It's completely legitimate to put Throbbing Gristle in this kind of list. I'm glad I listened to it. Genesis P Orridge was an auteur of some note. It is, of course, absolute garbage and anyone who says they like it, or would buy it, or would listen to it more than once, is a fraud.

It’s music, I guess. I’m sure someone likes it

I don't expect to convince people that Japan are one of the greatest bands to emerge from the new wave/post glam scene of the 70s but to my ears they were. This album, their musical breakthrough where they worked out their sound, is the bridge between that scene and the New Romantics. Duran Duran came from the image and the crossover disco/new wave sound of Japan. I mean look at them. Japan would make better albums, and they would break up too soon, but from every waaaa of the fretless bass to Sylvian's new found baritone this is a superb example of a band actually doing things to move music on and looking good and sounding good whilst they did it. I think after listening to over 200 albums in this project, I'm more sure of their greatness. But that's to my ears, maybe not yours.

I hadn't heard this album before but it's fascinating and friendly on the ear. I came late to Nick Cave. I found The Birthday Party "difficult" so kind of overlooked his following career. This is a great example of his work - an artist and a musician and a really interesting voice but what stands out is his way with words. One of the great lyricists of this era and able to tell a story in music.

I struggled through

It’s an album I know well and it has the sound that at the time propelled them into consciousness but it’s ultimately a bit flat. I don’t think it’s an album I’d keep going back to.

The context of this album was incredible. A surprise launch after years of silence from one of the all time greats. This is a good album but if it wasn’t Bowie and out of the blue would people listen to it over and over? I suspect not.

This is a lovely, gentle piece of work which must have been groundbreaking at the time. I'd listen to this again. 36 minutes long - albums used to be short enough to enjoy them.

Ok the odd great song that we know well but mainly a mess and not something I’d listen to all the way through with any pleasure

Art not the artist ... It's as good as a pop album gets with any number of absolutely fantastic songs.

It’s got a few tunes it’s got some filler - it’s not something I’d go back to.

This was a struggle. Turgid 12 bar blues.

An absolute work of genius. Every moment still as good as the first time I heard it. Came from nowhere and will last forever. Other bands wanted to be Pixies

I love lots of Elton John but I don't love this at all. Only one stand out song - Tiny Dancer - the rest a real struggle.

I struggled through

Lovely album with some great tunes

This is the perfect pop album. An absolute masterpiece and incredibly consistent. Aside from all the singles the rest could have been singles. The high point of 80s production adds a beautiful listening experience. There's a good reason why this album sold so many copies and it still stands up.

Perfectly pleasant but not something that I’d play again

Well this is dreadful self indulgent rubbish. I’m sure may have had some sort of influence at the time for those under the influence. Thank God that’s over.

Of its time. Still a good noise but not a keeper

Slowing down and speeding up the tape is a nice trick on song one, by song 5 it starts to grate a lot. That this is in any list is baffling.

The authentic rock sound they were looking for is great, if only they also had some songs to go with it.

Still a beast of an album. Derivative, yes, some painful lyrics but it's a rock and roll album that evokes an era.

This is a really nice sound. Pleasant background music. Completely fine. No stand out songs and nothing remarkable.

Well, I'm sure it was a thing, but it's not a thing now. I'm glad I listened to it and some bits I remembered but...

Fun album, really didn’t know it at all but recognised the lead single. Sort of a prog funk epic and enjoyed it.

Good standard rock and roll

Some great moments but like a lot of double albums would have made a superb single album

Discordant and tuneless. How the mighty fallen

Couple of good pop songs, some terrible covers and a rehash of an old cover. Mundane production but an extra star for her fabulous voice. Overall though a very bland offering.

Classic metal

I didn't know this album at all - it had completely passed me by - though I did know the big hit when it got to it. I enjoyed this, melodic grunge from an era in which I spent a lot of time buying music and going to indie clubs. Well worth a listen.

An epic album of funk and songs that heralded what was to come

I hadn't even heard of this band before and I sort of liked it in a curiosity way but it didn't have any stand out tracks and I don't think I'd listen to it again

I let this wash over me like a bad background record in a lunchtime diner. It's desperately of its era and woefully short of redeeming features. An album that marked a period of time that has now passed.

Well, what is to be said about a set of turgid one phrase songs that presumably have some vague interest if you are off your tits on E at a club in 1999. Listening to it is one of the most painful experiences I have had in this escapade. Utter rubbish that a child can now do on Garage Band.

Classic rock. I was too young first time round but came back to Neil Young out of curiosity and absolutely loved him.

Lovely listen to the early sounds of rock and roll. Happy days.

This is a stunning albums in many ways. The musicianship, the first tentative sounds of the Fairlight CMI in popular songs. An eclectic album and well worth a listen.

Raw 70s sound, a few tunes, a bit patchy.

I have no idea why anyone would listen to this

Really nice folk rock album, first time to it but I'd definitely listen again.

I was a bit hesitant with this, but it is a fine piece of work. Of course the narrative issues are difficult but done with a fine touch. Very much enjoyed listening to this.

A bit of a mixture this. Some iconic songs and a lot of pretty standard blues numbers. Some fantastic bass and drums and one of the great songs in the history of rock and roll. Curate's egg.

Pleasant distraction I can see why he’s a thing but not enough to make me revisit.

Delightful album. Absolutely lovely in all respects. Fine words, fine tunes and a great sound. First time I’d listened to an album of Dolly and it was a pleasure.

It’s pleasant enough but I have no idea why it’s on this list. A bit of a by numbers electronica pop album. Nice voice, the odd good tune but there’s probably a reason why this has never come up before in my life. It’s Ok, just that.

I liked this, in a gentle and interested way. Not by any means stand out but certainly worth a listen.

I found this much better than I expected. 1979 is one of the great songs of all time but I am a bit meh about the rest of their singles. This thought had a surprising tone - some really good songs.

This is a pleasurable piece of work, for all the bits that are now known there are still musical interludes that are interesting and challenging. That a record company was built on the back of it (and indeed the whole Virgin Branson empire) is amazing in retrospect. However, it's not going to get me to 4 or 5 as I wouldn't listen to it again and again.

To say this isn't my genre is an understatement. So I approached this with some trepidation which was completely unfounded. This is a good album. It's never going to be my thing but it's melodic, interesting, has some good songs and doesn't default to the lazy end of the genre.

I think a little dated. Obviously Message itself as a song is still amazing but the album is a little too soft and underwhelming.

Nice enough but it is absolutely baffling that this made any list of anything of note.

This may well be some maturing directional shift for ABBA, but to my ears it's oompah music on synths. One of Us is still a great single, the rest is for my granny. I never saw ABBA as an albums band - they produced fantastic pop singles but I can't imagine finding depths over the course of a long player. This confirms my breezy prejudice.

Definitely better listening to this 25 years later. I didn’t much like it at the time

Dreary, pedestrian goth music. I don't mind the genre but this is not worth the effort.

Teenage poetry set to Bontempi organ. Indescribable rubbish.

Pleasant enough, not something I'd play again and again.

Pleasant enough. They passed me by at the time. It's a little bit dinner party music for immersion but I didn't not like it.

Sold a lot of records. I wonder if anyone plays it now? It's not exactly a fun listen.

I know people for whom this is a defining album. Maybe if I’d have bought it then it would be for me too. It’s good. It’s just good. Not spectacular.

It’s pleasant enough - for this kind of music it tells decent stories

I am late, or adjacent to Bob Dylan. He's always been there, and I've heard his music all my life. But I've never been a Bob Dylan listener. People tell me I'm wrong and this album backs up that opinion. Musically and lyrically this is an outstanding album.

My heart sinks when I get a recent album I've not heard of and this is no exception. A baffling entry into any list of any albums. It’s ‘OK’ and no better than that

As with all these medium known artists I didn't hate it, but I don't see why I should particularly like it either. Nothing stand out.

What a great band, and A Forest and Play for Today are still fantastic, stand out songs that make me sit up and listen whenever they are played, but this is merely the herald of things to come, not the finished article. It's patchy, and some of it very clearly reflects how cheaply and quickly it was made. I'd love to give this more, but I can't.

Good old fashioned 90s rock and roll album. So good I listened twice.

An artist that of course I am aware of but have never really engaged. This is a lovely album, I enjoyed it greatly.

I wasn't a Dylan fan but everyone is really. This is a superb album, a man at the heights of his lyrical talent. Obviously one of the greats.

It's the Rolling Stones. It's Sticky Fingers. I would love to give it 5 stars but I've never listened to a Stones album and put it on my list of things to listen to over and over again. Great great songs but not a whole album.

Era defining, ground breaking, manufactured indi pop which now sounds like a couple of good songs and a load of filler. Diminished greatly in retrospect.

Jazz, but in a lively tuneful accessible way. Great listen. Will not be on repeat but glad I heard it.

I listened to this quite a lot at the time but in retrospect it's a bit of a bland nothing. The production sound is "terrible" even on the remaster, which I guess is a result of the technology of the time he home recorded it. One or two nice tunes but mainly a bit blah. It's not a 1 star though - there's enough dross in this list to give this two.

It’s music, I guess. I’m sure someone likes it

Good songs good guitar based indie.

It's a magnificent mess. Sound and experience and the genius of Fripp in the background. But it's not complete.

I’m sure someone likes this. The style and mood are something I should like, but there are no songs.

I don't really know what this music is for. Perhaps cooking to? It's nice, but it's not anything.

Still a beautiful album, a really nice musical moment and movement and well worth a listen.

I don't know how people listen to this. I don't know what it is. Is it music? I guess someone thought so.

It was an interesting listen, not something I would obviously seek out. Not something I’d listen to again but was good for one go.

I sort of like this but not enough. It has pleasant moments but never really grabbed me.

Interesting album, enjoyable

Lovely album and a great talent. It’s not his finest work so he loses a star for that but absolutely worth listening to.

Much better than I expected, pretty good all round album and well worth a listen.

Really enjoyed this - I'd never listened to a Siouxsie album and there's no reason why as this is right up my street.

I remember Sonic Youth being a favourite of John Peel and I didn't quite get it at the time. Now I've sat back and listened to this album I still don't get it. It's a sort of mixture of music and throwing stuff together rather lazily. I look back at a lot of the music like this and think that they were just messing with us.

This is the funk, right there.

Absolutely lovely album. I came to Nick Drake late and by chance from the soundtrack to Garden State. Whatever he thought about the orchestrations it's a fine album.

It's the Beatles. Get over yourselves, they are absolutely fundamental to the history of popular music and a hell of a lot of what went after them owes them a debt. After two albums filled with covers (people forget about that) this is the first full set of originals and packed with classics. The harmonies - If I Fell? - the energy - HDN. If Can't Buy Me Love came out now it would be a hit.

I've never been a deep Springsteen fan, though I know some are. Even by my generally ambivalent view I'm not sure there is anything particularly interesting about this album. It's OK.

Banger of an album, great to hear it again.

Really good pop/rock album that still sounds great. Not perfect - there's a couple of so so tunes - but a solid 4

Enjoyable in a m ephemeral way

Pleasant enough but not consistent

Very gentle listening, all very well known songs and stylistically very dated now but not a difficult album to listen to at all

Really good album, one of the true greats of music.

I was listening to this whilst cooking and it was a pleasant background for the mood I was in. I suspect I wouldn't have found it so pleasurable if I'd been listening intently.

Pleasant enough background music.

It's an album I bought at the time and struggled with then. It's one stand out tune and the rest is pretty mixed and feels a bit lazy.

Not really my scene but quite enjoyed it

Still an absolute classic, still a murderer.

It’s always been a difficult album to listen to but prig is prog

Really interesting very jazz based pop.

A slight surprise in that I'd never heard of it, yet it had sold so many copies - though in the USA. When it came to it I knew the signature song, of course, which is fun and prog. Sort of enjoyed it but wouldn't really go back to it.

I turned this on with some trepidation but it was actually quite a fun listen. Mad genre, no idea how people get into it but hey, it's part of music's rich tapestry.

Perfectly agreeable American rock/blues.

Nothing of note here. Quite literally.

Another odd choice of album to laud. Fairly pedestrian tap/hip hop album with no stand out moments at all. Passed me by for a very good reason.

One of the greatest rock and roll albums. Seems unfair to lose a star but I think it’s not quite complete. But still, what a sound. Particularly the production on the drums.

It’s obviously an important and influential album but it’s also self indulgent and ultimately Muzak. Bits of it I love but as a package it’s like the demo album of a special edition.

Really nice album, some good songs and altogether a pleasant listen. Not sure it should make any best ever lists but nice all the same.

It's the blues. Which song is it? Oh it's the last one again. It's a thing I guess.

I enjoyed this a lot more than expected. Double album though, so a lot to chew through. Nothing wrong with a bit of metal in your life

Some absolute stand out songs but some that just are not very interesting. Would be great fun to hear live but on record it’s just a bit flat.

Pleasant listening, much better than I expected, accessible jazz, but it's still a piano for an hour and repeating themes. It's great that this sort of album got made, reached a big audience and exists but it's not something I'm going to play over and over. I can appreciate it but that's as far as it goes.

Majestic genius - a rare fusion of incredible riffs, bass lines that are pivotal to the songs and a lyrical master. I nearly marked this one down for Shankly but, really, this is a great album from a group of youngsters who were in a extraordinary creative spurt. Cemetery Gates is a wonderful song and I still have the memory of hearing "There is a Light" for the first time on John Peel.

I didn't need to listen again to know this is 5 stars, though I did. Three times. Prince is a genius but his albums are a mixed bag as his prolific creativity was not always put into a filter. This, however, is a definite moment when it all worked. Not a single weak song on an imperious album. When Doves Cry without a bass is still spine tingly good. The title track, recorded live, is an epic ending by a band of supremely talented musicians. A perfect album.

Pleasant enough but all merges into one. Needs more barn.

Thank the Lord for "Paper Planes" as the rest of this is rubbish.

Fun, pleasant, not a stand out album but perfectly listenable. I get the left field blues from Mali vibe and it is interesting for that but otherwise a fairly unremarkable blues album.

When I started this I thought it just sounded like De La Soul. Then De La Soul turned up on it. It's fine, I didn't not enjoy it but I wouldn't listen to it again. Fairly generic rap/hip hop with 80s sound.

Bog standard country/rock. Not my thing "at all" but for those that like that. Fill your boots.

Fairly boring standard blues/rock album. A couple of songs stand out from the humdrum but this is not great.

Never really understood the appeal of Arcade Fire. This is a wholly unremarkable set of songs until you get to ‘Wake Up’

This is one of those albums in this list I would never have listened to without it. I think it's also one of those albums that if I'd found at a certain time in my life I'd know it really well. Love the fretless bass, enjoy the discordant bits and amused by Phil Collins playing drums.

