Isn't Anything by My Bloody Valentine

Isn't Anything

My Bloody Valentine

2.75
Rating
23437
Votes
1
14%
2
28%
3
33%
4
19%
5
6%
Distribution

Album Summary

Isn't Anything is the debut studio album by Anglo-Irish rock band My Bloody Valentine, released on 21 November 1988 by Creation Records. Its innovative guitar and production techniques consolidated the experimentation of the band's preceding EPs and would make the album a pioneering work of the subgenre known as shoegazing. Upon its release, the album received rave critical reviews and reached #1 on the UK Independent Albums Chart.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

At this point in time, the band’s taste exceeds their abilities. There are some interesting ideas and the songs are ok, but the songwriting and musicianship is yet to reach the maturity it would need to record mbv’s masterpiece several years later.

Could only find some shitty YouTube from 15 years ago and even then I couldn’t find the whole album. Wasn’t worth tracking down the rest. Not as good as Loveless unfortunately (but not much is in this genre)

its like loveless but bad (and thats good)

I did not like it. It was too fuzzy to be melodic and too melodic to be grungy

Фоновый шорох эпохи

Мой любимый их альбом. Жаль, что остальное не такое же.

Гитарки уже начали жужжать, но ещё не так громко. Пы. сы. Я конечно рад, что шугейз в этом списке впринципе упомянут Но Здесь вся дискография мбв, альбомы райд, кокту твинс, бич хаус Но где слоудайв, почему?

не мое - 3

Some great songs and some songs that sound like parodies of themselves.

There's a strange quality to it that pulls me in more than other albums I've rated 2 stars. Problem is, I was repelled the more I focused on it, particularly the vocal mixing.

First track - chromatic/dissonant, not much of a key going on here. Genre is some kind of post-punk, post-new wave (basslines are new-wave but there's little melody to speak of). Lost My Breath is moody and oppressive. Mix is all over the place, I can barely hear the vocals. (When You Wake) is the first track with something to latch onto, and it's a kind of post-hardcore instrumentation with clean vocals. Not bad. Almost puts me in mind of The Cure. Feed Me With Your Kiss - look, I am a fan of noisy music, but this is a little too amorphous and noisy for even me. Best track - When You Wake 3 stars - I get it, but they've just pushed a little too far for me. But When You Wake has the balance perfect.

My Bloody Valentine – Isn't Anything (1988) On Day 325, this foundational shoegaze debut proved to be a divided experience, opening with an unfocused, drifting wall of distortion before finding genuine emotional traction in its second half. Early on, the submerged vocals and disorienting pitch-bent guitars occasionally felt directionless, threatening to blur together without a clear melodic anchor. However, the back half successfully sharpened the focus and rewarded the patience: "No More Sorry" stood out with its dark, heavy percussion and unsettling, claustrophobic weight, while the closer "I Can See It (But I Can't Feel It)" finally elevated the bittersweet pop harmonies above the storm for a resonant, aching finish. An influential, textured sonic blueprint that takes time to cohere. A solid 3/5.

Avant-Garbage.

não consegui terminar o álbum. não sei se são meus fones de ouvido, mas me deu agonia como os vocais são baixos comparados ao instrumental.

Great Songs: (When You Wake) You're Still In a Dream Good Songs: Soft as Snow (But Warm Inside), Cupid Coma, No More Sorry, All I Need, Feed Me With Your Kiss, Several Girls Galore, I Can See It (But I Can't Feel It) Mid Songs: Lose My Breath, Sueisfine, You Never Should, Nothing Much To Lose Bad Songs:

One nice thing about getting older is realizing you don't have to make an effort to be into MBV. If someone put this on a party, that would be a weird party, but I wouldn't mind it.

I've only ever had Loveless in my rotation, and never dove deeper into the MBV catalog. This was a good listen and it sounds like it was ahead of its time for something coming out in 1988. I can sense the wall of noise that would become Loveless, but it's still evolving here.

I heard this at some point over the years but never came back to it, with good reason: Loveless is far superior, and even then I'm not an MBV zealot. Isn't Anything plays like a preview of things to come—and how much you enjoy it depends on how you regard what followed. I like Loveless but find this to be a bit of a slog...and I have little patience for the cult of personality that builds up around reclusive geniuses. 2.5 stars, rounding up to three.

