Jul 08 2021
View Author
2
Wow ok, not what I was expecting - I've always thought this guy was a guitarist's guitarist (but one of those ones that fly under the radar cause they write pop songs, kinda like John Mayer or something) - but I was WRONG.
This is "big concept" indie pop from the mid-2000s that we didn't ever need, kinda like arcade fire. This shit all follows the same pattern: it goes absolutely fucking nowhere, but takes forever to do it. Just sickly sweet, repetitive, modern easy listening tripe. I'm sure it gets called "ambitious" a lot, but there's no real ambition here; by the 10min mark you've heard everything it has to offer, but it just keeps on fucking going anyway and you start to gaslight yourself and assume there must be more to it that you're not "getting". But in reality it's just art school hipsters turning like 2 motifs into an hour and 15's worth of album, and then the wankers at outlets like Pitchfork act like it's groundbreaking because they are either a) fooled by the length, b) know pretentious art rock is fucking annoying and talk it up to piss normal people off, or c) both. I'm wondering where you'd be most likely to hear this: one of those hipster cafes where you have to sit on chairs they stole from a primary school? a tiny house owned by a girl who mostly wears a combo of overalls and doc martens? at a local theatre before a reinterpretation of Hamlet from Ophelia's perspective? 2/5.
👍
Oct 24 2021
View Author
1
Honestly just the blandest thing I've ever heard. If a yogurt made a sound this would be it.
👍
Feb 02 2021
View Author
3
This sounds like what a Wes Anderson movie would sound like if it were an album.
👍
Apr 15 2021
View Author
5
Songs as delicate as a gossamer spider’s web. But wait, spider silk is tougher than kevlar and stronger than steel. And so we come to the artless metaphor of my review. Sufjan’s finely crafted songs appear whispy and delicate, ephemeral things - but a closer listen reveals the rock solid songcraft, astonishing lyrics, transcendent beauty and strength.
👍
Oct 06 2021
View Author
5
One of the greatest albums ever made. Forget the lyrics and concept for a second, just the music alone is incredible. I love how you can hear each individual instrument coming together, but they become something greater than the some of their parts. \"They Are Night Zombies (...)\" is the perfect example of this. And the concept is super creative, and is explored in an amazing way. Absolutely flawless album, easily a top 5 album of all time for me.
👍
Feb 26 2021
View Author
5
LOVE LOVE LOVE. I love Sufjan and I love this album. From the epic joy of Chicago to the quiet tragedy of Casimir Pulaski Day to the eerie fun of They are Night Zombies!!, it's delightfully weird, wonderful, joyful, and diverse. I'm so glad he wrote an album for Illinois and I want to go back to Chicago listening to it.
👍
Jun 21 2021
View Author
4
crazy this dude still has 48 states to write an album for. also kinda pissed I was trying to study and spent 45 minutes reading about John Wayne Gacy instead
👍
Jan 25 2021
View Author
5
Love this album, one of my favourites from the last 20 years. Not a bad track, quite impressive considering its length.
👍
Oct 14 2020
View Author
5
This was a fantastic album in my opinion. It felt so familiar yet so new and refreshing. The lyrics were beautiful and the instrumentation was lovely. I totally get the hype now.
👍
Apr 18 2023
View Author
5
we are nothing, if not a mosaic of the places and spaces we inhabit; history is a documentation of the skin we shed on our journey to purpose, and the ground we walk on is filled with the dust of the bodies of previous generations now long decayed. Sufjan Stevens’ Illinois, a bombastic musical extravaganza about its titular state, is a beastly museum where the personal and historic collapse into, and inform each other, and are woven into a pointed take on the human condition. the second (and last) of Stevens’ purported 50 states project, Illinois soars because the titular area it highlights is merely a backdrop for more poignant tales on love and loss; innocence and regret; faith and death.