Album that sits firmly in my memory of being allowed to listen to it in a Primary School music lesson. The bridge between punk and new wave and that time when everything made the charts because good music was good music. The singles are right there but as an album it drifts a lot.

Really lovely album. Not one I knew and the jazz/fretless bass instrumentation great. Just not the songs.

They didn't invent metal, they just couldn't play or write tunes.

Fun album with some good tunes and the moment of "oh, yes, of course I know this song".

I've always struggled to get into Dylan, whilst of course recognising that what he does is unique and lyrically brilliant. This is a great album though, and reminds me of what I'm missing.

I can't quite get into the Stones as an album band, though they wrote some of the most sublime songs in rock history.

I loved this but I'm a sucker for a good voice. Whether it has a set of songs is a different debate.

A love letter to pain, an album that starts by saying "It doesn't matter if we all die" and that makes a new music form out of destructive thoughts. One of the great bands and one of their most important albums. Yet not quite perfect.

A work of art by one of the great musical geniuses of my lifetime. Outstanding songwriting and a beautiful singer and it is amazing this was not actually a massive hit.

Really good album. Great voice and lyrics. Enjoyable all round

I've tried with this album, I really have. Many times over the years. But it's got three good songs, one of them played 3 times, and a lot of self indulgent meanderings.

A storming beast of an album even now, over 30 years later.

It's classic hip-hop week for me on the generator and this sounds better to me now than it did when it came out. I didn't quite know what to make of it back then but I really appreciate it now. A fun frenzy of white rap. What a band.

This is simple. It's one of the greatest albums of all time, in my opinion and to my ears. When my first child was born I gave my wife a list of Cocteau Twins songs to choose from and so "Lorelei" is her middle name. A sweeping, storming wall of sonic perfection. I have no idea what she is singing about but it doesn't matter. It's genius. 10/5

Hmm, what's this about ... oh wait I know this song. Oh "that's" Weather Report. Good jazzy fun album. I'm a sucker for fretless bass though.

Started off brightly enough then goes on a bit and meanders to nowhere. It's OK, but I wouldn't listen again.

Jazz improvisation over a repetitive chord change for 20 minutes a song. I know he's a genius, and get the importance of this shift in his music but... well... not for me.

My first experience of him. Good old country music. Not my cup of tea but not unlistenable

Strengthened my belief that Blur wrote some outstanding songs but were a boring album band. It’s full of good lyrics and oh-so tunes. Very English but just not very interesting musically.

A wholly unremarkable album in every possible way. In fact, the only thing that is remarkable about this album is that it is on this list.

Dum de dum de dum de dum. Glass of wine would be lovely thanks. Dum de dum de dum. Who is this album? Ah yes, I heard it at Peter’s house last week, and I think Sarah was playing it too. Dum de dum de dum. mmm Dinner looks lovely thanks. Dum de dum de dum.

I had this album as a kid so know it well. Whether I think it is good or not is dressed up a little bit in nostalgia. I mean, I was 9 years old - what did I know of Ayn Rand? Ok so it's bonkers, and over the top but it's a prog metal album.

Great album, fun bursts of pop and some great tunes. Real attitude and enjoyed it.

Of its genre it's a really good album. Obviously a bit full on lyrically but goes with the terrain.

Some great tunes, great sound. Falls away a bit so not quite four dtars

Fairly tedious by numbers hip hop.

I mean, really? Whatever. Music should have songs, tunes, that sort of thing.

Albums by one hit wonders usually explain why they were one hit wonders and this is unfortunately not an exception. Not terrible and not unlistenable, just not very good.

Nice to hear a bit of rock and roll after a week of blip blip "mood" albums. Very much of its time but hey, it's the rhythm and blues as it should be before the tuneless people stole the genre.

Enjoyable rock for the ages.

I've always loved Madness for their singles but have never listened to an album. They never really struck me as an albums band but this is a beautiful work musically and lyrically. A real gem.

This could have been Life on Mars and a load of filler and I'd still give it 5 just for that extraordinary song. I didn't really get into Bowie until my middle ages and it's been an immense pleasure that I could go through his work and enjoy the changes and shifts in his songs. This is a musical opera and probably my favourite Bowie album.

Green Onions the song is a work of genius. The Stax house band at its finest. These musicians are legendary. This album, not so much. After the high of the iconic title track it quickly descends into elevator music. It's just not that interesting.

The amazing textures here - the different rhythms and light and sound. Lyrically very interesting and ... ... oh wait, no that was another album. It's a load of angry metal stuff. Was pretty good though.

Some people said listen to the end and you would be surprised. I was. It is surprising this ever got released, ever got onto this site and I ever had to listen to it. Not least until the end. For the UK people amongst us, this is the joke band from Jazz Club on the Fast Show.

Good prog is enjoyable. Bad prog is not.

I quite enjoyed this but it came off the back of a week of very difficult listens. Always quite liked the NY new wave/proto punk scene. Apart from Roadrunner it's pretty basic fare but it's come at a time of rare generosity on my marking.

I had this album as a kid and know every sound on it, which must mean it's a five star. A complete album in every sense - story telling, beautiful production and some excellent songs. If you get a chance, see the film that accompanied it.

It's a much better listen than I expected but it suffers from running out of ideas and though there are some good songs, there is a lot of aimless meanderings too.

Pleasant enough, sort of washed over me but a nice listen

I was slightly dreading this, as I'd had their studio album last week which was a sonic mess. However, this was a bit of mad escapist fun. No band would do this now, and sometimes it's worth remembering the joy of music doing things you shouldn't expect. Not by any means a classic, but nevertheless.

Some good songs, some crazy songs, some nice songs. It's hard to hate this but I don't love it either.

The good bit of this process is discovering albums - things that clearly sit in the family tree of music but I didn't know. A lot of them don't stand up but that doesn't mean they are not fun, of the time and of the genre. I've been a bit down on my marking on some of these but this one I'll give a 4 to as it is something I could imagine myself listening to.

I don’t know - it’s an album I might have really liked if I had known at the time but now seems a bit unremarkable. Black Hole Sun is a banger though.

I had this at the time, though it wasn't an obvious album for me. I quite like it, but I'm not sure it stands up to much repeat listening. It's sort of OK, I don't know, maybe now I've got to talk about it maybe it's just quite boring and repetitive. Still like Frontier Psychiatrist though.

It was when this came out, or maybe the second Gorillaz album, that I realised I'd got the Britpop wars all wrong and Damon is the genius from that era. I think you only get to extend a career by taking on new influences and trying new things, and this is a great example. Better than any Blur album with some great songs and still a great listen.

I enjoyed Moon Safari. I'm not sure this adds a lot though. In fact one or two of the tunes sound like pastiches of the first album tracks.

Fun in a random way.

I never really listened to the Gang of Four before - I wasn't quite sure what to expect. Very of its time, and I'm sure plenty of others influenced but not convinced there was much there beyond the sound/vibe.

Not immediately my thing but quite an interesting trip hop feel to a hip hop album. I don't think I'd want to listen again though, so gets a low mark.

It’s a great sound but lots of bands have this sound. Some of them don’t forget that songs need melodies and lyrics too. The Hives were good for one song but their schtick lacks the licks.

I came to Cave late - because I knew him from the Birthday Party which I found too impenetrable. He's a genius, a lyricist up there with the best and an auteur of our age. A beautiful album from a beautiful spirit.

Wasn't expecting much from this, though obviously knew Freak Scene is a banger. I can see why many recoil from his vocals - because he can't actually hold a tune. Weirdly though I didn't mind. It was some pretty good rock and roll indie from the time when guitars ruled the world and for 35 minutes of pure noise enjoyment it was pretty good. Singer aside it was quite tuneful too. Obviously apart from the last track, Don't. Which was a load of noise.

It's not possible to listen to this in 2023 without recoiling from what was considered perfectly normal in lyrics. This is the supreme rap album of all time though. The tightness of the words over the music, the genius of his phrasing, the fun and the craziness of the singles. It's the finest example of its genre and still blows a storm.

A folk singer that can’t write lyrics or melodies. It’s a novel singer and guitar approach… Christ I’m only on the first song. The only positive is that each dreadful, insight free, song is mercifully short before the next tuneless banality begins. Only 25,000 copies sold and I'll take a punt as to how many ended up in charity shops.

I really wanted to listen to this and it started off with a bang. However, over time it really began to be difficult to listen to. I just didn't like it by the end.

Pleasant enough but slightly aimless.

I'm definitely in the set of people that believe The Beatles changed everything and this is, at the end of their career together, the epitome of why they were so good. Three songwriters (OK 4 if you allow Ringo's contribution) desperate to outdo each other. Harrison finally getting his due regard. Something has the most sublime bass line from McCartney which, whatever Harrison thought about it, makes the song. I know "Come Together" was a rip off, but it's still my favourite Beatles song. Golden Slumbers is a beautiful piece of work. "Because" is a beautifully structured song. You know what? I like "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" - McCartney was always keen to nod to the story telling tradition of British music hall and why not? I hadn't listened for a while and the second side is still a whirlwind. The Beatles could throw away songs the best of the rest couldn't imagine writing.

A great example of how you can use mood and noise and guitars and still remember that songs need tunes. Really good album m.

I am sure this is great in a certain situation under a certain influence but it isn't an album to listen to, enjoy or immerse in. It's a songs characterised by a series of repetitive beats. And musical phrases. There's worse dance music, I have had to listen to some of it here, but it's still not interesting to do anything more than dance to.

I liked this a lot more - and knew it a lot better -than I expected. Some good tunes, plenty of good melodies. Obviously the theme is a bit "American" for my interests but that's kind of the point. A good find.

I like the blues but it’s all a bit repeat. Maybe it’s his earlier stuff that I should listen to.

One of the easiest games of ‘guess the rhyme’ so far. Very trite and obvious lyrics backed by unremarkable meanderings.

This isn’t the Love album people should listen to. It’s a bit thin.

It's still a great rock/alternative album that evokes a moment in time in music. Plenty of songs, plenty of anger and passion. Definitely in the top 20% of albums I've listened to so far.

This is where I came to The Beatles as my mum had an original vinyl copy. I played it over and over. Yes it's raw, and they were only starting out as songwriters but it's still got it. The harmonies, the playing. It's not a perfect album but it's a good reminder of how they developed.

Two Beatles albums in a row and from 2nd to 6th is a giant leap. This is the Beatles on the cusp of genius.

It's not really my genre, but this didn't really seem to offer anything musically. I guess if lyrics is your thing it might appeal but I don't think there's anything going on behind them.

Wasn't a band that I was into at the time, but I know all the singles really well. Indie standards. I know there are those that really worship Teenage Fanclub and that great Scottish indie scene. This is a good album, one I am sure if I'd bought at the time I'd have played to death.

Smooooooooth

I guess this could be described as a goth disco album. Unfortunately it's just a dreary shamble through a set of unremarkable songs. Not completely impossible to listen to, just not very rewarding.

It's really hard to listen contemporary albums and wonder whether they will endure, whether people will look back on it as a classic. I thought when I first heard this album it was one of those albums. In an era of music where so much is mood and ambiance without songs this was a stand out of the year it came out and of the decade it came out in. When I first listened I thought that this could have come out in 1973 and we would still be playing it now. There are few new albums that I listen to over and over again in an era of all I can consume streaming. Indeed, I'm doing this project so my average listen to an album I haven't heard before is sharply tending to zero. This, however, is a beautiful piece of work and I don't hesitate to put it in the top 20% of albums on this list.

A few songs, a lot of nurdling, prog/jazz it's the 70s man. Not terrible, not spectacular.

One good song and the rest goes on and on. I’m not buying.

I was a bit of a metal fan as a kid and so this was a rush of memory. I enjoyed it. Metal that is closer to rock.

Pure synth pop from the 80s. There are better albums for sure but few better songs than Take on Me.

A mess, a musical mess of tooting and blowing. Just not my thing at all.

This arrived with a b-b-bang. The greatest debut record of the 21st Century. An absolute explosion of music with lyrics, humour, observation and just the right amount of anger. A group of lads that worked out how to make music in their own way. A classic.

This surprised me - west coast hip hop has good sounds and beats but plenty of anger. The lyrics take a bit of stomach on the first few, but the overall sound is great.

Like many people coming to this for the first time I was completely surprised by the sound and the songs - not what I expected from the Chicago I knew from the late 70s/early 80s. Really interesting music and songs, then it over does the prog and meanders away a bit with guitar solos.

A really interesting album - of course very British in its politics and its music. I enjoyed this. Something about the sound of the dub and the horns and the lyrics.

A beautiful album. The great American song writers, the great American Sound Studios house band. Everything about this oozes the sound of Memphis Soul. Dusty's sound, her voice, her phrasing is all perfect.

This is a lovely, tuneful atmospheric album but drifts around a little over time.

It's probably my least favourite genre of music but this has an astonishing lack of merit. Musically tedious and there are better examples of the genre from that year alone. I don’t believe this will stand any test of time.

I've tried with this album so many times. I've tried to understand why it gets high up all time lists. It's just a rambling sound that offers nothing. No song structures, no songs. Maybe it's something I can't hear but what I can hear bores me.

I kind of liked this in a bouncy fun kind of way. Not something I'll put on my re-spin list but interesting enough.

Another album I wasn't really looking forward to once I'd opened the site. The start was a real surprise - really interesting, great sound. Then it slowly morphed into boring hip hop albeit with some musical interludes though all basic repetitive phrases.

It's an album so tied up with the British music movement of late 80s/90s, that I wonder what other nationalities make of it. Some guys stole some instruments, learned to bash out a tune and worked out that the guy they gave the mic to was a genius. Working class boys played in guitar bands and hoped to be famous and get out of the terrible lives they had. This gang of boys then took some ecstasy, went to the Hacienda and discovered rave. Then rather than throwing their guitars away and becoming a dance band they put it together. OK there were producers that helped, but this was the moment it all worked. They were too much of a shambles to be a stadium band, or to dry out or to keep it all together for a few more albums. But on this album, in that year, they created something absolutely unique and brilliant.

I listened to it twice and mostly it just merged into one long song with the obvious moment Pinball Wizard jumps out at you. Ultimately not a very interesting or listenable album.

I don't expect to convince people that Japan are one of the greatest bands to emerge from the new wave/post glam scene of the 70s but to my ears they were. This album, their musical breakthrough where they worked out their sound, is the bridge between that scene and the New Romantics. Duran Duran came from the image and the crossover disco/new wave sound of Japan. I mean look at them. Japan would make better albums, and they would break up too soon, but from every waaaa of the fretless bass to Sylvian's new found baritone this is a superb example of a band actually doing things to move music on and looking good and sounding good whilst they did it. I think after listening to over 200 albums in this project, I'm more sure of their greatness. But that's to my ears, maybe not yours.

Not sure what I make of this. Some songs, some music, some moments but mainly it drifted past me.

I really enjoyed this - funky, dance sound with a really light feel to it.

