Album Summary
Tommy is the fourth studio album by the English rock band The Who, a double album first released on 17 May 1969. The album was mostly composed by guitarist Pete Townshend, and is a rock opera that tells the story of Tommy Walker, a "deaf, dumb and blind" boy, including his experiences with life and his relationship with his family. Townshend came up with the concept of Tommy after being introduced to the work of Meher Baba, and attempted to translate Baba's teachings into music. Recording on the album began in September 1968, but took six months to complete as material needed to be arranged and re-recorded in the studio. Tommy was acclaimed upon its release by critics, who hailed it as The Who's breakthrough. Its critical standing diminished slightly in later years; nonetheless, several writers view it as an important and influential album in the history of rock music. The Who promoted the album's release with an extensive tour, including a live version of Tommy, which lasted throughout 1969 and 1970. Key gigs from the tour included appearances at Woodstock, the 1969 Isle of Wight Festival, the University of Leeds, the Metropolitan Opera House, and the 1970 Isle of Wight Festival. The live performances of Tommy drew critical praise and revitalized the band's career. Subsequently, the rock opera developed into other media, including a Seattle Opera production in 1971, an orchestral version by Lou Reizner in 1972, a film in 1975, and a Broadway musical in 1992. The original album has sold 20 million copies and has been inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame. It has been reissued several times on CD, including a remix by Jon Astley in 1996, a deluxe Super Audio CD in 2003, and a super deluxe box set in 2013, including previously unreleased demos and live material.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
I guess it's important and there are some good things but it's pretty long and often dreadfully dull, darling.
The story it’s telling is fine, but damn is this a slog musically. I’m just not a fan of the rock opera style. So many of the songs sound the same with very little movement. It has its moments, but at an hour-twenty minutes long I feel no need to revisit this.
Wasn’t crazy about the album.
Not revisiting because I remember being unimpressed.
Just never got The Who tbh, and this is no exception
The Who's most overrated album, and one of the most overrated albums of all time. While I've always appreciated the ambition and scope, there are too many damn songs and too many of them are too damm average. It pales in comparison to Quadrophenia.
✅️ STILL BANGS We did a version of this as our high school musical and I fell in love with the pianist for a couple years, so I have a deeply abiding love for this album. If it wasn't for that musical I don't think I would have had patience for some of the overtures and softer songs on here as a teen, and I'd probably be hearing them for the first time right now. Favorite songs: Pinball Wizard Go to the Mirror! I'm Free Welcome
I enjoyed this album but would have enjoyed it more if I had actually seen it knew the story behind it.
Best: Pinball Wizard Green: Overture, Pinball Wizard, Go To the Mirror!, Tommy Can You Hear Me?, Sensation, Sally Simpson Yellow: 1921, Amazing Journey, Eyesight To The Blind (The Hawker), Underture, Do You Think It’s Alright?, There’s A Doctor, Smash The Mirror, Miracle Cure, I’m Free, Welcome Red: It’s A Boy, Sparks, Christmas, Cousin Kevin, The Acid Queen, Fiddle About, Tommy’s Holiday Camp, We’re Not Gonna Take It
Favorite track(s): Eyesight to the Blind (The Hawker), Pinball Wizard, Go to the Mirror! At least I appreciate the Clone High episode that makes fun of this much more now. Heard before Previous rating: 6/10
Absolute classical concept album. A masterpiece. (Listened to it on vinyl)
I hate this album. I understand it was revolutionary and introduced the idea of a 'rock opera' and concept albums to rock in general, so I have to credit it for inspiring a chunk of the 70s rock albums I do enjoy, and I even like The Who a decent bit, but this albums concept is just misery porn that doesn't follow a compelling or cohesive story, most of the tracks are very dull, and the album is very long.
Some great tracks and the famous rhythm section is right up there. Would have preferred a shorter album with only the stronger tracks but I guess this misses the point of the whole concept album.
I’m not really sure how to assess Tommy. It’s fine, I guess. I appreciate the ambition. But I’m not sure it’s something I will even hanker to listen to again.