Stevens’ songwriting is laser sharp, almost deliriously so, that reading through his poetry is to pierce your own heart and bleed out. you think of a song like “Casimir Pulaski Day” and feel the emotion of losing a loved one in death (and the grappling with faith that immediately follows it), but Sufjan’s strength here goes beyond just the words: his lush orchestral instrumentation is ethereal and moving — it evokes and complements the largeness of his stories, sure, but there’s a paradoxical intimacy in the compositions too. every sound is so perfectly placed, tied closely to the sound before and the sound after. you combine the sounds with the words, and what you have is a juggernaut: songs that sound like life itself, that trace the very idea of being, from birth to love to death and even beyond. this is such a human album — challenging and complex and difficult to digest, but also light and jovial and ultimately rewarding. it is a tribute to the spaces that make us who we are; and just like a literal geographical location, it is vast in scope and scattered, but also raging with passion and romance — a glass-stained cornucopia of details and people and laughter and tears and bodies and monuments and buildings that, at its very core, just sounds thankful to be alive.
👍
Feb 02 2021
View Author
5
What a fantastic album. Even more amazing when you learn that Stevens played most of the instruments on the album. Loved the interludes between songs as well. The grandness of the compositions reminded me of Pet Sounds. Ambitious, but pulled off perfectly.
👍
Jan 13 2021
View Author
5
B e a utiful
👍
Apr 15 2021
View Author
3
Did it allay my suspicions that he's a poser whose experiments with fey grandeur via cutsie-pie rhymes and honeyed vocals don't liberate him from the thrall of easy listening? Yeah, pretty much. That stuff is sorta there but with less pretention, more whimsy and, most of all, melodies that are too full-bodied to ignore. In truth, I heard this as two stars but have bumped it to three as I could see that happening with repeat listens.
👍
Jan 11 2023
View Author
2
Christian rock for people who buy artisan maple syrup.
👍
Mar 28 2023
View Author
5
Lot of things to say here. First of all, so glad to see this included, Sufjan Stevens is one of the most incredible songwriters I’ve ever heard, and to this day I’d say that seeing him at Red Rocks remains my favorite concert I’ve attended. This was album two in the fifty state series (after Greetings from Michigan). Suffy, if you’re reading this, there’s still time and demand! Take us to Arizona or something next. Jokes aside, this album is an elaborate tapestry, woven with a level of care that most humans just don’t possess. It’s weird to talk about a musician like that, but Sufjan seems to have a reverence for minutiae and the ordinary, the kind of guy that literally couldn’t kill a fly because he’d see the fly as a provider for its family or lost in love or something. He devoted that compassionate meticulousness to making an ENTIRE album about Illinois, and if a sympathetic song about John Wayne Gacy isn’t an indicator of how rare this guy is, I don’t know what you’re looking for. The writing on here is top notch, and the production is so varied and impressive, lots of bright, clear percussion and unorthodox instruments. Sufjan was dialed the fuck in. Near the center of this album, back to back, lie two of the most powerful songs ever: “Chicago” and “Casimir Pulaski Day.” Powerful for different reasons: the former is a simple, euphoric song of transformation and moving on, moving forward. The latter is a devastating portrait of a childhood friend (maybe first love) taken too young by bone cancer. No idea if this is fiction or autobiographical, but I don’t care because either would blow my mind. Anytime I hear Casimir Pulaski Day, I play it a second time, and then I get distracted listening through all the other Sufjan songs I love. In other words, it took me a while to get through this album. I looked ahead and I’m afraid that Carrie and Lowell, his masterpiece from 2015 (and one of my absolute favorite albums ever), might not be on the list. Know that I would add it in a heartbeat over so many of the humdrum British rock wafers we’ve received, and go listen to that pronto. This one stands as tall as Seer’s Tower on its own. I expected to give it a 4.5 but we bumping that up today. I’m relishing a lot more than I had before on here.
Favorite tracks: Casimir Pulaski Day, Chicago, Concerning the UFO Sighting, John Wayne Gacy Jr., The Seer’s Tower, The Predatory Wasp.
Album art: Illinoise, spelled for the dummies. You got Al Capone, some UFOs, what the hell else do you need? It’s perfect for what it needed to accomplish. There’s a cool variant with a Chicago superhero flying around, I think that’s the vinyl I’ve got.
5/5
👍
Dec 14 2020
View Author
5
Yay, another one I've already listened to! Love this album very much. :)
👍
Sep 04 2020
View Author
5
Amazing
👍
Sep 17 2020
View Author
5
<3
👍
Mar 30 2021
View Author
2
false
👍
Jan 15 2021
View Author
2
Nothing special at all
👍
Sep 08 2021
View Author
2
I was bored by this. Lots of people love sufjan and never really given him a chance, maybe this was the wrong place to start?