I liked this, and may give it another go sometime, but it didn't grab me. He's a fantastic singer, obviously, but there was a groove rather than songs that stood out.

Second Who album in a week and I'm concluding I'm just not a big fan of The Who. This has two absolutely stand out songs and then a lot of not very much.

A perfectly good example of a perfectly good genre of music. Psychobilly by the masters. It's fun, it's got attitude and it's not overall my cup of tea but I'm not put off by it either.

I know it's achingly uncool to like Coldplay but there's a reason an indie band sells 13 million albums and that's because Chris Martin could write tunes. I've never massively been a fan of his voice but this is a great set of songs.

Exactly as expected from the Stooges, some proper shouty garage. A band to see live, I suspect, as on record it lacks much substance.

I'd resisted the obvious charms of Guy Garvey and the lads as it was not quite my kind of thing but this is an undeniably lovely album and very listenable.

It’s a great sound and when they write a tune it works. When they don’t it sort of drags.

I'd never heard this and didn't know of this kind of Velvet Underground. Reading around it, the exit of John Cale allowed Lou Reed to perform songs without the desire to make it knowingly arty. I really enjoyed this, a very nice set of songs. I'll listen to this again.

The singles are great but the album tends to drift a little.

Joyous fun album that is still a good listen

Very American sound of rock that didn’t quite make it in the UK. Some well known tunes, big sound. Not bad

It's a raw, great sound but it's a bit of a dull offer. OK for the once through but I don't think I'd ever listen again. Bit of a novelty record.

His last and one of his best albums. An absolute masterpiece of an album. Something missing in modern music of the experimental never overshadowing the tunes and the songs. A heartbreaking album but an amazing parting gift from one of the greats.

I entered yet another hip hop album with trepidation. It's not my genre and so many of them are just about the words. This though felt a bit more musical, interesting, listenable. I like his rapping style and it has momentum. Look, all rap is of its time and time has moved on, but I enjoyed this.

Great album, plenty of variation, some good songs and fuses styles.

I liked it a lot more than I expected but it sort of drifted nowhere. Repetitive phrases sometimes works but isn't particularly ground-breaking

I know every discordant piano chord, every lick of Paul Desmond's clarinet and honed my chops as a drummer learning 5/4 and 7/8 from the master, Joe Morello. My indie/new wave band introduced me to its genius at the age of 16 and I've loved it ever since. Jazz with a wink and a smile on its face. Pure enjoyment. Go on songwriters, throw a change of time signature in every now and then and make the music interesting.

I don't think this adds much to the history of music. A couple of good songs and then just a turgid rehash over and over.

It's got Bowie and Eno on the desk, it's got attitude and distinct US new wave sound, it's just a bit difficult to listen to without thinking it's all mood and no songs. I get it, I just don't enjoy it.

Constant sound of bongos. It's like sitting in Covent Garden on a Saturday. After a while all you hear is bongo bongo bongo. Bongos are great, in moderation. I was going to give it two stars, on the grounds that at least I can listen to it but, I'm afraid, I really can't. I made it through by mentally blocking the noise out.

Dum de dum de tiddly dum dum. Might sound better with a band.

Beautiful album, great songs, wonderful voice. What a talent George Michael was.

Wasn't my morning for this album. Feels like her voice was losing some strength and the richness it had. Pleasant enough but I don't know whether decent singer knocking out another album of covers is good enough to rate highly.

Good grief, that was hard work. Well done lads, you got someone to pay you for this. Joke's on them.

Great pop album with a few duffers - sadly the two Prince tracks in that. First time I've listened to this and plenty to recommend it but ultimately not perfect pop.

Some classic pop, some slightly going nowhere pop. Very of its time.

I’m assuming they are referring to the sound of children randomly hitting keys. Which appears to be what this is. If music was this easy we would all be making it.

Good melodic metal. Not an album I knew but certainly an enjoyable example of the genre.

Lovely voice, lovely sound, but there is something about 15 minute long songs that don't surprise at any point that is ultimately a bit aimless.

This is a great punk album, songs that stand up and attitude. Unlike a lot of punk they could really write a tune.

Dum Dum Dum Dum tingaling tingaling Dum Dum Dum "Here's some more about me". Tedious

The Police are one of the greatest bands of all time. Three piece that Copeland and Summers filled out to sound amazing. Sting is "a hell" of a songwriter. He was throwing out hits for fun in this period. Message in a Bottle is one of the greatest songs of all time and I never tire of hearing it. I remember this as being a bit patchy but with some real songs. Listening to it again in the middle of this exercise, I realise the difference between good bands and a great band. I've been a bit mean on the 5 stars and wouldn't have given this at the start of listening but this is is as good an album as anything else on this list.

I read the notes and an hour long concept album about poverty slightly terrified me. The resulting album wasn't terrifying at all, a gentle pop album with a smattering of songs and plenty of 80s dance. Obviously the lyrics are ludicrous, but lyrics often are.

Not my thing ‘at all’. Two chords and wailing.

Beautiful album. Absurdly I know some of the songs from listening to Miles of Aisles a lot as a kid but had never listened to this before.

Of course Bowie made the best glam albums of the era. Not consistent but consistently interesting this has two of the greatest - Drive In Saturday and The Jean Genie. A pleasure.

There's something about this album that is joyous. Fun, prog rock with a great sound. They got the Steely Dan T Shirts.

Some good moments, always good lyrics but not quite the standard of songs and consistency of a great album.

It’s hauntingly good. A mad musical experiment but with really good songs peeping through.

It's an interesting listen, to hear where they came from. Covers were a standard thing at the time - the Beatles' early albums were also full of them - so it is not odd that the Stones started with them. I can't mark it up without original songs but the sound is there and we all know where it ended up.

Another bridge between punk and new wave. Fine as it is but there are better examples.

A fine example of noodling without destination. Perfectly pleasant to listen to whilst doing almost anything else, but not interesting in and of itself. Streetlife obviously a banger, the rest of it gentle noodling in the void.

I was surprised by this. Another album of covers of standards never twitches my interest but this was beautifully done. Gentle, sparce and great interpretations.

Looking at the reviews, I'm out of tune with the group on this one. Fairly pedestrian jazz album.

I thought this was a beautiful, gentle album. Lots of artists I know but an album that was new to me. Really enjoyed the harmonies and the general sound.

I guess this means something, I guess it did something at the time. But it's just a series of samples and a drum beat that you could throw together in 5 minutes in Logic Pro now. I don't know why anyone would want to listen to this ever again.

Often the rap albums I've listened to on this project have lacked ambition, texture, tone, musicality. You can't accuse this album of any of these things. Whether it has tried too hard or is too discordant is another matter. I enjoyed listening to something that was different in the rap genre but it was not an ultimately satisfying experience.

Before recorded music had all the tricks a lad with a beautiful voice rolled into a studio and sang like an angel. Such a stunning voice we are so used to it we forget how lucky we were to ever hear it.

It's a great blues album and it is also totally forgettable.

I thought I'd like this, I was a fan as a kid and I always wanted this album but didn't get round to buying it. Starts off well, it's Highway Star, it's fun. Then it goes on, and on and on and on. It even has a long drum solo in one of the tracks that dates it horribly. It's how Prog Metal was, it's great if you are there and in the moment. On record it's a tiresome noise.

One of those unexpectedly fun albums you get from this project. I'm not sure it's a classic, but it was good to listen to.

Enjoyable rock and roll with a few good songs

This is a fairly unremarkable experience. American middle of the road rock.

How to follow Rumours, one of the greatest albums of all time? Well, put together a double album with a load of random songs and sounds including a marching band and produce something so different it's still a fantastic piece of work. An eminent music journalist in the UK said there is never a time when listening to Tusk is wrong. He's absolutely right. Some incredible songs. It's just not Rumours. But nothing is Rumours. Listen to Tusk. Take it all in.

I have a theory that prog like this died out because the boys that were making it and listening to it never got any sex. A tedious album in all respects.

Metal doesn’t get anything like the column inches it deserves. It’s a massively popular genre and this is one of the greatest metal albums of all time. Consistent, powerful and popular for good reason. After a run of pretenders it’s great to hear a proper rock and roll album.

I mean, it's Sgt. Pepper. I used the opportunity to listen yet again to the extraordinary Giles Martin Dolby Atmos remix. The way he lifted and cleaned the bass and the drums is amazing. It sounds clear, open and notes and sounds that I'd not heard in the many times I'd heard the album before appear out of nowhere. The harmonies the Beatles did were brilliant, on this version superlative. They left the singles off the albums, that's how good this album is. Get off with your ideas that they are not the most important band in the history of pop. Of course they are.

I saw the Beatnigs live and I know bits of this album - TV, Drug of the Nation and California Uber Alez so I knew what to expect. I think probably the older me finds it all a bit different to the younger me.

After initial trepidation about yet another unknown hip hop album I really warmed to this. Light tunes, good sound and nicely put together. A real revelation.

A beautiful piece of work. Some lovely instrumentation, lilting harmonies and a handful of stone cold classics. 30 minutes long. How albums should be - here's some great songs, that's enough.

There's some good here, and there is a whole lot of guitar, but ultimately it's a long drawn out blues jam and that can get tiring.

I've never listened to a T Rex album and had no idea he made so many - 12 in total. This is a great album, full of tunes and sound and attitude and a real find.

I can see there's a logic to something that was of the era/genre of the Rolling Stones that might have been part of a scene but I don't think this holds up well as an album not to miss.

Imagine is an overplayed dirge, Crippled Inside a throw away, Jealous Guy a song written by a genius It's So Hard is an unremarkable 12 bar blues. I Don't Wanna be a Soldier Mama, ibid Gimme Some Truth is OK I guess Oh My Love is a really nice song How Do You Sleep is John at his vile, ugly worst How is another good song Oh Yoko is a good closer I felt Lennon phoned in a lot of his last contributions to the Beatles. This has some absolute moments of genius with a couple of not very much but on the whole I'm more positive about it than I expected.

It's folk prog, it's interesting music and interesting lyrics. Those that love it love it, those, like me, that find it a bit much should still be able to recognise that it is worth listening to. Maybe at a different age with time on my hands I could have got into it.

Oh I’m so radical me. There are at least 100 better post-punk albums. Rubbish

Very good debut album. Not quite the highs of Back to Black but good songs.

I was not into MBV at all when younger though I’ve dipped into their more well known offerings. This hints but ultimately the singing is poor, the sound has not developed and so the songs are exposed.

Pretty raw, but still better post punk than a few of the efforts I've heard in this project.

Some nice moments. I never really got into Belle and Sebastian, although I'm going to see them live soon. Light, nice, very British.

A simmering beast of an album. A sonic soundscape of love and misery. The height of goth and The Cure's definitive album. Listen, enjoy, and lose yourself in the mood. Lullaby is one of his highest of high points - though the single version had a much better drum track.

Hi - is it OK if I push past as this is my floor. Many thanks.

This is a good album but not a spectacular one. That said, The Weight is a hell of a song and Dylan's lyrics lift many of the songs.

I understand the reason why Springsteen attracts such devotion, I just can't get into it myself. Yes he has some great songs but broadly the music to me all kind of mushes into one on albums like this. I get it, I just don't get it.

I was unsure whether this was a sprawling work of genius or a sprawling mess and I’ve definitely alighted on the latter.

Well that was interesting enough to listen to but that's as far as it goes.

I don't know why but I've always found Lust for Life to be a tedious song. I know I should like it but I don't. Then the rest of this album just washes over me and again, I should like Iggy. I just don't think it's that interesting.

There are few live albums that really cut through and this is one. It's a gentle and brilliant run across their catalogue and covers that just kind of works.

I loved this album when it came down and it holds up pretty well. Great songs, great sound and pop sounding as good as it can be.

An absolute masterpiece

One of those albums on the list that is difficult for me to place. I’m some ways stunning, in some ways transient. I don’t think I’d listen to it often and yet I can recognise how remarkable Simone was.

One of the greatest pop songs of all time, from a band that released a list of superlative pop songs. Yet as an album it’s really hard work. The lyrics on many of the songs are banal and predictable and the tunes weary. A magnificent singles band , one of the best ever, and a terrible albums band.

Well, I listened to it. They seemed to be enjoying themselves. Probably. Another of the list of very American albums that don't travel, certainly not as far as these ears.

A curiosity. A handful of good songs, an incredible sound and band but overall a bit boring. I don't love it but don't hate it, so it's bang in the middle I'm afraid.

The hi-hat (Stewart Copeland) on the opening track still makes me tingle, as does the flute motif opening up Sledgehammer. Kate Bush still raises goose bumps. Great songs, fantastic musicianship and the most amazing 80s production where everything is so clean & clear. Not a bad song on it. Absolutely his masterpiece. Funny that the slightly off the wall prog of early Genesis ended up in pure pop with each part of its membership.

Sonic Youth were one of those Peel bands I struggled with growing up in the 80s. Too atonal, too based around sound not songs. So I sort of ignored them. This was another one of those albums therefore I had a bit of a sigh when I saw, and when I read the top review. There's not many albums I've found through this process that I don't know yet want to hear again. This is great. I will listen to this again.

Kind of enjoyable, a nice groove but ultimately not very satisfying. Strong on vibe, short on tunes. Nothing to make me want to go back to it.

When Radiohead wrote actual songs they were majestic, epic, peerless. Better than all their peers from Britpop, the band Coldplay and others would dream of being. Everything on here shows the absolute return to structure and melody that they later decided they were against when they drifted into sound and mood. Every track stands up to listening and all the grunge and indie pretenders on this list would dream they had nailed it the way Radiohead did it on this. An absolute masterpiece and deserving of its position in the all time lists.

The only good thing to say about this album is that it is mercifully short.

Oh I love the Carpenters, at least I thought I loved the Carpenters. I mean I love her voice and the songs and the sound but a whole album of it is a challenge. It's beautiful and it's shallow.

A perfect expression of pop with great songs and great lyrics. Much better than some other pretenders (Adele). I’ve no idea whether it stands up long term or how it fits in her catalogue but I enjoyed it.

It starts as it means to go on - a perfect soulful voice against a great sounding rhythm track. Then it starts to repeat and repeat. Each song a two chord four bar repeat and it becomes really difficult to keep listening. The instrumental gives a welcome break as they actually put a few chords and a melody into it then it’s back to the repeat. It’s fantastic but I can’t listen to a whole album of it.

A great advert for double albums that might have made decent single albums. Sprawling, at times repetitive within each of the genres and could have done with a bit of sorting and editing. As a result the good points are diluted in a lot of so so tracks.

I enjoy a bit of post punk and this compared well to a lot of things I've listened to here, including this week. So I listened to it a few times and though it's never going to be a favourite I'm still OK with it.

What a joyous listen. Fun, funky and some great melodies - so good Rod obviously nicked one of them. Really lifted my journey up this morning.