There is some stuff on this album that is really good (1921, Christmas, Pinball Wizard). There's some stuff in this album that's really bad (The Acid Queen, Underture). But the big issue with this album isn't the quality of individual tracks, it's the format. Concept albums are hard to make work. But it doesn't help when the concept is kinda weak and it doesn't really feel like there's enough ideas to fill out the whole runtime. There's a lot of filler here but the second half of the album really drags. Maybe the film is better.
This album is way too long with no real stand out songs. I'm not a big fan of The Who and this just reinforced that.
Only half listened but not great
the who is good
Enjoyed it. Gonna revisit.
Disc de 3h i 24mins. Te bastanta instrumental. Ni tan mal. Soc com 3 discs, els 3r es un live de lo anterior. Global be.
Ambitious? Maybe, but it is more long and uninteresting than anything else. I am person that, in most cases, first values the music and then the lyrics. Not trying to devaluate lyricism, is just that if something doesn't musically appeal to me, then I most certainly won't be interested in what it is actually being said, and this record is the perfect example. With how inoffensive and boring everything sounds I personally can't care for the story that its being told. This is Opera Rock with drums, bass, piano, acoustic guitars, soft voices and some electric guitars in occasional moments, basically doing mediocre performances and playing mediocre melodies. The only parts that I find to be remotely okay are the biggest songs, "Pinball Wizard" and "Go To The Mirror!" because they have the most memorable and playful electric guitar riffs, and even these I'm not crazy about. Is not like the rest is extremely bland, as there are some playful moments and decent choirs. The thing is, there is not really much else I believe to be memorable, and when there are 24 songs with a total runtime of one hour and a quarter, it all sums up to a bad experience.
I've always been intrigued by the idea of concept albums and rock opera's. Tommy is often cited as a quintessential rock opera. But try as I might through maybe half a dozen listens, I find myself struggling to appreciate it as much as many other do. For one, I find this album to be a bit of a slog. Other than a couple memorable tunes, most notably Pinball Wizard, not much really grabs me. And if there is a story here, it is fairly convoluted.. despite multiple listens I still find myself consulting wikipedia to figure out what the story is. At the end of the day I find Tommy to be just okay.
After feeling underwhelmed with The Who’s debut, I was looking forward to see how they developed. Tommy is on a different level creatively to where they started, not that that is saying that much. I find the concept of this rock opera to be pretty interesting and commendable. There are musical moments I enjoyed more but it still doesn’t grab me sonically all that much. I do feel as if this was well-executed for how ambitious and unique it is, and I appreciate it for that. 1 re-listen Favorite Tracks: Pinball Wizard, We’re Not Gonna Take It, Go To The Mirror!, Overture, Christmas, 1921
There are some really good moments on this very long album. Overall, in that 3-4 range.
Tragi-porn the musical. Why has this got me singing along to a song about abuse of a disabled child on my way to work on a Monday? 1 great song (pinball wizard) and 1 good song (acid queen) don't make up for everything else. Story is also impossible to follow, had to Wikipedia it for a crumb of context after the first few songs. 2 stars overall, but 1 extra just for pinball wizard
Ahhhh a Boomer Sacred Cow! These are always fun to dissect. Before I get started, I should mention that I have never enjoyed The Who, and listening to a few of their stronger records through this project, hasn't changed my mind. I'm dreading this. Oh, and I just finished Ryan Adams's 18,000 hour long *Gold*, so..... I don't know if I can handle another Epic Super Long-Ass Deluxe Master Piece. **** More than halfway through this and I'm surprised how much I'm enjoying this. The story is keeping me hooked. Trying to fit the pieces together of what is happening to Tommy without much help is a fun exercise. Wait. I feel kind of like Tommy! At least in relation to the album, I can't see what's happening or ask any questions or interact with the characters..... I'm literally blind and dumb! In this essay, I will [insert film school paper]. "Pinball Wizard" is the standout track, obviously. But some of the others are pretty great as well. "1921," "Sparks," the coda on "Amazing Journey," "Christmas," "Underture," "Go to the Mirror!" are strong, with narrative reasons for being, good energy, and some fun riffs. *** And now I'm done with *Tommy*. Finally. The second half, like the second half of so much musical theater, loses a lot of energy and becomes a bit of a slog. Not that it's bad, exactly, it's just tedious. And I had a much harder time following the story. Ah well. Overall I'm glad I listened to this. Very unexpectedly, my favorite Who album so far. FOUR STARS
A legendary band at the height of their power
I already listened to Tommy on my Walkman in highschool and have it both on cd and vinyl. I really enjoyed listening it again and it is a fantastic rock opera. The live versions on the extended edition are awesome.