👍
Jan 18 2024
View Author
5
How can a song about John Wayne Gacy Jr be so beautiful?
This was a mix between The Eels and other 90s surf pop, The Divine Comedy and The Penguin Orchestra.
How can you not immediately love a song called “The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades Is Out To Get Us!” ?!
The instrumentals were a bit too jazzy for me, but overall loved this album.
👍
Jul 22 2021
View Author
5
This sounds like someone has mashed together the Flaming Lips, Neil Young, Super Furry Animals, the Polyphonic Spree and the chorus of a musical. What comes out is unlike anything ever, and quite brilliant. Big, orchestral, great melodies, with unusual and interesting lyrics. All complimented and contested with Sufjan Stevens' quiet, breathy vocals. A triumph of song writing and recording. 5/5.
👍
Nov 02 2021
View Author
4
I know every nook and crannie of this record. It was something that was played heavily in the tour van when Those Transatlantics were traversing the Eastern U.S. 2004-2006. We used to play the song about Chicago when we pulled into town for a show. It's a record with a lot of emotional weight on its own. Add the nostalgia for those times and it feels almost inappropriate to listen now. Like I'm an outsider to my own memories.
Musically, this is so interesting. And his voice is beautiful and sweet. Sad he only made it through a couple states in his quest to write a record for each in the Union. But I'm happy Michigan was one of them (it's good, but this is his peak in my opinion).
👍
Apr 04 2024
View Author
2
So just spitballin’ here, but an album about things from the state of Illinois does NOT sound like a recipe for musical goodness… I was also fascinated by the fact that this was voted the best album of 2005… No offense to Mr. Stevens, as a multi-instrumentalist – he is certainly very talented, but I would argue that “Illinois” being the best album of 2005, says more about the lack of quality music in 2005, as opposed to how exceptional this album is… If this came out in 1977, it’s not even in the Top 500 of that year…
I would argue that 70%+ of the albums on the 1,001 list SHOULD be coming from the 60’s & 70’s… Artists created music for the love of their art and craft back then, as there really wasn’t a lot of money in music at the time… Once that changed in the late 70’s and early 80’s – everyone subsequently got in it for the money, and the corporate formulas took over…
I’ve listened to a handful of self-made albums (i.e. where the artist plays every instrument for the most part…), and this was probably the best… Most of them just have a weird sound, like there wasn’t enough diversity in the playing, but this one sort of escaped that… Mr. Stevens is very talented, and definitely has a unique and original sound – so points for that, and for what he was trying to accomplish, the album is fairly well-done…
My main complaint, is that after a while, all of the songs sorta just sound the same… Enjoyed the piano-based songs better than the banjo ones – but that’s just me, and never thought I’d hear a song about “John Wayne Gacy”, but that’s “Illinois” for you…
👍
Jul 22 2021
View Author
2
Geeze. Someone give this bastard a hug and a cup of strong black coffee. It's nothing but a stack of sad-sack, hipster, pseudo-deep lyrics that are utterly lacking in perspective or passion. The only saving grace is that the musicianship and production are absolutely stellar.
👍
Apr 03 2024
View Author
1
If you're going to make an album that's over an hour long, you need to be a lot more interesting and dynamic than this.
👍
Feb 15 2024
View Author
5
This is why i like 1001
👍
Aug 06 2021
View Author
5
Landmark in indie folk of the 21st century. Each track is beautifully arranged with carefully crafted instrumentation and introspective lyrics that draw from classical compositions and great poets. Subject matter is focused on Illinois topics and his own Christianity, making for a very personal experience.
I could point something that stuck out to me on each track. For example, "Come on Feel the Illinoise" has a distinctive Chicago sound that reminds me of the musical. It's feels like a classical arrangement divided in movements, still cohesive, but flows naturally. In "John Wayne Gacy Jr", we see inspirations of his Christianity to humanize one of the most infamous serial killers in history, an individual who has a soul just like everyone else but grew up in circumstances that unfortunately led him down this past, teaching us that we can make the difference to prevent further massacres or redeem them as productive citizens. "Jacksonville" and "Decatur" remind me this is indeed a folk album with instruments like the banjo and a clear focus on the vocals. Oh and while I'm at it I love all the back vocals. You can tell there are different people on each track and it helps give each of them an identity.