Listening to it again as I have again and again over the years, the one thing that lets it down is the production which is horribly tinny. This is the remaster and it still sounds like he's singing in the bath. That said, their is some monstrous talent on display here. That Joke isn't Funny Any More, Well I Wonder, Barbarism Begins At Home are all superbly crafted songs. It's just not quite there across the whole album - and production.

Every beat seemed exactly the same, just a constant rap over the same drum pattern. Yes, the old bit of levity and the odd hook but mainly just a tedious reboot of the last song.

I subscribe to the view that The Doors were/are massively overrated whilst still comfortably enjoying this album as being a decent set of songs and a decent sound. I'll just not over rate it.

I have a general prejudice about post-melody Radiohead and I don't think I bothered listening to this much after I availed myself of their generous offer to download it for free. However, my reaction to this surprised me. Sure, they were drifting away from songs to sounds and mood scapes, and deep into prog rock, but this is an interesting album. Johnny Greenwood is a genius and I found myself quite immersed in this.

I don't know whether this is genius or madness. It's one of those albums that I think needs a bit more time than the one a day listen. I like that it's playing with chords and structure, but it might just be a mess.

Some classic prog with a lovely voice and totally un-listenable.

I think I've never quite been a Depeche Mode album fan and this is a good example why - it's got some good singles then kind of drifts around a bit going nowhere.

I like second rate Britpop as much as the next person. Unfortunately this is third rate Britpop. It passes my test of being not completely unlistenable, so saves itself from the indignity of 1 star to sit, comfortably, in the cold soup of 2 stars with all the other mediocre lift music.

Standard chord structures, predictable lyrics, nothing to see here.

This is a great album. Lyrically, musically, emotionally all there. Her finest work and also I guess her most accessible. Great to hear this again. This morning I was sure this was a 4 star. It’s now my fourth listen today and it’s a 5.

This would make the top 11 albums of all time. It is an extraordinary piece of work and art. The first side is a smack in the face with a set of perfectly crafted pop songs ending with the sublime Cloudbusting . The second side is an amazing immersive story of musical discovery. I don’t think I understood it properly before I saw it live but it didn’t matter in the hours and hours I spent listening to every mad twist of music before the sublime ‘Hello Earth’ emerges with John Williams on classical guitar. When my daughter was about 5 years old I gave her a turntable and this album. Kate Bush was the first woman singer songwriter to have a number one in the UK. This album is what happens when you give one of the greatest musical talents of my lifetime a studio of their own, a Fairlight and the space to achieve great things What an album.

A gig to be in the room not to listen to on a record. Classic songs, classic voice but everything a bit faster and one paced so ultimately the texture of each song is lost.

I hadn't heard this album before but it's fascinating and friendly on the ear. I came late to Nick Cave. I found The Birthday Party "difficult" so kind of overlooked his following career. This is a great example of his work - an artist and a musician and a really interesting voice but what stands out is his way with words. One of the great lyricists of this era and able to tell a story in music.

I know bits of Neil Young but not the whole potato. Partly because he's always made it a tricky exercise to listen via a streaming service. This is lyrically strong, "it's better to burn out than to fade away" is one of the iconic lyrics in rock music, and musically this is a good set of songs. There's something about Neil Young I think I would have got really into if I'd discovered him when young.

I don’t know, I can respect the musicianship, rate the genre and understand the influence but my oh my I cannot listen to it with anything but ennui.

Great sound and enjoy the single but over a whole album it gets a little one paced and samey.

Iconic and revered but quite a difficult listen. It’s Bowie so it is littered with genius but it’s also dark and moody.

This is one of those US nu metal bands that completely passed me by as we were just never quite into this genre in Blighty. I know of them, and they vaguely make sense but it's the kind of stuff I always equate with turning on the wrong MTV channel and getting some thunderous overblown American roccckkkk. I can pass on this.

First time I've heard this but it's clear from it why this is seen as where metal started. Nothing sounded this heavy before. The blues scale has done plenty of good work in popular music. As always, the lyrics are batshit, but Ozzy is a one off. I enjoyed this. It's also sounding good with the more or less live studio recording under the remaster .

Musically starts out interesting but slowly just repeats itself over and over. However, that's not its problem. It's melodically barren and rendered excruciating by the teenage level "oo England is bad war is bad" lyrics. Dreadful self centred low self-awareness moaning so loved by the kind of people that you should avoid talking to at parties.

They have a sound and it’s unique to them. I like the basics - and the sound and bass/lead interplay are great. It’s just overall it kind of repeats itself. Has some great tunes but not the whole deal.

Slightly emotional to listen to this knowing I’ll never see Terry Hall singing these songs again. The Specials are an iconic band in the UK - musically an important movement, political but in a clever way and just fun. Ska/two tone was a very British moment and it was all because of The Specials. Great album with all the vibe of a live band playing. Nothing quite like it.

I thought I would hate this but really didn’t. I was a big early adopter fan of Bragg but drifted away as he lost his knack for song and lyrics. This is the folk Americana album that Guthrie deserved for his poetry/lyrics.

Great new wave and bonkers sounds from a fairly unique band. Very enjoyable all round.

Great voice and great sound but it’s a covers album. I get how for some of the history of music that’s how it worked but it’s easy to pick any song out and pick a different version that resonates.

Really not my thing at all. I struggled through with the hope of some sort of musical respect but nope, it was terrible.

It’s the 80s and it’s pop and it has some great tunes but it’s too samey and it’s too cold for a whole album. But those pop hits are great.

This really swings. Great to listen to albums like this that laid the ground.

Great lyrics, good tunes, nothing to disagree with here, though nothing to really inspire either. It's a good album.

It's a good glam rock album. It's clear why Bowie liked them. It's also clear why we listen to Bowie and not Mott the Hoople but it's an album that I'm glad I listened to.

Starts off with a banger and maintains a light gray and breezy feel all the way through. I think I enjoyed this though there is a lot to get through.

My uncle lent me his copy of Physical Graffiti when I was a kid and I remember being captivated by the gatefold sleeve. When I finally got to New York years later I did go and take a look at the brownstone building just because. On the music this is a colossus of an album and Kashmir is one of the great moments in rock history. Yes it's bloated and overblown but sometimes you just have to let that pass.

I really like this genre of music but this is such a completely unremarkable album. It has nothing stand out, nothing original and no songs that would justify it being here. It's in that list of albums that wouldn't have made it on this list if it was not from America. Sometimes things don't become hits because they are just not very interesting.

There is no debate about this one being here. Despite being it's actual living demographic - an indi kid turning 19 the year it came out and lapping up its licks and groves - this is a stand out album that stands up now. Ian Brown may not have been able to sing away from a studio but on record he created the melodic and lyrical lines that could be underpinned by the swirling arpeggios of sound from John Squire, the relentless grooves of Mani and Reni. Sometimes everything just works, and this is one of those albums. Rarely it also doesn't have a duffer - we can argue the merits of Don't Stop maybe but let's not get too picky.

Joyous wild fun and cheered up a morning. Sometimes music is just about the fun they are having and letting you listen into.

Shoegaze very much passed me by, though I love The Cure and The Cocteau Twins who were both big influences. I think there's a reason it was never much of a movement and didn't have many successful bands which is that it's not very interesting. Take the songs, take the life out of them and make them so muddy and covered in distortion that you can only take so much. That said Ride have a great song closing this album - Vapour Trail - and a great single in Taste which is added to the extended version. The rest is all a mood and a sound and not a set of songs. I like it, but it's not going to take hold of the conscience. And it didn't.

I loved what I thought was the first Throwing Muses album - I just didn't know about this one at all. I was a big fan of House Tornado/Real Ramona/Hunkpappa and I thought Fat Skier was their first so now I'm totally confused! I saw them live back in 89 and forced my university friends to be fans too. This is great, full of the slightly discordant tempos and melodies over interesting chord structures. I get it won't be to everyone's tastes but it was great to discover this.

Not a Joni album I know, and none of the songs are familiar. Really loved the jazz vibe and the lyrics and music as interesting as ever. Not sure it quite has enough to get to the four stars but I think this is an album I will listen to again so it might just tip over.

I don’t know. It’s a jazz album. I played the version with additional tracks so heard some songs again but didn’t notice. Lovely but not attaching to my mind

An absurdly pretentious load of nonsense. Two really good songs but even one of those was ruined by the acoustic arrangement. I can't quite believe he did this.

Enjoyable blues jangling with one of the great songs of all time. Not the high standard across the album but still an enjoyable listen and a very individual sound.

Stir it up a classic, the sound still as fresh and as fun as the first time I heard the Wailers. Not a consistently great album but a good listen nonetheless.

This is a mad collosus of an album. Something I know I would have got into at the time if I'd come across it. I enjoyed this a lot for all its crazed meanderings.

I like Pet Shop Boys, I like the songs, it's a good sound, they write great tunes and at times interesting lyrics. It's just hard to listen to an album of it because it's very very anchored in the same beat and the same sound and the same compression. It's got no texture at all as an album. It's fun but it's also hard work, which is a shame. Because individually it's a great collection of songs but as a single piece of work it's too homogenous.

Really enjoyable new wave with a banger of a single and some good sound/tunes. Not stand out but enjoyable. A good album rather than a great one.

It’s a classic. It’s not the best album of all time, that’s a nonsense, but it’s a great album.

It’s late era Elvis and it’s as if the Beatles and rock had never happened and he puts out an album for your grandma. Nice enough but the world had moved on.

Not a moment of note. Standard US shouting over loud guitars and drums with hardly a song of note. I’m sure they loved it in the US but it’s not worth any of our time. I don’t actively hate it but nothing happened on it. Nothing at all.

Probably the most English album ever recorded and I'm all in for that. Ray Davies is one of the geniuses of British pop.

My idea of hell. Repetitive sounds made by machines with little artistic merit. Anyone with a synth/sampler and drum machine could do this. Four bar repeats with nothing, but nothing happening. Make this stop

Lovely whimsical album but ultimately forgettable.

An album I enjoyed far more than I expected. Really good example of how hip hop can have texture, sound and melody.

An extraordinary beast of an album. An aural experience and just better than all of that genre.

I can understand the influence of the band and the hype around Clapton. This is the sound of a band at the top of their genre.

This was good but not great, some good songs but not the absolute consistency of a great pop album.

Everything about this is mad, overblown and theatrical and everything about it works. There's a reason it's one of the best selling albums of all time, and who am I to argue. A sprawling colossus of sound.

A good set of songs, good lyrically and overall a fun album. Of course like most I come into it with the Fatboy Slim remix of Brimful and the album version seems thin by obvious comparison. But there's enough here to enjoy.

Ray Charles with his timeless beautiful voice runs through a range of songs with ease. There is always time to listen to Ray Charles.

I can appreciate the artistry, I can understand how people think Clapton is one of the greats, I can even enjoy the album. But I'll never be that into the blues to spend a great amount of time on it. It was a good album, a good listen. I might even listen to it again. But it is covers so doesn't get the high marks.

A lovely album, a fantastic voice a smooth set of songs a pleasant Friday listen and one of the great soul songs. Could have done with a few more like that though.

Bonkers. Standard predictable metal thrash hokum then goes bongo with classical guitars. An experience. Bonkers

This sounds so much better now than I gave it credit for at the time. In my indie snobbery I’d been too dismissive of Hip Hop. This is a really good, interesting and at the time obviously groundbreaking piece of work by great innovators.

This is a great album. Not quite the consistency of Show Your Bones but still some really good songs and overall a great sound. I think for that time it came out and the dip music has had in the intervening period it stands up even better than I remember.

One of those albums I expected to hate - a soundscape rather than a set of songs - but I really didn't. Yes it doesn't ever really change its moods but these are a very solid set of songs.

Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Thump Why would "anyone" choose to listen to this as an album, at home. Why?

Brightly sprightly bouncy and lively with all sorts.

I had the joy of living in Bristol when it all came together and the Wild Bunch settled down to make some fine music. Trip hop came from a time in England and, frankly, in Bristol. The dreadful mess of the 70s and 80s was beginning to get better, cities like Bristol were calming down and bursting with creativity. Massive Attack produced the absolute seminal Trip Hop album here. A genre that was brilliant but very much of a moment but an album that is absolutely timeless.

I don't think there's anything very useful to say about this. One of the greatest albums of all time that has been dissected by so those more able to than me. I know everything about this album from the numerous documentaries and articles and I also know every song inside out. An extraordinary set of songs, three songwriters at creative peaks at the same time, a sound of a band willing to work in a studio to find the right arrangement and lyrics of love longing and loss. There's a reason that this has sold so many, appears in the best of lists and appeals to people who like all kinds of genres. The best albums are the best albums. This is one of them.

One of those albums and artists I didn't know but this kicked into life and kept going. A really interesting mix of music and mahem. I don't know if I'll listen again but I think I enjoyed it.

A mixed bag that’s not held up quite as well as I expected. Obviously the raw energy and anger of FTP still makes you sit up and Express Yourself is a stone cold classic. The rest is up and down. Still has to be listened to though.

I thought this was surprisingly flat given the critical reviews it got. Very in the mould of Primal Scream/Oasis ish but without any stand out songs. I like the sound but there's nothing there to get into

One of the great bands of all time, swagger and sound and a greatest hits list that stands up to the best. But on album ... not so much. Rambling songs of RnB riffs with no particular place to go.

I had never heard of them and I don't know what to make of this on only one listen, but I think I will listen to it again and to their other albums. Not least because I recognise a couple of the songs from This Mortal Coil and so they must be the sort of band that bands I like listened to. So it's a gap in an important influence and I intend to fill it. For that I might have gone to four but at the moment it's a curious three.

I was a massive fan of early U2 but slowly drifted away as the sound became more bombastic. So curiously it's the first time I've ever listened to this album in full. It is a really good, but not a really great album. Some songs that really endure and I might give it a bit more space now I'm older and not hardline in my tastes in music.

I feel this is the moment when Muse sort of lost their way. Bland soundscapes and bombastic instead of edge and great songs. It's still a good album, and stands up against a lot here but I don't think it's a great album.

Slightly unsure what I’m listening to and whether it works but I’ll give it the benefit of the doubt.

It’s wu-tang so it’s an experience but not quite my thing.

After a bit of a difficult run it was a pleasure to hear this - light maybe but lovely songs and a beautiful production.

This is a really good album. Eclectic and interesting and at moments, like on Venus as a Boy, sublime.

I know lots of bands influenced by Husker Du but had not got round to dipping in so this was my first effort. I get the energy and the sound but this is a dreary album of standard songs. I found it hard going for an hour. It's boilerplate indie rock from the 80s. I guess one of the things about being influenced is taking a sound/attitude and building on it to make it a lot better.

An album to surprise me. Interesting indie-rock from US at a time when most of the interesting indie rock was here in the UK. Great set of songs, plenty of changes of mood and texture. Really good album.