An ultimately silly project. Far away from their best work.
Perhaps the first, great rock opera. I've seen the film and a stage production. I've listened to the album. Considering that most people had zero context or plot when this was first released I'm impressed with its reception. I think its a fantastic listen but I have the luxury of knowing what's going on.
One of the first rock operas. Classic The Who. Bit exhausting.
The music in this concept/rock opera album (rock, with some pop and psychedelia) is good, but what really sets the whole thing apart is the theme itself (the story of the life of a blind boy named Tommy). The story is cohesive and engaging as well as sweeping and grand when paired with the music. There are sad, happy, triumphant, and even eerily dark parts (especially "Cousin Kevin", "The Acid Queen", and "Fiddle About"). But that's how a story is structured, with conflict and a resolution (a happy one, here). This is one of the better themed albums I've listened to.
p164. 1969. 2 stars. The source of every pretentious and ridiculous concept album that followed it. Points deducted for being a double album, and for the resulting filler and wankage. On the plus side, it also contains some of Townsend's best songs. TLDR; watch the film adaptation.
I was expecting something overblown, and while the Who’s signature power pop/rock sound is dialed way back, the length and lack of musical variety still makes it feel self-important.
ogolnie ten album to taki sredni. muzyka brzmi albo jak swiateczna albo jak z disney channel filmow albo jak orkiestra na wreczaniu medali wojsku a jak brzmi inaczej to jest nijaka. overture i underture to jest tragedia i pieklo dla moich uszu, nie podoba mi siw koncept samej muzyki bez glosow jeszcze przez az tyle czasu. w kolko powtarzane slowo fiddle doprowadza mnie do szalu i to w sumie jest najgorsza czesc tego albumu. ostanie z muzyki to rzeczywiscie pasowala do tekstu utworow i sie tak atmosferowo vibeowo dopasowywala wiec to na plus juz nie patrzac czy mi sie ta muzyka podobala. storytelling jest glownym punktem tego albumu no i jest dobry i zrozumialy, nie trzeba za duzo myslec zeby zrozumiec co sie dzieje wiec tez spk bo teraz to bez geniusa nie da rady. ogolnie taka troche przykra historia ale pinball wizard mnie rozsmieszylo wiec tez byl aspekt pozytywny historii. podsumowajac sama muzyka mnie nie poruszyla i do utworow nie wroce napewno ale spojny i przejrzysty storytelling od poczatku do konca albumu rzeczywiscie byl zaciekawiajacy. takie 3,5 bym dala
Spoko.
Bardzo fajny koncept i sposób opowiadania. Strasznie baśniowy klimat. Pierwszy wokalista na stuwe wygląda jak Piotruś pan. Czuć Broadway. The acid Queen to krytyka kultury hipisów?? Być może. Na pewno hymn Kuby Wojewódzkiego. Pewnie powstało sporo iteracji tego albumu. Przyjemna zabawa głosem wpisująca się w klimat dekady. Ale kurwa 10 minut instrumental to przesada. On miał opisać stan po kwasie¿ Słaba 4 bliżej 7/10 niż 8
Na początku myślałem że bedzie to album do spania, jednak po underture nastąpił przełom i chlopaki się rozkrecili. Od tego momentu nabrali wiatru w żagle i słychać bylo że sie dobrze bawią. "Sally simpson" brzmiał jakby śpiewał je dziadek przed domem na bujanym fotelu we wstępie do sitcomu, co wdg mnie świetnie pasuje i jest to jeden z lepszych kawałków na płycie, a utwory takie jak "Tommy can you hear me?" czy "pinball wizard" przez swoją dynamikę nadają całemu dziełu tempa. Historia została przedstawiona w fajny sposób dzięki zarowno utworom instrumentalnym jak i licznym interludiom. Do tego jako bonus okladka jest bardzo przyjemna dla oka, choc moze nie dla trypofobów. Daje jednak 3 gwiazdki (choc tak naprawde 3.5) bo część kawałków zlewa się z całością, jest rozstrzał miedzy poziomem utworów, a pierwsza czesc albumu mnie znudziła.