But then we get back to "Chicago" and the mood shifts from small time folk to big city feels (more like indie pop) with busy instruments and loud vocals, inviting the audience to sing along. And again it feels like a musical (Chicago) with the focus on the narrator given those momentary soliloquies about his personal experiences. Love the coda but I'm not sure it fit with the rest of the song since the rest of the song didn't feel particularly holy. This is followed by "Casimir Pulaski Day" which is another favorite of mine, for its simplicity and all-over-the-place story that reflects youthful grief and confusion. "The Man of Metropolis" is probably the next most complex song after "Chicago", fusing many different genres, especially rock. Love the distorted guitar sound at the end. "Prarie Fire" to me starts out sounding like it has a mystery theme turning into some holiday-themed Eastern European folk song between the chorus vocals and strange Christmas-like instruments in the latter half. Again, I could talk about the rest of the songs, but the point is that each shows Sufjan's creativity and masterful display of how to use the limited tools at his disposal to the full extent, playing with instruments and vocals in a million ways that doesn't sound experimental or repetitive, making each song stand out while still putting emphasis to his poetic lyrics. From start to finish, this album is a masterpiece to show indie musicians just what is possible with pure talent.
👍
Apr 15 2021
View Author
5
Was pretty gutted when this ended. Will always love this.
👍
Apr 20 2021
View Author
5
i listened to this album a lot in high school. sometimes i'm not feeling his style but today it was hitting me right
👍
Jan 22 2021
View Author
5
4 stars, would listen to again.
👍
Mar 01 2024
View Author
2
Not something I would normally listen to, and with good reason because it was rubbish.
Only song that got anywhere near grabbing my attention was The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts, and even then it was not because it was actually any good but because it was the only track that didn’t sound identical to the others.
Everything from the track names, to the songs, to the album itself is boring, too long, overly complicated, and trying too hard to be clever (haha Illinoise - do you get it?).
This gets a 2 only because it’s not quite as terrible as some others on this list.
👍
Oct 14 2023
View Author
1
Never heard of this album or artist before. I'll be blunt. I hated every track. The creepy, breathy, wimpy vocals were the worst part. The rest of the music had nothing exciting or memorable. One song that said Lincoln is known as the great emancipator sounded like something a kid would write for extra credit in his high school history class. I'd be embarrassed to listen to this in front of anyone. Did not listen to the bonus CD tracks. I can guess what they sound like.
👍
Sep 21 2024
View Author
5
Such a great album. I listened to this so many times in high school and college. It holds up so well.
👍
Aug 24 2024
View Author
5
Ich bin heute in Illinois in Chicago. Da war ich besonders gespannt, welcher Soundtrack von einem mir unbekannten Sufjan Stevens geboten wird. Nach den ersten Tönen merkt man, dass es jetzt gehobene Kost mit wunderschönen Melodien, Gesängen, Chöre und allen möglichen Instrumente gibt. Harmonisch, kein Ton zuviel, kein Ton zu wenig. Zum Weinen schön. John Wayne ein berühmter Westernheld, wird hier sensibel und zärtlich besungen. Von wegen Illinoise, hier stimmt das Zusammenspiel, auch der Dialog zwischen Blechbläser, Banjo und Geigen, selbst die Chören passen auch unangemeldet. Und Chicago? Was geht ab? Meine Frage stellt sich: Gibt es eine bessere Hymne? Ich verneige mich vor Sufjan Stevens und bedanke mich für die beste Hymne, die je über Chicago geschrieben wurde. Natürlich kenne ich kaum Hymnen über Chicago. Aber was ich heute gehört habe reicht. Alles andere kann jetzt nur verlieren.
👍
Feb 15 2024
View Author
5
Certified Sufjan classic
👍
Feb 14 2024
View Author
5
I don't know why, but I had the mistaken impression that Sufjan Stevens put out "romantic" bubble gum pap. I was really wrong. This is really good.
