Sep 02 2025
2
Fall Out Boy makes very catchy rock songs with lot of bombastic arrangements. The songs individually are ok (but not great) and listening to an album as a whole the repeated trick that is used makes it boring and inoffensive. This album will not Save Rock And Roll.
Sep 09 2025
1
Kinda hard to save rock and roll with a corporate-shlock sellout album designed for Top 40 radio play.
Sep 02 2025
3
Holy cringe
Oct 15 2025
2
Respectfully, are you fucking kidding me? This is the chosen Fall Out Boy album? I was such a fan of FOB when I was younger, they were the perfect emo band to make me feel something. Their first few albums remain great: Take This To Your Grave and From Under the Cork Tree are so important to me, I'd defend them forever. Infinity on High was solid, but they started getting a little big for their britches around there. After that, they pivoted into more pop/stadium rock anthem stuff. I don't know why bands take that trajectory, but they do. Same thing happened to Panic at the Disco, and Maroon 5 was similar (they went from like adult contemporary rock stuff to pop slop). This album is post-greatest hits album. That's the sure sign you're past the expiration date. I do kinda like "Alone Together" on here, but even that is a far cry from their peak. This album is part of a really embarrassing fall from grace for a band that once meant the world to me.
2/5
Sep 13 2025
5
The Phoenix was a nearly over the top opening to an album I wasn’t sure I’d enjoy. But I really loved it! Courtney Love was an interesting addition. And the Elton John ending was a great finish.
Sep 02 2025
4
Not the best pop/emo/punk album. But very enjoyable
Sep 07 2025
2
Fall Out Boy are one of the few ‘emo’ pop-punk bands from my mid ‘00s childhood I still enjoy listening to, and their first four albums are all stellar examples of the genre, with fantastic hooks all over the show and a real openness to experiment with a wide range of different sounds, with more hardcore punk leanings on their debut and musical theatre sprinkles on their final pre-hiatus record Folie a Deux.
The five years between Folie a Deux and this album felt like an eternity, and I cannot overstate the sheer fucking hype when it became clear they were actually coming back. And then Save Rock and Roll came out and it felt… off. The energy and creativity of the first four albums was not there at all, and this is a far less interesting project (though nowhere near as bad as some of the absolute dross they put out after).
I wanted to give this the benefit of the doubt after so many years - the sudden shift to a more pop-oriented sound screamed of cashing out at the time, but I thought it may bear more fruit with some distance, similarly to how Linkin Park’s more electronic and pop-oriented A Thousand Suns really grew on me after some time and revision of expectations. But no, I still found this very disappointing. There’s some good stuff on here - the opener The Phoenix is a banger, and the twee acoustic Young Volcanoes is very catchy, but the album crashed and burned in so many places, and the audacity of its title just seems incredibly unearned. If this is what saving rock and roll sounds like, then the rumours are true - rock and roll is dead
Sep 22 2025
1
Oh god what a way to title your pop album the douchiest thing you could possibly think. This also reminds me of the worst ex I ever had so this thing is really batting at a disadvantage. I think if i can survive the two annoying lead singles. I don't hate Alone Together as a pop song, though the melody line is a little dull. Young Volcanoes might as well have been written by Imagine Dragons. Save Rock and Roll with Elton John? fuuuuuuuccccckkkkkk offfffff.
Sep 03 2025
5
Love this
5
Such an iconic album, with unforgettable bangers. Their best for sure.
Sep 05 2025
5
Heard of them but didn't know the music. Very good!
Sep 16 2025
5
Definitely feels like a bit of a guilty pleasure. It's anthemic, polished and bombastic. Though it feels a bit full of itself at times, i loved every track on this album except Rat-A-Tat-Tat... that just hit wrong, and I'm a big Courtney Love/Hole fan.
Sep 17 2025
4
I unapologetically love FOB. This is one of their later, lesser albums in my opinion, but still full of fun bangers.