meh
pierwszy kawalek brzmi jak the sims CAS music w koncu sa interludes!!! I calkiem spoko storytelling chociaz mam wrazenie ze momentami sami juz nie wiedzieli co robia ale jest to naprawde pocieszny i przyjemny album im glebiej w album tym bardziej czulam ze zadna z tych piosenek nie moglaby poleciec w radiu byly przerozne skoki w sciezce i struktura utworow wcale nie byla stala and thats the shit bylo mi naprawde ciezko przebrnac przez Underture i wtedy pojawily sie pierwsze watpliwosci czy ten album faktycznie mi sie podoba ale po Pinball Wizard sie podnioslam spoko album bylabym w stanie go sluchac ale to wciaz nie do konca to pozdrawiam 3,5
Trochę monotonny ale solidnie wykonany
Kiedyś moi rodzice wyjechali i zostałem sam w domu z moim wujkiem. :( Byłem wtedy mały i powiedziałem do mojego wujka po tym jak ściągnął spodnie "to jest za dużo". Podobnie mam z tym albumem. 3h historii młodego, ślepego i głuchego chłopca, gdzie czasami z piosenek nic się nie dowiadujemy. Spoko jego rodzina była chujowa, ale średnio mnie to obchodziło. Dużo średnich piosenek, które nie wprowadzają nic szokującego do historii. Wujek zostawił we mnie traumę, a po tym albumie pozostało we mnie poczucie straty czasu.
Ogólnie imo taki album do przesłuchania na raz historia spoko, intro brzmiało jak soundtrack z wiedźmina potem się trochę rozkręciło. W skali narkotykowej myślę że mocne 6 Mogli coś wziąć żeby rozkminić coś takiego. Moją uwagę przykuł numer Underture- kogoś popierniczyło żeby zapiernixzyc 11 min instrymentalu???? Jakby ten musical był grany w teatrze mógłbym na niego pójść Jest ok!
Intro fajnie wrzuca w klimat albumu Potem zaczyna się album 70s generator Tommy can you hear me? Basic strasznie wydaje sie ten album Brzdęka sobie gitarka, takie żeby leciało w tle Nie widzę tu nic przebojowego co by wyróżniało ten album Na ten moment chyba najgorszy album tutaj, a szkoda bo po intro zapowiadało się na back2back cinematic experience :c
Narrative makes like zero sense to me, but who cares. Reading is for nerds; pinball is life.
TBH, I didn't get it. Nice for it's time though
Listened before? No Familiar with the artist? Yes Thoughts: - I was happy to see this come up, because it's one of those albums I've been meaning to "get around to" forever. - I love musicals, love Rock operas, and loved the previous Who album I rated here (Who's Next). But I don't think I can say I loved "Tommy." - I was pretty into it in the beginning, but the longer it went the more I found myself getting bored. I don't think I'd really go back to it, other than Pinball Wizard. Favorite track(s): Pinball Wizard
Epic
I had money on the acid trip shattering Tommy's world but I guess the literal broken glass has some poetry to it as well. Also surprised that "1921" did not have a blanket resurgence after Christmas 2020. Maybe we, as a whole, were distracted. 6 keepers in 24 (25%) 1 klunker (4%) 21
Subdued filler is how I'd appraise this one. You have to sit through 12 tracks before getting to Pinball Wizard, which basically means the pace stays firmly in the slow lane the entire time, with only the occasional slow-burning spark and limited appeal. Their headline track isn't exactly epic either, just fairly typical anthem rock. As for the post-Pinball Wizard dross, "Tommy, Can You Hear Me?" is particularly soft and forgettable. Apparently, their real strength was outside the confines of these polite studio recordings, where they could truly let rip live. It turns out I've listened to that too and didn't think much of it, so clearly this just isn't for me. I think I get the appeal. There's some theatre, some nice guitar work, and a degree of ambition. But it's about as convincing as a pantomime, and I can't shake the feeling that it's all a bit fake.