Very very interesting song titles (e.g., "The Black Hawk War, or, How to Demolish an Entire Civilization and Still Feel Good About Yourself in the Morning, or, We Apologize for the Inconvenience but You're Going to Have to Leave Now, or, 'I Have Fought the Big Knives and Will Continue to Fight Them Until They Are Off Our Lands!'")
There's a lot of complicated things going on here. And a significant amount of creepiness. Oddly and inexplicably, I am experiencing a sense of dread.
This is not background music. It requires that you devote an hour and 14 minutes to paying attention. Is it a symphony? The Sergeant Pepper of the 2000s?
Although I don't particularly LOVE every song, I enjoyed the listening experience very much. There's just so much going on (did I already say that?). Vocals (lead and background), instrumentation, everything together... very nice.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
__________________________________
🎧 LPs reviewed: 40
🎧 LPs left to review: 961
🎧 LPs I found great/relevant enough to be mandatory listens (5): 10
🎧 LPs I *might* include in my own list (4): 14
🎧 LPs I will certainly *not* include in mine (1-2): 10
👍
Mar 09 2021
View Author
5
Fand ich völlig gile!
👍
Feb 18 2021
View Author
5
Muy bueno, me ha encantado
👍
Apr 03 2021
View Author
5
Prachtig album.
👍
Apr 03 2021
View Author
5
Really a nice surprise for me. Recent (younger than me) music that’s right up my alley.
👍
Apr 03 2021
View Author
5
De orkestrale composities, en de vrolijke noten in dit album hebben mij positief verrast! De korte instrumentale intermezzo's zorgen voor leuke afwisseling.
Zeker een album om nog eens opnieuw te beluisteren
👍
Feb 14 2021
View Author
5
Even if he never finished the other states in this Grand and ambitious project, this is a beautiful loveletter to the time and place.
👍
Jan 26 2021
View Author
5
Great album! Can't believe I hadn't heard it earlier.
👍
Apr 20 2021
View Author
5
One of my favorite albums that helped get me through a lot of my emo highschool days. I still listen to it every so often when I am in the right mood.
Fave Track - Decatur (or something something step mom)
👍
Feb 19 2021
View Author
5
One of my favorite albums. Love it!
👍
Feb 02 2021
View Author
5
Love this album, specifically Chicago, feel the illinoise!, and Casimir Pulaski day. The experimental nature and samples feel intimately eccentric, like reading a journal.
👍
Feb 09 2021
View Author
5
love
👍
Apr 16 2021
View Author
5
I've listened to this album before once or twice maybe, and it never really grabbed me, but paying more attention to it this time around and it's _wonderful_. Gorgeous music, poignant lyrics, amazing stuff.
Fave track - "Chicago", although I can imagine that might change with a few more listens...
👍
Jan 19 2021
View Author
5
Super, complexe instrumentatie, van typisch singer songwriter tot hard
👍
Jan 14 2021
View Author
5
Absolutely a perfect example of the Genre. Many songs I've heard before, but have never listened through the album completely. Definitely worth multiple listens.
👍
Jan 15 2021
View Author
5
The greatest Sufjan album ever. I was a jr. in high school when this album came out and it was like nothing i'd ever heard.
👍
Jan 19 2021
View Author
5
There's something special there, despite the overuse of children's choir.
👍
Jan 27 2021
View Author
5
already loved it
👍
Feb 11 2021
View Author
5
AMAZING. One of my favourite albums.
👍
Jan 28 2021
View Author
5
Classic emo/indie rock
👍
Jun 21 2021
View Author
5
Still great after all these years
👍
Mar 26 2021
View Author
5
Love love love
👍
Nov 30 2020
View Author
5
I really like this album. It is a soothing listen even with some heavy concepts.
👍
May 27 2024
View Author
4
First time hearing this album. Very unique and hard to categorize. Kind of have to be in the mood to listen to it, but then it really works. Definitely better as an end-to-end album that something you'd shuffle into your playlist. Don't really need a song detailing the life and times of John Wayne Gacy popping up just any random time.