I've never quite bought into the Springsteen thing, though I can appreciate it. I came to the song "Born to Run" via Frankie Goes to Hollywood" which controversially I still think is a better version. Thunder Road is a nailed on classic and Jungleland a great song. I can acknowledge this album's standing without it quite being my thing.

No doubt this is in the top of all time. A band that borrowed the Blues, for sure, but made it great in this set of songs.

No doubt this is in the top of all time. A band that borrowed the Blues, for sure, but made it great in this set of songs. The new wave that came out of New York at that time produced some stunning music and laid the ground for many other changes in pop. This is beautifully quirky, sparse before they really hit their groove and the songs became top tier but still a great album.

I'd possibly find 1001 instrumental albums worth istening to before this one.

If what you want is a great soul album then this is a great soul album.

It was difficult to hear all of it as it's not on any streaming services, which is a shame because this is one of those rare finds that I think I would like a lot. I might download it and listen properly.

This should be docked marks for the awful cover but aside from this, Paul Simon is one of the very very few absolute greats. The shortlist of outstanding songwriters that there is no doubt about. What an incredible set of songs.

This album is utterly bonkers but is also, curiously, absolutely worth listening to. Sometimes something like this had to be made.

I don’t really know what to make of early Pink Floyd. The band members revered Syd in a way that’s hard to relate from the outside. Sure there was a lot of LSD but this is a mess of sound. I guess it gets a bit of kudos for being part of the psychedelic movement and if it’s time and probably people should listen to it. So it’s going to get far more from me than it deserves on music alone.

It's Aretha's masterpiece.

Four bar repeats of basic riffs. Art has to be something I can't do. Anyone can do this. Set the drum machine to 4/4 choose a BPM and write a short bass line. Make some sounds over it. Repeat. Repeat. Repeat. Utter rubbish.

A couple of stone cold classics, some average fayre and some bland boring covers. Definitely a mixed bag of an album.

I wanted to like this album because Bob is such a nice bloke and they have a light air about them. Sadly, though, this was very very pedestrian.

Perfectly listenable pedestrian country music.

I wouldn’t normally give good marks for an album with so many covers but this is a lovely piece of work. I’m no fun of country either. But this is worth a listen.

Of the albums in the electronica/instrumental dance in this project this is one of the more worthy as it has some tunes, and indeed some singing, but ultimately it's incidental music.

Not an album I knew before, though obviously I was aware of her work and her extraordinary voice. This is a full throated, literally, blues album that absolutely blasts through the speakers. This is going to be the first 5 star that I hadn't heard before. It's a hell of an experience of sound and emotion.

This is and it isn't. It has songs, swagger and fun but it's also flat, samey and ultimately uninspiring. I think I'd have liked it a whole lot more back in 1981.

Of all the "American" albums this is the best - some gentle, haunting versions of songs that just feel like Cash letting us know what we would miss. The genius of Hurt is summed up in changing one chord from the original that takes it to being a masterpiece of painful recollection.

Dolphins and Everybody's Talking are classics and I quite like his voice and the sound but it's a middle ranking album for me.

One of those middling albums that if I'd listened as a kid I might have made more of but coming to it cold it's fine, but only fine.

This is a really nice album. Tracey Thorn has a lovely voice, the songs are very gentle and overall a good piece of work.

A pleasant set of tunes that I didn't need to struggle through but don't necessarily need to hear again.

Why not? WHY NOT?

Difficult one to place. It is clearly an album of note, something really worthy of the list. But it's also a mad blanket of noise over songs and tunes trying to get out. Where they are allowed to, like on Only Shallow it creates a beautiful noise. On others the noise wins out. It's not my genre, but I can see that for that genre this is a thing so for sentimental reasons am over indexing it.

Well it's a dance album, it's like all dance albums, not made for listening to, but at least it tries a little more than a series of 4 bar repeats.

Nothing wrong with some good prog metal. Rush did some good prog metal.

I never was into Pulp and I came back to this fully expecting I'd dunk on it as not quite good enough Britpop warbling. But, well, even misfits have their moments of mainstream and this is as good as a pop/britpop album as any and it's full of gleeful fun songs that bring back great times. For one album, amongst a load of their average indie output, Pulp wrote and performed a masterpiece.

A really good album. Solid set of songs, great sound. Something I may come back to again.

I'm not quite sure about this. I admire Cohen as a writer of tales, a commentator on life, but the songs are not enough to draw you in as a musical work and the sound/production is terrible.

I'm no fan of live albums being on this list, but I recognise that this is often seen as a classic of the genre. That said, a handful of covers and not exactly a tight performance doesn't make me think this is all I was led to believe.

I have this on vinyl from back in the day and used to play the singles when I was a DJ. I loved their sound and that dance/indie fusion that was around at the time. Playing it again now I still like it but across a whole album it drags a bit. It’s a good album, it’s just perhaps not as good as I remember. Or maybe music moved on.

A full throated, fully derivative album of supremely average songs. It’s a nice sound, it’s a good production and it doesn’t have a single stand out track. Background music for terrible bars who would play it too loudly.

This is amazingly of its time, right down to the terrible electronic drums on the first few tracks. He could go back and record those properly and they might be ok. After a few songs they decide to have a decent drum sound and it's all a bit less ridiculous. Oh wait, no back to hitting a wet tea cloth Summary. There's something here desperate to break out but it's just very uneven.

The Grateful Dead are one of those bands I was aware of, knew the cult following around them and yet had no knowledge of their music at all. When I heard them I was completely surprised, I had never had in my head the idea that this was the music they made. It's good, country/folk/Americana call it what you will but I can see why people like them. Minor fact - they played their first ever UK gig in my village, about 200 yards from my house, 3 weeks before I was born.

A rollocking bit of rock fun

What you would expect from the Chili Peppers. A lot of their funky/white rap/discordant guitar and then one great great song. I don't know how to mark something that is generally a bore to listen to but has a stone cold classic but 3 feels very generous.

I have a bit of a problem with dance music/electronica particularly pure instrumental but this is a decent album. One I owned so I know reasonably well. So it cuts a bit above the crowd.

Ridiculous but great fun.

A perfect album which is almost impossible to pull off, as this project shows. There really isn't a bad song on this album. I know this album really well but still never mind re[listening to it. Every note sounds good to me and the songs build and play out in the right way. Verses, choruses, melodies. Ah those were the days of pop. Working hour ... the way it builds is beautiful. Everybody Wants to Rule the World was written because it needed a single and it's one of the greatest pop songs of the 80s. Everything about this is glorious. Even the bonkers last, instrumental track. Oh, and the production is beautiful - the 80s really knew how to let the instruments have space and depth.

I see it's a seminal album in thrash metal and I think for that genre that's a fair comment. It's really interesting, complex, musical whilst being of course in your face. I enjoyed it.

There are albums that are good, there are albums that are great and there is the Canon. Those albums so far ahead of the pack that there is a special place reserved from them. This is in the rock and pop Canon.

There's a lot of post punk I love, there's a new wave that needed pioneers. I can trace a line from this to them. There's a time when I'd have got into an album like this "just because" but it's difficult listening. But I can see what it led to.

Certainly in my personal top ten albums of all time, this is a track by track experience in perfection. A musical style almost all of their own but certainly influencing many others and a set of songs that burst with energy but are proper songs.

Very middling experience. Plenty of yelling over standard rock tracks and nothing stood out. I knew Election, as most people probably do, but I wasn't really interested by much on offer here.

I thought this was fun, it has a couple of classic songs and it could not be more 1984. That said, I thought it was a bit of a chore to get through as it was so light/pop/80s production that it felt it didn't quite pull it off as an album to go back to.

I bought this a long while back and had the same experience then than now when listening to it. A lazy, half hearted album with one of the best songs rendered acapella and lots of beats with random talking over. A great shame because when they made songs they really sounded great.

I have a lot of affection for Cohen. My mum was a big fan and though as a child I couldn't quite see the point I listened enough to have absorbed it into my musical heritage. This is a good reflection of his work - lyrically brilliant, musically average. That's the point I guess. He is his own genre.

It sort of passed over me, then suddenly the song I knew was played, then it drifted by again.

I doubt I'm the first person to say that this proves that Lennon and McCartney were right and Harrison had obviously bought a load of average songs into the Beatles rehearsals. If all double albums might have made a good single album, this triple album has a great EP in it.

I feel with this, just like with Hats, that some people that spent their teenage years wandering around in the rain worrying about girls might have liked this but if you missed that moment of vulnerability you would never quite get it. Tinsel Town in the Rain is great though.

One of those albums on here that's a pleasure to be introduced to. It's never going to be my jam, but I'm glad to have listened to it.

Something that was considered so radical and subversive at the time feels so tame and bland now. He was a good covers artist but other early rock and roll somehow stands up better. An album for your mum here.

Lyrics seem to have been written by a 12 year old. A cliché of a rock album and ridiculous. Geared me up for the Spinal Tap sequel.

A fine sound that washes over me whilst I work. Nothing to send me to either extremes of marking. Bang in the centre. Lovely voice though.

Ridiculous but fun

I didn't have this at the time, and I still have this bias that Blur didn't put together great albums but this is as good as they got. Enough songs to establish itself as a really good album but not quite consistent enough to be great.

Well I'm glad I listened to their masterpiece and not one of their shit albums.

I bought this for my mum, so this is an emotional vote.

It's difficult to find fault with Willie Nelson. Great voice, nice lyrics, it's an easy listen. It's just not my thing.

I'm not the demographic so kind of missed all of this strand of music when it came out. This is a glorious piece of work. Languid, trippy, hip hop with a hook and I really enjoyed it.

My opening thought was "oh Jesus" but I oddly enjoyed this. There's some weird stuff, obviously, and some mad syncopation and bad drumming but it's art pop and there's space for that in the world. I wouldn't recommend it to a friend, mind.

I loved Deep Purple as a kid so there’s a lot of nostalgia. Musically it’s a great band. Lyrically terrible.

I think I enjoyed this more than a Beach Boys album. Really good sound, some nice songs and a very pleasant listen.

Starts with promise but very quickly runs out of any ideas

Just not as good as all the indie press made out.

This is kind of bonkers - overblown show versions of songs with the madcap backing of the Divine Comedy.

There's there's a good reason this genre didn't travel past America over to us Brits. It's very very boring.

I’ve really enjoyed both spiritualized albums from this list. An album I’d have listened to a lot if it had arrived with me at the time.

Raw, powerful, emotional, atonal, rubbish. Write some songs Polly, write some songs.

A gentle, easy album with some lovely songs. There’s a reason some albums sell by the bucket load.

Gentle piece of work with a couple of classic songs on it. Drifted by quite nicely.

Intriguing collection of songs. Quirky but not in a bad way and I ended up listening a few times.

Sort of what you would expect, slightly sparse bleak post punk before PIL hit more of a groove. Certainly interesting.

Pages of 4 and 5 star reviews but an average of 3? Someone's been boosting reviews ... It's a non-album. Nothing of note at all.

Raw new wave New York punk. You can see where it goes.

One of those really pleasing finds. I'll make the obvious comment that I wasn't expecting this kind of album. Very enjoyable.

I didn't realise how well I knew this album until I listened to it again today. It's a pretty good all round pop album. Of its time, obviously, but I don't think I can knock it on that basis. It's a good set of songs.

It’s got some good songs, it still sounds pretty good but probably tails off a bit too much to be outstanding

It's a difficult album - experimental prog and I'm aware of Holger Czukay's work from David Sylvian albums. I guess avant-garde is a thing for some and it has influenced some great musicians. Unfortunately in some instances (Radiohead). But ultimately it isn't an album I'd listen to with any enthusiasm.

One of those albums that isn't hard work but isn't great either. I usually have a no live albums merit greatness award but I can understand why the odd one is put in - this was most definitely the best known Lizzy album when I was a kid.

Much better than I was led to believe by the reviews. Enjoyed the sound and the vibe.

Much better than I was led to believe by the reviews. Enjoyed the sound and the vibe.

This is another way that Tom Waits has grown on me. It's raw but compelling. I might listen to a lot more Tom Waits.

A bit of a mess this. Some things hit some things feel like they were just filling out time. I get the psychedelic folk roots thing but this just sounds like a bunch of guys taking too much stuff and recording whatever.

Some of the greatest songs written and performed - Only Living Boy being the stand out. It’s only let down by a vanilla cover of a song that already had a definitive version. That’s probably churlish though so I’ll skip and ignore.

I enjoyed it though it did wash over me a bit.

I love the Pixies but over time have neglected this album. It has one of the great "first sides " (for those of us that had it on vinyl originally. Absolutely blasts in with their cover of Cecilia Ann and then continues in same vein with Rock Song. Plenty of changes of style, plenty based on the country music with screaming they are known for. This is a lot better than I remember it.

The best song was the rock song. The rest of it was reasonably boiler plate angry man.

Post punk thumping toms but ultimately not quite there yet as a band. Hong Kong garden, not on the album but on the re-release, shows they were starting to write songs but the rest is a bit unsatisfactory.

I struggled a bit at the start but then a few of the hits came in and it perked up and then I just went with it. Fun, ridiculous rock.

I get that it was genre defining, I understand there's a thing. But this is over two hours of one idea over and over again. Someone now could make this with Logic Pro loops. It's of almost no musical merit. But it's not impossible to listen to so it doesn't hit the floor vote.

Pretty good album of rock/verging on what the UK would have as metal. Nothing spectacular but it's a thing.

One of those albums that is very American rock, and another one that doesn't hold much on interest to me, with not US Rock tastes. The lyrics, as others have said, are rather trite but the music is trite too. Nothing interesting, nothing discovered. It hardly sold even in the US, and there might just be a reason for that.

We get a lot of very USA albums that don’t work on my English ears. I suspect this is very much the same in reverse. It’s so British it could have been sung by a bulldog with a Union Jack jacket. British observational working class lyrics and a very accomplished band.

Well this is a supremely silly album. Funk is done better by many many other people. It fails to pass my unlistenable test but really 1001 people, we deserve better than this.

Sometimes the right album comes along in this sequence. After a tricky week of US rock landfill a melodic album with songs and plenty of texture can seem so much better. I enjoyed this a lot, it's a good album and holds up across the whole set of songs.

Nice sound nice groove but nothing stand out

It will be good when it’s finished. Halfway through it being on I thought "I should put some music on" then remembered this was playing. It's so light as to be overlooked. Of course, it's not terrible, and I understand why young men might be smitten by it but it's a novelty EP spun out.

It's a nice sound but it's very shallow.

Hendrix is a genius, inspired many, was one of the great guitarists yet never seemed to make a decent album. The gap between his ability and the consistency of his records is the widest I can think of.

I've never been a huge fan as I found them a bit repetitive - maybe the sound of Stype doesn't quite do it for me. But this is a really good album with some great songs and very consistent.