There were plenty of moments of interest in this sprawling concept album. I could probably lift a few tracks and create a playlist that would wow anybody into thinking that listening to this for the whole seventy five minutes would be worthwhile. "Pinball Wizard" is obviously the well known single off the album and is a genuine highlight. I'll be honest, I lost patience with it. There was something demanding and self-aggrandizing about the whole endeavour. And there was never any musical hook that caught me and made me think my fullest attention would be rewarded. This might be one for the hardcore fans to really dive into, but I didn't find that sort of depth. Less of a fever dream, and more of one of those annoying lie-in dreams when you are semi-conscious. It might seem quite deep when you are in it and then the cold light of day washes away the mystique and reveals the trivial.
solid, for cleaning dust
Not my favorite, but man, I what a concept album.
Þetta er mjög gott rokk. Skemmtileg concept plata en frekar mikið rúnk fyrir minn smekk inn á milli. Hef alltaf haft smá hate á the who veit ekki afhverju. Þetta er flott og fínt en engin fimma hjá mér. Slefar þó alveg upp í 3,55
Örugglega fínasta rokkópera, en virkar sem plata. Pinball Wzard stendur upp úr.
Very strange album!! I enjoyed the actual music - very atmospheric and quirky. Strange concept for an album, not a type of music I'm used to! Giving this another listen because I didn't quite appreciate what this album was until talking to my dad. On the second listen I realise now this is like being told a story.
It's okay. A bit iconic. Really has very little to no chill with all the rapey stuff.
I favorited some of the songs. It didnt wow me, but I liked the instrumentals more than the lyrics. Extra extra read all about it Malcoms in his feelings and he cant get out of it
przesłuchałam ale nie sluchalam
As a big who fan I enjoyed this album, not my favorite album by the band though. Pinball wizard is a classic
Standouts Pinball Wizard Smash the Mirror
6.5/10
I refuse.
Excellent!
Super strange album. Great effort for the lengthy concept and actually following through with every song (and seemingly every line). But some of the material is a bit much and the closing song especially is uncomfortable. 2.5/5.0
It's a very good album, and probably the first real Rock Opera. Obviously, you know the Big Sogs on the album, but the rest of the album is well worth a listen. Obviously,, there is filler or exposition songs, but it all adds to the story.
I don’t rate this at all
An interesting early example of a full-on rock opera by a band that had already experimented with strange concept albums like The Who Sell Out. Musically quite good, but the narrative struck me a bit as trying far too hard to give its titular character a DEEP and DARK backstory (thanks, Uncle Ernie).
Interesting concept. I think as far as rock operas go, I might have liked it better than The Wall overall. Like, still not really my thing, and my god it was long, but still enjoyable overall.
I think the more I think about the story, the less I care for it. I gave this two attentive listens to really make my mind up on it, the first of which was on a walk, generally unfocused on the lyrics. As a result, that time around I completely missed a lot of the suffercore aspects on the first half which, on re-listen with the lyrics up, really became my main gripe with the album. I just feel like it spends a disproportionate amount of runtime on the childhood traumas compared to the comparatively short and abrupt cult arc. The execution feels overall clunky, especially having experienced The Wall in the past. Story aside though, these guys really came through with the arrangements. This isn't The Who I had come to know! The bar was low with My Generation and The Who Sell Out, but this sounds like an outright different band. I respect the ambition! Standouts: Christmas • Underture • We're Not Gonna Take It
Why don't I like this album as much as The Wall? Stay tuned for an immaculately researched essay that I'll link here later. My father had disc 2 of this album in his car for many, many years, so it does hold a special place in my heart. I feel like the second part is perfect. Sensation is one of my favorite songs by The Who. I was transfixed by the glass breaking effect in Smash the Mirror. The storytelling in Sally Simpson was so gripping to me at the time. Their music is much more complex and interesting on this one for sure. However, I feel that disc 1 has wasted space. The overture AND underture are presumably holdovers from taking the term rock opera very literally, but eat up a lot of space that could be used on storytelling. Disc 1 has a lot of inner thought stuff that is great but doesn't have room to breathe and develop. I almost never return to disc 1 when I listen.
