Hard to remember they're a real band, pleasantly surprised
Some good stuff, some that went on a bit
oh yeah, this rocks
Killing Me Softly is 6/5, the rest isn't so good
Punk production values, prog self-indulgence levels
Pleasant enough, mostly passed me by
Don't mind Radiohead but this was a bit meh
interesting, a bit avant-garde
unexpected unorthodox bangers on there
bit jazzy, but solid
solid
Not as bad as I expected
had some tunes but a bit too pompous in parts
just meh
solid
HONESTLY
better than i expected
pretty good actually
Pleasant enough, bit dull in parts
bit annoying, nothing there for me
Would rather Alan Rickman get me a necklace
Belinda slapped
Bad title, but decent album
pretty rough, prog rubbish
jazzy
Pleasantly surprised, didn't know what to expect, but it went pretty hard
A bit indulgent on the piano at times, but I'll let it off
Tedious, unimaginative, and poorly executed
Should be held to account
pompous hair pop
Bit repetitive, but alright overall
not as good as college dropout
might have gotten a 3 if he wasn't a wrong'un but happy to mark it down
pleasant enough, kinda passed me by
solid bit of country, more of a 2.5
like fine, but no need for it to be on here
had some 4 tracks, had some 2 tracks, meets in the middle overall
classic blues, especially the first one
he does seem a bit horny so the title is appropriate
I was kinda disappointed because it doesn't have any of their bangers on there
Yeah, one hit at the start, then a pile of samey pop
better than expected
decent enough, but where are the bangers?
solid enough 2nd tier Britpop, could have been a 4 but let itself down with some nonsense towards the end
full of bangers
Another Girl Another Planet is good but the rest isn't
feel so cringe, but I did quite enjoy that
nice enough, but you kept wanting to hear Paul Simon jump outta there
simply lovely
strong 6music vibes, but I enjoyed that
could have been a 4 but some tracks let it down
didn't have the cricket one so i was already disappointed, then just a bit boring
kinda fine, just not very interesting, a bit too electric for my tastes
started off strong but faded into unnoteworthiness
could definitely have been a 3 (maybe a 4) if they engaged in some more self-editing
fine, didn't really leave much an impression
was very scared until I realized it was just the first 4 tracks. But still, what?
definitely has some "album tracks" on there, but still holds up well, big nostalgia value
masterpiece
He got all the instruments out of the library, and wanted to get his money's worth. Very bizarre, including the weird little comedy character at the start of track 2.
Credit where it is due, the first 30 seconds of 2 or 3 of them would be good theme tunes for snooker highlights on the BBC, but then just goes on way too long.
that wasn't very beach boys-y
kinda fine, quite backgroundy, couple were decent.
Overall not quite worth the effort
just a bit meh, singer's voice had that annoying quality that was quite prominent at this time. Last track had some nonsense which was the decider between 2 and 3
it has some bangers, so flirted with a 4, but not consistent enough, plus the broader context, earns Jacko a 3 here
Had some bangers, had some meh
yeah I really like a couple, but the rest is too weird
quite enjoyed it, as discussed, feels very of its time
that was pretty fun
start to finish bangers, no mucking about, fiiiiiiiive
very of it's time, nice for having a quiet coffee and cake to or whatever, but doesn't give me much beyond that
what about justice for my ears?
Honestly, this is just drivel. All the songs sound the same and that same is really really bad, they also manage to be twice as long as they need to be while doing that, at least Slipknot had the decency not to suck up so much of my time. Their name is also really unimaginative.
A few songs to pull out
One - yep, you nailed the rating lads
The Shortest Straw - that's what I drew to have to listen to this
Harvester of Sorrow - credit for dipping away from the derivative heavy metal bag of words their sort normally indulge in, to talk about a sad time at a chain restaurant
The Frayed Ends of Sanity - pretty much where I was this deep into it
Solid enough second-tier Britpop, some good ones, some a bit indulgently weird
Quite good, especially when you remember when it came
Found the motifs a bit repetitive
Sufjan Stevens (no relation of Cat or Shakin') is always someone I feel like I should like, or assume I would, but never really tried or did get into. This album confirms that, it's like just a bit too meh and poetry for me, reminds me a lot of songs from like Phoebe Bridgers or Belle and Sebastian that I find meh, compared to their better ones. But apart from Chicago, there aren't enough of the "better ones" compared to the meh. And I don't like to indulge concept albums.
better than I expected (less wet)
quite enjoyed that, even without too much lyrical deepness, has a nice rhythm to it
felt like I've heard it before
pretty bloody good, nice bit of shoegazy stuff
terrible name though
definitely good, but not one I'd listen to over and over
there's a 5 in there if they were a bit more judicious
probably a low 4, but I did enjoy it
(also did the Bowie mix, strange there wasn't a plain one)
not like an easy listen, but surprisingly enjoyable
every part of it was music!