What a horrible racket. That noise really stressed me out. I couldn't even listen to the whole album. Terrible. 1/6

Знаю цих, але вони мені не подобались. Послухаємо)

Lots of elements of this album that I enjoyed. Not a favorite overall but solid

Sadboi atmospheric alt rock. It’s not world beating and definitely gets stale pretty quickly but it’s good for what it is.

It's nothing on Loveless. Also ANOTHER band whose singer needs to admit they can't sing

First time listening to this album. While with Loveless I could 100% see why it's popular even if I don't really like the genre, I just don't understand why Isn't Anything is on the list at all. Boring 2/5

Chock-full of ideas but missing out on the perfect execution that would define their following EPs and albums.

Big love for this

Great one, funny to me how Apple Music classifies it as pop.

For 1988 this is groundbreaking. Isn’t Anything pushed the envelope for shoegaze music and it sounded fresh and original. Their first album have more punk/noise elements to it than their later output. It’s not as cohesive than Loveless or MBV but it’s a strong entry for the pioneers of the genre.

I hedged on this album. I either really like it and it will grow on me and I will wish I had given it four stars or it will remain just ... a bit too odd or chaotic overall to fully enjoy as much as I like. It is certainly inventive and innovative, it is generally up my alley... It really is a good and fun and interesting album, I do not want to say I am giving it a weak rating, no... more like I want to give it a three and a half but IDK about four with all the competition out there... Again though, I have made mistakes before and I could wish some day that I just gave it the damn four. But for today... I might rate the entire band higher overall, but this album, lets stick with modesty.

475/1102 No More Sorry is really cool and feels a lot more unique and interesting than the other songs so far (they’re decent but not groundbreaking imo) think i would need more time with this one for it to click. had some highlights but wasn’t too excited otherwise faves: No More Sorry, Nothing Much To Lose, I Can See It…, Cupid Come 55/100

It's not my favourite sound, but it's growing on me with more listens. I think music that's heavily focused on texture and noise is like auditory roughage to me – I need more zing and sweetness to help it go down and make all the grain worthwhile. It's still pretty nice, though.

Another album which stirred no emotions at all. Well perhaps merely frustration that I wasn't spending the time listening to something else. If this is "shoegaze" music then I don't need to hear any more. Nothing in this for me at all.

I used to really like this album but I’m not 100% sure why. It’s still good but obviously nowhere near the heights of Loveless. It feels all a little clunky and amateurish but not in an enjoyable way anymore

I find it kinda wild that some people think this is MBV's best record, cos for me there is an absolute gulf in quality between this and Loveless. There's some good stuff here and the snatches of that woozy wall of sound are still good, but it's just an interesting late '80s indie record, whereas Loveless is something SPECIAL.

I can understand to some extent why My Bloody Valentine are included on the 1001 Albums list, as their influence is undeniable. However, setting aside their reputation and speaking strictly from personal taste, their music simply doesn't resonate with me the way it does for others. The songs here fail to grab, interest, or thrill me. At times, the sound is overly dissonant, and off-kilter; even on cleaner, more driving tracks like '(When You Wake) You're Still in a Dream' or 'Feed Me With Your Kiss', the material remains unmemorable. 1 "Soft as Snow (But Warm Inside)" (2/5) 2 "Lose My Breath" (3/5) 3 "Cupid Come" (2/5) 4 "(When You Wake) You're Still in a Dream" (2/5) 5 "No More Sorry" (3/5) 6 "All I Need" (2/5) 7 "Feed Me with Your Kiss" (2/5) 8 "Sueisfine" (2/5) 9 "Several Girls Galore" (2/5) 10 "You Never Should" (2/5) 11 "Nothing Much to Lose" (2/5) 12 "I Can See It (But I Can't Feel It)" (2/5) Total - 26 Average - 2.2 465/1001 245/465 albums reviewed were new to me.

Love MBV, I’m not sure every single album of theirs needs to be on this list

2,2 Highlights: Lose My Breath, (When You Wake) You're Still A Dream

Sehr ungewöhnlicher, psychedelischer Sound, manchmal für mich etwas zu dissonant und inkonsistent, müsste man mehrmals anhören, um es verstehen zu können

Ich mag den Vibe vom ganzen Album, ja selbstverständlich ist es bisschen eigenartig und experimentell, aber trotzdem besser und sogar origineller als manche andere Alternative Rock Alben. Ich kann keine 4 Sterne geben, weil die Musik an manchen Stellen so kontraintuitiv und unzusammenhängend ist, dass es mich irritiert. Deswegen war es nicht so angenehm zum Hören, aber auf jeden Fall interessant!