Sometimes this 1001 albums journey is revelatory. I said as much in a previous review of a Who album--I grew up hearing their music on the radio in the 70s and 80s and just took them for granted. Listening to all of Tommy was a revelation. The movie soundtrack looked so cheesy (I sold many copies working for a record store), I just assumed the music was not worth listening to. Damn, I was wrong. While not every song hits home for me, the whole project is super ambitious and I love most of it. Now that I'm older and have learned to love musicals, I am probably more open to this than I was as a teenager. Anyway, I thought it was great. Even the goofy bits were sort of charming. It gets 5 stars from me.
Fine.
Did not listen fully but i am pretty sure i dont like rock ad genre
well its definitely a rock opera, but why so many trumpet sounds. was not bad but didn't really peak my interest (2.5/5)
Overture 4 It's a Boy 3.5 1921 4.1 Amazing Journey 4 Sparks 3.8 Eyesight to the Blind (The Hawker) 3.9 Christmas 4.3 Cousin Kevin 4 The Acid Queen 4 Underture 4.1 Do You Think It's Alright? 3.6 Fiddle About 3.8 Pinball Wizard 4.4 There's a Doctor 3 Go to the Mirror Boy! 4 Tommy Can You Hear Me? 3.6 Smash the Mirror 3.8 Sensation 3.6 Miracle Cure 3 Sally Simpson 3.7 I'm Free 3.9 Welcome 3.6 Tommy's Holiday Camp 3 We're Not Gonna Take It 4.2 Score: 3.7875
Man, this album just does not hold up. I like The Who, generally. But here, the production is generally really weird (vocals are mostly just way too loud), shoehorning the story in ruins some of the better songs, and the pure filler songs just suck. Keith Moon (the best part of the band) sounds restrained here, and it's just all bleh. I still think this album should be here, I recognize its importance, but man this is not something I like at all
Always heard about Tommy never listened to it. I can see how foundation of rock opera
Sure, there are a few standout great songs, but I think this one is best enjoyed from start to finish as a story, and I prefer the original recording, not the 2+ hour Super Deluxe version.
This is a pretty good rock opera. I don't think it does anything incredibly unique, though, so 1969 recieves yet another 3. Album #145 The Who album 3/5 Favorite Track: Christmas
It was alright. It felt long and a bit repetitive. Not something I would listen to again
Solid album, but nothing stood out to me.
I am not a big Who fan but have to admire this album!
I started playing this on Tuesday and there's still 12 tracks to go! Overly ambitious for an album that contains just one memorable track. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ Revisit ❌️ ★★★☆☆(5/10) Total reviewed : 457 Already owned : 99 Purchased : 25 To buy : 3 Nope : 330
This is the most rock opera rock opera to ever rock opera. I mean, you don't get more rock opera than Tommy. This is one of the albums from this list that I have in my record collection, and it came with a book that presents the lyrics of each song like a script, with each verse having the name of the character that says the verse to the side. It sucks that writing this is how I found out that the record store I bought this from, Rock of Ages in Vero Beach, FL, shut down in May of this year. They still do a few popups every once in a while according to their Instagram posts. I never went there too frequently, but I do have like three or four records from them. My dad got one of his favorite shirts from there. Anyways, this is a wonderful album, easily in my top 3 rock operas, and I've listened to a good few of them. I think it's neat that they manged to sneak in a cover song and still have it make sense in the story of the album. I don't really have a whole lot to say about the music despite how much I love this album, so I'll just end with a fun fact: Bally, one of the pinball companies mentioned in Pinball Wizard, actually released a Pinball Wizard-themed table in reference to this song.
Complete Load of nonsense, good in parts , live disc amazing
Chönt vlt au es 4i si
A couple of great tracks drowning in a sea of guff
Tommy is one of the greatest albums ever. Aside from the eponymous Pinball Wizard, this album is a well crafted, thoughtful experiment in a way. Each song flows beautifully into the next. Definitely worth more than one listen. Brilliant. Easy ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
This is a very ambitious double album that left me both awed and ambivalent. I love me a good rock opera, but I do wish this album's instrumentations were more interesting. While I can absolutely hear why "Tommy" became a staple rock album, and I was decently engaged in its storyline, it can often buckle under it's own weight. Perhaps it's another case of time leaving some initially revolutionary albums behind, though I imagine that the full broadway musical adaptation elevates this to a whole new experience!