I love the Specials. Fun, energy and just a moment where music of all sorts took over the British charts. Patchy, yes but still a good album. I suspect one that the Americans really don't get. It's so culturally British and of a time.

Another album that I listened to without particularly feeling engaged. Pleasant enough but not my sort of thing.

I enjoyed this - lovely light album. Marlena is a great song. Folky and gentle.

This is a great album. Fantastic sound, great set of songs. I've always loved the single, it's an absolute classic. OK it's one that obviously appeals to my musical taste but it was still very consistent across the whole album and just a great production.

Rather boring, flat, unremarkable. It may well be a grower or some hidden masterpiece but on the listen I gave it, it's not worth bothering about.

I don't know this album as well as Blue Lines, though I did buy it at the time. It's a really fantastic piece of work. For a moment in time trip hope was a sound that was new, vibrant and great to listen to. Often much more interesting than the rap genres it derives from, it is a sound of Britain, and indeed Bristol where I studied at the time it was all happening. So glad to have rediscovered this masterpiece. (OK we will forget the last track as if it had never happened)

For people that like this sort of thing this is probably a very good example. For people that are browsing the genre, it's not exactly going to spark a lifetime's fanship. Probably better full of beer in a field and yelling along.

There's no reason why anyone should love Steely Dan but there's also no reason on earth to hate them. This is as smooth as music gets. A great British rock critic once told me that there was never a bad time to listen to Steely Dan and that sort of sold me on them. This isn't the highest of their peaks, but it's a piece of work. Deacon Blue is a beautiful example of the texture, and lyrical agility of Becker and Fagen. Peg is an absolute pick up for any moment - though I think I have to thank De La Soul for that.

Two Steely Dan in a row - I guess it sometimes happen. So good I listened to it four times. Some great songs, really well written music and lyrically. And, like the last one, smooth as music gets. Not going to be one of the greatest albums of all time but definitely a good album.

You know what you are getting right form the start - performance art, not music. It's aimed at a certain type of person to nod along knowingly and point out the strands of the metaphors, how the music brings out the timbre of the artists mood. That sort of rubbish. Basically it's for people that hate it to pretend they love it to other people who also hate it and are pretending they love it so they all seem "cultured" and smart in loving something they know everyone hates. Well done.

An interesting album of its genre. Nerd point is that I particularly like the production/snare drum sound. Enjoyed it in a good but not great way.

Nice bawdy punk with tunes and a good sound. Just a bit short of stand out songs but pleasant notheless.

Not for me I'm afraid. I'm OK with shoegaze, I'm OK with Prog but this is just a long and uninteresting ramble.

A beautiful album, obviously important for her breakthrough. Doesn't quite hit 5 because it's mainly a covers album and I have rules.

Another pleasure from this project. Listening to albums I would have no earthly reason to otherwise find. It's interesting for obvious reasons, and a perfectly good listen. Not ultimately my thing, but we all knew that before I played it.

Indie landfill. One for a certain USA audience. I think that of this genre there are loads better albums.

Starts on a real high - I hadn't clocked that was Coldcut for some reason. There's some other good tunes, but ultimately feels a bit like one of those "megamixes" as it winds on. It's of its time of course.

Was a bit too avant-garde for me and a bit early for me to appreciate. I get its significance and that of Kraftwerk but that doesn’t necessarily mean I also would return to it.

Certainly Radiohead’s high point, certainly one of the best of all time. A sprawling prog rock epic masquerading as an indie album. Moments of the sublime. When Radiohead still liked to write songs they created a classic.

It was OK - perfectly passable post-hardcore. Could see myself listening at a moment in time but not going to convince me now.

I don’t know about this. It’s fun I guess and the creator wasn’t taking himself too seriously. And it influenced hip hop. So I cut it some slack

I was all ready to dunk on this. Jazz is hard enough but Freeform jazz … anyway to hell with it, one of music’s greats doing something different and there should be more of that in life.

It’s of interest, and of course of note for his influence. Fair play to him he starts off by saying it’s not actually musical or melodic or structured. It’s honest at least.

His is really nice. Some beautifully structured songs. Good production as you might expect from an accomplished producer as well as artist. But there’s nothing to raise the eyebrows. No stand out songs. It’s good but I can’t think it’s moving anything anywhere. Nice though. Might listen again.

Probably of some note at the time - that dance/acid house movement of the Uk but it’s not aged well. One song and a lot of not very much.

Fairly mad album - certainly an experience. Not sure what to think about it but I think it was worth listening to.

I don't think you can accuse this album of having any rough edges. It's a soulful jazzfest throughout. To the point that it might be a parody album, I can't really tell.

I thought this was an outstanding piece of work. Really reminiscent, or more correctly influential, on music I've enjoyed in my life but first time I've consciously heard him. I can see from the write up that this isn't necessarily representative of his earlier work, but it's a fine piece of music.

A fun raucous punk album. After the last two weeks of bland soup I’ve had to sit though I can fully understand now why punk happened and thank god for it. Sometimes you just need to smash it up a bit.

It’s interesting as a curiosity but my word it’s a shambles. He wasn’t fit to record and it’s mess of half written and half performed songs. I never really got the Sid was the genius story. He wrote whimsical songs. He fell apart. This seems half a sincere attempt to get him through his problems and half an attempt to exploit them.

Probably my least favourite genre and this lived down to expectations. Sure, Waterfall is a great pop song but the rest of it is bland plinky plonk over empty drum machines with melodies that are not even trying.

It's OK, but no more than that. He has this slightly miserable but wants to be a west end show vibe about him. The songs are fairly unremarkable though. I listened to it a few times and it was passable background music.

One of those albums that is worth hearing even if it's not quite for me. I guess the US brand of punk/hardcore didn't quite land in the UK, and that kind of genre throughout this project has been littered with US albums that we just didn't listen to. I remember Henry Rollins doing his spoken word gig at my University in the early 90s and I'd never heard of him. Anyway, nice to hear a bit of anger and some structure to punk.

My standard problem with Costello. Some fantastic songs but I can't take a whole album of it. I should love it as British new wave but I've never managed quite to be sold on him. He's got a greatest hits album many would beg for, but his albums are not very compelling.

I kind of love Pfunk, Funkadelic and all of that scene. It was incredibly influential on some great pop but is great in itself. I don't mind the prog funk approach to songs and very happily get into the groove here.

I started to enjoy it, at least I think I enjoyed it, then I slowly got lost in its lack of tone and then it just descended into noise.

This is an album I bought in my heavy Talking Heads phase and it's still a good listen - though it tails off after the pop songs it's still got the kind of grooves and sounds that make it interesting.

A really pleasant listen though on some of the tracks the terrible drumming rather spoiled it for me as did some of the rather forced lyrics. Consequently a bit middling rather than a great album. Another of those Mercury wins that went for "a bit different" over "the best album this year". "Once around the block" is a good song, the rest a bit ephemeral.

Despite being a bit sceptical with it being such a recent album I really enjoyed this. A nice light Saturday listen.

Another desperately American album from a band that didn't every trouble the UK. It's formulaic nu metal with terrible lyrics and dreadful songs. Maybe in its genre it does something but there's a reason none of this ever travelled to the UK.

The hits are great, happy infectious pop. The rest of the album makes a lot more sense to me now I know that Nick Heyward was a fan of Talking Heads and XTC. He's trying to create the same grooves and pop sensibility of the two. It doesn't quite work because he lacks, probably, the slight off beam genius of those two bands.

A few tunes but mainly it sounds like someone has set the loops in Logic Pro and then sung some songs over them. It feels such a lazy boring way to make music. Sometimes it really works when the melody is there but over a whole album it feels creatively thin.

After a few insipid manufactured albums this was an absolute pleasure of muso self indulgence.

Yea, it's the White Album. It has everything - every idea any band has ever had since stems from this work. It's nearly 60 years old for christs sake. Why doesn't anyone try to make anything interesting any more?

I have a lot of reviews bemoaning formulaic albums so it would be a bit churlish to knock this - a proper avant-garde 21st century album. Maybe would like a bit more song to the song but it's still a lovely listen and self-consciously experimental.

The classic version of all the classics. A different kind of era and a different kind of singer but it's a pleasure to listen to.

It's polished and they are clearly of a kind well liked but I can't get past how flat and uninteresting I find them. Just never grabbed me.

Hit Me Baby One More Time is an absolute classic, one of the great pop songs of all time. The rest feels a little formulaic but I'd rather have an album of pop songs than an album of pop "sounds" that don't bother putting a song together. Dated, a bit hit and miss but it's a pop album, it's not supposed to get me to change the world.

One of those albums that everyone bought for their parents. Only now I'm a parent and I'm old and this is good and the songs are good and the production is that lovely 80s open sheen of sound. This is what a great album sounds like.

Swampy blues rock that does what it does.

I think this is a fairly uninspiring new wave album with one great song that wasn't even originally on it. There's a strand of UK new wave that was just a bit purposeless/moody but underwhelmed on the songs.

Beautifully performed, produced and orchestrated bunch of nothings. It's got a great sound and not a single song.

I didn't really listen to any Neil Young until my 40s. Which I guess is also the right time to listen to Neil Young. This is a great rock and roll album, from the production to the raw sound of live recording. More one note guitar solos in my life and this sounds tremendous in Atmos.

Enjoyable but essentially musak.

I think this is another one where the US post-punk movement and the UK post-punk movement were divergent. So I don't know this and I don't think it was as influential on our strand of music. It's fine though.

I started a bit unsure but hey, this is one of the groundbreaking albums that defined a genre and of course everyone should listen to it.

Jazz takes many forms, some of which I like some that I can appreciate and some that pass me by. This is somewhere between the last two.

Never quite got into Depeche Mode though I know the singles this was a definite hit. Really good album, great sound and far better than I knew.

I've done Pentangle a few times now, and I worship at the bass of Danny Thompson but it's not really my thing. That said, it is "A" thing and it's musically very good and part of a very British folk tradition. One of those things that I don't need myself but I'm very glad is there.

Not exactly an album to listen to and hum along. Very of its time and I'm sure fine in a club.

Maybe it's groundbreaking but it's also mind-numbingly boring.

Some good moments - and despite all the hype I thought more homage to Beatles than Nirvana - but overall despite a good sound and production it didn't have any stand out songs. I think the hype was willing them to do well rather than recognising their limitations.

It's good to hear a recent album that has substance, a great sound and songs and is a pleasure to listen to. I don't know whether it will stand up against time but it's one of the best post 2000 albums in this project so far.

After a run of variable albums it's always a joy to open up an old friend. Doves had two great albums, in my mind, and a third that was still very good. This is a moody, melodic, atmospheric album that sits at the bookend of the golden era of British indie. Not quite perfect but that’s a high bar for me.

One of the joys of my later life has been discovering Nick Cave. I didn't take to The Birthday Party as a teenager and took some time to get over that and actually listen to Cave. He's a fantastic lyricist, polemicist and artist. This is a fun, fascinating, captivating piece of work. Listen away. The man's a genius.

A minor curiosity of its time.

One paced American rock/post punk that doesn’t intend to go anywhere and succeeds.

An album that is mixed but also one I’d place a lot later so I can see how it was influential and moved music along. I think a bit variable but with some absolute classics.

The birth of modern music and a genius that was too short lived

Enjoyable in parts but drags in others. Certainly a broad piece of art but hard going for the casual listener.

Lovely piece of work whilst also being too long and drifting too much in parts.

Loud raucous rock and roll at breakneck speed. I’m all in for it.

Good wholesome post punk and for once a US album from that era/genre which isn’t bland

I enjoyed this a lot more than I remember. Plenty of great songs, great sound - I'm a sucker for the 80s approach to production - and a good soul/funk vibe to it all.

Marvellous - a rousing epic of an album. More things should sound like this.

To my ears this is the worst kind of plinky plonk country - though I am sure that those that love country may have a completely different view.

I didn't know how this would stand up. I had it at the time and saw them live on the early tours but had sort of forgotten how smooth and laid back a lot of this album is - even though they went full lounge jazz after this. Groove and a great sound. I enjoyed returning to this.

The first time I listened it fell flat but it just so happened I had time yesterday for a few more listens through. It is really good in an understated way without being spectacular.

I found this reasonably boring

I don’t know why anyone would find this pleasurable. A long tuneless moan

Such a boring band but I have this theory that if I was 13 years old when I first heard them I would have loved them. But yes, boring. Apart from No Cars Go, which is a really good song.

In that way it's probably my favourite Blur album it's also not that consistent. Some good songs, some experimentation. A good band but not a great one. Yet Damon is a genius for all the other things he's done alongside this.

High anger high energy rap that is a fine example of the genre.

I've tried with Wyatt, and I'll try again but this is painful stuff.

Stands up pretty well as a full on rock and roll blast of noise and energy. I think I liked this more now than I did then.

A lovely voice wasted on some vaudeville cover-by-numbers country songs. Lovely, but it's just karaoke.

The 20 year old me thought Nirvana were a Pixies rip off band, though of course in Smells Like Teenage Spirit they did it well. Even Cobain said they wanted to sound like Pixies. This is an amazing debut album though. The energy/sound/songs and the tight rendering. It just sounds like rock music should sound and is so much better than almost all of the moody but ultimately tune light grunge coming out of the US at that time. Basically all but Pixies, who invented the sound this is based on. The young me was far too snobbish about the purity of music. This is a classic.

Great psychedelic folk that stands up well what with having some great songs and all that.

Starts out with a song of howlingly bad lyrics with dead rhymes. Carries on with pretty much every dull country cliché. Maybe they invented the clichés, who knows.

Proper full on rock/metal with catchy tunes and sing alongs. Yes we all know the songs too well but there's a reason for that.

I obviously hate electronic dance music, I obviously bought this album like everyone else. It still sounds good, it's seeped into the consciousness of my brain and it is as good as this terrible genre will ever get.

Oh to be at the dawn of punk when this meant something rather than sounding like a shambolic rant.

I kind of like the Kinks, particularly their lyrical Englishness, but this is a bit pedestrian as a set of songs. Apart from Sunny Afternoon nothing really sticks out.

It's probably better at the gig, like a lot of live albums. Listening to it each song just merges into the other one.

My mum loved Joni and she loved Leonard Coen. I loved Blue - the first verse of "case of you" is a masterpiece of writing. I don't think I would have come to her if it hadn't been played to me as a kid - it's obviously very arty folk and her voice and phrasing are unique. This is a superb album, definitely one of the best ever and it deserves its reputation.

I really enjoyed this. XTC had moments of pop brilliance with some bits that were too obscure to really engage with. This sits neatly in the middle as a kind of prog album. It's one I hadn't heard before and it was a real pleasure.

A couple of days ago I posted a review saying that electronic dance music was the worst genre. I apologise to those fans because I had forgotten that drum and bass is the worst music genre. Botempi organ music - tedious repetitive rubbish a child could create.