👍
Jan 29 2024
View Author
4
a few good tunes and lots of meandering, like his other work
[edit: I spent a bit more time with this than usual over a weekend, and found it to be more complex and complete than I previously understood. Bumped up a point for quality. Jacksonville and Chicago are legit bangers, and some of the more oddly-titled ones are good fun. Could still lose about 15 mins]
👍
Mar 02 2023
View Author
4
It’s Sufjan Stevens being some top tier Sufjan
👍
Feb 28 2023
View Author
4
I love concept albums and while I'm not an expert on Illinois history, I know enough to appreciate and recognize many of the references and homages. The range of music fits together seamlessly using certain interludes and intermissions between certain tracks that get the listener ready for a shift in tone and style. Listening to the first track, I was worried it was going to be a basic pop/folk album. I was anticipating a 2. Not that that style would be bad for an album, I just usually expect those albums don't push the boundaries very much. By the time I got into the second track I knew I was completely wrong and was then just along for the ride, not knowing what to expect. Things never really get out of hand in this album and while there is a difference in style among several tracks, there's a consistent sound. Overall, the biggest downfall to this record is that it's too long. That's significant considering it's not actually an overwhelmingly long album when looking at the runtime. It sits on the longer side of the spectrum at 1hr and 14 mins but there are longer albums. This is an album you have to dedicate that full hour and 14 minutes for. Listening in episodes would be like stopping a movie every 15 minutes or so and then coming back to it later. It's definitely somewhere between a 4.0 and a 4.5. It's lack of replay value hurts the score just a little bit but it's definitely an ambitious and important homage to a state and country's history.
👍
Dec 30 2022
View Author
4
This album did not sound at all like I was expecting based on the cover art.
👍
Dec 11 2022
View Author
4
A really fun one. It's totally all over the place lyrically, but sonically it really makes the most of using a similar sound for much of it. The lyrics are really beautiful and silly at times which keeps it very interesting as well. 7/10
👍
Oct 11 2022
View Author
3
Ce pâle clone de Cat Stevens nous offre un album long comme le sexe nouvellement dressé de Muddy Waters (voir review sur Hard Again), cela ne prend malheureusement pas avec moi.
👍
Nov 09 2021
View Author
3
OK, this is going to sound really bad. But I thought Sufjan Stevens was the lead singer from System Of A Down.
Oops. Definitely not.
Yeah, so this isn't bad. But it is a bit.... different. It's a bit noodle-y in places. Experimental music has (to me) sometimes the feel of pretentiousness. "Look, I can put together anything and package it and people will buy it." I get the point of the concept album, and maybe if I was from the midwest I could appreciate it more. As it is, it just didn't hit me like I was expecting. Not something I will revisit.
👍
Sep 08 2021
View Author
3
Wow this was well confusing. I've never known how I feel about Sufjan Stevens tbh, and this confirmed this .. again. I really loved some and utterly hated others. Strange place to!
👍
Apr 04 2024
View Author
2
Interesting album… I would describe this as folk more than alternative. Although I say that more because of the vocal stylings.
Musical arrangements for to Intricate and layered, The guy knows how to put a song together!
At the end of the album, though, not my cup of tea.
👍
Mar 12 2024
View Author
2
Yeah, maybe on a different day this could’ve gotten 3 stars. Just could not vibe with it.
👍
Mar 07 2024
View Author
2
Huh not sure what to say about this one. the fact i can't remember a single song after it's finished is not a good sign.
👍
Feb 29 2024
View Author
2
A bit boring
👍
Nov 21 2023
View Author
2
I remember when this came out and every hipster was spewing in his/her/their pants.
This album marks the beginning of the pussification of the USA. Can't give it a 1, since there's some good orchestral moments.
👍
Nov 12 2023
View Author
1
Ég á ofboðslega erfitt með Sufjan Stevens - þykir stöffið hans meira og minna allt tilgerðarlegt drasl. Það á meðal annars við um þessa plötu.
👍
Jun 16 2023
View Author
1
Brrr
👍
Nov 29 2024
View Author
5
I just love this so much.
👍
Nov 25 2024
View Author
5
All-time favorite.
👍
Nov 25 2024
View Author
5
sprawling, ambitious, gorgeous - so excited to see some sufjan stevens on here. aside from being basically the only christian i respect, he's an immensely talented musician, and while parts of this album feel a little dated to me (unclear if that's due to my own obsessive listening/relistening in high school, or a general early aughts indie sound), it's still an incredible work that eclipses anything else that was happening in the genre at the time. my personal pick of his for this list would be Carrie & Lowell, but i can also see why this would be chosen for how important it was to the time. maybe we can have both in later editions???