Sep 24 2025
4
Rating: 8/10
Best songs: The phoenix, My songs know what you did in the dark, Alone together, Just one yesterday, Miss missing you, Rat a tat
Sep 03 2025
3
Another band with an immediately familiar name that I had no sense at all of what their sound was. I browsed a handful of what a quick search suggested as their hits and nothing was particularly familiar. No idea why I know about this band. The album was immediately appealing, but then a whole lot of it fell into a pretty uniform groove. Pop, and nothing against it, well performed and decent lyrics, but a little shallow.
Sep 03 2025
3
Upbeat, melodic pop rock. Song after song after song. A formula repeated from first track to last.
Sep 04 2025
3
Love FOB, hate this album
Sep 06 2025
3
Fall out Boy is ok. This was ok. 3/5.
Sep 17 2025
3
Yeah I mean idk, sounds like Fall Out Boy
Sep 20 2025
3
Some fun songs, maybe short of a great album
Sep 26 2025
3
I think maybe Fall Out Boy could get a spot but not with this. It just sounded so... generic? Insipid?
I think the other comments really cover it well. This sounds like it is meant for generic sound commercials and ad promos.
I thought Fall Out Boy had a more emo sound no? Apparently they did early in their career which is what I remember from high school.
My personal rating: 2/5
My rating relative to the list: 3/5
Should this have been included on the original list? No.
Sep 28 2025
3
Pop rock. Ni fu ni fa.
Nov 11 2025
3
Hum...they didn't save the rock and roll, but it's a nice album. I believe late emo-ish albums are indeed a lack on the original 1001 list, but I prefer others from Fall Out Boy.
Sep 04 2025
2
Sorry personal view but Iv never liked fall out boy and never will. Something about them and their music just grates on me.
If this what saves rock n roll deary me.
Sep 08 2025
2
A bit corny and cliched
Sep 09 2025
2
This sounds like the bastard child of mid-2000s Black Eyed Peas and the incidental music from an episode of Lucifer.
While a couple of the tracks are alright - I'd not consider this to be a "must listen" by any stretch.
Sep 19 2025
2
Having fall out boy on this list kind of makes sense. They were a huge band two decades ago and some absolute bangers that were pretty much unavoidable and are still great listens. Unfortunately this is not the album I was speaking about. This is the pop rock album that came out 8 years later and was filled with a bunch of ESPN promo songs that were significantly less enjoyable than what made them famous. Good band. Wrong album. 5.4/10
Oct 13 2025
2
No catchy hooks or hits
Oct 29 2025
2
Not their best, but better than a lot of the crap on the list.
Oct 30 2025
2
What happened to this band?
Nov 03 2025
2
Rock and Roll is in a lot of trouble.
Nov 10 2025
2
I can't say that this sounds bad, but it really really didn't speak to me. Too be fair, I'm not a fan of Fall Out Boy, so I didn't think it was going to, but I've been pleasantly surprised before. This just felt really generic to me
2/5 Also, doing a sequel to We Didn't Start the Fire is an unforgivable lapse in judgement. I'm not saying that this played into my rating here, but I just want to state for the record that I hate it and the entire thought process that led to it
Sep 19 2025
1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=En_VILln4qE
Oct 07 2025
1
Couldn’t get past that it sounded like 5SOS
Oct 30 2025
1
Really, really not my style. Reminds me a lot of Maroon 5 actually. Surely we could’ve gone for From Under The Cork Tree? Cover is tuff though
Nov 10 2025
1
More cliched and soulless than a mall painting of a soft-focused wolf howling in front of a flag.
This might be the most AI-sounding auto-tuned generic music on the list. Quasi-emo-punk slop that sounds fake and completely inhuman and yet not in any fun electronic way.
If you told ChatGPT to make an album of this genre it would do better which should terrify anyone.
TL;DR: I do not care for it.
1/10 1 star
Nov 10 2025
1
I cannot take this band seriously it sounds like what a fourth grader would pick if they have to run a kilometre for school. Like the voice alone reminds me of middle school and like I just can’t do more than a song.
Nov 14 2025
1
Millennial grocery store muzak.