. The happiest music one could find was Coldplay - and literally nobody needs that. And then, along came Scissor Sisters. They took a look at the desperate, desolate wasteland of the early 2000s music scene and said "Balls to that, let's DANCE, motherfucker!" and released this joyous masterwork. Back in the day, I loved it. Sure, there's a couple of bum tracks. Incredibly, when it was released I thought that their cover version of Comfortably Numb was an abomination. Listening to it again today, it's actually pretty good. Filthy/Gorgeous is underrated, eclipsed but not outdone by Take Your Mama. Scissor Sisters, along with Alison Goldfrapp and Franz Ferdinand started music back towards fun. For that, they have to get 5 stars.
Today's album is a pop rock/modern day disco record by Scissor Sisters. This is a very unique genre which I haven't really heard before. It sounds like it would be awful, but surprisingly it works. The band have hints of Bee Gees, ABBA, and Queen in their delivery, and are apparently staples of the LGBTQ community, having got their start in the "NYC Gay Nightlife" scene. Some of their music is quite comical, such as Tits on the Radio, which is loosely a song about beating off because you can't see tits on a radio. The only other band that I can think of who are close to this sound is Ultraviolet Sound. Overall, a surprisingly great album today. This music makes you want to get up and move. Especially Filthy/Gorgeous. I enjoyed the album so much today that I listened to it twice. Very different and interesting. Favourite songs: Filthy/Gorgeous, Take Your Mama, Tits on the Radio, The Skins, Music is the Victim, Laura Least favourite songs: Comfortably Numb 4/5
Not bad, I can handle some modern Disco or whatever the hell you'd call this much better on a Tuesday morning then a Monday. Best tracks are "Take your Mama" and "Tits on the Radio"
9/10 crazy fun pop album certified bangers throughout
Nothing grabbed me at all
I had never heard of this band prior, but there are some wonderful pop tunes on this record. Some don’t land for me, but the ones that do are REALLY great!
This is so good Steadily going down from the first song 3
I bloody love this album, loved it in 2004 when it came out (no pun intended), love it now. Just full of fun, joy and party. A slight shame that at the time they were characterised as 'that gay band' (which I don't think would be the case in 2023) as there is something for all stripes here. A slight shame that one of the most horrible sounds I have ever heard precedes the bonus tracks, but it's so banging I can forgive that.
This was a fun album but I wouldn't say that this is super great. Not really very memorable. 6/10
Joyous fun album that is still a good listen
Brilliant synthy scene music. Shears falsetto evokes British gay icons like the Communards or Elton John and always reminds me of similar bands during my twelfth year (The Darkness, Franz Ferdinand, Electric Six). The music is tight, zippy, funky, cocksure and enjoyable. Plus, from memory, the mamas loved it. Stronger than I remember if a touch poppy for me
I thought the album was good Good experimentation with the instruments and I liked the vocals