👍
Nov 21 2024
View Author
5
Listened to this beforehand on a 'music night'. Masterpiece of an album, amazing use of the orchestra to create a majestic feel to the album. I feel like I'm floating and on a journey when I listen to this.
Fun to find out the meaning of the tracks in relation to Illinois, not so fun to listen to some of the lyrics.
👍
Nov 20 2024
View Author
5
Like many elder Millennials, this is a seminal album for me. Bursting with creativity and ingenuity. Beautiful, timeless, endlessly rewarding.
👍
Nov 19 2024
View Author
5
Oh, Gott ist das schön. Allein schon die Hymne über Chicago. Traumhaft wunderschöne Melodien und Arrangemnts. Hier fühlt man Illinoise, hier fühlt man die Schönheit der Stimmungen.
👍
Nov 15 2024
View Author
5
PERFECT
👍
Nov 10 2024
View Author
5
Beautiful album, but the names are where my appreciation lie. Apparently this was adapted to a Broadway play, pretty cool.
👍
Nov 07 2024
View Author
5
Absolutely stunning album. 5 stars.
👍
Nov 07 2024
View Author
5
I’m gonna need more time with this album, but at first pass, I’m at a 4.5 that I simply admire so much that I’m gonna bump it up to a 5.
Perhaps it’s the post-election inner fear talking, but this felt like the perfect album at the perfect time – just an inspired biographical reminder of what I hope this country is, what I hope it can continue to be, and what makes it truly great. I’ve never heard a Sufjan Stevens album for this; never even heard of the guy, really. I’m beyond impressed.
I’m a sucker for historical references in music; not because it’s necessarily great for songwriting, but because it tells me that I’m dealing with someone who knows and is embedded into history, at least to some degree. As a trivia guy, it just gives me a point of reference to really feel where a song is coming from. This album is jam-packed with them, up and down, and quite frankly, the balance between all the references and being able to actively blend them and weave them into such compelling narratives and melodies is one of the most impressive things I’ve heard in the 310 albums we’ve done so far.
Past that, my goodness, the music; what an absolute behemoth of a production this must’ve had. Occasionally, this album gets a little too cute with its vocal mixing at the expense of the listener, but more often than not, that orchestration and instrumentation so perfectly captures a mood that might be impossible to put into words. I say that knowing that his songwriting here is about as impressive as the instrumentation, if not moreso.
It’s a deeply bombastic album, fantastically structured, and its long-ass song titles provide the humor in places where it’s desperately needed. It definitely feels like he had fun making this, but he also knew exactly how much weight this thing was carrying. To find such a great balance between instrumentation, songwriting, vocals and production, while making sure this thing doesn’t collapse under the weight of its own ambition and honesty is nothing short of a miracle. Again, there are flaws here; a few tracks go on a bit long, some of the funny filler could’ve been cut instead of doing it to satiate a long song title or to keep the “musical” structure alive, but those “flaws” are more like production choices that just didn’t click with me.
I need another pass or two on this album without the misty-eyed dread of November 5th, 2024 looming long in my head, to more critically analyze it, and really take away its theming and lyricism more without clinging so deeply onto its messaging of hope and promise… but if the album’s already got me that hooked, in light of what just happened, it’s doing something right. If anything, I feel like I’ll appreciate it even more. It’s a 4.5 that I’m bumping up to a 5.
👍
Nov 04 2024
View Author
5
I loved almost everything from the cover art to the variety of sound and themes. My only complaint is that it feels almost too polished and there's not enough grit, but that's like saying my greatest weakness is being a perfectionist.
👍
Nov 04 2024
View Author
5
One of his best!
👍
Nov 02 2024
View Author
5
I first listened to this album when I was 21. I had been out of my “all music ended in 1979” mindset for about a year by that point, but I still only listened to what my friends told me about. I stumbled upon this on my own, almost by accident even though it had been out for a few years by that point. Almost immediately, my idea of what music could be was transformed.