I am not sure whether it's my lack of ear for country but I don't see this as particularly stand out or quite get why it won such plaudits. It's pleasant enough but it doesn't warrant another listen.

I'm still fighting through this as I write, but this is awful. It's not got a single song on it. Just aimless warbling over a drum machine with the odd little wibble wobble synth sound in the background. One song of it might work, but a whole album of it is torture. Only critics like tuneless rubbish like this.

An enjoyable pastiche of fiddle music and soul. Not something that I'm going to keep with me but perfectly listenable.

It's songs in the key of life. Just don't listen to the albums after it.

I thought this was a lovely album. Great set of songs, very consistent. I'll listen to this again, definitely.

The Theme from Shaft is a great song. The music from the film Shaft is things to listen to in the background whilst watching the film Shaft. Otherwise it's just a boring pile of nothing.

I needed a bit of rock today. Apart from a rotten Kinks cover, not a bad attitude.

A beautiful polished pop album - new wave/new romantic call it what you will - they put together a great album here. As great a bunch of songs that came from that era, a great sound with Andy Taylor bringing in rock sensibility, John Taylor is an astonishing bass player who should be mentioned in lists but is always overlooked. (First time for me hearing the US remixes - they sound terrible.)

Although I think Eminem is one of the greats in his field, I did find this a bit more patchy on re-listening than I thought I would.

I hoped coming back to this that I'd find something new but no, it's just an atonal mess. Self indulgent, and I guess what you can do with a major label recording contract and some hits behind you. Spend months producing sonic soundscapes without any tunes.

I'm glad that avant garde punk/rock exists and I'm glad they released this and I'm glad I don't have to listen to it again. These are not negative thoughts. There's a space for music like this and there are other bands that went somewhere more melodic with the influence of this band/record.

This is a sprawling work of genius. Sometimes infuriatingly throw away often sublime. It's not a first listen album I think - it rewarded me listening a few times as a kid. Something about it being so disjointed and jumping around the styles. It's a classic though, a one off from a one off. None of the easy constitency of Purple Rain but a rolling sound of bursting creativity. I had a ticket to see Prince on this tour. He cancelled. I never did see Prince.

Interesting from a British prog/psychedelia perspective. Clearly of that strain of Pink Floyd kind of scene. Not brilliant, just interesting.

I was at the Mercury Award ceremony when this won album of the year. I was surprised then and I’m still surprised. It’s nice enough but nothing that engaging. Nice lead track and not a lot else to hook onto

Solid album of iconic reggae.

This is a blast of rock and roll that captures the energy of one of the greats. Without his awful inhumanity he would have been so much more.

I didn't know this album but it felt very familiar to me, and I did know the main tracks. Really enjoy this period of the post punk development of New Wave. The punks learned to sing and play their instruments and it laid the ground for so much that came after.

An album I don't know but definitely sits in one of my happy places between punk and new wave/pop. The developing scene of music that drew from punk sensibilities but bought musicianship and songs. It's not full of catchy songs, it's a sound. I think it's something I might have listened to a lot at the time but probably has passed too long for me to give it the time.

It’s an easy listen and it’s easy not to listen to it again. Good though.

I was ready to trash this as a terrible end of career mistake when U2 had run out of songs but it starts out with three great singles and it is fairly consistent on songs. It's nowhere near the heights of their career, but most bands would be pretty happy to have put this out. I'm not saying it's great, it's just not a turkey.

A good listen but not a remarkable album. Solid.

Really good listen. Sort of timeless - could have been from any decade and I wouldn't have guessed 60s. A pleasure.

It’s 1973 and the boys are playing the blues. Enjoyed this.

I've never quite got the Fall. I don't hate it though.

I thought this was lazy drivel.

Light bouncy indie psychedelic tunes. Fun and fine.

Jay Z passed me by apart from the obvious but this is a top rank hip hop album. Great use of sounds and rhythm and a really solid piece of work.

Solid swamp/blues rock call it what you like but this was a great album.

A dreary music genre is not going to be lifted by this example of its oeuvre. the first song drifts into a repetitive phrase, the second song drifts in with incoherency and I desperately want this to end. The third song barely makes an effort. Christ some of this is total rubbish. Randomly repeating words over dreadful substance free plinky plonking. Starts very badly and gets much much worse.

Fairly pedestrian

A set of great songs, plenty of punk energy. What's not to like.

Boundless joy. One of my favourite albums of all time.

I was going to rate this low, as it's a live album, but it's a fine piece of work. Not stella, but fine.

This is a really good album - this is how you do electronic pop. Remember to write some songs.

It's a lovely album, it's the Eagles, it's easy and has some great songs but ultimately it's a bit forgettable.

It's a great sound and it will eventually work better on Scott 4. This is a more variable set of songs.

It's a great sound, Skunk is a great singer, everything is great apart from the songs. Not one of them stands out. Maybe "Lately" but even that's a bit by numbers.

A superb album by an extraordinary artist that laboured without success in his too short lifetime. White Bicycles by Joe Boyd it a great read about Nick Drake and his life and work. Thankfully due to the friendship and patronage of Joe Boyd his albums were never deleted and he eventually found his audience. He released records at an amazing time for creativity in music and in British music. The folk movement was overshadowed by rock and pop. Relative to his peers he found it hard to be heard. But over the lifetime of recorded music his work really does stand out.

I think this is the perfect album of this genre. It’s a great example pf the fact that you can build a song around a groove or a simple chord structure but you also need the melody to do the heavy lifting. Take note every artist basing their career on albums written on a computer since 2001

I tried with the Penguin Cafe orchestra in my pretentious teenage faze and like now I couldn’t quite connect.

I do like this album, particularly the Old Man. A perfect 30 minutes of englishness. Thank god Scott existed.

I enjoyed this a lot. I knew the single, the rest was new to me.

I get how part of this project is to get you to listen to things you would otherwise not. But this is basically like a soundtrack to a very long children's TV show from the 1970s.

This is a mess. None of the band seem to know how to keep together, it's a shambles. At times un-listenable. Usually I find I can bear to get through every album here. This one I had to take a break halfway through to rest my ears.

I liked this, but I think people only need one Sigur Ros album in their life, and it isn't this one.

For a 1980 album this sounds like it invented the sound of 83/4/5 Everyone else was coming out of punk and new wave and into the cusp of pop. This seems to have been ahead of that. For good and ill. This is truly tedious though.

From every note to every emote this is one of the greatest albums ever created. The lyrical dexterity, the songs built on melody and complex chord structure and Thomas Dolby's peak as a producer. Paddy McAloon is one of the greatest songwriters these isles have produced. This is one of the great albums of all time. I got to it by chance - I won a competition for 4 tickets to the gig in Stoke that evening. Me and my mate went. I still have the other two tickets. Wendy was ill. It didn't matter, I was introduced to some sort of genius.

I was at a BBQ at a friend’s house in around 2001/2. His old flatmate kept taking the music off and putting his band’s demo tape on. It got very annoying. My pal said they were never gong to make it as they had been trying for years. The Darkness did make it though. Can’t be too serious about music and sometimes it’s just fun to enjoy.

I like Rod’s voice and all that but covers albums don’t count. I get that Rod couldn’t write songs, but get yourself a songwriter if you want to go solo

I know I should love it as it's Frank Black but I found it all a bit lacking in something - nothing stand out, nothing terrible. Maybe something if I listened to a lot I could get into but on this timetable didn't grab me.

Never been a big fan of the voice or the sound. They had their short moment in a very long career but this is bland and nothing stands out.

Light, fun album. I think this is one I'll listen to again a bit. I like Hot Chip, not least because it gives me hope that as a very old man I can still make it in pop.

An album can be groundbreaking and still be rubbish. I get how electronica needed influences like this, I can also agree that it is a movement that lacks musical merit.

An interesting little vignette

A couple of classics, a lot of standard 12 bar blues and some godawful stereo production putting instruments in each ear (drums only on the left? What were they thinking of). I get they were influential and this is part of their journey but I'm not sure it's a classic.

When someone goes through all Marianne Faithfull did it's going to sound rough. It's all about redemption that she managed it. She's no working class hero though - she's a posh kid that clearly struggled with mental health.

I ignored Nick Cave for about three decades. A good friend at 6th form liked the Birthday Party and I thought it was a hot mess. In the last 10 years I've repented and am very much looking forward to seeing him again live this year. So it was with some trepidation I went back to the source of my dismissal, and it started off prodding me to that memory. As it went on, though, I started to really see the reason Cave shone through - the anger is focused, the lyrics are forming and the sound is the wail of a young man that mellowed.

It's a rocking blues album with too long songs and jamming and who knows what but I'm all in for it today.

It started out strong but then really dragged.

It's Bowie, it's genius.

Fairly poor recording of an OK set of live songs. My general problem with live albums is that unless they are uniquely interesting it's just a fancy greatest hits album. So I mark them down accordingly.

"I cannot understand why you just moved to Finland" sort of encapsulates why this is such a dreadful self-indulgent album. Some awful cod American accent stuff. Some Beatlesish melody songs. Some of the worst lyrics the Gibb brothers ever put down on record. Altogether a struggle to get through.

I didn't know the role of Dinosaur Jr in shoegaze, but it makes sense after listening to this. It's an album I might have got into as a kid but it's all too late now.

There are jazzers there are anti-jazzers and I sit somewhere in the middle. But this didn't grab me. I did muse that if I was 18 years old when this came out I'd have been right on it, but they had invented words by the time I was born.

This production sounds so good - really deep sound. And of course the songs and the musicianship. One of the greats.

This held up a lot more than I thought it would

Dark, sparse album but has a thread to it that makes it compelling. A long way from Joy.

I can listen to death metal but it doesn't go anywhere does it? I guess it's more of a live experience or a primordial need for angry sound.

One of those that is discovered by this process that would never have otherwise be found. It jollied along, albeit at a bit too long. Nobody should hear Imagine again in any form though.

It feels wrong to be snooty about the marvellous Niles Rodgers and a band that have been so important and influential in disco and pop. But this is half an album only. Two amazing songs, but as a whole it's fairly uneven.

I don’t know whether this is a slow burning indie classic or a bit of a ramble. I’d have been listening to Pixies at the time so would probably have considered this a bit second rate.

I’ve never been all in on Costello but I needed to hear something with songs and new wave after a procession of average albums so he gets marked up.

I've never been a great fan of REM. Something about the sound I find a bit repetitive, something about his voice doesn't quite do it for me. But then this album has such a rich set of songs, Peter Buck hadn't yet bought a mandolin to ruin every song and it's as good an album as you will hear. Four or five absolute classic songs.

I thought I was going to hate this but it was a bit more of the accessible side of Can.

Very different, kind of beautiful. I don’t know if I’d listen to it again and again but for this one day I enjoyed it.

I am not a massive fan and this is OK but just grates a bit.

Unsurprisingly this is incredibly repetitive. For those that like this sort of thing at least they have some tunes but otherwise it is really really boring. Elektrobank is one of the worst songs ever to grace a No1 album. Also, "It Doesn't Matter" is too. This song is mind blowingly bad. No song has been this long and less whelming in the history of music.

An album I don't know, though I know the lead single by a band I was never completely aware of, though I know John Peel played them. I think now there's lots of albums and bands I love that have a debt to Sonic Youth, I probably should have given them more time and this was certainly worth listening to.

An album my mum had that sort of sat there without me playing it for years until I slowly decided to explore some of the back catalogue. It's sort of brilliant, whilst also only understandable if you get that he's a poet not a musician and he's got his own kind of style.

A mad prog album of songs and things and I might actually listen to this a lot. At first I thought it was a bit Muse but it’s much more interesting than that.

I thought this was a wonderful album. Full of songs, sounds as fresh as if it were released now. I don't think I've ever listened to a Pretenders album but this is going on my list of things to go back to again and again. OK - I'm a sucker for new wave and anything post punk but this is a fantastic album.

I've never enjoyed Queen in the round, only in singles and bursts. This is good, and has interesting songs but it didn't grip me.

Not unlistenable is about as enthusiastic as I can get about this album.

It's fascinating to listen to, as it's obviously very very influential. It's also very difficult to listen to as a drummer, as he's clearly terrible. It's a fun pastiche of every metal lyric but also bad. Presumably bad in a way that lots of very important musicians found to be good.

All the bluegrass you will ever need to listen to. Get one bluegrass album, get this one. That’s it.

Maybe it’s not one of the greatest albums ever, maybe it isn’t that peak of creativity but for me it is a great album with a consistent set of songs and I’d be happy to listen to it a lot.

It's not obvious to me when each song finishes and another one starts. This is wallpaper. Dinner party music. The album the manager of the Noble in Finsbury Park recommended I listened to. Background.

Mad art rock which is much older than I thought Roxy started. Enjoyable fun.

Well if you are going to listen to thrash metal you might as well listen to one of the best.

It's perfectly enjoyable, but not very profound.

I don't know whether this is a perfect expression of country/pop in the late 80s or oddly bland. It's taken lots of awards and plaudits (though in the UK we have never heard of it/her) so it means something, and it's not a bad album really. I'm going to give it a break.

There were a whole load of records in the pile my parents had at home that I listened to all the time. One of the records in the pile was this, which my mother owned. I never played this as a kid for the following reasons: 1) I'd never heard of Carole King; 2) I'm still not entirely confident of the difference between a tapestry and an embroidery. 3) It seemed to be a load of cover versions. My mum also had some terrible covers albums and I thought this was one of them. Frankly why would I listen to this woman I'd never heard of singing a song rather than listen to the Aretha Franklin original? So I don't know exactly when it happened, but I either read it was a thing or someone told me it was a thing and I thought "I've got that". It's pretty much a perfect album if you pretend that Smackwater Jack doesn't exist. And I've come to terms with that song as time has gone by. Of course, they were all her songs and like others (some here) the covers thing was a mistake. She was a hell of a songwriter and it turns out she was a hell of a performer too. Carole King is a remarkable and important figure in the history of music and this is one of the greatest albums ever made.

This was a struggle.

I'm sure groundbreaking, it's definitely avant garde but it's also not really a selection of songs, it's a selection of sounds. A curiosity so I'll give it an extra star.

My wife has a theory that the Fugees ruined pop music. They took everything and slowed it down with generic "beats" and wailing. She's onto something with this bland procession of blah.

Another country album that I'm sure is great of the genre but isn't for me. Nice harmonies. Pretty samey all the way through.

Slacker blues and perfectly listenable. Not really that compelling.

Like a lot of the influential metal and thrash albums I recognise that it’s an important and wildly popular genre but often it’s just not for me. This is too samey.

I don’t know whether this is a pretentious album that would have appealed to my younger self or a pretentious album that bores my older self.

It’s a nce album but if they had picked the best songs and kept it single they could really have had something. As it is there’s too much drift.