Album #226: The Who – Tommy ⭐⭐⭐⭐ I’d really recommend anyone listening to this to give it at least two listens. This is an album that requires repeat listening. A daunting enough task at nearly 80 minutes long, but this is a stellar album. On the second listen you really appreciate how orchestrated and meticulously crafted it all is. On the first, there are just so many songs, some of them really short, that they go by in the blink of an eye. It can be hard to keep track of the lyrics and the story. This didn’t initially strike me as something I’d be into, being a rock opera. That being said, I do love Jesus Christ Superstar. But what I really like about this is that, despite being labelled a rock opera, it still sounds like a simple enough rock band performing it. No frills. It just sounds like a Who album. But boy, is it operatic. I think it’s an album that’s completely without pretentiousness, which is remarkable for a double concept album and rock opera. It’s a silly story in some ways, but it’s also really sad. I ended up genuinely feeling for and caring about Tommy through the music, and I think that’s amazing. There are parts that are downright creepy and uncomfortable, particularly the Uncle Ernie and Cousin Kevin characters. Those tracks are not pleasant to listen to, but that’s a feat in itself. They’re amazingly well performed. Very few songs on this album are anything less than excellent. The recurring See Me, Feel Me / Listening to You refrain is so powerful, especially when it comes back during Go to the Mirror!. I love that section of the album so much. I love Overture and Underture, too. Pete Townshend’s guitar playing is fantastic, that bluesy sound, but with real virtuosity. They’re an interesting band because they’re not really heavy rock or hard rock. It’s folky, very English, slightly understated rock and roll, largely acoustic-based. What they have going for them is fantastic harmonies and great performances from everyone. So yeah, this probably should be a five. I’m going with four because I’m trying to be a little more judicious with my five-star reviews, and it does lose me a bit around Welcome and the whole messianic section towards the end. But it comes back with We’re Not Gonna Take It, which is a great song. I’d never listened to this before. It’s a legendary album in a lot of ways, and it deserves its status. It’s fantastic.
Listens: 2 Standout Tracks: Cousin Kevin, Pinball Wizard A rock opera in 1969 seems like it was a novel and interesting idea, and functionally a concept album to boot, but I wasn't really too engaged with the music itself... or the story I guess. After reading about the story on Wikipedia, I do see how the songs string together, but the story itself seems somewhat convoluted. I think being a double album, with a few quite long songs made it more of slog to get through than it otherwise might have. Cousin Kevin and Fiddle About are pretty disturbing songs. I think this deserves to be on the List, but I didn't care too much for it, compared to some of The Who's other work.
Very interesting concept and the music stands up amazingly. Truly a piece ahead of its time.
I'm sure the concept of this was interesting but I just found the music incredibly boring unfortunately
The Who's smash rock opera. Phenomenal songwriting and story telling.
A phenomenally interesting album but one that's more fun to listen to in concept than in practice. Really needs the visuals to go along with it if you're seriously thinking about listening to it straight through.
"Epic" is not synonymous with "good". I can appreciate the scope and the ambition, but the overall delivery is too melodramatic. A "rock opera" doesn't work unless it changes things up every now and then, be it musically or thematically. That's why Pink Floyd's "The Wall" and the Smashing Pumpkins' "Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness" work so well, but Nine Inch Nails' "The Fragile" does not. You need to change the tone, add a little humor, but in a way that fits - UNLIKE "Tommy's Holiday Camp", which just seems stupid in the middle of all the drama of this record. Sure they can play. Sure Roger Daltrey is good (but inferior to Robert Plant, Ozzy Osbourne or Ian Gillan). But if you're gonna listen to a Who album, make it "Who's Next". "Tommy" is, and has always been, overrated as hell.
This is the OG of rock operas. As with most rock operas, that means a few well known good songs and a bunch of filler. This is hardly The Who's best work.
the lyrics are hella weird
Highlights: Go to the Mirror!