This is the second album by My Bloody Valentine that I've gotten on the list. The first was "Loveless", which I really liked and gave a 4/5. This album is just not as good in my opinion. It seems a bit of a mess at times. I still love the melancholy sound and I know this album is on the list because it's their first and the one that really started the shoegaze genre. But I just didn't find anything I liked on it particularly well. It also is not available on Spotify in the U.S., so not easy to track down.

WARNING!!!!!

Hints of what's to come are there but not nearly as good 3/5

Impossible not to compare this to loveless, but on its own, Isn't Anything stands up pretty well. Lots of interesting things happening in and around that noise, and it's still fairly accessible. Would listen again.

Couldn’t even find the thing

interresting to hear the roots of what was to come in this

Can’t say I really loved this. Sounded like a lot of noise and nothing really memorable. Maybe other albums and songs are better? 2.25

Annoyingly difficult to find. But a pretty decent listen. Rating in line with their other album on the list. 3/5

Woof. Tough to get through. This is shoegaze? No thanks.

An underrated high point of rock music in the 80s. As good as Loveless. I don't care how many bands claim the shoegaze mantle, no one comes close to sounding like mbv.

this album might have had the roughest opening i've ever heard. after that, it was up and down, but mostly down. at least they figured it out with loveless later

Sorry MBV this is mixed like dog water - there is little that is redeemable about this one for me.

Original shoegaze guitar, hasn't improved with time.

My Bloody Valentine walked, so Placebo could run directly into my ashtray heart.

Pretty good.

This band perfected shoegaze

Giving 2 stars but only listened to pieces on YouTube - my main gripe with this band is that have 1 trick and that is to make as much noise as possible. They are good at this trick, maybe the best, but I get no pleasure from listening to it.

I’m not a huge fan of this band to begin with, and I’m a little surprised the generator chose this album rather than its far more famous and beloved follow-up, Loveless. There are certainly things to like here. Some decent songwriting, interesting structures, and genuine melodies buried somewhere in the mix. Tracks like “Nothing Much to Lose” and “Cupid Come” have an almost Pixies-adjacent quality that I could really get behind. Unfortunately, just as something promising starts to emerge, it sounds like somebody has started power-washing the studio windows, spraying a garden hose directly into the microphones, or operating a power drill in the next room. I understand that this is essentially the point of shoegaze, but to me, a lot of it just sounds like noise. Maybe that makes me sound a hundred years old, but I can’t help thinking that if they just cleaned some of this up, these songs would be substantially better. Instead, whatever melodies are there get completely sandblasted by sound. In a lot of ways, it reminds me of Smashing Pumpkins, particularly Siamese Dream, which I’ve always liked considerably less than Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. Except I think the Pumpkins do this sort of thing much better. There’s clearly some musical talent and imagination here, and I can appreciate what they’re going for intellectually, but I don’t particularly enjoy listening to it. Ultimately, not my thing. I doubt I’ll revisit it. 3.9/10

could only listen to one song on spotify, the rest seem to have been removed from the platform

It has been significantly hard to assess this album on its own merit. Despite being a stepping stone in music as the pioneer of the Shoegaze genre, it is grossly overshadowed by its follow-up. However, there are not many albums that feel as compelling within the genre, making it a more than worthy inclusion. 8/10 [KEEP]

This tried my patience. It wasn’t bad but also like just not what I was in the mood to listen to at the time.

Messy but in a good way

it's like you want me to rate things a five.

Much colder and less intimate than Loveless, their more successful follow-up. This is still a very interesting album, but unfortunately not the generational masterwork that this band would go on to create.