Peter Gabriel: 2 - you got greedy sunshine
Some stuff on here that is okay, but just too much nonsense and his voice is kinda grating after a few minutes
quite pleasant, a couple of bangers on there but otherwise only okay
bit jazzy, didn't really care for it
Very jazzy! that was quite a lot of fun with the accompanying wikipedia, I wish more live albums had riot prevention.
props to Jordan Peele's impression too
A low 4 perhaps, but just enough on there to give me fugees vibes to keep me interested, especially the last couple of songs
does feel like it could have been quite good, but just too many weird beepy noises, and then the fact the singer is a cunt makes you want to mark more harshly as well
not quite 5 material but that was very good, deeper than I expected
very pleasant
yeah this was pretty dope, Mrs Robinson, America, Hazy Shade of Winter, few of the heavy hitters
Fun fact, I got this album when I was like all 15 and quite liking the idea of being a bit hipster and musically pretentious. Some things never change. But it is still very beautiful
...news.
None of the Talking Heads heavy hitters on there, but it does flow very nicely as an album, and Heaven is really really good
had some good tunes on there, can really see the influence it had on later Britpop too
never heard of them before but I did like that, bit acceptable face of grunge for me
yeah, lovely stuff, nice dry voice Neil Hannon has
Horses!
but not enough horses to get above a 3
Who's that LADY
Whoa-oh, listen to the music.....news
But other than that, alright, nothing special
the best song is mostly just a soundtrack for family package holiday adverts. Other than that....meh. Doesn't sink quite to the grubby shameful metal depths to earn itself a 1, but is quite bad
was torn between a 2 and 3 here, it felt like it had a lot of potential in the first few songs but didn't really live up to it. Then got quite self-indulgent toward the end which I did not care for. I'll be generous and give it a 3 but it definitely had 4 potential
let's be honest, the album title and artist name combo had me hovering over the 1 button before we started. And they did very little to move me away from there, making sad little edgelord music in their 30s
Me, listening politely
I've said it once, I'll say it 1001 times, there's good material on here, but need to cut out the rubbish and get themselves down to a normal album length. Once again, cost themselves a point in doing so
actually surprisingly good beyond the obvious jokes about CCR, even if I do love how the genre is called "swamp rock"
when you start with a song from the Shrek 2 soundtrack, you know you're going places. And he keeps on going places
Bit jazzy. Has that one banger but meh otherwise
I only listened to this yesterday and I cannot remember anything about it.
Dithered between a 2 and a 3, went with 2 cos he's a cunt
What's going on? Some decent tunes
like fine I guess, couple of bangers, but a bit pretentious. I have very little time for rock operas as a concept.
pleasant enough, but very background music. Wingspan music but 20% more turnt (still not very turnt)
a couple of bangers, but the rest of it is a bit too dull and repetitive to drag it beyond a 3. Probably some good emotional lyrical stuff that is lost on me
I was really quite disappointed with this one, had quite high hopes. But yeah, top-heavy, goes on a bit, which seems out of kilter for a band at the relatively early stage of its career. Enough tunes to scrape a 3, although I do feel like they should change some of the lyrics so that everyone can enjoy them
one of those great moments where you find yourself going "oh this one!" quite a few times.
quite enjoyed that, and being generous, I realize the regional accent talky shtick was much less tiresome at the time of release. Bonus for not being a nonce too
Better than their post-2008 stuff would have you remember, but only decent, a bit repetitive and grated after a while
I liked it, feels like the most modern album we've had on this for a while. Very much an archetypal mercury prize winner, whatever that means
the first real dad rock on the list? And nicely done with it
some of these, I quite enjoyed, others not. Bob Mould (say it like Bob Dole), puts on a voice that is too annoying and emo-adjacent a bit too much of the time. Ummed and ahhed between a 3 and a 4, and went with the former. Surprised I'd never heard of this band before
Fine enough, but neaux bangers
not so jazzy. Weird this kind of music, kept feeling like it was going to break into a larger set of instruments, but it never happened. Maybe if he had sung me a song he would have got a 3
quite enjoyable, but nothing special, no riot prevention necessary
was quite surprised to have a queen album without any of the advert-y classics that you immediately think of when one thinks of Queen. And evaluating them independently, it's...kind of okay? A bit weird, a bit pompous, nothing that really stands out
I did quite enjoy, it's flitting between a 3 and a 4, becomes a 3 with wally tax
I have no evidence for this, but I assume every subsequent Morrissey album after The Smiths get worse as he's further removed from the stabilizing influence of Johnny Marr and has no one to tell him to wind his neck in just a touch (his neck is still very much wound out)
decent as far as reggae goes, I don't love it but I don't hate it either
nice enough, but nothing special. Can't help feel like he needs a couple of friends (or maybe occasionally three friends) to jam with