Could not find a way of listening to this full album on any service. So only heard the first song. I don't feel I was missing out.

I always find the Stones albums very variable. A real inconsistency in songs backed up by some of the greatest of all time. This is no exception. A curious band.

Ground breaking and incredibly influential but so lame in retrospect. It’s hard to appraise this in a modern era where it’s just repetitive sounds when it was such a leap when it came out.

Unexpected this one - it didn't pass consciousness in the UK. It's a really interesting album. Lo fi, but tuneful and engaging.

"Dion effectively disowned the record" and so should you.

More to add to my late life discovery of Neil Young

It’s a lovely album. Whether it’s a great album is a different matter. Minis points for terrible car lyrics and ending the Art Garfunkel collaboration for good.

I did not realise it was recorded in 1982. Makes it more of an influential ahead of its time piece.

I don’t see this as anything particularly notable. And some lyrics have dated terribly.

Avant-garde, mental, weirdly compelling. I mean there are tunes here and she just does her mad thing. It’s worth listening to. Really.

A lovely stripped down immersive piece

Really enjoyed this. Something a bit different, not heard of it before. A nice break from some of the drudgery of this project.

I saw Adele live at the time. She said about 4 songs in "you better dance to this one because it's all slow from now on" or something like that. It was and so is this. Shouty lyrics and soulful sounds and my god it's tedious. I can't believe this will stand up to history. But hey. It sold "a lot".

This is a mad masterpiece.

Not my favourite Roxy sound. Though some of it clearly influenced another favourite of mine, Japan. A bit too honky art rock for me and a bit short on stand out songs.

Jolly bit of jazz. Light and not too jazzy.

Well it had one thing I knew and lots of other samples I could recognise. But in the end it's just the same thing on repeat on every song. I imagine it as useful stock music for "TV Montages" but really, would you listen to it?

I knew as soon as I saw it that the US contingent would go nuts that this was on the list. A well known band in the UK and indeed one year had the biggest selling album in the world (Stars). Sadly, the US contingent are correct. This is an awful album in retrospect. A couple of songs, a lot of filler and the worst ever cover of a Talking Heads song ever committed to vinyl. It was painful listening to him kill Heaven. This "does not" stand up in retrospect.

Beautiful voice, incredible array of songs. Minus points for compilation and covers.

So much of modern RnB is just warbling over "sounds". I don't think there's a single recognisable song here.

Jingle jangle jingle jangle jingle jangle. Nice harmonies. A bit one paced.

A difficult one as I know it well and have a fondness for it but I'm not sure objectively I would rate it 4/5 stars. So I have plumped down the middle.

I enjoyed this and it's a perfectly good rock record but it's not something I'd be that interested in properly immersing myself in.

Everyone should listen to this. It’s a seminal album of its genre. Then everyone should give it one star, because it’s rubbish

Bouncy fun roots.

A really good album. Plenty to immerse yourself in, some great songs and a warm sound.

Pretty solid album, good sound, some songs. Nothing remarkable but reasonably up my street.

One of those albums that didn't quite gel on first listen but I had the chance of being on train journeys so listened to it a few times and it grew on me.

I don't know. In some ways it was an interesting experience. It was not difficult to listen to. But did it do anything interesting?

Ah, takes me back to 6th form college and Birthday coming out and sounding like nothing else and then this album with its post punk energy. It's a great album, though I think their third is better.

Some seminal metal and for once a live album that actually sounds live rather than overdubbed.

A lovely piece of work, some nice songs, some nice textures. Not a stellar album but plenty of charm.

Avant gard, tuneful, experimental. Really interesting piece of work. I might listen to this a few times.

Every so often in this you get an album that stands on its record. Lots of bands have influence but this was a seismic point in the history of music. Their influence is obviously huge but also, as a Brit, you can ground it in a time when everything was going to shit. The 70s were terrible, a dark, dangerous, difficult, hopeless decade and it took a long time to get out of it. Punk was a product of that. Sure the Clash made better albums, and others had the same ideas but the Pistols were a package of music, attitude and PR management that made a serious impact. And you know what, Anarchy in the UK, God Save the Queen, Pretty Vacant etc. all sound forceful nearly 50 years later. And people still jump up and down and sing along. Not bad.

The uptempo funky Temptations with their fine voices and some banging tunes.

There's room for innovators. After the horror of Trout Mask Replica this was a blessed relief.

Surprisingly accessible end of Slipknot. Underneath this kind of metal is some incredible musicianship.

It's The Beatles, it's Revolver. Take a step back you ridiculous person - it's one of the most important albums in the history of music. We amateurs are not worthy of reviewing it. Modern music started here.

It’s not a terrible album, it’s just a very unremarkable album. Nothing happens

Perfectly pleasant but completely unremarkable.

I wasn’t sure about this but it was a great piece of work full of texture.

I found this a bit of a struggle. It's not a great set of songs. Sure, the glam/metal edge to it was interesting and for a time they were "huge" in the UK. But it really hasn't dated well.

Grime is one of the worst musical gifts that England has given to, well, just England as none of this travels for obvious reasons. A mildly popular sub genre that gets far far far too much media attention. This is slightly interesting but no more.

Good bouncy soulful album that is a pleasure to listen to but doesn't stand out.

Great songs great sound. Second soul in two days but back to back I’d give this one more star.

I've always liked this album. A very British mash up of soul, ska and I guess folk. Geno was such a good single, really made an impression on me at the time. Still enjoy listening to this.

This is a lazy set of songs. Half formed jamming riffs with terrible lyrics. Really terrible lyrics.

Not the worst of the electronica, by far, but not that compelling either. It's just repetitive sounds and never feels that serious as a musical form.

Lovely gentle album, just the thing to listen to on a long train home after an exhausting 5 days at a conference.

Sort of lovely but it's mainly covers. The Beatles cover is outstanding though.

Really good for what it is - I'd probably listen to this again. Nothing spectacular though.

There's a big cultural difference in the paths indie took in the early 90s. In the US I do think it got stuck in this rather uninteresting deep indie sound and forgot the songs.

It's a great piece of pop. I'm no great fan of modern RnB but this has songs and attitude and a great sound.

Thorn has a lovely voice and their better work has been on songs with traditional structures. I get why bands try new musical styles but ultimately this genre dumbs down all the music. Definitely liked it better on second listen though it drops off a bit.

It's a sweet set of songs. Definitely at the pop end of country.

A really great bridge from new wave/post punkish Joy Division to what really became New Order and the use of sequencing/loops and techniques from the dance world to develop a different strand of indie music in the UK. The two down sides are the lyrics and Barney's dreadful voice. Which is a shame because this is a really good album otherwise.

Really lovely piece of work. Hadn't heard of him or his tragic story before.

Some of the best German Industrial music ever created. I don't know whether it's maddening or musical though. But if you only listen to one German Industrial album, this is probably the one to listen to.

I have said before, I like that music has space for albums like this. I just think the conceit has been executed better by other instrumental albums.

Gentle, lovely sound and great harmonies. Ultimately a song or two light.

I wasn't totally sure what to expect but this is a really good album. All the use of harmonies you expect from them and with some rich songs and just a good listen. Big shout out for 33m long albums too.

I came to this album via Infected, which is a more polished album. The drum machine still grates a bit but the album itself stands up really well. Very much enjoyed going back to this.

It's completely legitimate to put Throbbing Gristle in this kind of list. I'm glad I listened to it. Genesis P Orridge was an auteur of some note. It is, of course, absolute garbage and anyone who says they like it, or would buy it, or would listen to it more than once, is a fraud.

This is the most English album (and English, not British) probably ever made. Maybe only The Kinks could rival that. I don't expect anyone outside England to understand what the hell is going on with this - from the light pop of Lazy Sunday to the great Stanley Unwin. It's delightful, bonkers and a pleasure to listen to. If you are English.

This isn't about the 1001 most listener friendly albums of all time. It's an anthology of music - how we got to where we are. Some things in the history of music sent it in different directions, influenced people that used sounds and bought them into the mainstream. On that basis, this is absolutely the sort of thing that should be here. It's worth listening to.

As with all Nick Cave I was a late adopter but this is a towering album with some magnificent songs.

Sound + warbling = art. I mean, write a tune Bjork.

Oh this is pleasant, nice sound, mmm samba. Sorry, can I squeeze past, this is my floor.

It’s nice enough. But what’s the point in listening to it? It doesn’t break any new ground.

I enjoyed this in a mad "prog-it-was-the-70s-why-not?" kind of way.

This sounds like the sort of terrible music played too loud in over-expensive bars I used to have to go to with friends back in my single days. I hated it then and hate it now. Or it's just a set of incidental music stings from TV shows. Either way, it's not something I'd care to listen to again.

I wasn’t sure what to expect from this as it’s not my genre of choice but this is a lovely album. Even the covers are rendered beautifully and the contrast of f the two voices is bliss

This is a turgid mess of nothing in particular. My oh my it was hard work.

This far in I can now calibrate the marks much more objectively. This is a wonderful, tuneful, fascinating album that deserves its place. It’s a great work.

Not the greatest of albums but I guess had a place in the movement that had stronger bands like Pixies

As good as it gets for English folk.

I like Neil Young but this is a bit of a rough rag bag of an album. Not one of his high points.

It's not a great recording. His voice is not in great form. There's a load of cover versions. Other than that ...

Always been a gap between their high points - Tonight/1979 the latter of which is one of the great songs of all time IMHO - and their albums which I always thought could be a bit variable/stodgy. This is a good listen in retrospect but still not quite consistent enough.

Pretty decent album all round. They have such a fascinatingly unique sound. Short of a few songs but you can see where it's going.

You can trace so much music of the 60s and 70s back to Muddy Waters. It’s all here - the good kind of RnB.

One of the seminal rap/hip hop albums. Yes it’s sketchy at times and the vocals are surprisingly badly recorded and mixed. But it’s a piece of worlk that stands out.

An album I had time to listen to a few times today and it got curiously worse every time I listened to it. Once you get past the hits it's very lazy by numbers pop/RnB. Outro is terrible.

It's one of those albums that is in popular culture because it is up there as a great piece of work. Musically interesting, good songs. I mean it's not going to start a revolution but everything has its place.

I don't know but this sort of drifted past me. I didn't engage much with it. I might, given the story around it give it another go when I've got some time on my hands but at the moment it scores low. Maybe I'm like David Geffen.

A mighty album of mad 80s pop, art and Trevor Horn. It still sprawls around and sounds like a moment in time.

I've always wondered why I never got into Chvrches and now I know. It's thin, vacuous synth indie pop.

It's all loops and repetitive sections but each song still fascinates me. A kind of album that only a band can make. The freedom to make albums like this, and giving it a way to find an audience feels like something that's been lost a bit in music. This is a real piece of art.

Optimistically I would say that even if you find some of the metal albums in this project difficult this is very much at the listenable end. Proper songs, the right amount of screaming and musically interesting. They have kept going on the basis of being about the best that there is in this genre and this is as good a metal album as you will here.

It is a good piece of work, very evocative of a time for me. Some great songs. Overall a little too background music at times but stands up well.

A bouncy fun new wave album that got me through US election results

Franz Ferdinand is everything I love from music - indie with discordant guitars. Yet I absolutely hate it. Trite lyrics, unnecessary tempo changes and the worst kind of root note oompah bass that makes me think the player never learned an instrument in his life. I struggled through every awful, unlistenable song of this.

I like Dexy's and I admire his inventiveness and sheer bloody mindedness but this isn't a great album.

An experimental, fascinating album. Sounds really raw and loved it.

I'm not by nature a Costello fan. He's got a great back catalogue of singles but I've never really managed his albums. This is good though - consistent, enjoyable, really nice production on it.

Those coming to Simple Minds when they became a stadium rock band often don't know their roots as an influential and important part of the new wave electronica scene. Until this their albums were packed with instrumentals. This is really the bridge to their popular phase but I still really like the nods back to it with "someone up there likes you" and the more proggy/electronica tracks. I like this a lot. It's got depth.

It's one of those albums that consistently gets plaudits but I can't really see past the first, of course brilliant, song. The rest of it plays out nicely without ever engaging.

I was a bit nervous about this one but it deserves the accolades. A hip hop album of substance and texture. Not the perfect article but definitely stands out in that genre.

It's a good album. Possibly a great album. But the "best of all time"?? Come on, that's nonsense and you know it's nonsense. I'm not trying to detract from the fact that this is a really good piece of work, but. "Come. On". Lyrically groundbreaking sure, but musically quite safe. Some stand out songs but tonally and textually quite samey in between. The second track is almost a cover of the first track. Maybe intentionally, but it adds to the sense that it isn't breaking ground musically.

I was going to give it 2 stars on the grounds that you can actually listen to it but halfway through I made my mind up. If just for the sheer audacity of being on this list it's not worthy of 2 stars but nobody can in all conscious listen to this all the way through without screaming into the void. It's an album so transparent you can see straight through to the lazy drum machine programming that sits behind every tuneless yelp of this samey, boring, unmusical piece of rubbish. Make it stop.

It's jazz, lounge, smooth, dinner party, background hum scat singing nothingness. As pleasant as you want it to be and no more.

Noodle noodle noodle. I knew about the myth of the Dead long before I'd ever heard them and I was a bit surprised. It wasn't what I expected at all. It's fine, for them. For me it's just a bit aimless. Fun fact - they played their first UK gig at a festival in a village on a farm behind my house a month before I was born.

Kraftwork were of course groundbreaking and incredibly influential. Making the most of a nascent technology and providing art in the widest sense. They were also, because of those constraints, pretty boring. I can admire the art and the influence and still think this is pretty boring.

Nobody sings like Janis.

His biggest drawback is he can't sing. Lyrically pretty good but why not listen to Nick Cave instead? I found it a bit tedious/flat/samey.

It's the tribute band known as the Boring Beach Boys. At least to me. Really really really tedious. Each song is one idea over and over and over. And each song is that same idea. An album of one idea. Over and over.

I've always loved Party Fears Two, I quite like Country Club, I love new wave and this kind of era synth/pop/new wave. But this really grated over a whole album.

A properly interesting, inventive, tuneful piece of work. I ended up listening to it a few times and will definitely do so again.

It's a work of mad genius and luckily I had time for a few listens (it is a Sunday) so got past my immediate reaction and settled into it.

I really liked this. Ryan Adams is one of those artists I've never really engaged with. It's a good, consistent album.

Soothing enough. Not really my thing but pleasant ambling background music.

Some people in music got to the point in the year where they had to write an album and knuckled down and wrote enough songs. Bush from Hounds of Love onwards seems to have just absorbed herself and written symphonies. Whole album of texture and sound, of musical experimentation. One of the finest prog rock artists of all time. I bought this in the autumn it came out and I'm listening to it here in November and it still screams cold, dark days and nights to me. A virtually perfect piece of work. Hell this is good. It even has Mick Karn.