It's a bit meandering, though that sort of qualifies most shoegaze so maybe that's more of a genre issue. To its credit, it's considerably more accessible than Loveless and leans more into a classic rock sound with glimpses of noise shining through, so that's potentially a positive for people like me. I do appreciate the sorts of funky effects they can get out of an electric guitar. Standouts: Soft as Snow (Bur Warm Inside) • Cupid Come • (When You Wake) You're Still in a Dream • You Never Should

Mitenköhän tähän pitäisi suhtautua… tämä on ilmeisesti bändin debyytti enkä tunne muuta tuotantoa lainkaan. Vaikutelma on, että soitto- ja laulutaito on hyvin rajallinen mutta olen taipuvainen kuitenkin uskomaan, että koska yhtye on saanut levydiilin, on tämä soundimaailma ja genre ihan tietoinen valinta. Biisit ovat lähtökohtaisesti hyvin kehnoja, samoin laulu ja sinänsä erikoiset kitarasoundit alkavat koko albumin mitassa rasittamaan. On levyllä toki hyviä hetkiäkin kuten biisi Feed me with your kiss. 2/5

Favourite Songs: No More Sorry Feed Me With Your Kiss

a bit noisy punky, but also the production sounds a bit 'thin', with a very 80s feel. Not sure if this is something I might get into with some listening as it seems to be a precursor for some other stuff I used to like (Nirvana, Damned, Pixies), but this listen didn't grab me

Isn't Anything is a conundrum because it pairs extraordinary guitar tones with some of the worst songwriting you'll ever hear. Sonically this feels very much like Loveless, with harsh yet pretty sounds that weave and bend in interesting ways. "No More Sorry" is a great example of this - the way sounds just cascade over each other is lovely. It's such a shame then that nearly every verse and chorus just feels so clunky, rarely fitting together at all. While the band's later work has a lot of dream pop influence, meaning the sounds can wash over you, this feels more like punk, with harsher riffs that hit you haphazardly. Kevin Shields's vocals also feel just as clumsy as the music. The fact that the band fully realized their sound on later albums may make this one seem worse by comparison, but even standing alone I think it would not quite feel like it comes together.

MBV had always passed me by, I think I am ok with that.

Where's Loveless? 4.5.

Very shocked it’s this album on here. It’s pretty good but it’s no Loveless.

Dammit. Somehow, my rating didn't save, maybe because of my lengthy rant about albums that don't deserve a place on this list. This list included all three of MBV's studio albums. Are you kidding me? Much bigger bands have loads of better records with just three, or even fewer, entries here. Ok, back to #973 for me on this list. Like the other two MBV albums: Nope.

can someone please explain this band to me because i really want to understand but i just don't. the last song on this album is called I Can See It (But I Can't Feel It) and i think that just sums it up really.

loveless vokaller az olunca daha iyi olmuş ama, mbv'nin vekaletini dinlemek değişik

niezle spoko

Сара 1 Марко 1

shoegaze?? puh c

As inscrutable as a radio station you can only just find the frequency of. More difficult and thin than ‘Loveless’ and not as compelling or melodic. There are interesting ideas here and cool use of sound, but I’m not chomping at the bit to revisit this one. Feels a little bad to rate an MBV album this low, but I didn’t gel with this very much.

Not as refined as Loveless, but it definitely birthed shoegaze. A few songs definitely suck here though, but most are really unique.

Shoegaze is hit or miss for me. This wasn’t a total miss, but definitely not a hit. I’ve liked their other stuff more.

Interesting and not bad. I enjoyed it, but it never made me go Wow! 3/5

I enjoyed it, but this probably doesn’t deserve to be on this list. MBV’s classic album Loveless does though, I love that one.

I think Loveless is better but I do like this one, annoying that I had to search for it.

Not great. Oh, well.

I liked this. I didn’t like it as much as I thought I would, but it was still a very solid album that I’m glad I heard through this list. 4/5 ⭐️ 283/1081

I wish more of this was on Spotify. 15 year old scratchy YouTube rips aren’t the best way to enjoy this, but, this is some crunchy shoegaze and alternative from an early, pre grunge period, and it’s pretty dang good. The influence is way off the charts. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Soft as Snow (But Warm Inside) Feed Me with Your Kiss

Hot take: shoegaze should have a limit to 5 albums tops….loveless not this.

Not yet Loveless

Every so often a moment in a song floated by that I enjoyed. The rest just kind of existed, which sounds like it might be the point. What took me out were the moments of harsh change, almost clashing sounds, that might have been intentional. If they were, it seems counterintuitive to the rest of the style. If not, then it was time for another take. I definitely don't have the same hate for this as many reviewers, nor the same love. So I ask, would I seek it out again or recomend to most of my friends? Probably not.

Not on Spotify, listened to on Youtube

A foreshadowing of what MBV will become.