I’ve listened to this one a lot since then. Listening to it again for this project reinforces everything that this album has meant to me. Every song still brings out such powerful emotions. In these dark times, “Come On Feel the Illinoise” and “Jacksonville” are such strong beacons of light. “John Wayne Gacy, Jr.” is still haunting, I still know every word of “Decatur”, and “Chicago” never fails to bring a tear to the eye. And that doesn’t even get to what may be the single saddest song ever written, “Casimir Pulaski Day”.
This is a very long album, but it earns every second of its run time. (Also, listening to it now, 350-odd albums into this project, some of the interludes feel like they were meant to be intermissions, which helps with the length). The back half of the album is full of gems. Even after all this time, I was surprised at how affected I was by “Predatory Wasp”, even though nothing about this album should surprise me anymore. And the reward for sticking it out to the end is “The Tallest Man, the Broadest Shoulders”, about as good of an album climax as I’ve ever heard.
Illinois is a perfect album, plain and simple. I’m glad to see that such a monumental album in my life remains that way after all these years.
👍
Oct 30 2024
View Author
5
I kinda view this album in 4 parts (I’m not counting the interludes and I’m not calling the tracks by their stupidity long names)
Part 1: UFO-> Jacksonville
Part 2: Decatur-> Casimir Pulaski day
Part 3: Man of metropolis->Night zombies
Part 4:Seers tower-> Out of Egypt
There now this album is much more digestible:
Part 1 is strong I really like John Wayne Gacy for the ‘twist’ at the end Illinoise and Jacksonville are both brilliant, they’re not my favourites on the album (but I’ll get to them) still amazing though. UFO is a nice short opener and Black hawk works well in the aftermath. 4.5/5
Part 2 starts a bit weaker with Decatur which has always sounded like a kiddies song to me, but it’s alright. But Chicago and Casimir Pulaski day are two of my favourites on the album, this is the moment when all things go on Illinois. 4.5/5
Part 3 is my favourite, sure prairie fire isn’t AS good but it’s still a disorienting experience. But then Man of metropolis, Palisades and Night Zombies are just masterpieces. Man of metropolis and Night Zombies come off as a bit surprising as they’re quite different from the album so far but at this point in the album a shift was needed. Palisades is just beautiful. 5/5
Part 4 feels like you’ve ran straight into a brick wall (in the best way possible) seers tower is such a gloomy song but it’s beautiful too. Tallest man drags but it’s a great climax to the album. Then out of Egypt is just a good instrumental. 4/5
It’s a double album of course there’s gonna be filler, I really don’t care if you come up with an ‘exception’ they’ve always got something that’s not as good. And the interludes (especially on first listen) can get annoying, literally a good 10/15 minutes of the album is just interlude. But it still has to be a 5/5. It’s incredible.
👍
Oct 28 2024
View Author
5
I've slept on this artist for way too long. Cracking album, very enjoyable listen.
👍
Oct 25 2024
View Author
5
sooooo good and i wish michigan had been on here as well <3 can't wait for the other 48 state albums!
👍
Oct 23 2024
View Author
5
A comfortable composition of expressive music that is outlined with subtle vocals and great lyrics
👍
Oct 22 2024
View Author
5
A wonderful album.
👍
Oct 21 2024
View Author
5
Full of interesting songs!
👍
Oct 19 2024
View Author
5
❤️❤️❤️
👍
Oct 15 2024
View Author
5
I love it
👍
Oct 14 2024
View Author
5
Chad recommended this album to me two years ago. There’s some incredible songs on it. Happy to listen to this masterpiece again.
👍
Oct 14 2024
View Author
5
What a phenomenal album. I'm a sucker for dissonant, brassy syncopation and this album was indulgently full of it while somehow keeping it fresh and interesting every single time. Bravo, Sufjan.
👍
Oct 10 2024
View Author
5
I wasn’t sure what to expect of this album, having not knowingly heard any Sufjan Stevens before today. I certainly wasn’t expecting miserable alt rock. To clarify, miserable alt is one of my favourite genres, so this is no jibe. The orchestration here stayed interesting throughout, and the vocals were soft and lovely when on their own, and an absolute delight when sang in chorus. My only criticism of this album is that it is a little long which makes for sleepy brains becoming distracted away from the music. Otherwise, this is a great album.
👍